Mechanisms and Evolution of Diversity-Generating RiPP Biosynthesis

Insights into the production and evolution of lantibiotics from a computational analysis of peptides associated with the lanthipeptide cyclase domain

Lanthipeptides are a large group of ribosomally encoded peptides cyclized by thioether and methylene bridges, which include the lantibiotics, lanthipeptides with antimicrobial activity. There are over 100 experimentally characterized lanthipeptides, with at least 25 distinct cyclization bridging patterns. We set out to understand the evolutionary dynamics and diversity of lanthipeptides. We identified 977 peptides in 2785 bacterial genomes from short open-reading frames encoding lanthipeptide modifiable amino acids (C, S and T) that lay chromosomally adjacent to genes encoding proteins containing the cyclase domain. These appeared to be synthesized by both known and novel enzymatic combinations. Our predictor of bridging topology suggested 36 novel-predicted topologies, including a single-cysteine topology seen in 179 lanthionine or labionin containing peptides, which were enriched for histidine. Evidence that supported the relevance of the single-cysteine containing lanthipeptide precursors included the presence of the labionin motif among single cysteine peptides that clustered with labionin-associated synthetase domains, and the leader features of experimentally defined lanthipeptides that were shared with single cysteine predictions. Evolutionary rate variation among peptide subfamilies suggests that selection pressures for functional change differ among subfamilies. Lanthipeptides that have recently evolved specific novel features may represent a richer source of potential novel antimicrobials, since their target species may have had less time to evolve resistance.

Kinetic Analysis of Lanthipeptide Cyclization by Substrate-Tolerant ProcM

Lanthipeptides are ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptides characterized by the presence of thioether crosslinks. Class II lanthipeptide synthetases are bifunctional enzymes responsible for the multistep chemical modification of these natural products. ProcM is a class II lanthipeptide synthetase known for its remarkable substrate tolerance and ability to install diverse (methyl)lanthionine rings with high accuracy. Previous studies suggested that the final ring pattern of the lanthipeptide product may be determined by the substrate sequence rather than by ProcM, and that ProcM operates by a kinetically controlled mechanism, wherein the ring pattern is dictated by the relative rates of the individual cyclization reactions. This study utilizes kinetic assays to determine if rates of isolated modifications can predict the final ring pattern present in prochlorosins. Changes in the core substrate sequence resulted in changes to the reaction rates of ring formation as well as a change in the order of modifications. Additionally, individual chemical reaction rates were significantly impacted by the presence of other modifications on the peptide. These findings indicate that the rates of isolated modifications are capable of predicting the final ring pattern but are not necessarily a good predictor of the order of modification in WT ProcA3.3 and its variants.

Promiscuous Enzymes for Residue-Specific Peptide and Protein Late-Stage Functionalization

The late-stage functionalization of peptides and proteins holds significant promise for drug discovery and facilitates bioorthogonal chemistry. This selective functionalization leads to innovative advances in in vitro and in vivo biological research. However, it is a challenging endeavor to selectively target a certain amino acid or position in the presence of other residues containing reactive groups. Biocatalysis has emerged as a powerful tool for selective, efficient, and economical modifications of molecules. Enzymes that have the ability to modify multiple complex substrates or selectively install nonnative handles have wide applications. Herein, we highlight enzymes with broad substrate tolerance that have been demonstrated to modify a specific amino acid residue in simple or complex peptides and/or proteins at late-stage. The different substrates accepted by these enzymes are mentioned together with the reported downstream bioorthogonal reactions that have benefited from the enzymatic selective modifications.

Sequence controlled secondary structure is important for the site-selectivity of lanthipeptide cyclization

Lanthipeptides are ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptides that are generated from precursor peptides through a dehydration and cyclization process. ProcM, a class II lanthipeptide synthetase, demonstrates high substrate tolerance. It is enigmatic that a single enzyme can catalyze the cyclization process of many substrates with high fidelity. Previous studies suggested that the site-selectivity of lanthionine formation is determined by substrate sequence rather than by the enzyme. However, exactly how substrate sequence contributes to site-selective lanthipeptide biosynthesis is not clear. In this study, we performed molecular dynamic simulations for ProcA3.3 variants to explore how the predicted solution structure of the substrate without enzyme correlates to the final product formation. Our simulation results support a model in which the secondary structure of the core peptide is important for the final product's ring pattern for the substrates investigated. We also demonstrate that the dehydration step in the biosynthesis pathway does not influence the site-selectivity of ring formation. In addition, we performed simulation for ProcA1.1 and 2.8, which are well-suited candidates to investigate the connection between order of ring formation and solution structure. Simulation results indicate that in both cases, C-terminal ring formation is more likely which was supported by experimental results. Our findings indicate that the substrate sequence and its solution structure can be used to predict the site-selectivity and order of ring formation, and that secondary structure is a crucial factor influencing the site-selectivity. Taken together, these findings will facilitate our understanding of the lanthipeptide biosynthetic mechanism and accelerate bioengineering efforts for lanthipeptide-derived products.

