A synthetic analogue of melittin aggregates in large oligomers

Activity determinants of helical antimicrobial peptides: a large-scale computational study

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs), produced by a wide range of organisms, have attracted attention due to their potential use as novel antibiotics. The majority of these peptides are cationic and are thought to function by permeabilizing the bacterial membrane, either by making pores or by dissolving it ('carpet' model). A key hypothesis in the literature is that antimicrobial and hemolytic activity correlate with binding affinity to anionic and zwitterionic membranes, respectively. Here we test this hypothesis by using binding free energy data collected from the literature and theoretical binding energies calculated from implicit membrane models for 53 helical AMPs. We indeed find a correlation between binding energy and biological activity, depending on membrane anionic content: antibacterial activity correlates best with transfer energy to membranes with anionic lipid fraction higher than 30% and hemolytic activity correlates best with transfer energy to a 10% anionic membrane. However, the correlations are weak, with correlation coefficient up to 0.4. Weak correlations of the biological activities have also been found with other physical descriptors of the peptides, such as surface area occupation, which correlates significantly with antibacterial activity; insertion depth, which correlates significantly with hemolytic activity; and structural fluctuation, which correlates significantly with both activities. The membrane surface coverage by many peptides at the MIC is estimated to be much lower than would be required for the 'carpet' mechanism. Those peptides that are active at low surface coverage tend to be those identified in the literature as pore-forming. The transfer energy from planar membrane to cylindrical and toroidal pores was also calculated for these peptides. The transfer energy to toroidal pores is negative in almost all cases while that to cylindrical pores is more favorable in neutral than in anionic membranes. The transfer energy to pores correlates with the deviation from predictions of the 'carpet' model.

Effects of cyclic lipodepsipeptide structural modulation on stability, antibacterial activity, and human cell toxicity

Bacterial infections are becoming increasingly difficult to treat due to the development and spread of antibiotic resistance. Therefore, identifying novel antibacterial targets and new antibacterial agents capable of treating infections by drug-resistant bacteria is of vital importance. The structurally simple yet potent fusaricidin or LI-F class of natural products represents a particularly attractive source of candidates for the development of new antibacterial agents. We synthesized 18 fusaricidin/LI-F analogues and investigated the effects of structure modification on their conformation, serum stability, antibacterial activity, and toxicity toward human cells. Our findings show that substitution of an ester bond in depsipeptides with an amide bond may afford equally potent analogues with improved stability and greatly decreased cytotoxicity. The lower overall hydrophobicity/amphiphilicity of amide analogues in comparison with their parent depsipeptides, as indicated by HPLC retention times, may explain the dissociation of antibacterial activity and human cell cytotoxicity. These results indicate that amide analogues may have significant advantages over fusaricidin/LI-F natural products and their depsipeptide analogues as lead structures for the development of new antibacterial agents.

Helical membrane peptides to modulate cell function

In recent years there has been an abundance of research into the potential of helical peptides to influence cell function. These peptides have been used to achieve a variety of different outcomes from cell repair to cell death, depending upon the peptide sequence and the nature of its interactions with cell membranes and membrane proteins. In this critical review, we summarise several mechanisms by which helical peptides, acting as either transporters, inhibitors, agonists or antibiotics, can have significant effects on cell membranes and can radically affect the internal mechanisms of the cell. The various approaches to peptide design are discussed, including the role of naturally-occurring proteins in the design of these helical peptides and current breakthroughs in the use of non-natural (and therefore more stable) peptide scaffolds. Most importantly, the current successful applications of these peptides, and their potential uses in the field of medicine, are reviewed (131 references).

