Spectral electromyographic fatigue analysis of back muscles in healthy adult women compared with men

Understanding the Biering-Sørensen test: Contributors to extensor endurance in young adults with and without a history of low back pain

The Biering-Sørensen test is commonly used to assess paraspinal muscle endurance. Research using a single repetition of the test has provided conflicting evidence for the contribution of impaired paraspinal muscle endurance to low back pain (LBP). This study investigated how Sørensen test duration, muscle activation, and muscle fatigability are affected by multiple repetitions of the test and determined predictors of Sørensen test duration in young adults with and without a history of LBP. Sixty-four young individuals performed three repetitions of the Sørensen test. Amplitude of activation and median frequency slope (fatigability) were calculated for the lumbar and thoracic paraspinals and hamstrings. Duration of the test was significantly less for the 3rd repetition in individuals with LBP. In individuals without LBP, test duration was predicted by fatigability of the lumbar paraspinals. In individuals with LBP, Sørensen test duration was predicted by fatigability of the hamstrings and amplitude of activation of the thoracic and lumbar paraspinals. Our findings demonstrate that it is necessary to amplify the difficulty of the Sørensen test to reveal impairments in young, active adults with LBP. Training programs aiming to improve lumbar paraspinal performance should monitor performance of other synergist muscles during endurance exercise.

Understanding the Biering-Sørensen test: contributors to extensor endurance in young adults with and without low back pain

Impaired paraspinal muscle endurance may contribute to persistent low back pain (LBP) and is frequently assessed using a single repetition of the Biering-Sørensen test. This study investigated how Sørensen test duration, muscle activation, and muscle fatigability are affected by multiple repetitions of the test, and determined predictors of Sørensen test duration in young, active adults with and without a history of LBP. Sixty-four individuals with and without persistent LBP performed 3 repetitions of the Sørensen test. Amplitude of activation and median frequency slope (fatigability) were calculated for the lumbar and thoracic paraspinals and the hamstrings. Duration of the test was significantly less for the 2nd and 3rd repetitions in individuals with LBP. In individuals without LBP, fatigability of the lumbar paraspinals was the best predictor of test duration. In individuals with LBP, Sørensen test duration was predicted by fatigability of the hamstrings and amplitude of activation of the thoracic and lumbar paraspinals. Our findings demonstrate that it is necessary to amplify the difficulty of the Sørensen test to elucidate impairments in young, active adults with LBP. Training programs aiming to improve lumbar paraspinal performance in individuals with LBP should monitor performance of other synergist muscles during endurance exercise.

Comparison of erector spinae fatigability between female patients with Parkinson's disease and healthy individuals: a cross sectional pilot study

BACKGROUND

Postural abnormality is one of the main symptoms of Parkinson's disease (PD). The erector spinae muscles play an important role in maintaining an upright posture, but the fatigability of the erector spinae in patients with PD is unknown. The purpose of this study was to compare the trunk extension maximum voluntary contraction (MVC) and the fatigability of the erector spinae between female patients with PD and healthy volunteers.

METHODS

Th participants of this cross-sectional pilot study comprised 19 patients with PD and nine healthy volunteers matched for sex, age, and physical characteristics as a control group. The MVC of all participants was measured, and after sufficient rest, the Sørensen back endurance test was conducted to the point of exhaustion. The muscle activity of the erector spinae during the Sørensen back endurance test was measured using surface electromyography. The median frequency (MF) slope, which is an index of fatigability, was calculated from the recorded surface muscle activity by means of power spectrum analysis using a Fast Fourier transformation.

RESULTS

Nine of the 19 patients with PD were unable to perform the Sørensen back endurance test, and a lower proportion of the PD group were able to perform it compared with the control group. The MVC of those patients with PD who were able to perform the Sørensen back endurance test was lower than that of the control group, and the time for which the pose could be maintained was shorter. There was no significant difference between the MF slope on the left and right side in the PD group, and it was higher on both sides than in the control group.

CONCLUSION

This is the first study to demonstrate a reduction of maximum muscle strength and great fatigability of the erector spinae in patients with PD. This discovery strongly underlines the need for paraspinal muscle training from an early stage with the aim of preventing the progression of postural abnormality in patients with PD.

