Intrinsic and extrinsic factors affecting phrenic motoneuronal excitability in neonatal rats

Recruitment of Motoneurons

Beginning about half a century ago, the rules that determine how motor units are recruited during movement have been deduced. These classical experiments led to the formulation of the 'size principle'. It is now clear that motoneuronal size is not the only indicator of recruitment order. In fact, motoneuronal passive, active and synaptic conductances are carefully tuned to achieve sequential recruitment. More recent studies, over the last decade or so, show that the premotor circuitry is also functionally specialized and differentially recruited. Modular sub networks of interneurons and their post-synaptic motoneurons have been shown to drive movements with varying intensities. In addition, these modular networks are under the influence of neuromodulators, which are capable of acting upon multiple motor and premotor targets, thereby altering behavioral outcomes. We discuss the recruitment patterns of motoneurons in light of these new and exciting studies.

Convergence of pattern generator outputs on a common mechanism of diaphragm motor unit recruitment

Motor units are the final element of neuromotor control. In manner analogous to the organization of neuromotor control in other skeletal muscles, diaphragm motor units comprise phrenic motoneurons located in the cervical spinal cord that innervate the diaphragm muscle, the main inspiratory muscle in mammals. Diaphragm motor units play a primary role in sustaining ventilation but are also active in other nonventilatory behaviors, including coughing, sneezing, vomiting, defecation, and parturition. Diaphragm muscle fibers comprise all fiber types. Thus, diaphragm motor units display substantial differences in contractile and fatigue properties, but importantly, properties of the motoneuron and muscle fibers within a motor unit are matched. As in other skeletal muscles, diaphragm motor units are recruited in order such that motor units that display greater fatigue resistance are recruited earlier and more often than more fatigable motor units. The properties of the motor unit population are critical determinants of the function of a skeletal muscle across the range of possible motor tasks. Accordingly, fatigue-resistant motor units are sufficient to generate the forces necessary for ventilatory behaviors, whereas more fatigable units are only activated during expulsive behaviors important for airway clearance. Neuromotor control of diaphragm motor units may reflect selective inputs from distinct pattern generators distributed according to the motor unit properties necessary to accomplish these different motor tasks. In contrast, widely distributed inputs to phrenic motoneurons from various pattern generators (e.g., for breathing, coughing, or vocalization) would dictate recruitment order based on intrinsic electrophysiological properties.

Impact of diaphragm muscle fiber atrophy on neuromotor control

In skeletal muscles, motor units comprise a motoneuron and the group of muscle fibers innervated by it, which are usually classified based on myosin heavy chain isoform expression. Motor units displaying diverse contractile and fatigue properties are important in determining the range of motor behaviors that can be accomplished by a muscle. Muscle fiber atrophy and weakness may disproportionately affect specific fiber types across a variety of diseases or clinical conditions, thus impacting neuromotor control. In this regard, fiber atrophy that affects a specific fiber type will alter the relative contribution of different motor units to overall muscle structure and function. For example, in various diseases there is fairly selective atrophy of type IIx and/or IIb fibers comprising the strongest yet most fatigable motor units. As a result, there is muscle weakness (i.e., reductions in force per cross-sectional area) associated with an apparent improvement in resistance to fatiguing contractions. This review will examine neuromotor control of respiratory muscles such as the diaphragm muscle and the impact of muscle fiber atrophy on motor performance.

Neuromotor control in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

Neuromotor control of skeletal muscles, including respiratory muscles, is ultimately dependent on the structure and function of the motor units (motoneurons and the muscle fibers they innervate) comprising the muscle. In most muscles, considerable diversity of contractile and fatigue properties exists across motor units, allowing a range of motor behaviors. In diseases such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), there may be disproportional primary (disease related) or secondary effects (related to treatment or other concomitant factors) on the size and contractility of specific muscle fiber types that would influence the relative contribution of different motor units. For example, with COPD there is a disproportionate atrophy of type IIx and/or IIb fibers that comprise more fatigable motor units. Thus fatigue resistance may appear to improve, while overall motor performance (e.g., 6-min walk test) and endurance (e.g., reduced aerobic exercise capacity) are diminished. There are many coexisting factors that might also influence motor performance. For example, in COPD patients, there may be concomitant hypoxia and/or hypercapnia, physical inactivity and unloading of muscles, and corticosteroid treatment, all of which may disproportionately affect specific muscle fiber types, thereby influencing neuromotor control. Future studies should address how plasticity in motor units can be harnessed to mitigate the functional impact of COPD-induced changes.

