Surgical Decompression for Chiari Malformation Type I: An Age-Based Outcomes Study Based on the Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale

Fourth ventricular roof angle does not predict surgical outcome in paediatric patients with Chiari I malformation

PURPOSE

Pre-operative fourth ventricle roof angle (FVRA) has recently been highlighted as a novel radiographic predictor of clinical severity in Chiari type-I malformation (CM-I) as reported by Seaman et al. (J Neurosurg Pediatr 25:1-8, 2021). This has led to suggestions that FVRA could be included in algorithms to determine indications for surgery. We aimed to test the accuracy of FVRA as a predictor of clinical severity and its effect on post-operative outcome in a large retrospective cohort of paediatric patients who underwent decompression for CM-I.

METHODOLOGY

Patients undergoing craniocervical decompression for CM-I at the Queensland Children's Hospital and Mater Hospital, Brisbane, between 2006 and 2018 were included. Data was collected from 66 patients aged 0-18 years. Post-operative outcome was assessed by calculating Chicago Chiari Outcomes Score (CCOS) at follow-up. The FVRA was taken from a mid-sagittal T1-weighted MRI as previously described (Seaman et al. in J Neurosurg Pediatr 25:1-8, 2021). The angle is subtended between superior and inferior medullary velum.

RESULTS

Whilst results from Seaman et al. demonstrated a strong correlation between a FVRA > 65° and symptomatic CM-I, this did not translate to our dataset (p = 0.61). Additionally, pre-operative FVRA is not useful as a predictive tool for post-surgical outcome as assessed by CCOS (p = 0.50), and post-operative reduction in FVRA did not correlate with improved outcomes (p = 0.81). We did note significantly worse outcomes in patients presenting with pre-operative brainstem dysfunction (p = 0.03).

CONCLUSION

Paediatric CM-I is a challenging cohort to manage, often due to young age and a lack of language skills. There is a heavy reliance on radiological findings. Whilst FVRA has previously been reported to be of value as a determinant of clinical severity in adult and paediatric patients, we find that this measurement is of dubious value in our retrospective cohort.

Impacts of type 1 Chiari malformation on elderly

Background

This study aims to evaluate the surgical outcomes of elderly patients with Chiari malformation (CM) who underwent suboccipital craniectomy (SC) with duraplasty (DP) or dural splitting (DS). The focus is on symptom relief, changes in syrinx size, hospital admission duration, and postoperative complications.

Methods

A retrospective study was performed to evaluate the outcomes of elderly CM patients who underwent SC with DP or dural splitting (DS). Patients older than 60 years who underwent posterior fossa decompression (PFD) together with DP or DS who underwent surgery from 1989 to 2022 were included in the study. Patients were divided into two categories based on their surgical approach - SC with DP and SC with dural splitting (DS) surgery. Demographic details, co-morbidities, clinical features, management details, Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale (CCOS), complications, and follow-up details were obtained.

Results

Of the seven patients, five were females, and two were males. The mean age at the time of the operation is 65.14 years. Among the seven patients, six had syrinx, with a mean diameter of 6.17 mm; one patient had hydrocephalus, and one had scoliosis. All the patients underwent PFD; six patients also underwent DP, and one patient underwent DS. The median CCOS at the time of discharge is 13.

Conclusion

In elderly CM patients, surgery improved symptoms for most but led to reoperations in two cases. Despite a slight increase in syrinx diameter and a drop in the CCOS score, better outcomes were associated with smaller syrinxes. Further research is needed to optimize treatment strategies for this population.

An autologous duraplasty in situ technique in the treatment of Chiari malformation Type I: a prospective study

OBJECTIVE

Our study aims to prospectively compare an autologous duraplasty in situ technique (IS group) with the synthetic dural graft duraplasty (SDG group) to clarify the effectiveness and superiority of the former in the treatment of patients with Chiari malformation type 1 (CM-I).

METHOD

29 patients with CM-I were randomly assigned to either IS or SDG group. In both groups, a dissection from the occipital bone was performed. All procedures were performed by the same surgeon. The two duraplasty methods were compared in terms of surgical factors and complications. Data analysis was done for the baseline material, the neurological outcome and MRI-documented syrinx size at the 6 month follow-up.

RESULT

29 patients were enrolled in this study, 14 in the IS group and 15 in the SDG group. The results showed no significant difference in operation time (P = 0.916), amount of bleeding (P = 0.120), operation complications, hospitalization time (P = 0.854) and prognosis between the two groups. The hospitalization cost of IS group was 15,125 yuan less than that of SDG group (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The autogenous duraplasty in situ technique is a novel, simple, effective and economical surgical management for patients with CM-I.

Predictors of poor functional outcomes in adults with type I Chiari Malformation: Clinical and surgical factors assessed with the Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale over long-term follow-up

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to identify clinical and surgical features associated with poor long-term postoperative outcomes in patients diagnosed with Type I Chiari Malformation (CMI) treated with posterior fossa decompression with duroplasty (PFDD), with or without tonsillar coagulation.

METHODS

This retrospective, single-center study included 107 adult patients with CMI surgically treated between 2010 and 2021. The surgical technique involved a midline suboccipital craniectomy, C1 laminectomy, durotomy, arachnoid dissection, duroplasty, and tonsillar coagulation until 2014, after which tonsillar coagulation was discontinued. Postoperative outcomes were assessed using the Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale (CCOS) at a median follow-up of 35 months. Clinical, surgical, and neuroimaging data were analyzed using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test, Cox regression analysis, and Kaplan-Meier survival curves to identify predictors of poor functional outcomes.

