A model for the dynamics of the free-living stages of equine cyathostomins

US-wide equine strongylid egg count data demonstrate seasonal and regional trends

Equine strongylid parasites are ubiquitous around the world and are main targets of parasite control programmes. In recent years, automated fecal egg counting systems based on image analysis have become available allowing for collection and analysis of large-scale egg count data. This study aimed to evaluate equine strongylid fecal egg count (FEC) data generated with an automated system over three years in the US with specific attention to seasonal and regional trends in egg count magnitude and sampling activity. Five US regions were defined; North East, South East, North Central, South Central and West. The data set included state, region and zip code for each FEC. The number of FECs falling in each of the following categories were recorded: (1) 0 eggs per gram (EPG), (2) 1 ⩽ 200 EPG, (3) 201 ⩽ 500 EPG and (4) >500 EPG. The data included 58 329 FECs. A fixed effects model was constructed fitting the number of samples analysed per month, year and region, and a mixed effects model was constructed to fit the number of FECs falling in each of the 4 egg count categories defined above. The overall proportion of horses responsible for 80% of the total FEC output was 18.1%, and this was consistent across years, months and all regions except West, where the proportion was closer to 12%. Statistical analyses showed significant seasonal trends and regional differences of sampling frequency and FEC category. The data demonstrated that veterinarians tended to follow a biphasic pattern when monitoring strongylid FECs in horses, regardless of location.

Biological implications of long-term anthelmintic treatment: what else besides resistance are we selecting for?

Long-term intensive use of anthelmintics for parasite control of livestock, companion animals, and humans has resulted in widespread anthelmintic resistance, a problem of great socioeconomic significance. But anthelmintic therapy may also select for other biological traits, which could have implications for anthelmintic performance. Here, we highlight recent examples of changing parasite dynamics following anthelmintic administration, which do not fit the definition of anthelmintic resistance. We also consider other possible examples in which anthelmintic resistance has clearly established, but where coselection for other biological traits may have also occurred. We offer suggestions for collecting more information and gaining a better understanding of these phenomena. Finally, we propose research questions that require further investigation and make suggestions to help address these knowledge gaps.

Shortened strongylid egg reappearance periods in horses following macrocyclic lactone administration - The impact on parasite dynamics

Over the past three decades, equine strongylid egg reappearance periods (ERPs) have shortened substantially for macrocyclic lactone anthelmintics. The ERPs of ivermectin and moxidectin were originally reported in the 8-10 and 12-16 week ranges, respectively, but several recent studies have found them to be around 4-5 weeks for both actives. This loss of several weeks of suppressed strongylid egg output could have substantial implications for parasite control. This study made use of a computer simulation model to evaluate the impact of shortened ERPs on the anthelmintic performance of ivermectin and moxidectin against equine cyathostomins. The original ERPs were set to 7.1 and 15.4 weeks for ivermectin and moxidectin, respectively, while the reduced ERP was set to 4.6 weeks for both actives. Simulations were set to compare model outputs between original and reduced ERP scenarios and results expressed as percent increase in strongylid egg output, infective third stage larvae on herbage (L3h), and encysted early third stage larvae (EL3). For each drug, simulations were evaluated for two different treatment scenarios (2 and 4 treatments annually), two different age groups (yearlings and adults), and for four different climates (cold humid continental, temperate oceanic, humid subtropical, and hot/cold semi-arid). Across all simulations, there was a substantial increase of the three evaluated parameters. With the ivermectin simulations, all three parameters increased in the 100-300% range across climates, age groups and treatment intensities. The moxidectin simulations displayed a wider range of results with parameters increasing from a few hundred to several thousand percent. The increases were most pronounced for L3h in the two cooler climates, reaching as high as 6727%. Overall, the loss of anthelmintic performance was at a magnitude of 10 times larger for moxidectin compared to ivermectin. This performance loss was climate dependent, and was also affected by treatment intensity, but not by horse age. This is the first study to evaluate consequences of shortened ERPs in horses and demonstrated a substantial loss in anthelmintic performance resulting from this development. The results illustrate that anthelmintic efficacy is more than the percent reduction of fecal egg counts at 14 days post treatment, and that substantial anthelmintic performance can be lost despite FECRTs remaining at 100%.