Phrenic motor unit recruitment during ventilatory and non-ventilatory behaviors

Phrenic motoneurons are located in the cervical spinal cord and innervate the diaphragm muscle, the main inspiratory muscle in mammals. Similar to other skeletal muscles, phrenic motoneurons and diaphragm muscle fibers form motor units which are the final element of neuromotor control. In addition to their role in sustaining ventilation, phrenic motor units are active in other non-ventilatory behaviors important for airway clearance such as coughing or sneezing. Diaphragm muscle fibers comprise all fiber types and are commonly classified based on expression of contractile proteins including myosin heavy chain isoforms. Although there are differences in contractile and fatigue properties across motor units, there is a matching of properties for the motor neuron and muscle fibers within a motor unit. Motor units are generally recruited in order such that fatigue-resistant motor units are recruited earlier and more often than more fatigable motor units. Thus, in sustaining ventilation, fatigue-resistant motor units are likely required. Based on a series of studies in cats, hamsters and rats, an orderly model of motor unit recruitment was proposed that takes into consideration the maximum forces generated by single type-identified diaphragm muscle fibers as well as the proportion of the different motor unit types. Using this model, eupnea can be accomplished by activation of only slow-twitch diaphragm motor units and only a subset of fast-twitch, fatigue-resistant units. Activation of fast-twitch fatigable motor units only becomes necessary when accomplishing tasks that require greater force generation by the diaphragm muscle, e.g., sneezing and coughing.

Neural control of phrenic motoneuron discharge

Phrenic motoneurons (PMNs) provide a synaptic relay between bulbospinal respiratory pathways and the diaphragm muscle. PMNs also receive propriospinal inputs, although the functional role of these interneuronal projections has not been established. Here we review the literature regarding PMN discharge patterns during breathing and the potential mechanisms that underlie PMN recruitment. Anatomical and neurophysiological studies indicate that PMNs form a heterogeneous pool, with respiratory-related PMN discharge and recruitment patterns likely determined by a balance between intrinsic MN properties and extrinsic synaptic inputs. We also review the limited literature regarding PMN bursting during respiratory plasticity. Differential recruitment or rate modulation of PMN subtypes may underlie phrenic motor plasticity following neural injury and/or respiratory stimulation; however, this possibility remains relatively unexplored.

Phrenic motoneuron discharge patterns during hypoxia-induced short-term potentiation in rats

Hypoxia-induced short-term potentiation (STP) of respiratory motor output is manifested by a progressive increase in activity after the acute hypoxic response and a gradual decrease in activity on termination of hypoxia. We hypothesized that STP would be differentially expressed between physiologically defined phrenic motoneurons (PhrMNs). Phrenic nerve "single fiber" recordings were used to characterize PhrMN discharge in anesthetized, vagotomized and ventilated rats. PhrMNs were classified as early (Early-I) or late inspiratory (Late-I) according to burst onset relative to the contralateral phrenic neurogram during normocapnic baseline conditions. During hypoxia (F(I)O(2) = 0.12-0.14, 3 min), both Early-I and Late-I PhrMNs abruptly increased discharge frequency. Both cell types also showed a progressive increase in frequency over the remainder of hypoxia. However, Early-I PhrMNs showed reduced overall discharge duration and total spikes/breath during hypoxia, whereas Late-I PhrMNs maintained constant discharge duration and therefore increased the number of spikes/breath. A population of previously inactive (i.e., silent) PhrMNs was recruited 48 +/- 8 s after hypoxia onset. These PhrMNs had a Late-I onset, and the majority (8/9) ceased bursting promptly on termination of hypoxia. In contrast, both Early-I and Late-I PhrMNs showed post-hypoxia STP as reflected by greater discharge frequencies and spikes/breath during the post-hypoxic period (P < 0.01 vs. baseline). We conclude that the expression of phrenic STP during hypoxia reflects increased activity in previously active Early-I and Late-I PhrMNs and recruitment of silent PhrMNs. post-hypoxia STP primarily reflects persistent increases in the discharge of PhrMNs, which were active before hypoxia.

