Kinetic study of the aggregation and lipid mixing produced by alpha-sarcin on phosphatidylglycerol and phosphatidylserine vesicles: stopped-flow light scattering and fluorescence energy transfer measurements

The interaction of the ribotoxin α-sarcin with complex model lipid vesicles

Fungal ribotoxins are extracellular RNases that inactivate ribosomes by cleaving a single phosphodiester bond at the universally conserved sarcin-ricin loop of the large rRNA. However, to reach the ribosomes, they need to cross the plasma membrane. It is there where these toxins show their cellular specificity, being especially active against tumoral or virus-infected cells. Previous studies have shown that fungal ribotoxins interact with negatively charged membranes, typically containing phosphatidylserine or phosphatidylglycerol. This ability is rooted on their long, non-structured, positively charged loops, and its N-terminal β-hairpin. However, its effect on complex lipid mixtures, including sphingophospholipids or cholesterol, remains poorly studied. Here, wild-type α-sarcin was used to evaluate its interaction with a variety of membranes not assayed before, which resemble much more closely mammalian cell membranes. The results confirm that α-sarcin is particularly sensitive to charge density on the vesicle surface. Its ability to induce vesicle aggregation is strongly influenced by both the lipid headgroup and the degree of saturation of the fatty acid chains. Acyl chain length is indeed particularly important for lipid mixing. Finally, cholesterol plays an important role in diluting the concentration of available negative charges and modulates the ability of α-sarcin to cross the membrane.

Involvement of loops 2 and 3 of α-sarcin on its ribotoxic activity

Ribotoxins are a family of fungal ribosome-inactivating proteins displaying highly specific ribonucleolytic activity against the sarcin/ricin loop (SRL) of the larger rRNA, with α-sarcin as its best-characterized member. Their toxicity arises from the combination of this activity with their ability to cross cell membranes. The involvement of α-sarcin's loops 2 and 3 in SRL and ribosomal proteins recognition, as well as in the ribotoxin-lipid interactions involving cell penetration, has been suggested some time ago. In the work presented now different mutants have been prepared in order to study the role of these loops in their ribonucleolytic and lipid-interacting properties. The results obtained confirm that loop 3 residues Lys 111, 112, and 114 are key actors of the specific recognition of the SRL. In addition, it is also shown that Lys 114 and Tyr 48 conform a network of interactions which is essential for the catalysis. Lipid-interaction studies show that this Lys-rich region is indeed involved in the phospholipids recognition needed to cross cell membranes. Loop 2 is shown to be responsible for the conformational change which exposes the region establishing hydrophobic interactions with the membrane inner leaflets and eases penetration of ribotoxins target cells.

Hirsutellin A: A Paradigmatic Example of the Insecticidal Function of Fungal Ribotoxins

The fungal pathogen Hirsutella thompsonii produces an insecticidal protein named hirsutellin A (HtA), which has been described to be toxic to several species of mites, insect larvae, and cells. On the other hand, on the basis of an extensive biochemical and structural characterization, HtA has been considered to be a member of the ribotoxins family. Ribotoxins are fungal extracellular ribonucleases, which inactivate ribosomes by specifically cleaving a single phosphodiester bond located at the large rRNA. Although ribotoxins were brought to light in the 1960s as antitumor agents, their biological function has remained elusive. Thus, the consideration of hirsutellin A, an insecticidal protein, as a singular ribotoxin recalled the idea of the biological activity of these toxins as insecticidal agents. Further studies have demonstrated that the most representative member of the ribotoxin family, α-sarcin, also shows strong toxic action against insect cells. The determination of high resolution structures, the characterization of a large number of mutants, and the toxicity assays against different cell lines have been the tools used for the study of the mechanism of action of ribotoxins at the molecular level. The aim of this review is to serve as a compilation of the facts that allow identification of HtA as a paradigmatic example of the insecticidal function of fungal ribotoxins.

Fungal extracellular ribotoxins as insecticidal agents

Fungal ribotoxins were discovered almost 50 years ago as extracellular ribonucleases (RNases) with antitumoral properties. However, the biological function of these toxic proteins has remained elusive. The discovery of the ribotoxin HtA, produced by the invertebrates pathogen Hirsutella thompsonii, revived the old proposal that insecticidal activity would be their long searched function. Unfortunately, HtA is rather singular among all ribotoxins known in terms of sequence and structure similarities. Thus, it was intriguing to answer the question of whether HtA is just an exception or, on the contrary, the paradigmatic example of the ribotoxins function. The work presented uses HtA and α-sarcin, the most representative member of the ribotoxins family, to show their strong toxic action against insect larvae and cells.