RESULTS

Of the 107 patients (mean age 43.9 years, SD 13), 81 (75.5 %) showed functional improvement, 25 (23.4 %) remained unchanged, and 1 (0.9 %) experienced worsened outcomes. Cephalalgia, bilateral motor weakness, and bilateral paresthesia were the most frequent initial symptoms. Tonsillar coagulation was performed in 31 cases (28.9 %) but was clinically associated with higher rates of unfavorable outcomes. The Wilcoxon signed-rank test indicated that long-term follow-up CCOS was significantly higher than postoperative CCOS (Z = -7.678, p < 0.000). Multivariate Cox analysis identified preoperative bilateral motor weakness (HR 6.1, 95 % CI 1.9-18.9; p = 0.002), hydrocephalus (HR 3.01, 95 % CI 1.3-6.9; p = 0.008), and unilateral motor weakness (HR 2.99, 95 % CI 1.1-8.2; p = 0.033) as significant predictors of poor outcomes on a long-term follow-up.

CONCLUSION

This study highlights the high rate of functional improvement in CMI patients following PFDD. Preoperative motor weakness and hydrocephalus were significant predictors of poor long-term outcomes. Tonsillar coagulation did not demonstrate a clear clinical benefit and may be associated with worse outcomes. Our findings suggest that careful preoperative assessment and selection of surgical techniques are crucial for optimizing patient outcomes.

Preoperative estimation of intracranial compliance in symptomatic children with Chiari malformation type 1: impact on outcome and risk of complications

BACKGROUND

The role of reduced intracranial compliance (ICC) in the outcome after foramen magnum decompression (FMD) was demonstrated in adults with Chiari malformation Type 1 (CMI). However, similar observations from children treated for CMI are missing.

METHODS

We reviewed pediatric cases of CMI referred to FMD between 2006 and 2022. Children with clinical and/or radiological signs suggesting reduced ICC (Group A) underwent overnight measurements of the pulsatile intracranial pressure (ICP): mean ICP wave amplitude (MWA) served as a surrogate marker of ICC. Children with more typical symptoms of CMI (Group B) underwent FMD without preoperative ICC estimation. This study presents the clinical, radiological, and outcome differences between these groups.

RESULTS

Sixty-four children (mean age 11.1 ± 4.3 years) underwent FMD: In Group A (n = 30), the finding of reduced ICC as estimated from preoperative ICP measurement resulted in CSF diversion (ventriculoperitoneal shunt) before FMD in 11 children. Two patients required shunt due to complications after FMD (total shunt rate 43%). In Group B (n = 34) treated with FMD without preoperative ICC estimation, five children (15%) required shunting due to complications. In Group A, we found a significantly higher frequency of headache, nausea, fatigue, and dizziness. The outcome assessed by the modified Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale (mean follow-up 83 ± 57 months) was comparable between the groups, but the complication rate after FMD was significantly lower in Group A (7% vs. 32%; p = 0.011). The number of procedures (ICP measurement, FMD, shunt, re-do FMD, shunt revisions) was significantly higher in Group A (2.6 ± 0.9 vs. 1.5 ± 1.1 per patient; p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

In symptomatic children with CMI, the preoperative estimation of ICC from the overnight measurement of pulsatile ICP was more reliable for identifying those with reduced ICC than clinical and radiological assessment alone. When children with abnormally reduced ICC were identified and treated with CSF diversion before FMD, the complication rate was significantly reduced.

Complication Avoidance in Chiari Malformation Surgery

Posterior fossa decompression for symptomatic Chiari malformation is an effective and frequently performed procedure, but it does carry risks of significant complications including cerebrospinal fluid leak and craniocervical instability. Patients sometimes do not improve or worsen after decompression, which may discourage neurosurgeons from performing Chiari decompression surgery. In this chapter, management strategies and surgical approaches are discussed that minimize the risks of complications and maximize favorable outcomes in Chiari malformation surgery.

Individualized Functional Decompression Options for Adult Chiari Malformation With Syringomyelia and A Novel Scale for Syringomyelia Resolution: A Single-Center Experience

OBJECTIVE

To compare outcomes of posterior fossa bony decompression alone (PFD) versus PFD with duraplasty (PFDD) versus PFDD with additional obex exploration (PFDDO) in patients with Chiari malformation type I (CMI) combining syringomyelia.

METHODS

Clinical records of adult patients who underwent decompressions from 2014 to 2022 were retrospectively analyzed. The decompression procedure was individualized based on the cerebrospinal fluid pulse in the surgical field. The Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale (CCOS) was used to assess the prognosis of the patients and a novel syringomyelia resolution scale, based on 3-dimensional volume, was introduced. The percentage change in the cervical syrinx volume was classified as follows by resolution: ≥ 70%, 30%-70%, and < 30%.

RESULTS

Seventy-eight individuals were enrolled, of which 22, 20, and 36 underwent PFD, PFDD, and PFDDO, respectively. The three decompression groups had no significant difference in the preoperative characteristics and postoperative prognosis. Multivariate analyses revealed that better CCOS was significantly correlated with younger age at surgery (p = 0.018), syrinx originated from lower cervical levels (p = 0.037), narrower preoperative cerebral aqueduct (p = 0.005), and better syrinx volume resolution (p = 0.004). Additionally, a better cervical syrinx volume resolution was significantly correlated with higher CCOS (p = 0.017), narrower cerebral aqueduct (p = 0.035), and better tonsillar descent resolution (p = 0.007).

CONCLUSION

Individualized functional decompression induced an equal effect on CCOS and syrinx volume resolution for all CMI patients with syringomyelia. Our syringomyelia resolution scale facilitates communication and prediction of CMI prognosis.