Trophic factor expression in phrenic motor neurons

The function of a motor neuron and the muscle fibers it innervates (i.e., a motor unit) determines neuromotor output. Unlike other skeletal muscles, respiratory muscles (e.g., the diaphragm, DIAm) must function from birth onwards in sustaining ventilation. DIAm motor units are capable of both ventilatory and non-ventilatory behaviors, including expulsive behaviors important for airway clearance. There is significant diversity in motor unit properties across different types of motor units in the DIAm. The mechanisms underlying the development and maintenance of motor unit diversity in respiratory muscles (including the DIAm) are not well understood. Recent studies suggest that trophic factor influences contribute to this diversity. Remarkably little is known about the expression of trophic factors and their receptors in phrenic motor neurons. This review will focus on the contribution of trophic factors to the establishment and maintenance of motor unit diversity in the DIAm, during development and in response to injury or disease.

Key aspects of phrenic motoneuron and diaphragm muscle development during the perinatal period

At the time of birth, respiratory muscles must be activated to sustain ventilation. The perinatal development of respiratory motor units (comprising an individual motoneuron and the muscle fibers it innervates) shows remarkable features that enable mammals to transition from in utero conditions to the air environment in which the remainder of their life will occur. In addition, significant postnatal maturation is necessary to provide for the range of motor behaviors necessary during breathing, swallowing, and speech. As the main inspiratory muscle, the diaphragm muscle (and the phrenic motoneurons that innervate it) plays a key role in accomplishing these behaviors. Considerable diversity exists across diaphragm motor units, but the determinant factors for this diversity are unknown. In recent years, the mechanisms underlying the development of respiratory motor units have received great attention, and this knowledge may provide the opportunity to design appropriate interventions for the treatment of respiratory disease not only in the perinatal period but likely also in the adult.

GABAB-receptor-mediated suppression of sympathetic outflow from the spinal cord of neonatal rats

Using a splanchnic nerve-spinal cord preparation in vitro that could spontaneously generate sympathetic nerve discharge (SND), we investigated the roles of intraspinal GABAB receptors in the regulation of SND. Despite an age-dependent difference in sensitivity, bath applications of baclofen (Bac; GABAB-receptor agonist) consistently reduced SND in a concentration-dependent manner. The drug specificity of Bac in activation of GABAB receptors was verified by application of its antagonist saclofen (Sac) or CGP-46381 (CGP). Sac or CGP alone did not change SND. However, in the presence of Sac or CGP, the effects of Bac on SND inhibition were reversibly attenuated. The splanchnic sympathetic preganglionic neuron (SPN) was recorded by blind whole cell, patch-clamp techniques. We examined Bac effects on electrical membrane properties of SPNs. Applications of Bac reduced excitatory synaptic events, induced membrane hyperpolarizations, and inhibited SPN firing. In the presence of 12 mM Mg2+ or 0.5 μM TTX to block Ca2+- or action potential-dependent synaptic transmissions, applications of Bac induced an outward baseline current that reversed at −29 ± 6 mV. Because the K+ equilibrium potential in our experimental conditions was −100 mV, the Bac-induced currents could not simply be attributed to an alteration of K+ conductance. On the other hand, applications of Bac to Cs+-loaded SPNs reduced Cd2+-sensitive and high-voltage-activated inward currents, indicating an inhibition of voltage-gated Ca2+ currents. Our results suggest that the activation of intraspinal GABAB receptors suppresses SND via a mixture of ion events that may link to a change in Ca2+ conductance.