The insecticidal protein hirsutellin A from the mite fungal pathogen Hirsutella thompsonii is a ribotoxin

The mite fungal pathogen Hirsutella thompsonii produces a single polypeptide chain, insecticidal protein named hirsutellin A (HtA) that is composed of 130 amino acid residues. This protein has been purified from its natural source and produced as a recombinant protein in Escherichia coli. Spectroscopic analysis has determined that the two protein forms are indistinguishable. HtA specifically inactivates ribosomes and produces the alpha-fragment characteristic of ribotoxin activity on rRNA. Behaving as a cyclizing ribonuclease, HtA specifically cleaves oligonucleotides that mimick the sarcin/ricin loop of the ribosome, as well as selected polynucleotides and dinucleosides. HtA interacts with phospholipid membranes as do other ribotoxins. As a consequence of its ribonuclease activity and its ability to interact with cell membranes, HtA exhibits cytotoxic activity on human tumor cells. On the basis of these results, HtA is considered to be a member of the ribotoxin group of proteins, although it is significantly smaller (130 aa) than all known ribotoxins that are composed of 149/150 amino acids. Ribotoxins are members of a larger family of fungal ribonucleases whose members of smaller size (100/110 aa) are not cytotoxic. Thus, the characterization of the fungal ribotoxin HtA represents an important milestone in the study of the diversity and the function of fungal ribonucleases.

Fungal ribotoxins: molecular dissection of a family of natural killers

RNase T1 is the best known representative of a large family of ribonucleolytic proteins secreted by fungi, mostly Aspergillus and Penicillium species. Ribotoxins stand out among them by their cytotoxic character. They exert their toxic action by first entering the cells and then cleaving a single phosphodiester bond located within a universally conserved sequence of the large rRNA gene, known as the sarcin-ricin loop. This cleavage leads to inhibition of protein biosynthesis, followed by cellular death by apoptosis. Although no protein receptor has been found for ribotoxins, they preferentially kill cells showing altered membrane permeability, such as those that are infected with virus or transformed. Many steps of the cytotoxic process have been elucidated at the molecular level by means of a variety of methodological approaches and the construction and purification of different mutant versions of these ribotoxins. Ribotoxins have been used for the construction of immunotoxins, because of their cytotoxicity. Besides this activity, Aspf1, a ribotoxin produced by Aspergillus fumigatus, has been shown to be one of the major allergens involved in allergic aspergillosis-related pathologies. Protein engineering and peptide synthesis have been used in order to understand the basis of these pathogenic mechanisms as well as to produce hypoallergenic proteins with potential diagnostic and immunotherapeutic applications.

The role of electrostatic interactions in the antitumor activity of dimeric RNases

The cytotoxic action of some ribonucleases homologous to bovine pancreatic RNase A, the superfamily prototype, has interested and intrigued investigators. Their ribonucleolytic activity is essential for their cytotoxic action, and their target RNA is in the cytosol. It has been proposed that the cytosolic RNase inhibitor (cRI) plays a major role in determining the ability of an RNase to be cytotoxic. However, to interact with cRI RNases must reach the cytosol, and cross intracellular membranes. To investigate the interactions of cytotoxic RNases with membranes, cytotoxic dimeric RNases resistant, or considered to be resistant to cRI, were assayed for their effects on negatively charged membranes. Furthermore, we analyzed the electrostatic interaction energy of the RNases complexed in silico with a model membrane. The results of this study suggest that close correlations can be recognized between the cytotoxic action of a dimeric RNase and its ability to complex and destabilize negatively charged membranes.

