A critical review on correlating active sites, oxidative species and degradation routes with persulfate-based antibiotics oxidation

Enhancement of peroxymonosulfate activation with nickel foam-supported CuCo2O4 for tetracycline degradation: Performance and mechanism insights

The modulation of bimetallic oxide structures and development of efficient, easily recoverable catalysts are expected to effectively overcome the limitations associated with powdered catalysts in activating peroxymonosulfate (PMS). In this study, CuCo2O4 was successfully immobilized on the surface of nickel foam (NF) via an electrodeposition-calcination procedure, with highly efficient activation of PMS for tetracycline (TC) degradation (0.55 min-1). Besides acting as a support carrier and providing ample active sites, NF mediated electron transport, prevented the leaching of metal ions and enhanced the efficiency of recycling. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations and experimental tests illustrated that Cu/Co dual-sites can efficiently adsorb PMS, enabling simultaneous reduction and oxidation reactions. The dual-site synergy substantially decreased the adsorption barrier and increased the electron transfer rate. Especially, the Cu+/Cu2+ redox couple acted as an electron donor and facilitated rapid charge transfer, leading to the conversion of Co3+ to Co2+. Moreover, the CuCo2O4@NF + PMS system effectively eliminated TC by employing radical pathways (SO4•-, •OH) and nonradical processes (1O2, e-). Therefore, this study introduces a new approach to overcome the limitations of powdered bimetallic oxides, providing a promising solution for practical applications.

Densely distributed Co onto carbon-layer-coated flower-like Ni/Al2O3 and its tailored integration into a stirrer for multiple catalytic degradation and solar-powered water evaporation

Multiple functional tailored materials have shown great potential for both pollutant degradation and freshwater recovery. In this study, we synthesized densely distributed Co onto carbon-layer-coated Ni/Al2O3 hydrangea composites (Ni/Al2O3@Co) via the polymerization of dopamine under a controlled graphitized process. The characterization results revealed that Ni/Al2O3@Co, with abundant exposed bimetallic Co-Ni species on the surface of Al2O3, could afford accessible catalytic sites for persulphate activation and subsequent pollutant degradation. The tetracycline (TC) degradation rate of optimal Ni/Al2O3@Co500 reached 98.1% within 15 min with a first-order rate constant of 0.498 min-1, which is ∼1.38 times that of Al2O3@Co500 (0.362 min-1), indicating the existing Co-Ni intermetallic synergy. Free radical quenching experiments indicated that ˙O2- plays a leading role in the catalytic degradation of TC. Moreover, Ni/Al2O3@Co500 afforded strong flexibility for the degradation of methylene blue (MB), norfloxacin (NFX), bisphenol A (BPA), and oxytetramycin (OTC). Ni/Al2O3@Co500 catalysts were anchored onto a customized sponge via a calcium-triggered hydrogel crosslink strategy to construct an integral and tailored stirrer, which was used directly as the mechanical stirrer catalyst for the activation of peroxymonosulfate and pollutant removal. This obtained stirrer was also used as a monolith evaporator affording an evaporation rate of 1.944 kg m-2 h-1 at a solar-driven photothermal interface. We also demonstrated that the shape of the tailored sponge weakly affects the course of the degradation reaction. Furthermore, the degradation rates of TC in actual water sources on a Ni/Al2O3@Co500 sponge were still maintained up to 90% with rational recycling properties, which provide a promising solution for the multiple-functional pollutant degradation and water regeneration.

Intrinsic structure-function connections of carbon-encapsulated nanoscale zero-valent-iron using various pyrolysis atmospheres

Carbon-encapsulated nanoscale zero-valent-iron (C@Fe0) derived from plant-based extracts has been the subject of growing interest due to its environmental friendliness. However, the effects of various pyrolysis atmospheres on the structure-function connections of C@Fe0 are still unclear. In this study, three pyrolytic atmospheres, namely Air, N2, and 5% H2/Ar were selected to fabricate X-C@Fe0 (X represented as A, N, H) for removing 2,4,6-Trichlorophenol (TCP), and the relationships between their structures and functions were demonstrated. The N-C@Fe0 with improved hydrophobicity exhibited superior TCP adsorptive performance compared to H-C@Fe0 and A-C@Fe0. Apart from this, N-C@Fe0 effectively reduced TCP through dechlorination, this process achieved 25.9% dichlorination efficiency, and in turn alleviated products toxicity. Electrochemical tests and density functional theory calculations showed that the substitution of nitrogen with carbon in N-C@Fe0 elevated the Fe-d band center and enhanced the hybridization between Fe-3d and C-2p orbital, which collectively promoted the dichlorination of TCP. This study will provide practical guideline for improving the intrinsic activity of iron-carbon materials using pyrolytic atmosphere engineering.

Degradation of extracellular antibiotic resistance gene through singlet oxygen produced by carbon nanotubes-activated persulfate

Extracellular antibiotic resistance gene (eARG) has emerged as a global crisis in recent years, yet commonly used disinfectants have proven ineffective for their elimination. Seeking to enhance the degradation efficiency of eARG, this study explored the potential of carbon nanotubes-activated persulfate (CNTs + PS) system as a novel method for eradicating eARG. Our findings demonstrated that CNTs + PS effectively disrupted the intact structure of eARG, inhibited their genetic replication and horizontal transfer capability, achieving remarkable degradation of eARG contamination. Further experiments revealed that 1O2 played a predominant role in eARG degradation, while electron transfer played minor roles in the degradation process. The carbonyl groups served as the primary sites for activating PS to generate 1O2. CNTs can enhance the efficiency of electron transfer from eARG to PS. Moreover, the degradation efficacy of eARG by CNTs + PS was influenced by various factors including the dosage ratio between CNTs and PS, initial concentrations of eARG, pH values, inorganic anions and humic substances and water matrix. Reusability experiment demonstrated that CNTs + PS exhibited stable degradation performance after multiple uses. These findings offer a new perspective for the efficient degradation of eARG in environmental remediation.

