Not all SuDS are created equal: Impact of different approaches on combined sewer overflows

Connecting blue-green infrastructure elements to reduce combined sewer overflows

By infiltrating and retaining stormwater, Blue-Green Infrastructure (BGI) can help to reduce Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs), one of the main causes of urban water pollution. Several studies have evaluated the ability of individual BGI types to reduce CSOs; however, the effect of combining these elements, likely to occur in reality, has not yet been thoroughly evaluated. Moreover, the CSO volume reduction potential of relevant components of the urban drainage system, such as detention ponds, has not been quantified using hydrological models. This study presents a systematic way to assess the potential of BGI combinations to mitigate CSO discharge in a catchment near Zurich (Switzerland). Sixty BGI combinations, including four BGI elements (bioretention cells, permeable pavement, green roofs, and detention ponds) and four different implementation rates (25%, 50%, 75%, and 100% of the available sewer catchment area) are evaluated for four runoff routing schemes. Results reveal that BGI combinations can provide substantial CSO volume reductions; however, combinations including detention ponds can potentially increase CSO frequency, due to runoff prolongation. When runoff from upstream areas is routed to the BGI, the CSO discharge reductions from combinations of BGI elements differ from the cumulative CSO discharge reductions achieved by individual BGI types, indicating that the sum of effects from individual BGI types cannot accurately predict CSO discharge in combined BGI scenarios. Moreover, larger BGI implementation areas are not consistently more cost-effective than small implementation areas, since the additional CSO volume reduction does not outweigh the additional costs. The best-performing BGI combination depends on the desired objective, being CSO volume reduction, CSO frequency reduction or cost-effectiveness. This study emphasizes the importance of BGI combinations and detention ponds in CSO mitigation plans, highlighting their critical factors-BGI types, implementation area, and runoff routing- and offering a novel and systematic approach to develop tailored BGI strategies for urban catchments facing CSO challenges.

Combined sewer overflow mitigation through SUDS - A review on modelling practices, scenario elaboration, and related performances

Hydrologic-hydraulic modelling of urban catchment is an asset for land managers to simulate Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems (SUDS) implementation to fulfil combined sewer overflow (CSO) regulations. This review aims to assess the current practices in modelling SUDS scenarios at large scale for CSO mitigation encompassing every stage of the modelling process from the choice of the equation to the validation of the initial state of the urban system, right through to the elaboration, modelling, and selection of SUDS scenarios to evaluate their performance on CSO. Through a quantitative and qualitative analysis of 50 published studies, we found a diversity of choices when modelling the status quo of the urban system. Authors generally do not explain the modelling processes of slow components (deep infiltration, groundwater infiltration) and interconnexion between SUDS and the sewer system. In addition, only a few authors explain how CSO structures are modelled. Furthermore, the modelling of SUDS implementation at catchment scale is highlighted in the 50 studies retrieved with three different approaches going from simplified to detailed. SUDS modelling choices seem to be consistent with the objectives: studies focusing on dealing with several objectives at the time typically opt for a complex system configuration that includes the surface processes, network, CSO, SUDS, and often the soil and/or groundwater components. Conversely, authors who have selected a basic configuration generally aim to address a single, straightforward question (e.g., which type of SUDS). However, elaboration and selection of scenarios for CSO mitigation is mainly based on local constraints, which does not allow hydrological performance to be directly optimised. In conclusion, to improve current practices in modelling SUDS scenarios at large scale for CSO mitigation, authors suggest to: (i) improve clear practices of CSO modelling, calibration and validation at the urban catchment scale, (ii) develop methods to optimize the performance of scenarios for CSO mitigation using hydrological drivers, and (iii) improve parsimonious and user-friendly models to simulate SUDS scenarios in a context of data scarcity.

Do baseline assumptions alter the efficacy of green stormwater infrastructure to reduce combined sewer overflows?