Tyr-48, a conserved residue in ribotoxins, is involved in the RNA-degrading activity of α-sarcin

Residue Tyr-48 in alpha-sarcin is conserved not only within the ribotoxin family, but also within the larger group of extracellular fungal ribonucleases, best represented by RNase T1. A mutant protein in which this Tyr residue was substituted by Phe has been produced and isolated to homogeneity. It was spectroscopically analyzed by means of circular dichroism, fluorescence emission and NMR. Taken together, these results and those from enzyme characterization have revealed the essential role of the -OH group from the Tyr-48 phenolic ring in the cleavage of polymeric RNA substrates, including the ribosome-embedded 28S rRNA, the natural substrate of ribotoxins. Thus, the mutant protein does not degrade its natural ribosomal RNA substrate. However, it has been shown that this Y48F mutant still retains its ability to cleave a phosphodiester bond in a minimal substrate such as the dinucleoside phosphate ApA. The role of different alpha-sarcin residues within the enzyme reaction catalyzed by this protein is discussed.

Deletion of the NH2-terminal beta-hairpin of the ribotoxin alpha-sarcin produces a nontoxic but active ribonuclease

Ribotoxins are a family of highly specific fungal ribonucleases that inactivate the ribosomes by hydrolysis of a single phosphodiester bond of the 28 S rRNA. alpha-Sarcin, the best characterized member of this family, is a potent cytotoxin that promotes apoptosis of human tumor cells after internalization via endocytosis. This latter ability is related to its interaction with phospholipid bilayers. These proteins share a common structural core with nontoxic ribonucleases of the RNase T1 family. However, significant structural differences between these two groups of proteins are related to the presence of a long amino-terminal beta-hairpin in ribotoxins and to the different length of their unstructured loops. The amino-terminal deletion mutant Delta(7-22) of alpha-sarcin has been produced in Escherichia coli and purified to homogeneity. It retains the same conformation as the wild-type protein as ascertained by complete spectroscopic characterization based on circular dichroism, fluorescence, and NMR techniques. This mutant exhibits ribonuclease activity against naked rRNA and synthetic substrates but lacks the specific ability of the wild-type protein to degrade rRNA in intact ribosomes. The results indicate that alpha-sarcin interacts with the ribosome at two regions, i.e. the well known sarcin-ricin loop of the rRNA and a different region recognized by the beta-hairpin of the protein. In addition, this latter protein portion is involved in interaction with cell membranes. The mutant displays decreased interaction with lipid vesicles and shows behavior compatible with the absence of one vesicle-interacting region. In agreement with this conclusion, the deletion mutant exhibits a very low cytotoxicity on human rhabdomyosarcoma cells.

Arginine 121 is a crucial residue for the specific cytotoxic activity of the ribotoxin alpha-sarcin

Alpha-sarcin, a cyclizing ribonuclease secreted by the mould Aspergillus giganteus, is one of the best characterized members of a family of fungal ribotoxins. This protein induces apoptosis in tumour cells due to its highly specific activity on ribosomes. Fungal ribotoxins display a three-dimensional protein fold similar to those of a larger group of microbial noncytotoxic RNases, represented by RNases T1 and U2. This similarity involves the three catalytic residues and also the Arg121 residue, whose counterpart in RNase T1, Arg77, is located in the vicinity of the substrate phosphate moiety although its potential functional role is not known. In this work, Arg121 of alpha-sarcin has been replaced by Gln or Lys. These two mutations do not modify the conformation of the protein but abolish the ribosome-inactivating activity of alpha-sarcin. In addition, the loss of the positive charge at that position produces dramatic changes on the interaction of alpha-sarcin with phospholipid membranes. It is concluded that Arg121 is a crucial residue for the characteristic cytotoxicity of alpha-sarcin and presumably of the other fungal ribotoxins.

Involvement of the amino-terminal beta-hairpin of the Aspergillus ribotoxins on the interaction with membranes and nonspecific ribonuclease activity

