Mutation of oppF gene in the Mycoplasma synoviae MS-H vaccine strain and its implication for differential serological responses to vaccination versus field challenge

Obg plays a significant role in temperature sensitivity of Mycoplasma synoviae live attenuated vaccine strain MS-H

The MS-H vaccine strain (Vaxsafe MS®; Bioproperties Pty. Ltd., Australia) is a live attenuated temperature sensitive derivative of a virulent strain of M. synoviae, 86079/7NS, and is used to prevent diseases from M. synoviae challenges in poultry farms. The genome sequence of MS-H includes 32 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) compared to that of 86079/7NS. To investigate the nature of mutations responsible for temperature sensitivity, MS-H strain was subjected to thermal adaptation in vitro and in vivo. The only observed variation detected in the MS-H culture following sequential passages with incremental incubation temperature from 33 °C to 39.5 °C was an Ala210Val variation in Obg protein, associated with loss of temperature sensitivity phenotype. An identical variation was detected in the MS-H culture reisolated from one out of five bird 28 days after inoculation with MS-H. These findings suggest that M. synoviae is capable of thermoadaptive evolution and Obg plays a significant role in this trait.

Genomic Diversity of a Globally Used, Live Attenuated Mycoplasma Vaccine

The Mycoplasma synoviae live attenuated vaccine strain MS-H (Vaxsafe MS; Bioproperties Pty., Ltd., Australia) is commonly used around the world to prevent chronic infections caused by M. synoviae in birds and to minimize economic losses in the poultry industry. MS-H is a temperature-sensitive strain that is generated via the chemical mutagenesis of a virulent M. synoviae isolate, 86079/7NS. 32 single nucleotide polymorphisms have been found in the genome of MS-H compared to that of 86079/7NS, including 25 in predicted coding sequences (CDSs). There is limited information on the stability of these mutations in MS-H in vitro during the propagation of the vaccine manufacturing process or in vivo after the vaccination of chickens. Here, we performed a comparative analysis of MS-H genomes after in vitro and in vivo passages under different circumstances. Studying the dynamics of the MS-H population can provide insights into the factors that potentially affect the health of vaccinated birds. The genomes of 11 in vitro laboratory passages and 138 MS-H bird reisolates contained a total of 254 sequence variations. Of these, 39 variations associated with CDSs were detected in more than one genome (range = 2 to 62, median = 2.5), suggesting that these sequences are particularly prone to mutations. From the 25 CDSs containing previously characterized variations between MS-H and 86079/7NS, 7 were identified in the MS-H reisolates and progenies examined here. In conclusion, the MS-H genome contains individual regions that are prone to mutations that enable the restoration of the genotype or the phenotype of wild-type 86079/7NS in those regions. However, accumulated mutations in these regions are rare. IMPORTANCE Preventative measures, such as vaccination, are commonly used for the control of mycoplasmal infections in poultry. A live attenuated vaccine strain (Vaxsafe MS; MS-H; Bioproperties Pty. Ltd., Australia) is used for the prevention of disease caused by M. synoviae in many countries. However, information on the stability of previously characterized mutations in the MS-H genome is limited. In this study, we performed a comparative analysis of the whole-genome sequences of MS-H seeds used for vaccine manufacturing, commercial batches of the vaccine, cultures minimally passaged under small-scale laboratory and large-scale manufacturing conditions, MS-H reisolated from specific-pathogen-free (SPF) chickens that were vaccinated under controlled conditions, and MS-H reisolated from vaccinated commercial poultry flocks around the world. This study provides a comprehensive assessment of genome stability in MS-H after in vitro and in vivo passages under different circumstances and suggests that most of the mutations in the attenuated MS-H vaccine strain are stable.

Tracheal cellular immune response in chickens inoculated with Mycoplasma synoviae vaccine, MS-H or its parent strain 86079/7NS

Mycoplasma synoviae causes respiratory tract disease in chickens characterised by mild to moderate lymphoplasmacytic infiltration of the tracheal mucosa. MS-H (Vaxsafe1 MS, Bioproperties Pty Ltd.) is an effective live attenuated vaccine for M. synoviae, but the immunological basis for its mechanism of protection has not been investigated, and the phenotypes of lymphocytes and associated cytokines involved in the local adaptive immune response have not been described previously. In this study, specific-pathogen-free chickens were inoculated intra-ocularly at 3 weeks of age with either M. synoviae vaccine strain MS-H or vaccine parent strain 86079/7NS (7NS), or remained uninoculated. At 2-, 7- and 21 days post-inoculation (dpi), tracheal mucosal pathology, infiltrating lymphocytes subsets and transcription levels of mRNA encoding 8 cytokines were assessed using light microscopy, indirect immunofluorescent staining and RT-qPCR, respectively. After inoculation, tracheal mucosal thickness, tracheal mucosal lesions, and numbers of infiltrating CD4⁺CD25^- cells, B-cells, and macrophages were greater in MS-H- and 7NS-inoculated chickens compared with non-inoculated. Inoculation with 7NS induced up-regulation of IFN-γ, while vaccination with MS-H induced up-regulation of IL-17A, when compared with non-inoculated birds. Both inoculated groups had a moderate infiltrate of CD4⁺CD25⁺ T cells in the tracheal mucosa. These findings reveal that the tracheal local cellular response after MS-H inoculation is dominated by a Th-17 response, while that of 7NS-inoculated chickens is dominated by a Th-1 type response.