Continuous, integrated sensors for predicting fatigue during non-repetitive work: demonstration of technique in the operating room

Surface electromyography (sEMG) can monitor muscle activity and potentially predict fatigue in the workplace. However, objectively measuring fatigue is challenging in complex work with unpredictable work cycles where sEMG may be influenced by the dynamically changing posture demands. This study proposes a multi-modal approach integrating sEMG with motion sensors and demonstrates the approach in the live surgical work environment. Seventy-two exposures from twelve participants were collected, including self-reported musculoskeletal discomfort, sEMG, and postures. Posture sensors were used to identify time windows where the surgeon was static and in non-demanding positions, and mean power frequencies (MPF) were then calculated during those time windows. In 57 out of 72 exposures (80%), participants experienced an increase in musculoskeletal discomfort. Integrated (multi-modality) measurements showed better performance than single-modality (sEMG) measurements in detecting decreases in MPF, a predictor of fatigue. Based on self-reported musculoskeletal discomfort, sensor-based thresholds for identifying fatigue are proposed for the trapezius and deltoid muscle groups. Practitioner summary Work-related fatigue is one of the intermediate risk factors to musculoskeletal disorders. This article presents an objective integrated approach to identify musculoskeletal fatigue using wearable sensors. The presented approach could be implemented by ergonomists to identify musculoskeletal fatigue more accurately and in a variety of workplaces. Abbreviations: sEMG: surface electromyography; IMU: inertia measurement unit; MPF: mean power frequency; ACGIH: American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists; SAGES: Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons; LD: left deltoid; LT: left trapezius; RD: right deltoid; RT: right trapezius.

Fatigue-related differences in erector spinae between prepubertal children and young adults using surface electromyographic power spectral analysis

BACKGROUND

The erector spinae is more resistant to fatigue in adult women than men. However, no study has reported the sex differences in back muscle fatigue in children.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the fatigability of erector spinae in prepubertal children and adults, in both males and females.

METHODS

Fourteen prepubertal boys, 13 prepubertal girls, 14 adult men, and 13 adult women performed the Sørensen back isometric endurance test until exhaustion. The results of electromyographic (EMG) power spectral analysis of erector spinae were compared between both age groups and sexes.

RESULTS

The slopes of EMG power spectral median and mean power frequency were significantly higher in males than in females, in both age groups. Furthermore, the slopes were significantly lower in prepubertal children than in adults, in both males and females.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results showed major differences in the fatigue threshold of the erector spinae between boys and girls and children and adults. The muscle fatigued faster in prepubertal boys and adult men than in prepubertal girls and adult women. In both sexes, a lower slope of EMG power spectrum parameters of the erector spinae was noted during endurance test in prepubertal children compared to adults.

Age-related sex differences in erector spinae muscle endurance using surface electromyographic power spectral analysis in healthy humans

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Previous studies reported that the erector spinae muscle is more resistant to fatigue in healthy adult women than in men. However, no study has reported changes in back muscle fatigue with aging in healthy men and women.

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate age-related changes in muscle fatigue of erector spinae muscle in men and women.

STUDY DESIGN/SETTING

This cross-sectional study was conducted in a laboratory.

PATIENT SAMPLE

Fifty-three healthy subjects (11 elderly men, 11 elderly women, 17 young men, and 14 young women) without low back pain history.

OUTCOME MEASURES

The median frequency (MF) and mean power frequency (MPF) during trunk holding test were derived from the raw electromyographic (EMG) signal using Fast Fourier Transform spectrum analysis program. The rates of changes in MF and MPF were calculated.

METHODS

Subjects performed the unsupported trunk holding test until exhaustion. The results of power spectral analysis of the EMG activity of the left erector spinae muscle were compared in both age groups and sexes.

RESULTS

The endurance time in young men was significantly shorter than in young women. The slopes of MF and MPF in young men were significantly higher than in young women. There were no significant differences in MF and MPF slopes of elderly men and elderly women. Furthermore, the MF and MPF slopes were significantly lower in elderly men than young men but similar in the two women groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Age-related changes in the slopes of MF and MPF of erector spinae muscle occur in healthy men but not in healthy women.