Ribotoxins are a family of potent cytotoxic proteins from Aspergillus whose members display a high sequence identity (85% for about 150 amino acid residues). The three-dimensional structures of two of these proteins, alpha-sarcin and restrictocin, are known. They interact with phospholipid bilayers, according to their ability to enter cells, and cleave a specific phosphodiester bond in the large subunit of ribosome thus inhibiting protein biosynthesis. Two nonconservative sequence changes between these proteins are located at the amino-terminal beta-hairpin of alpha-sarcin, a characteristic structure that is absent in other nontoxic structurally related microbial RNases. These two residues of alpha-sarcin, Lys 11 and Thr 20, have been substituted with the equivalent amino acids in restrictocin. The single mutants (K11L and T20D) and the corresponding K11L/T20D double mutant have been produced in Escherichia coli and purified to homogeneity. The spectroscopic characterization of the purified proteins reveals that the overall native structure is preserved. The ribonuclease and lipid-perturbing activities of the three mutants and restrictocin have been evaluated and compared with those of alpha-sarcin. These proteins exhibit the same ability to specifically inactivate ribosomes, although they show different activity against nonspecific substrate analogs such as poly(A). The mutant variant K11L and restrictocin display a lower phospholipid-interacting ability correlated with a decreased cytotoxicity. The results obtained are interpreted in terms of the involvement of the amino-terminal beta-hairpin in the interaction with both membranes and polyadenylic acid.

Assignment of the contribution of the tryptophan residues to the spectroscopic and functional properties of the ribotoxin alpha-sarcin

alpha-Sarcin, a potent cytotoxic protein from Aspergillus giganteus, contains two tryptophan residues at positions 4 and 51. Two single, W4F and W51F, and the double mutant, W4/51F, have been produced and purified to homogeneity. These two residues are neither required for the highly specific ribonucleolytic activity of the protein on the ribosomes (production of the so called alpha-fragment) nor for its interaction with lipid membranes (aggregation and fusion of vesicles), although the mutant forms involving Trp-51 show a decreased ribonuclease activity. Proton NMR data reveal that no significant changes in the global structure of the enzyme occur upon replacement of Trp-51 by Phe. Substitution of each Trp residue results in a 4 degrees C drop in the thermal denaturation midpoint, and the double mutant's midpoint is 9 degrees C lower. Trp-51 is responsible for most of the near-UV circular dichroism of the protein and also contributes to the overall ellipticity of the protein in the peptide bond region. Trp-51 does not show fluorescence emission. The membrane-bound proteins undergo a thermal denaturation at a lower temperature than the corresponding free forms. The interaction of the protein with phospholipid bilayers promotes a large increase of the quantum yield of Trp-51 and its fluorescence emission is quenched by anthracene incorporated into the hydrophobic region of such bilayers. This indicates that the region around this residue is located in the hydrophobic core of the bilayer following protein-vesicle interaction.

The pH-dependent interaction of cinnamomin with lipid membranes investigated by fluorescence methods

Cinnamomin, a new type II ribosome-inactivating protein (RIP), was found to be able to induce the release of calcein loaded in lecithin small unilamellar vesicles and the fusion or aggregation of the lecithin liposomes. Such induction could be promoted severalfold by a pH 5.0 environment, a condition similar to that in endocytic vesicles. Lowering the pH from 7.5 to 5.0 evoked conformational changes of cinnamomin and unmasked its hydrophobic areas, including the exposure of 1-anilino-8-naphthalenesulfonate (1,8-ANS) binding sites of the molecule. Some tryptophan residues with affinity to acrylamide were demonstrated to participate in the lipid-protein interaction. The pH dependent fusogenicity of type II RIP might suggest its in vivo function as a fusogen to exert its cytotoxicity.

Ribotoxins are a more widespread group of proteins within the filamentous fungi than previously believed

Alpha-sarcin, restrictocin and mitogillin are the best known members of the family of fungal ribotoxins. In recent years, new members of this family have been discovered and characterised. In this work, we study the occurrence of ribotoxins among different species of fungi. The presence of ribotoxins has been identified in some new species by means of genetic studies, as well as expression and activity assays. The ribotoxin genes have been partially sequenced, and demonstrate a high degree of similarity. These studies demonstrate that these toxins are more widespread than previously considered. This is surprising, considering the ribotoxins are such specific and potent toxins, of unknown biological function. These studies confirm the hypothesis that these proteins are naturally engineered toxins derived from ribonucleases of broad substrate specificity.

Oligomerization of the cytotoxin alpha-sarcin associated with phospholipid membranes

alpha-Sarcin is a cytotoxic protein that specifically inactivates ribosomes. The protein translocates across phospholipid membranes. Oligomerization of the protein occurs upon interaction with membranes. Chemically cross-linked protein oligomers have been obtained by treatment of protein-vesicle complexes with the membrane impermeant reagent bis-(sulfosuccinimidyl) suberate. These structures are only obtained in the presence of acidic lipid vesicles composed of either natural or synthetic phospholipids. Such oligomers are not produced in concentrated protein solutions in the absence of vesicles. The formation of the chemically stabilized oligomers is saturated at the same lipid to protein molar ratio as all the perturbations caused by alpha-sarcin on lipid vesicles. Results are discussed in terms of the involvement of oligomer formation on protein translocation across membranes.

