Using pulsed wave ultrasound to evaluate the suitability of hydroxyl radical scavengers in sonochemical systems

Effects of alcohols and dissolved gases on sonochemical generation of hydrogen in a 300 kHz sonoreactor

The sonochemical generation of hydrogen (H2) was investigated using various water/alcohol solutions under argon (Ar) 100 % in a 300 kHz sonoreactor. Five types of alcohols-methanol, ethanol, isopropanol, n-propanol, and n-butanol-were used at various concentrations (0 - 100 % v/v). The H2 generation rate in water was 0.31 μmol/min in the absence of alcohols. The H2 generation rate increased, peaked, and then decreased as the alcohol concentration increased. The concentrations used for the peak H2 generation were 5 %, 1 %, 0.5 %, 0.5 %, and 0.1 % for methanol, ethanol, isopropanol, n-propanol, and n-butanol, respectively. The highest generation rate (5.46 μmol/min) was obtained for methanol 5 % among all conditions in this study, and no H2 was detected for 100 % alcohol concentrations. The reason for the enhancement of the sonochemical H2 generation by the addition of alcohols might be due to strong scavenging effect of alcohols for sonochemically generated oxidizing radicals and vigorous reactions of alcohol molecules and their derivatives with H radicals. No significant correlations were found between the H2 generation rates and physicochemical properties of the alcohols in any of the data in this study. As alcohol concentration increased, the calorimetric power decreased. This indicates that the calorimetric power does not represent the degree of sonochemical reactions in the water/alcohol mixtures. The effect of oxygen (O2) content in the dissolved gases on the generation of H2O2 (representing sonochemical oxidation activity) and H2 (representing sonochemical reduction activity) was investigated using Ar/O2 mixtures for water, methanol 5 % and n-propanol 0.5 %. In water, the highest H2O2 generation was obtained for Ar/O2 (50:50), which is similar to previous research results. However, the H2O2 generation increased as the O2 content increased. In addition, H2 generation decreased as the O2 content increased under all liquid conditions (water, methanol, and n-propanol).

Optimum scavenger concentrations for sonochemical nanoparticle synthesis

Maintaining nanoparticle properties when scaling up a chemical synthesis is challenging due to the complex interplay between reducing agents and precursors. A sonochemical synthesis route does not require the addition of reducing agents as they are instead being continuously generated in-situ by ultrasonic cavitation throughout the reactor volume. To optimize the sonochemical synthesis of nanoparticles, understanding the role of radical scavengers is paramount. In this work we demonstrate that optimum scavenger concentrations exist at which the rate of Ag-nanoparticle formation is maximized. Titanyl dosimetry experiments were used in conjunction with Ag-nanoparticle formation rates to determine these optimum scavenger concentrations. It was found that more hydrophobic scavengers require lower optimum concentrations with 1-butanol < 2-propanol < ethanol < methanol < ethylene glycol. However, the optimum concentration is shifted by an order of magnitude towards higher concentrations when pyrolytic decomposition products contribute to the reduction. The reduction rate is also enhanced considerably.

Effects of gas saturation and sparging on sonochemical oxidation activity in open and closed systems, part II: NO2-/NO3- generation and a brief critical review

The sonochemical generation of NO₂^- and NO₃^- is considered to be one of the reasons for the low sonochemical oxidation activity in the presence of N₂ in the liquid phase. In this study, the generation characteristics of NO₂^- and NO₃^- were investigated using the same 28 kHz sonoreactor and the 12 gas conditions used in Part I of this study. Three gas modes, saturation/closed, saturation/open, and sparging/closed, were applied. N₂:Ar (25:75), N₂:Ar (50:50), and O₂:N₂ (25:75) in the saturation/closed mode generated the three highest values of NO₂^- and NO₃^-. Ar and O₂ were vital for generating relatively large concentrations of NO₂^- and NO₃^-. The absorption of N₂ from the air resulted in high generation of NO₂^- and NO₃^- for Ar 100 % and Ar/O₂ mixtures under the saturation/open mode. In addition, gas sparging enhanced the generation of NO₂^- and NO₃^- for N₂:Ar (25:75), O₂:N₂ (25:75), and N₂ significantly because of the change in the sonochemically active zone and the increase in the mixing intensity in the liquid phase, as discussed in Part I. The ratio of NO₃^- to NO₂^- was calculated using their final concentrations, and a ratio higher than 1 was obtained for the condition of Ar 100 %, Ar/O₂ mixtures, and O₂ 100 %, wherein a relatively high oxidation activity was detected. From a summary of the results and findings of previous studies, it was revealed that the observations of NO₂^- + NO₃^- could be more appropriate for investigating the NO₂^- and NO₃^- generation characteristics. In addition, H₂O₂/NO₂^-/NO₃^- related activity rather than H₂O₂ activity was suggested to quantify the OH radical activity more appropriately in the presence of N₂.

