Risk of venous thromboembolism with third-generation oral contraceptives: A review

Contraceptive Recommendations for Women with Immune-Mediated Inflammatory Diseases: A Delphi Consensus

INTRODUCTION

Immune-mediated inflammatory diseases (IMID) are a group of disorders characterized by chronic inflammation caused by an altered immune regulation in targeted organs or systems. IMID itself could have an implied increased risk of venous thromboembolism (VTE) and this risk varies throughout the course of the disease as well as with some contraceptive methods and treatments. The aim of this study was to present some key considerations in relation to contraception in women with IMID.

METHODS

This was an exploratory study conducted in Spain following the online modified Delphi methodology with two rounds of participation. Four questionnaires were designed for each medical specialty: gastroenterology, rheumatology, dermatology, and gynecology. Each questionnaire was divided in three domains: general recommendations about IMID, specific recommendations, and contraceptive methods for patients with IMID. A 5-point Likert scale measured agreement with each statement, with an 80% agreement threshold. Following the first round, the percentage of each response was calculated for every item. Subsequently, a second round was conducted to reach a consensus on the items for which discrepancies were observed.

RESULTS

A total of 52 and 50 experts participated in the first and second round, respectively. Participants agreed on the existence of a higher risk of VTE in inflammatory bowel diseases, psoriasis, and rheumatoid arthritis diseases. Regarding recommendations for contraceptive methods in patients with IMID, experts considered the hormonal intrauterine device (IUD) as a first-line contraceptive (80.0%) and low doses of progesterone-only pills if the latter is not recommended (88.0%). Most of the interviewees concurred on the importance of the patients' contraceptive needs during the disease course (98.1%).

CONCLUSION

Raising awareness and promoting a multidisciplinary relationship among the physicians involved in the therapeutic decisions by considering all the risk factors when prescribing a contraceptive method is important to prevent VTE in women with IMID.

Cerebral venous sinus thrombosis due to desogestrel intake in a young lady: A case report

Cerebral Venous Sinus Thrombosis (CVST) is a subtype of venous thromboembolism, which occurs in the dural venous sinuses. Blockage of the venous drainage of the brain leads to the development of hemorrhages. Strokes can hence develop in any individual, irrespective of age or sex. CVST is a very serious condition requiring immediate thrombolysis to prevent residual neurological deficits. We report the case of a lady aged 25 years, who presented to the emergency department with a severe diffuse headache for 4 days, associated with vomiting. This was followed by multiple episodes of seizures and altered sensorium the previous day. She had been taking desogestrel for the past 2 months. On examination, the patient was unconscious and febrile (102.8 F). On admission, Glasgow Coma Scale score of E2V2M3 and bilateral extensor plantar response were noted. Signs of meningeal irritation were absent. Her pupils were mid-dilated, sluggishly reactive to light, and papilledema was present bilaterally. Based on imaging studies, she was diagnosed with a case of CVST. Her homocysteine levels were elevated. She recovered on appropriate treatment and was discharged on Ryle's feeding tube after 26 days of hospital stay with a Glasgow Coma Scale score of E4V5M6 and a flexor plantar response. The case emphasizes the need to rule out CVST in young adult females on oral contraceptive pills (OCP) presenting with severe neurological dysfunction. Vigilant screening, clinical suspicion and timely management can help cut down the associated mortality and morbidity in such cases.

Effect of Age on Oral Contraceptive-Induced Venous Thrombosis

This study was undertaken to investigate the effect of age on oral contraceptive-induced venous thrombosis. All women seen in the University of Padua Department of Medical and Surgical Science who had had two courses of oral contraceptive therapy at different ages were included. A total of 28 subjects met these criteria. Fifteen patients had a congenital or acquired prothrombotic condition, whereas 13 women were normal subjects. The mean age at which thrombosis occurred was 33.3 and 36.3 years for women with or without a prothrombotic condition, respectively. The ages during which the women remained asymptomatic were 23.1 and 23.3 years for women with or without a predisposing defect, respectively. Thrombosis occurred, during the second course of oral contraceptive therapy, after the mean duration of 6.5 cycles or 18.4 cycles in women with or without prothrombotic defects, respectively. During the asymptomatic course, approximately the same number of women took old progestins or third-generation compounds. On the contrary, during the second period, 21 of 28 women took progestins with third-generation compounds. Age seems to plays an important role in oral contraceptive-induced venous thrombosis. In normal women, thrombosis occurred after a greater number of oral contraceptive cycles as compared with the women with prothrombotic defects. Because the majority of women took preparations that contained third-generation progestins during the second course of therapy, concomitant contributing effects of these compounds cannot be excluded.

