Effect of distraction rate and consolidation period on bone density following mandibular osteodistraction in rats

Publication Trends in Craniofacial Distraction: A Bibliometrical Analysis

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to analyze the craniofacial distraction literature published over the last 50 years and to determine various trends in publications.

METHODS

A literature search was conducted in November and December 2015. The date search range was 1965 to 2015. Databases searched included Medline, Web of Science, Biosis, SciELO, Data Citation, and Zoologic Records. Data were collected on distraction type, author specialty, date of publication, country, state (if United States), number of citations, journal name, journal type, and Le Fort type (for midfacial distractions).

RESULTS

Total number of craniofacial distraction publications was 1729. Cranial distraction accounted for (11%), midfacial (11%), and mandibular (78%). Largest increase in publications was in the 1990s, with 48 publications from 1991 to 1995 rising to 261 publications from 1996 to 2000. Among the cranial distraction publications, Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (PRS) (67%) were the most frequent authors but among the midfacial and mandibular distraction publications, Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery (OMFS) were the most frequent authors (68% and 64%, respectively). Total number of citations was 26,281 with OMFS (50.4%) and PRS (37%) being cited most frequently. Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery was cited most for mandibular and midfacial distraction, and PRS was cited most for cranial distraction.

CONCLUSION

Research on craniofacial distraction has significantly increased since the 1970s, with mandibular distraction accounting for the majority of this rise. Among specialties, OMFS and PRS account for the majority of the literature. The United States leads the publication. Authors tend to publish distraction literature in their corresponding journal specialty, with the exception of PRS who publishes most frequently in OMFS journals.

Deferoxamine enhances bone regeneration in mandibular distraction osteogenesis

BACKGROUND

Distraction osteogenesis is a powerful reconstructive technique for bone growth and repair. An angiogenic means of enhancing the efficacy of this metabolically demanding procedure would be beneficial in expanding its therapeutic potential. The authors posit that the angiogenic effect of deferoxamine, an iron chelator that has been shown to increase angiogenesis, will improve bone regeneration by means of augmentations in quality and quantity of bone and bone-producing cells.

METHODS

Two groups of rats (n = 12) underwent surgical external fixation and subsequent distraction. During the distraction stage, the experimental deferoxamine group (n = 5) was treated with injections into the distraction gap. After 28 days of consolidation, mandibles were harvested and prepared for histologic analysis.

RESULTS

The authors found a proliferation of osteocytes in the deferoxamine-treated group when compared with the regenerate of the control group. Deferoxamine effected a significant increase in osteocytes and an increase in bone volume fraction, with subsequent decreased osteoid volume fraction. The data also demonstrated no significant difference in empty lacunae.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors' study demonstrates the effectiveness of deferoxamine treatment to enhance the number of osteocytes within the regenerate in a murine mandibular distraction osteogenesis model. Maintenance of full lacunae supports the authors' finding of a robust cellular response to deferoxamine therapy. These results suggest that the angiogenic capabilities of deferoxamine translate into an increase in the number of bone-forming cells in the regenerate. Deferoxamine may have utility in optimizing bone formation in distraction osteogenesis and lead to superior reconstructive capabilities for craniofacial surgeons in the future.

Deferoxamine enhances the vascular response of bone regeneration in mandibular distraction osteogenesis

BACKGROUND

Bone regeneration during distraction osteogenesis is intricately associated with an enhanced vascular response. Augmenting this response may offer considerable clinical advantages such as optimizing the quality of regenerate formation, decreasing lengthy consolidation periods, or increasing regenerate size and distance. Using deferoxamine, an angiogenic transcriptional activator, the authors posit that substantial increases in vascular volume beyond the normal response to mechanical distraction can be quantified with micro-computed tomography after vessel perfusion during mandibular distraction osteogenesis.

