On the linkage between RNA processing and RNA translatability

Cellular variability of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay

Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) is an mRNA degradation pathway that eliminates transcripts containing premature termination codons (PTCs). Half-lives of the mRNAs containing PTCs demonstrate that a small percent escape surveillance and do not degrade. It is not known whether this escape represents variable mRNA degradation within cells or, alternatively cells within the population are resistant. Here we demonstrate a single-cell approach with a bi-directional reporter, which expresses two β-globin genes with or without a PTC in the same cell, to characterize the efficiency of NMD in individual cells. We found a broad range of NMD efficiency in the population; some cells degraded essentially all of the mRNAs, while others escaped NMD almost completely. Characterization of NMD efficiency together with NMD regulators in single cells showed cell-to-cell variability of NMD reflects the differential level of surveillance factors, SMG1 and phosphorylated UPF1. A single-cell fluorescent reporter system that enabled detection of NMD using flow cytometry revealed that this escape occurred either by translational readthrough at the PTC or by a failure of mRNA degradation after successful translation termination at the PTC.

The Yin and Yang of RNA surveillance in B lymphocytes and antibody-secreting plasma cells

The random V(D)J recombination process ensures the diversity of the primary immunoglobulin (Ig) repertoire. In two thirds of cases, imprecise recombination between variable (V), diversity (D), and joining (J) segments induces a frameshift in the open reading frame that leads to the appearance of premature termination codons (PTCs). Thus, many B lineage cells harbour biallelic V(D)J-rearrangements of Ig heavy or light chain genes, with a productively-recombined allele encoding the functional Ig chain and a nonproductive allele potentially encoding truncated Ig polypeptides. Since the pattern of Ig gene expression is mostly biallelic, transcription initiated from nonproductive Ig alleles generates considerable amounts of primary transcripts with out-of-frame V(D)J junctions. How RNA surveillance pathways cooperate to control the noise from nonproductive Ig genes will be discussed in this review, focusing on the benefits of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) activation during B-cell development and detrimental effects of nonsense-associated altered splicing (NAS) in terminally differentiated plasma cells.

MHC-I presentation of peptides derived from intact protein products of the pioneer round of translation

Among the earliest protein products of most cellular genes are those synthesized during the pioneer round of translation (PRT), a key step in nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) that allows scanning of new transcripts for the presence of a premature termination codon (PTC). It has been demonstrated that at least some PRT degradation products can be targeted to major histocompatibility (MHC)-I presentation. To gain new insight into this putative PRT-to-MHC-I route, we have assembled 2 pairs of reporter genes so that the 2 genes in each pair encode an identical fusion protein between a model antigenic peptide and enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP), one of which harbors a PTC. We expressed these genes in different mouse and human cell lines and confirmed enhanced NMD activity for the PTC(+) gene in each pair by monitoring the effect of cycloheximide on the level of the respective mRNA. We then exploited several strategies for establishing the ratio between level of peptide presentation and total amount of protein product. We consistently observed significantly higher ratios for the PTC(+) mRNAs compared with the PTC(-) ones, pointing to correlation between the turnover of otherwise identical proteins and the fate of their template mRNA. Using confocal microscopy, we showed a clear link between NMD, the presence of misfolded EGFP polypeptides, and enhanced MHC-I peptide presentation. Altogether, these findings imply that identical full-length gene products differing only in 3' noncoding sequences can be differentially degraded and targeted to the MHC-I presentation pathway, suggesting a more general role for the PRT in establishing the MHC-I peptidome.-Weinstein-Marom, H., Hendel, L., Laron, E. A., Sharabi-Nov, A., Margalit, A., Gross, G. MHC-I presentation of peptides derived from intact protein products of the pioneer round of translation.

Post-transcriptional regulatory networks in immunity

Post-transcriptional mechanisms that modulate global and/or transcript-specific mRNA stability and translation contribute to the rapid and flexible control of gene expression in immune effector cells. These mechanisms rely on RNA-binding proteins (RBPs) that direct regulatory complexes (e.g. exosomes, deadenylases, decapping complexes, RNA-induced silencing complexes) to the 3'-untranslated regions of specific immune transcripts. Here, we review the surprising variety of post-transcriptional control mechanisms that contribute to gene expression in the immune system and discuss how defects in these pathways can contribute to autoimmune disease.