Chronic pulmonary embolism in a young athletic woman

Exercise-induced dyspnea (EID) is a common complaint in young athletes. Exercise-induced bronchospasm (EIB) is the most common cause of EID in healthy athletes, but it is important to recognize more serious pathology. Herein we present the case of an 18-year-old woman with a 1.5-year history of EID. She had been treated for EIB without relief. Her arterial oxygen saturation was 88% during exercise testing. Computed tomographic angiography to assess for vascular abnormalities identified a large thrombus in the main pulmonary trunk. Symptoms markedly improved with therapeutic anticoagulation. Massive pulmonary embolus is an exceedingly rare etiology of exertional dyspnea in young athletes. Hypoxemia during exercise testing was an important clue that something more ominous was lurking that required definitive diagnosis.

Family history unawareness of blood clot risk: links to misdiagnoses and illness uncertainties in personal and expert realms

The difficulty of diagnosing blood clots makes salient the question, "What role does family history awareness have for guiding lay and expert actions?" The authors examine the in-depth life reflection interviews of 20 women who experienced a first venous blood clot between the ages of 18 and 50 years, identifying causal attributions the women made for thrombosis after the event. Twelve participants described an understanding of the cascade of events linked to thrombosis, revealing that there is seldom a single cause. The other eight identified belief in a single determining cause for their thrombosis. The authors reflect on the symptoms the women experienced during the course of the clotting event, patterns of care that they executed to self-manage their blood clot, and their misdiagnoses associated with symptoms and care. The women recalled the patterns of care received through formal health care systems and the reported misdiagnoses linked to these interactions. The recollections reveal that the subtle nature of venous blood clot symptoms contributes to lay and expert misdiagnoses. Use of antibiotics and pain killers in the wake of misdiagnosis masks symptoms, contributing to costly delays in accurate diagnoses. Four women were aware of a family history of clotting when the event occurred, 13 had such a history but lacked awareness until the clotting event, and three had no known history. Among women with awareness of their family history, blood clot diagnosis occurred sooner, promoting survival and efficiencies in health care. Implications for communicating about family history of thrombosis are considered.

Estrogen administration enhances thrombin generation in rats

Venous thrombosis is a serious disorder that may be fatal if complicated by pulmonary embolism. Venous thrombosis is usually related to one of three factors: reduced blood flow, changes in vessel wall integrity, or changes in the blood composition. Factors leading to thrombosis are classified as either genetic or acquired. Puerperium and oral contraceptives are examples of the acquired factors. The risk of thrombosis during pregnancy is high compared to that in the overall population,. however, this increases by three to five times in puerperium. Deep vein thrombosis (DVT) complicated by pulmonary thromboembolism (PE) is considered the leading cause of maternal death in the United States and Europe [Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 164 (1991) 603; Obstet. Gynecol. 84 (1994) 240] and the third cause in Japan [M Ishikawa, Maternal mortality and pulmonary thromboembolism. Study on maternal mortality in Japan. Report from the Ministry of Health of Japan in Maternal and Child Health Research, 1996. p. 123-128]. Patients without history of familial thrombophilia have 14-fold higher risk of DVT during puerperium [Thromb. Haemost. 25 (1999) 610]. Little is known about the underlying mechanism of thrombotic disorders in puerperium. It is recognized that oral contraceptive estrogen enhances the risk of DVT [Am. J. Epidemiol. 133 (1991) 32]. However, there is little research regarding the relation between estrogen and blood coagulation, although it is known that plasma estrogen reaches extremely high levels near term. We assume that high-level plasma estrogen plays an important role in the blood coagulation activity that results in the occurrence of DVT. To assess this likely association, we studied the effects of high estrogen levels on coagulation in rat plasma.