Green stormwater infrastructure (GSI) is growing in popularity to reduce combined sewer overflows (CSOs) and hydrologic simulation models are a tool to assess their reduction potential. Given the numerous and interacting water flows that contribute to CSOs, such as evapotranspiration (ET) and groundwater (GW), these models should ideally account for them. However, due to the complexity, simplified models are often used, and it is currently unknown how these assumptions affect estimates of CSOs, GSI effectiveness, and ultimately planning guidance. This study evaluates the effect on estimates of CSOs and GSI effectiveness when different flows and hydrologic processes are neglected. We modified an existing EPA SWMM model of a combined sewer system in Switzerland to include ET, GW, and upstream inflows. Historical rainfall data over 30 years are used to assess volume and duration of CSOs with and without three types of GSI (bioretention basins, permeable pavements and green roofs). Results demonstrate that neglect of certain flows in modelling can alter CSO volumes from -15 % to 40 %. GSI effectiveness also varies considerably, resulting in differences in simulated percent of CSO volume reduced from 8 % to 35 %, depending on the GSI type and modeled flow or process. Representation of GW within models is particularly crucial when infiltrating GSI are present, as CSOs could increase in certain subcatchments due to higher GW levels from increased infiltration. When basing GSI planning decisions on modeled estimates of CSOs, all relevant hydrologic processes should be included to the extent possible, and uncertainty and assumptions should always be considered.

Effects of urban catchment characteristics on combined sewer overflows

Pollution from Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs) cause diffuse environmental problems, which are still not satisfactorily addressed by current management practices. In this study, a sensitivity analysis was conducted on several CSO environmental impact indicators, with respect to parameters that characterise climate, urban catchment and the CSO structure activation threshold. The sensitivity analysis was conducted by running 10000 simulations with the Storm Water Management Model, using a simplified modelling approach. The indicators were calculated at yearly scale to evaluate overall potential effects on water bodies. The results could be used to estimate pollution load ranges, known the values of the input parameters, and to investigate suitable strategies to reduce pollution of the receiving water bodies. The percentage of impervious surface of the catchment was found the most influent parameter on all the indicators, and its reduction can contain the discharged pollutant mass. The activation threshold, instead, resulted the second least influent parameter on all the indicators, suggesting that its regulation alone would not be a suitable strategy to reduce CSO pollution. However, along with the reduction of the imperviousness, its increase could effectively decrease the concentration of pollutant in the overflow. The results also indicate that neither adopting sustainable urban drainage practices, nor interventions on the CSO device, significantly affect the frequency of the overflows. Therefore, restricting this latter was found to be ineffective for the reduction of both the discharged pollutant mass and the concentration of pollutant in the overflow.

The effect of green infrastructure on resilience performance in combined sewer systems under climate change

Climate change is currently reshaping precipitation patterns, intensifying extremes, and altering runoff dynamics. Particularly susceptible to these impacts are combined sewer systems (CSS), which convey both stormwater and wastewater and can lead to combined sewer overflow (CSO) discharges during heavy rainfall. Green infrastructure (GI) can help mitigate these discharges and enhance system resilience under historical conditions; however, the quantification of its effect on resilience in a future climate remains unknown in the literature. This study employs a modified Global Resilience Analysis (GRA) framework for continuous simulation to quantify the impact of climate change on CSS resilience, particularly CSOs. The study assesses the efficacy of GI interventions (green roofs, permeable pavements, and bioretention cells) under diverse future rainfall scenarios based on EURO-CORDEX regional climate models (2085-2099) and three Representative Concentration Pathways (2.6, 4.5, 8.5 W/m2). The findings underscore a general decline in resilience indices across the future rainfall scenarios considered. Notably, the total yearly CSO discharge volume increases by a range of 145 % to 256 % in response to different rainfall scenarios. While GI proves effective in increasing resilience, it falls short of offsetting the impacts of climate change. Among the GI options assessed, green roofs routed to pervious areas exhibit the highest adaptive capacity, ranging from 9 % to 22 % at a system level, followed by permeable pavements with an adaptation capacity between 7 and 13 %. By linking the effects of future rainfall scenarios on CSO performance, this study contributes to understanding GI's potential as a strategic tool for enhancing urban resilience.