A model of the rat phrenic motor neuron

We have developed a model for the rat phrenic motor neuron (PMN) that robustly replicates many experimentally observed behaviors of PMNs in response to pharmacological, ionic, and electrical perturbations using a single set of parameters. Our model suggests that the after-depolarization (ADP) response seen in action potentials is a result of the slow deactivation of the fast sodium channel in the range of the ADP coupled with the activation of the L-type calcium channel (I(CaL)). This current and its interactions with the small and large conductance calcium-activated potassium currents (I(KCaSK) and I(KCaBK), respectively) is also important in the generation of spike frequency adaptation in the repetitive firing mode of activity. Other aspects of the model conform very well to experimental observations in both the action potential and repetitive firing mode of activity, including the role of I(KCaSK) in the medium after-hyperpolarization (AHP) and the role of I(KCaBK) in the fast AHP. We have made a number of predictions using the model, including the characterization of two putative sodium currents (fast and persistent), as well as functional roles for the N- and T-type calcium currents.

Cellular and synaptic effect of substance P on neonatal phrenic motoneurons

Experiments were carried out on the in vitro brainstem-spinal cord preparation of the newborn rat to analyse the effects of substance P (SP) on phrenic motoneuron (PMN) activity. In current-clamp mode, SP significantly depolarized PMNs, increased their input resistance, decreased the rheobase current and shifted the firing frequency-intensity relationships leftwards, but did not affect spike frequency adaptation or single spike configuration. The neurokinin receptor agonist NK1 had SP-mimetic effects, whereas the NK3 and NK2 receptor agonists were less effective and ineffective, respectively. In a tetrodotoxin-containing aCSF, only SP or the NK1 receptor agonist were still active. No depolarization was observed when the NK1 receptor agonist was applied in the presence of muscarine. In voltage-clamp mode, SP or the NK1 receptor agonist produced an inward current (ISP) which was not significantly reduced by extracellular application of tetraethylammonium, Co2+, 4-aminopyridine or Cs+. In aCSF containing tetrodotoxin, Co2+ and Cs+, ISP was blocked by muscarine. No PMN displayed any M-type potassium current but only a current showing no voltage sensitivity over the range -100 to 0 mV, reversing near the expected EK +, hence consistent with a leak current. SP application to the spinal cord only (using a partitioned chamber) significantly increased the phrenic activity. Pretreatment with the NMDA receptor antagonist DL-2-amino-5-phosphonovaleric acid (AP5) decreased the C4 discharge duration and blocked the effect of SP, thus exhibiting an NMDA potentiation by SP. In conclusion, SP modulates postsynaptically the response of phrenic motoneurons to the inspiratory drive through the reduction of a leak conductance and the potentiation of the NMDA component of the synaptic input.

Rhythmic sympathetic nerve discharges in an in vitro neonatal rat brain stem-spinal cord preparation

To understand the origination of sympathetic nerve discharge (SND), I developed an in vitro brain stem-spinal cord preparation from neonatal rats. Ascorbic acid (3 mM) was added into the bath solution to increase the viability of preparations. At 24 degrees C, rhythmic SND (recorded from the splanchnic nerve) was consistently observed, but it became quiescent at <16 degrees C. Respiratory-related SND (rSND) was discernible and was well correlated with C(4) root activity. Power spectral analysis of SND revealed a dominant 2-Hz oscillation. In most preparations (86%), such oscillation was persistent, whereas it only slightly reduced its magnitude after isolation from the brain stem. The removal of neural structures rostral to the superior cerebellar artery (equivalent to the level of facial nuclei) reduced rSND, increased tonic SND, but did not affect the temporal coupling between SND and C(4) root activity. Our data suggest a prominent contribution of SND from the neural mechanisms confined within the neonatal rat spinal cord. This ascorbic acid-enhanced in vitro preparation is a very useful model to study neural mechanisms underlying sympathorespiratory integration.