Effect of four oral contraceptives on hemostatic parameters

This is the first double-blind, controlled, randomized study comparing the effect of different estrogen components in oral contraceptives (OCs) on hemostasis variables. Four groups of 25 women each were treated for six cycles with monophasic combinations containing 21 tablets with either 30 microg ethinylestradiol (EE) + 2 mg dienogest (DNG) (30EE/DNG), 20 microg EE + 2 mg DNG (20EE/DNG), 10 microg EE + 2 mg estradiol valerate (EV) + 2 mg DNG (EE/EV/DNG) or 20 microg EE + 100 microg levonorgestrel (LNG) (EE/LNG). Blood samples were taken on Days 21-26 of the control cycle and on Days 18-21 of the first, third and sixth treatment cycle. Treatment with all four OCs caused an increase in levels of fibrinogen, prothrombin fragment 1+2, D-dimer, plasminogen, plasmin-antiplasmin complex and an increase in protein C activity, a decrease in antithrombin activity, tissue-plasminogen activator (t-PA) and plasminogen activator inhibitor (PAI), and a slight decrease in the sensitivity to activated protein C, but no significant change in that of the thrombin-antithrombin complex. In users of the DNG-containing OCs, the reduction in total and free protein S, and in t-PA and PAI was dependent on the EE dose, while factor VII activity was elevated, but not significantly different from EE/LNG. The results are in agreement with those of previous studies. The effects of EE/EV/DNG on total and free protein S and on t-PA and PAI were lower than those of 20EE/DNG, suggesting that the impact of 2 mg EV on several hemostasis variables is less than that of 10 microg EE. The results show an antagonistic effect of LNG on the EE-induced rise of factor VII activity and fragment 1+2 and on the EE-dependent reduction of total and free protein S.

Sex and gender issues and venous thromboembolism

At least 250,000 episodes of VTE leading to hospitalization or death are estimated to occur in the United States each year. A number of clinical and demographic risk factors for VTE are recognized,with the latter including both age and race. Overall,the incidence of VTE does not appear to vary significantly by sex, as evidenced by a lack of consistency in the magnitude and even direction of effect of sex in a variety of epidemiologic studies of varying design. Several studies have shown a higher incidence among women than men during childbearing age. The issue of a gender effect on the natural history of VTE has not been well studied. The main influence of gender on VTE is the relationship between female gender and several well-recognized clinical risk factors for VTE:oral contraceptive use, hormone replacement therapy, estrogen receptor modulator therapy, and pregnancy. Hormonal therapies are associated with a twofold to threefold increase in VTE incidence. Risk is higher with some formulations than others, during initial use, and among women who are obese, smoke, or have one of several forms of heritable thrombophilia. The pregnant state is associated with a threefold to fivefold increase in VTE risk, and thromboembolism is a major cause of peripartum death. Heritable thrombophilias are also important co-determinants of VTE risk in pregnancy. The mechanisms through which pregnancy and hormonal therapies increase VTE risk have not been definitively established, but hormonal effects on levels of coagulation and anticoagulation factors likely play a role. Venous compression and venous injury also contribute to increased risk during pregnancy and the puerperium. Approaches to diagnosis of VTE in the pregnant woman are largely the same as in the nonpregnant patient, but special treatment considerations do apply. Warfarin is embryopathic, particularly between the 6th and 12th weeks of pregnancy, and should be avoided in favor or heparin or low-molecular weight heparin when treatment of the pregnant woman is necessary. Guidelines have been published to assist the clinician in decision making about prophylaxis of pregnant women at increased risk or pregnancy-related or post-partum VTE.

Changes in prescription patterns of oral contraceptives in a northern Italian province: relation with venous thromboembolism

Oral contraceptives (OC) are a definite risk for venous thrombosis. It is commonly accepted that they cause a fourfold increased risk of thrombosis compared to non-users. The prescription patterns were evaluated from 1990 to 2000 in a northern Italian province (province of Padua). This province is typical of other northern Italian provinces. As a consequence, it can be safely assumed that the observations gathered may apply to the entire north of Italy. During these years, a sharp increase in the use of OC was noted. Furthermore, around 1995 to 1996, a marked switch toward the use of preparations containing third-generation progestins was noted. During the past few years of the observation period, approximately 80% of women use preparations containing third-generation progestins. During the same period, an increased incidence of episodes of venous thromboembolism (VTE) was noted. The increase in the prevalence of VTE episodes appeared to be proportional to the increased use of OC, regardless of the type of progestin contained in the oral contraceptive preparations.

