The effect of fertility drugs and in vitro methods on the outcome of 106 triplet pregnancies

Prevalence of Gestational Diabetes in Triplet Pregnancies: A Retrospective Cohort Study and Meta-Analysis

Background: Over the last decades, there has been a substantial increase in the incidence of higher-order multiple gestations. Twin pregnancies are associated with an increased risk of gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM). The literature on GDM rates in triplet pregnancies is scarce. Methods: A retrospective cohort study was performed to assess the prevalence of GDM in women with a triplet pregnancy. GDM was defined through an abnormal oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT). A meta-analysis of GDM prevalence was also carried out. Results: A cohort of 60 women was included in the analysis. Of these, 19 (31.7%) were diagnosed with GDM. There were no differences in pregnancy outcomes between women with and without GDM. In the meta-analysis of 12 studies, which used a sound GDM definition, an estimated pooled prevalence of 12.4% (95% confidence interval: 6.9–19.1%) was found. In a leave-one-out sensitivity analysis, the estimated GDM prevalence ranged from 10.7% to 14.1%. Conclusion: The rate of GDM seems increased in women with triplets compared to singleton pregnancies. However, GDM did not impact short-term pregnancy outcomes.

Triplet Pregnancy: Is the Mode of Conception Related to Perinatal Outcomes?

Many triplets are conceived as a consequence of assisted reproductive technology (ART). Concerns have been raised that triplet pregnancies conceived by ART are more complicated than those conceived spontaneously. The purpose of this study was to evaluate all triplet pregnancies managed over a 12-year period to determine if there were any differences in outcome based on the mode of conception. All triplet pregnancies between 1999 and 2011 that reached at least 20 weeks’ gestation and that were managed at the Royal Women's Hospital (RWH), Melbourne, Victoria were identified. Maternal and neonatal outcomes were compared between ART conceived and spontaneously conceived triplets. In the study period, 53 sets of triplets managed in our institution met the eligibility criteria. Twenty-five triplet sets were conceived by ART and 28 were conceived spontaneously. More ART conceptions resulted in trichorionic triamniotic (TCTA) triplets than did spontaneous conceptions (p= .015). There were no differences between ART and spontaneously conceived triplets for any of the maternal or neonatal complications studied. Trichorionic (TC) triplets delivered at a later gestation than other triplets: 32.1 (SD2.9) versus 30.4 (SD3.9) weeks (p= .08). TC triplets were significantly less likely to die than monochorionic (MC) or dichorionic (DC) triplets: 3/93 (3%) versus 13/66 (20%) (p= .025). In conclusion, triplets conceived by ART are more likely to have TCTA placentation and TCTA triplet sets had lower mortality rates than other triplet combinations. Outcomes for triplets conceived by ART were similar to those of triplets conceived spontaneously.

Neonatal outcomes in triplet pregnancies: assisted reproduction versus spontaneous conception

AIMS

The purpose of this study is to compare neonatal outcomes of spontaneously conceived triplets with triplets conceived by assisted reproduction.

METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort study of all cases from assisted triplet pregnancies and controls from spontaneous triplet pregnancies. A total of 24 triplet pregnancies were studied: six spontaneous and 18 assisted. The following variables were evaluated in all newborns: prematurity, birth-weight, small for gestational age, birth-weight discordance, Apgar scores, major neonatal morbidity and perinatal mortality.

RESULTS

Gestational age (33+/-1 vs. 33+/-2 weeks) and birth-weight (1760+/-256 vs. 1907+/-452 g) were similar in spontaneous and assisted triplet pregnancies. There were no significant differences in the rates of small for gestational age, discordance, and major neonatal morbidity. In the assisted reproduction group only the following cases were recorded: 1 surgically treated patent ductus arteriosus, 1 feto-fetal transfusion syndrome, 2 grade II intraventricular hemorrhage, 1 Cri du Chat syndrome and 1 stillbirth with malformations.

