Directing differentiation in Theileria annulata: old methods and new possibilities for control of apicomplexan parasites

Theileria annulata: Its Propagation in Rabbits for the Attenuation of Piroplasms in Cross-Bred Calves

Tropical theileriosis caused by the protozoan; Theileria annulata is a tick-borne disease (TBD) transmitted by ticks of genus Hyalomma; is clinically characterized by fever, anemia, and lymphadenopathy; and is responsible for heavy economic losses in terms of high morbidity and mortality rates with reduced production. Infected red blood cells of T. annulata were inoculated into rabbits intraperitoneally, and propagation of T. annulata has been investigated. The current study has shown an association between induced tropical theileriosis and variation of body temperature in rabbits. A significant rise in temperature (39.92 ± 0.33 °C) was seen on day 8 onwards, with the maximum temperature (40.27 ± 0.44 °C) on day 14 post-inoculation. In the current study, in vivo trials in susceptible cross-bred calves to investigate the attenuation and comparison with the infected group were also conducted. All the infected calves (n = 5) showed a significant rise in temperature (40.26 ± 0.05 °C) on day 10 onwards, with the maximum temperature (40.88 ± 0.05 °C) on day 16. The temperature of inoculated calves increased gradually post-inoculation, but the difference was not significant. A maximum parasitemia of 20% was observed in infected calves, but no piroplasm parasitemia was observed in inoculated calves. The prescapular lymph nodes of infected calves were enlarged, while the lymph nodes of inoculated calves remained normal throughout the trial. Analysis of clinical and parasitological responses of infected and inoculated calves showed a significant difference (p ≤ 0.05) in terms of temperature, parasitemia, and lymph node scoring between two groups. The current study was primarily aimed to attenuate T. annulata in rabbit and to check its virulence in susceptible calves. It is concluded that propagation of Theileria annulata in rabbits made it attenuated. Rabbit can be used as an in vivo model to weaken the virulence of T. annulata.

ApiAP2 Factors as Candidate Regulators of Stochastic Commitment to Merozoite Production in Theileria annulata

Background

Differentiation of one life-cycle stage to the next is critical for survival and transmission of apicomplexan parasites. A number of studies have shown that stage differentiation is a stochastic process and is associated with a point that commits the cell to a change over in the pattern of gene expression. Studies on differentiation to merozoite production (merogony) in T. annulata postulated that commitment involves a concentration threshold of DNA binding proteins and an auto-regulatory loop.

Principal Findings

In this study ApiAP2 DNA binding proteins that show changes in expression level during merogony of T. annulata have been identified. DNA motifs bound by orthologous domains in Plasmodium were found to be enriched in upstream regions of stage-regulated T. annulata genes and validated as targets for the T. annulata AP2 domains by electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA). Two findings were of particular note: the gene in T. annulata encoding the orthologue of the ApiAP2 domain in the AP2-G factor that commits Plasmodium to gametocyte production, has an expression profile indicating involvement in transmission of T. annulata to the tick vector; genes encoding related domains that bind, or are predicted to bind, sequence motifs of the type 5'-(A)CACAC(A) are implicated in differential regulation of gene expression, with one gene (TA11145) likely to be preferentially up-regulated via auto-regulation as the cell progresses to merogony.

Conclusions

We postulate that the Theileria factor possessing the AP2 domain orthologous to that of Plasmodium AP2-G may regulate gametocytogenesis in a similar manner to AP2-G. In addition, paralogous ApiAP2 factors that recognise 5'-(A)CACAC(A) type motifs could operate in a competitive manner to promote reversible progression towards the point that commits the cell to undergo merogony. Factors possessing AP2 domains that bind (or are predicted to bind) this motif are present in the vector-borne genera Theileria, Babesia and Plasmodium, and other Apicomplexa; leading to the proposal that the mechanisms that control stage differentiation will show a degree of conservation.