A Novel Craniocervical Junction Compression Severity Index-Based Grading System for Multidirectional Quantification of the Biomechanics at Foramen Magnum of Chiari Malformation Type I

Objective  This study aimed to establish a novel grading system, based on the craniovertebral junction compression severity index (CVJCSI) for multidirectional quantification at the foramen magnum plane for Chiari malformation type I (CMI). Methods  The CVJCSI grading system was established to stratify patients based on the ventral (modified clivoaxial angle < 138°), dorsal (tonsil herniation), and central (brainstem herniation) CVJ (craniovertebral junction) compression, the CVJCSI grading system was established to stratify patients. The optimal surgical method for each grade was recommended by intragroup comparisons regarding the efficacy of the three operations. Finally, according to the CVJCSI grading system, a prospective validation trial was performed and surgically treated for internal validation. Results  Based on the retrospective study ( n  = 310), the CVJCSI included six grades: I: syrinx alone without compression; II: dorsal compression; III: dorsal and central compression; IV: ventral compression; V: dorsal and ventral compression; and VI: ventral, dorsal, and central compression. Among all available variables, only the CVJCSI and surgical methods significantly affected the CCOS. The CCOS scores, overall and for each CVJCSI grade, increased in the prospective cohort ( n  = 42) compared with that in the retrospective analysis. Conclusions  The CVJCSI can be used to stratify CMI patients. The higher the CVJCSI grade, the more severe the CVJ compression and the worse posterior fossa deformity. Meanwhile, the CVJCSI was negatively correlated with the CCOS. The lower the CVJCSI grade, the better the response to surgery, and the less-invasive surgical procedures were warranted. Finally, the prospective cohort study validated the proposed CVJCSI-based surgical protocols.

A long-term follow-up study of adults with Chiari malformation type I combined with syringomyelia

Background

There is a considerable amount of controversy regarding the treatment and prognosis of adult patients with Chiari malformation type I (CM-I) at home and abroad; furthermore, no large-sample, long-term, follow-up studies have examined CM-I patients with syringomyelia (SM) comparing posterior fossa decompression with resection of tonsils (PFDRT) vs. posterior fossa decompression with duraplasty (PFDD).

Objective

This study retrospectively analyzed the factors affecting the treatment and long-term prognosis of adults with CM-I combined with SM.

Methods

We retrospectively analyzed data from 158 adult CM-I patients combined with SM who underwent PFDRT or PFDD, including 68 patients in group PFDRT and 90 patients in group PFDD. We examined the clinical manifestations, imaging features, and follow-up data of patients. Clinical outcomes were assessed using the Chicago Chiari Outcomes Scale (CCOS), and radiographic outcomes were indicated by the syrinx remission rate. Multivariate logistic regression analysis and multiple linear regression analysis were used to explore the relevant factors affecting the long-term prognosis of patients.

Results

This study showed that compared with preoperative patients in the PFDRT group and PFDD group, the sensory impairment, cough-related headache, and movement disorder were significantly improved (p < 0.01); meanwhile, the diameter of the syrinx and the volume of the syrinx decreased significantly (p < 0.001). Additionally, the study found that there were significant differences in the syrinx remission rate (p = 0.032) and the clinical cure rates (p = 0.003) between the two groups. Multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that age (p = 0.021), cerebellar-related symptoms (p = 0.044), preoperative cisterna magna volume (p = 0.043), and peak systolic velocity (p = 0.036) were independent factors for clinical outcomes. Multiple linear regression analysis showed that different surgical procedures were positively correlated with the syrinx remission rate (p = 0.014), while preoperative syrinx diameter (p = 0.018) and age (p = 0.002) were negatively correlated with the syrinx remission rate.

Conclusion

In conclusion, this study suggested that, in a long-term follow-up, although both surgical procedures are effective in treating patients with CM-I and SM, PFDRT is better than PFDD; age and cerebellar-related signs independently affect the patient's prognosis. Additionally, an effective prognosis evaluation index can be developed for patients, which is based on imaging characteristics, such as preoperative cisterna magna volume, preoperative syrinx diameter, and preoperative cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) hydrodynamic parameters to guide clinical work.

Prospective, Longitudinal Study of Clinical Outcome and Morphometric Posterior Fossa Changes after Craniocervical Decompression for Symptomatic Chiari I Malformation

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The time course of changes in posterior fossa morphology, quality of life, and neurologic function of patients with Chiari I malformation after craniocervical decompression requires further elaboration. To better understand the pace of these changes, we longitudinally studied patients with Chiari I malformation, with or without syringomyelia, before and after the operation for up to 5 years.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty-eight symptomatic adult patients (35 women, 3 men) diagnosed with Chiari I malformation only (n = 15) or Chiari I malformation and syringomyelia (n = 23) and without previous Chiari I malformation surgery were enrolled in a clinical study. Patients underwent outpatient study visits and MR imaging at 7 time points (ie, initial [before the operation], 3 months, 1 year, 2 years, 3 years, 4 years, and 5 years) during 5 years. The surgical procedure for all patients was suboccipital craniectomy, C1 laminectomy, and autologous duraplasty.

RESULTS

Morphometric measurements demonstrated an enlargement of the CSF areas posterior to the cerebellar tonsils after the operation, which remained largely stable through the following years. There was a decrease in pain and improved quality of life after the operation, which remained steady during the following years. Reduction in pain and improved quality of life correlated with CSF area morphometrics.

CONCLUSIONS

Most changes in MR imaging morphometrics and quality of life measures occurred within the first year after the operation. A 1-year follow-up period after Chiari I malformation surgery is usually sufficient for evaluating surgical efficacy and postoperative MR imaging changes.

Congress of Neurological Surgeons Systematic Review and Evidence-Based Guidelines for Patients With Chiari Malformation: Surgical Interventions

BACKGROUND

Chiari malformation type I (CIM) diagnoses have increased in recent years. Controversy regarding the best operative management prompted a review of the literature to offer guidance on surgical interventions.

OBJECTIVE

To assess the literature to determine (1) whether posterior fossa decompression or posterior fossa decompression with duraplasty is more effective in preoperative symptom resolution; (2) whether there is benefit from cerebellar tonsillar resection/reduction; (3) the role of intraoperative neuromonitoring; (4) in patients with a syrinx, how long should a syrinx be observed for improvement before additional surgery is performed; and 5) what is the optimal duration of follow-up care after preoperative symptom resolution.

