Inhibition of DNA synthesis in young cycling human diploid fibroblast-like cells upon fusion to enucleate cytoplasts from senescent cells

Regulation of the p21Sdi1/Cip1/Waf1DNA Synthesis Inhibitor in Senescent Human Diploid Fibroblasts

A large body of evidence has demonstrated that normal human fibroblasts have a limited division potential in culture and underwent senescence, a process whereby cells became arrested in the G1 phase of the cell cycle and overexpressed a DNA synthesis inhibitor(s). Cyclin-dependent kinase two (Cdk2) is required for the promotion of the Gi-to-S phase transition in human cells. Senescent fibroblasts contain intact cyclin-Cdk2 complexes but cannot induce Cdk2 protein kinase activity in response to mitogen stimulation. Recently, we cloned p21Sdi1, a potent inhibitor of DNA synthesis and Cdk2 kinase activity, from a senescent cell cDNA library and demonstrated that it was expressed at significantly higher levels in senescent cells than actively proliferating cells. In contrast to actively dividing cells, mitogen-stimulated senescent cells do not down-regulate the expression of p21Sdi1and do not express late G1 phase gene products that are required for entry into S phase. We suggest that the inability of mitogen-stimulated senescent cells to down-regulate p21Sdi1levels contributes to the resulting lack of late Gi gene expression and failure to traverse the G1/S phase boundary.

Replicative enzymes and ageing: importance of DNA polymerase alpha function to the events of cellular ageing

A hallmark of cellular ageing is the failure of senescing cells to initiate DNA synthesis and transition from G1 into S phase of the cell cycle. This transition is normally dependent on or concomitant with expression of a set of genes specifying cellular proteins, some of which directly participate in DNA replication. Deregulation of this gene expression may play a pivotal role in the ageing process. The number of known enzymes and co-factors required to maintain integrity of the genome during eukaryotic DNA replication has increased significantly in the past few years, and includes proteins essential for DNA replication and repair, as well as for cell cycle regulation. In eukaryotic cells, ranging from yeast to man, a replicative enzyme essential for initiation of transcription is DNA polymerase alpha (pol alpha), the activity of which is coordinately regulated with the initiation of DNA synthesis. DNA pol alpha, by means of its primase subunit, has the unique ability to initiate de novo DNA synthesis, and as a consequence, is required for the initiation of continuous (leading-strand) DNA synthesis at an origin of replication, as well as for initiation of discontinuous (lagging-strand) DNA synthesis. The dual role of the pol alpha-primase complex makes it a potential interactant with the regulatory mechanisms controlling entry into S phase. The purpose of this review is to address the regulation and/or modulation of DNA pol alpha during ageing that may play a key role in the cascade of events which ultimately leads to the failure of old cells to enter or complete S phase of the cell cycle.

A hVti1 homologue: its expression depends on population doubling levels in both normal and SV40-transformed human fibroblasts

A cDNA clone was isolated by differential colony hybridization from a cDNA library prepared from life-extended SV40-transformed human fibroblasts. The clone, tentatively named N-10, was 1272 bp in length coding for 232 amino acids. Northern analysis revealed that the expression level of N-10 was increased in normal senescent and life-extended SV40-transformed fibroblasts than in their young counterparts but was not enhanced by growth arrest. The protein fused to GFP (green fluorescent protein) localized in cytoplasmic granule. Enforced expression of N-10 resulted in premature senescence in young fibroblasts. The deduced amino acid sequence of N-10 was identical to the recently reported hVti1 gene except in one amino acid: Asp24(GAC) was ours and Asn24 (AAC) was reported. Additional base differences were found, so we referred to our sequence as the hVti1 homologue. As hVti1 protein was suggested to be involved in the vesicle transport process, the homologue may be concerned with increased secretion of extracellular matrix and various cytokines associated with cellular senescence.