Moringa oleifera as a Natural Alternative for the Control of Gastrointestinal Parasites in Equines: A Review

Studies have shown a wide variety of parasites that infect horses, causing major gastrointestinal damage that can lead to death, and although the main method of control has been synthetic anthelmintics, there are parasites that have developed resistance to these drugs. For generations, plants have been used throughout the world as a cure or treatment for countless diseases and their symptoms, as is the case of Moringa oleifera, a plant native to the western region. In all its organs, mainly in leaves, M. oleifera presents a diversity of bioactive compounds, including flavonoids, tannins, phenolic acids, saponins, and vitamins, which provide antioxidant power to the plant. The compounds with the greatest antiparasitic activity are tannins and saponins, and they affect both the larvae and the oocytes of various equine gastrointestinal parasites. Therefore, M. oleifera is a promising source for the natural control of gastrointestinal parasites in horses.

In vitro evaluation of fitness parameters for isolates of Teladorsagia circumcincta resistant and susceptible to multiple anthelmintic classes

Anthelmintic resistance (AR) is an ever increasing problem for the sheep industry. Several studies worldwide have investigated reversing the trend of increasing AR and documented evidence for reversion toward susceptibility has been found. The hypothesis that resistance mutations compromise parasite fitness was drawn from this evidence. The aim of this study was to assess whether there were measurable differences in the fitness of Teladorsagia circumcincta isolates depending on their AR status. Four isolates were selected for the trial based on their known resistance status; D and M were multi-drug resistant, and T and W were susceptible to the benzimidazole, levamisole, and macrocyclic lactone anthelmintic classes. A secondary aim was to develop a series of in vitro bioassays for assessing fitness characteristics of parasites. The in vitro assays included; the cold stress test measured the number of third stage larvae (L3) developing from eggs stored at 4 °C for different lengths of time. Larval aging measured the locomotory activity of L3 after storage at 30 °C for different lengths of time. The exsheathment assay measured the exsheathment percentage of L3. Larval Length used length as a proxy for fecundity. The egg hatch assay evaluated egg hatch rate in water at room temperature. All isolates exhibited a decrease in the number of L3 recovered after storage of eggs at 4 °C (p < 0.001). Storage of L3 at 30 °C significantly influenced the ability of L3 to migrate through a 20 µm sieve (p < 0.001), however, there were no differences between isolates (p > 0.05). Exsheathment rate was higher for isolate D in comparison to isolates M and W, and for isolate T compared to isolate W. Isolate W was significantly longer than all other isolates (p < 0.05), whilst isolate M was significantly longer than isolate D (p < 0.05). No significant differences were found between isolates in egg hatch (p > 0.05). Overall, the results do not support differences in fitness associated with anthelmintic resistance status, even though differences were seen between the isolates for some assays. This suggests there is considerable variation in fitness parameters between isolates, making it difficult to determine whether resistance genotypes come with lower fitness.

Effect of temperature on the development of the free-living stages of horse cyathostomins

Cyathostomins are considered as the most prevalent and pathogenic parasites of grazing horses. The development on pastures of the free-living stages of these gastrointestinal worms is particularly influenced by outdoor temperature. Understanding the bionomics of free-living stages is an important prerequisite to implement mathematical models designed to assess the parasitic risk for grazing equids. The aim of this study was to assess the effect of 3 constant temperatures under laboratory conditions (10 ± 1 °C, 23 ± 2 °C, 30 ± 2 °C) and one fluctuating temperature under outdoor conditions (mean: 17 ± 4 °C) on the minimum time taken by cyathostomin eggs to develop into first/second stage larvae (L1/L2) then into infective third stage larvae (L3) in horse faeces. According to the temperatures, the minimum time taken by eggs to develop into L1/L2 was between 1 and 3 days and into L3 between 4 and 22 days. At 10 °C, the development time of eggs into L3 was the longest and at 30 °C the fastest. The results were consistent with historically available data and their compilation should lead to the improvement of parameterised models assessing the parasitic risk period in grazing equids.