A drainage network-based impact matrix to support targeted blue-green-grey stormwater management solutions

Urban floods will continue to be an alarming issue worldwide due to climate change and urban expansion. The costly and less environmentally friendly grey infrastructure is not always the most adequate solution to resolve urban pluvial flooding issues. The combination of grey and blue-green infrastructures, also called hybrid infrastructure, has been considered a promising solution for urban stormwater management. Existing approaches for identifying suitable hybrid solutions frequently rely on global multi-objective optimization algorithms. We developed a pre-screening method that decomposes a drainage network into clusters of pipes connected to sub-catchments, based on pipe hydraulic characteristic that allows for the impact of infrastructure combinations (blue-green and grey) to be mapped. Four impact matrices are proposed to map the total, local, upstream, and downstream flood reduction of all possible blue-green, grey, and hybrid solutions. Using an urban catchment in Guangzhou (China) as a case study, results showed that such an exercise could identify prime candidate locations for blue-green and grey infrastructure while filtering out ineffective locations for flood reduction. Furthermore, the impact matrices enabled the identification of flood zones where blue-green infrastructure could handle flood mitigation without the need of local grey infrastructure upgrades. As such, they are not only useful for quick screening of suitable interventions for each flooded zone, but can also potentially serve as a priori knowledge before diving into the data and computationally expensive process of finding the most effective flood mitigation solutions.

Global resilience analysis of combined sewer systems under continuous hydrologic simulation

Managing and reducing combined sewer overflow (CSO) discharges is crucial for enhancing the resilience of combined sewer systems (CSS). However, the absence of a standardised resilience analysis approach poses challenges in developing effective discharge reduction strategies. To address this, our study presents a top-down method that expands the existing Global Resilience Analysis to quantify resilience performance in CSS. This approach establishes a link between threats (e.g., rainfall) and impacts (e.g., CSOs) through continuous and long-term simulation, accommodating various rainfall patterns, including extreme events. We assess CSO discharge impacts from a resilience perspective by introducing eight new metrics. We conducted a case study in Fehraltorf, Switzerland, analysing the performance of three green infrastructure (GI) types (bioretention cells, green roofs, and permeable pavements) over 38 years. The results demonstrated that GI enhanced all resilience indices, with variations observed in individual CSO performance metrics and their system locations. Notably, in Fehraltorf, green roofs emerged as the most effective GI type for improving resilience, while the downstream outfall displayed the highest resilience enhancement. Overall, our proposed method enables a shift from event-based to continuous simulation analysis, providing a standardised approach for resilience assessment. This approach informs the development of strategies for CSO discharge reduction and the enhancement of CSS resilience.

Development of an analytical permeable pavement model for vehicular access areas

Permeable pavements (PPs) are widely used for stormwater control in urbanized areas as they provide absorption and retention of surface runoff. Previous studies on PP systems mainly focus on non-vehicular access areas with light traffic loads where the base usually connects to native soils which allow exfiltration from the bottom. The runoff reduction performance of the PPs in vehicular access areas (PPs-VAA) featured by more complex structure with underdrain outflow control still needs in-depth investigation. In this study, an analytical probabilistic model was developed to quantify the runoff control performance of PPs-VAA taking into account the effects of climate conditions, layer configurations and varying underdrain outflows. The calibration and verification of the proposed analytical permeable pavement model for vehicular access areas (APPM-VAA) were performed by comparing the analytical results with SWMM simulation results. The model was tested in case studies in Guangzhou and Jinan, China, with humid and semi-humid climate conditions, respectively. Close agreement between the results obtained from the proposed analytical model and those from continuous simulation outputs was observed. The proposed analytical model is proved to be capable of rapidly assessing the runoff control performance of PPs-VAA; it can thus be used in the hydrologic design and analysis of permeable pavement systems in engineering practices.

Enhancing stormwater management with low impact development (LID): a review of the rain barrel, bioretention, and permeable pavement applicability in Indonesia

Low impact development (LID) is a sustainable land use and planning strategy that aims to minimize the environmental impacts of development. A community can enhance their water resources and create sustainable and resilient neighbourhoods. This approach has demonstrated success in managing stormwater and promoting water reuse globally, however, its suitability in developing countries like Indonesia remains uncertain and requires further investigation. The implementation of LID in developing countries may face several challenges including high density and complex drainage networks, combined sewer usage, clay soil type, irregular housing layouts, community socio-economic characteristics, affordability, cost, and the availability of regulations and policies. With proper planning and site-specific strategies, LID can be implemented effectively in Indonesia. Clear regulations, secured funding source and community-based LID are all essential for successful LID deployment. This paper can be used as a starting point for considering LID implementation in Indonesia and other countries with similar characteristics.