Engineering ribosomally synthesized and posttranslationally modified peptides as new antibiotics

The rise of antimicrobial resistance is an urgent public health threat demanding the invention of new drugs to combat infections. Naturally sourced nonribosomal peptides (NRPs) have a long history as antimicrobial drugs. Through recent advances in genome mining and engineering technologies, their ribosomally synthesized and posttranslationally modified peptide (RiPP) counterparts are poised to further contribute to the arsenal of anti-infectives. As natural products from diverse organisms involved in interspecies competition, many RiPPs already possess antimicrobial activities that can be further optimized as drug candidates. Owing to the mutability of precursor protein genes that encode their core structures and the availability of diverse posttranslational modification (PTM) enzymes with broad substrate tolerances, RiPP systems are well suited to engineer complex peptides with desired functions.

Emulating nonribosomal peptides with ribosomal biosynthetic strategies

Peptide natural products are important lead structures for human drugs and many nonribosomal peptides possess antibiotic activity. This makes them interesting targets for engineering approaches to generate peptide analogues with, for example, increased bioactivities. Nonribosomal peptides are produced by huge mega-enzyme complexes in an assembly-line like manner, and hence, these biosynthetic pathways are challenging to engineer. In the past decade, more and more structural features thought to be unique to nonribosomal peptides were found in ribosomally synthesised and posttranslationally modified peptides as well. These streamlined ribosomal pathways with modifying enzymes that are often promiscuous and with gene-encoded precursor proteins that can be modified easily, offer several advantages to produce designer peptides. This review aims to provide an overview of recent progress in this emerging research area by comparing structural features common to both nonribosomal and ribosomally synthesised and posttranslationally modified peptides in the first part and highlighting synthetic biology strategies for emulating nonribosomal peptides by ribosomal pathway engineering in the second part.

Investigating the Specificity of the Dehydration and Cyclization Reactions in Engineered Lanthipeptides by Synechococcal SyncM

ProcM-like enzymes are class II promiscuous lanthipeptide synthetases that are an attractive tool in synthetic biology for producing lanthipeptides with biotechnological or clinically desired properties. SyncM is a recently described modification enzyme from this family used to develop a versatile expression platform for engineering lanthipeptides. Most remarkably, SyncM can modify up to 79 SyncA substrates in a single strain. Six SyncAs were previously characterized from this pool of substrates. They showed particular characteristics, such as the presence of one or two lanthionine rings, different flanking residues influencing ring formation, and different ring directions, demonstrating the relaxed specificity of SyncM toward its precursor peptides. To gain a deeper understanding of the potential of SyncM as a biosynthetic tool, we further explored the enzyme's capabilities and limits in dehydration and ring formation. We used different SyncA scaffolds for peptide engineering, including changes in the ring's directionality (relative position of Ser/Thr to Cys in the peptide) and size. We further aimed to rationally design mimetics of cyclic antimicrobials and introduce macrocycles in prochlorosin-related and nonrelated substrates. This study highlights the largest lanthionine ring with 15 amino acids (ring-forming residues included) described to date. Taking advantage of the amino acid substrate tolerance of SyncM, we designed the first single-SyncA-based antimicrobial. The insights gained from this work will aid future bioengineering studies. Additionally, it broadens SyncM's application scope for introducing macrocycles in other bioactive molecules.

Macrocyclization and Backbone Modification in RiPP Biosynthesis

The past decade has seen impressive advances in understanding the biosynthesis of ribosomally synthesized and posttranslationally modified peptides (RiPPs). One of the most common modifications found in these natural products is macrocyclization, a strategy also used by medicinal chemists to improve metabolic stability and target affinity and specificity. Another tool of the peptide chemist, modification of the amides in a peptide backbone, has also been observed in RiPPs. This review discusses the molecular mechanisms of biosynthesis of a subset of macrocyclic RiPP families, chosen because of the unusual biochemistry involved: the five classes of lanthipeptides (thioether cyclization by Michael-type addition), sactipeptides and ranthipeptides (thioether cyclization by radical chemistry), thiopeptides (cyclization by [4+2] cycloaddition), and streptide (cyclization by radical C-C bond formation). In addition, the mechanisms of backbone amide methylation, backbone epimerization, and backbone thioamide formation are discussed, as well as an unusual route to small molecules by posttranslational modification.