Enhanced expression of cyclin D1 in senescent human fibroblasts

When human fibroblast, TIG-1, was growth-stimulated with fetal bovine serum, the induction level of cell cycle-dependent genes was generally much lower in senescent cells than in young counterparts. Exceptionally, the expression level of cyclin D1 in senescent cells was constitutively higher than in young cells and further increased after serum stimulation, which was confirmed by Northern and Western blots and immunoprecipitation. This was also true in other human diploid fibroblast lines, TIG-3 and MRC-5. However, cyclin D1-dependent kinase activity was not detected in senescent cells. When sense- or antisense-cyclin D1 cDNA driven by beta-actin promoter was transfected into young TIG-1 cells, the number of appeared colonies from sense-strand transfected cultures was lower than that from antisense-strand-transfected ones. However, clones expressing cyclin D1 at low or undetectable level which were isolated after transfection with antisense-cyclin D1 proliferated up to the same division limit as untransfected and sense-strand transfected cells. Four clones of SV40-transformed TIG-1 expressed cyclin D1 at moderate levels during their extended proliferative lifespan. It appears that, if the extremely overexpressed cyclin D1 could cause an inhibition of cell proliferation at senescent stage, cellular senescence occurs regardless of overexpression of cyclin D1.

Cleavage of the epidermal growth factor receptor by a membrane-bound leupeptin-sensitive protease active in nonionic detergent lysates of senescent but not young human diploid fibroblasts

Numerous studies suggest that epidermal growth factor (EGF) signaling is impaired in nonproliferating senescent human diploid fibroblasts downstream of receptor binding. One possible explanation for these results is that senescent cells possess unique enzymatic activities capable of regulating functional levels of the EGF receptor. To test that hypothesis, nonionic detergent lysates of young and senescent cells were compared for proteolytic activity directed towards the EGF receptor, and a protease that cleaves the 170 kDa EGF receptor was identified in lysates from senescent but not young cells. Although studies presented here were carried out with WI-38 cells, our data indicate that other senescent fibroblasts possess a similar activity. The degradation product immunoprecipitated by a monoclonal antibody specific for an EGF receptor exocytosolic epitope had an approximate molecular weight of 100,000. This product was also detected following cell surface labeling with 125I, and by cross-linking 125I-EGF to intact cells with disuccinimidyl suberate. The proteolytic activity in senescent cell lysates was specifically inhibited by leupeptin and did not require divalent cations; it was also inactivated by aprotic solvents such as dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) or ethylene carbonate. Interestingly, this protease was not active during ligand-induced intracellular processing of the EGF receptor, suggesting that it does not normally function in endocytic or lysosomal compartments. The susceptibility of the protease to inactivation by cell surface trypsinization is consistent with a plasma membrane localization. Since EGF receptor cleavage is not observed unless senescent cells are solubilized with nonionic detergents, it seems likely that the protease is confined to specialized regions of the plasma membrane. Whether or not the EGF receptor is a physiologic target for this protease is unclear. Its expression at the cell surface is nevertheless significant, since it suggests there are mechanisms for regulating membrane-bound proteins, or biologically active peptides in the extracellular space, in senescent cells that are either absent or inactive in young cells.

Stimulation of DNA synthesis in senescent human cells following incubation with plasma membranes

DNA synthesis and mitosis were increased in mitogen-stimulated senescent WI-38 cells following incubation with plasma membranes prepared from young or senescent WI-38 cells, A431 cells, 3T3 cells, or NR6 cells. The percentage of [3H]thymidine-labeled nuclei in senescent cultures was two- to fivefold greater than that seen in controls in which cells were incubated in the absence of membranes or in the presence of boiled membranes. The effect was trypsin sensitive, suggesting that a protein moiety is necessary for stimulation of DNA synthesis. As the culture age increased, basal levels of DNA synthesis, as well as maximal stimulation of DNA synthesis following incubation with plasma membranes, decreased. These observations are consistent with the hypothesis that different subpopulations exist in senescing cultures and suggest a complex pattern of inhibitory and stimulatory regulation of cell proliferation.

The cultured diploid fibroblast as a model for the study of cellular aging

The limited proliferative potential of the cultured human diploid fibroblast is now well established. A number of biological correlates suggest that this culture system is a model for the study of aging at the cellular level. The mechanism(s) that causes the loss of proliferative activity is unknown; the results of some recent studies indicate that specific genes may play a pivotal role in cellular aging in vitro. The extent to which changes in proliferative functions are causally related to aging in vivo is currently under investigation.