METHODS

A systematic review was performed using the National Library of Medicine/PubMed and Embase databases for studies on CIM in children and adults. The most appropriate surgical interventions, the use of neuromonitoring, and clinical improvement during follow-up were reviewed for studies published between 1946 and January 23, 2021.

RESULTS

A total of 80 studies met inclusion criteria. Posterior fossa decompression with or without duraplasty or cerebellar tonsil reduction all appeared to show some benefit for symptom relief and syrinx reduction. There was insufficient evidence to determine whether duraplasty or cerebellar tonsil reduction was needed for specific patient groups. There was no strong correlation between symptom relief and syringomyelia resolution. Many surgeons follow patients for 6-12 months before considering reoperation for persistent syringomyelia. No benefit or harm was seen with the use of neuromonitoring.

CONCLUSION

This evidence-based clinical guidelines for the treatment of CIM provide 1 Class II and 4 Class III recommendations. In patients with CIM with or without syringomyelia, treatment options include bone decompression with or without duraplasty or cerebellar tonsil reduction. Improved syrinx resolution may potentially be seen with dural patch grafting. Symptom resolution and syrinx resolution did not correlate directly. Reoperation for a persistent syrinx was potentially beneficial if the syrinx had not improved 6 to 12 months after the initial operation. The full guidelines can be seen online at https://www.cns.org/guidelines/browse-guidelines-detail/3-surgical-interventions .

Low versus High Intracranial Compliance in Adult Patients with Chiari Malformation Type 1-Comparison of Long-Term Outcome After Tailored Treatment

BACKGROUND

In patients with Chiari malformation type 1 (CMI) presenting with low intracranial compliance (ICC), foramen magnum decompression (FMD) often fails and the complication rate may be higher. We therefore routinely perform a preoperative assessment of ICC from intracranial pressure measurement. Patients with low ICC are treated with ventriculoperitoneal shunt (VPS) before FMD. In this study, we assess the outcome of patients with low ICC, compared with patients with high ICC treated with FMD alone.

METHODS

We reviewed the clinical and radiologic data of all consecutive patients with CMI treated between April 2008 and June 2021. ICC was assessed by overnight measurement of the pulsatile intracranial pressure: mean wave amplitude (MWA) above a previously defined threshold for abnormality was considered a surrogate marker for low ICC. The outcome was scored by Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale.

RESULTS

Of 73 patients, 23 with low ICC (average MWA 6.8 ± 1.2 mm Hg) received VPS before FMD, whereas 50 with high ICC (average MWA 4.4 ± 1.0 mm Hg) received only FMD. After a mean follow-up of 78.7 ± 41.4 months, 96% of all patients subjectively improved. The mean Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale score was 13.1 ± 2.2. Enlargement of cerebrospinal fluid space in the foramen magnum was achieved in 95% and regression of syringomyelia in 74% of cases. We found no significant difference in outcome between the patients with low and high ICC.

CONCLUSIONS

By identifying patients with CMI associated with low ICC and tailoring their treatment by VPS before FMD, we achieved favorable clinical and radiologic outcomes comparable to those with high ICC.

A novel scoring system for assessing adult syringomyelia associated with CM I treatment outcomes

BACKGROUND

A specific scoring system for syringomyelia is lacking. Our objective was to investigate the value of a novel scoring system (Syringomyelia Outcome Scale of Xuanwu hospital, SOS-XW) in assessing surgical outcomes in the treatment of syringomyelia (SM) associated with Chiari malformation type I (CM I).

METHODS

A quantitative evaluation system (SOS-XW) of SM includes 4 parameters: pain (P), sensation (S), movement (M), and syringomyelia tension index (STI). The clinical data of 88 patients with CM I-related syringomyelia treated by foramen magnum and Magendie dredging (FMMD) from January 2018 to January 2019 were retrospectively analysed with a mean follow-up of 14.3 months, and the SOS-XW score was used to assess the efficacy.

RESULTS

The higher the SOS-XW score, the more severe was the SM and related symptoms. The mean preoperative score was 5.97, and the postoperative score was 2.66. The symptom improvement rates were 77.78% for P, 69.01% for S, 31.82% for M, and 95.06% for the syringomyelia tension index (STI). The symptom improvement rate of the PSM score was weakly correlated with the improvement rate of STI, R² = 0.0016. The percentage of PSM (P + S + M) improvement was lower in patients with an STI of 0. The postoperative SOS-XW score was positively correlated with the postoperative JOA score, R² = 0.8314. The positive detection rate of SOS-XW was higher than that of the JOA score.

CONCLUSIONS

To evaluate the surgical procedure efficacy in the treatment of syringomyelia, the SOS-XW score can provide a more objective, detailed, and comprehensive analysis, especially STI. A reduction in STI is the practical standard for assessing the effectiveness of surgery.

Above-The-Hairline Suboccipital Transverse Approach for the Treatment of Chiari I Malformation

BACKGROUND

Chiari I malformation is a common pediatric neurosurgical disorder with an established treatment paradigm. Posterior fossa decompression and duraplasty (PFDD) is associated with symptom improvement but it carries postoperative risk, particularly cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak and wound complications. In addition, the cosmetic outcomes of PFDD have been overlooked in the literature.

OBJECTIVE

To describe a novel approach for PFDD in which the transverse surgical incision is completely hidden above the hairline and to report early outcomes in a prospective patient cohort.

METHODS

Clinical and cosmetic outcomes were recorded for 15 consecutive pediatric patients who underwent PFDD for Chiari I malformation via the above-the-hairline transverse suboccipital approach.

RESULTS

The median clinical follow-up time was 6 months (range 1-12 months), and the majority of patients experienced significant improvement of their preoperative symptoms. Three patients (20%) experienced complications associated with surgery, which included injury to the greater occipital nerve, CSF hypotension and subfascial pseudomeningocele, and superficial wound dehiscence that resolved spontaneously with oral antibiotics. Zero patients (0%) returned to the operating room for persistent CSF leak, deep wound infection, or revision decompression. An excellent cosmetic outcome was achieved in 12 patients (80%). No patient had a poor cosmetic outcome.

