Inborn errors of mitochondrial acyl-coenzyme a metabolism: acyl-CoA biology meets the clinic

Whole exome sequencing reveals a dual diagnosis of BCAP31-related syndrome and glutaric aciduria III

Background

Biochemical testing is a common first-tier approach in the setting of genetic evaluation of patients with unexplained developmental delay. However, results can be unclear, and a plan for second-tier analysis must be determined based on the patient's biochemical results and clinical presentation - in many cases, triggering a diagnostic odyssey.

Case presentation

A male patient from the United States presenting with unexplained developmental delay, microcephaly, hypotonia, and feeding difficulties was referred for clinical genetic evaluation at age 8 months. Biochemical testing revealed an isolated marked elevation of glutaric acid on urine organic acid profile, without elevations of related metabolites. Further testing included GCDH sequencing, a neurometabolic gene panel, chromosomal microarray, Prader Willi/Angelman testing, and lysosomal disease enzyme panel, all of which were non-diagnostic. The patient had persistent developmental delay and hypotonia, dystonia, sensorineural hearing loss, and abnormal brain myelination on magnetic resonance imaging. Whole exome sequencing (WES) was performed and revealed a dual diagnosis of glutaric aciduria III (GA III) and BCAP31-related disorder, an X-linked intellectual disability syndrome, caused by a novel pathogenic variant.

Conclusions

GA III has historically been considered clinically benign, with few reported cases. This patient's presenting symptoms were similar to those commonly seen in GA I and GA II, however the biochemical abnormalities were not consistent with these disorders, prompting additional molecular and biochemical testing. Ultimately, WES confirmed a diagnosis of BCAP31-related syndrome, a rare neurological disorder, which explained the patient's presenting symptoms. WES also identified a secondary diagnosis of GA III. We present a patient with two rare genetic conditions, highlighting the importance of deep phenotyping and the utility of WES in the setting of a patient with dual genetic diagnoses.

Brain CoA and Acetyl CoA Metabolism in Mechanisms of Neurodegeneration

The processes of biotransformation of pantothenic acid (Pan) in the biosynthesis and hydrolysis of CoA, key role of pantothenate kinase (PANK) and CoA synthetase (CoASY) in the formation of the priority mitochondrial pool of CoA, with a high metabolic turnover of the coenzyme and limited transport of Pan across the blood-brain barrier are considered. The system of acetyl-CoA, a secondary messenger, which is the main substrate of acetylation processes including formation of N-acetyl aspartate and acetylcholine, post-translational modification of histones, predetermines protection of the neurons against degenerative signals and cholinergic neurotransmission. Biochemical mechanisms of neurodegenerative syndromes in the cases of PANK and CoASY defects, and the possibility of correcting of CoA biosynthesis in the models with knockouts of these enzymes have been described. The data of a post-mortem study of the brains from the patients with Huntington's and Alzheimer's diseases are presented, proving Pan deficiency in the CNS, which is especially pronounced in the pathognomonic neurostructures. In the frontal cortex of the patients with Parkinson's disease, combined immunofluorescence of anti-CoA- and anti-tau protein was detected, reflecting CoAlation during dimerization of the tau protein and its redox sensitivity. Redox activity and antioxidant properties of the precursors of CoA biosynthesis were confirmed in vitro with synaptosomal membranes and mitochondria during modeling of aluminum neurotoxicity accompanied by the decrease in the level of CoA in CNS. The ability of CoA biosynthesis precursors to stabilize glutathione pool in neurostructures, in particular, in the hippocampus, is considered as a pathogenetic protection mechanism during exposure to neurotoxins, development of neuroinflammation and neurodegeneration, and justifies the combined use of Pan derivatives (for example, D-panthenol) and glutathione precursors (N-acetylcysteine). Taking into account the discovery of new functions of CoA (redox-dependent processes of CoAlation of proteins, possible association of oxidative stress and deficiency of Pan (CoA) in neurodegenerative pathology), it seems promising to study bioavailability and biotransformation of Pan derivatives, in particular of D-panthenol, 4'-phospho-pantetheine, its acylated derivatives, and compositions with redox pharmacological compounds, are promising for their potential use as etiopathogenetic agents.