Ecological risks of sulfonamides and quinolones degradation intermediates: Toxicity, microbial community, and antibiotic resistance genes

The ecological risks posed by incompletely degraded antibiotic intermediates in aquatic environments warrant significant attention. This study investigated the degradation mechanisms of sulfonamides (sulfadiazine, sulfamethoxazole) and quinolones (ciprofloxacin, norfloxacin) during thermally activated persulfate (TAP) treatment. The main degradation mechanisms for sulfonamides involved S-N bond cleavage and -NH2 oxidation mediated by sulfate and hydroxyl radicals, whereas quinolone degradation occurred primarily through piperazine ring cleavage facilitated by a single linear oxygen. Toxic degradation intermediates were found to be enriched with bacteria in real water samples, including Aeromonas (SDZ-50, 9.61%), Acinetobacter (SMZ-50, 21.91%), unclassified Archaea (CIP-50, 19.32%), and Herbaspirillum (NOR-50, 17.36%). Meanwhile, the abundance of sulfonamide-associated antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) (sul1 and sul2) and quinolone-associated ARGs (mfpA, emrA, and lfrA) significantly increased, with SMZ-50 and NOR-50 reaching 659.34 and 2009.98 RPKM, respectively. Correlation analysis revealed differences in host diversity and composition driven by the same classes of antibiotics and their intermediates.

Reactive species in peracetic acid-based AOPs: A critical review of their formation mechanisms, identification methods and oxidation performances

The efficient removal of emerging micropollutants poses significant challenges in wastewater treatments. Advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) are extensively studied in the field, and peracetic acid (PAA) has attracted great attention as an alternative oxidant in recent years. Various reactive species yield in PAA-based AOPs, which are regarded as the promising approaches for pollutants elimination. This review systematically investigates the formation pathways, identification methods and oxidation performances of the reactive species in PAA-based AOPs, putting focus on the organic radicals such as CH3C(O)O•, CH3C(O)OO•, CH3OO• and •CH3. Firstly, the formation pathways of reactive species induced by PAA activation are outlined. Then the specific probes and quenchers used for the identification of reactive species are summarized, and the commonly used methods are described and discussed. The reaction kinetics and mechanisms of reactive species and compounds are compared, indicating that the oxidation performances of organic radicals are mainly depended on the properties of radicals and the structure of compounds. Finally, the prospects on further research of PAA-based AOPs are proposed. This article provides a comprehensive overview of organic radicals for the first time, which can serve useful reference for ongoing studies in PAA-based AOPs.

Efficient degradation of sulfadiazine via facilitated electron transfer by iron-carbon catalyst with highly exposed active sites

The inaccessible active sites, excessive metal leaching and radical mediated degradation pathway greatly hinder the performances of Fe-C composite catalyst oxidation process in the advanced oxidation water treatment. Herein, a facile method was developed to in situ growth of MIL-53 (Fe) on the powder active carbon (PAC) surface by a mild condition, which finally yields PAC supported Fe3O4@C particles (PAC@MOFs-2T) after heat treatment. The detailed characterizations indicate that the fine Fe3O4 particles encapsulated with carbon layers were evenly anchored on the PAC as active sites, which made the catalytic centers highly accessible for the peroxydisulfate activation and sulfadiazine degradation. In addition, the carbon layers, coated on the active sites could prevent the metal leaching during the catalytic process resulting in the high stability in a wide pH range. More attractively, the density functional theory (DFT) simulations and emperimental evidences further proved that the oxidation was dominated by a electron transfer process (ETP), during which, the peroxydisulfate (PDS) was adsorbed on Fe3O4 to form PDS∗ with high oxidation potential to initiate the ETP. Meanwhile, it was also demonstrated that the optimized sample PAC@MOFs-2T enriched with electron donating groups could selectively degrade the sulfadiazine, which avoid the negative impacts from the co-existed foreign ions and organic matters during the oxidation process. In addition, the toxicity analysis of intermediate products revealed that the sulfadiazine can be degradated into low-toxic or non-toxic products, which further permits viability of this ETP mediated advanced oxidation processes.

Performance of pharmaceutical products removal in a bioelectrochemical system at low temperatures and changes in microbial communities and antibiotic resistance genes

Biological methods do not effectively remove pharmaceutical products (PPs) and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) from wastewater at low temperatures, leading to environmental pollution. Therefore, anaerobic-aerobic-coupled upflow bioelectrochemical reactors (AO-UBERs) were designed to improve the removal of PPs at low temperatures (10 ± 2 °C). The result shows that diclofenac (DIC) and ibuprofen (IBU) removals in the system with aerobic anodic and anaerobic cathodic chambers were 91.7% and 94.7%, higher than that in the control system (12.2 ± 1.5%, 36.5 ± 5.9%), and aerobic zone favors DIC and IBU removal; fluoroquinolone antibiotics (FQs) removals in the system with aerobic cathodic and anaerobic anodic chambers were 17.5-22.4% higher than that in the control system (9.1-22.4%), and anaerobic zone favors FQs removal. Analysis of microbial community structure and ARGs showed that different electrotrophic microbes (Flavobacterium, Acinetobacter, and Delftia) with cold-resistant ability to degrade PPs were enriched in different electrode combinations, and the aerobic cathodic chambers could remove certain ARGs. These results showed that AO-UBERs under intermittent electrical stimulation mode are an alternative method for the effective removal of PPs and ARGs at low temperatures.

Understanding the variations in degradation pathways and generated by-products of antibiotics in modified TiO2 and ZnO photodegradation systems: A comprehensive review

This review examines various modification techniques, including metal doping, non-metal doping, multi doping, mixed doping, and the construction of heterojunction photocatalysts, for enhancing the performance of pure TiO2 and ZnO in the photodegradation of antibiotics. The study finds that mixed and multi doping approaches are more effective in improving photodegradation performance compared to single doping. Furthermore, the selection of suitable semiconductors for constructing heterojunction photocatalysts is crucial for achieving an efficient charge carrier separation. The environmental impacts, recent research, and real application of photocatalysis process have been discussed. The review also investigates the impact of operating parameters on the degradation pathways and the generation of by-products for different antibiotics. Additionally, the toxicity of the by-products resulting from the photodegradation of antibiotics using modified ZnO and TiO2 photocatalysts is explored, revealing that these by-products may exhibit higher toxicity than the original antibiotics. Consequently, to enable the widespread implementation of photodegradation systems, researchers should focus on optimizing degradation systems to control the conversion pathways of by-products, developing innovative photoreactors, and evaluating toxicity in real wastewater matrices.