CONCLUSIONS

This study is unable to assess the influence of assisted reproduction on the neonatal outcomes of triplet pregnancies. However, the results suggest that the incidence of major neonatal morbidity, especially malformations, might increase due to assisted reproduction. This finding requires further confirmation.

Use of outcomes-based data in reducing high-order multiple pregnancies: the role of age, diagnosis, and embryo score

OBJECTIVE

To identify high-risk categories for high-order multiple pregnancy (HMP) in in vitro fertilization (IVF), establish clinic-specific HMP risk data for counseling use, and verify their utility in reducing HMP.

DESIGN

Before and after intervention study.

SETTING

Two IVF programs using the same embryology laboratory and IVF protocols.

PATIENT(S)

All IVF patients undergoing fresh embryo transfers.

INTERVENTION(S)

Use of clinic-specific age, diagnosis, and embryo score (ES) risk data in assessing individual HMP risk during informed consent.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

HMP and pregnancy outcomes.

RESULT(S)

In determining clinic-specific high risk categories and developing outcomes-based HMP risk data for counseling, the good outcome rate (GR) was defined as the percentage of singleton or twin deliveries per cycle and the bad outcome rate included no pregnancy or nondelivered pregnancies (miscarriages, multifetal reduction) and HMP per cycle. During 1995 to 1999, age <35 years, calculated morphologic ES, and donor egg (DE) cycles were factors shown by logistic regression to statistically significantly affect the GR. The optimal GRs for DE <35 and >or=35 years (donor age), and non-DE cycles <35 years were achieved with two (57.7%), three (43.2%), and three (43.2%) embryos transferred, respectively. A DE <35 years with >or=3 embryos transferred had the highest risk for HMP. The GR correlated (0.91) with the ES according to the formula: GR = 3.3 + 2.0 ES, when ES range was between 4 and 26. Clinic-specific risks for HMP based on age, diagnosis, and ES were developed and considered while counseling for ET during 2004. The clinic-specific HMP risk data made for a reduction in the HMP rate of 90.9% for DE-IVF (11.8% to 1%) and 53.8% for all IVF (9.1% to 4.2%), without decreases in clinical pregnancy or delivery rates. Physicians showing the greatest decline (64%) in HMP had no reduction in pregnancy or delivery rates.

CONCLUSION(S)

The use of clinic-specific HMP risk data in counseling based on age, diagnosis, and ES provided a 53% to 64% reduction in HMP without affecting rates of pregnancy or delivery. The clinic-specific ES system correlated closely with good outcomes. A standardized ES system may provide useful information for counseling during ET informed consent.

Antepartum management and neonatal outcome of triplet pregnancies

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The maternal and neonatal outcome of 27 triplet and 1 quadruplet gestations was studied at the University Hospital of Verona.

RESULTS

Mean maternal age was 31.7+/-3.7 years; 24 women (85.7%) were nulliparous. Six (21.4%) patients had conceived spontaneously. Common maternal complications were: preterm labor (78.6%), anemia (57.1%), preeclampsia (25.0%). Thirteen patients (46.4%) had cervical cerclage, 21(75%) received tocolysis, 20 (71.4%) corticosteroid prophylaxis, 4 (14.3%) unfractionated heparin. All patients underwent Caesarean section with mean gestational age of 32+/-2.5 weeks and mean postoperative stay was 9 days. Three patients were treated in ICU after delivery, 1 was hysterectomized and 6 received blood transfusions. The live newborns were 80, the stillborns 5. Mean birth weight was 1,520+/-516 g (range 650-2,665), 95.0% being LBW. The following neonatal complications were observed: RDS (28.7%), cerebral hemorrhage (26.2% of II degrees and 1.2% of III degrees ), anemia (20%), PDA (12.5%), ROP (6.5%), polyglobulia (3.75%), NEC (2.5%). Mean hospitalization time was 30.6 days (range 2-132).

