Development of a human live attenuated West Nile infectious DNA vaccine: Identification of a minimal mutation set conferring the attenuation level acceptable for a human vaccine

In vivo rescue of arboviruses directly from subgenomic DNA fragments

Reverse genetic systems are mainly used to rescue recombinant viral strains in cell culture. These tools have also been used to generate, by inoculating infectious clones, viral strains directly in living animals. We previously developed the "Infectious Subgenomic Amplicons" (ISA) method, which enables the rescue of single-stranded positive sense RNA viruses in vitro by transfecting overlapping subgenomic DNA fragments. Here, we provide proof-of-concept for direct in vivo generation of infectious particles following the inoculation of subgenomic amplicons. First, we rescued a strain of tick-borne encephalitis virus in mice to transpose the ISA method in vivo. Subgenomic DNA fragments were amplified using a 3-fragment reverse genetics system and inoculated intramuscularly. Almost all animals were infected when quantities of DNA inoculated were at least 20 µg. We then optimized our procedure in order to increase the animal infection rate. This was achieved by adding an electroporation step and/or using a simplified 2- fragment reverse genetics system. Under optimal conditions, a large majority of animals were infected with doses of 20 ng of DNA. Finally, we demonstrated the versatility of this method by applying it to Japanese encephalitis and Chikungunya viruses. This method provides an efficient strategy for in vivo rescue of arboviruses. Furthermore, in the context of the development of DNA-launched live attenuated vaccines, this new approach may facilitate the generation of attenuated strains in vivo. It also enables to deliver a substance free of any vector DNA, which seems to be an important criterion for the development of human vaccines.

Adaptation of a live-attenuated genotype I Japanese encephalitis virus to vero cells is associated with mutations in structural protein genes

The SD12-F120 is a live-attenuated genotype I strain of Japanese encephalitis virus (JEV) and was obtained by serial passage of wild-type strain SD12 on BHK-21 cells combined with multiple plaque purification and virulence selection in mice. The large scale production and vast clinical trials always demand ideal safety and efficacy profile of live-attenuated vaccines. In the present study, SD12-F120VC has undergone serial passaging of P1-P30 in WHO qualified Vero cells to assess the potential effect of adaptation to growth on Vero cells. The series of experiments showed that vaccine SD12-F120VC (Vero cell adapted) variants have consistently increased in peak virus titer compared to early passages and have good adaptation to growth in Vero cells. The animal experiments showed that Vero cell adapted SD12-F120VC variants have attenuation phenotype in suckling mice and the plaque morphology for all SD12-F120VC variants was small. Vaccination of mice with SD12-F120VC vaccine produced complete protection for homologous SD12 genotype I strain, but failed to give the complete protection of vaccinated mice against the challenge of heterologous N28 genotype III strain. In response to immunization of SD12-F120VC in mice, the neutralizing antibodies titer against homologous SD12-F120VC and SD12 (GI) was higher than heterologous N28 (GIII) strain. The prM protein has 6 amino acid substitutions, of which 5 amino acid changes were confined at the start of the pr domain in the ∼40 amino acids, and some mutations in the pr domain of prM might contribute to Vero cell adaptation. Our findings in this study are important for validation, evaluation and quality control study of live attenuated flaviviruses vaccines and show that Vero cells are a suitable substrate for the production of a safe and stable live-attenuated JEV vaccine.

West Nile Virus: An Update on Pathobiology, Epidemiology, Diagnostics, Control and "One Health" Implications

West Nile virus (WNV) is an important zoonotic flavivirus responsible for mild fever to severe, lethal neuroinvasive disease in humans, horses, birds, and other wildlife species. Since its discovery, WNV has caused multiple human and animal disease outbreaks in all continents, except Antarctica. Infections are associated with economic losses, mainly due to the cost of treatment of infected patients, control programmes, and loss of animals and animal products. The pathogenesis of WNV has been extensively investigated in natural hosts as well as in several animal models, including rodents, lagomorphs, birds, and reptiles. However, most of the proposed pathogenesis hypotheses remain contentious, and much remains to be elucidated. At the same time, the unavailability of specific antiviral treatment or effective and safe vaccines contribute to the perpetuation of the disease and regular occurrence of outbreaks in both endemic and non-endemic areas. Moreover, globalisation and climate change are also important drivers of the emergence and re-emergence of the virus and disease. Here, we give an update of the pathobiology, epidemiology, diagnostics, control, and “One Health” implications of WNV infection and disease.

Japanese encephalitis vaccine-specific envelope protein E138K mutation does not attenuate virulence of West Nile virus

West Nile (WNV) and Japanese encephalitis viruses (JEV) are closely related, mosquito-borne neurotropic flaviviruses. Although there are no licensed human vaccines for WNV, JEV has multiple human vaccines, including the live, attenuated vaccine SA14-14-2. Investigations into determinants of attenuation of JE SA14-14-2 demonstrated that envelope (E) protein mutation E138K was crucial to the attenuation of mouse virulence. As WNV is closely related to JEV, we investigated whether or not the E-E138K mutation would be beneficial to be included in a candidate live attenuated WNV vaccine. Rather than conferring a mouse attenuated phenotype, the WNV E-E138K mutant reverted and retained a wild-type mouse virulence phenotype. Next-generation sequencing analysis demonstrated that, although the consensus sequence of the mutant had the E-E138K mutation, there was increased variation in the E protein, including a single-nucleotide variant (SNV) revertant to the wild-type glutamic acid residue. Modeling of the E protein and analysis of SNVs showed that reversion was likely due to the inability of critical E-protein residues to be compatible electrostatically. Therefore, this mutation may not be reliable for inclusion in candidate live attenuated vaccines in related flaviviruses, such as WNV, and care must be taken in translation of attenuating mutations from one virus to another virus, even if they are closely related.