The ability of vector-borne Apicomplexan parasites (Babesia, Plasmodium and Theileria) to change from one life-cycle stage to the next is critical for establishment of infection and transmission to new hosts. Stage differentiation steps of both Plasmodium and Theileria are known to involve stochastic transition through an intermediate form to a point that commits the cell to generate the next stage in the life-cycle. In this study we have identified genes encoding ApiAP2 DNA binding proteins in Theileria annulata that are differentially expressed during differentiation from the macroschizont stage, through merozoite production (merogony) to the piroplasm stage. The results provide evidence that the ApiAp2 factor in Theileria that possesses the orthologue of the Plasmodium AP2-G domain may also operate to regulate gametocytogenesis, and that progression to merogony is promoted by the ability of a merozoite DNA binding protein to preferentially up-regulate its own production. In addition, identification of multiple ApiAP2 DNA binding domains that bind related motifs within and across vector-borne Apicomplexan genera lead to the proposal that the mechanisms that promote the transition from asexual to sexual replication will show a degree of conservation.

Modulation of NF-kappaB activation in Theileria annulata-infected cloned cell lines is associated with detection of parasite-dependent IKK signalosomes and disruption of the actin cytoskeleton

Apicomplexan parasites within the genus Theileria have the ability to induce continuous proliferation and prevent apoptosis of the infected bovine leukocyte. Protection against apoptosis involves constitutive activation of the bovine transcription factor NF-kappaB in a parasite-dependent manner. Activation of NF-kappaB is thought to involve recruitment of IKK signalosomes at the surface of the macroschizont stage of the parasite, and it has been postulated that additional host proteins with adaptor or scaffolding function may be involved in signalosome formation. In this study two clonal cell lines were identified that show marked differences in the level of activated NF-kappaB. Further characterization of these lines demonstrated that elevated levels of activated NF-kappaB correlated with increased resistance to cell death and detection of parasite-associated IKK signalosomes, supporting results of our previous studies. Evidence was also provided for the existence of host- and parasite-dependent NF-kappaB activation pathways that are influenced by the architecture of the actin cytoskeleton. Despite this influence, it appears that the primary event required for formation of the parasite-dependent IKK signalosome is likely to be an interaction between a signalosome component and a parasite-encoded surface ligand.

Properties of non-coding DNA and identification of putative cis-regulatory elements in Theileria parva

Background

Parasites in the genus Theileria cause lymphoproliferative diseases in cattle, resulting in enormous socio-economic losses. The availability of the genome sequences and annotation for T. parva and T. annulata has facilitated the study of parasite biology and their relationship with host cell transformation and tropism. However, the mechanism of transcriptional regulation in this genus, which may be key to understanding fundamental aspects of its parasitology, remains poorly understood. In this study, we analyze the evolution of non-coding sequences in the Theileria genome and identify conserved sequence elements that may be involved in gene regulation of these parasitic species.

Results

Intergenic regions and introns in Theileria are short, and their length distributions are considerably right-skewed. Intergenic regions flanked by genes in 5'-5' orientation tend to be longer and slightly more AT-rich than those flanked by two stop codons; intergenic regions flanked by genes in 3'-5' orientation have intermediate values of length and AT composition. Intron position is negatively correlated with intron length, and positively correlated with GC content. Using stringent criteria, we identified a set of high-quality orthologous non-coding sequences between T. parva and T. annulata, and determined the distribution of selective constraints across regions, which are shown to be higher close to translation start sites. A positive correlation between constraint and length in both intergenic regions and introns suggests a tight control over length expansion of non-coding regions. Genome-wide searches for functional elements revealed several conserved motifs in intergenic regions of Theileria genomes. Two such motifs are preferentially located within the first 60 base pairs upstream of transcription start sites in T. parva, are preferentially associated with specific protein functional categories, and have significant similarity to know regulatory motifs in other species. These results suggest that these two motifs are likely to represent transcription factor binding sites in Theileria.

