Why TP53 status does not associate with clinical endpoints in ovarian cancer: facts and hypotheses

Prognosis of patients with BRCA1-associated ovarian carcinomas depends on TP53 accumulation status in tumor cells

OBJECTIVE

TP53 mutation is the most frequent molecular event in BRCA1-associated ovarian carcinomas. TP53 status may be a confounding factor in the evaluation of clinical importance of other proteins. We aimed to evaluate the clinical significance of BRCA1 mutations with respect to the TP53 accumulation status in 159 high-grade ovarian carcinomas.

METHODS

Statistical analyses were done with the Kaplan-Meier method, log-rank test, the Cox's and logistic regression models for all patients, and in subgroups with and without TP53 accumulation (TP53+ and TP53-, respectively).

RESULTS

Forty of 159 ovarian carcinomas (25.2%) were diagnosed in patients with BRCA1 germline mutations; 102 tumors (64.2%) were TP53+ and 57 (37.8%) were TP53-. Among patients with TP53+ carcinomas, BRCA1 carriers had increased odds of recurrence compared with sporadic cases (HR 2.25, P=0.003; median disease-free survival time 7.7 vs. 18.4months, respectively). In the smaller TP53- subgroup, BRCA1 mutation reduced the risk of death by 46% (HR 0.54, P=0.099, median overall survival time 42.7 vs. 28.1months), but beyond the border of significance. When the TP53 status was not taken into account, BRCA1 mutations did not show any significance, however, there was a trend toward increased odds of complete remission for women with BRCA1 mutations compared to non-carriers (OR 2.47, P=0.064). Taxane-platinum therapy showed advantage over the platinum-cyclophosphamide one in the entire group of patients and in the TP53+ subgroup.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that the TP53 accumulation status determines the prognosis of BRCA1 mutation carriers with high-grade ovarian carcinomas.

The putative oncogene, CRNDE, is a negative prognostic factor in ovarian cancer patients

The CRNDE gene seems to play an oncogenic role in cancers, though its exact function remains unknown. Here, we tried to assess its usefulness as a molecular prognostic marker in ovarian cancer. Based on results of our microarray studies, CRNDE transcripts were further analyzed by Real-Time qPCR-based profiling of their expression. The qPCR study was conducted with the use of personally designed TaqMan assays on 135 frozen tissue sections of ovarian carcinomas from patients treated with platinum compounds and either cyclophosphamide (PC, N = 32) or taxanes (TP, N = 103). Elevated levels of two different CRNDE transcripts were a negative prognostic factor; they increased the risk of death and recurrence in the group of patients treated with TP, but not PC (DNA-damaging agents only). Higher associations were found for overexpression of the short CRNDE splice variant (FJ466686): HR 6.072, 95% CI 1.814-20.32, p = 0.003 (the risk of death); HR 15.53, 95% CI 3.812-63.28, p < 0.001 (the risk of recurrence). Additionally, accumulation of the TP53 protein correlated with decreased expression of both CRNDE transcripts in tumor cells. Our results depict CRNDE as a potential marker of poor prognosis in women with ovarian carcinomas, and suggest that its significance depends on the therapeutic regimen used.

p19(INK4d) mRNA and protein expression as new prognostic factors in ovarian cancer patients

p19(INK4d) (CDKN2D) is a negative regulator of the cell cycle. Little is known of its role in cancer development and prognosis. We aimed to evaluate the clinical significance of p19(INK4d) expression in ovarian carcinomas with respect to the TP53 accumulation status, as well as the frequency of CDKN2D mutations. p19(INK4d) and TP53 expression was evaluated immunohistochemically in 445 ovarian carcinomas: 246 patients were treated with platinum-cyclophosphamide (PC/PAC), while 199 were treated with taxane-platinum agents (TP). CDKN2D gene expression (mRNA) was examined in 106 carcinomas, while CDKN2D mutations in 68 tumors. Uni- and multivariate statistical analyses (logistic regression and the Cox proportional hazards model) were performed for patient groups divided according to the chemotherapeutic regimen administered, and in subgroups with and without TP53 accumulation. High p19(INK4d) expression increased the risk of death, but only in patients with the TP53-negative carcinomas (HR 1.61, P = 0.049 for PC/PAC-treated patients, HR 2.00, P = 0.015 for TP-treated patients). This result was confirmed by the mRNA analysis (HR 4.24, P = 0.001 for TP-treated group). High p19(INK4d) protein expression associated with adverse clinicopathological factors. We found no alterations in the CDKN2D gene; the c.90C>G (p.R30R; rs1968445) polymorphism was detected in 10% of tumors. Our results suggest that p19(INK4d) expression is a poor prognostic factor in ovarian cancer patients. Analyses of tumor groups according to the TP53 accumulation status facilitate the identification of cancer biomarkers.