A peptide of nine amino acid residues from alpha-sarcin cytotoxin is a membrane-perturbing structure

A water-soluble synthetic peptide with only nine amino acid residues, comprising the 131-139 sequence region of the cytotoxic protein alpha-sarcin (secreted by the mold Aspergillus giganteus), interacts with large unilamellar vesicles composed of acid phospholipids. It promotes lipid mixing between bilayers and leakage of vesicle aqueous contents, and it also abolishes the phospholipid phase transition. Other larger peptides containing such an amino acid sequence also produce these effects. These peptides acquire alpha-helical conformation in the presence of trifluoroethanol, but display beta-strand conformation in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate. The interaction of these peptides with the lipid vesicles also results in beta-structure. The obtained data are discussed in terms of the involvement of the 131-139 stretch of alpha-sarcin in its interaction with lipid membranes.

Release of lipid vesicle contents by an antibacterial cecropin A-melittin hybrid peptide

A synthetic cecropin A(1-8)-melittin(1-18) hybrid peptide, with antimalarial and antibacterial properties, promotes leakage of aqueous contents of phospholipid vesicles, as determined by measuring the induced release of vesicle-entrapped fluorescence probes. The release of vesicle contents corresponds to an all-or-none mechanism. High molecular weight entrapped solutes (fluorescence-labeled dextrans, 20 and 4 kDa molecular mass) are also released by the peptide. This fact and the high peptide stoichiometry required for the release of vesicle contents suggest a detergent-like disruption of the bilayer. The leakage process is not related to any membrane event requiring lipid-mixing between bilayers. The peptide destabilizes both negatively and neutrally charged phospholipid vesicles. The thermal variation of the fluorescence anisotropy of 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene-labeled vesicles is modified by the peptide. Circular dichroism and tryptophan fluorescence emission spectra reveal conformational changes in the peptide molecule upon interaction with the lipid vesicles. These changes are consistent with an increased alpha-helical content and a less polar environment for the single tryptophan residue of the peptide. The leakage induced in phosphatidylserine vesicles is a faster process than in phosphatidylcholine vesicles, while the peptide is more effective in releasing the contents of the latter type of vesicles. This suggests that acidic phospholipids may modulate the effect of the peptide on membranes.

Thermal unfolding of the cytotoxin alpha-sarcin: phospholipid binding induces destabilization of the protein structure

The effect of membrane binding on the structure and stability of the cytotoxin alpha-sarcin has been studied by differential scanning calorimetry, Fourier-transform infrared and fluorescence spectroscopic techniques. The thermal unfolding of alpha-sarcin in aqueous solution fits into a two-state transition characterized by a transition temperature (Tm) of 52.6 degrees C and a calorimetric enthalpy (delta Hcal) of 136 kcal/mol. Upon interaction with phosphatidylglycerol vesicles, alpha-sarcin undergoes conformational changes, as deduced from the FTIR and fluorescence emission spectra. These changes result in a decreased Tm and delta Hcal values for the thermal unfolding of phospholipid-bound alpha-sarcin. The lower Tm value for lipid-bound alpha-sarcin is also observed at the level of secondary and tertiary structures, based on analyses of both the amide I' infrared spectrum and the tryptophan emission of the protein as a function of temperature, respectively. The results obtained indicate a protein destabilization promoted by the phospholipid interaction.