Tentative guidelines and practical suggestions to avoid venous thromboembolism during oral contraceptive therapy

Oral contraceptive therapy (OCT) is widely used in the world. It is usually safe and effective but side effects are occasionally seen. Venous thromboembolism is one of the most feared side effects. To avoid this complication adequate guidelines are needed. These have to take into account family history, personal history, and suitable laboratory investigations. The presence of an idiopathic venous thrombosis in the family or in the personal history is of paramount importance. However it is often difficult to ascertain whether a venous thrombosis is idiopathic or not. Even when there is doubt, a coagulation study should be carried out. An adequate coagulation study in this case should include at least an evaluation of antithrombin, protein C, and protein S. A search for homozygosity of factor V Leiden appears advisable. These defects represent absolute contraindications to the use of OCT. Relative contraindications may be represented by other minor coagulation disorders such as heterozygous factor V Leiden, fibrinolysis defects, and a G-to-A 20210 prothrombin abnormality. Other noncoagulation-related conditions such as hypertension, liver damage, and obesity may represent absolute or relative contraindications to the use of OCT.

A survey of deep venous thrombosis management by consultant vascular surgeons in the United Kingdom and Ireland

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to detail the current consensus amongst vascular surgeons in Great Britain and Ireland regarding their investigation and management of patients with suspected or proven deep vein thrombosis (DVT).

METHODS

The database of the Vascular Surgical Society of Great Britain and Ireland (VSS) was utilised to send coded postal questionnaires to all consultant surgeon members.

RESULTS

Replies were received from 281 (65%) consultants. Duplex ultrasound is used alone to confirm DVT by 69% of respondents. A thrombophilia screen is always performed by 14% of consultants, for patients with proven DVT, and is more commonly requested by consultants based in a teaching hospital. The majority (57%) of consultants treat DVT with unfractionated heparin (UFH) and warfarin, whereas only 38% utilise low molecular weight heparins (LMWH) and warfarin. A management policy for DVT is reported to be in place by 59%, and a set policy for the specific management of calf vein DVT by just 20%.

CONCLUSION

New diagnostic modalities and treatments have been developed for DVT that are more convenient and cost-effective. Although clinical guidelines for the management of patients with DVT are beginning to emerge, there is still a wide discrepancy in many areas of DVT management, and practice at variance with the current evidence base, amongst vascular surgeons in the United Kingdom and Ireland.

Long-Term Use of Oral Contraceptive Therapy in Women With the Prothrombin 20210 G-A Polymorphism Without Thrombotic Complications: A Study of 13 Women (12 Heterozygotes and 1 Homozygote)

Thirteen female patients with the prothrombin 20210 G-A abnormality (twelve heterozygotes and one homozygote) were selected out of 551 patients admitted to our Department of Medicine or to our Outpatient Hemostasis Units between January 1999 and October 2000. The selection was based on the fact that all patients had taken or were still taking oral contraceptives (OC) for a period of 3 years or longer than 3 years. None of these patents as gathered from history, physical examination, private physician records and our records has shown any DVT during or immediately after OC intake. Physical and compression ultrasonography examinations at the time of study were all negative. The average length of oral contraceptives therapy (OCT) was 10 years (range 3-23). The average age of patients at the time of oral contraception was 30 years. The 13 women had also 17 pregnancies without any venous thrombosis. The observations casts several doubt about the prothrombotic effect of this polymorphism. Since DVT has been shown to occur occasionally even in normal women, it is likely that the same may occur in women with this polymorphism regardless of the existence or not of any pathogenetic relationship between the two phenomena. Occasional reports suggesting a link between this polymorphism and oral contraception-related venous thrombosis should be carefully evaluated in order to avoid premature and incorrect conclusions.