Three-year study to evaluate an anthelmintic treatment regimen with reduced treatment frequency in horses on two study sites in Belgium

In the present study, an anthelmintic treatment regimen with reduced treatment frequency was evaluated in horses on two study sites in Belgium during three consecutive summer pasture seasons. Historically, the horses on both study sites were treated up to 6 times a year with ivermectin (IVM) or up to 4 times a year with moxidectin (MOX), and previous efficacy evaluations indicated a reduced egg reappearance period in some of the treated horses for both IVM (28 days) and MOX (42 days). In the present study, all horses were treated with IVM or MOX in the spring and in autumn. Faecal egg counts (FEC) were conducted every two weeks during the summer pasture season and whenever the individual FEC exceeded 250 eggs per gram of faeces, the specific horse was treated with pyrantel embonate. No increase in parasitic disease over the three-year period of the study was observed. The FEC data collected in the study as well as the age of the animals and local weather data were then imported into a cyathostomin life-cycle model, to evaluate long term effects of the newly applied treatment regimen on the selection pressure for anthelmintic resistance, and compare to the previous high frequency treatment regimen. The model simulations indicated that the whole-herd treatment regimen with at least 4 macrocyclic lactone treatments annually led 2-3 times faster resistance development than any of the alternative treatment regimens evaluated under the specific conditions of these two study sites. Further lowering the treatment frequency or applying even more selective treatments enhanced the delay in resistance development, but to a lesser extent.

Helminth infections in Italian donkeys: Strongylus vulgaris more common than Dictyocaulus arnfieldi

Donkeys have been used as working animals for transport and farm activities worldwide. Recently, in European countries, there has been an increasing interest in donkeys due to their use as pets, onotherapy or milk production. During 2014-2016, a countrywide survey was conducted to determine prevalence and risk factors of principal helminth infections in 1775 donkeys in 77 Italian farms. A questionnaire on management and parasite control practices was filled out for each farm. Faecal samples were examined using a modified McMaster technique, a centrifugation/flotation method and a sedimentation technique. Pooled coprocultures were performed for differentiation of strongylid eggs. Strongyles were the most common parasites detected (84.9%), followed by Dictyocaulus arnfieldi (6.9%), Oxyuris equi (5.8%), Parascaris spp. (3.6%), Anoplocephala spp. (1.0%), Strongyloides westeri (0.3%). Coprocultures revealed an omnipresence of cyathostomins (100%), followed by Strongylus vulgaris (31.0%), Poteriostomum spp. (25.0%), Triodontophorus spp. (9.0%), Strongylus edentatus (7.0%), Strongylus equinus (5.0%). Logistic regression analysis identified breed, co-pasture with horses, living area, herd size and number of treatments as significantly associated with strongyles. Sex, age, living area and herd size were significantly associated with Parascaris spp. Dictyocaulus arnfieldi was significantly associated with sex, grass, co-pasture with horses, living area and herd size. Strongylus vulgaris was significantly associated with living area and herd size. The mean number of anthelmintic treatments/year was 1.4; most of the donkeys (71.8%) were dewormed using an ivermectin drug. It is important to design parasite programs to specifically address both D. arnfieldi and S. vulgaris in donkeys, and this is especially important if donkeys co-graze with horses.

Gastrointestinal Strongyles Egg Excretion in Relation to Age, Gender, and Management of Horses in Italy

Simple Summary

Horses worldwide are plagued by gastrointestinal parasites that can lead to severe health problems. The occurrence and intensity of these worm infections vary based on the geographical location, season, and animal management strategies applied. One of these strategies is to monitor the parasite situation in different parts of the world. This research investigates the abundance, proportions, and risk factors of strongyle egg shedding of horses in Italy. Overall, the results showed that approximately 40% of all horses in Italy shed strongyle eggs and that almost 90% of stables have at least one infected animal. In addition, most parasite eggs are found in just a small fraction of the horse population, confirming the need for improved parasite control strategies.