Confronting the Mysteries of Oxidative Reactive Species in Advanced Oxidation Processes: An Elephant in the Room

Advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) are rapidly evolving but still lack well-established protocols for reliably identifying oxidative reactive species (ORSs). This Perspective presents both the radical and nonradical ORSs that have been identified or proposed, along with the extensive controversies surrounding oxidative mechanisms. Conventional identification tools, such as quenchers, probes, and spin trappers, might be inadequate for the analytical demands of systems in which multiple ORSs coexist, often yielding misleading results. Therefore, the challenges of identifying these complex, short-lived, and transient ORSs must be fully acknowledged. Refining analytical methods for ORSs is necessary, supported by rigorous experiments and innovative paradigms, particularly through kinetic analysis based on in situ spectroscopic techniques and multiple-probe strategies. To demystify these complex ORSs, future efforts should be made to develop advanced tools and strategies to enhance the mechanism understanding. In addition, integrating real-world conditions into experimental designs will establish a reliable framework in fundamental studies, providing more accurate insights and effectively guiding the design of AOPs.

Regulation of reactive species during ionizing radiation by peroxydisulfate for enhanced degradation of typical pollutants in coking wastewater

This study focused on exploring the effect of peroxydisulfate (PDS) on the regulation of reactive species during water radiolysis process and its potential application for degrading organic pollutants. The results indicated that PDS was successfully activated by ionizing radiation for efficient removal of three typical phenolic compounds over a wide pH range (3.0∼12.0) at absorbed dose of 5 kGy. Chemical probe methods provided the evidence that the addition of PDS could introduce the sulfate radicals (SO4•-) and enhance the production of hydroxyl radicals (•OH). According to the quenching tests, •OH and SO4•- were the dominant reactive species responsible for the degradation of 4-NP, while hydrated electron (eaq-) played a minor role. The regulatory effect of PDS on active species in the ionizing radiation process could divided by (i) PDS could be directly activated by ionizing radiation to produce •OH and SO4•- via energy transfer pathway; (ii) PDS could boost the conversion of eaq- to SO4•- via electron transfer pathway. Furthermore, we assessed the applicability of the IR and IR/PDS systems in treating mixed solutions containing various pollutants and actual coking wastewater.

Reconstructing the electron and spin structures of nanoscale iron sulfide through a biosurfactant layer towards radical-nonradical co-dominant regime

Radical-nonradical co-dominant pathways have become a hot topic in advanced oxidation, but achieving this on transition metal sulfides (TMS) remains challenging because their inherently higher electron and spin densities always induce radicals rather than nonradicals. Herein, a biosurfactant layer (BLR) was introduced to redistribute the electron and spin structure of nanoscale iron sulfide (FeS), which allowed both radical and nonradical to co-dominate the catalytic reaction. The resulting BLR-encased FeS hybrid (BLR@FeS) exhibited satisfactory removal efficiency (98.5 %) for hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) activation, outperforming both the constituent components [FeS (70.9 %) and BLR (86.2 %)]. Advanced characterizations showed that C, O, N-related sites (-CO and -NC) in BLR attracted electrons in FeS due to their strong electronegativity and electron-withdrawing capacity, which not only decreased electron density in FeS, but also resulted in a shift of the Fe/S sites from the high-spin to the medium-spin state. The reaction routes established by the BLR@FeS/H2O2 system maintained desirable stability against environmental interferences such as common inorganic anions, humic acid and changes in pH. Our study provides a state-of-the-art, molecule-level understanding of tunable co-dominant pathways and expands the targeted applications in the field of advanced oxidation.

Facilely tuning the coating layers of Fe nanoparticles from iron carbide to iron nitride for different performance in Fenton-like reactions

In this study, a series of Fe-based materials are facilely synthesized using MIL-88A and melamine as precursors. Changing the mass ratio of melamine and MIL-88A could tune the coating layers of generated zero-valent iron (Fe0) particles from Fe3C to Fe3N facilely. Compared to Fe/Fe3N@NC sample, Fe/Fe3C@NC exhibits better catalytic activity and stability to degrade carbamazepine (CBZ) with peroxymonosulfate (PMS) as oxidant. Free radical quenching tests, open-circuit potential (OCP) test and electron paramagnetic resonance spectra (EPR) prove that hydroxyl radicals (OH) and superoxide radical (O2-) are dominant reactive oxygen species (ROSs) with Fe/Fe3C@NC sample. For Fe/Fe3N@NC sample, the main ROSs are changed into sulfate radicals (SO4-) and high valent iron-oxo (Fe (IV)=O) species. In addition, the better conductivity of Fe3C is beneficial for the electron transfer from Fe0 to the Fe3C, thus could keep the activity of the surface sites and obtain better stability. DFT calculation reveals the better adsorption and activation ability of Fe3C than Fe3N. Moreover, PMS can also be adsorbed on the Fe sites of Fe3N with shorter FeO bonds and longer SO bonds than on Fe3C, the Fe (IV)=O is thus present in the Fe/Fe3N@NC/PMS system. This study provides a novel strategy for the development of highly active Fe-based materials for Fenton-like reactions and thus could promote their real application.

Non-radical oxidation driven by iron-based materials without energy assistance in wastewater treatment

Chemical oxidation is extensively utilized to mitigate the impact of organic pollutants in wastewater. The non-radical oxidation driven by iron-based materials is noted for its environmental friendliness and resistance to wastewater matrix, and it is a promising approach for practical wastewater treatment. However, the complexity of heterogeneous systems and the diversity of evolutionary pathways make the mechanisms of non-radical oxidation driven by iron-based materials elusive. This work provides a systematic review of various non-radical oxidation systems driven by iron-based materials, including singlet oxygen (1O2), reactive iron species (RFeS), and interfacial electron transfer. The unique mechanisms by which iron-based materials activate different oxidants (ozone, hydrogen peroxide, persulfate, periodate, and peracetic acid) to produce non-radical oxidation are described. The roles of active sites and the unique structures of iron-based materials in facilitating non-radical oxidation are discussed. Commonly employed identification methods in wastewater treatment are compared, such as quenching, chemical probes, spectroscopy, mass spectrometry, and electrochemical testing. According to the process of iron-based materials driving non-radical oxidation to remove organic pollutants, the driving factors at different stages are summarized. Finally, challenges and countermeasures are proposed in terms of mechanism exploration, detection methods and practical applications of non-radical oxidation driven by iron-based materials. This work provides valuable insights for understanding and developing non-radical oxidation systems.