Mechanisms for removal of gaseous toluene in headspace using sonophysical and sonochemical effects at the gas-liquid interface

We developed a new method for removing gaseous substances by using high frequency (200 kHz) ultrasonic irradiation of water, and the effects of ultrasonic irradiation on gas-phase toluene were evaluated quantitatively for the first time. The removal ratio of gaseous toluene increased with increasing ultrasonic power, but the reaction was inhibited by the addition of radical scavengers, indicating that ultrasonic irradiation not only accelerated the dissolution of gaseous toluene but also induced toluene decomposition. The contribution made by OH radicals to the decomposition of gaseous toluene at the gas-liquid interface was confirmed by the difference in removal ratios between addition of KI and addition of tert-butyl alcohol. The toluene removal mechanism was investigated by studying the logarithmic plots for toluene concentration at specified times. The results of this study clearly showed the promotion of gaseous toluene dissolution and the reaction via OH radicals at the gas-liquid interface by sonophysical and sonochemical effects with both effects contributing to the removal of gaseous toluene. Furthermore, the total organic carbon concentration in the aqueous phase increased with increasing reaction time, indicating that the toluene degradation products were trapped and decomposed into low-molecular-weight organic compounds in the aqueous phase.

Comparative study of degradation of ketoprofen and paracetamol by ultrasonic irradiation: Mechanism, toxicity and DBP formation

The present study comparatively investigated the ultrasonic degradation of ketoprofen (KET) and paracetamol (PCT) in water. Ultrasonic irradiation at 555 kHz achieved rapid degradation of KET and PCT in water, the removal efficiencies of KET (2.5-80 μM) and PCT (2.5-80 μM) reached 87.7%-100% and 50.6%-86.9%, respectively, after 10 min of reaction under an ultrasonic power of 60 W. The degradation behaviors of both KET and PCT followed the Langmuir-Hinshelwood model. KET was eliminated faster than PCT because of its higher hydrophobicity. Acidic media favored ultrasonic degradation of KET and PCT. Organic compounds in water matrices exerted a great negative effect on the ultrasonic degradation rates of KET and PCT major by competing with target compounds with the generated radicals at the bubble/water interfacial region. The effects of anions were species dependent. The introduction of ClO4- and Cl- enhanced KET and PCT degradation to different extents, while the introduction of HCO3- posed a negative effect on both KET and PCT. KET and PCT degradation are accompanied by the generation of several transform intermediates, as identified via LC/MS/MS analysis, and corresponding reaction pathways have been proposed. A human umbilical vein endothelial cell (HUVEC) toxicity evaluation indicated that ultrasonic treatment was capable of controlling the toxicity of KET or PCT degradation. Of note, the enhanced formation of disinfection byproducts (DBPs), i.e., trichloromethane (TCM) and trichloronitromethane (TCNM), was found due to chlorination after ultrasonic treatment for both KET and PCT.

A review on pharmaceuticals removal from waters by single and combined biological, membrane filtration and ultrasound systems

Contaminants of emerging concern (CEC) such as pharmaceuticals commonly found in urban and industrial wastewater are a potential threat to human health and have negative environmental impact. Most wastewater treatment plants cannot efficiently remove these compounds and therefore, many pharmaceuticals end up in aquatic ecosystems, inducing problems such as toxicity and antibiotic-resistance. This review reports the extent of pharmaceutical removal by individual processes such as bioreactors, advanced oxidation processes and membrane filtration systems, all of which are not 100% efficient and can lead to the direct discharge of pharmaceuticals into water bodies. Also, the importance of understanding biotransformation of pharmaceutical compounds during biological and ultrasound treatment, and its impact on treatment efficacy will be reviewed. Different combinations of the processes above, either as an integrated configuration or in series, will be discussed in terms of their degradation efficiency and scale-up capabilities. The trace quantities of pharmaceutical compounds in wastewater and scale-up issues of ultrasound highlight the importance of membrane filtration as a concentration and volume reduction treatment step for wastewater, which could subsequently be treated by ultrasound.