Conclusion

Theileria genomes are highly compact, with selection seemingly favoring short introns and intergenic regions. Three over-represented sequence motifs were independently identified in intergenic regions of both Theileria species, and the evidence suggests that at least two of them play a role in transcriptional control in T. parva. These are prime candidates for experimental validation of transcription factor binding sites in this single-celled eukaryotic parasite. Sequences similar to two of these Theileria motifs are conserved in Plasmodium hinting at the possibility of common regulatory machinery across the phylum Apicomplexa.

Stochastic induction of Theileria annulata merogony in vitro by chloramphenicol

Theileria annulata inhabits the cytoplasm of bovine leukocytes where it can be found as a multinucleated schizont. The schizont is the pathogenic stage of the life cycle and by interfering with host signalling pathways, it induces unlimited host cell proliferation and protection against apoptosis. In the infected animal, the schizont differentiates to the merozoite life cycle stage in a process called merogony. This takes place within the host leukocyte, resulting in the production of merozoites that are subsequently released by leukocyte lysis. In established cultures of T. annulata-transformed cells, merogony does not spontaneously occur, but the process can be activated by a shift in temperature. In this study we show that chloramphenicol induces schizont differentiation in proliferating T. annulata-transformed cells. We demonstrate that chloramphenicol-induced merogony is inherently asynchronous and has a quantitative basis. The process is accompanied by the down-regulation of schizont-specific surface proteins, de novo expression of merozoite-specific markers such as Tamr1 and Tams1 and the morphological hallmarks of merogony. Chloramphenicol-induced parasite differentiation was found to be associated with diminished proliferation potential and extensive morphological changes of the host cell, including increased numbers of pseudopodia. Significantly, chloramphenicol treatment can accelerate merogony induced by elevated temperature, supporting postulation that the differentiation event is a stochastic process that can be manipulated to alter the outcome of parasitic infection.

Naegleria fowleri: Functional expression of the Nfa1 protein in transfected Naegleria gruberi by promoter modification

To establish a transient transfection system in a Naegleria, we constructed three nfa1-pEGFP-N1 vectors by the promoter replacement and insertion of a nfa1 gene and transfected the DNAs into Naegleria gruberi using a lipid reagent. The transfection efficiency and usefulness of the three modified vectors were estimated by identifying the expressions of the EGFP and Nfa1 protein from N. gruberi. After transfection, the Nfa1 protein was functionally expressed on pseudopodia of N. gruberi. The strong GFP fluorescence was observed in N. gruberi transfected with the actin-nfa1-pEGFP-N1 vector, of which the CMV promoter region in the expression vector was replaced with the actin 5' UTR region. Additionally, when transgenic N. gruberi trophozoites were co-cultured with CHO target cells, the Nfa1 protein was also located on cytoplasm and pseudopodia, especially on a food cup that was formed in contact with target cells as it shown in pathogenic N. fowleri.

Expression of the nfa1 gene cloned from pathogenic Naegleria fowleri in nonpathogenic N. gruberi enhances cytotoxicity against CHO target cells in vitro

The pathogenic amoeba Naegleria fowleri has a 360-bp nfa1 gene that encodes the Nfa1 protein (13.1 kDa), which is located in the pseudopodia of the amoeba, and an anti-Nfa1 antibody reduces N. fowleri-induced mammalian-cell cytotoxicity in vitro. In contrast, an anti-Nfa1 antibody cannot detect Nfa1 protein expression in the nonpathogenic amoeba Naegleria gruberi, which also possesses the nfa1 gene. In the present study, the nfa1 gene cloned from pathogenic N. fowleri was transfected into nonpathogenic N. gruberi to determine whether it was related to pathogenicity. The nfa1 gene was initially inserted into a eukaryotic transfection vector, pEGFP-C2, containing a cytomegalovirus promoter and the green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene, and was designed as pEGFP-C2/nfa1UTR (nfa1UTR contains 5' upstream regions, the nfa1 open reading frame, and 3' downstream regions). After transfection, the green fluorescence was observed in the cytoplasm of N. gruberi trophozoites. These transfectants were preserved for more than 9 months after selection. The transfected nfa1 gene was observed by PCR using nfa1- and vector-specific primers in the genomic DNA of N. gruberi transfected with the pEGFP-C2/nfa1UTR vector. In addition, the nfa1 and GFP genes were identified by reverse transcription-PCR in transgenic N. gruberi. The Nfa1 protein expressed in transgenic N. gruberi was identified as a 13.1-kDa band by Western blotting using an anti-Nfa1 antibody. Finally, N. gruberi transfected with the pEGFP-C2/nfa1UTR vector was found to have enhanced cytotoxicity against CHO cells compared with naïve N. gruberi.