Enhanced cycling of Fe(III)/Fe(II) and mass transfer strategy for efficient and stable activation of peroxydisulfate for water decontamination via a flow-through Fe-MOFs cathode

The efficiency and stability of the electrical activation of persulfate (PS) by transition metal-based cathode are controlled by the cycling of Fe(III)/Fe(II) and the mass transfer of PS. In this study, the mixed-valence MOFs catalyst (FeII-MIL-53(Fe)) modified flow-through cathode was prepared for the first time. FeII-MIL-53(Fe) was prepared by replacing part of the iron-oxygen network structure in MIL-53(Fe) with Fe(II), resulting in the formation of coordinated unsaturated iron centers (CUICs). The increase of the Fe(III) CUICs facilitated the conversion of Fe(III) to Fe(II). Furthermore, the cycling of Fe(III)/Fe(II) was further promoted by the electric field. Meanwhile, the hydrodynamic behavior of flow-through cathode was indicated by the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation. The quenching experiments and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) results showed that several reactive specie (SO4·-, ·OH, O2·- and 1O2) were produce. In summary, this work provided an effective strategy for the efficient and stable electrical activation of PDS.

A critical review of persulfate-based electrochemical advanced oxidation processes for the degradation of emerging contaminants: From mechanisms and electrode materials to applications

The persulfate-based electrochemical advanced oxidation processes (PS-EAOPs) exhibit distinctive advantages in the degradation of emerging contaminants (ECs) and have garnered significant attention among researchers, leading to a consistent surge in related research publications over the past decade. Regrettably, there is still a lack of a critical review gaining deep into understanding of ECs degradation by PS-EAOPs. To address the knowledge gaps, in this review, the mechanism of electro-activated PS at the interface of the electrodes (anode, cathode and particle electrodes) is elaborated. The correlation between these electrode materials and the activation mechanism of PS is systematically discussed. The strategies for improving the performance of electrode material that determining the efficiency of PS-EAOPs are also summarized. Then, the applications of PS-EAOPs for the degradation of ECs are described. Finally, the challenges and outlook of PS-EAOPs are discussed. In summary, this review offers valuable guidance for the degradation of ECs by PS-EAOPs.

Graphene/MoS2-assisted alum sludge electrode induces selective oxidation for organophosphorus pesticides degradation: Co-oxidation and detoxification mechanism

Designing an electrode that can generate abundant free radicals and 1O2, which can effectively degrade and detoxify organophosphorus pesticides (OPPs) through a co-oxidation pathway, is important. In this study, we prepared a electrode GO/MoS2@AS by supporting MoS2 on alum sludge (AS) under graphene oxide (GO) nanoconfinement. The results show that the dominant role of 1O2 at the cathode and •OHads at the anode for degradation, in addition to the involvement of 1O2 in the cathodic degradation mechanism, can be attributed to the abundant precursor •O2- and H2O2. Furthermore, calculations using density functional theory and toxicity prediction of products show that the energy (∆E) requirements of •OHfree to break the C-O bond of the pyridine ring and phosphate group are higher than that required for 1O2, and this non-radical oxidation plays a key role in detoxification. In contrast, accelerating ring opening and oxidation processes are attributed to radical oxidation. Above all, the cathodic detoxification is more effective than anodic detoxification. Three prevalent OPPs, chlorpyrifos, glyphosate, and trichlorfon, were degraded in the GO/MoS2@AS system by over 90 %, with mineralization rates of 76.66 %, 85.46 %, and 82.18 %, respectively. This study provides insights into the co-oxidation degradation and detoxification mechanism mediated by 1O2 and •OHfree.

Analyzing the active sites of carbocatalyst for peroxydisulfate activation: Specific surface area or electrochemical surface area?

Persulfates activation by various nanomaterials has been intensively reported for advanced oxidation processes (AOPs), and substantial progress has been made in understanding the mechanism. However, most of the published articles only present the unnormalized catalytic properties, which generated confusion to compare different catalysts and identify the active sites. Herein, we presented electrochemical surface area (ECSA) as a practical normalized method and confirmed the primary active sites in N-doped graphene. By controlling the aggregation state of graphene sheets to adjust the activity of doped graphite-N species, the active sites for peroxydisulfate (PDS) activation were accurately estimated. In further experiments, specific surface area (SSA, by N2-physisorption and methylene blue adsorption) and ECSA were adopted to conclude the normalized oxidation rate constant and graphitic-N was confirmed as the primary site in nitrogen-doped graphene for the carbocatalyst/PDS system. The normalized results revealed that SSA derived from inert gas on materials could not reflect the true active sites at solid-liquid interface, while ECSA considering the operated solid-liquid situation can be used for accurate estimation of the active sites. Therefore, this study suggests that ECSA integrates the properties of both kinetics and thermodynamics, which can be adopted as a useful methodology for analyzing nano-sized environmental catalysts performance.

Accelerated screening of active sites on biochar for catalysis and adsorption via multidimensional fingerprint factor descriptors

Highly active biochar has great application potential in heterogeneous catalysis and adsorptive processes. The complexity of carbonization process makes it difficult to construct target active sites. This work put forward a reactive descriptor based on pyrolysis parameters and intrinsic composition of biomass. Results show that the model showed better predictive performance for C-C/C=C (R2 = 0.85), C=O (R2 = 0.85) and defect (R2 = 0.91) sites. The SHapley Additive exPlanation analysis shows that the pyrolysis parameters and the higher heating values are equally important for the active sites. The predictive performance and guiding role of the descriptor were validated by experiments. The descriptors proposed in this study integrated significant advantages of simplicity and easy accessibility, which would break the bottleneck of accurate construction of active sites and provide a theoretical basis for high-value resource utilization of biomass.

