Chiari Malformations Type I without Basilar Invagination in Adults: Morphometric and Volumetric Analysis

Biomechanical Study of Atlanto-occipital Instability in Type II Basilar Invagination: A Finite Element Analysis

OBJECTIVE

Recent studies indicate that 3 morphological types of atlanto-occipital joint (AOJ) exist in the craniovertebral junction and are associated with type II basilar invagination (BI) and atlanto-occipital instability. However, the actual biomechanical effects remain unclear. This study aims to investigate biomechanical differences among AOJ types I, II, and III, and provide further evidence of atlanto-occipital instability in type II BI.

METHODS

Models of bilateral AOJ containing various AOJ types were created, including I-I, I-II, II-II, II-III, and III-III models, with increasing AOJ dysplasia across models. Then, 1.5 Nm torque simulated cervical motions. The range of motion (ROM), ligament and joint stress, and basion-dental interval (BDI) were analyzed.

RESULTS

The C0-1 ROM and accompanying rotational ROM increased progressively from model I-I to model III-III, with the ROM of model III-III showing increases between 27.3% and 123.8% indicating ultra-mobility and instability. In contrast, the C1-2 ROM changes were minimal. Meanwhile, the stress distribution pattern was disrupted; in particular, the C1 superior facet stress was concentrated centrally and decreased substantially across the models. The stress on the C0-1 capsule ligament decreased during cervical flexion and increased during bending and rotating loading. In addition, BDI gradually decreased across the models. Further analysis revealed that the dens showed an increase of 110.1% superiorly and 11.4% posteriorly, indicating an increased risk of spinal cord impingement.

CONCLUSION

Progressive AOJ incongruity critically disrupts supportive tissue loading, enabling incremental atlanto-occipital instability. AOJ dysplasia plays a key biomechanical role in the pathogenesis of type II BI.

Multi-Dimensional Morphometric and Volumetric Analysis of the Posterior Cranial Fossa to Study Type I Chiari Malformation

BACKGROUND

Chiari malformation type I (CM-1) is a complex disorder in which tonsillar herniation through the foramen magnum (FM) manifests with a spectrum of clinical symptoms. This work analyzes morphometric and volumetric characteristics of CM-1 patients.

METHODS

With institutional review board approval, we retrospectively reviewed a total of 72 adult CM-1 patients and 26 healthy adult volunteers who underwent volumetric magnetic resonance brain imaging. Clinical data were retrospectively extracted from the electronic medical record. We analyzed multidimensional morphometric and volumetric features within the posterior cranial fossa and correlated these features with syrinx formation and the decision to undergo surgical decompression.

RESULTS

In our study, CM-1 patients had decreased cerebellar (CBL), brainstem, and fourth ventricular volumes but larger tonsillar volume with increased total tonsillar length. CM-1 patients who underwent surgery had significantly more neural tissue within the cross-sectional area of the cisterna magna. Logistic regression demonstrated that combining neural tissue at the FM with CBL and fourth ventricular volumes led to a great degree of correlation with syrinx formation (area under the curve: 0.911).

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest that the amount of tissue at the FM correlates with CM-1 patients who underwent decompressive surgery, more so than tonsillar length. Additionally, the combination of neural tissue at the FM, CBL, and fourth ventricular volumes led to a great degree of correlation with syrinx formation. Together, these findings suggest that a global compressive phenomenon within the posterior fossa leads to CM-1 symptomatology and syrinx formation.

Geometric morphometric analysis of the brainstem and cerebellum in Chiari I malformation

Background

Chiari I malformation (CMI) is characterized by inferior descent of the cerebellar tonsils through the foramen magnum and is associated with headache and neck pain. Many morphometric research efforts have aimed to describe CMI anatomy in the midsagittal plane using classical measurement techniques such as linear dimensions and angles. These methods are less frequently applied to parasagittal features and may fall short in quantifying more intricate anatomy with fewer distinct homologous landmarks.

Methods

Landmark-based geometric morphometric techniques were used to asses CMI morphology in five anatomical planes of interest.

Results

Significant shape differences between CMI and age/sex-matched controls were found in the midsagittal (Pseudo-F = 5.4841, p = 0.001) and axial planes through the rostral medulla (Pseudo-F = 7.6319, p = 0.001). In addition to tonsillar descent, CMI principal component 1 (PC1) scores in the midsagittal protocol were associated with marked anterior concavity of the brainstem and generalized verticality of the cerebellum with anterior rotation of its anterior lobe. In the axial medulla/cerebellum protocol, CMI PC1 scores were associated with greater anterior-posterior (A-P) dimension with loss of medial-lateral (M-L) dimension.

