Rhythm annotation and interobserver reproducibility of measures of heart rate variability

Inter- and intra-researcher reproducibility of heart rate variability parameters in three human cohorts

Heart rate variability (HRV) is a valid and non-invasive indicator of cardiac autonomic nervous system functioning. Short-term HRV recordings (e.g., 10 min long) produce data that usually is manually processed. Researcher subjective decision-making on data processing could produce inter- or intra-researcher differences whose magnitude has not been previously quantified in three independent human cohorts. This study examines the inter- and intra-researcher reproducibility of HRV parameters (i.e., the influence of R–R interval selection by different researchers and by the same researcher in different moments on the quantification of HRV parameters, respectively) derived from short-term recordings in a cohort of children with overweight/obesity, young adults and middle-age adults. Participants were recruited from 3 different studies: 107 children (10.03 ± 1.13 years, 58% male), 132 young adults (22.22 ± 2.20 years, 33% males) and 73 middle-aged adults (53.62 ± 5.18 years, 48% males). HRV was measured using a Polar RS800CX heart rate monitor. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) ranged from 0.703 to 0.989 and from 0.950 to 0.998 for inter-and intra-researcher reproducibility, respectively. Limits of agreement for HRV parameters were higher for the inter-researcher processing compared with the intra-researcher processing. On average, the intra-researcher differences were 31%, 62%, and 80% smaller than the inter-researchers differences based on Coefficient of Variation in children, young and middle-aged adults, respectively. Our study provides the quantification of the inter-researcher and intra-researcher differences in three independent human cohorts, which could elicit some clinical relevant differences for HRV parameters. Based on our findings, we recommend the HRV data signal processing to be performed always by the same trained researcher and we postulate a development of algorithms for an automatic ECG selection.

Interobserver reproducibility of heart rate variability in children (the Bogalusa Heart Study)

Changes in time and frequency domain measures of heart rate variability appear to correlate with morbidity and mortality in patients with congenital heart disease. This study demonstrates that these measures are highly reproducible in children, a finding that has been previously described only in adults.

Consistency of multicenter measurements of heart rate variability in survivors of acute myocardial infarction

Heart rate variability (HRV) analysis from 24-hour ambulatory ECG has been widely used in risk stratification of patients after myocardial infarction (MI). The accuracy of HRV assessment is known to potentially vary when different commercial systems are used. However, the consistency of HRV measurements has never been fully investigated. Twenty-six post-MI patients (mean age 59 +/- 8 years, 22 men) were studied, of whom 13 succumbed to sudden cardiac death (SCD) within 1 year and 13 remained alive for at least 3 years (MI survivors). Each patient had a 24-hour Holter ECG recorded before hospital discharge. HRV analysis was performed four times from the same recordings using three different Holter tape analysis systems (Marquette, Reynolds, and CardioData) by four independent operators (CardioData system was used twice, once in the United Kingdom and once in the United States). Mean normal-to-normal RR intervals (mNN) and 3 HRV parameters (SDNN, RMSSD, and HRV triangular index [HRVi]) were derived from each recording. The consistency of mNN and HRV measurements was evaluated by coefficient of variance (CV) and by the Bland-Altman method. The results demonstrated that (1) all indices measured by different systems were statistically similar (P = NS) except the measurement of RMSSD (P = 0.01), (2) the measurements of mNN were highly reproducible with a maximum mean difference of 1.8 +/- 13.8 ms and maximum limits of agreement from -14.6 to +15.6 ms. The maximum mean differences were--1.8 +/- 1.4 unit and 4.4 +/- 9.6 ms for HRVi and SDNN, respectively, and RMSSD was less reproducible with a maximum mean difference of--11.1 +/- 11.5 ms, and limits of agreement from -16.2 to +9.6 ms; and (3) the consistency of mNN (CV 0.9% +/- 0.9%) was significantly higher than that of HRVi, SDNN, and RMSSD (P < 0.0001). The consistency of HRVi was similar to that of SDNN (4.8% +/- 2.1% vs 5.7% +/- 4.8%, P = 0.4), and the consistency of RMSSD (26.6% +/- 13.3%) was significantly lower than that of the other measurements (P < 0.00001). In conclusion, the measurements of mNN by different analytical systems are the most consistent among the parameters studied. The global 24-hour measurements of HRV (SDNN and HRVi) are highly reproducible, whereas the measurement of short-term HRV components (RMSSD) is significantly less reproducible.