The Surface Confinement of FeO Assists in the Generation of Singlet Oxygen and High-Valent Metal-Oxo Species for Enhanced Fenton-Like Catalysis

Transition metal compounds (TMCs) have long been potential candidate catalysts in persulfate-based advanced oxidation process (PS-AOPs) due to their Fenton-like catalyze ability for radical generation. However, the mechanism involved in TMCs-catalyzed nonradical PS-AOPs remains obscure. Herein, the growth of FeO on the Fe3O4/carbon precursor is regulated by restricted pyrolysis of MIL-88A template to activate peroxymonosulfate (PMS) for tetracycline (TC) removal. The higher FeO incorporation conferred a 2.6 times higher degradation performance than that catalyzed by Fe3O4 and also a higher interference resistance to anions or natural organic matter. Unexpectedly, the quenching experiment, probe method, and electron paramagnetic resonance quantitatively revealed that the FeO reassigned high nonradical species (1O2 and FeIV═O) generation to replace original radical system created by Fe3O4. Density functional theory calculation interpreted that PMS molecular on strongly-adsorbed (200) and (220) facets of FeO enjoyed unique polarized electronic reception for surface confinement effect, thus the retained peroxide bond energetically supported the production of 1O2 and FeIV═O. This work promotes the mechanism understanding of TMCs-induced surface-catalyzed persulfate activation and enables them better perform catalytic properties in wastewater treatment.

Correlating active sites and oxidative species in single-atom catalyzed Fenton-like reactions

Single-atom catalysts (SACs) have gained widespread popularity in heterogeneous catalysis-based advanced oxidation processes (AOPs), owing to their optimal metal atom utilization efficiency and excellent recyclability by triggering reactive oxidative species (ROS) for target pollutant oxidation in water. Systematic summaries regarding the correlation between the active sites, catalytic activity, and reactive species of SACs have rarely been reported. This review provides an overview of the catalytic performance of carbon- and metal oxide-supported SACs in Fenton-like reactions, as well as the different oxidation pathways induced by the metal and non-metal active sites, including radical-based pathways (e.g., ·OH and SO4˙-) and nonradical-based pathways (e.g. 1O2, high-valent metal-oxo species, and direct electron transfer). Thereafter, we discuss the effects of metal types, coordination environments, and spin states on the overall catalytic performance and the generated ROS in Fenton-like reactions. Additionally, we provide a perspective on the future challenges and prospects for SACs in water purification.

Bioinspired axial S-coordinated single-atom cobalt catalyst to efficient activate peroxymonosulfate for selective high-valent Co-Oxo species generation

The efficient activation and selective high-valent metal-oxo (HVMO) species generation remain challenging for peroxymonosulfate (PMS)-based advanced oxidation processes (PMS-AOPs) in water purification. The underlying mechanism of the activation pathway is ambiguous, leading to a massive dilemma in the control and regulation of HVMO species generation. Herein, bioinspired by the bio-oxidase structure of cytochrome P450, the axial coordination strategy was adopted to tailor a single-atom cobalt catalyst (CoN4S-CB) with an axial S coordination. CoN4S-CB high-selectively generated high-valent Co-Oxo species (Co(IV)=O) via PMS activation. Co(IV)=O demonstrated an ingenious oxygen atom transfer (OAT) reaction to achieve the efficient degradation of sulfamethoxazole (SMX), and this allowed robust operation in various complex environments. The axial S coordination modulated the 3d orbital electron distribution of the Co atom. Density functional theory (DFT) calculation revealed that the axial S coordination decreased the energy barrier for PMS desorption and lowered the free energy change (ΔG) for Co(IV)=O generation. CoN4S-PMS* had a narrow d-band close to the Fermi level, which enhanced charge transfer to accelerate the cleavage of O-O and O-H bonds in PMS. This work provides a broader perspective on the activator design with natural enzyme structure-like active sites to efficient activate PMS for selective HVMO species generation.

Were Persulfate-Based Advanced Oxidation Processes Really Understood? Basic Concepts, Cognitive Biases, and Experimental Details

Persulfate (PS)-based advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) for pollutant removal have attracted extensive interest, but some controversies about the identification of reactive species were usually observed. This critical review aims to comprehensively introduce basic concepts and rectify cognitive biases and appeals to pay more attention to experimental details in PS-AOPs, so as to accurately explore reaction mechanisms. The review scientifically summarizes the character, generation, and identification of different reactive species. It then highlights the complexities about the analysis of electron paramagnetic resonance, the uncertainties about the use of probes and scavengers, and the necessities about the determination of scavenger concentration. The importance of the choice of buffer solution, operating mode, terminator, and filter membrane is also emphasized. Finally, we discuss current challenges and future perspectives to alleviate the misinterpretations toward reactive species and reaction mechanisms in PS-AOPs.

Activation of peroxymonosulfate with natural pyrite-biochar composite for sulfamethoxazole degradation in soil: Organic matter effects and free radical conversion

Peroxymonosulfate (PMS)-based advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) represent an effective method for the remediation of antibiotic-contaminated soils. In this study, a natural pyrite-biochar composite material (FBCx) was developed, demonstrating superior activation performance and achieving a 76% removal rate of SMX from soil within 120 min. There existed different degradation mechanisms for SMX in aqueous and soil solutions, respectively. The production of 1O2 and inherent active species produced by soil slurry played an important role in the degradation process. The combination of electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and free radical probe experiments confirmed the presence of free radical transformation processes in soil. Wherein, the·OH and SO4·- generated in soil slurry did not directly involve in the degradation process, but rather preferentially reacted with soil organic matter (SOM) to form alkyl-like radicals (R·), thereby maintaining a high concentration of reactive species in the system. Furthermore, germination and growth promotion of mung bean seeds observed in the toxicity test indicated the environmental compatibility of this remediation method. This study revealed the influence mechanism of SOM in the remediation process of contaminated soil comprehensively, which possessed enormous potential for application in practical environments.