Relief of CoA sequestration and restoration of mitochondrial function in a mouse model of propionic acidemia

Propionic acidemia (PA, OMIM 606054) is a devastating inborn error of metabolism arising from mutations that reduce the activity of the mitochondrial enzyme propionyl-CoA carboxylase (PCC). The defects in PCC reduce the concentrations of nonesterified coenzyme A (CoASH), thus compromising mitochondrial function and disrupting intermediary metabolism. Here, we use a hypomorphic PA mouse model to test the effectiveness of BBP-671 in correcting the metabolic imbalances in PA. BBP-671 is a high-affinity allosteric pantothenate kinase activator that counteracts feedback inhibition of the enzyme to increase the intracellular concentration of CoA. Liver CoASH and acetyl-CoA are depressed in PA mice and BBP-671 treatment normalizes the cellular concentrations of these two key cofactors. Hepatic propionyl-CoA is also reduced by BBP-671 leading to an improved intracellular C3:C2-CoA ratio. Elevated plasma C3:C2-carnitine ratio and methylcitrate, hallmark biomarkers of PA, are significantly reduced by BBP-671. The large elevations of malate and α-ketoglutarate in the urine of PA mice are biomarkers for compromised tricarboxylic acid cycle activity and BBP-671 therapy reduces the amounts of both metabolites. Furthermore, the low survival of PA mice is restored to normal by BBP-671. These data show that BBP-671 relieves CoA sequestration, improves mitochondrial function, reduces plasma PA biomarkers, and extends the lifespan of PA mice, providing the preclinical foundation for the therapeutic potential of BBP-671.

The multiple facets of acetyl-CoA metabolism: Energetics, biosynthesis, regulation, acylation and inborn errors

Acetyl-coenzyme A (Ac-CoA) is a core metabolite with essential roles throughout cell physiology. These functions can be classified into energetics, biosynthesis, regulation and acetylation of large and small molecules. Ac-CoA is essential for oxidative metabolism of glucose, fatty acids, most amino acids, ethanol, and of free acetate generated by endogenous metabolism or by gut bacteria. Ac-CoA cannot cross lipid bilayers, but acetyl groups from Ac-CoA can shuttle across membranes as part of carrier molecules like citrate or acetylcarnitine, or as free acetate or ketone bodies. Ac-CoA is the basic unit of lipid biosynthesis, providing essentially all of the carbon for the synthesis of fatty acids and of isoprenoid-derived compounds including cholesterol, coenzyme Q and dolichols. High levels of Ac-CoA in hepatocytes stimulate lipid biosynthesis, ketone body production and the diversion of pyruvate metabolism towards gluconeogenesis and away from oxidation; low levels exert opposite effects. Acetylation changes the properties of molecules. Acetylation is necessary for the synthesis of acetylcholine, acetylglutamate, acetylaspartate and N-acetyl amino sugars, and to metabolize/eliminate some xenobiotics. Acetylation is a major post-translational modification of proteins. Different types of protein acetylation occur. The most-studied form occurs at the epsilon nitrogen of lysine residues. In histones, lysine acetylation can alter gene transcription. Acetylation of other proteins has diverse, often incompletely-documented effects. Inborn errors related to Ac-CoA feature a broad spectrum of metabolic, neurological and other features. To date, a small number of studies of animals with inborn errors of CoA thioesters has included direct measurement of acyl-CoAs. These studies have shown that low levels of tissue Ac-CoA correlate with the development of clinical signs, hinting that shortage of Ac-CoA may be a recurrent theme in these conditions. Low levels of Ac-CoA could potentially disrupt any of its roles.