Occlusive vascular diseases in oral contraceptive users. Epidemiology, pathology and mechanisms

Despite being an unprecedented departure from normal physiology, the combined oral contraceptive is not only highly effective, but it also has a remarkably good safety record. Concerns over safety persist, though, particularly with regard to venous thromboembolism (VTE), stroke and myocardial infarction (MI). Epidemiological studies consistently show an increase in risk of VTE, but the results are more contentious with regard to arterial diseases. Despite 40 years of research, the mechanisms behind these adverse effects are not understood. In this review, we integrate information from published studies of the epidemiology and pathology of the occlusive vascular diseases and their risk factors to identify likely explanations for pathogenesis in oral contraceptive users. Oral contraceptives induce both prothrombotic and fibrinolytic changes in haemostatic factors and an imbalance in haemostasis is likely to be important in oral contraceptive-induced VTE. The complexity of the changes involved and the difficulty of ascribing clinical significance has meant that uncertainty persists. A seriously under-researched area concerns vascular changes in oral contraceptive users. Histologically, endothelial and intimal proliferation have been identified in women exposed to high plasma estrogen concentrations and these lesions are associated with thrombotic occlusion. Other structural changes may result in increased vascular permeability, loss of vascular tone and venous stasis. With regard to arterial disease risk, epidemiological information relating to dose effects and joint effects with other risk factors, and studies of pathology and changes in risk factors, suggests that oral contraceptive use per se does not cause arterial disease. It can, nevertheless, synergise very powerfully with subclinical endothelial damage to promote arterial occlusion. Accordingly, the prothrombotic effects of the oral contraceptive estrogen intervene in a cycle of endothelial damage and repair which would otherwise remain clinically silent or would ultimately progress - in, for example, the presence of cigarette smoking or hypertension - to atherosclerosis. Future work in this area should focus on modification of the effects of established risk factors by oral contraceptive use rather than modification of the supposed risk of oral contraceptive use by established risk factors. Attempts to understand vascular occlusion in oral contraceptive users in terms of the general features of VTE or with reference to atherosclerosis may be limiting, and future work needs to acknowledge that such occlusions may have unique features. Unequivocal identification of the mechanisms involved would contribute considerably to the alleviation of fears over vascular disease and to the development of even safer formulations.

Congenital and acquired thrombotic risk factors in women using oral contraceptives: clinical aspects

We describe the thrombophilic and clinical characteristics of a group of patients who suffered venous thrombosis (VT) (n = 36) and ischemic stroke (n = 8) while taking oral contraceptives (OC). Our purpose is to ascertain whether there are differences between users of second and third generation progestogen and to investigate the influence of concurrent congenital and acquired risk factors (other than OC) on the onset of the thrombosis. The group of patients included 36 women with VT and eight with ischemic stroke. The patients' recognized predisposing factors were recorded. We also considered age, length of time on OC, types of OC, rethrombosis, family history of VT, and the presence of thrombophilic genetic defects. In the group of patients with VT, 54% were treated with second generation OC (n = 23), and 30% (n = 11) were treated with third generation OC. We found no significant statistical differences with respect to age and length of time on OC between the two types of OC. The prevalence of genetic defects in these patients--factor V (FV) Leiden, prothrombin G20210A mutation and protein S deficiency--was 19% (n = 7), 17% (n = 6), and 8% (n = 3) respectively. We observed the shortest time lapse between initiating OC and the first thrombotic event in carriers of FV Leiden and in patients with combined defects, but the differences were not significant. In patients with ischemic stroke, 50% were treated with second generation OC and 50% were treated with third generation OC. Prothrombin G20210A mutation was detected in two patients. In both patients,the stroke occurred earlier than in the rest of the patients, but these differences were not statistically significant. With respect to preventing thrombotic events in these patients, our data suggest that OC therapy should be avoided in patients with a previous history of thrombosis and in patients with an evident thrombotic tendency in the family. In patients in whom the family history of thrombosis is not very evident, it would be recommended to screen for FV Leiden, prothrombin G20210A mutation, and protein S, and to rule out OC if the patient does in fact have one of these risk factors. Moreover, if a patient develops a thrombotic complication while taking OC, an evaluation to search for a thrombophilic defect is warranted, and at the same time, alternative methods of contraception should be considered.