Development of an ultrasound-enhanced smartphone colorimetric biosensor for ultrasensitive hydrogen peroxide detection and its applications

In this work, we developed the first ultrasound technique enhanced smartphone application for highly sensitive determination of hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂). The measurement technique is based on the change in color intensity due to the transformation of tetramethylbenzidine (TMB) to oxidized tetramethylbenzidine (oxTMB) by the oxidation process with hydroxyl radical (OH˙) from the oxidation etching of silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) and its ultrasound usability. The oxTMB product occurs without peroxidase and can be detected with a saturation channel using HSV methodology via the application of a smartphone. To prove the peroxidase mimic property, our proposed method was also validated by determination of certain biomolecules, including glucose, uric acid, acetylcholine and total cholesterol, of which the known amounts are a valuable diagnostic tool. The proposed method provided the lowest limits of detection (LOD) of 2.0, 5.0, 12.50, 7.50, and 10.0 nmol L⁻¹ for H₂O₂, glucose, uric acid, acetylcholine, and cholesterol, respectively, when compared with LODs obtained from other smartphone colorimetric methods. Reproducibility was calculated from the detection of H₂O₂ at 25.0 and 50.0 nmol L⁻¹ with the highest standard deviations of 3.47 and 4.58%, respectively. Additionally, the determination of all analytes in human urine samples indicated recoveries in the range of 96–104% with the highest relative standard deviation of 3.98%, offering high accuracy and precision. Our research shows the novel compatibility of basic technology and chemical methodology with green chemistry principles by reducing a high-power process and organic solvent as well as exhibiting good colorimetric performance and effective sensitivity and selectivity. Thus, our developed method can be applied for point-of-care medical diagnosis.

In this work, we developed the first ultrasound technique enhanced smartphone application for highly sensitive determination of hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂).

Sonochemical degradation of triclosan in water in a multifrequency reactor

Degradation of triclosan (TCS) by multifrequency ultrasound (US) was studied at high and low frequencies. Frequency effect on initial degradation rates was analyzed, and an optimum frequency was found. Power density always has a positive effect on degradation rates over the whole equipment work range. A reaction mechanism similar to that proposed by Serpone resulted in a pseudo-linear model that fitted statistically better than the nonlinear model proposed by Okitsu. Pulsed US showed a positive effect on degradation rates; however, simultaneous analysis of the effect of power, frequency, pulse time, and silent time did not show a clear trend for degradation as a function of pulse US variables. According to these results and those for degradation in the presence of radical scavengers, it was concluded that US TCS degradation was taking place in the bubble/liquid interface. A toxicity test was conducted by Microtox®, showing a decrease in toxicity as TCS concentration decreased and increase in toxicity after total depletion of TCS. Eight possible degradation by-products were identified by GC-MS analysis, and a degradation pathway was proposed.

Influence of ultrasound on the properties of dissolved organic matter with regards to proton and metal ion binding moieties

Ultrasound is widely used in water and wastewater treatment. However, the influence of ultrasound on the composition and structure of dissolved organic matter (DOM) and consequently its behaviors is still unclear. In this study, the changes in proton and metal binding moieties in DOM caused by ultrasound at an environmentally relevant concentration (about 5 mg·L^-1) were investigated using spectrophotometric titrations. The amounts of carboxylic and phenolic-like groups in DOM before and after ultrasound were quantified by the spectral parameter, Dslope_350-400 (the differential slope of the Log-transformed DOM absorbance in the wavelength region of 350-400 nm) in combination with the non-ideal competitive adsorption (NICA) model. The results demonstrate that the concentration of carboxylic-like sites decreased with an increase in the ultrasound intensity at the same reaction time. However, the concentration of phenolic-like sites increased with an increase in the ultrasound intensity in most cases. The amounts of bound metal Ca(II) and Al(III) ions decreased with an increase of the ultrasound intensity due to the reduction of available total binding sites (carboxylic-like and phenolic-like groups) in the DOM after ultrasound. This study provides detailed in-situ information concerning the changes in the properties and behaviors of DOM in ultrasound, which would be useful to understand in more detail and to optimize the utility of ultrasound in water and wastewater treatment.