Preliminary comparative analysis of the genomes of selected field reisolates of the Mycoplasma synoviae vaccine strain MS-H reveals both stable and unstable mutations after passage in vivo

Background

Genomic comparison of Mycoplasma synoviae vaccine strain MS-H and the MS-H parental strain 86,079/7NS established a preliminary profile of genes related to attenuation of MS-H. In this study we aimed to identify the stability of mutations found in MS-H after passage in experimental or field chickens, and to evaluate if any reverse mutation may be associated with changes in characteristics of MS-H in vitro or in vivo.

Results

Whole genome sequence analysis of 5 selected MS-H field reisolates revealed that out of 32 mutations reported previously in MS-H, 28 remained stable, while four found to be reversible to the wild-type. Each isolate possessed mutations in one to three of the genes obg, oppF₁ and gap and/or a non-coding region. Examination of the 4 reversible mutations by protein modeling predicted that only two of them (in obg and oppF₁ genes) could potentially restore the function of the respective protein to that of the wild-type.

Conclusions

These results suggest that the majority of the MS-H mutations are stable after passage in vaccinated chickens. Characterisation of stable mutations found in MS-H could be utilised to develop rapid diagnostic techniques for differentiation of vaccine from field strains or ts- MS-H reisolates.

Integrated Transcriptomic and Proteomic Analyses of the Interaction Between Chicken Synovial Fibroblasts and Mycoplasma synoviae

Mycoplasma synoviae (MS), which causes respiratory disease, eggshell apex abnormalities, infectious synovitis, and arthritis in avian species, has become an economically detrimental poultry pathogen in recent years. In China, the disease is characterized by infectious synovitis and arthritis. However, the mechanism by which MS causes infectious synovitis and arthritis remains unknown. Increasing evidence suggests that synovial fibroblasts (SF) play a key role in the pathogenesis of arthritis. Here, both RNA sequencing and tandem mass tag analyses are utilized to compare the response of primary chicken SF (CSF) following infection with and without MS. The host response between non-infected and infected cells was remarkably different at both the mRNA and protein levels. In total, 2,347 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) (upregulated, n = 1,137; downregulated, n = 1,210) and 221 differentially expressed proteins (DEPs) (upregulated, n = 129; downregulated, n = 92) were detected in the infected group. A correlation analysis indicated a moderate positive correlation between the mRNA and protein level changes in MS-infected CSF. At both the transcriptomic and proteomic levels, 149 DEGs were identified; 88 genes were upregulated and 61 genes were downregulated in CSF. Additionally, part of these regulated genes and their protein products were grouped into seven categories: proliferation-related and apoptosis-related factors, inflammatory mediators, proangiogenic factors, antiangiogenic factors, matrix metalloproteinases, and other arthritis-related proteins. These proteins may be involved in the pathogenesis of MS-induced arthritis in chickens. To our knowledge, this is the first integrated analysis on the mechanism of CSF-MS interactions that combined transcriptomic and proteomic technologies. In this study, many key candidate genes and their protein products related to MS-induced infectious synovitis and arthritis were identified.

Complementation of the Mycoplasma synoviae MS-H vaccine strain with wild-type oppF1 influences its growth characteristics

The Mycoplasma synoviae (MS) vaccine strain MS-H harbours a frameshift mutation in oppF₁ (oligopeptide permease transporter) which results in expression of a truncated OppF₁. The effect of this mutation on growth and attenuation of the MS-H is unknown. In this study, the impact of the mutation on the vaccine phenotype was investigated in vitro by introducing a wild-type copy of oppF₁ gene in the MS-H genome. Wild-type oppF₁ was cloned under the vlhA promoter into an oriC vector carrying a tetracycline resistance gene. MS-H was successfully transformed with the final construct pMS-oppF₁-tetM or with a similar vector lacking oppF₁ coding sequence (pMS-tetM). The MS-H transformed with pMS-oppF₁-tetM exhibited smaller colony size than MS-H transformed with pMS-tetM. Monospecific rabbit sera against C-terminus of OppF₁ detected bands of expected size for full-length OppF₁ in the 86079/7NS parental strain of MS-H and the MS-H transformed with pMS-oppF₁-tetM, but not in MS-H and MS-H transformed with pMS-tetM. Comparison of the growth curve of MS-H transformants harvested from media with/without tetracycline was conducted using vlhA Q-PCR which revealed that MS-H transformed with pMS-tetM had a higher growth rate than MS-H transformed with pMS-oppF₁-tetM in the media with/without tetracycline. Lastly, the whole genome sequencing of MS-H transformed with pMS-oppF₁-tetM (passage 27) showed that the chromosomal copy of the mutated oppF₁ had been replaced with a wild-type version of the gene. This study reveals that the truncation of oppF₁ impacts on growth characteristics of the MS-H and provides insight into the molecular pathogenesis of MS and perhaps broader mycoplasma species.RESEARCH HIGHLIGHTS The full-length OppF₁ was expressed in Mycoplasma synoviae MS-H vaccine.Truncation of oppF₁ impacts on growth characteristics of the MS-H.Chromosomal copy of the mutated oppF₁ in MS-H was replaced with wild-type oppF₁.