Discussion

These results suggest that CMI is associated with greater curvature of the brainstem and spinal cord, which may perturb normal neural activities and disrupt cerebrospinal fluid movements. Previous reports on the A-P diameter of the posterior fossa in CMI have conflicted; our findings of greater A-P cerebellar dimensionality with concomitant loss of width alludes to the possibility that more caudal aspects of the posterior cranial fossa are more bowl-like (homogenous in axial dimensions) and less trough-like or elongated in the M-L direction.

C1-2 Fusion in Atlantoaxial Dislocation and Basilar Invagination with and without Chiari Malformation: Clinical/Radiological and Craniometric Results

OBJECTIVE

Patients with Chiari malformation (CM) associated with atlantoaxial dislocation (AAD) and basilar invagination (BI) may present with a small posterior cranial fossa, but data on the volumetric analysis are lacking. Additionally, whether additional foramen magnum decompression (FMD) is needed together with atlantoaxial fusion remains controversial. This study evaluated the volumetric alterations of the posterior cranial fossa in these patients and analyzed the radiological and clinical outcomes after posterior C1-C2 reduction and fixation plus C1 posterior arch resection.

METHODS

Thirty-two adult CM patients with AAD and BI (CM-AAD/BI group) and 21 AAD and BI patients without CM (AAD/BI-only group) who received posterior atlantoaxial fusion plus C1 posterior arch resection were retrospectively studied. The clinical and radiological outcomes and volumetric measurements of the posterior cranial fossa were evaluated.

RESULTS

The majority of CM-AAD/BI patients (94%) improved clinically and radiologically at 12 mo postoperatively, and none required additional FMD. Morphological analysis revealed a significant reduction in the bony posterior cranial fossa volumes of the CM-AAD/BI group (P < 0.01) and the AAD/BI-only group (P < 0.01) relative to those of the CM group. No significant differences were observed between the CM-AAD/BI and AAD/BI groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Compared with patients with simple CM, patients with AAD/BI with or without CM demonstrated a considerably and equally reduced bony posterior cranial fossa volume. No additional FMD is needed in the treatment of CM-AAD/BI patients after posterior reduction and fusion plus C1 posterior arch resection.

Potential association among posterior fossa bony volume and crowdedness, tonsillar hernia, syringomyelia, and CSF dynamics at the craniocervical junction in Chiari malformation type I

Objective

The characteristic morphological parameters (bony posterior fossa volume (bony-PFV), posterior fossa crowdness, cerebellar tonsillar hernia, and syringomyelia) and CSF dynamics parameters at the craniocervical junction (CVJ) in Chiari malformation type I (CMI) were measured. The potential association between these characteristic morphologies and CSF dynamics at CVJ was analyzed.

Methods

A total of 46 cases of control subjects and 48 patients with CMI underwent computed tomography and phase-contrast magnetic resonance imaging. Seven morphovolumetric measures and four CSF dynamics at CVJ measures were performed. The CMI cohort was further divided into "syringomyelia" and "non-syringomyelia" subgroups. All the measured parameters were analyzed by the Pearson correlation.

Results

Compared with the control, the posterior cranial fossa (PCF) area, bony-PFV, and CSF net flow were significantly smaller (P < 0.001) in the CMI group. Otherwise, the PCF crowdedness index (PCF CI, P < 0.001) and the peak velocity of CSF (P < 0.05) were significantly larger in the CMI cohort. The mean velocity (MV) was faster in patients with CMI with syringomyelia (P < 0.05). In the correlation analysis, the degree of cerebellar tonsillar hernia was correlated with PCF CI (R = 0.319, P < 0.05), MV (R = -0.303, P < 0.05), and the net flow of CSF (R = -0.300, P < 0.05). The Vaquero index was well correlated with the bony-PFV (R= -0.384, P < 0.05), MV (R = 0.326, P < 0.05), and the net flow of CSF (R = 0.505, P < 0.05).

Conclusion

The bony-PFV in patients with CMI was smaller, and the MV was faster in CMI with syringomyelia. Cerebellar subtonsillar hernia and syringomyelia are independent indicators for evaluating CMI. Subcerebellar tonsillar hernia was associated with PCF crowdedness, MV, and the net flow of CSF at CVJ, while syringomyelia was associated with bony-PFV, MV, and the net flow of CSF at the CVJ. Thus, the bony-PFV, PCF crowdedness, and the degree of CSF patency should also be one of the indicators of CMI evaluation.

A new supportive approach in the diagnosis of Chiari malformation type 1 in pediatric patients

PURPOSE

Chiari malformation type 1 (CM-1) is a posterior fossa anomaly characterized by herniation of the cerebellar tonsils from the foramen magnum (FM). This study compares FM, medulla spinalis (MS), and herniated cerebellar tonsils ratios by making area measurements from axial plane MRI in CM-1 patients and the control group.