Theileria annulata: identification, by differential mRNA display, of modulated host and parasite gene expression in cell lines that are competent or attenuated for differentiation to the merozoite

To identify both host and parasite genes that show altered expression during differentiation of Theileria annulata from the macroschizont to the merozoite stage of the life cycle, the RNA profiles of two T. annulata-infected clonal cell lines (D7 and D7B12) with the same genetic background have been compared by RNA display. In the cloned cell line D7, T. annulata differentiates from the macroschizont to the merozoite at 41 degrees C, whereas in the cell line D7B12, which was derived by recloning D7, the parasite does not differentiate. Therefore, genes that show altered expression levels in either clone could be modulated by the differentiation event and are possible candidates for regulators of this process. Differential display was carried out initially on RNA extracted from D7 and D7B12 macroschizont-infected cells cultured at 37 degrees C and secondly on RNA extracted from the two cell lines incubated at 41 degrees C to induce differentiation to the merozoite. The first procedure identified 29 cDNA fragments that displayed altered levels between D7 and D7B12, 9 of which were confirmed to be differentially expressed by Northern blot analysis. Of these 9 gene fragments, 8 were found to be of host origin, while 1 was parasite derived. The second RNA display analysis identified 14 transcripts that showed altered levels during a differentiation time course, of which 6 were confirmed to be differentially expressed between D7B12 cells and differentiating D7 cells by Northern blot analysis. Of these 6 gene fragments, 1 was of host and 5 were of parasite origin. The parasite genes either showed levels of RNA consistent with constitutive gene expression or, in one case, a genuine upregulation of mRNA associated with the differentiation process.

Proinflammatory cytokine expression by Theileria annulata infected cell lines correlates with the pathology they cause in vivo

Control of Theileria annulata is currently best achieved by the use of live attenuated cell line vaccines. However, the mechanisms underlying attenuation are unclear and there is a need to rapidly produce new cell line vaccines, which could safely and effectively vaccinate cattle against tropical theileriosis. There is increasing evidence to suggest that proinflammatory cytokines produced by T. annulata infected cells play a central role in both pathology and immune evasion. This study aimed to test this hypothesis and to evaluate cytokine expression as a marker of virulence. The pathogenicity and protective efficacy of cloned T. annulata cell lines that expressed different levels of proinflammatory cytokines were compared. In two independent trials using different stocks of T. annulata, cell lines that expressed higher levels of proinflammatory cytokines induced severe reactions, and in some cases death, when used to vaccinate groups of cattle. In contrast, low cytokine expressing lines induced low post-vaccinal reactions. The results clearly demonstrated that cytokine expression by T. annulata infected cells could be used as a marker of virulence and provided strong evidence to support a role for cytokines in the induction of pathology. Both high and low cytokine expressing cell lines protected cattle against heterologous challenge infection, offering the possibility of using cytokine expression to rapidly select new safe, potent vaccines against tropical theileriosis without the need for culture attenuation.