STATIC ENDURANCE OF THE BACK EXTENSOR MUSCLES: ASSOCIATION BETWEEN PERFORMANCE AND REPORTED REASONS FOR TEST TERMINATION

Purpose: Quite a few studies have reported previously on reasons for terminating tests of back muscles endurance. This study investigated the association between endurance performance and reported reasons for terminating back extensor muscle endurance test in apparently healthy adults. Methods: Three-hundred-and-seventy-six volunteers with the mean age of 38.9 ± 13.5 years participated in this study. All participants underwent modified Biering–Sørensen test of Static Muscular Endurance. Descriptive statistics of mean and standard deviation, Pearson's correlation and Chi-square, ANOVA and ANCOVA were used to analyze the data. The α level was set at 0.05. Results: It is found that 76.1% of the participants terminated the test due to fatigue in the low back, followed by low-back pain (LBP) (12.8%) and fatigue in the gluteal or hamstring muscles (7.4%) respectively. The magnitudes of the endurance time for each reason of termination — fatigue in the low back (121 ± 49.3 sec), fatigue in the gluteal or hamstring muscles (102 ± 44.0 sec), LBP (59 ± 27.4 sec), and behavioral factors (92 ± 34.7 sec) were found to be significantly different (p = 0.001). Test termination due to fatigue in the low back was on the average 62 seconds longer than that due to LBP. Conclusions: Fatigue was the most commonly reported reason for back extensor muscles' endurance test termination. Endurance time was least in those individuals who terminate the test due to complaints of LBP and greatest in those who end the task for fatigue only.

Biering-Sorensen test performance of Japanese young males: comparison with other ethnicities and relationship to electromyography, near-infrared spectroscopy and exertion ratings

Back muscle endurance is a predictor of future low back pain and is commonly assessed using the Biering-Sorensen Test (BST). Differences exist between ethnic groups that may affect the performance and interpretation of the BST and should be investigated. This study's aim was to explore objective and subjective measures of the BST in a Japanese group in comparison with previous studies in other ethnic groups. A total of 27 young male Japanese students performed the BST while measures of muscle fatigue were collected. The mean BST time (152.7 (32.5) s) was greater than the median of the reported mean times in other ethnic groups over the previous decade (128.6 s). Objective measures indicated that the Japanese subjects' lumbar muscles were as fatigued as those of previous studies, while subjective measures appear to indicate that subjects under-reported exertion. The better performance of the Japanese subjects in the BST may reflect physical, psychosocial and lifestyle differences related to ethnicity. STATEMENT OF RELEVANCE: Ergonomics research and practice needs to be applicable to different ethnic groups. Despite the substantial body of evidence on back muscle endurance and indications of potential ethnicity related differences, this had not been previously investigated. These results help ergonomists to interpret physical ergonomics evidence in a multi-ethnic world.

Muscle maintenance by volitional contraction against applied electrical stimulation

Muscle training exercises are needed for muscular endurance during spaceflight. This study was designed to investigate effects of volitional contraction against applied electrical stimulation on the muscular endurance of the proximal upper extremity. Thirteen healthy sedentary men were allocated into two groups. One group participated in a hybrid (HYB) exercise regimen in which the biceps brachii was stimulated as he volitionally extended his elbow, and the triceps brachii was stimulated as the volitionally flexed his elbow. The second group underwent a similar regimen in which the electrical stimulation (ELS) was alternatively delivered to the biceps brachii and then to the triceps brachii with the limb fixed. Forty-second surface electromyography (EMG) recordings at 50% maximum voluntary contraction (MVC) were made as baseline data at just before starting the training regimen, and again conclusion. The median frequency (MF) and mean power frequency (MPF) slopes with time were determined using power spectrum analysis. There were statistical significance only for the triceps in which the MF and MPF slopes in the HYB Group became less negative over the period of study (from -45.7+/-14.7 and -47.0+/-8.6%/min at baseline to -36.9+/-10.7 and -36.8+/-7.0%/min at the end of training, respectively). The corresponding values for these slopes in the ELS Group showed opposite tends with less marked changes of borderline significance for MF and of statistical significance for MPF. These results suggested that the HYB exercise regimen was capable of producing an improvement in triceps but not biceps brachii.

Scapulothoracic and glenohumeral kinematics following an external rotation fatigue protocol

STUDY DESIGN

Repeated-measures experimental design.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the effects of shoulder external rotator muscle fatigue on 3-dimensional scapulothoracic and glenohumeral kinematics.

BACKGROUND

The external rotator muscles of the shoulder are important for normal shoulder function. Impaired performance of these muscles has been observed in subjects with impingement syndrome and it is possible that external rotator muscle fatigue leads to altered kinematics of the shoulder girdle.

METHODS AND MEASURES

Twenty subjects without a history of shoulder pathology participated in this study. Three-dimensional scapulothoracic and glenohumeral kinematics were determined from electromagnetic sensors attached to the scapula, humerus, and thorax. Surface electromyographic (EMG) data were collected from the upper and lower trapezius, serratus anterior, anterior and posterior deltoid, and infraspinatus muscles. Median power frequency (MPF) values were derived from the raw EMG data and were used to indicate the degree of local muscle fatigue. Kinematic and EMG measures were collected prior to and immediately following the performance of a shoulder external rotation fatigue protocol.