DISCUSSION

Iatrogenic multiple births are increasing as the use of assisted conception techniques expands. Gynecologists should be aware of maternal complications and neonatal outcome of triplet pregnancies and infertility management strategies should try to avoid iatrogenic multiple gestations.

Pregnancy outcome in spontaneous twins versus twins who were conceived through in vitro fertilization

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to compare maternal and neonatal complications in spontaneous versus in vitro fertilization twins.

STUDY DESIGN

Twin gestations that were delivered from 1995 to 2000 were reviewed. Cases consisted of 56 in vitro fertilization twins, each of which was matched to two control mothers by age and parity. They were compared regarding various maternal and neonatal complications.

RESULTS

In vitro fertilization twins were more likely to have preterm labor compared with control twins, with no difference in the incidences of pregnancy-induced hypertension, gestational diabetes mellitus, placenta previa, or preterm premature rupture of membranes between the two groups. The cesarean delivery rate was significantly higher in cases of twins who were conceived by in vitro fertilization (76.8% vs 58.0%, P=.026), despite a similar rate of elective cesarean delivery and the incidence of nonvertex twin A in both groups. The preterm delivery rate was significantly higher (67.9% vs 41.1%, P=.002) and the gestational age was significantly lower (35+/-3 weeks vs 36+/-3 weeks, P=.043) in cases compared with control subjects. Both twins were, on the average, 230 g lighter in the in vitro fertilization group compared with the control group. However, intrauterine growth restriction was more frequent in the control group (36.6% vs 25%, P=.044). There was a significantly higher incidence of admission to the neonatal intensive care unit, respiratory distress syndrome, a need for mechanical ventilation, and pneumothorax in cases compared with control subjects.

CONCLUSION

When compared with spontaneous twins, in vitro fertilization twins are more likely to be delivered by cesarean delivery and to have a higher incidence of preterm birth and prematurity-related respiratory complications with a longer nursery stay.

Outcome of twin pregnancies after assisted reproductive techniques--a comparative study

OBJECTIVE

To compare obstetrical and perinatal outcome of twin pregnancies after assisted reproductive techniques (ART) with that of twins conceived spontaneously.

STUDY DESIGN

Hospital based retrospective study.

RESULTS

There were 132 twin deliveries of which 36 were conceived after ART. Patients of the ART group were mostly nulliparous and slightly older. There was no statistically significant difference in the frequency of preterm delivery or mean gestational age at delivery. Elective Caesarean delivery was more frequent in twin pregnancies conceived after ART, and there were no other differences in maternal complications. There was also no difference in the mean birth weight or frequency of neonatal complication between the two groups.

CONCLUSION

In this comparative study, the obstetric and neonatal outcomes between spontaneous twins and those conceived after ART are similar except for higher operative deliveries in the latter group of twins.

Triplet placentas: reference values for weights

The occurrence of twins, triplets, and other multiple births increased significantly between 1970 and 2000 in the United States and other industrialized countries. The number of triplet placentas submitted for examination as pathologic specimens has also markedly increased, but no reference values are published for triplet weights. We examined 196 normal triplet placentas. Specimens with associated conditions known to affect the weights of the placentas were excluded. The gestational ages ranged between 20 and 38 weeks. Mean weights for different gestational ages are summarized as follows: 253 g for 20 weeks, 319 g for 22 weeks, 406 g for 24 weeks, 509 g for 26 weeks, 621 g for 28 weeks, 738 g for 30 weeks, 855 g for 32 weeks, 965 g for 34 weeks, 1,065 g for 36 weeks, and 1,147 g for 38 weeks. Weight gain of triplet placentas appears to parallel that of twin placentas. The mean values of placental weights for triplets at each gestational age are less than triple those of singleton weights for the same duration of gestation. The placental weights in multiple gestations do not increase proportionately with the number of fetuses.