METHODS

Two groups of Sprague-Dawley rats (n = 12) underwent external fixator placement, mandibular osteotomy, and 5.1-mm distraction. During distraction, the experimental group (n = 6) was treated with deferoxamine injections into the distraction gap. After consolidation, the animals were perfused and imaged with micro-computed tomography. Vascular radiomorphometrics were calculated and statistical comparison was conducted with the independent samples t test. A value of p ≤ 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

A 40 percent statistically significant increase in the number of vessels (0.82 vessels/mm versus 1.15 vessels/mm; p < 0.012) and a complementary decrease in the space between vessels (1.18 mm versus 0.86 mm; p < 0.012) were calculated in the experimental regenerate when compared with controls. This robust increase in vascularity could also be readily observed with micro-computed tomographic image reconstruction. Gross examination revealed a denser regenerate in the deferoxamine-injected group that is clearly illustrated with Faxitron radiography.

CONCLUSION

The authors' study quantifies the ability of deferoxamine to augment the vascular response of mandibular distraction osteogenesis and establishes correlations between this therapeutic enrichment and enhanced regenerate formation.

The effect of periosteal injury and masticatory micromovement on the healing of a mandibular distraction osteogenesis site

OBJECTIVES

Surgical periosteal injury and masticatory loading are likely factors affecting the healing of a mandibular DO site. This study is aimed to characterize the healing features of an early-phase mandibular DO site and assess the effects of these factors.

DESIGN

Eighteen 3-6-month-old miniature pigs received a right mandibular osteotomy and were distracted for 5 days (1 mm/day) and consolidated for 0, 1 or 2 weeks (Groups A, B and C, respectively). Bone formation, chondrogenesis and vascular structure of the distraction site were measured using histological methods and their changes with consolidation time were characterized. The effect of periosteal injury was assessed by comparing the more severely injured lateral side with the less disturbed medial side. The effect of masticatory loading was evaluated by relating the healing features to the interfragmentary micromovement caused by soft-diet mastication.

RESULTS

With consolidation time, bone formation and chondrogenesis became stronger whilst vascular structure became more mature. Compared to the medial side, bone formation and chondrogenesis on the lateral side were significantly delayed in Groups A and B, but not in Group C, in which periosteal recovery had occurred. No difference was found for vascular measurements between the medial and lateral sides. In Group B, bone formation, but not chondrogenesis or vascular structures, tended to be negatively correlated with the magnitude of masticatory micromovement during the distraction phase.

CONCLUSION

The results suggest that periosteal injury inhibits early mandibular DO site healing, whereas micromovement from soft-diet mastication mechanics has a negligible effect.

Nicotine impairs distraction osteogenesis in the rat mandible

Distraction osteogenesis (DO) has gained clinical acceptance as a surgical technique for treatment of congenital craniomaxillofacial deficiencies requiring skeletal expansion. The use of this technique elsewhere requires more information on overcoming difficult clinical settings, for which new animal models will be needed. The aim of this study was to develop and validate a model of impaired DO of the rat mandible with nicotine. Twenty rats underwent a right vertical mandibular body osteotomy, after which distraction began with custom-made percutaneous devices and a 3-day latency period, 6-day distraction (0.25 mm twice daily) and 30 days of neutral fixation. Rats received either nicotine or placebo slow-release pellets. Specimens were analysed after removal of the devices for quantitative radiographic bone fill, amount of bone advancement and histological features. The mean radiographic bone-fill score with nicotine treatment was 75% of that with placebo (P=0.0036). The nicotine-treated rats had less (49%) elongation than the placebo-treated controls (P=0.0008). Histological analysis demonstrated less bone, vascularity and cellular activity in nicotine-treated rats. This study shows that nicotine reproducibly inhibits osteogenesis, vascularity and bone lengthening in mandibular DO.

Recommendations for optimal distraction protocols for various animal models on the basis of a systematic review of the literature

The principles of orthopaedic distraction osteogenesis (DO) have been successfully applied to the craniofacial skeleton, but the latency time, rate and rhythm of distraction, and length of the consolidation period that are optimal for long-bone distraction may be suboptimal for craniofacial DO. The aim of this study was to provide recommendations for optimal distraction parameters in animal experimental research on craniofacial DO. The data used were from studies, added to the PubMed database between 1 January 1973 and 1 January 2007, on the outcome of DO resulting from variations in a single distraction parameter while standardizing the other distraction parameters. Although experimental animal group sizes were rather small, especially in those studies that used large animals, and both skeletally mature and immature animals were used, the (in most cases quantitative) data provided useful information on the optimal parameters in craniofacial DO. A latency period may not be necessary at all. Distraction should be performed at a rate of 1mm/day (this may be halved when small animals such as rats are used) preferably with a continuous rhythm, followed by a consolidation period of 6-8 weeks. These recommendations can be used as basic guidelines for further animal experimental studies on craniofacial DO.