Analytical methods for selectively determining hydrogen peroxide, peroxymonosulfate and peroxydisulfate in their binary mixtures

Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), peroxymonosulfate (PMS), and peroxydisulfate (PDS) are key bulk oxidants in many advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) for treating chemically contaminated water. In some systems these peroxides may coexist in solution either through intentional co-addition or their inadvertent formation (especially H2O2) due to reaction chemistry. While many analytical methods to determine these peroxides individually have been established, mutual interference among the peroxides in such methods has seldom been evaluated, and new methods or variants of established methods to selectively determine peroxides in binary mixtures are lacking. We re-examined five established colorimetric methods-the Permanganate, Titanium Oxalate (Ti-oxalate), Iodide, N.N‑diethyl-p-phenylenediamine (DPD), and 2,20-azino-bis(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulfonate (ABTS) methods-for mutual interference among peroxides and devised variants of these methods for selectively quantifying one peroxide in the presence of another. Hydrogen peroxide can be selectively determined by the Permanganate method at short reaction time; by the Ti-oxalate method; by the DPD method with added peroxidase (POD); or by the ABTS method with added POD. PMS can be selectively determined by the Iodide method; by the DPD or ABTS methods with added iodide ion as catalyst; or by the DPD method with added catalase (CAT) (with co-existing H2O2 but not PDS). The DPD method can be used to determine PDS without interference by H2O2 and-provided the sample is pretreated with l-histidine-without interference by PMS. The recommended methods were successfully applied to binary peroxide mixtures in complex waters, including a tap water and a synthetic water. Overall, the new selective methods will assist mechanistic investigation of AOPs based on these peroxides and support efforts to apply them commercially.

Core-Shell MnFe Nanocatalyst Derived from Prussian Blue Analogs for Peroxymonosulfate Activation: Nonradical Mechanism and Bimetallic Valence Cycle

Sulfamethazine (SAT) is widely present in sediment, soil, rivers, and groundwater. Unfortunately, traditional water treatment technologies are inefficient at eliminating SAT from contaminated water. Therefore, developing an effective and ecologically friendly treatment procedure to effectively remove SAT is critical. This has raised concerns about its potential impact on the environment and human health. In this study, metal-organic-inorganic composites consisting of graphene-encapsulated Fe-Mn metal catalyst (Mn3Fe1-NC) were synthesized by calcining MnFe Prussian blue analogs (PBA) under a nitrogen atmosphere. The composites were applied to activate peroxymonosulfate (PMS) and facilitate the degradation of SAT in aquatic environments. The Mn3Fe1-NC, dosed with 5 mg, in combination with PMS, dosed with 1.5 mmol L-1, achieved a 91.8% degradation efficiency of SAT. The transformation of the CN skeleton led to the formation of a carbon shell structure, which consequently reduced metal ion leaching from the material. At various pH levels, the iron and manganese ions were observed to leach out at levels lower than 0.1392 and 0.0580 mg L-1, respectively. In contrast, the Mn3Fe1-NC was found to be minimally impacted by pH levels and coexisting ions present in the aqueous environment. Radical burst experiments and electrochemical analysis tests verified that degradation primarily occurs through the nonradical pathway of electron transfer. The active sites responsible for this process were identified as the Mn (IV) and graphitic-N atoms on the material, which facilitate direct electron transfer. Additionally, the presence of Fe atoms promotes the valence cycling of Mn atoms. This study introduces new insights into the reaction mechanism and the constitutive relationship of catalytic centers in nonradical oxidation reactions.

Construction of Bi2WO6/g-C3N4 Z-Scheme Heterojunction and Its Enhanced Photocatalytic Degradation of Tetracycline with Persulfate under Solar Light

Z-scheme heterojunction Bi2WO6/g-C3N4 was obtained by a novel hydrothermal process; its photocatalysis-persulfate (PDS) activation for tetracycline (TC) removal was explored under solar light (SL). The structure and photoelectrochemistry behavior of fabricated samples were well characterized by FT-IR, XRD, XPS, SEM-EDS, UV-vis DRS, Mott-Schottky, PL, photocurrent response, EIS and BET. The critical experimental factors in TC decomposition were investigated, including the Bi2WO6 doping ratio, catalyst dosage, TC concentration, PDS dose, pH, co-existing ion and humic acid (HA). The optimum test conditions were as follows: 0.4 g/L Bi2WO6/g-C3N4 (BC-3), 20 mg/L TC, 20 mg/L PDS and pH = 6.49, and the maximum removal efficiency of TC was 98.0% in 60 min. The decomposition rate in BC-3/SL/PDS system (0.0446 min-1) was 3.05 times higher than that of the g-C3N4/SL/PDS system (0.0146 min-1), which might be caused by the high-efficiency electron transfer inside the Z-scheme Bi2WO6/g-C3N4 heterojunction. Furthermore, the photogenerated hole (h+), superoxide (O2•-), sulfate radical (SO4•-) and singlet oxygen (1O2) were confirmed as the key oxidation factors in the BC-3/SL/PDS system for TC degradation by a free radical quenching experiment. Particularly, BC-3 possessed a wide application potential in actual antibiotic wastewater treatment for its superior catalytic performance that emerged in the experiment of co-existing components.

Plastic wastes-derived N-doped carbon nanotubes for efficient removal of sulfamethoxazole in high salinity wastewater via nonradical peroxymonosulfate activation

Peroxymonosulfate (PMS) catalytic activation is effective to eliminate organic pollutants from water, thus the development of low-cost and efficient catalysts is significant in applications. The resource conversion of plastic wastes (PWs) into carbon nanotubes (CNTs) is a promising candidate for PMS-based advanced oxidation processes (AOPs), and also a sustainable strategy to realize plastic management and reutilization. Herein, cost-effective PWs-derived N-doped CNTs (N-pCNTs) were synthesized, which displayed efficient activity for PMS activation through an electron transfer pathway (ETP) for sulfamethoxazole (SMX) degradation in high salinity water. The pyrrolic N induced the positively charged surface of N-pCNTs, favoring the electrostatic adsorption of PMS and subsequent generation of active PMS* . A galvanic oxidation process was developed to prove the electron-shuttle dominated ETP for SMX oxidation. Combined with theoretical calculations, the efficiency of ETP was determined by the potential difference between HOMO of SMX and LUMO of N-pCNTs. Such oxidation produced low-toxicity intermediates and resulted in selective degradation of specific sulfonamide antibiotics. This work reveals the feasibility of low-cost N-pCNTs catalysts from PWs serving as an appealing candidate for PMS-AOPs in water remediation, providing a new solution to alleviate environmental issues caused by PWs and also advances the understanding of ETP during PMS activation.