Optimal siting of rainwater harvesting systems for reducing combined sewer overflows at city scale

The installation of green infrastructure (GI) is an effective approach to manage urban stormwater and combined sewer overflow (CSO) by restoring pre-development conditions in urban areas. Research on simulation-optimization techniques to aid with GI planning decision-making is expanding. However, due to high computational expense, the simulation-optimization methods are often based on design storm events, and it is unclear how much different rainfall scenarios (i.e., design storm events vs. long-term historical rainfall data) impact the optimal siting of GI. The Parallel Pareto Archived Dynamically Dimensioned Search (ParaPADDS) algorithm in a novel simulation-optimization tool OSTRICH-SWMM was used to leverage distributed computing resources. A case study was conducted to optimally site rainwater harvesting cisterns within 897 potential subcatchments throughout the City of Buffalo, New York. Seven design storm events with different return periods and rainfall durations and a one-month historical rainfall time series were considered. The results showed that the optimal solutions of siting cisterns using event-based scenarios, though less computationally expensive, may not perform well under continuous rainfall scenarios, suggesting design rainfall scenarios should be carefully considered for optimizing GI planning. The impact of rainfall scenarios was particularly significant in the middle region of the Pareto front of multi-objective optimization. Utilizing high-performance parallel computing, OSTRICH-SWMM is a promising tool to optimize GI at large spatial and temporal scales.

Optimization of in-pipe storage capacity use in urban drainage systems with improved DP considering the time lag of flow routing

The active control of urban drainage systems (UDSs) is playing an increasingly important role in the world threatened by urban flooding and associated disasters caused by insufficient drainage capacity. However, little research has recognized the importance of the optimal use of in-pipe storage space. To address this issue, the use of the in-pipe storage capacity was optimized in this study. A novel approach, that is, dynamic programming with successive approximation considering the time lag of flow routing (DPSA-TL), was developed to determine the control policies, in addition to the commonly used passive, rule-based control (RBC), and evolutionary algorithm (EA) strategies. A real-life urban catchment considering flooding control and combined sewer overflow (CSO) reduction was used as the case study. First of all, the potential benefit of maximizing the use of in-pipe storage space was tested using the four control strategies in three storm events, including a 3-year, 2-hour design (46.5 mm), a 5-year, 2-hour design (56.0 mm) and a 7-h historical (152.5 mm) storm events. Results indicate that DPSA-TL performed best in all cases. Without compromising the goal of flooding control, it provided 16.5%, 12.6%, and 3.0% reductions in CSO volume for the three storm events when compared with the passive strategy. Due to the limited capacity of in-pipe storage, the relative improvement diminished as the total rainfall depth increased. Then, control strategies were further applicated to the real-time operation. DPSA-TL was found to be the best alternative for CSO control, with the CSO volume reduced by 14.7%, 11.4%, and 2.5% in the three storm events, respectively. The findings suggest that the performance of UDS can be significantly improved by optimizing the use of in-pipe storage capacity, and the proposed method is effective in the offline optimization and real-time control of UDSs.

Costs and benefits of combined sewer overflow management strategies at the European scale

Combined sewer overflows (CSOs) may represent a significant source of pollution, but they are difficult to quantify at a large scale (e.g. regional or national), due to a lack of accessible data. In the present study, we use a large scale, 6-parameter, lumped hydrological model to perform a screening level assessment of different CSO management scenarios for the European Union and United Kingdom, considering prevention and treatment strategies. For each scenario we quantify the potential reduction of CSO volumes and duration, and estimate costs and benefits. A comparison of scenarios shows that treating CSOs before discharge in the receiving water body (e.g. by constructed wetlands) is more cost-effective than preventing CSOs. Among prevention strategies, urban greening has a benefit/cost ratio one order of magnitude higher than grey solutions, due to the several additional benefits it entails. We also estimate that real time control may bring on average a CSO volume reduction of just above 20%. In general, the design of appropriate CSO management strategies requires consideration of context-specific conditions, and is best made in the context of an integrated urban water management plan taking into account factors such as other ongoing initiatives in urban greening, the possibility to disconnect impervious surfaces from combined drainage systems, and the availability of space for grey or nature-based solutions.