Regulation of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay

Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) is a highly conserved pathway that was originally identified as a RNA surveillance mechanism that degrades aberrant mRNAs harboring premature termination (nonsense) codons. Recently, it was discovered that NMD also regulates normal gene expression. Genome-wide studies showed that ablation of NMD alters the expression of ∼10% of transcripts in a wide variety of eukaryotes. In general, NMD specifically targets normal transcripts that harbor a stop codon in a premature context. The finding that NMD regulates normal gene expression raises the possibility that NMD itself is subject to regulation. Indeed, recent studies have shown that NMD efficiency varies in different cell types and tissues. NMD is also subject to developmental control in both higher and lower eukaryotic species. Molecular mechanisms have been defined-including those involving microRNAs and other RNA decay pathways-that regulate the magnitude of NMD in some developmental settings. This developmental regulation of NMD appears to have physiological roles, at least in some model systems. In addition to mechanisms that modulate the efficiency of NMD, mechanisms have recently been identified that serve the opposite purpose: to maintain the efficiency of NMD in the face of insults. This 'buffering' is achieved by feedback networks that serve to regulate the stability of NMD factors. The discovery of NMD homeostasis and NMD regulatory mechanisms has important implications for how NMD acts in biological processes and how its magnitude could potentially be manipulated for clinical benefit.

Cross talk between immunoglobulin heavy-chain transcription and RNA surveillance during B cell development

Immunoglobulin (Ig) genes naturally acquire frequent premature termination codons during the error-prone V(D)J recombination process. Although B cell differentiation is linked to the expression of productive Ig alleles, the transcriptional status of nonfunctionally recombined alleles remains unclear. Here, we tracked transcription and posttranscriptional regulation for both Ig heavy-chain (IgH) alleles in mice carrying a nonfunctional knock-in allele. We show that productively and nonproductively VDJ-rearranged alleles are transcribed throughout B cell development, carry similar active chromatin marks, and even display equivalent RNA polymerase II (RNAPII) loading after B cell stimulation. Hence, these results challenge the idea that the repositioning of one allele to heterochromatin could promote the silencing of nonproductive alleles. Interestingly, the efficiency of downstream RNA surveillance mechanisms fluctuates according to B cell activation and terminal differentiation: unspliced nonfunctional transcripts accumulate in primary B cells, while B cell activation promotes IgH transcription, RNA splicing, and nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD). Altogether, IgH transcription and RNA splicing rates determine by which RNA surveillance mechanisms a B cell can get rid of nonproductive IgH mRNAs.

Alternative splicing induced by nonsense mutations in the immunoglobulin mu VDJ exon is independent of truncation of the open reading frame

In addition to triggering nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD), premature translation-termination codons (PTCs) frequently induce alternative splicing, an observation referred to as nonsense-associated alternative splicing (NAS). In many cases, NAS is induced because the nonsense mutation alters a splicing signal, such as inactivating an exonic splicing enhancer. However, for a few genes, NAS was reported to be PTC specific, implying that a translation signal could influence splicing. Here, we investigated whether production of a previously undetected alternatively spliced transcript from immunoglobulin mu (Ig-mu) depends on premature termination of the open reading frame. We show that PTCs at different positions in the VDJ exon of an Ig-mu minigene activate usage of an alternative 3' splice site, generating an alternative transcript that lacks the initial PTC and a previously identified NMD-promoting element (NPE), but contains new PTCs because of a frame shift. Corroborating the importance of the NPE for maximal NMD response, the alternative transcript is only moderately down-regulated by NMD. We further demonstrate that NAS of Ig-mu minigene transcripts is not PTC specific. This finding, together with our results that contradict the previously reported frame dependence of TCR-beta NAS, challenges the idea that cells might possess mechanisms that would allow regulation of splice site selection in response to premature termination of the ORF.

RNAi and RNA-based regulation of immune system function

Gene regulation by short RNAs is a ubiquitous and important mode of control. MicroRNAs are short, single-strand RNAs that bind with partial complementarity to the 3' untranslated region of several genes to silence their expression. This expanding class of endogenous short RNAs are evolutionarily conserved and participate in control of development and cell-specific gene function. Several of these microRNAs have been cloned uniquely from mammalian lymphocytes suggesting specialized roles in lymphocyte development and function. In addition, several genes linked to RNAi in lower eukaryotes have mammalian homologs with specialized roles in adaptive immunity. For example, in worms, the nonsense-mediated decay (NMD) and RNAi pathways appear to be intricately linked. NMD plays a key role in regulating antigen-receptor expression in lymphocytes and there are mammalian homologs for factors identified in worms that appear to be common in both RNAi and NMD pathways. On the other hand, RNA editing and RNAi have an inverse relationship and RNA editing has an important role in viral immunity. These observations indicate unique roles for dsRNAs in the mammalian immune system.