Masticatory mechanics of a mandibular distraction osteogenesis site: interfragmentary micromovement

Micromovement at a fracture or distraction osteogenesis (DO) site may play a significant role in bone formation and healing. Mastication is an important physiological process that can cause substantial micromovement at a mandibular disjunction. The purpose of this study is to characterize and quantify the micromovement caused by mastication. Eighteen pigs, divided into three groups based on duration of consolidation, received a unilateral (right) mandibular angle distraction osteogenesis protocol. Differential variable reluctance transducers (DVRTs) and ultrasound crystals were used to measure the change of gap width as well as interfragmentary movement during mastication. Synchronized chewing video and interfragmentary movement recordings were used to determine the magnitude and direction of micromovement at different phases of the chewing cycle. The magnitude of micromovement did not increase significantly with distraction up to almost 5 mm, but did decrease gradually with consolidation. The average micromovement magnitude during the distraction phase was 0.2-0.3 mm, equaling 50,000-250,000 microstrain (muepsilon) on interfragmentary tissue. The dominant deformation pattern was bending in the sagittal plane. The most common direction of bending at the power stroke of chewing was concave dorsally, i.e., superior shortening and inferior lengthening. These findings elucidate how masticatory mechanics affect a mandibular distraction site, and the measurements may be useful for future simulation studies.

Condylar mineralization following mandibular distraction in rats

The impact of mandibular distraction on condyles is poorly understood. To examine how condylar mineralization is affected, we performed distraction in 128 one-month-old rapidly and 126 three-month-old slowly growing rats. The rate of distraction was 0.0 mm (sham), 0.2 mm (slow), 0.4 mm (moderate), or 0.6 mm (rapid). From 7 to 9 rats from each rate (n = 29-32) were killed at 4 time periods (D6, D10, D24, and D38) following osteotomy. Calcein and alizarin were injected 6 and 3 days, respectively, prior to death. Methacrylate-embedded sagittal condylar sections were examined under epifluorescence, and mineral apposition rates were measured. Results indicated that: (1) rapidly growing rats showed higher mineral apposition rates (p < 0.01-0.001) than did slowly growing rats; (2) mineral apposition rates were lower in distracted sides at all times in rapidly growing rats (p < 0.05-0.01), while this side-dependency was seen only at D24 in slowly growing rats (p < 0.05); and (3) distraction rates had little effect on mineral apposition rates. Thus, mandibular distraction decreases condylar mineral apposition rates, but only in rapidly growing rats, which is related to surgery and its functional consequences, not to the distraction rate.

Assessment of cell proliferation during mandibular distraction osteogenesis in the maturing rat

INTRODUCTION

The cellular mechanisms controlling distraction osteogenesis are not well understood. The purpose of this study was to examine the role of cell proliferation in the regulation of mandibular distraction osteogenesis.

METHODS

Unilateral mandibular ramus osteotomies were performed on 125 3-month-old Sprague-Dawley rats. The rats were randomized into 4 distraction rate groups and distracted for 5 days after 3-day latency. Rats (7 or 8 from each rate group) were killed at 4 time points. The rats received 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine (BrdU) injections (40 mg per kilogram, i.p.) at day 3 (end of latency).

RESULTS

Both intramembranous and endochondral ossification was seen in the osteogenesis area. BrdU+ mesenchymal progenitor cells were significantly higher at day 10 (P <.05) and were found most numerously around the sagittal middle portion of the gap (P <.01). The greatest numbers of BrdU+ osteocytes were seen at day 38 (P <.05). Both BrdU+ osteoclasts and chondrocytes peaked at day 24.

