Electromagnetic Guided Percutaneous Renal Access Outcomes Among Surgeons and Trainees of Different Experience Levels: A Pilot Study

Application of image overlapping in percutaneous nephrolithotomy

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the application of ultrasound and CT image overlap in percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL).

METHODS

A total of 140 patients with complicated kidney stones requiring PCNL were prospectively enrolled, from January 2020 to December 2022. These patients were randomly divided into 2 groups, with 70 patients each in the research group and the control group. All participants underwent dual-source, non-contrast CT scan of both kidneys and pelvis before surgery. Preoperative three-dimensional CT reconstruction and simulated puncture were performed in patients from the research group. The best puncture path was determined through ultrasound and CT image overlap. Puncture guided by regular CT and ultrasound was conducted in patients from the control group. Differences in the surgical outcomes between the two groups were compared.

RESULTS

Compared to the control group, the research group had higher stone clearance rate in stage I PCNL, success rate of one-time puncture, less percutaneous channels, less reduction of hemoglobin and shorter procedure time. Complications in stage I PCNL were comparable in the two groups, and there was no significant change in the final stone clearance rates between the two groups.

CONCLUSION

An optimal puncture channel can be chosen using ultrasound and CT image overlap. PCNL can be achieved with precise puncturing, thus achieving coincidence between imaging and anatomy and reducing the amount of blood loss during stage I of PCNL. It also shortens the procedure time and improves stone clearance rate of PCNL.

Advances in percutaneous renal puncture: a comprehensive review of the literature

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) constitutes the gold standard procedure for patients suffering from more than 2 cm renal stones. The puncture is a very critical step of PCNL, affecting manoeuvrability of the nephroscope, possibility to remove stone fragments, risk of bleeding and radiation exposure. The aim of the current review was to discuss the advances in percutaneous renal puncture.

RECENT FINDINGS

Following technological evolution in medicine, there was a consistent development in the puncture techniques, aiming at the improvement of its efficacy and safety. The use of specific agents can improve ultrasonic guidance, making the challenging step of gaining access to the kidney easier for the experienced surgeon and more accessible for the resident urologist. Future developments in the electromagnetic and three-dimensional (3D) technology may establish a high level of accuracy with decreased rates of related complications, even in the hands of beginners.

SUMMARY

The advances in percutaneous puncture can lead to improved safety and accuracy of this procedure decreasing the radiation exposure and the complication rate.

Electromagnetic-guided puncture: a tool or a tale?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The puncture technique and site of the puncture can impact the clinical outcome and the development of postoperative adverse events following percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL). The aim of the current review was to discuss the available puncture guidance approaches and outline the potential role of the recently introduced electromagnetic-guided method.

RECENT FINDINGS

The puncture and PCNL tract establishment is usually performed using fluoroscopic or ultrasound guidance or a combination of two approaches. Electromagnetic-guided puncture is one of the most recent advancements of technology. The puncture navigation to the renal collecting system is available after placing a special wire with an electromagnetic tracking sensor into the desired calyx through the flexible ureterorenoscope. The available experimental and clinical studies have shown a high first puncture rate, decreased median time for obtaining a puncture, and shorter learning curves for beginners.

SUMMARY

Fluoroscopic and ultrasound guidance are the main approaches used by urologists. However, these modalities require a steep learning curve, approximately 60 cases for reaching competency. The initial data on electromagnetic navigation have shown the feasibility and potential promising outcomes of this novel approach. New studies are required to investigate its potential implementation opportunities in the daily practice of urologists.

The Life and Death of Percutaneous Stone Removal: "Looking Back-Looking Forward"

Although percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) is less morbid than open surgery, it still carries risks of significant complications as well as injury to the renal parenchyma. Flexible ureteroscopic stone removal, although causes no appreciable damage to the renal parenchyma, has limitations, most notably, a lower stone-free rate than PCNL. Advances in our knowledge regarding ureteral physiology combined with technical developments applied to ureteral access sheath deployment and size may well propel retrograde intrarenal surgery to the forefront of kidney stone removal, regardless of stone size or location.

Simplified biplanar (0-90°) fluoroscopic puncture technique for percutaneous nephrolithotomy: the learning curve

PURPOSE

To evaluate the learning curve of the simplified fluoroscopic biplanar (0-90º) puncture technique for percutaneous nephrolithotomy.

METHODS

We prospectively evaluated patients with renal stones treated with percutaneous nephrolithotomy by a single institution's fellows employing the simplified bi-planar (0-90º) fluoroscopic puncture technique for renal access. The learning curve was assessed with the fluoroscopic screening time and the percutaneous renal puncture time. Data obtained were compared to a subset of patients operated by a senior surgeon.

RESULTS

Eighty-nine patients were included in the study. Forty patients were operated by fellow-1, 39 by fellow-2, and 10 patients by the senior surgeon. Demographic data of all patients between groups were homogeneous, with no difference in gender (p = 0.432), age (p = 0.92), stone volume (p = 0.78), puncture laterality (p = 0.755), and body mass index (p = 0.365). The mean puncture time was 7.5, 4, and 3.1 min for fellow-1, fellow-2, and expert, respectively. The mean fluoroscopic screening time for the puncture was 10, 11, and 5.1 s for fellow-1, fellow-2, and the expert, respectively. Stone cases, both fellows needed to complete 10 procedures to match the senior surgeon in the mean puncture time (p = 0.046); meanwhile, the fluoroscopic screening time was equal even before to complete 10 procedures.

CONCLUSION

This study suggests that with the simplified biplanar (0-90º) puncture technique, the fluoroscopic screening time used in the learning process is brief. A novice fellow could require to complete ten cases to flatten the learning curve treating complex stone cases, and a flat learning curve is seen since the beginning when treating simple renal stones.

Minimizing radiation dose in management of stone disease: how to achieve 'ALARA'

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Exposure to radiation is known to have adverse effects such as secondary malignancies. Patients with nephrolithiasis are exposed to radiation in the workup and treatment of their condition. Furthermore, exposure to radiation is often repeated due to the high recurrence rate of nephrolithiasis.

RECENT FINDINGS

We discuss practices inside and outside of the operating room to strive to keep radiation exposure as low as reasonably achievable (ALARA) for patients being treated for nephrolithiasis. These efforts include reduced dose computed tomography scans, fluoroless surgical techniques and new alternative technologies.

SUMMARY

Maintaining radiation exposure ALARA for our patients is increasingly practical. The urologist must make every effort to adhere to ALARA principles to protect patients from the stochastic effects of radiation.