Real-time model predictive and rule-based control with green infrastructures to reduce combined sewer overflows

The impact of integrating large-scale distribution of green infrastructures (GIs) with different real-time control strategies on combined sewer overflows (CSOs) is assessed for the southern area of the City of Montreal's combined sewer system (Canada). An iterative process involving a synthetic design rainfall event and model predictive control (MPC) of the sewer system is developed to distribute GIs according to cost-efficiency and spatial analysis criteria. The distributed GIs are alternatively integrated with static, rule-based control (RBC) and MPC, for which model simulations are performed for a two-month period. The performance of the three strategies is compared in terms of CSO volume and frequency reductions, fulfillment of the outfall environmental priorities and transfer of runoff capture to CSO volume reduction. A gradual increase in GI implementation levels and an alternative scenario of GIs distribution are also considered to assess the performance of the two real-time control (RTC) strategies. By comparing the scenarios where GIs are uniformly distributed with those where no GIs are implemented and omitting the most extreme rainfall event, average CSO volume reduction is about 65%, 82% and 92%, respectively, for static control, RBC and MPC. Moreover, the scenario integrating GIs with MPC is the only one permitting to avoid almost all CSO events and the fulfilment of the outfall environmental priorities. GIs efficiency performance (the transferability between global runoff capture and CSO volume reduction) is also the highest under MPC, even when considering varying GI implementation levels and spatial distribution schemes.

Scientific Evidence behind the Ecosystem Services Provided by Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems

Urban green infrastructure such as sustainable urban drainage systems are potential providers of ecosystem services. This paper reviews the field studies that empirically verify the potential benefits of SUDS. The cultural, provisioning, supporting, and regulating ecosystem services investigated in real cases have been studied and classified according to climatology (except for the control of urban hydrology, which has been widely corroborated). Although successful cases of runoff decontamination are numerous, there is heterogeneity in the results of the systems beyond those associated with climatic differences. The other ecosystem services have not been as widely studied, giving very variable and even negative results in some cases such as climate change control (in some instances, these techniques can emit greenhouse gases). Installations in temperate climates are, by far, the most studied. These services derive from the biological processes developed in green infrastructure and they depend on climate, so it would be advisable to carry out specific studies that could serve as the basis for a design that optimizes potential ecosystem services, avoiding possible disservices.

Characteristics of overflow pollution from combined sewer sediment: Formation, contribution and regulation

Sewer sediments contain high concentrations of carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus pollutants, which can be the main source of overflow pollution due to high-velocity scouring. To elucidate the scouring overflow pollution characteristics and regulation mechanism of sewer sediment under different precipitation intensities, a sewer-storage tank linkage control experimental device was established to simulate the practical sewer overflow under different precipitation intensities and the control process of storage tank overflow pollutants. Based on the division of flow from small to large, the pollution characteristics of overflow pollutants and the contribution rate of sewer sediments to overflow pollutants were analysed. The results showed that the total load of overflow pollutants increased with an increase in rainfall intensity and were 7.58 kg, 16.54 kg, 27.42 kg, respectively. The concentration of particulate pollutants increased sharply in a short time, and the concentration of dissolved pollutants decreased at a certain dilution. Sewer sediment was the main source of overflow pollutants, contributing up to 70%. After the overflow pollutants entered the regulation and storage tank, a certain stratification phenomenon was discovered at different sedimentation times. The concentration of large particle pollutants gradually increased from top to bottom in the regulation and storage tank, and the concentration of dissolved pollutants showed no obvious difference between the layers. With an increase in rainfall intensity, the recommended regulation and storage times of overflow pollutants were within 15 min, 45-60 min, and 60 min, respectively. Finally, based on the relationship among rainfall intensity, sediment scouring thickness, regulation and storage time, a prediction formula for the regulation and storage time of overflow pollutants was obtained, which provided a basis for the regulation and treatment of subsequent overflow pollutants.

A novel multi-objective optimization framework for urban green-gray infrastructure implementation under impacts of climate change

Frequent urban flooding disasters can cause severe economic and property losses. Accordingly, the construction of sponge city has become critical to alleviating urban flooding. However, the functional and structural integration of Green Infrastructure (GI) and Gray Drainage Facility (GDF) is still a matter of concern. This study proposed a novel implementation framework for GI and GDF synchronization optimization (G-GSOIF) based on the SWMM and SUSTAIN models, and used data from Beilin District in Xi'an, China to verify the effects. The results show that the spatiotemporal integrated optimization design of GI and GDF proves to be effective in stormwater management. The total investment was reduced by 16.7% and economic benefit was increased by 15.4% based on disaster risk control, and the utilization rate of rainwater resources exceeded 40%. The Staged optimization model (SSOM) based on the SUSTAIN model established in the G-GSOIF was demonstrated to effectively cope with the impact of future climate change by adjusting and optimizing the design scheme dynamically in different simulation scenarios. Integrated LID (I-LID) measures are conducive for simulation of large catchment areas, and have the same implementation effect as distributed LID measures. The results of this study could support decision-making for urban stormwater management and sponge city construction.