Progress of disinfection catalysts in advanced oxidation processes, mechanisms and synergistic antibiotic degradation

Human diseases caused by pathogenic microorganisms make people pay more attention to disinfection. Meanwhile, antibiotics can cause microbial resistance and increase the difficulty of disease treatment, resulting in risk of triggering a vicious circle. Advanced oxidation process (AOPs) has been widely studied in the field of synergistic treatment of the two contaminates. This paper reviews the application of catalytic materials and their modification strategies in the context of AOPs for disinfection and antibiotic degradation. It also delves into the mechanisms of disinfection such as the pathways for microbial inactivation and the related influencing factors, which are essential for understanding the pivotal role of catalytic materials in disinfection principles by AOPs. More importantly, the exploratory research on the combined use of AOPs for disinfection and antibiotic degradation is discussed, and the potential and prospects in this field is highlighted. Finally, the limitations and challenges associated with the application of AOPs in disinfection and antibiotic degradation are summarized. It aims to provide a starting point for future research efforts to facilitate the widespread use of advanced oxidation processes in the field of public health.

Visible light-driven C/O-g-C3N4 activating peroxydisulfate to effectively inactivate antibiotic resistant bacteria and inhibit the transformation of antibiotic resistance genes: Insights on the mechanism

Antibiotic resistant bacteria (ARB) and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) dissemination within water pose a serious threat to public health. Herein, C and O dual-doped g-C3N4 (C/O-g-C3N4) photocatalyst, fabricated via calcination treatment, was utilized to activate peroxydisulfate (PDS) to investigate the disinfection effect on tetracycline-resistant Escherichia coli and the transformation frequency of ARGs. As a result, approximately 7.08 log E. coli were inactivated, and 72.36 % and 53.96 % of antibiotics resistance gene (tetB) and 16 S rRNA were degraded respectively within 80 min. Futhermore, the transformation frequency was reduced to 0.8. Characterization and theoretical results indicated that C and O doping in g-C3N4 might lead to the electronic structure modulation and band gap energy reduction, resulting in the production of more free radicals. The mechanism analysis revealed that C/O-g-C3N4 exhibited a lower adsorption energy and reaction energy barrier for PDS compared to g-C3N4. This was beneficial for the homolysis of O-O bonds, forming SO4•- radicals. The attack of the generated active species led to oxidative stress in cells, resulting in damage to the electron transport chain and inhibition of ATP production. Our findings disclose a valuable insight for inactivating ARB, and provide a prospective strategy for ARGs dissemination in water contamination.

Constructing an orderly electron transport channel on boron regulated biomass carbon fiber for selective ROS generation and water decontamination

Antibiotic pollution has raised widely attention due to the difficult biodegradation and lasting toxicity to public health, metal-free material based heterogeneous catalysis is a highly-promise and eco-friendly technology for organics elimination. Herein, boron doped biomass carbon fiber (B-CF) was synthesized to construct orderly electron transport channels for enhancing catalytic performance and deeply purifying organics polluted water. Integrating systematical quenching experiments and EPR detection, O2·- and 1O2 are found to be dominating reactive oxygen species (ROS) for norfloxacin (NOR) degradation rather than ∙OH or SO4∙-. Adsorption, catalytic degradation in pristine CF/peroxodisulfate (PDS) and B-CF/PDS systems, electrochemical tests, and theory calculations were compared and the results suggested B-CF surface can trigger intense electron transfer via simultaneous activating NOR and PDS, and electrons transferred from NOR to B-CF-PDS compound, resulting in selective and remarkably enhanced ROS generation. Moreover, it was found that B-CF exhibited surprising adsorption capacity for NOR (834.4 mg g-1), and it can also remove SO42- from the solution through electrostatic attraction. This B-CF/PDS system is efficient within a wide operation pH from 3 to 11 and exhibits long lasting activity (> 274 h maintaining over 80% efficiency). This study unveils the highly selective formation of O2-· and 1O2 and solves the short lifetime of catalysts in persulfate-based catalysis, which provides feasible technology for advanced water purification.

Critical Functions of Soil Components for In Situ Persulfate Oxidation of Sulfamethoxazole: Inherent Fe(II) Minerals-Coordinated Nonradical Pathway

Naturally occurring iron (Fe) minerals have been proved to activate persulfate (PS) to generate reactive species, but the role of soil-inherent Fe minerals in activating PS as well as the underlying mechanisms remains poorly understood. Here, we investigated sulfamethoxazole (SMX) degradation by PS in two Fe-rich soils and one Fe-poor soil. Unlike with the radical-dominant oxidation processes in Fe-poor soil, PS was effectively activated through nonradical pathways (i.e., surface electron-transfer) in Fe-rich soils, accounting for 68.4%-85.5% of SMX degradation. The nonradical mechanism was evidenced by multiple methods, including electrochemical, in situ Raman, and competition kinetics tests. Inherent Fe-based minerals, especially those containing Fe(II) were the crucial activators of PS in Fe-rich soils. Compared to Fe(III) minerals, Fe(II) minerals (e.g., ilmenite) were more liable to form Fe(II) mineral-PS* complexes to initiate the nonradical pathways, oxidizing adjacent SMX via electron transfer. Furthermore, mineral structural Fe(II) was the dominant component to coordinate such a direct oxidation process. After PS oxidation, low-crystalline Fe minerals in soils were transformed into high-crystalline Fe phases. Collectively, our study shows that soil-inherent Fe minerals can effectively activate PS in Fe-rich soils, so the addition of exogenous iron might not be required for PS-based in situ chemical oxidation. Outcomes also provide new insights into the activation mechanisms when persulfate is used for the remediation of contaminated soils.