Abstract

Current equine helminth control strategies play a key role in strongyle epidemiology and anthelmintic resistance and have led to the recommendation for new treatment plans, which include diagnostic and efficacy surveillance. Assessing the equine strongyle distribution patterns would thus be useful and this study describes the strongyle prevalence in the equine population in Italy through coprological analysis and coproculture. In addition, individual data on each animal were collected in order to identify risk factors associated with strongyle egg shedding. Of the total number of stables investigated, 86.4% were found to have at least one positive animal and a 39.5% prevalence of strongyle egg shedding with a mean eggs per gram (EPG) of 245. A total of 80% of the total recorded EPG was shed from 12.8% of positive horses, thus confirming the need for new targeted intervention strategies. Significant differences in parasite prevalence were found based on season, sex, geographical distribution, management and rearing system, and breed. Significantly lower EPG values were found in horses that had received anthelmintic treatment, and macrocyclic lactones (MLs) were the most effective. Lastly, although large strongyles are more pathogenic, horses in Italy are mainly burdened by small strongyles, which pose an important animal health risk requiring continuous parasitological monitoring.

Climate change is likely to increase the development rate of anthelmintic resistance in equine cyathostomins in New Zealand

Climate change is likely to influence livestock production by increasing the prevalence of diseases, including parasites. The traditional practice of controlling nematodes in livestock by the application of anthelmintics is, however, increasingly compromised by the development of resistance to these drugs in parasite populations. This study used a previously developed simulation model of the entire equine cyathostomin lifecycle to investigate the effect a changing climate would have on the development of anthelmintic resistance. Climate data from six General Circulation Models based on four different Representative Concentration Pathways was available for three New Zealand locations. These projections were used to estimate the time resistance will take to develop in the middle (2040–49) and by the end (2090–99) of the century in relation to current (2006–15) conditions under two treatment scenarios of either two or six yearly whole-herd anthelmintic treatments. To facilitate comparison, a scenario without any treatments was included as a baseline. In addition, the size of the infective and parasitic stage nematode population during the third simulation year were estimated. The development of resistance varied between locations, time periods and anthelmintic treatment strategies. In general, the simulations indicated a more rapid development of resistance under future climates coinciding with an increase in the numbers of infective larvae on pasture and encysted parasitic stages. This was especially obvious when climate changes resulted in a longer period suitable for development of free-living parasite stages. A longer period suitable for larval development resulted in an increase in the average size of the parasite population with a larger contribution from eggs passed by resistant worms surviving the anthelmintic treatments. It is projected that climate change will decrease the ability to control livestock parasites by means of anthelmintic treatments and non-drug related strategies will become increasingly important for sustainable parasite control.

•

The development of anthelmintic resistance under climate change was simulated.

•

Climate can become more suitable for parasite development, increasing population size.

•

The time resistance took to develop was linked to changes in parasite population size.

•

Non-drug related strategies will become increasingly important for parasite control.

Effects of life history stage and climatic conditions on fecal egg counts in plains zebras (Equus quagga) in the Serengeti National Park

In wildlife, endoparasite burden can be affected by host life history stage, environmental conditions, host abundance, and parasite co-infections. We tested the effects of these factors on gastrointestinal parasite infection in plains zebras (Equus quagga) in the Serengeti ecosystem, Tanzania, using fecal egg counts of two nematode families (Strongylidae and Ascarididae) and the presence/absence of cestode (Anoplocephalidae) eggs. We predicted higher egg counts of Strongylidae and Ascarididae, and increased likelihood of Anoplocephalidae infection in individuals (1) during energetically costly life history stages when resource allocation to immune processes may decrease and in young zebras after weaning because of increased uptake of infective stages with forage, (2) when climatic conditions facilitate survival of infective stages, (3) when large zebra aggregations increase forage contamination with infective stages, and (4) in individuals co-infected with more than one parasite group as this may indicate reduced immune competence. Strongylidae egg counts were higher, and the occurrence of Anoplocephalidae eggs was more likely in bachelors than in band stallions, whereas Ascarididae egg counts were higher in band stallions. Strongylidae and Ascarididae egg counts were not increased in lactating females. Strongylidae egg counts were higher in subadults than in foals. Regardless of sex and age, Ascarididae infections were more likely under wet conditions. Co-infections did not affect Strongylidae egg counts. Ascarididae egg counts in adult females were higher when individuals were co-infected with Anoplocephalidae. We present evidence that parasite burdens in plains zebras are affected by life history stage, environmental conditions, and co-infection.