RESULTS

After completing the fatigue protocol subjects demonstrated less external rotation of the humerus. Additionally, they had less posterior tilt of the scapula in the beginning phase of arm elevation, and more scapular upward rotation and clavicular retraction in the mid ranges of arm elevation.

CONCLUSIONS

Performance of an external rotation fatigue protocol results in altered scapulothoracic and glenohumeral kinematics. Further studies are needed to investigate the effects of external rotator muscle fatigue on scapulothoracic and glenohumeral kinematics in subjects with shoulder pathology.

Spinal muscle evaluation using the Sorensen test: a critical appraisal of the literature

The first test for evaluating the isometric endurance of trunk extensor muscles was described by Hansen in 1964. In 1984, following a study by Biering-Sorensen, this test became known as the "Sorensen test" and gained considerable popularity as a tool reported to predict low back pain within the next year in males. The test consists in measuring the amount of time a person can hold the unsupported upper body in a horizontal prone position with the lower body fixed to the examining table. This test has been used in many studies, either in its original version or as variants. Although its discriminative validity, reproducibility, and safety seem good, debate continues to surround its ability to predict low back pain; in addition, the gender-related difference in position-holding time remains unexplained and the influence of body weight unclear. A contribution of the hip extensor muscles to position holding has been established, but its magnitude remains unknown. The influence of personal factors such as motivation complicates the interpretation of the results. Despite these drawbacks, the Sorensen test has become the tool of reference for evaluating muscle performance in patients with low back pain, most notably before and after rehabilitation programs.

Effects of shoulder muscle fatigue caused by repetitive overhead activities on scapulothoracic and glenohumeral kinematics

The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of shoulder muscle fatigue on three dimensional scapulothoracic and glenohumeral kinematics. Twenty healthy subjects participated in this study. Three-dimensional scapulothoracic and glenohumeral kinematics were determined from electromagnetic sensors attached to the scapula, humerus, and thorax. Surface electromyographic (EMG) data were collected from the upper and lower trapezius, serratus anterior, anterior and posterior deltoid, and infraspinatus muscles. Median power frequency (MPF) values were derived from the raw EMG data and were used to indicate the degree of local muscle fatigue. Kinematic and EMG measures were collected prior to and immediately following the performance of a shoulder elevation fatigue protocol. Following the performance of the fatigue protocol subjects demonstrated more upward and external rotation of the scapula, more clavicular retraction, and less humeral external rotation during arm elevation. All muscles with the exception of the lower trapezius showed EMG signs of fatigue, the most notable being the infraspinatus and deltoid muscles. In general, greater scapulothoracic motion and less glenohumeral motion was observed following muscle fatigue. Further studies are needed to determine what effects these changes have on the soft tissues and mechanics of the shoulder complex.

Muscle endurance and power spectrum of the triceps brachii in wheelchair marathon racers with paraplegia

OBJECTIVE

To investigate differences in triceps brachii endurance and electrical activity between elite marathon and recreational wheelchair athletes with paraplegia.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Nine male elite wheelchair athletes between 20 and 46 years of age (average 29.0 +/- 8.2 years) with complete (ASIA-A) T4-L1 paraplegia were compared to a group of six male height- and weight-matched recreational wheelchair athletes with similar ages and injuries. Right triceps brachii maximum voluntary contraction (MVC), as well as the duration of the ability to maintain a 50% MVC were determined for all subjects. Median frequency (MF) and mean power frequency (MPF) were evaluated with fast Fourier transform spectrum analysis. MF and MPF rates of change were calculated and compared with the Student's t-test.

SETTING

: Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, University of Occupational and Environmental Health, Japan.

RESULTS

Right triceps brachii MVCs of the marathoners (42.4 +/- 8.8 N m (range 33-55 N m)) and recreational athletes (41.6 +/- 9.3 N m (range 32-56 N m)) did not differ significantly (P = 0.63). Endurance, however, did. All of the athletes, but none of the control subjects, were able to maintain a 50% MVC contraction of the right triceps brachii for 2 min (the average contraction duration in the latter group was 75.5+/-16.2 s). MF and MPF of the triceps brachii decreased linearly in both groups, but the slopes in the marathoners (-8.9 +/- 4.6 (-3.8 to -16.4) and -9.7 +/- 4.6 (-4.0 to -17.2)%/min, respectively) were statistically less steep than those in the recreational athletes (-22.3 +/- 8.2 (-9.6 to -31.4) and -21.2 +/- 6.4 (-11.4 to -28.6)%/min, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Elite marathoners and active wheelchair users have similar triceps brachii strength. The marathoner's triceps brachii, however, display a significantly improved endurance and a slower decline of MF and MPF with time than do those of their recreational athlete control group.