Dissection of Antibacterial and Toxic Activity of Melittin

Melittin, a naturally occurring antimicrobial peptide, exhibits strong lytic activity against both eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells. Despite a tremendous amount of work done, very little is known about the amino acid sequence, which regulates its toxic activity. With the goal of understanding the basis of toxic activity and poor cell selectivity in melittin, a leucine zipper motif has been identified. To evaluate the possible structural and functional roles of this motif, melittin and its two analogs, after substituting the heptadic leucine by alanine, were synthesized and characterized. Functional studies indicated that alanine substitution in the leucine zipper motif resulted in a drastic reduction of the hemolytic activity of melittin. However, interestingly, both the designed analogs exhibited antibacterial activity comparable to melittin. Mutations caused a significant decrease in the membrane permeability of melittin in zwitterionic but not in negatively charged lipid vesicles. Although both the analogs exhibited similar secondary structures in the presence of negatively charged lipid vesicles as melittin, they failed to adopt a significant helical structure in the presence of zwitterionic lipid vesicles. Results suggest that the substitution of heptadic leucine by alanine impaired the assembly of melittin in an aqueous environment and its localization only in zwitterionic but not in negatively charged membrane. Altogether, the results suggest the identification of a structural element in melittin, which probably plays a prominent role in regulating its toxicity but not antibacterial activity. The results indicate that cell selectivity in some antimicrobial peptides can probably be introduced by modulating their assembly in an aqueous environment.

Modes of membrane interaction of a natural cysteine-rich peptide: viscotoxin A3

Among the very homologous family of alpha- and beta-thionins, known for their antimicrobial activity, the viscotoxin subfamily differs from other members because it is cytotoxic against tumoral cells but weakly hemolytic. We studied the interactions between the most active of these toxins, viscotoxin A3 (VA3), and model membranes made of phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylserine (PS), the major zwitterionic and acidic phospholipids found in eukaryotic cells. Monolayer studies showed that electrostatic forces are essential for the interaction and are mainly involved in modulating the embedding of the toxin in the PS head group region. This in turn induces membrane stiffening, as shown by fluorescence polarization assays with 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene and its derivatives. Moreover, vesicle permeabilization analyses showed that there are two modes of interaction, which are directly related to the stiffening effect and depend on the amount of VA3 bound to the surface of the vesicles. We propose an interaction model in which the embedding of VA3 in the membrane induces membrane defects leading to the gradual release of encapsulated dye. When the surfaces of the vesicles are saturated with the viscotoxin, complete vesicle destabilization is induced which leads to bilayer disruption, all-or-none encapsulated dye release and rearrangement of the vesicles.

A Pro --> Ala substitution in melittin affects self-association, membrane binding and pore-formation kinetics due to changes in structural and electrostatic properties

Melittin, the main component of bee venom of Apis mellifera, contains a proline at position 14, which is highly conserved in related peptides of various bee venoms. To investigate the structural and functional role of Pro14 a melittin analogue was studied where proline is substituted by an alanine residue (P14A). The investigations were focussed on: (i) the secondary structure in aqueous solution and membranes; (ii) the self-association in solution; (iii) the binding to POPC membranes; and (iv) the P14A-induced leakage and pore formation in membrane vesicles. Circular dichroism and gel filtration experiments showed that P14A exists at concentrations < 12 microM in monomeric form with an alpha-helicity of 28 +/- 7%. A further increase in peptide concentration leads to the formation of large aggregates consisting of 9 +/- 1 monomers. While binding studies with POPC vesicles revealed for P14A a stronger binding affinity towards membranes than for melittin, the peptide-induced leakage of fluorescent markers from vesicles was less efficient for P14A than for melittin. Furthermore, an unexpected efflux behaviour at high values of bound P14A was observed which indicated that the pore formation kinetics for P14A is more complex than it was reported for melittin. The different features of P14A in aggregation, binding and efflux compared to melittin are mainly ascribable directly to structural changes caused by the proline --> alanine substitution. Furthermore, the results indicate an improved screening of the positively charged residues of P14A by counterions which contributes additionally to the observed differences in peptide activities. It is suggested that the presence of proline in melittin is not only of structural importance but also influences indirectly the electrostatic properties of the native peptide.

Effects of ligand binding on the internal dynamics of maltose-binding protein

Ligand binding to proteins often causes large conformational changes. A typical example is maltose-binding protein (MBP), a member of the family of periplasmic binding proteins of Gram-negative bacteria. Upon binding of maltose, MBP undergoes a large structural change that closes the binding cleft, i.e. the distance between its two domains decreases. In contrast, binding of the larger, nonphysiological ligand beta-cyclodextrin does not result in closure of the binding cleft. We have investigated the dynamic properties of MBP in its different states using time-resolved tryptophan fluorescence anisotropy. We found that the 'empty' protein exhibits strong internal fluctuations that almost vanish upon ligand binding. The measured relaxation times corresponding to internal fluctuations can be interpreted as originating from two types of motion: wobbling of tryptophan side-chains relative to the protein backbone, and orientational fluctuations of entire domains. After binding of a ligand, domain motions are no longer detectable and the fluctuations of some of the tryptophan side-chains become rather restricted. This transformation into a more rigid state is observed upon binding of both ligands, maltose and the larger beta-cyclodextrin. The fluctuations of tryptophan side-chains in direct contact with the ligand, however, are affected in a slightly different way by the two ligands.