Transient transfection of Theileria annulata

We have developed a method to transiently transfect infective, uninucleate, Theileria annulata sporozoites. Transfection vectors have been constructed using a number of T. annulata 5' gene flanking sequences linked to the enhanced green fluorescence protein (eGFP) reporter gene. Sporozoites were transfected with these constructs using the lipid transfection agent SuperFect, then allowed to infect purified bovine mononuclear cells (PBMs). Green fluorescence was observed in developing trophozoites, 36-40 h post infection, using constructs containing the upstream regions of the T. annulata Hsp70, T. annulata merozite surface antigen 1 (TamS1) and T. annulata macroschizont-specific AT hook-containing protein2 (TashAT2) genes. A construct with the 5' TamS1 upstream sequence in reverse orientation gave no detectable fluorescence indicating fluorescence was derived by expression from the T. annulata promoter. A cytomegalovirus (CMV) promoter construct showed no activity in this stage of the parasite. However, when this construct was introduced directly into schizont-infected cells by electroporation, fluorescence was observed in the bovine cells but not the schizont. We describe the significance of these results in relation to novel control strategies and the fundamental biology of Theileria parasites.

Characterization of attenuated Theileria annulata vaccines from Spain and the Sudan

Theileriosis caused by Theileria annulata can be effectively prevented by vaccination with attenuated, cultured schizonts. Although these attenuated vaccines have been applied for a long time, not much is known about the fate of the vaccine strain in the field. Here, two experimental Spanish vaccine strains originating in Cádiz and Cáceres, and one Sudanese strain are studied to address the development of a carrier status and the infectivity for Hyalomma ticks. Moreover, the heterogeneity of the merozoite surface protein, Tams1, was analyzed in search for an attenuation marker. Using the sensitive reverse line blot (RLB) hybridization, the development of a low level carrier status was demonstrated in the Cáceres and Sudanese line vaccinated calves. Although no signal was detected in the Cádiz line vaccinated calves, seroconversion against the schizont stage was observed, as it was in all other calves. The experimental transmission of T. annulata by Hyalomma ticks to naïve calves was unsuccessful for all cell line inoculated calves. Tams1 heterogeneity indicated a clonal selection of parasites during the process of attenuation, but the Tams1 sequence itself has no connection with the attenuation status. In conclusion, a carrier status develops in attenuated schizont culture vaccinated calves, but is not infective for Hyalomma ticks. Based on these data, the risk for spread of the vaccine strains in the field may be very low.

An upstream element of the TamS1 gene is a site of DNA-protein interactions during differentiation to the merozoite in Theileria annulata

Apicomplexan parasites are major pathogens of humans and domesticated animals. A fundamental aspect of apicomplexan biology, which may provide novel molecular targets for parasite control, is the regulation of stage differentiation. Studies carried out on Theileria annulata, a bovine apicomplexan parasite, have provided evidence that a stochastic process controls differentiation from the macroschizont to the merozoite stage. It was postulated that this process involves the presence of regulators of merozoite gene expression in the preceding stage of the life cycle, and that during differentiation a quantitative increase of these factors occurs. This study was carried out to test these postulations. Nuclear run-on analysis showed that TamS1 expression is controlled, at least in part, at the transcriptional level. The transcription start site showed homology with the consensus eukaryotic initiator motif, and study of the 5′ upstream region by the electrophoretic mobility-shift assay demonstrated that a 23 bp motif specifically bound factors from parasite-enriched nuclear extracts. Three complexes were shown to bind to a 9 bp core binding site (5′-TTTGTAGGG-3′). Two of these complexes were present in macroschizont extracts but were found at elevated levels during differentiation. Both complexes contain a polypeptide of the same molecular mass and may be related via the formation of homodimer or heterodimer complexes. The third complex appears to be distinct and was detected at time points associated with the transition to high level merozoite gene expression.

Should I stay or should I go now? A stochastic model of stage differentiation in Theileria annulata

The events that initiate and determine stage differentiation of protozoan parasites are not fully understood. In this article, Brian Shiels suggests that for differentiation to the merozoite in Theileria annulata the process is predetermined by the parasite, but can be initiated and modulated by changes to the extracellular environment. Shiels proposes a mechanism operating on the basis of factors that regulate gene expression reaching a commitment threshold. Similarities across protozoan and higher eukaryotic differentiation systems lead Shiels to speculate that the T. annulata model may be of relevance to other parasites.