Selective oxidation of organic pollutants based on reactive oxygen species and the molecular structure: Degradation behavior and mechanism analysis

The selective and rapid elimination of refractory organic pollutants from surface water is significant. However, the relationship of between reactive oxygen species (ROSs) and diversified pollutants molecular structures still needs to be further clarified. Here, we utilize polydopamine (PDA)-assisted coating strategy to prepare hollow 2D carbon nanosheet (ZPL-HCNS) and 2D Co3O4 nanosheet (ZPL-Co3O4) by thermolysis of PDA coated ZIF-L (ZIF-L@PDA) precursor under different gas atmosphere, which realizes the controlled generation of radicals and non-radicals. Organic pollutants including bisphenols, sulfonamides, quinolones, tetracyclines, and azo dyes are applied to assess the catalytic performance. Results show that dyes containing azo structure are more likely to be degraded by radical process, which is due to that the energy (ΔE) requirements to break the azo bond is higher than energy released from singlet oxygen to oxygen molecule and lower than that of sulfate radical to sulfate. Frontier molecular orbital theory HOMO-LUMO and Fukui function expounded the possible selectivity mechanism. In addition, the degradation pathway and biotoxicity test are carried out. This work provides a reference to illustrate the selective degradation for ROSs and molecular structure of pollutants.

Optimization of process parameters for trimethoprim and sulfamethoxazole removal by magnetite-chitosan nanoparticles using Box-Behnken design

The contamination of the aquatic environment with antibiotics is among the major and developing problems worldwide. The present study investigates the potential of adsorbent magnetite-chitosan nanoparticles (Fe3O4/CS NPs) for removing trimethoprim (TMP) and sulfamethoxazole (SMX). For this purpose, Fe3O4/CS NPs were synthesized by the co-precipitation method, and the adsorbent characteristics were investigated using XRD, SEM, TEM, pHzpc, FTIR, and VSM. The effect of independent variables (pH, sonication time, adsorbent amount, and analyte concentration) on removal performance was modeled and evaluated by Box-Behnken design (BBD). The SEM image of the Fe3O4/CS adsorbent showed that the adsorbent had a rough and irregular surface. The size of Fe3O4/CS crystals was about 70 nm. XRD analysis confirmed the purity and absence of impurities in the adsorbent. TEM image analysis showed that the adsorbent had a porous structure, and the particle size was in the range of nanometers. In VSM, the saturation magnetization of Fe3O4/CS adsorbent was 25 emu g-1 and the magnet could easily separate the adsorbent from the solution. The results revealed that the optimum condition was achieved at a concentration of 22 mg L-1, a sonication time of 15 min, an adsorbent amount of 0.13 g/100 mL, and a pH of 6. Among different solvents (i.e., ethanol, acetone, nitric acid, and acetonitrile), significant desorption of TMP and SMX was achieved using ethanol. Also, results confirmed that Fe3O4/CS NPs can be used for up to six adsorption/desorption cycles. In addition, applying the Fe3O4/CS NPs on real water samples revealed that Fe3O4/CS NPs could remove TMP and SMX in the 91.23-95.95% range with RSD (n = 3) < 4. Overall, the Fe3O4/CS NPs exhibit great potential for removing TMP and SMX antibiotics from real water samples.

Kinetics and mechanism of sulfate radical-and hydroxyl radical-induced disinfection of bacteria and fungal spores by transition metal ions-activated peroxymonosulfate

Peroxymonosulfate(PMS)-based advanced oxidation process have been recognized as efficient disinfection processes. This study comprehensively investigated the role of sulfate radical (SO4•-) and hydroxyl radical (•OH)-driven disinfection of bacteria and fungal spores by the PMS/metals ions (Me(II)) systems and modeled the CT value based on the relationship between survival and ∫[Radical]dt, with the aim to provide an accurate and quantitative kinetic data of inactivation processes. The results indicated that •OH played a more central role than SO4•- in the inactivation process, and bacteria were more vulnerable to radical attack than fungal spores due to the differences in antioxidant mechanisms and external structures. The k value of •OH -induced inactivation of E. coli was approximately 3-fold higher than that of A. niger, and the shoulder length of •OH -induced inactivation of E. coli was closely 52-fold shorter than that of A. niger after treated with the PMS/Co(II) system. The morphological and biochemical changes revealed that PMS/Me(II) treatment caused membrane damage, intracellular ROS accumulation and esterase activity loss in microorganisms. This study significantly improved the understanding of the contribution of radicals in the process of microbial inactivation by PMS/Me(II) and would provide important implications for the further development of technologies to cope with the highly resistant fungal spores in drinking water.

Merits and Limitations of Radical vs. Nonradical Pathways in Persulfate-Based Advanced Oxidation Processes

Urbanization and industrialization have exerted significant adverse effects on water quality, resulting in a growing need for reliable and eco-friendly treatment technologies. Persulfate (PS)-based advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) are emerging as viable technologies to treat challenging industrial wastewaters or remediate groundwater impacted by hazardous wastes. While the generated reactive species can degrade a variety of priority organic contaminants through radical and nonradical pathways, there is a lack of systematic and in-depth comparison of these pathways for practical implementation in different treatment scenarios. Our comparative analysis of reaction rate constants for radical vs. nonradical species indicates that radical-based AOPs may achieve high removal efficiency of organic contaminants with relatively short contact time. Nonradical AOPs feature advantages with minimal water matrix interference for complex wastewater treatments. Nonradical species (e.g., singlet oxygen, high-valent metals, and surface activated PS) preferentially react with contaminants bearing electron-donating groups, allowing enhancement of degradation efficiency of known target contaminants. For byproduct formation, analytical limitations and computational chemistry applications are also considered. Finally, we propose a holistically estimated electrical energy per order of reaction (EE/O) parameter and show significantly higher energy requirements for the nonradical pathways. Overall, these critical comparisons help prioritize basic research on PS-based AOPs and inform the merits and limitations of system-specific applications.