Natural versus induced twinning and pregnancy outcome: a Dutch nationwide survey of primiparous dizygotic twin deliveries

OBJECTIVE

To compare obstetrical outcome of twin pregnancies after assisted reproduction with that of natural twin pregnancies.

DESIGN

Retrospective national database study.

SETTING

Academic Medical Centre.

PATIENT(S)

One thousand ninety-three primiparous mothers registered in the Dutch National Birth Registry who gave birth to a dizygotic (DZ) twin (male/female) in 1994, 1995, and 1996. We compared 613 natural twin pregnancies and 480 twin pregnancies born after assisted reproduction.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Gestational length, mode of delivery, mode of presentation of the children, birth weight, APGAR score, congenital anomalies, perinatal mortality rate, highest recorded maternal diastolic blood pressure, and maternal postpartum complications.

RESULT(S)

Rates of perinatal mortality and very premature parturition (<29 weeks) were lower in natural twin mothers. Overall, induced DZ twins were born 3.5 days earlier with a lower birth weight and APGAR score compared with controls. Rates of congenital anomalies and incidence of cesarean section were not different. The highest recorded diastolic blood pressure was lower in induced twinning with a 30% lower incidence of diastolic blood pressure >90 mm Hg.

CONCLUSION(S)

Obstetric outcome for induced DZ twin pregnancy is less optimal than in natural DZ twin pregnancy. Twinning in assisted reproduction is known for its contribution to the high rate of premature deliveries, but in addition being a subfertile patient undergoing treatment makes an intrinsic contribution to adverse events as well.

Multiple births and outcome

The rate of multiple-gestation pregnancies has grown exponentially over the last few decades and is responsible for the steady increase in the birth rate of low-birth weight infants. As a group, infants of multiple-gestation pregnancies have higher mortality and morbidity than singleton pregnancies. The increase in adverse outcomes is related directly to the increased risk for preterm delivery and low-birth weight, and not to the multiple gestation itself. Outcomes for multiple-gestation infants appear to be similar whether conceived spontaneously or through artificial reproductive technology. Efforts to reduce the birth rate of low-birth weight infants should target multiple-gestation pregnancies.

Perinatal and neonatal outcomes in multiple gestations: assisted reproduction versus spontaneous conception

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to test the hypothesis that multiple pregnancies resulting from assisted reproductive therapy have a better outcome than those resulting from spontaneous conception.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a retrospective cohort study. Cases came from pregnancies from assisted reproductive techniques. Controls were identified from spontaneous multiple pregnancies delivered in the same time period. Matching was done for maternal age, parity, fetal number, and presence of maternal medical problems. A total of 72 cases (56 twins and 16 triplets) and 124 controls (108 twins and 16 triplets) were studied. The primary outcome was perinatal mortality. Secondary outcomes were preterm delivery, birth weight, maternal complications, neonatal morbidity, and length of hospitalization.

RESULTS

Perinatal mortality is significantly increased in spontaneous twin gestations compared with twins resulting from assisted reproductive techniques (24 vs 2, P =.003). No difference is seen in the perinatal mortality in triplets. Mean gestational age at diagnosis was lower for twins and triplets resulting from assisted reproductive techniques (9.4 vs 13.3; P <.001 and 8.8 vs 15. 8; P <.001, respectively). Rate of cerclage and number of prenatal visits was higher for triplets in the assisted reproductive techniques group (P =.05 and.02, respectively). Mean gestational age at delivery, birth weight, rate of preterm labor, preterm premature rupture of membranes, pregnancy-induced hypertension, and incidence of gestational diabetes were not significantly different between the groups. No significant differences in neonatal morbidity were detected.

CONCLUSIONS

Assisted reproductive techniques-associated twins have lower perinatal mortality than spontaneously conceived twins. Perinatal and neonatal morbidity, gestational age at delivery, and birth weight are not affected by assisted reproductive techniques, even with closer surveillance and earlier gestational age at diagnosis in this group. Differences may be due to a higher frequency of monochorionic placentation in the spontaneously conceived group.