METHODS

Our study evaluated 30 pediatric patients with CM-1 and 30 people in the control group. The lengths of the McRae line, twining line, and clivus line were measured on the posterior cranial fossa evaluation. The areas of FM (A_FM), MS (A_MS), and herniated cerebellar tonsils (A_TONSILS) were measured by axial images.

RESULTS

As a result of area measurements obtained from axial cross-sectional MRI, a statistically significant difference was found between CM-1 patients and the control group. According to the results of the ROC analysis, if an individual's A_MS/A_FM value is above 17.9% or the A_TONSILS/A_FM value is above 18.4%, it can be interpreted as a CM-1 patient.

CONCLUSION

It will be easier to diagnose the patient with the new approach we obtained from axial MR images in addition to sagittal MR images. This method can be a guide in some cases when the surgeons are undecided.

The Small Posterior Cranial Fossa Syndrome and Chiari Malformation Type 0

Patients showing typical Chiari malformation type 1 (CM1) signs and symptoms frequently undergo cranial and cervical MRI. In some patients, MRI documents >5 mm of cerebellar tonsillar herniation (TH) and the diagnosis of CM1. Patients with 3−5 mm TH have “borderline” CM1. Patients with less than 3 mm of TH and an associated cervical syrinx are diagnosed with Chiari “zero” malformation (CM0). However, patients reporting CM1 symptoms are usually not diagnosed with CM if MRI shows less than 3−5 mm of TH and no syrinx. Recent MRI morphometric analysis of the posterior fossa and upper cervical spine detected anatomical abnormalities in and around the foramen magnum (FM) that explain these patients’ symptoms. The abnormalities include a reduced size of the posterior fossa, FM, and upper cervical spinal canal and extension of the cerebellar tonsils around the medulla rather than inferior to the foramen magnum, as in CM1. These morphometric findings lead some neurologists and neurosurgeons to diagnose CM0 in patients with typical CM1 signs and symptoms, with or without cervical syringes. This article reviews recent findings and controversies about CM0 diagnosis and updates current thinking about the clinical and radiological relationship between CM0, borderline CM1, and CM1.

Evaluation Of Cervical Sagittal Parameters On Supine Magnetic Resonance Imaging In Patients With Chiari I Malformation Without Syringomyelia

OBJECTIVE

. The current study aimed to assess the effects of tonsillar herniation on cervical alignment in Chiari I patients without syringomyelia using new cervical sagittal alignment parameters, such as C0-2 Cobb angle, C2-7 cobb angle, T1 slope, and C2-7 sagittal vertical axis (SVA).

METHODS

Two spinal surgeons independently evaluated midline T2-weighted sagittal magnetic resonance imaging findings of 28 Chiari I patients without syringomyelia and 40 patients without tonsillar herniation but with similar complaints. Thereafter, the measured C0-2 Cobb angle, C2-7 Cobb angle T1 slope, and C2-7 SVA were compared using the t-test.

RESULTS

Differences in the mean values for C2-7 Cobb angle, T1 slope, and C2-7 SVA were found between Chiari I patients and those without tonsillar herniation Conclusion: The current study showed that Chiari I patients were less lordotic (kyphotic) compared to subjects without tonsillar herniation.

Is there a morphometric cause of Chiari malformation type I? Analysis of existing literature

Although many etiologies have been proposed for Chiari malformation type I (CM-I), there currently is no singular known cause of CM-I pathogenesis. Advances in imaging have greatly progressed the study of CM-I. This study reviews the literature to determine if an anatomical cause for CM-I could be proposed from morphometric studies in adult CM-I patients. After conducting a literature search using relevant search terms, two authors screened abstracts for relevance. Full-length articles of primary morphometric studies published in peer-reviewed journals were included. Detailed information regarding methodology and symptomatology, craniocervical instability, syringomyelia, operative effects, and genetics were extracted. Forty-six studies met inclusion criteria, averaging 93.2 CM-I patients and 41.4 healthy controls in size. To obtain measurements, 40 studies utilized MRI and 10 utilized CT imaging, whereas 41 analyzed parameters within the posterior fossa and 20 analyzed parameters of the craniovertebral junction. The most commonly measured parameters included clivus length (n = 30), tonsillar position or descent (n = 28), McRae line length (n = 26), and supraocciput length (n = 26). While certain structural anomalies including reduced clivus length have been implicated in CM-I, there is a lack of consensus on how several other morphometric parameters may or may not contribute to its development. Heterogeneity in presentation with respect to the extent of tonsillar descent suggests alternate methods utilizing morphometric measurements that may help to identify CM-I patients and may benefit future research to better understand underlying pathophysiology and sequelae such as syringomyelia.