Sponge City Practices in China: From Pilot Exploration to Systemic Demonstration

In recent years, China has been committed to strengthening environmental governance and trying to build a sustainable society in which humans and nature develop in harmony. As a new urban construction concept, sponge city uses natural and ecological methods to retain rainwater, alleviate flooding problems, reduce the damage to the water environment, and gradually restore the hydrological balance of the construction area. The paper presents a review of sponge city construction from its inception to systematic demonstration. In this paper, research gaps are discussed and future efforts are proposed. The main contents include: (1) China’s sponge city construction includes but is not limited to source control or a drainage system design. Sponge city embodies foreign experience and the wisdom of ancient Chinese philosophy. The core of sponge city construction is to combine various specific technologies to alleviate urban water problems such as flooding, water environment pollution, shortage of water resources and deterioration of water ecology; (2) this paper also introduces the sponge city pilot projects in China, and summarizes the achievements obtained and lessons learned, which are valuable for future sponge city implementation; (3) the objectives, corresponding indicators, key contents and needs of sponge city construction at various scales are different. The work at the facility level is dedicated to alleviating urban water problems through reasonable facility scale and layout, while the work at the plot level is mainly to improve the living environment through sponge city construction. The construction of urban and watershed scales is more inclined to ecological restoration and blue-green storage spaces construction. Besides, the paper also describes the due obligations in sponge city construction of various stakeholders.

A SUDS Planning Decision Support Tool to Maximize Ecosystem Services

In the past years, alternative drainage approaches have emerged, such as Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems (SUDS), to prevent run-off and flooding impacts on the most vulnerable zones of the cities. These systems not only provide the benefit of water regulation but also promote other types of ecosystem services. Several studies have developed optimization tools to assist SUDS selection, location, and design. However, they do not consider a comprehensive set of ecosystem services (e.g., provision, regulation, cultural, and support services). This research proposes a flexible and adaptable methodology to incorporate SUDS in different stages of urban projects using a multi-objective optimization technique to minimize run-off, maximize ecosystem services and minimize cost. The methodology comprises four phases: (1) the preliminary analysis of ecosystem services potentially generated by each SUDS type, (2) the priority and opportunity index quantification, (3) the physical feasibility analysis, and (4) the multi-objective optimization tool implementation. The methodology was successfully applied to three different urban areas of Bogotá city (Colombia). Results evidence that the interaction of the budget constraints and the available area restrict the potential benefits of SUDS implementation. These results are helpful to support different urban planning stages.

Blue-Green Infrastructure for Flood and Water Quality Management in Southeast Asia: Evidence and Knowledge Gaps

In Southeast Asia, projections of rapid urban growth coupled with high water-related risks call for large investments in infrastructure-including in blue-green infrastructure (BGI) such as forests, parks, or vegetated engineered systems. However, most of the knowledge on BGI is produced in the global North, overlooking the diversity of urban contexts globally. Here, we review the literature on BGI for flood risk mitigation and water quality improvement in Southeast Asian cities to understand the scope of practical knowledge and identify research needs. We searched for evidence of local types of BGI in peer-reviewed and grey literature and assessed the performance of BGI based on hydrological, societal, and environmental metrics. The body of literature on BGI in Southeast Asia is small and dominated by wealthier countries but we found evidence of uptake among researchers and practitioners in most countries. Bioretention systems, constructed wetlands, and green cover received the most attention in research. Evidence from modelling and laboratory studies confirmed the potential for BGI to address flooding and water quality issues in the region. However, practical knowledge to mainstream the implementation of BGI remains limited, with insufficient primary hydrological data and information on societal and environmental impacts. In addition, the performance of BGI in combination with grey infrastructure, under climate change, or in informal settlements is poorly studied. Future research and practice should focus on producing and sharing empirical data, ultimately increasing the regional knowledge base to promote efficient BGI strategies.