Substance P and central respiratory activity: a comparative in vitro study on foetal and newborn rat

Experiments were performed in vitro on foetal (embryonic days 18 to 21, E18-21) and newborn rat (postnatal days 0 to 3, P0-3) brainstem spinal cord preparations to analyse the perinatal developmental changes in the effects induced by substance P. Superfusion of the preparations with SP-containing artificial cerebrospinal fluid (aCSF) induced significant increase in the respiratory frequency of newborn rats (10-9 M), whereas concentration up to 10-7 M induced no change in foetal preparations. A whole cell patch clamp approach was used to record intracellularly from phrenic motoneurones. In newborn or E20-21 foetal rats SP-containing aCSF depolarised the phrenic motoneurones, increased their input resistance, reduced the rheobase current and shifted the frequency-intensity curves upward. In E18 foetal rats, no change was evoked by SP. A peptidase inhibitor mixture was used to block the enzymatic degradation of endogenous SP. This mixture was ineffective in changing the respiratory frequency in newborn and foetal preparations. In newborn rat phrenic motoneurones, the peptidase inhibitor mixture induced changes similar to those caused by SP but no change was induced in foetal rats. These results indicate that SP may modulate (i) the activity of the respiratory rhythm generator in newborn but not in foetal rats, and (ii) the activity of phrenic motoneurones at E20, E21 and in newborn rats but not at E18. Results obtained using the peptidase inhibitor mixture suggest that endogenous SP is probably not involved in the control of the respiratory rhythm in the prenatal period, but may influence the activity of the phrenic motoneurones after birth.

Maturation of the mammalian respiratory system

In this review, the maturational changes occurring in the mammalian respiratory network from fetal to adult ages are analyzed. Most of the data presented were obtained on rodents using in vitro approaches. In gestational day 18 (E18) fetuses, this network functions but is not yet able to sustain a stable respiratory activity, and most of the neonatal modulatory processes are not yet efficient. Respiratory motoneurons undergo relatively little cell death, and even if not yet fully mature at E18, they are capable of firing sustained bursts of potentials. Endogenous serotonin exerts a potent facilitation on the network and appears to be necessary for the respiratory rhythm to be expressed. In E20 fetuses and neonates, the respiratory activity has become quite stable. Inhibitory processes are not yet necessary for respiratory rhythmogenesis, and the rostral ventrolateral medulla (RVLM) contains inspiratory bursting pacemaker neurons that seem to constitute the kernel of the network. The activity of the network depends on CO2 and pH levels, via cholinergic relays, as well as being modulated at both the RVLM and motoneuronal levels by endogenous serotonin, substance P, and catecholamine mechanisms. In adults, the inhibitory processes become more important, but the RVLM is still a crucial area. The neonatal modulatory processes are likely to continue during adulthood, but they are difficult to investigate in vivo. In conclusion, 1) serotonin, which greatly facilitates the activity of the respiratory network at all developmental ages, may at least partly define its maturation; 2) the RVLM bursting pacemaker neurons may be the kernel of the network from E20 to adulthood, but their existence and their role in vivo need to be further confirmed in both neonatal and adult mammals.

GABAergic inhibition of neonatal rat phrenic motoneurons

Phrenic motoneurons (PMNs) receive intermittently glutaminergic inspiratory drives and GABAergic inhibition in adult mammals. Since gamma-amino-butyric acid (GABA) might act as an excitatory amino acid in early stages of development, we here investigated if GABA(A) receptors inhibit PMNs in neonates. Using in vitro neonatal rat brainstem-spinal cord preparation, local application of GABA and muscimol (a GABA(A) receptor agonist) to the vicinity of PMNs consistently reduced the inspiratory activity of C4 ventral roots. Under whole-cell patch-clamp conditions and in the presence of 0.5 microM TTX to block synaptic transmission, muscimol (10 microM) decreased whole-cell input resistance, and surprisingly, when PMNs were voltage-clamped at their resting membrane potential, muscimol induced depolarizing-inward, rather than hyperpolarizing-outward membrane current. Our findings indicate that GABA(A) receptors mediate a depolarizing blockade of the glutaminergic excitatory inputs to neonatal rat PMNs.