GLOWORM-PARA: a flexible framework to simulate the population dynamics of the parasitic phase of gastrointestinal nematodes infecting grazing livestock

Gastrointestinal nematodes are a significant threat to the economic and environmental sustainability of keeping livestock, as adequate control becomes increasingly difficult due to the development of anthelmintic resistance in some systems and climate-driven changes to infection dynamics. To mitigate any negative impacts of climate on gastrointestinal nematode epidemiology and slow anthelmintic resistance development, there is a need to develop effective, targeted control strategies that minimise the unnecessary use of anthelmintic drugs and incorporate alternative strategies such as vaccination and evasive grazing. However, the impacts climate and gastrointestinal nematode epidemiology may have on the optimal control strategy are generally not considered, due to lack of available evidence to drive recommendations. Parasite transmission models can support control strategy evaluation to target field trials, thus reducing the resources and lead-time required to develop evidence-based control recommendations incorporating climate stochasticity. Gastrointestinal nematode population dynamics arising from natural infections have been difficult to replicate and model applications have often focussed on the free-living stages. A flexible framework is presented for the parasitic phase of gastrointestinal nematodes, GLOWORM-PARA, which complements an existing model of the free-living stages, GLOWORM-FL. Longitudinal parasitological data for two species that are of major economic importance in cattle, Ostertagia ostertagi and Cooperia oncophora, were obtained from seven cattle farms in Belgium for model validation. The framework replicated the observed seasonal dynamics of infection in cattle on these farms and overall, there was no evidence of systematic under- or over-prediction of faecal egg counts. However, the model under-predicted the faecal egg counts observed on one farm with very young calves, highlighting potential areas of uncertainty that may need further investigation if the model is to be applied to young livestock. The model could be used to drive further research into alternative parasite control strategies such as vaccine development and novel treatment approaches, and to understand gastrointestinal nematode epidemiology under changing climate and host management.

Dealing with double trouble: Combination deworming against double-drug resistant cyathostomins

An alternative control regimen for drug-resistant parasites is combination deworming, where two drugs with different modes of action are administered simultaneously to target the same parasite. Few studies have investigated this in equine cyathostomins. We previously reported that an oxibendazole (OBZ) and pyrantel pamoate (PYR) combination was not sustainable against a cyathostomin population with high levels of OBZ and PYR resistance. This study consisted of a field study and two computer simulations to evaluate the efficacy of a moxidectin-oxibendazole (MOX-OBZ) combination against the same cyathostomin population. In the field study, anthelmintic treatments occurred when ten horses exceeded 100 eggs per gram. Fecal egg counts and efficacy evaluations were performed every two weeks. The two simulations utilized weather data as well as equine and parasite population parameters from the field study. The first simulation repeated the treatment schedule used in the field study over a 40 year period. The second evaluated efficacies of combination treatments using selective therapy over 40 years. In the field study, efficacies of MOX and both combination treatments were 100%. The egg reappearance period for MOX was 16 weeks, and the two combination treatments were 12 and 18 weeks. The first (46.7%) and last (40.1%) OBZ efficacies were not significantly different from each other. In the simulation study, the combination treatment delayed MOX resistance development compared to when MOX was used as a single active. This occurred despite the low efficacy of OBZ. The second set of simulations identified combination treatments used with selective therapy to be the most effective at delaying MOX resistance. Overall, this study supports the use of combination treatment against drug-resistant cyathostomins, when one of the actives exhibits high efficacy, and demonstrates benefits of this approach despite substantially lowered efficacy of the other active ingredient.

•

Oxibendazole-moxidectin combination treatments were 100% effective.

•

Oxibendazole efficacies (<50%) did not differ pre and post combination treatment.

•

The model observed oxibendazole-moxidectincombinationto delaymoxidectin resistance.

•

Combination use in selective therapy delayed resistance most effectively.