Surface electromyography assessment of back muscle intrinsic properties

The purpose of this study was to assess (1) the reliability and (2) the sensitivity to low back pain status and gender of different EMG indices developed for the assessment of back muscle weakness, muscle fiber composition and fatigability. Healthy subjects (men and women) and chronic low back pain patients (men only) performed, in a static dynamometer, maximal and submaximal static trunk extension tasks (short and long duration) to assess weakness, fiber composition and fatigue. Surface EMG signals were recorded from four (bilateral) pairs of back muscles and three pairs of abdominal muscles. To assess reliability of the different EMG parameters, 40 male volunteers (20 controls and 20 chronic low back pain patients) were assessed on three occasions. Reliable EMG indices were achieved for both healthy and chronic low back pain subjects when specific measurement strategies were applied. The EMG parameters used to quantify weakness and fiber composition were insensitive to low back status and gender. The EMG fatigue parameters did not detect differences between genders but unexpectedly, healthy men showed higher fatigability than back pain patients. This result was attributed to the smaller absolute load that was attributed to the patients, a load that was defined relative to their maximal strength, a problematic measure with this population. An attempt was made to predict maximal back strength from anthropometric measurements but this prediction was prone to errors. The main difficulties and some potential solutions related to the assessment of back muscle intrinsic properties were discussed.

Gender differences in skeletal muscle fatigability are related to contraction type and EMG spectral compression

The purposes of this study were 1) to evaluate gender differences in back extensor endurance capacity during isometric and isotonic muscular contractions, 2) to determine the relation between absolute load and endurance time, and 3) to compare men [n = 10, age 22.4 +/- 0.69 (SE) yr] and women (n = 10, age 21.7 +/- 1.07 yr) in terms of neuromuscular activation patterns and median frequency (MF) shifts in the electromyogram (EMG) power spectrum of the lumbar and hip extensor muscles during fatiguing submaximal isometric trunk extension exercise. Subjects performed isotonic and isometric trunk extension exercise to muscular failure at 50% of maximum voluntary contraction force. Women exhibited a longer endurance time than men during the isometric task (146.0 +/- 10.9 vs. 105.4 +/- 7.9 s), but there was no difference in endurance performance during the isotonic exercise (24.3 +/- 3.4 vs. 24.0 +/- 2.8 repetitions). Absolute load was significantly related to isometric endurance time in the pooled sample (R(2) = 0.34) but not when men and women were analyzed separately (R(2) = 0.05 and 0.04, respectively). EMG data showed no differences in neuromuscular activation patterns; however, gender differences in MF shifts were observed. Women demonstrated a similar fatigability in the biceps femoris and lumbar extensors, whereas in men, the fatigability was more pronounced in the lumbar musculature than in the biceps femoris. Additionally, the MF of the lumbar extensors demonstrated a greater association with endurance time in men than in women (R(2) = 0.45 vs. 0.19). These findings suggest that gender differences in muscle fatigue are influenced by muscle contraction type and frequency shifts in the EMG signal but not by alterations in the synergistic activation patterns.

EMG-interference pattern analysis

The EMG interference pattern, built up of single motor unit action potentials, may be analyzed subjectively, or objectively by computer aided, quantitative methods, like counting of zero-crossings, counting of spikes, amplitude measurements, integration of the area under the curve, decomposition techniques, power spectrum analysis and turn/amplitude analysis. Since the shape of the interference pattern of healthy muscles is dependent on age, sex, force, muscle, temperature, fatigue, fitness level, recording site and surrounding tissue, electrode type, sensitivity, filters, sampling frequency and threshold level, all methods of analyzing the IP have to be standardized. Quantitative methods of analyzing the EMG interference pattern may be used for monitoring botulinum toxin therapy of dystonia and spasticity, quantifying spontaneous activity, assessment of chronic muscle pain, neuro-urological and proctological function, and diagnosing neuromuscular disorders. For diagnostic purposes, the methods favored are those that use needle electrodes and do not require measurement or monitoring of muscle force. The most well-evaluated methods are those using turn/amplitude analysis, like the cloud methods and the peak-ratio analysis. Peak-ratio analysis has the advantage that reference limits are easy to obtain and that its utility is well established and confirmed by several investigations. Overall, automatic methods of EMG interference pattern analysis are powerful tools for diagnostic and non-diagnostic purposes.