Attitudes of in vitro fertilization and intrauterine insemination couples toward multiple gestation pregnancy and multifetal pregnancy reduction

OBJECTIVE

To determine attitudes regarding multiple pregnancy and multifetal pregnancy reduction in couples embarking on gonadotropin therapy.

DESIGN

Questionnaire given to couples initiating gonadotropin therapy.

SETTING

University hospital-based infertility unit.

PATIENTS

Twenty-seven couples undergoing IVF and 50 couples undergoing IUI.

RESULTS

The groups' responses tended to be quite similar, with all groups reporting declining favorability ratings as the fetal order increased. The IUI group did feel more favorable than the IVF group toward all gestational outcomes and less favorable toward multifetal pregnancy reduction. A history of live births and length of infertility had no significant impact on the results.

CONCLUSION

Couples undergoing gonadotropin therapy have an overall favorable attitude toward multiple gestational pregnancies of triplets or twins and an increased willingness to consider multifetal pregnancy reduction for quadruplets and more.

Course and outcome of IVF pregnancies and spontaneous conceptions within an IVF setting

The study determines mortality and morbidity levels during pregnancy and the perinatal period in those conceiving through IVF in the Republic of Ireland in comparison with other parts of the world and a peer infertile group conceiving spontaneously whilst on the IVF clinic books. Six hundred and sixty couples had 187 IVF pregnancies from whom 220 babies were born to 151 deliveries. There were also 78 spontaneous conceptions which produced 78 offspring from 73 deliveries. The majority had trouble free pregnancies. The incidence of all complications was less than has been reported elsewhere. Of the IVF group, 16.5% aborted completed as did 5% of the spontaneous conceptions. A further 7% and 3.8%, respectively, aborted one sac of a multiple pregnancy. Of the IVF deliveries, 35.8% were multiple as were 6.8% of the spontaneous conceptions. Higher order multiple presence detrimentally influenced delivery mode, gestational age and birth weights in the IVF group. Of IVF patients, 55.7% were section deliveries as were 10.9% of the spontaneous conceptions. Incidence of IVF-group significant congenital abnormality was 1.8%. The perinatal mortality rate was 4.2 per 1000 births. This series suggests the final take-home baby outlook of 81% from conception by IVF is not as poor as previously portrayed. However, attention should be given to abortion, section and multiple pregnancy rates.

Perinatal outcome of triplet pregnancies following assisted reproduction

PURPOSE

This collaborative work was undertaken to assess perinatal outcome of in vivo conceived triplets to those following in vitro fertilization and assisted reproductive technologies (ART).

METHODS

151 triplets were examined; 56 delivered following ART, 55 following ovulation induction by gonadotropins (GN), 27 following clomiphene citrate (CC), and 13 conceived spontaneously.

RESULTS

Mean gestational length of triplets following ART (33.2 wks) was not different from those conceived following GN (33.4 wks) or CC (34.2 wks), but was significantly shorter compared to triplets following spontaneous conception (35.3 wks). Mean fetal birthweight following ART (1743 g) did not differ significantly from that following GN (1683 g) or CC (1863 g) but was significantly lower compared to those delivered after spontaneous conception (1963 g). Although no difference was found in the incidence of low birthweight infants between the groups studied, the incidence of very low birthweight newborns (<1500 g) following ART or GN was significantly higher than following spontaneous conceptions (30.6%, 30.3% vs 10.3%). Differences in perinatal mortality were not significantly different between the groups examined (77.9, 60.6, 111.0, 25.6/1000 for ART, GN, CC, and spontaneous conceptions respectively).

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, a similar perinatal outcome was shown for triplets conceived following ART and those following ovulation induction by GN, suggesting that the in vitro conditions as such were not the main contributing factor influencing the clinical outcome but rather the GN treatment. Triplets conceived spontaneously have a better outcome compared to those following ovulation induction or ART in terms of gestational length and birthweight.