Premature termination codons do not affect the rate of splicing of neighboring introns

Introduction of a premature termination codon (PTC) into an exon of a gene can lead to nonsense-mediated decay of the mRNA, which is best characterized as a cytoplasmic event. However, increasing evidence has suggested that PTCs may also influence the nuclear processing of an RNA transcript, leading to models of nuclear surveillance perhaps involving translating nuclear ribosomes. We used quantitative RT-PCR to measure the in vivo steady-state levels of every exon-intron junction in wild-type, PTC-containing, and missense-containing precursor mRNAs of both the nonrearranging dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) and the somatically rearranging Ig- micro genes. We find that each exon-intron junction's abundance and, therefore, the rate of intron removal, is not significantly affected by the presence of a PTC in a neighboring exon in either the DHFR or Ig- micro pre-mRNA. Similarly, the abundance of the uncleaved Ig- micro polyadenylation sites does not differ between wild-type and PTC-containing Ig- micro pre-mRNAs. Our Ig- micro data were confirmed by RNase protection analyses, and multiple cell isolates were examined to resolve differences with previously published data on steady-state pre-mRNA levels. We conclude that the presence of a PTC affects the rate of neither splicing nor the cleavage step of 3' end formation during pre-mRNA processing in the nucleus. Our results are discussed with respect to existing evidence for nuclear surveillance mechanisms.

A quality control pathway that down-regulates aberrant T-cell receptor (TCR) transcripts by a mechanism requiring UPF2 and translation

Nonsense-mediated decay (NMD) is an RNA surveillance pathway that degrades mRNAs containing premature termination codons (PTC). T-cell receptor (TCR) and immunoglobulin (Ig) transcripts, which are encoded by genes that very frequently acquire PTCs during lymphoid ontogeny, are down-regulated much more dramatically in response to PTCs than are other known transcripts. Another feature unique to TCR, Ig, and a subset of other mRNAs is that they are down-regulated in response to nonsense codons in the nuclear fraction of cells. This is paradoxical, as the only well recognized entity that recognizes nonsense codons is the cytoplasmic translation apparatus. Therefore, we investigated whether translation is responsible for this nuclear-associated mechanism. We found that the down-regulation of TCR-beta transcripts in response to nonsense codons requires several features of translation, including an initiator ATG and the ability to scan. We also found that optimal down-regulation depends on a Kozak consensus sequence surrounding the initiator ATG and that it can be initiated by an internal ribosome entry site, neither of which has been demonstrated before for any other PTC-bearing mRNA. At least a portion of this down-regulatory response is mediated by the NMD pathway as antisense hUPF2 transcripts increased the levels of PTC-bearing TCR-beta transcripts in the nuclear fraction of cells. We conclude that a hUPF2-dependent RNA surveillance pathway with translation-like features operating in the nuclear fraction of cells prevents the expression of potentially deleterious truncated proteins encoded by non-productively rearranged TCR genes.

Activation-induced cytidine deaminase turns on somatic hypermutation in hybridomas

The production of high-affinity protective antibodies requires somatic hypermutation (SHM) of the antibody variable (V)-region genes. SHM is characterized by a high frequency of point mutations that occur only during the centroblast stage of B-cell differentiation. Activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), which is expressed specifically in germinal-centre centroblasts, is required for this process, but its exact role is unknown. Here we show that AID is required for SHM in the centroblast-like Ramos cells, and that expression of AID is sufficient to induce SHM in hybridoma cells, which represent a later stage of B-cell differentiation that does not normally undergo SHM. In one hybridoma, mutations were exclusively in G*C base pairs that were mostly within RGYW or WRCY motifs, suggesting that AID has primary responsibility for mutations at these nucleotides. The activation of SHM in hybridomas indicates that AID does not require other centroblast-specific cofactors to induce SHM, suggesting either that it functions alone or that the factors it requires are expressed at other stages of B-cell differentiation.

Precursor RNAs harboring nonsense codons accumulate near the site of transcription

Messenger RNAs containing premature termination codons (PTCs) are selectively eliminated by nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD). Paradoxically, although cytoplasmic ribosomes are the only known species capable of PTC recognition, in mammals many PTC-containing mRNAs are apparently eliminated prior to release from the nucleus. To determine whether PTCs can influence events within the nucleus proper, we studied the immunoglobulin (Ig)-mu and T cell receptor (TCR)-beta genes using fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH). Alleles containing PTCs, but not those containing a missense mutation or a frameshift followed by frame-correcting mutations, exhibited elevated levels of pre-mRNA, which accumulated at or near the site of transcription. Our data indicate that mRNA reading frame can influence events at or near the site of gene transcription.