CONCLUSIONS

Mesenchymal progenitor cells are mostly recruited in the early consolidation period, but they decrease in the middle and late consolidation periods during mandibular distraction osteogenesis. The rapid rate might suppress or sustain the proliferation and differentiation of mesenchymal progenitor cells during mandibular distraction osteogenesis. BrdU+ cells can survive throughout the entire experimental period of 5 weeks.

Vertical distraction osteogenesis in the human mandible: a prospective morphometric study

Vertical distraction osteogenesis has received considerable interest as a way to augment bone prior to implant placement. However, very little is known regarding the appropriate distraction protocols in the human mandible. In this study, we evaluate the effect of the distraction rate and the duration of neutrofixation on bone formation and closure of the gap in the human mandible. Vertical distraction was performed in the atrophic mandible of 16 edentulous patients, aged 62+/-6 years. The bone was distracted for approximately 10 mm at a rate of either 0.5 or 1 mm/day. Bone biopsies were taken after 7-20 weeks of neutrofixation. Histological analysis demonstrated newly formed bone in the distraction gap in all biopsies. The bone was predominantly of the woven type. After 10 weeks of neutrofixation, the gap was bridged by new bone in two out of three intact samples in the 0.5 mm/day group, but not in two intact samples of the 1 mm/day group. Histomorphometry revealed longer bone trabeculae (P=0.02) and a somewhat increased bone volume in the area where new bone formation started (P=0.07) in the group of patients having the 0.5 mm/day of distraction rate than in the 1 mm/day group. We conclude that in elderly patients, a distraction rate of 0.5 mm/day results in faster osteogenesis in the distraction gap than a rate of 1 mm/day. A minimum of 10 weeks of neutrofixation seems to be needed to close a 10 mm gap after cessation of distraction.

Mandibular mechanics after osteotomy and distraction appliance placement I: Postoperative mobility of the osteotomy site

PURPOSE

Fixation at the osteotomy site for mandibular distraction osteogenesis (DO) is probably not rigid, especially during mastication. Micromotion may affect the course of DO. This study aimed to measure the mobility of the fresh distractor-fixed osteotomy site in response to mastication and masticatory muscle stimulation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty-eight domestic pigs, 6 to 8 weeks old, underwent osteotomy of the right mandible and placement of a distractor appliance. Immediately after surgery, displacement at 3 different locations (superior-lateral, inferior-lateral, and inferior-medial) of the osteotomy site was assessed using ultrasound piezoelectric crystals or differential variable reluctance transducers (DVRTs). The amount of lengthening or shortening at each location was measured during mastication and muscle stimulation. Displacement was also measured for bilateral osteotomy during muscle stimulation from a subgroup of 12 pigs.

RESULTS

The osteotomy site demonstrated significant mobility during power strokes of mastication with an average magnitude of 0.3 to 0.4 mm. Distinct patterns of displacement were associated with different locations, and the patterns varied between chewing sides. The most common pattern was lengthening at the superior-lateral and shortening at both inferior sites. Similar amounts of displacement were observed during the stimulation of jaw-closers (masseter and medial pterygoid), but the patterns produced by these muscles did not completely explain the masticatory pattern. Opening the osteotomy to 1.5 mm did not alter the displacements observed during muscle stimulation. Bilateral osteotomy tended to decrease displacement.

CONCLUSIONS

The study demonstrates that during mastication and masticatory muscle stimulation, an acute mandibular osteotomy site is mobile despite fixation by a distractor appliance.

Microstructural and Strength Evaluation of Regenerate Tissue during the Consolidation Period after Vertical Mandibular Ramus Distraction

Mandibular ramus height restoration by distraction osteogenesis (DO) is a key procedure in mandibular hypoplasia reconstruction. The objective of this study was to evaluate short-term skeletal changes in the regenerated bone after vertical mandibular ramus DO using a buried distraction device. Eight subadult beagle dogs underwent bilateral vertical mandibular ramus DO. After a 7-day latency period, distraction was performed at a rate of 0.5 mm twice a day for 12 days. Four dogs were killed at 1 month and four dogs at 2 months after the end of distraction. One intact beagle was included as an unoperated control. After sacrifice, micro computed tomography (muCT) and mechanical testing of distracted sites were used to measure bone volume (BV), total volume (TV), and mechanical peak load strength, respectively. The muCT images showed wide variation in the response, with some animals demonstrating considerable bone formation and reconstitution of the canal for the inferior alveolar nerve. Quantitatively, BV was no more than 67% and BV/TV was less than 25% of the intact control, and strength was approximately 33% of the intact control value. The 1 and 2 month values were similar. These results suggest that internal distractors can successfully reconstitute bone but that the regenerated tissue did not regain structural and mechanical characteristics of native bone within the 2 month study period.