Aqueous solubilization of transmembrane peptide sequences with retention of membrane insertion and function

We recently reported that the peptide C-K4-M2GlyR mimics the action of chloride channels when incorporated into the apical membrane of cultured renal epithelial monolayers. C-K4-M2GlyR is one of a series of peptides that were prepared by the addition of lysine residues to the N- or C-terminus of the M2 transmembrane sequence of the brain glycine receptor. This study addresses how such modifications affect physical properties such as aqueous solubility, aggregation, and secondary structure, as well as the ability of the modified peptides to form channels in epithelial monolayers. A graded improvement in solubility with a concomitant decrease in aggregation in aqueous media was observed for the M2GlyR transmembrane sequences. Increases in short-circuit current (I(SC)) of epithelial monolayers were observed after treatment with some but not all of the peptides. The bioactivity was higher for the more soluble, less aggregated M2GlyR peptides. As described in our previous communication, sensitivity of channel activity to diphenylamine-2-carboxylate, a chloride channel blocker, and bumetanide, an inhibitor of the Na/K/2Cl cotransporter, was used to assess changes in chloride selectivity for the different assembled channel-forming peptides. The unmodified M2GlyR sequence and the modified peptides with less positive charge are more sensitive to these agents than are the more highly charged forms. This study shows that relatively insoluble transmembrane sequences can be modified such that they are easier to purify and deliver in the absence of organic solvents with retention of membrane association, insertion, and assembly.

The use of a long-lifetime component of tryptophan to detect slow orientational fluctuations of proteins

The membrane protein porin and a synthetic polypeptide of 21 hydrophobic residues were inserted into detergent micelles or lipid membranes, and the fluorescence of their single tryptophan residue was measured in the time-resolved and polarized mode. In all cases, the tryptophan fluorescence exhibits a long-lifetime component of about 20 ns. This long-lifetime component was exploited to detect slow orientational motions in the range of tens of nanoseconds via the anisotropy decay. For this purpose, the analysis of the anisotropy has to be extended to account for different orientations of the dipoles of the short- and long-lifetime components. This is demonstrated for porin and the polypeptide solubilized in micelles, in which the longest relaxation time reflects the rotational diffusion of the micelle. When the polypeptide is inserted into lipid membranes, it forms a membrane-spanning alpha-helix, and the slowest relaxation process is interpreted as reflecting orientational fluctuations of the helix.

Protection by chlorpromazine, albumin and bivalent cations against haemolysis induced by melittin, [Ala-14]melittin and whole bee venom

The ability of the peptides melittin, [Ala-14]melittin (P14A) and whole bee venom to lyse red blood cells (RBC) and to cause shape transformation, binding, partitioning and changes in volume of the cells during haemolysis, as well as the action of the bivalent cations Zn2+ and Ca2+, chlorpromazine, albumin and plasma on the peptide-induced haemolysis of RBC in high ionic-strength solution, have been investigated. The protective effect of all inhibitors depends on whether they have been added to the media before or after the cells. When added before the cells they reduced significantly the rate of peptide-induced haemolysis and shape transformation. The effect was maximal when agents acted simultaneously after introduction of the cells into the media containing both inhibitors and peptides. Incubation of the cells in isotonic solution before the addition of peptides enhanced 2-3-fold the RBC susceptibility (i.e. rate of haemolysis) to lytic action of the same amount of peptides, and increased the order of the haemolytic reaction, although the power law coefficient did not exceed a value of 2 for all peptides, suggesting that haemolysis is attributable to the monomeric or dimeric forms of the peptides. Partition coefficients were of the order of approximately 10(6) M-1, and P14A possessed a value 3-fold larger compared with melittin and bee venom, which correlated with its enhanced haemolytic activity. The protective action of inhibitors against peptide-induced haemolysis has been explained on the basis of their ability to compete with peptide binding at an early stage of peptide-membrane interaction, and not as a result of inhibition of a pre-existing peptide-induced pore. Whereas melittin increased the volume of RBC during haemolysis, P14A, melittin in the presence of phospholipase A2 or bee venom, reduced the volume in a concentration-dependent manner. The present data reveal the significant role of the initial stage of peptide-membrane interaction and peptide structure in the mechanism of haemolysis. These data are not consistent with a lipid-based mechanism of peptide-induced haemolysis, indicating that the mode of peptide-protein interaction is an important and decisive step in the haemolytic mechanism. It should be noted that data (in the form of three additional Tables) on the ability of inhibitors to protect cells from haemolysis when inhibitor and peptide act simultaneously are available. They are reported in Supplementary Publication SUP 50178, which has been deposited at the British Library Document Supply Centre, Boston Spa, Wetherby, West Yorkshire LS23 7BQ, U.K., from whom copies can be obtained on the terms indicated in Biochem. J. (1996) 313, 9.