CONCLUSION

The above-the-hairline transverse suboccipital approach for PFDD in patients with Chiari I malformation offers favorable cosmetic outcomes and fascial closure while permitting adequate decompression.

Prevalence and treatment of typical and atypical headaches in patients with Chiari I malformation: A meta-analysis and literature review

OBJECTIVE

A meta-analysis was conducted to analyze the incidence of typical and atypical headaches and outcomes following various treatments in patients with Chiari I malformation.

BACKGROUND

Headache is the most common symptom of Chiari malformation, which can be divided into typical and atypical subgroups to facilitate management. Much controversy surrounds the etiology, prevalence and optimal therapeutic approach for both types of headaches.

METHOD

We identified relevant studies published before 30 July 2022, with an electronic search of numerous literature databases. The results of this study were reported according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses statement.

RESULT

A total of 1913 Chiari malformation type I CIM patients were identified, 78% of whom presented with headache, within this group cephalgia was typical in 48% and atypical in 29% of patients, and migraine was the most common type of atypical headache. The ratio of typical/atypical headaches with international classification of headache disorders diagnosis was 1.53, and without international classification of headache disorders diagnosis was 1.56, respectively. The pooled improvement rates of typical headaches following conservative treatment, extradural decompression and intradural decompression were 69%, 88%, and 92%, respectively. The corresponding improvement rates for atypical headaches were 70%, 57.47%, and 69%, respectively. The complication rate in extradural decompression group was significantly lower than in intradural decompression group (RR, 0.31; 95% CI: 0.06-1.59, I² = 50%, P = 0.14). Low reoperation rates were observed for refractory headaches in extradural decompression and intradural decompression groups (1%).

CONCLUSION

The International Classification of Headache Disorders can assist in screening atypical headaches. extradural decompression is preferred for typical headaches, while conservative therapy is optimal for atypical headaches. A definite correlation exists between atypical headaches and Chiari Malformation Type I patients with higher prevalence than in the general population. Importantly, decompression is effective in relieving headaches in this particular patient population.

Headache and Other Symptoms in Chiari Malformation Type I Are Associated with Cerebrospinal Fluid Flow Improvement After Decompression: A Two-Institutional Study

OBJECTIVE

Chiari malformation type I (CMI) is a common neurologic condition and surgery is the standard treatment. We aim to establish the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) flow change as a potential objective indicator of surgical efficacy to improve symptoms.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective 2-center analysis of surgically treated patients with CMI. Qualitative CSF flow studies obtained preoperatively and postoperatively were analyzed by the neuroradiologist, seeking improvement in CSF flow. Symptom status, including headache and neck pain, were recorded.

RESULTS

Forty-nine patients were identified between 2010 and 2017. The average age was 36 years, with 47 females. After decompression, CSF flow was improved in 41 patients (group A) and unchanged in 8 (group B). Group A and B had a mean age of 34 and 42 years (P < 0.05) and an average tonsillar herniation of 8.3 and 8.5 mm (P = 0.40), respectively. Group A had improved clinical outcomes, compared with group B (P = 0.024), more specifically, in headache (50% vs. 37%), neck pain (66% vs. 33%), dizziness (78% vs. 50%), vision symptoms (84% vs. 80%), and weakness (100% vs. 66%), respectively. Group B had the only patient who did worse on clinical follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with CMI often present with a constellation of symptoms. We showed a significant association between improved CSF flow after decompression and symptom alleviation. Further, our study suggests that the presence of improved CSF flow postoperatively could represent an objective indicator for improved patient outcomes.

Precise Management of Chiari Malformation with Type I

Diagnosis of Chirai malformation type I (CM-I) is based on magnetic resonance imaging of the brain or cervical spinal cord. The main goal of surgery is to relieve the blockage to the free pulsatile flow of cerebrospinal fluid beyond the foramen magnum and to stop the progression of a syringomyelia. Despite recent advances in imaging and surgery, even today, there is no consensus on optimal management of CM-I. Ongoing focus is devoted to a better consideration of the pathophysiology of CM-I and the development of more effective medical and surgical treatments. It is hoped that proposed algorithm helps the neurosurgeon to provide a precise management for patients with CM-I in advance.

External validation of current prediction systems of improvement after decompression surgery in Chiari malformation type I patients: can we do better?

OBJECTIVE

The Chiari Severity Index (CSI) and points-based algorithm of Thakar et al. are two prognostic tools that have been developed to predict the likelihood of improvement after suboccipital decompression in adult patients with Chiari malformation type I (CM-I). This study aimed to externally validate and critically evaluate these algorithms in the interest of guiding the development of improved prediction systems.

METHODS

A consecutive cohort of CM-I patients undergoing suboccipital decompression between September 2006 and September 2018 were included. The CSI and Thakar point score were computed for all patients, and associations with improvement were analyzed. The ability of both prediction systems to predict improvement as measured by different Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale (CCOS) cutoffs was assessed using receiver operating curve analysis. Post hoc correlations between the algorithms and different CCOS subcomponents were also assessed.

RESULTS

The surgical cohort was composed of 149 adult CM-I patients, of whom 39 (26%) had a syrinx. Most patients experienced improvement after surgery (80% CCOS ≥ 13; 96% CCOS ≥ 11). The proportion of patients improving decreased with increasing CSI, but the results were not statistically significant (p = 0.246). No statistically significant difference in the mean Thakar point score was identified between improved and nonimproved patients using both CCOS cutoffs (p = 0.246 for a cutoff of 13 and p = 0.480 for a cutoff of 11). The CSI had a poor ability in identifying improved patients at a CCOS cutoff of 13 (area under the curve [AUC] 0.582) and 11 (AUC 0.646). The Thakar point score similarly had poor discrimination at a cutoff of 13 (AUC 0.467) and 11 (AUC 0.646). Neither algorithm had significant correlation with any of the CCOS subcomponents except for CSI and nonpain symptom improvement (coefficient = -0.273, p = 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Previously published algorithms failed to provide prediction value with regard to clinically meaningful improvement following suboccipital decompression in adult CM-I patients. Future models and practical scoring systems are still required to improve the decision-making process.