Japanese encephalitis virus (JEV) and West Nile virus (WNV) are closely related neurotropic viruses—a live attenuated vaccine exists for JEV but not for WNV. A team led by Alan D.T. Barrett at the University of Texas investigated whether a key E-protein mutation (E138K) in the live attenuated JEV vaccine can also attenuate a candidate live WNV vaccine. The mutant WNV vaccine shows essentially identical behavior to the virulent parental strain in vitro but unexpectedly also has unimpaired lethality and neurotropism when mice are challenged intraperitoneally. Sequencing of the mutant WNV vaccine demonstrated increased frequencies of single-nucleotide variants clustered around residue 138—including reversion to the parental strain glutamic acid. E138K mutation is therefore unlikely to be a reliable means to attenuate candidate WNV vaccines.

Towards development of plasmacytoma cells-based expression systems utilizing alphavirus vectors: An NS0-VEE model

Plasmacytoma (myeloma) cells have a large protein expression capacity, although their industrial use is confined to stable expression systems. Vectors derived from genomes of viruses from the genus Alphavirus allow obtaining of high yields of target proteins but their use is limited to transient expression. Little information has been published to date on attempts to combine the myeloma cells as hosts with alphaviruses as expression vectors. A plasmid construct which allows rescue of a model alphavirus Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus (VEE) upon transfection of a cell culture was created. Mutations in the capsid and nsP2 genes allow for less cytopathogenic propagation of the virus. A cDNA-copy of the genome was placed in a plasmid under the control of the CMV promoter for virus rescue following DNA transfection. Parameters for the virus rescue by electroporating of the infectious clone in murine myeloma cells (NS0) were optimized. The highest FFU counts (1.2 × 10⁵ FFU per 10 ug DNA) were produced with 2 pulses (voltage 250 V, capacitance 960 u F) and the best electroporation buffer was selected from eight buffers. Self-sustained VEE infection was established in NS0 cultures with high titers (8 × 10⁸ FFU/ml) of the virus, despite a fraction of infected cells dying during 5-days observation. Further development of the NS0-VEE expression system may require addressing of apoptosis induced by VEE.

Replication-Defective West Nile Virus with NS1 Deletion as a New Vaccine Platform for Flavivirus

We previously produced a replication-defective West Nile virus (WNV) lacking NS1 (WNV-ΔNS1) that could propagate at low levels (10⁵ infectious units [IU]/ml) in a 293T cell line expressing wild-type (WT) NS1. This finding indicates the potential of developing WNV-ΔNS1 as a noninfectious vaccine. To explore this idea, we developed an NS1-expressing Vero cell line (Vero_NS1) that significantly improved the yield of WNV-ΔNS1 (10⁸ IU/ml). We evaluated the safety and efficacy of WNV-ΔNS1 in mice. WNV-ΔNS1 appeared to be safe, as no replicative virus was found in naive Vero cells after continuous culturing of WNV-ΔNS1 in Vero_NS1 cells for 15 rounds. WNV-ΔNS1 was noninfectious in mice, even when IFNAR^-/- mice were administered a high dose of WNV-ΔNS1. Vaccination with a single dose of WNV-ΔNS1 protected mice from a highly lethal challenge with WT WNV. The antibody response against WNV correlated well with the protection of vaccinated mice. Our study demonstrates the potential of the NS1 trans complementation system as a new platform for flavivirus vaccine development.IMPORTANCE Many flaviviruses are significant human pathogens that frequently cause outbreaks and epidemics around the world. Development of novel vaccine platforms against these pathogens is a public health priority. Using WNV as a model, we developed a new vaccine platform for flaviviruses. WNV containing a NS1 deletion (WNV-ΔNS1) could be efficiently trans complemented in Vero cells that constitutively expressed WT NS1 protein. A single-dose immunization with WNV-ΔNS1 elicited robust immune responses in mice. The immunized animals were fully protected against pathogenic WNV infection. No adverse effects related to the WNV-ΔNS1 vaccination were observed. The results have demonstrated the potential of the NS1 complementation system as an alternative platform for flavivirus vaccine development, especially for highly pathogenic flaviviruses.

Structure-based prediction of West Nile virus-human protein-protein interactions

In recent years, West Nile virus (WNV) has posed a great threat to global human health due to its explosive spread. Studying the protein-protein interactions (PPIs) between WNV and human is beneficial for understanding the pathogenesis of WNV and the immune response mechanism of human against WNV infection at the molecular level. In this study, we identified the human target proteins which interact with WNV based on protein structure similarity, and then the interacting pairs were filtered by the subcellular co-localization information. As a result, a network of 3346 interactions was constructed, involving 6 WNV proteins and 1970 human target proteins. To our knowledge, this is the first predicted interactome for WNV-human. By analyzing the topological properties and evolutionary rates of the human target proteins, it was demonstrated that these proteins tend to be the hub and bottleneck proteins in the human PPI network and are more conserved than the non-target ones. Triplet analysis showed that the target proteins are adjacent to each other in the human PPI network, suggesting that these proteins may have similar biological functions. Further, the functional enrichment analysis indicated that the target proteins are mainly involved in virus process, transcription regulation, cell adhesion, and so on. In addition, the common and specific targets were identified and compared based on the networks between WNV-human and Dengue virus II (DENV2)-human. Finally, by combining topological features and existing drug target information, we identified 30 potential anti-WNV human targets, among which 11 ones were reported to be associated with WNV infection. Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.