Protein markers for cellular mortality and immortality

Fixed mortality of normal somatic cells is a well-established fact though the mechanism underlying this universal phenomenon remains unknown. Use of immortal cells in conjunction with their normal mortal counterparts has delineated the dominant genetic nature of the senescent phenotype over immortalization. Although the involvement of proteins in determining the entry/exit/arrest of cells in the cell cycle is evident from the literature, none of them has been confirmed for its role in senescence-associated irreversible cell cycle exit/arrest. The identification of true mortality markers might be possible by selecting a system of natural and conditional aging achieved by the fusion of mortal and spontaneously immortalized cells of the same origin. We report here a few such protein markers which might serve as useful handles to tease out the molecular events determining mortality/immortality of cultured cells.

Negative growth effectors and cellular senescence

Current studies suggest a genetic program governs the lifespan of each organism. Using cellular senescence as a model system, components of this program for aging have been sought. Human diploid fibroblasts, upon reaching senescence, express active inhibitors of DNA synthesis. It is believed that such inhibitors could be members of a new family of negative growth effectors involved in the pathway to senescence. Factors capable of inhibiting DNA synthesis in a similar manner have also been identified from human quiescent fibroblasts and liver cells as well as from quiescent rodent liver cells. The relationship of these inhibitors to previously identified negative growth effectors and aging are discussed.

Extension of the life-span of human endothelial cells by an interleukin-1 alpha antisense oligomer

The proliferative potential of human diploid endothelial cells is finite, and cellular senescence in vitro is accompanied by the failure of the endothelial cell to respond to exogenous growth factors. Senescent human endothelial cells were shown to contain high amounts of the transcript for the cytokine interleukin-1 alpha (IL-1 alpha), a potent inhibitor of endothelial cell proliferation in vitro. In contrast, transformed human endothelial cells did not contain detectable IL-1 alpha messenger RNA. Treatment of human endothelial cell populations with an antisense oligodeoxynucleotide to the human IL-1 alpha transcript prevented cell senescence and extended the proliferative life-span of the cells in vitro. Removal of the IL-1 alpha antisense oligomer resulted in the generation of the senescent phenotype and loss of proliferative potential. These data suggest that human endothelial cell senescence in vitro is a dynamic process regulated by the potential intracellular activity of IL-1 alpha.

Altered regulation of platelet-derived growth factor A-chain and c-fos gene expression in senescent progeria fibroblasts

The study of human genetic disorders known as premature aging syndromes may provide insight into the mechanisms of cellular senescence. These diseases are clinically characterized by the premature onset and accelerated progression of numerous features normally associated with human aging. Previous studies have indicated that fibroblasts derived from premature aging syndrome patients have in vitro growth properties similar to senescent fibroblasts from normal individuals. As an initial approach to determine whether gene expression is altered in premature aging syndrome fibroblasts, RNA was prepared from various cell strains and used for gel blot hybridization experiments. Although normal fibroblasts only express platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) A-chain mRNA for a brief period following mitogenic stimulation, one strain of Hutchinson-Gilford (progeria) syndrome fibroblasts, AG3513, constitutively expresses PDGF A-chain mRNA and PDGF-AA homodimers. The PDGF A-chain gene does not appear to be amplified or rearranged in these fibroblasts. AG3513 progeria fibroblasts have properties characteristic of senescent cells, including an altered morphology and a diminished mitogenic response to growth promoters. The diminished response of AG3513 progeria fibroblasts to PDGF stimulation was examined in some detail. Studies using 125I-PDGF-BB, which binds with high affinity to both A- and B-type PDGF receptors, indicate that normal and AG3513 progeria fibroblasts have a similar number of PDGF receptors. Although receptor autophosphorylation occurs normally in PDGF-stimulated AG3513 progeria fibroblasts, c-fos mRNA induction does not. The senescent phenotype of AG3513 fibroblasts is probably unrelated to their constitutive PDGF A-chain gene expression; further studies are necessary in order to directly address this issue. Also, additional analysis of this progeria fibroblast strain may provide information on the control of mitogen-inducible gene expression in normal cells.