A premature termination codon within an alternative exon affecting only the metabolism of transcripts that retain this exon

Protein 4.1 pre-mRNA splicing is regulated in tissue- and development-specific manners. Exon 16, which encodes the N-terminal region of the spectrin/actin-binding domain, is one of the alternatively spliced sequence motifs. It is present in late differentiated erythroid cells but absent from early erythroblasts and from lymphoid cells. We describe a single nucleotide deletion of the erythroid protein 4.1 gene associated with hereditary elliptocytosis. The deletion located in exon 16 leads to a frameshift and a premature termination codon within the same exon. In an effort to examine the premature stop codon effect in relationship with exon 16 alternative splicing, we analyzed erythroid and lymphoid protein 4.1 mRNAs using the mutation and a linked downstream polymorphism as markers. We found that the premature stop codon does not affect the tissue-specific alternative splicing among the two cell types analyzed and that the resulting alteration of mRNA metabolism correlates with the retention of exon 16 in reticulocytes. Conversely, skipping of exon 16 in lymphoid cells converts the mutant mRNA to a normal lymphoid-specific mRNA isoform, hence bypassing the nonsense codon. Consistent with data obtained on constitutive nonsense exons, our observations argue in favor of a stop codon recognition mechanism that occurs after the regulated splicing status of the nonsense exon has been achieved.

Infrequent translation of a nonsense codon is sufficient to decrease mRNA level

In many organisms nonsense mutations decrease the level of mRNA. In the case of mammalian cells, it is still controversial whether translation is required for this nonsense-mediated RNA decrease (NMD). Although previous analyzes have shown that conditions that impede translation termination at nonsense codons also prevent NMD, the residual level of termination was unknown in these experiments. Moreover, the conditions used to impede termination might also have interfered with NMD in other ways. Because of these uncertainties, we have tested the effects of limiting translation of a nonsense codon in a different way, using two mutations in the immunoglobulin mu heavy chain gene. For this purpose we exploited an exceptional nonsense mutation at codon 3, which efficiently terminates translation but nonetheless maintains a high level of mu mRNA. We have shown 1) that translation of Ter462 in the double mutant occurs at only approximately 4% the normal frequency, and 2) that Ter462 in cis with Ter3 can induce NMD. That is, translation of Ter462 at this low (4%) frequency is sufficient to induce NMD.

Alternative Splicing and Hypermutation of a Nonproductively Rearranged TCR α-Chain in a T Cell Hybridoma

Like Ig genes, TCR genes are formed by somatic rearrangements of noncontiguous genomic V, J, and C regions. Unlike Ig genes, somatic hypermutation of TCR V regions is an infrequent event. We describe the occurrence of spontaneous hypermutation in a nonproductively rearranged TCR α-chain gene in a clonal T cell hybridoma that had lost its productively rearranged α-chain. The mutating hybridoma was eventually supplanted in culture by a nonmutating variant that had restored an open reading frame in the nonproductively rearranged TCR α-chain through the use of cryptic splice sites in the Vα region. Evidence is presented for the presence of cDNA reverse transcripts of the TCR α-chain within the hybridoma, suggesting a role for reverse transcriptase in the generation of mutations.

At least one intron is required for the nonsense-mediated decay of triosephosphate isomerase mRNA: a possible link between nuclear splicing and cytoplasmic translation

Mammalian cells have established mechanisms to reduce the abundance of mRNAs that harbor a nonsense codon and prematurely terminate translation. In the case of the human triosephosphate isomerase (TPI gene), nonsense codons located less than 50 to 55 bp upstream of intron 6, the 3'-most intron, fail to mediate mRNA decay. With the aim of understanding the feature(s) of TPI intron 6 that confer function in positioning the boundary between nonsense codons that do and do not mediate decay, the effects of deleting or duplicating introns have been assessed. The results demonstrate that TPI intron 6 functions to position the boundary because it is the 3'-most intron. Since decay takes place after pre-mRNA splicing, it is conceivable that removal of the 3'-most intron from pre-mRNA "marks" the 3'-most exon-exon junction of product mRNA so that only nonsense codons located more than 50 to 55 nucleotides upstream of the "mark" mediate mRNA decay. Decay may be elicited by the failure of translating ribosomes to translate sufficiently close to the mark or, more likely, the scanning or looping out of some component(s) of the translation termination complex to the mark. In support of scanning, a nonsense codon does not elicit decay if some of the introns that normally reside downstream of the nonsense codon are deleted so the nonsense codon is located (i) too far away from a downstream intron, suggesting that all exon-exon junctions may be marked, and (ii) too far away from a downstream failsafe sequence that appears to function on behalf of intron 6, i.e., when intron 6 fails to leave a mark. Notably, the proposed scanning complex may have a greater unwinding capability than the complex that scans for a translation initiation codon since a hairpin structure strong enough to block translation initiation when inserted into the 5' untranslated region does not block nonsense-mediated decay when inserted into exon 6 between a nonsense codon residing in exon 6 and intron 6.