Prognostic significance of C1-C2 facet malalignment after surgical decompression in adult Chiari malformation type I: a pilot study based on the Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale

OBJECTIVE

The authors assessed the prognostic significance of various clinical and radiographic characteristics, including C1-C2 facet malalignment, in terms of surgical outcomes after foramen magnum decompression of adult Chiari malformation type I.

METHODS

The electronic medical records of 273 symptomatic patients with Chiari malformation type I who were treated with foramen magnum decompression, C1 laminectomy, and duraplasty at Mayo Clinic were retrospectively reviewed. Preoperative and postoperative Neurological Scoring System scores were compared using the Friedman test. Bivariate analysis was conducted to identify the preoperative variables that correlated with the patient Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale (CCOS) scores. Multiple linear regression analysis was subsequently performed using the variables with p < 0.05 on the bivariate analysis to check for independent associations with the outcome measures. Statistical software SPSS version 25.0 was used for the data analysis. Significance was defined as p < 0.05 for all analyses.

RESULTS

Fifty-two adult patients with preoperative clinical and radiological data and a minimum follow-up of 12 months were included. Motor deficits, syrinx, and C1-C2 facet malalignment were found to have significant negative associations with the CCOS score at the 1- to 3-month follow-up (p < 0.05), while at the 9- to 12-month follow-up only swallowing function and C1-C2 facet malalignment were significantly associated with the CCOS score (p < 0.05). Multivariate analysis showed that syrinx presence and C1-C2 facet malalignment were independently associated with the CCOS score at the 1- to 3-month follow-up. Swallowing function and C1-C2 facet malalignment were found to be independently associated with the CCOS score at the 9- to 12-month follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

The observed results in this pilot study suggest a significant negative correlation between C1-C2 facet malalignment and clinical outcomes evaluated by the CCOS score at 1-3 months and 9-12 months postoperatively. Prospective studies are needed to further validate the prognostic value of C1-C2 facet malalignment and the potential role of atlantoaxial fixation as part of the treatment.

The impact of neurosurgical technique on the short- and long-term outcomes of adult patients with Chiari I malformation

OBJECTIVE

This study is aimed to compare and evaluate any differences in clinical and radiological outcomes of different operative techniques of cranio-cervical decompression (CCD) performed in adults with symptomatic Chiari malformation type I (CM-1) within a single tertiary neurosurgical center.

METHODS

A retrospective review using the Hospital theatre management system (ORSOS) and records of patients who underwent CCD for CM-1 between January 2011 and October 2019 was performed. Patients were divided in three cohorts according to the operative technique used: an extradural osteo-ligamentous decompression (BD), BD followed by dural opening either without duraplasty (DOWD) or plus duroplasty (DOPD). The primary clinical outcome was measured by utilizing the Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale (CCOS). Syrinx outcome was measured on post-op MRI. Statistical analysis was performed using IBM SPSS 24 with α = 0.05.

RESULTS

67 adults underwent 69 CCD: 10 BD, 29 DOWD and 30 DOPD. Median follow-up was 47.3 months (Interquartile Range (IQR) 26.3-73.7). Patients who underwent DOPD had a shorter median hospital stay (p-value 0.001), fewer unplanned readmissions (p-value 0.015), a higher median CCOS (p-value 0.001) and a lower post-operative complications rate (p-value 0.001) compared to patients who underwent DOWD. BD revealed a 40 % failure rate and was ineffective in cases with syringomyelia.

CONCLUSION

Better clinical outcomes, lower complication risk, and short duration of hospital stay were associated with patients who underwent dural opening with augmentative watertight duraplasty. Bony decompression alone despite being a very safe technique, does not appear to be reliable and effective in controlling and relieving the clinical symptoms and the syringomyelia of adult patients with CM-1.

Chiari 1 malformation: age-based outcomes in a paediatric surgical cohort

PURPOSE

Substantial evidence exists describing differences between paediatric and adult Chiari 1 malformation (CM1) patients. Differences in clinical presentation between very young (0-6 years old) and older (7-18 years old) paediatric patients is similarly well-established. However, progression on these findings with regard to surgical outcomes is limited. We aimed to establish whether inter-paediatric age group modifies surgical outcome for CM1 decompression.

METHODS

Retrospective chart review was conducted for 65 patients receiving posterior fossa decompression between 2006 and 2018. Presenting features, surgical management, and outcome were evaluated and stratified into very young patients (0-6 years) or older patients (7-18 years). Outcomes were assessed using the Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale (CCOS), a validated 16-point framework for comparison.

RESULTS

Very young patients (21 patients) scored significantly lower in surgical outcome overall compared with older patients (44 patients) (12.1 ± 3.2/16 vs 14.2 ± 1.6/16, p = 0.011), and across 3/4 CCOS subscores: non-pain symptoms, functionality, and complications. Very young patients also returned to theatre more commonly (47.6% vs 13.6%, p = 0.003), primarily for re-do decompression (7/10 patients, 70%). Finally, the presentation of very young patients differed to older patients with significantly more oropharyngeal (38.1% vs 9.0%, p = 0.014) and motor symptoms (47.6% vs 22.7%, p = 0.042).

DISCUSSION

Very young patients (0-6 years) do not appear to respond as well to standard posterior fossa decompression, as their older (7-18 years) paediatric counterparts, in the absence of several baseline cohort characteristic differences. We hypothesise underlying anatomical differences may contribute to this finding.