Cardiac-specific deficiency of 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl coenzyme A lyase in mice causes cardiomyopathy and a distinct pattern of acyl-coenzyme A-related biomarkers

Deficiency of 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl-CoA (HMG-CoA) lyase (HL) is an autosomal recessive inborn error of acyl-CoA metabolism affecting the last step of leucine degradation. Patients with HL deficiency (HLD) can develop a potentially fatal cardiomyopathy. We created mice with cardiomyocyte-specific HLD (HLHKO mice), inducing Cre recombinase-mediated deletion of exon 2 at two months of age. HLHKO mice survive, but develop left ventricular hypertrophy by 9 months. Also, within minutes after intraperitoneal injection of the leucine metabolite 2-ketoisocaproate (KIC), they show transient left ventricular hypocontractility and dilation. Leucine-related acyl-CoAs were elevated in HLHKO heart (e.g., HMG-CoA, 34.0 ± 4.4 nmol/g versus 0.211 ± 0.041 in controls, p < 0.001; 3-methylcrotonyl-CoA, 5.84 ± 0.69 nmol/g versus 0.282 ± 0.043, p < 0.001; isovaleryl-CoA, 1.86 ± 0.30 nmol/g versus 0.024 ± 0.014, p < 0.01), a similar pattern to that in liver of mice with hepatic HL deficiency. After KIC loading, HMG-CoA levels in HLHKO heart were higher than under basal conditions, as were the ratios of HMG-CoA/acetyl-CoA and of HMG-CoA/succinyl-CoA. In contrast to the high levels of multiple leucine-related acyl-CoAs, biomarkers in urine and plasma of HLHKO mice show isolated hyper-3-methylglutaconic aciduria (700.8 ± 48.4 mmol/mol creatinine versus 37.6 ± 2.4 in controls, p < 0.001), and elevated C5-hydroxyacylcarnitine in plasma (0.248 ± 0.014 μmol/L versus 0.048 ± 0.005 in controls, p < 0.001). Mice with liver-specific HLD were compared, and showed normal echocardiographic findings and normal acyl-CoA profiles in heart. This study of nonhepatic tissue-specific HLD outside of liver reveals organ-specific origins of diagnostic biomarkers for HLD in blood and urine and shows that mouse cardiac HL is essential for myocardial function in a cell-autonomous, organ-autonomous fashion.

Propionic acidemia in mice: Liver acyl-CoA levels and clinical course

Propionic acidemia (PA) is a severe autosomal recessive metabolic disease caused by deficiency of propionyl-CoA carboxylase (PCC). We studied PA transgenic (Pat) mice that lack endogenous PCC but express a hypoactive human PCCA cDNA, permitting their survival. Pat cohorts followed from 3 to 20 weeks of age showed growth failure and lethal crises of lethargy and hyperammonemia, commoner in males (27/50, 54%) than in females (11/52, 21%) and occurring mainly in Pat mice with the most severe growth deficiency. Groups of Pat mice were studied under basal conditions (P-Ba mice) and during acute crises (P-Ac). Plasma acylcarnitines in P-Ba mice, compared to controls, showed markedly elevated C3- and low C2-carnitine, with a further decrease in C2-carnitine in P-Ac mice. These clinical and biochemical findings resemble those of human PA patients. Liver acyl-CoA measurements showed that propionyl-CoA was a minor species in controls (propionyl-CoA/acetyl-CoA ratio, 0.09). In contrast, in P-Ba liver the ratio was 1.4 and in P-Ac liver, 13, with concurrent reductions of the levels of acetyl-CoA and other acyl-CoAs. Plasma ammonia levels in control, P-Ba and P-Ac mice were 109 ± 10, 311 ± 48 and 551 ± 61 μmol/L respectively. Four-week administration to Pat mice, of carglumate (N-carbamyl-L-glutamic acid), an analogue of N-carbamylglutamate, the product of the only acyl-CoA-requiring reaction directly related to the urea cycle, was associated with increased food consumption, improved growth and absence of fatal crises. Pat mice showed many similarities to human PA patients and provide a useful model for studying tissue pathophysiology and treatment outcomes.

Pantothenate kinase activation relieves coenzyme A sequestration and improves mitochondrial function in mice with propionic acidemia

[Figure: see text].