In vivo aging of human fibroblasts does not alter nuclear plasticity in heterokaryons

In vivo aging of human fibroblasts altered proliferative properties but not the potential for novel gene expression in response to muscle trans-acting factors. Heterokaryons produced by fusing fibroblasts with muscle cells permitted a dissociation of the effects of aging on cell division and other cell functions. Skin fibroblasts derived from fetal and adult stages of development were distinct cell types based on their doubling time, protein content, cell size, and specific binding of insulin and insulin-like growth factor I. Despite these differences in growth parameters, the two cell types were indistinguishable in heterokaryons. Muscle gene activation occurred in the absence of changes in chromatin structure requiring DNA replication. In addition, the time course, maximal efficiency, and effect of gene dosage on the expression of muscle gene products were similar for heterokaryons containing fetal and adult fibroblasts but distinct for heterokaryons containing keratinocytes. The difference between fibroblasts and keratinocytes in the time course of muscle gene expression is likely to reflect mechanisms of gene activation at the transcriptional level, since the kinetics of muscle protein accumulation paralleled that of muscle transcripts. These results indicate that nuclear plasticity is not altered in fibroblasts by in vivo aging.

Further studies on the genetic and biochemical basis of cellular senescence

Cell fusion analysis, exploiting the fact that the phenotype of immortality is recessive in hybrids, has allowed the assignment of 26 different immortal human cell lines to at least four complementation groups for indefinite division. This indicates that there are at least four sets of genes or processes involved in the mechanisms leading to cellular senescence. We have also observed alterations in gene expression accompanying senescence that induce the expression of a protein inhibitor of DNA synthesis, expression of new cell surface epitopes as identified by monoclonal antibodies specific to senescent cells, and changes in the extracellular matrix. We have yet to determine whether these changes in gene expression are casual or the result of senescence. The assignment of immortal cell lines to specific complementation groups now allow for a focused approach to identify the normal growth regulatory genes that have been modified to yield immortal cells and determine whether certain senescent cell specific patterns of gene expression continue to be expressed in immortal cells within a group. In addition, the isolation of senescent cell-specific antibodies provides for the first time the tools with which to probe the relationship between in vitro and in vivo aging.

A potent DNA synthesis inhibitor expressed by the immortal cell line SUSM-1

We have previously reported the production of DNA synthesis inhibitor proteins by both quiescent and senescent human diploid fibroblasts. Young, proliferating fibroblasts do not produce such inhibitors, but are capable of responding to either the quiescent or senescent cell DNA synthesis inhibitors. Recently, we have analyzed the immortal cell line SUSM-1 (derived from normal liver fibroblasts following exposure to carcinogen) for inhibitory activity. We have found that SUSM-1 cells produce a factor capable of inhibiting DNA synthesis in young fibroblasts. Crude extracts prepared from SUSM-1 cells inhibit DNA synthesis in a dose-dependent manner at concentrations 10-fold lower than those of either senescent or quiescent fibroblast cell extracts. SUSM-1 cells are incapable of responding to the inhibitor they produce, as are three other immortal human cell lines tested. One immortal cell line, HeLa, does respond to the SUSM-1 inhibitor, though to a lesser degree than observed with normal young fibroblasts. One hypothesis is that the DNA synthesis inhibitor protein(s) of senescent cells plays a role in determining the finite in vitro life span of normal cells. The results reported here suggest that SUSM-1 cells may have escaped senescence through loss of a receptor or cofactor for the inhibitor protein(s).

Cellular senescence revisited: a review

The field of cellular senescence (cytogerontology) is reviewed. The historical precedence for investigation in this field is summarized, and placed in the context of more recent studies of the regulation of cellular proliferation and differentiation. The now-classical embryonic lung fibroblast model is compared to models utilizing other cell types as well as cells from donors of different ages and phenotypes. Modulation of cellular senescence by growth factors, hormones, and genetic manipulation is contrasted, but newer studies in oncogene involvement are omitted. A current consensus would include the view that the life span of normal diploid cells in culture is limited, is under genetic control, and is capable of being modified. Finally, embryonic cells aging in vitro share certain characteristics with early passage cells derived from donors of increasing age.