Sequential histomorphometric analysis of regenerate osteogenesis following mandibular distraction in the rat

Few studies of distraction osteogenesis in the craniofacial region have examined the dynamic nature of the bone healing process. This study investigated bone formation in distraction sites at various times following slow, moderate, and rapid rates of mandibular distraction in adult rats. After a 3-day latency period, 16 groups of 8-9 rats underwent unilateral mandibular distraction for 5 days at four different rates (0, 0.2, 0.4, and 0.6 mm/day) and were sacrificed at four different time points (6, 10, 24, and 38 days). Vital bone labels were injected prior to sacrifice and histological sections were examined under epifluorescence to measure mineral apposition rate (MAR) and the number of red and green pixels that corresponded to the wavelengths of the two bone labels. These pixel counts were designed to quantify the amount of fluorescent bone formation. For MAR and the pixel counts, no significant differences were found between the distraction rate groups. Over time, MAR was significantly higher (p < 0.001) at 24 days (4.50 microm/day) compared to 38 days (3.78 microm/day). Thus, MAR appears to be elevated at mid-consolidation compared to late consolidation. The pixel counts showed that the 6-day (mid-distraction) and 10-day (early consolidation) time points had significantly lower total fluorescent activity compared to the 24-day (mid-consolidation) and 38-day (late consolidation) time points (p < 0.001). The red, green, and red + green pixel counts were found to correlate significantly but weakly with microdensity (r = 0.318, 0.307, and 0.334, respectively). The pixel counts and microdensity both showed similar patterns over time.

Trabecular organization in mandibular osteodistraction in growing and maturing rats

PURPOSE

Our goal was to investigate the trabecular organization of the distraction regenerate during various consolidation phases and as a result of various distraction rates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred ninety-two growing and maturing rats (96 each) received unilateral mandibular osteotomies and distraction device placement. They were randomly allocated into 4 distraction rate groups (0, 0.2, 0.4, and 0.6 mm/day for 5 days) after a 3-day latency. Eight rats from each rate group were sacrificed at early (10 days), mid (24 days) and late (38 days) consolidation time points. Harvested hemimandibles were embedded in micro-bed resin, sectioned sagittally at 10 mum thickness and stained using the Von Kossa method. The histologic images were captured and processed using Adobe Photoshop (Version 7.0; Adobe Systems Inc, San Jose, CA). Custom-made software (MacAzimuth; written by Prof. J.M. Rensberger, University of Washington) was further used to analyze the orientation (anisotropy and angle distribution) and mass (density and thickness) of trabecular structures in the regenerates.

RESULTS

Trabecular orientation significantly differed at the mid-consolidation time point with less anisotropy ( P < or = .000 to .023) and narrower angular distribution ( P < or = .007 to .021). Trabecular mass increased significantly from early to mid-consolidation ( P < or = .000 to .002). Growing rats showed greater trabecular organization than maturing rats did at the same time points ( P < or = .000 to .009). The trabecular organization parameters were associated significantly with bone mineral density and microdensity ( P < or = .000 to .044).

CONCLUSION

The peak change in orientation occurred around the mid-consolidation with a greater increase in trabecular mass. Growing rats showed a greater capacity for trabecular organization at earlier time points. However, distraction rate did not have an effect on trabecular organization. These results suggest that trabecular organization can be used as an important indicator to evaluate bone maturation and quality in the distraction regenerate.

Apoptosis in the regenerate produced by mandibular osteodistraction in the mature rat*

AUTHORS: Liu ZJ, Anderson MW, Gu GM, King GJ.

OBJECTIVE

Little is known about the contribution of apoptosis to the formation of the regenerate in distraction osteogenesis. This study investigated the role of apoptosis in the regulation of osteogenesis in relation to mandibular distraction rate and recovery time.