Inner Dynamic Detection and Prediction of Water Quality Based on CEEMDAN and GA-SVM Models

Urban water quality is facing strongly adverse degradation in rapidly developing areas. However, there exists a huge challenge to estimating the inner features and predicting the variation of long-term water quality due to the lack of related monitoring data and the complexity of urban water systems. Fortunately, multi-remote sensing data, such as nighttime light and evapotranspiration (ET), provide scientific data support and reasonably reveal the variation mechanisms. Here, we develop an integrated decomposition-reclassification-prediction method for water quality by integrating the CEEMDN method, the RF method mothed, and the genetic algorithm-support vector machine model (GA-SVM). The degression of the long-term water quality was decomposed and reclassified into three different frequency terms, i.e., high-frequency, low-frequency, and trend terms, to reveal the inner mechanism and dynamics in the CEEMDAN method. The RF method was then used to identify the teleconnection and the significance of the selected driving factors. More importantly, the GA-SVM model was designed with two types of model schemes, which were the data-driven model (GA-SVMd) and the integrated CEEMDAN-GA-SVM model (defined as GA-SVMc model), in order to predict urban water quality. Results revealed that the high-frequency terms for NH3-N and TN had a major contribution to the water quality and were mainly dominated by hydrometeorological factors such as ET, rainfall, and the dynamics of the lake water table. The trend terms revealed that the water quality continuously deteriorated during the study period; the terms were mainly regulated by the land use and land cover (LULC), land metrics, population, and yearly rainfall. The predicting results confirmed that the integrated GA-SVMc model had better performance than single data-driven models (such as the GA-SVM model). Our study supports that the integrated method reveals variation rules in water quality and provides early warning and guidance for reducing the water pollutant concentration.

Effects of low impact development on the stormwater runoff and pollution control

The frequent urbanization and extreme rainfall events have posed the threat to the urban environment. The implementation of low impact development (LID) practices with great potential for control urban flood and overflow pollution is not comprehensively understood yet due to the influence of complex factors (i.e., hydrological pattern, installation location, and vertical parameter setting). In this study, the hydraulic and water quality model were used to analyze the hydrological and pollution reduction of outfall and storage under different hydrological patterns, vertical parameter setting, and green infrastructure installation locations, which can determine the best implementation of the scheme for overflow pollution control. The results showed that nine parameters of the vertical layer regarding the four parameters impacted the peak value and load of suspended solids (SS). The combination scheme of the LID practices was further proposed based on the selection and analysis of the single LID practice. Besides, considering the installation location, the downstream installed location was a better choice. The horizontal connection of overflow runoff and pollution could be reduced by up to 9.75% and 36.46%, respectively. In addition, the horizontal connection can effectively reduce the peak value of inflow and pollutants at the time of assessing storage tank impact, which reach the maximum of 14.08% and 29.25%, respectively. The pollutants distribution became uniform and showed better resilience against rainfall intensity, which is beneficial to the management of stormwater. Our findings can provide guidance for Sponge City construction and effectively alleviate the combined sewer overflow.

Preliminary Model-Based Evaluation of Water Conservation Strategies in a Semi-Arid Urban Zone

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency stormwater management model was applied to a semi-arid urban micro watershed. The sub-catchment’s current features were modeled as scenario A, while the insertion of a set of LID technologies (rain barrels, bioretention cells, permeable pavement, and infiltration trenches) was represented as scenario B. A third scenario (C), considering only the most feasible LID technologies, was also modeled. All the scenarios were evaluated under two representative storm events (30 and 9 mm in two consecutive days, and 39 mm of rainfall in one day) occurred during the sampling performed in this study. Water quality was also simulated for a 30-mm storm event and compared against field assessment results after a real 30-mm storm event. Through the model, the inefficiency of current evacuation methods after 30- and 39-mm storm events was demonstrated. Simulation of scenario B showed that LID technologies could satisfactorily diminish peak flows generated by the selected storm events as well as runoff-conveyed pollution, while the realistic scenario allowed a lower but satisfactory hydrological performance and almost the same runoff quality than scenario B. This preliminary study could contribute to spread awareness about the benefits of LID technologies in semi-arid urban areas of the developing world.