Membrane-associated inhibitor of DNA synthesis in senescent human diploid fibroblasts: characterization and comparison to quiescent cell inhibitor

Cell membranes prepared from senescent human diploid fibroblasts (HDF) inhibited entry into S phase by 35% when added to the medium of replicating young HDF. This membrane-associated inhibitory activity was (i) sensitive to trypsin, heat, and periodate, which suggests that the inhibitor is a glycoprotein, and (ii) not able to inhibit DNA synthesis in simian virus 40-transformed HDF, which indicates that not all types of cells are sensitive to this inhibitor. Quiescent young HDF also have a surface membrane-associated inhibitor of DNA synthesis. A comparison of the senescent HDF and quiescent HDF inhibitor activities indicates that they may have the same chemical and physical nature and the same specific activity, but their regulation is different. The inhibitory activity of quiescent young HDF is abolished within 20 hr after refeeding with fresh serum-containing medium, whereas that of senescent HDF remains unchanged. Quiescent old HDF (two or three population doublings remaining) exhibit an intermediate response to serum with approximately two-thirds of the inhibitory activity abolished. The fraction of cells in S phase at 20-24 hr post-stimulation (37% in young HDF, 24% in old HDF, and 0% in senescent HDF) is inversely proportional to inhibitor levels. This suggests that inability to neutralize the inhibitory activity in response to serum stimulation could be involved in the inability of senescent HDF to enter S phase. Disappearance of the inhibitory activity from quiescent young HDF occurs late in G1 phase. Thus, the inhibitor may play a role in determining the length of the G0 to S phase transition in these cells.

Senescent and quiescent cell inhibitors of DNA synthesis. Membrane-associated proteins

Cytoplasts derived from senescent and quiescent human diploid cells inhibit DNA synthesis initiation when fused with cells capable of proliferation. When the cytoplasts were subjected to a variety of conditions (trypsin and cycloheximide treatment and growth on fibronectin), this inhibitory activity was lost, suggesting that the inhibitors involved were proteins associated with the surface membranes of the cells. We have studied the quiescent cell inhibitor in greater detail and determined that surface membrane-enriched preparations isolated from quiescent cells and proteins extracted from these membrane preparations have DNA synthesis-inhibitory activity.

DNA replication and H5 histone exchange during reactivation of chick erythrocyte nuclei in heterokaryons

Fusion of terminally differentiated chick erythrocytes (CE) with replicating quail myoblasts or established L6J1 rat myoblasts results in reactivation of DNA synthesis in the dormant CE nuclei and in suppression of DNA synthesis in the myoblast nuclei. The nuclei of primary quail myoblasts are more effectively inhibited than the nuclei of established rat myoblasts. Inhibition of DNA replication occurs not only by preventing G1 nuclei from entering S-phase but also by blocking nuclei in S-phase and by delaying nuclei in G2 from undergoing mitosis and starting a new DNA replication cycle. No inhibition of DNA synthesis could be observed when mouse erythrocytes, i.e., erythrocytes lacking nuclei, were fused with rat myoblasts to generate mouse-globin-containing L6J1 cybrids.--Reactivation of CE nuclei is associated with a loss of the tissue-specific H5 histone variant. Complete elimination of H5 histone, however, does not seem to be a necessary prerequisite for the initiation or completion of DNA replication in CE nuclei since H5 antigens are found on reactivated G1, S, and G2 nuclei.

Inhibition of DNA synthesis in senescent-proliferating human cybrids is mediated by endogenous proteins

Cytoplasts were prepared from senescent human diploid fibroblasts. Brief treatments of the senescent cells with cycloheximide or puromycin prior to or after enucleation eliminated the ability of senescent cytoplasts to block initiation of DNA synthesis in senescent-young cybrids. Senescent cells treated with cycloheximide, enucleated and allowed to recover in complete medium without cycloheximide, regained the ability to block initiation of DNA synthesis in senescent-young cybrids. These results support the hypothesis that senescent cells synthesize an inhibitor of DNA synthesis which is either a protein(s) or its activity is mediated by a protein(s) found in the cytoplasm of the senescent cell.