Sonolysis and sono-Fenton oxidation for removal of ibuprofen in (waste)water

Two sonochemical processes were compared for the removal of ibuprofen in different water matrixes (distilled water and effluent from wastewater treatment plant). The effect of various operating parameters, such as pH (2.6-8.0), ultrasound power density (25-100W/L), sonication frequency (12-862kHz), addition of radical promoters (H₂O₂ and Fenton's reagent) or scavengers (n-butanol and acetic acid), was evaluated. Sono-degradation of ibuprofen followed a first-order kinetic trend, whose rate constant increased with ultrasound density and frequency. For this hydrophobic and low volatile molecule, a free-radical mechanism at the bubble interface was established. Coupling ultrasound with Fenton reaction showed a positive synergy, especially in terms of mineralization yield, while adding H₂O₂ alone had no significant beneficial effect. Dedicated experiments proved this synergy to be due to the enhanced regeneration of ferrous ions by ultrasound. Efficacy of the sonolysis process was hampered in wastewater matrix, mainly as the consequence of higher pH increasing the molecule solubility. However, after convenient acidification, sono-Fenton oxidation results remained almost unchanged, indicating no significant radical scavenging effects from the effluent compounds.

Investigating natural organic carbon removal and structural alteration induced by pulsed ultrasound

The application of pulsed ultrasound for DOC removal from natural water samples has been thoroughly investigated in this work. Natural water samples were treated with ultrasound at power levels of 48 and 84 W with treatment times of 5 and 15 min. Chemical fractionation was conducted for both untreated and treated samples to clearly identify the change in DOC structure caused by ultrasonic treatments. Statistical analyses applying 2(3) factorial design were performed to study the behaviour of the response (i.e. DOC removal) under different operating conditions. Overall, ultrasonic treatments resulted in DOC removal of 7-15% depending on the applied operating conditions. The treated water had high microbial loading that interfered with DOC removal due primarily to the release of microbial products when exposed to ultrasound. Pulse ultrasound was found to be more effective than the continuous mode for DOC removal at the same effective power level. A regression model was developed and tested for DOC removal prediction. The model was adequate in predicting DOC removal with a maximum deviation from the experimental data of <11%. Pulsed ultrasound at low power levels and short treatment times was found to be the most energy efficient treatment for DOC removal.

Analyses of factors affecting nickel ferrite nanoparticles synthesis in ultrasound-assisted aqueous solution ball milling

Ball milling experiments were conducted with and without ultrasound wave assistance in deionized water using NiCO3·2Ni(OH)2·4H2O as raw materials. In the reaction process of NiFe2O4 prepared by ultrasound-assisted aqueous solution ball milling, some influencing factors including raw materials, ultrasonic frequency, ball to powder ratio and liquid level were changed. Samples were characterized by X-ray diffraction, fluorescence measurements and electroconductivity detections. The results indicate that more hydroxyl radicals and ions can be generated under the coupling effect of ultrasonic and ball milling. The fluorescence measurements and electroconductivity detections also reflect the reaction speed, allowing for optimal parameters to be determined.

Kinetics and mechanism of sonochemical degradation of pharmaceuticals in municipal wastewater

A series of six pharmaceuticals were degraded by continuous wave (CW) and pulsed wave (PW) ultrasound at 205 kHz using deionized water, wastewater effluent, and its isolated organic matter matrices. In deionized water, we observed that hydrophobicity is superior to diffusivity (D(W)) for predicting degradation kinetics. Enhancements in degradation kinetics by the PW mode were greatest for the highest DW (i.e., fluorouracil (5-FU)) and K(OW) (i.e., lovastatin (LOVS)) compounds, indicating that a pharmaceutical with either high diffusivity and low hydrophobicity or low diffusivity and high hydrophobicity benefits from additional time to populate the bubble-water interface during the silent cycle of PW ultrasound. Degradation of 5-FU and LOVS were inhibited by wastewater effluent to a greater extent than the other pharmaceuticals. In addition, a pulse enhancement (PE) for 5-FU and LOVS was not present in wastewater effluent. Irradiating 5-FU and LOVS in hydrophobic (HPO), transphilic (TPI), and hydrophilic (HPI) fractions of effluent organic matter (EfOM) showed that the TPI fraction reduced the PE the most, followed by the HPI and HPO fractions. The smaller size of the TPI over the HPO fraction and higher hydrophobicity of TPI over HPI implicate both size and hydrophobicity of EfOM in hindering degradation of pharmaceuticals.