METHODS

One hundred and twenty-nine 3-month rats received unilateral mandibular ramus osteotomy and distraction device placement. After 3-day latency, these were distracted for 5 days. The slow group was distracted a total of 1 mm (0.2 mm/day), the moderate 2 mm (0.4 mm/day), the rapid 3 mm (0.6 mm/day), and the sham was not distracted (0.0 mm/day). Eight to nine rats from each group were killed at 6 (mid-distraction), 10 (early-consolidation), 24 (mid-consolidation) and 38 (late-consolidation) days following device placement. Baseline data were obtained from an additional eight rats killed at day 3 (end of latency). Sagittal sections (7 mum) of the harvested hemi-mandibles were embedded in paraffin, double-stained with the DeadEnd(TM) Colorimetric TUNEL system for apoptotic cells and tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase for osteoclasts. Cell counts of apoptotic cells and osteoclasts (apoptotic or otherwise) were preformed at 40x magnification using a calibrated grid at the middle regions of the caudal, central and rostral parts of the distraction gap. Counting reproducibility was verified as <13%.

RESULTS

Counts from all three regions were combined because no significant regional difference was found. The majority of the fibrous matrix regenerate was seen at days 6 and 10 while osseous regenerate occurred mainly at days 24 and 38. Significantly higher levels of apoptotic activity were seen at day 24. Apoptotic osteoclasts also peaked at day 24. Apoptotic cell numbers in the slow and moderate groups most closely followed the pattern of the sham in which the apoptosis activity peaked at days 10 or 24. However, those in the rapid group showed delayed peaks at days 24 or 38.

CONCLUSIONS

Chalmers Street, Surry Hill, NSW 2010, Australia. gshe6437@mail.usyd.edu.au The transition from fibrous to osseous regenerate during mandibular distraction osteogenesis is accompanied by an increase in cell clearance via apoptosis. A slow to moderate distraction rate allows for the most typical pattern of bone healing while a rapid rate prolongs the healing process.

Alterations of morphology and microdensity in the condyle after mandibular osteodistraction in the rat

PURPOSE

In this study, we examined the effects of mandibular distraction osteogenesis on the morphology and the microdensity of the rat condyle.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred twenty-nine rats were allocated to 4 experimental groups (n = 32 or 33). Each received unilateral mandibular ramus osteotomy and distraction device placement. After a 3-day latency, these were distracted once a day for 5 days. The slow distraction group was distracted a total of 1 mm (0.2 mm/d); the moderate group, 2 mm (0.4 mm/d); the rapid group, 3 mm (0.6 mm/d); and the sham group, no distraction (0.0 mm/d). Eight to 9 rats in each group were sacrificed at each of 4 time points after device placement (6, 10, 24, and 38 days). Baseline data were obtained 3 days after osteotomy and device placement without distraction from an additional 10 rats. Radiographs of the hemimandibles were scanned and measured to evaluate changes in condylar size (height, width, and area), angulation, and bone microdensity converted to equivalent bone thickness using a stepwedge. The wet weights of masseter muscle were measured at the time of harvest.

RESULTS

1) Muscle weight gains over time were significantly lower in the treated than the untreated sides throughout the consolidation period (P <.001). 2) Condylar size and angulation on the untreated side increased postoperatively, whereas there was a significant reduction of these parameters (P <.01 to.001) on the treated side at 24 and/or 38 days. 3) Condylar microdensity significantly increased on the untreated side at 24 and 38 days (P <.05 to.01) but not on the treated side. 4) Faster or larger distraction caused more severe size reduction and more upright condylar angulation, prevented an increase in bone microdensity on the treated side, especially during the consolidation periods (P <.05 to.01), and retarded increase in muscle weight, whereas a slower distraction rate showed few negative, and even some positive effects. 5) Correlations in size, angulation, and microdensity between right and left condyles became less significant over time. 6) There were positive correlations between muscle weight and condylar size, angulation, and microdensity.

CONCLUSION

An increased rate of mandibular distraction has significant negative effects on condylar morphology and microdensity.