Chiari Malformation and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder

Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a neurodevelopmental condition characterized by inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity. Chiari malformations (CM), first described approximately a hundred years ago, refer to a spectrum of hindbrain malformations characterized by cerebellar herniation through the foramen magnum. We present the case of a 28-year-old woman with ADHD and concurrent Chiari malformation type I (CM-I) that was diagnosed by CT scan. There is growing evidence supporting the role of the cerebellum and its associated structures in the pathophysiology of ADHD. Thus, a cerebellar malformation such as CM may impact neurological circuitry in a manner favoring the development of a neuropsychiatric disorder such as ADHD. Our case highlights the need for further studies pertaining to the role of the cerebellum in the pathophysiology of ADHD and the importance of considering the presence of CM when evaluating a patient with ADHD.

Correlation of a new hydrodynamic index with other effective indexes in Chiari I malformation patients with different associations

This study aimed to find a new CSF hydrodynamic index to assess Chiari type I malformation (CM-I) patients’ conditions and examine the relationship of this new index with morphometric and volumetric changes in these patients and their clinical symptoms. To this end, 58 CM-I patients in four groups and 20 healthy subjects underwent PC-MRI. Ten morphometric and three volumetric parameters were calculated. The CSF hydrodynamic parameters were also analyzed through computational fluid dynamic (CFD) simulation. The maximum CSF pressure was identified as a new hydrodynamic parameter to assess the CM-I patients’ conditions. This parameter was similar in patients with the same symptoms regardless of the group to which they belonged. The result showed a weak correlation between the maximum CSF pressure and the morphometric parameters in the patients. Among the volumetric parameters, PCF volume had the highest correlation with the maximum CSF pressure, which its value being higher in patients with CM-I/SM/scoliosis (R² = 65.6%, P = 0.0022) than in the other patients. PCF volume was the more relevant volumetric parameter to assess the patients’ symptoms. The values of PCF volume were greater in patients that headache symptom was more obvious than other symptoms, as compared to the other patients.

Family History in Chiari Malformation Type I: Presentation and Outcome

BACKGROUND

Some patients with Chiari malformation type I (CM-1) present with a positive family history of CM-1, the significance of which remains unknown. We aimed to study whether family history affects the clinical presentation characteristics and surgical outcome of adult patients with CM-1.

METHODS

A database of adult patients with CM-1 presenting between January 1, 2006 and December 31, 2018 was used. Presenting characteristics were compared between patients with and without a family history (first, second, or third degree) of CM-1. Among surgically treated patients, perioperative and long-term outcomes, with favorable outcome defined as a Chiari Outcome Scale score ≥14, were compared between patients with and without CM-1 family history. All patients completed at least 6 months of postoperative follow-up.

RESULTS

The database consisted of 233 adult patients with CM-1, 14 of whom (6%) had a positive family history. Presenting characteristics were comparable between patients with and without a positive family history. A total of 150 patients underwent suboccipital decompression, 12 of whom (8%) had a positive family history. After a mean follow-up of 1.9 years, patients with a family history of CM-1 were significantly less likely to achieve a favorable outcome (odds ratio, 0.22; 95% confidence interval, 0.06-0.78; P = 0.019) while controlling for several covariates. Post hoc analysis showed that the difference was most significant when looking at pain symptoms.

CONCLUSIONS

Presentation characteristics are comparable between patients with and without a family history of CM-1. Patients with a positive family history may be less likely to respond favorably to suboccipital decompression.

The SHORE Score: A Novel Predictive Tool for Improvement After Decompression Surgery in Adult Chiari Malformation Type I

BACKGROUND

A practical scoring system predicting significant improvement after surgical decompression in adult Chiari malformation type I (CM-1) based on validated outcome measures is lacking. We aimed to develop a simple score and improvement calculator to facilitate the decision making process in symptomatic CM-1 patients.

METHODS

We evaluated adult CM-1 patients who presented to our institution between September 2006 and September 2018 and underwent surgical decompression. Previously treated patients were excluded. Univariable analysis and multivariable logistic regression were conducted to derive an optimal model predictive of improvement on last follow-up as measured by the Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale. A score was derived using the beta coefficients of the model, and predictive performance was assessed using receiver operating curves with bootstrap validation. Finally, a web-based improvement calculator was deployed.

RESULTS

The surgical cohort consisted of 149 adult CM-1 patients, of which 100 (67%) experienced significant clinical improvement (Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale ≥14) after a mean follow-up of 1.9 years. The final model predictive of significant clinical improvement consisted of headache with Valsalva (odds ratio [OR] = 2.39; P = 0.030), nonwhite race (OR = 2.57; P = 0.041), absence of visual symptoms (OR = 2.59; P = 0.015), syrinx absence (OR = 1.59; P = 0.315), and increased odontoid retroflexion (OR = 2.82; P = 0.009). The score was termed SHORE, which summarizes the model's predictive factors, each assigned 1 point. The model had an area under the curve of 0.754 with an optimism-correct value of 0.721. A calculator was deployed under: https://jhuspine2.shinyapps.io/SHORE_score/.

CONCLUSIONS

The score and calculator can serve as supplements to clinical decision making by providing realistic and personalized expectations of postoperative outcome.

Multidimensional, patient-reported outcome after posterior fossa decompression in 79 patients with Chiari malformation type I

Background:

We studied patient-reported outcome among patients who underwent posterior fossa decompression (PFD) for Chiari malformation type I (CM-I).

Methods:

We interviewed patients who underwent PFD for CM-I from 1995 to 2016.