Spectroscopic characterization of the alkylated alpha-sarcin cytotoxin: analysis of the structural requirements for the protein-lipid bilayer hydrophobic interaction

alpha-Sarcin is a ribosome-inactivating protein that translocates across lipid bilayers, these two abilities explaining its cytotoxic character. This protein is composed of a single polypeptide chain with two disulfide bridges. Reduction and carboxyamidomethylation of alpha-sarcin results in protein unfolding, based on the results of the spectroscopic characterization of the chemically modified protein. The absorption and fluorescence emission bands of the tryptophan residues of the modified protein appear blue- and red-shifted, respectively. Far-UV circular dichroism analysis reveals the presence of residual secondary structure (beta-strands and turns) in the alkylated protein. This retains its ability to interact with lipid bilayers. It promotes vesicle aggregation, lipid-mixing between bilayers and leakage of the intravesicular aqueous contents. The modified protein tends to abolish the phase transition of acid phospholipids as detected by differential scanning calorimetry and depolarization measurements of fluorescence-labelled vesicles. The protein gain access to vesicle-entrapped trypsin. The fluorescence emission of the tryptophan residues is blue-shifted upon interaction of the protein with the bilayers, and anthracene incorporated into the hydrophobic core of the membranes quenches the tryptophan fluorescence emission of the protein. The secondary structure of the alkylated protein interacting with lipid vesicles has been studied by infrared spectroscopy. An increase in the alpha-helix and turn contents and a concomitant decrease in the beta-structure content are observed upon interaction with the bilayers. The results obtained are discussed in terms of the structural requirements for the interaction of alpha-sarcin with lipid membranes.

Substitution of histidine-137 by glutamine abolishes the catalytic activity of the ribosome-inactivating protein alpha-sarcin

The alpha-sarcin cytotoxin is an extracellular fungal protein that inhibits protein biosynthesis by specifically cleaving one phosphodiester bond of the 28 S rRNA. The His137 residue of alpha-sarcin is suggested to be involved in the catalytic activity of this protein, based on the observed sequence similarity with some fungal ribonucleases. Replacement of this residue by Gln (H137Q mutant variant of alpha-sarcin) abolishes the ribonuclease activity of the protein. This has been demonstrated for an homogeneous preparation of the H137Q alpha-sarcin by measuring its effect against both intact rabbit ribosomes and the homopolymer poly(A). The conformation of H137Q alpha-sarcin is highly similar to that of the wild-type protein, which has been analysed by CD and fluorescence spectroscopy. Both H137Q and wild-type alpha-sarcin exhibit identical CD spectra in the peptide-bond region, indicating that no changes at the level of the secondary structure are produced upon mutation. Only minor differences are observed in both near-UV CD and fluorescence emission spectra in comparison to those of the wild-type protein. Moreover, H137Q alpha-sarcin interacts with phospholipid vesicles, promoting the same effects as the native cytotoxin. Therefore, we propose that His137 is part of the ribonucleolytic active site of the cytotoxin alpha-sarcin.

Membrane interaction of a beta-structure-forming synthetic peptide comprising the 116-139th sequence region of the cytotoxic protein alpha-sarcin

alpha-Sarcin is a cytotoxic protein that strongly interacts with acid phospholipid vesicles. This interaction exhibits a hydrophobic component although alpha-sarcin is a highly polar protein. A peptide comprising the amino acid sequence corresponding to the 116-139th segment of the alpha-sarcin cytotoxin has been synthesized by a standard fluoren-9-yl-methoxycarbonyl-based solid phase method. Its primary structure is: (116)-NPGPARVIYTYPNKVFCGIIAHTK-(139). Two beta-strands have been predicted in this region of alpha-sarcin, where the less polar stretches of the protein are found. The synthetic peptide interacts with negatively charged large unilamellar vesicles of either natural or synthetic phospholipids. An apparent fragmentation of the vesicles is produced by the peptide based on electron microscopy studies. The peptide promotes leakage of the intravesicular aqueous contents and lipid mixing of bilayers. The packing of the phospholipid molecules is greatly perturbed by the peptide, as deduced from the drastic changes induced by the peptide in cooperative properties associated with the phase transition of the bilayers. At saturating peptide/phospholipid ratios, the phase transition of dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol vesicles is abolished. All of these effects are saturated at about 0.3 peptide/lipid molar ratio. The peptide adopts a mostly random structure in aqueous solution. A conformation composed of a high proportion of antiparallel beta-sheet is induced as a consequence of the interaction with the phospholipid vesicles in opposition to trifluoroethanol that promotes alpha-helical peptide structures, as deduced from circular dichroism measurements. The obtained results are discussed in terms of the potential involvement of the region comprising residues 116-139 of alpha-sarcin in the hydrophobic interactions of this cytotoxic protein with membranes.