Coenzyme a Biochemistry: From Neurodevelopment to Neurodegeneration

Coenzyme A (CoA) is an essential cofactor in all living organisms. It is involved in a large number of biochemical processes functioning either as an activator of molecules with carbonyl groups or as a carrier of acyl moieties. Together with its thioester derivatives, it plays a central role in cell metabolism, post-translational modification, and gene expression. Furthermore, recent studies revealed a role for CoA in the redox regulation by the S-thiolation of cysteine residues in cellular proteins. The intracellular concentration and distribution in different cellular compartments of CoA and its derivatives are controlled by several extracellular stimuli such as nutrients, hormones, metabolites, and cellular stresses. Perturbations of the biosynthesis and homeostasis of CoA and/or acyl-CoA are connected with several pathological conditions, including cancer, myopathies, and cardiomyopathies. In the most recent years, defects in genes involved in CoA production and distribution have been found in patients affected by rare forms of neurodegenerative and neurodevelopmental disorders. In this review, we will summarize the most relevant aspects of CoA cellular metabolism, their role in the pathogenesis of selected neurodevelopmental and neurodegenerative disorders, and recent advancements in the search for therapeutic approaches for such diseases.

Glutaric acidemia type 1: Treatment and outcome of 168 patients over three decades

Glutaric acidemia type 1 (GA1) is a disorder of cerebral organic acid metabolism resulting from biallelic mutations of GCDH. Without treatment, GA1 causes striatal degeneration in >80% of affected children before two years of age. We analyzed clinical, biochemical, and developmental outcomes for 168 genotypically diverse GA1 patients managed at a single center over 31 years, here separated into three treatment cohorts: children in Cohort I (n = 60; DOB 2006-2019) were identified by newborn screening (NBS) and treated prospectively using a standardized protocol that included a lysine-free, arginine-enriched metabolic formula, enteral l-carnitine (100 mg/kg•day), and emergency intravenous (IV) infusions of dextrose, saline, and l-carnitine during illnesses; children in Cohort II (n = 57; DOB 1989-2018) were identified by NBS and treated with natural protein restriction (1.0-1.3 g/kg•day) and emergency IV infusions; children in Cohort III (n = 51; DOB 1973-2016) did not receive NBS or special diet. The incidence of striatal degeneration in Cohorts I, II, and III was 7%, 47%, and 90%, respectively (p < .0001). No neurologic injuries occurred after 19 months of age. Among uninjured children followed prospectively from birth (Cohort I), measures of growth, nutritional sufficiency, motor development, and cognitive function were normal. Adherence to metabolic formula and l-carnitine supplementation in Cohort I declined to 12% and 32%, respectively, by age 7 years. Cessation of strict dietary therapy altered plasma amino acid and carnitine concentrations but resulted in no serious adverse outcomes. In conclusion, neonatal diagnosis of GA1 coupled to management with lysine-free, arginine-enriched metabolic formula and emergency IV infusions during the first two years of life is safe and effective, preventing more than 90% of striatal injuries while supporting normal growth and psychomotor development. The need for dietary interventions and emergency IV therapies beyond early childhood is uncertain.

Deficiency of 3-hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenase (BDH1) in mice causes low ketone body levels and fatty liver during fasting

d-3-Hydroxy-n-butyrate dehydrogenase (BDH1; EC 1.1.1.30), encoded by BDH1, catalyzes the reversible reduction of acetoacetate (AcAc) to 3-hydroxybutyrate (3HB). BDH1 is the last enzyme of hepatic ketogenesis and the first enzyme of ketolysis. The hereditary deficiency of BDH1 has not yet been described in humans. To define the features of BDH1 deficiency in a mammalian model, we generated Bdh1-deficient mice (Bdh1 KO mice). Under normal housing conditions, with unrestricted access to food, Bdh1 KO mice showed normal growth, appearance, behavior, and fertility. In contrast, fasting produced marked differences from controls. Although Bdh1 KO mice survive fasting for at least 48 hours, blood 3HB levels remained very low in Bdh1 KO mice, and despite AcAc levels moderately higher than in controls, total ketone body levels in Bdh1 KO mice were significantly lower than in wild-type (WT) mice after 16, 24, and 48 hours fasting. Hepatic fat content at 24 hours of fasting was greater in Bdh1 KO than in WT mice. Systemic BDH1 deficiency was well tolerated under normal fed conditions but manifested during fasting with a marked increase in AcAc/3HB ratio and hepatic steatosis, indicating the importance of ketogenesis for lipid energy balance in the liver.