Nuclear survivin expression is a positive prognostic factor in taxane-platinum-treated ovarian cancer patients

Background

Survivin is an inhibitor of apoptosis and a regulator of mitotic progression. TP53 protein is a negative transcriptional regulator of survivin. The aim of our study was to evaluate the clinical significance of survivin expression in advanced stages ovarian cancer with respect to the TP53 status.

Methods

Survivin and TP53 expression was evaluated immunohistochemically in 435 archival samples of ovarian carcinomas (244 patients were treated with platinum/cyclophosphamide-PC/PAC; 191-with taxane-platinum (TP) agents). Univariate and multivariate statistical analyses were performed in patients groups divided according to the administered chemotherapeutic regimen, and in subgroups with and without TP53 accumulation (TP53+ and TP53-, respectively).

Results

Nuclear and cytoplasmic survivin expression was observed in 92% and 74% of the carcinomas, respectively. In patients treated with TP, high nuclear survivin expression decreased the risk of disease recurrence and death, and increased the probability of high platinum sensitivity (p < 0.01), but only in the TP53(+) group, and not in the TP53(-) group.

Conclusions

It appears that TP53 status determines the clinical importance of nuclear survivin expression in taxane-platinum treated ovarian cancer patients.

TP53, BCL-2 and BAX analysis in 199 ovarian cancer patients treated with taxane-platinum regimens

OBJECTIVE

In cell line studies, BCL-2 and BAX proteins interfere with cancer response to taxanes. This issue has not received much attention with regard to taxane-platinum (TP)-treated ovarian cancer patients.

METHODS

We evaluated prognostic/predictive significance of BCL-2 and BAX with regard to TP53 status. Immunohistochemical analysis was performed on 199 ovarian carcinomas FIGO stage IIB-IV treated with TP; the results were analyzed by the Cox and logistic regression models.

RESULTS

Clinicopathological parameters (residual tumor size, FIGO stage and/or tumor grade, but not patient's age) were the only or the strongest predictors of patient's outcome. Platinum highly sensitive response showed a positive association with TP53 accumulation (p=0.045). As in our previously published analysis on platinum-cyclophosphamide-treated group, complete remission showed a borderline negative (paradoxic) association with high BAX expression in the whole group (p=0.058) and with BCL-2 expression in the TP53(-) group (p=0.058).

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest that TP53, BCL-2 and BAX proteins carry some predictive potential in taxane-platinum-treated ovarian cancer patients, auxiliary to clinicopathological factors. We have confirmed on another patient group that clinical importance of BCL-2 may depend on TP53 status.

TP53 status and taxane-platinum versus platinum-based therapy in ovarian cancer patients: a non-randomized retrospective study

Background

Taxane-platinum therapy (TP) has replaced platinum-based therapy (PC or PAC, DNA damaging chemotherapy) in the postoperative treatment of ovarian cancer patients; however, it is not always effective. TP53 protein plays a differential role in response to DNA-damaging agents and taxanes. We sought to define profiles of patients who benefit the most from TP and also of those who can be treated with PC.

Methods

We compared the effectiveness of PC/PAC (n = 253) and TP (n = 199) with respect to tumor TP53 accumulation in ovarian cancer patients with FIGO stage IIB-IV disease; this was a non-randomized retrospective study. Immunohistochemical analysis was performed on 452 archival tumors; univariate and multivariate analysis by the Cox's and logistic regression models was performed in all patients and in subgroups with [TP53(+)] and without TP53 accumulation [TP53(-)].

Results

The advantage of taxane-platinum therapy over platinum-based therapy was seen in the TP53(+), and not in the TP53(-) group. In the TP53(+) group taxane-platinum therapy enhanced the probability of complete remission (p = .018), platinum sensitivity (p = .014), platinum highly sensitive response (p = .038) and longer survival (OS, p = .008). Poor tumor differentiation diminished the advantage from taxane-platinum therapy in the TP53(+) group. In the TP53(-) group PC/PAC was at least equally efficient as taxane-platinum therapy and it enhanced the chance of platinum highly sensitive response (p = .010). However, in the TP53(-) group taxane-platinum therapy possibly diminished the risk of death in patients over 53 yrs (p = .077). Among factors that positively interacted with taxane-platinum therapy in some analyses were endometrioid and clear cell type, FIGO III stage, bulky residual tumor, more advanced age of patient and moderate tumor differentiation.

Conclusion

Our results suggest that taxane-platinum therapy is particularly justified in patients with TP53(+) tumors or older than 53 years. In the group of patients ≤53 yrs and with TP53(-) tumors platinum-based therapy is possibly equally efficient. We provide hints for planning randomized trials to verify these observations.