Managing anthelmintic resistance in cyathostomin parasites: Investigating the benefits of refugia-based strategies

Selective anthelmintic therapy has been recommended as a sustainable strategy for cyathostomin control in horse populations for several decades. The traditional approach has been to determine strongyle fecal egg counts (FEC) for all horses, with treatment only recommended for those exceeding a predetermined threshold. The aims are to achieve a reduction of overall egg shedding, while leaving a proportion of the herd untreated, which lowers anthelmintic treatment intensity and reduces selection pressure for development of anthelmintic resistance. This study made use of the cyathostomin model to evaluate the influence of treatment strategies with between 1 and 8 yearly treatment occasions, where either 1) all horses were treated, 2) a predetermined proportion of the herd remained untreated, or 3) horses were treated if their FEC exceeded thresholds between 100 and 600 strongyle eggs per gram. Weather data representing four different climatic zones was used and three different herd age structures were compared; 1) all yearlings, 2) all mature horses 10-20 years old, and 3) a mixed age structure of 1-20 years of age. Results indicated a consistent effect of age structure, with anthelmintic resistance developing quickest in the yearling group and slowest among the mature horses. Development of anthelmintic resistance was affected by treatment intensity and selective therapy generally delayed resistance. Importantly, the results suggest that the effects of selective therapy on resistance development are likely to vary between climatic zones and herd age structures. Overall, a substantial delaying of resistance development requires that the average number of treatments administered annually across a herd of horses needs to be about two or less. However, results also indicate that an age-structured prioritisation of treatment to younger horses should still be effective. It appears that a 'one-size-fits-all' approach to the management of anthelmintic resistance in cyathostomins is unlikely to be optimal.

Encysted cyathostomin larval counts: Mucosal digestion revisited

Cyathostomins are pervasive equine parasites in horses across the world, and larval stages are known to cause the deadly disease larval cyathostominosis. The mucosal digestion technique is widely used for enumeration of encysted larval stages. Previous studies have investigated the spatial variation of encysted larvae, however current protocols lack a description of a standardized area from which to take the tissue sample. This study sought to evaluate spatial variation in encysted cyathostomin larval counts among the large intestinal organs and their subsections. Following humane euthanasia, ceca, ventral, and dorsal colons were harvested from 8 foals (aged 4-8 months) raised in an anthelmintic naïve parasitology research herd. Each organ was weighed and separated into 3 equal sections by length: the orad, intermediate, and aborad portions. From each of those sections, two 5% weight tissue samples were collected and digested to quantify the early third stage larvae (EL3) and late third stage larvae/fourth stage larvae (LL3/L4). A mixed model statistical analysis was carried out to evaluate for differences of larval counts among the different organs, sections, and the interaction term between the organs and sections. There were significant differences among organs (P < 0.0001), with the ceca having higher counts than the ventral and dorsal colons. However, there were no significant differences among the three defined organ sections (P = 0.1076). Coefficients of variation (CV) were all calculated to be greater than 1, suggesting a high level of variability among the samples; the least amount of variation can be found in the cecal data with a CV of 1.4024 compared with the ventral colon's 1.529845 and dorsal colon's 3.339135 within the respective organ. The following sections had the highest mean counts of encysted larvae: intermediate cecum, orad ventral colon, and aborad dorsal colon. Though only a portion of the results were significant, trends were observed and these should be investigated further in future studies and potentially employed in larvicidal efficacy evaluations.

Modelling the development of anthelmintic resistance in cyathostomin parasites: The importance of genetic and fitness parameters

Previously described models for the free-living and parasitic phases of the cyathostomin life-cycle were combined into a single model for the complete life-cycle. The model simulates a single free-living population on pasture utilising parasite egg output from the horses and localised temperature and rainfall data to estimate infective larval density on herbage. Multiple horses of different ages are possible, each with an individualised anthelmintic treatment programme. Genotypes for anthelmintic resistance are included allowing for up to three resistance genes with 2 alleles each. Because little is known of the genetics of resistance to anthelmintics in cyathostomins, the first use of this model was to compare the effect of different assumptions regarding the inheritance of resistance on model outputs. Comparisons were made between single and two-gene inheritance, where the heterozygote survival was dominant, intermediate or recessive under treatment, and with or without a fitness disadvantage associated with the resistance mechanism. Resistance developed fastest when the heterozygotes survived anthelmintic treatment (i.e., were dominant) and slowest when they did not (i.e., were recessive). Resistance was slower to develop when inheritance was poly-genic compared to a single gene, and when there was a fitness cost associated with the resistance mechanism, although the latter variable was the least influential. Importantly, while these genetic factors sometimes had a large influence on the rate at which resistant genotypes built up in the model populations, their order of ranking was always the same, when different anthelmintic use strategies were compared. Therefore, the described model is a useful tool for evaluating different treatment and management strategies on their potential to select for resistance.