A Silent Biosynthetic Gene Cluster from a Methanotrophic Bacterium Potentiates Discovery of a Substrate Promiscuous Proteusin Cyclodehydratase

Natural product-encoding biosynthetic gene clusters (BGCs) within microbial genomes far outnumber the known natural products; chemical products from such BGCs remain cryptic. These silent BGCs hold promise not only for the elaboration of new natural products but also for the discovery of useful biosynthetic enzymes. Here, we describe a genome mining strategy targeted toward the discovery of substrate promiscuous natural product biosynthetic enzymes. In the genome of the methanotrophic bacterium Methylovulum psychrotolerans Sph1^T, we discover a transcriptionally silent natural product BGC that encoded numerous ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptide (RiPP) natural products. These cryptic RiPP natural products were accessed using heterologous expression of the substrate peptide and biosynthetic enzyme-encoded genes. In line with our genome mining strategy, the RiPP biosynthetic enzymes in this BGC were found to be substrate promiscuous, which allowed us to use them in a combinatorial fashion with a similarly substrate-tolerant cyanobactin biosynthetic enzyme to introduce head-to-tail macrocyclization in the proteusin family of RiPP natural products.

Substrate Sequence Controls Regioselectivity of Lanthionine Formation by ProcM

Lanthipeptides belong to the family of ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptides (RiPPs). The (methyl)lanthionine cross-links characteristic to lanthipeptides are essential for their stability and bioactivities. In most bacteria, lanthipeptides are maturated from single precursor peptides encoded in the corresponding biosynthetic gene clusters. However, cyanobacteria engage in combinatorial biosynthesis and encode as many as 80 substrate peptides with highly diverse sequences that are modified by a single lanthionine synthetase into lanthipeptides of different lengths and ring patterns. It is puzzling how a single enzyme could exert control over the cyclization processes of such a wide range of substrates. Here, we used a library of ProcA3.3 precursor peptide variants and show that it is not the enzyme ProcM but rather its substrate sequences that determine the regioselectivity of lanthionine formation. We also demonstrate the utility of trapped ion mobility spectrometry-tandem mass spectrometry (TIMS-MS/MS) as a fast and convenient method to efficiently separate lanthipeptide constitutional isomers, particularly in cases where the isomers cannot be resolved by conventional liquid chromatography. Our data allowed identification of factors that are important for the cyclization outcome, but also showed that there are no easily identifiable predictive rules for all sequences. Our findings provide a platform for future deep learning approaches to allow such prediction of ring patterns of products of combinatorial biosynthesis.

Functional Expression and Characterization of the Highly Promiscuous Lanthipeptide Synthetase SyncM, Enabling the Production of Lanthipeptides with a Broad Range of Ring Topologies

Lanthipeptides are ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptides characterized by the presence of lanthionine rings that provide stability and functionality. Genome mining techniques have shown their huge diversity and potential for the discovery of novel active molecules. However, in many cases, they are not easily produced under laboratory conditions. The heterologous expression of these molecules using well-characterized lanthipeptide biosynthetic enzymes is rising as an alternative system for the design and production of new lanthipeptides with biotechnological or clinical properties. Nevertheless, the substrate-enzyme specificity limits the complete modification of the desired peptides and hence, their full stability and/or biological activity. New low substrate-selective biosynthetic enzymes are therefore necessary for the heterologous production of new-to-nature peptides. Here, we have identified, cloned, and heterologously expressed in Lactococcus lactis the most promiscuous lanthipeptide synthetase described to date, i.e., SyncM from the marine cyanobacteria Synechococcus MITS9509. We have characterized the functionality of SyncM by the successful expression of 15 out of 18 different SyncA substrates, subsequently determining the dehydration and cyclization processes in six representatives of them. This characterization highlights the very relaxed substrate specificity of SyncM toward its precursors and the ability to catalyze the formation of exceptionally large rings in a variety of topologies. Our results suggest that SyncM could be an attractive enzyme to design and produce a wide variety of new-to-nature lanthipeptides with a broad range of ring topologies.