14
|
Walsh M, Whitlock R, Garg AX, Légaré JF, Duncan AE, Zimmerman R, Miller S, Fremes S, Kieser T, Karthikeyan G, Chan M, Ho A, Nasr V, Vincent J, Ali I, Lavi R, Sessler DI, Kramer R, Gardner J, Syed S, VanHelder T, Guyatt G, Rao-Melacini P, Thabane L, Devereaux PJ. Effects of remote ischemic preconditioning in high-risk patients undergoing cardiac surgery (Remote IMPACT): a randomized controlled trial. CMAJ 2015; 188:329-336. [PMID: 26668200 DOI: 10.1503/cmaj.150632] [Citation(s) in RCA: 19] [Impact Index Per Article: 2.1] [Reference Citation Analysis] [Abstract] [Track Full Text] [Journal Information] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Accepted: 10/26/2015] [Indexed: 01/09/2023] Open
Abstract
BACKGROUND Remote ischemic preconditioning is a simple therapy that may reduce cardiac and kidney injury. We undertook a randomized controlled trial to evaluate the effect of this therapy on markers of heart and kidney injury after cardiac surgery. METHODS Patients at high risk of death within 30 days after cardiac surgery were randomly assigned to undergo remote ischemic preconditioning or a sham procedure after induction of anesthesia. The preconditioning therapy was three 5-minute cycles of thigh ischemia, with 5 minutes of reperfusion between cycles. The sham procedure was identical except that ischemia was not induced. The primary outcome was peak creatine kinase-myocardial band (CK-MB) within 24 hours after surgery (expressed as multiples of the upper limit of normal, with log transformation). The secondary outcome was change in creatinine level within 4 days after surgery (expressed as log-transformed micromoles per litre). Patient-important outcomes were assessed up to 6 months after randomization. RESULTS We randomly assigned 128 patients to remote ischemic preconditioning and 130 to the sham therapy. There were no significant differences in postoperative CK-MB (absolute mean difference 0.15, 95% confidence interval [CI] -0.07 to 0.36) or creatinine (absolute mean difference 0.06, 95% CI -0.10 to 0.23). Other outcomes did not differ significantly for remote ischemic preconditioning relative to the sham therapy: for myocardial infarction, relative risk (RR) 1.35 (95% CI 0.85 to 2.17); for acute kidney injury, RR 1.10 (95% CI 0.68 to 1.78); for stroke, RR 1.02 (95% CI 0.34 to 3.07); and for death, RR 1.47 (95% CI 0.65 to 3.31). INTERPRETATION Remote ischemic precnditioning did not reduce myocardial or kidney injury during cardiac surgery. This type of therapy is unlikely to substantially improve patient-important outcomes in cardiac surgery. TRIAL REGISTRATION ClinicalTrials.gov, no. NCT01071265.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Michael Walsh
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Richard Whitlock
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Amit X Garg
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Jean-François Légaré
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Andra E Duncan
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Robert Zimmerman
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Scott Miller
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Stephen Fremes
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Teresa Kieser
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Ganesan Karthikeyan
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Matthew Chan
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Anthony Ho
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Vivian Nasr
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Jessica Vincent
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Imtiaz Ali
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Ronit Lavi
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Daniel I Sessler
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Robert Kramer
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Jeff Gardner
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Summer Syed
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Tomas VanHelder
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Gordon Guyatt
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Purnima Rao-Melacini
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - Lehana Thabane
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | - P J Devereaux
- Population Health Research Institute (Walsh, Whitlock, Vincent, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; McMaster University (Walsh, Whitlock, Syed, VanHelder, Guyatt, Rao-Melacini, Thabane, Devereaux), Hamilton, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Garg, Lavi), Western University, London, Ont.; Dalhousie University (Légaré), Halifax, NS; Cleveland Clinic (Duncan, Nasr, Sessler), Cleveland, Ohio; Maine Medical Center (Zimmerman, Kramer), Portland, Me.; Wake Forest University (Miller, Gardner), Winston-Salem, NC; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (Fremes), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; University of Calgary (Kieser, Ali), Calgary, Alta.; All India Institute of Medical Sciences (Karthikeyan), New Delhi, India; The Chinese University of Hong Kong (Chan, Ho), Hong Kong SAR, China
| | | |
Collapse
|