Is flow control in a space-constrained drainage network effective? A performance assessment for combined sewer overflow reduction

Recurring combined sewer overflows (CSOs) can have a significant impact on the ecological condition of receiving water bodies. There are several structural measures, like adding retention basins and switching to low impact development solutions, that have been proposed to reduce the number of sewage overflows. Besides, several flow control strategies have been discussed in scientific literature that take advantage of the space within urban drainage networks, which is assumed to be adequate, for temporary storage. The adequacy of such storage space, however, is not a universally valid assumption as a large fraction of drainage networks frequently operate close to their design discharge. In this paper, we investigate the efficacy of flow control for a space-constrained drainage network. We employ a low-cost, heuristic real time control strategy with the use of flow control devices (FCDs) and available in-sewer space to reduce the magnitude of CSOs. We consider the performance of the proposed control strategy and discuss the effect of FCD location on CSO reduction. Our results, based on over 300 rainfall-event simulations, show that the flow control strategy using limited sewer capacity is more efficient during relatively small rainfall events, where the CSO is large enough to enable reduction using the chosen control rules. The CSO is reduced, to varying degrees, for around 80% of rainfall events with peak intensity between 10 and 20 mm h^-1. For larger rainfall events, the flow control is more unstable in response to abrupt water release during control operation, which seems to be unavoidable because of the water accumulation effect and the transition to pressurized pipe flow in space-constrained networks. We also found that the flow control performance is highly sensitive to the FCD location - as it depends on the interplay of the peak rainfall intensity and the water level condition immediately upstream of the FCD. The efficacy of a location for flow control is determined by the unfilled capacity (i.e., effective in-sewer storage potential) in the pipe upstream of the FCD during the rainfall peak; furthermore, the location also has to be resistant to the water accumulation effect. Using our analysis, we substantiate two anticipated caveats to flow control strategies when the storage space is limited in a drainage network: diminished performance in CSO reduction and the appearance of additional control-related challenges, which are otherwise mitigated in more spacious networks.

Design and Simulation of Stormwater Control Measures Using Automated Modeling

Stormwater control measures (SCMs) are decentralized technical elements, which can prevent the negative effects of uncontrolled stormwater flow while providing co-benefits. Optimal SCMs have to be selected and designed to achieve the desired hydrological response of an urban catchment. In this study, automated modeling and domain-specific knowledge in the fields of modeling rainfall-runoff (RR) and SCMs are applied to automate the process of optimal SCM design. A new knowledge library for modeling RR and SCMs, compliant with the equation discovery tool ProBMoT (Process-Based Modeling Tool), was developed. The proposed approach was used to (a) find the optimal RR model that best fits the available pipe flow measurements, and (b) to find the optimal SCMs design that best fits the target catchment outflow. The approach was applied to an urban catchment in the city of Ljubljana, Slovenia. First, nine RR models were created that generally had »very good« performance according to the Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency criteria. Second, six SCM scenarios (i.e., detention pond, storage tank, bio-retention cell, infiltration trench, rain garden, and green roof) were automatically designed and simulated, enabling the assessment of their ability to achieve the target outflow. The proposed approach enables the effective automation of two complex calibration tasks in the field of urban drainage.

A review of combined sewer overflows as a source of wastewater-derived emerging contaminants in the environment and their management

Emerging contaminants such as pharmaceuticals, illicit drugs and personal care products can be released to the environment in untreated wastewater/stormwater mixtures following storm events. The frequency and intensity of combined sewer overflows (CSOs) has increased in some areas due to increasing urbanisation and climate change. Therefore, this review provides an up-to-date overview on CSOs as an environmental source of emerging contaminants. Other than compounds with high removal, those chiral species subject to enantioselective changes (i.e. degradation or inversion) during wastewater treatment can be effective markers of CSO discharge in the environment. A proposed framework for the selection of emerging contaminants as markers of CSOs is outlined. Studies have demonstrated that CSOs can be the main source of emerging contaminants with high removal efficiency during wastewater treatment (e.g. > 90%). However, the impact of CSOs on the environment is location specific and requires decision-making on their appropriate management at catchment level. This process would be aided by further studies on CSOs which incorporate the monitoring of emerging contaminants and their effects in the environment with those more routinely monitored pollutants (e.g. pathogens and priority substances). Mitigation and treatment strategies for emerging contaminants in CSOs are also discussed.