The effect of climate, season, and treatment intensity on anthelmintic resistance in cyathostomins: A modelling exercise

Anthelmintic resistance is widespread in equine cyathostomin populations across the world, and with no new anthelmintic drug classes in the pharmaceutical pipeline, the equine industry is forced to abandon traditional parasite control regimens. Current recommendations aim at reducing treatment intensity and identifying high strongylid egg shedders in a targeted treatment approach. But, virtually nothing is known about the effectiveness of these recommendations, nor their applicability to different climatic regions, making it challenging to tailor sustainable recommendations for equine parasite control. This study made use of a computer model of the entire cyathostomin life-cycle to evaluate the influence of climate and seasonality on the development of anthelmintic resistance in cyathostomin parasites. Furthermore, the study evaluated the impact of recommended programs involving selective anthelmintic therapy on delaying anthelmintic resistance development. All simulations evaluated the use of a single anthelmintic (i.e., ivermectin) over the course of 40 model years. The study made use of weather station data representing four different climatic zones: a cold humid continental climate, a temperate oceanic climate, a cold semi-arid climate, and a humid subtropical climate. Initially, the impact of time of the year was evaluated when a single anthelmintic treatment was administered once a year in any of the twelve months. The next simulations evaluated the impact of treatment intensities varying between 2 and 6 treatments per year. And finally, we evaluated treatment schedules consisting of a combination of strategic treatments administered to all horses and additional treatments administered to horses exceeding a predetermined fecal egg count threshold. Month of treatment had a large effect on resistance development in colder climates, but little or no impact in subtropical and tropical climates. Resistance development was affected by treatment intensity, but was also strongly affected by climate. Selective therapy delayed resistance development in all modelled scenarios, but, again, this effect was climate dependent with the largest delays observed in the colder climates. This study is the first to demonstrate the value of cyathostomin parasite refugia in managing anthelmintic resistance, and also that climate and seasonality are important. This modelling exercise has allowed an illustration of concepts believed to play important roles in anthelmintic resistance in equine cyathostomins, but has also identified knowledge gaps and new questions to address in future studies.

A model for the dynamics of the parasitic stages of equine cyathostomins

A model was developed to reproduce the dynamics of the parasitic stages of equine cyathostomins. Based on a detailed review of published literature, a deterministic simulation model was constructed using the escalator boxcar-train approach, which allows for fully-overlapping cohorts of worms and approximately normally distributed variations in age/size classes. Key biological features include a declining establishment of ingested infective stage larvae as horses age. Development rates are constant for all the parasitic stages except the encysted early third stage larvae, for which development rates are variable to reflect the sometimes extended arrestment of this stage. For these, development is slowed in the presence of adult worms in the intestinal lumen, and when ingestion of infective larvae on herbage is high or extended. In the absence of anthelmintic treatments, the life span of adult worms is approximately 12 months, and the presence of an established adult worm burden largely blocks the transition of luminal fourth stage larvae to the adult stage, resulting in mortality of the larvae. This inhibition is removed by effective anthelmintic treatment allowing the rapid replacement of adult worms from the pool of mucosal stages. Within the model, the rate and seasonality at which infective stage larvae are ingested strongly influences the dynamics of the pre-adult stages. While the adult worm burden remains relatively stable within a year, due to the negative feedback they have on developing stages, the numbers and proportions of larval stages relative to the total worm burden increase with the numbers of infective larvae ingested. Further, within the model, the seasonal rise and fall of encysted stages is largely driven by the seasonal pattern of infective larvae on pasture. Because of this, the model reproduces the contrasting seasonal patterns of mucosal larvae, typical of temperate and tropical environments, using only the appropriate seasonality of larvae on pasture. Thus, the model reproduces output typical of different climatic regions and suggests that observed patterns of arrested development may simply reflect the numbers and seasonality of free-living stages on pasture as determined by different management practices and weather patterns.