A long lifetime component in the tryptophan fluorescence of some proteins

The tryptophan fluorescence of two membrane proteins (outer membrane protein A and lactose permease), a 21-residue hydrophobic peptide, three soluble proteins (rat serum albumin, ribonuclease T1, and azurin), and N-acetyltryptophanamide (NATA) was investigated by time-resolved measurements extended over 65 ns. A long lifetime component with a characteristic time of 25 ns and an amplitude below 1% was found for outer membrane protein A, lactose permease, the peptide in lipid membranes, and azurin in water, but not for rat serum albumin, ribonuclease T1, and NATA in water. When outer membrane protein A was dissolved and unfolded in guanidinum hydrochloride, the long lifetime component disappeared. Hence, a hydrophobic environment seems to be a necessary requirement for the long lifetime component to be present. However, NATA dissolved in butanol does not exhibit the long lifetime component, while the peptide dissolved in the same solvent under conditions which preserve its helical structure does show the long lifetime. Thus, a regular secondary structure for the polypeptide chain to which the tryptophan residue belongs seems to be a second necessary requirement for the long lifetime component to be present. The long lifetime component may therefore be seen in the context of protein substates.

The role of amphipathicity in the folding, self-association and biological activity of multiple subunit small proteins

The effect that altering amphipathicity has on the folding process and self association of melittin, a small model protein, has been investigated using single amino acid substitutions of lysine 7, a residue distant from the contact residues involved in the hydrophobic core of tetrameric melittin. While substitutions of such a residue were not expected to interfere with the packing process, the largest alterations in the potential overall amphipathicity of melittin were found to prevent the folding into an alpha-helical conformation to occur and, in turn, to prevent the self association. Amphipathic alpha-helices were found to be a key determining feature in the early folding process of the self association of peptides and protein segments. Those substitutions, which prevented the inducible amphipathic folding ability, were also found to result in a loss in hemolytic and antimicrobial activity. These results, combined with studies of the binding to artificial liposomes and to polysialic acids, indicate that the losses in activity were due to an initial inability to be induced into an amphipathic alpha-helix and to self associate. Ultimately, melittin's self association is proposed to be required to penetrate the carbohydrate barrier present in biological membranes.

Permeabilization of the mitochondrial inner membrane by short cecropin-A-melittin hybrid peptides

A number of cecropin-A-melittin hybrid peptides have previously been shown to be potent antibacterial agents [Andreu, D., Ubach, J., Boman, A., Wahlin, B., Wade, D., Merrifield, R. B. & Boman, H. G. (1992) FEBS Lett. 296, 190-194]. In the present report we analyze their action on biological systems using rat liver mitochondria as a test system. We demonstrate that the longest peptide, cecropin-A-(1-8)-melittin(1-18) permeabilizes the mitochondrial inner membrane allowing the movement of both charged and non-charged solutes. Concentrations used have already been shown to be bactericidal. This effect is also demonstrated under respiring conditions where succinate oxidation is uncoupled. Shorter analogs also permeabilize mitochondria although at ten-fold higher concentrations. Heparin potentiates the peptide effects at low concentrations, while at high concentration it becomes inhibitory. We propose that the cecropin-melittin analogs disrupt the mitochondrial membrane in a detergent-like mode rather than by creating selective channels as had been previously suggested.