Results:

A total of 79 patients were interviewed. The median age at surgery was 30 years (range 5–72 years) with 27 pediatric patients. Forty-six patients had syringomyelia (36 adults and 10 pediatric patients). Fifty-four patients (68%) reported at least some improvement, 46 (58%) important improvement, 13 (16%) worsening, and 12 stabilization (15%). Any improvement as well as important improvement were significantly more often reported in the nonsyringomyelia group (85% vs. 57%, P = 0.01 and 76% vs. 46%, P = 0.01, respectively). Of the 47 patients reporting preoperative neck pain, 31 (66%) reported at least some improvement after surgery and 9 (19%) worsening after surgery. Of the 59 patients experiencing headaches before surgery, 45 (76%) reported at least some improvement after surgery and 4 (7%) worsening. Quality of life was mostly affected by pain and discomfort in all groups. Sixty-two patients (78%) were satisfied or very satisfied with the results of surgery and 8 (11%) were unsatisfied or very unsatisfied. Up to 71 patients (90%) would consent to surgery again.

Conclusion:

In CM-I patients, PFD offers symptom improvement in about two-thirds of patients with high patient satisfaction. Symptom improvement is significantly higher in patients without associated syringomyelia, but patient satisfaction is similar. Symptom worsening is more frequent in the adult than in the pediatric population, with similar rates of postoperative improvement and patient satisfaction.

Outcomes and complications for individual neurosurgeons for the treatment of Chiari I malformation at a children's hospital

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the outcomes and complications for individual surgeons at British Columbia Children's Hospital for the treatment of Chiari I Malformation (CMI) in children.

METHODS

This was a retrospective review of patients with CMI who had surgery from 1986 to 2015. We assessed the Chicago Chiari Outcome Scores (CCOS) and complication rates by surgeon.

RESULTS

Seventy patients, 38 males and 32 females, underwent posterior fossa decompression including 14 extradural and 56 intradural approaches. Syringomyelia was present in 74.3%. Most syringomyelia improved with no difference between intradural and extradural surgeries. After initial surgery, 13 patients (18.6%) had complications including 2/14 (14.3%) of extradural and 11/56 (19.6%) of intradural surgeries. Two patients required surgical intervention for complications whereas 11 had transient complications. The complication rate by surgeon ranged from 11 to 20% for extradural (2 surgeons only) and 10.5 to 40% for intradural surgeries (4 surgeons). The CCOS ranged from 12 to 15 for extradural and 6 to 16 for intradural. The CCOS ranges for surgeons 1 and 2 were 12-15 and 13-15 respectively for extradural. The CCOS ranges for surgeons 1, 2, 3, and 4 were 12-16, 6-15, 12-16, and 12-16 respectively for intradural. Thirteen patients had a second surgery for CMI. The final CCOS was good in 86% and moderate in 14%.

CONCLUSION

There was variability in surgeries performed at BCCH by different surgeons, with variations in CCOS and complication rates. This information is important during decision making, consent process, and for quality improvement.

Quantification of changes in brain morphology following posterior fossa decompression surgery in women treated for Chiari malformation type 1

PURPOSE

While 84% of patients surgically treated for Chiari malformation type 1 (CM1) demonstrate improved quality of life after posterior fossa decompression surgery, there are many risks associated with this surgery. Surgical planning to identify candidates likely to improve postoperatively may benefit from an improved understanding of morphological changes after decompression surgery. To evaluate these changes, we quantified 59 morphological parameters on 42 CM1 adult female patients before and after CM1 decompression surgery.

METHODS

Fifty-nine morphological parameters in the posterior cranial fossa, cranio-cervical, and intracranial regions in the midsagittal plane were evaluated using 42 T1-weighted magnetic resonance images of female CM1 patients before and after surgery, and 42 healthy female controls. Morphological differences before and after surgery were compared through the development of a technique to establish the opisthion location, a key reference point not present after surgery.

RESULTS

In addition to the expected reduction of the cranio-caudal dimension of the cerebellum, objective analyses showed a significant increase in the area of the cerebrospinal fluid spaces, posterior (6×) and inferior (2.6×) to the cerebellum (+ 112 ± 102 and + 140 ± 127 mm2, respectively). This increased area was primarily impacted by an average reduction in the occipital bone length of 24.5 ± 7.3 mm following surgery. Based on multiple angles, results demonstrated a 2°-4° anterior rotation of the cerebellum after surgery.

CONCLUSION

Our results show that decompression surgery results in significant changes in the cerebellum and cerebrospinal fluid spaces. Further investigation should determine how these morphological changes impact clinical outcomes.

Relationship of Morphologic Changes in the Brain and Spinal Cord and Disease Symptoms with Cerebrospinal Fluid Hydrodynamic Changes in Patients with Chiari Malformation Type I

BACKGROUND

Morphometric analysis or examination of symptoms in patients with Chiari malformation type I (CM-I) with various associations does not suffice for evaluation of surgical outcome of these patients. We assessed the relationship of morphologic changes in brain and spinal cord and disease symptoms with changes in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) hydrodynamic parameters in patients with CM-I.

METHODS

The study included 41 patients in 3 groups of CM-I, CM-I/occipitoatlantoaxial joint instability, and CM-I/tethered cord syndrome and 18 normal subjects. Phase-contrast magnetic resonance imaging and computational fluid dynamics analysis were done for all samples.

RESULTS

Maximum CSF velocities and pressures in patients had an increase of 17.1%-23.2% and 41.5%-56.8%, respectively, compared with normal subjects. The data dispersion of maximum CSF velocity was >3.1 times that of the maximum pressure. Results showed that maximum CSF pressure is a more appropriate hydrodynamic parameter than maximum CSF velocity for assessing the condition of patients. Results also showed that CSF and PCF volumes had declined 57% and 11.3%, respectively, in CM-I. These declines were greater in CM-I than in the other 2 groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Maximum CSF pressure regardless of the group the patients belonged to was similar in patients with symptoms of similar intensity. The correlation between maximum CSF pressure with CSF and PCF volumes decreased secondary to the disease. PCF volume was more favorable than CSF volume for assessing intensity of disease symptoms. Furthermore, in a constant pressure change, sensitivity of PCF volume in CM-I/occipitoatlantoaxial joint instability and CM-I/tethered cord syndrome groups was more than in the CM-I group.