T cell receptor (TCR) mini-gene mRNA expression regulated by nonsense codons: a nuclear-associated translation-like mechanism

Premature termination codons (PTCs) are known to decrease mRNA levels. Here, we report our investigation of the mechanism for this downregulation using the TCR-beta gene, which acquires PTCs as a result of programmed rearrangements that occur during normal thymic development. We found that a mini-gene version of this gene, which contains only three TCR-beta exons, exhibited efficient downregulation in response to PTCs. This demonstrates that the full coding sequence is not necessary for appropriate regulation. Mutation of the translation start AUG and a downstream in-frame AUG that displayed similarity to the Kozak consensus sequence reversed the downregulatory response to PTCs. Thus, an AUG start codon is required to define the reading frame of a PTC. Specific suppressor tRNAs also reversed the downregulatory response, strongly implicating the involvement of a translation-like process. Remarkably, the addition of suppressor tRNAs or the inactivation of the start AUGs caused a dramatic rise in the levels of PTC-bearing transcripts in the nuclear fraction prepared by two independent methods. Collectively, our results provide evidence for a codon-based surveillance mechanism associated with the nucleus that downregulates aberrant transcripts encoding potentially toxic polypeptides from nonproductively rearranged genes.

Instability of endogenous MRP/proliferin transcripts in the nucleus of mouse embryo fibroblasts contrasts with their stability when produced during transient transfections

The mitogen regulated protein/proliferin (MRP/PLF) gene is transcribed in primary mouse embryo fibroblasts (MEFs), but the pre-mRNA is not properly converted into a stable cytoplasmic mRNA and instead is rapidly degraded, apparently in the nucleus [Malyankar et al. (1994): Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91:335-359]. In 3T3 cells derived from the MEFs by the standard 3T3 immortalization protocol, stable MRP/PLF mRNA is produced. We show here that the processing of intron sequences is similar in the two cell types and that some of the MRP/PLF transcripts are polyadenylated in the MEFs. We also document the production of stable MRP/PLF mRNA generated by transcription of various plasmid constructs containing different portions of the MRP/PLF3 gene after calcium phosphate-mediated transfection into the MEFs. We conclude that the inability of the MRP/PLF mRNA to accumulate in the MEFs is unlikely to result solely from a single localized sequence in the primary transcript (or the mRNA) that causes it to be subject to rapid breakdown; possibly export of the mRNA from the MEF nucleus is defective or some aspect of the transcriptional process marks the transcript for degradation.

A regulatory mechanism that detects premature nonsense codons in T-cell receptor transcripts in vivo is reversed by protein synthesis inhibitors in vitro

Gene rearrangement during the ontogeny of T- and B-cells generates an enormous repertoire of T-cell receptor (TCR) and immunoglobulin (Ig) genes. Because of the error-prone nature of this rearrangement process, two-thirds of rearranged TCR and Ig genes are expected to be out-of-frame and thus contain premature terminations codons (ptcs). We performed sequence analysis of reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction products from fetal and adult thymus and found that newly transcribed TCR-beta pre-mRNAs (intron-bearing) are frequently derived from ptc-bearing genes but such transcripts rarely accumulate as mature (fully spliced) TCR-beta transcripts. Transfection studies in the SL12.4 T-cell line showed that the presence of a ptc in any of several TCR-beta exons triggered a decrease in mRNA levels. Ptc-bearing TCR-beta transcripts were selectively depressed in levels in a cell clone that contained both an in-frame and an out-of-frame gene, thus demonstrating the allelic specificity of this down-regulatory response. Protein synthesis inhibitors with different mechanism of action (anisomysin, cycloheximide, emetine, pactamycin, puromycin, and polio virus) all reversed the down-regulatory response. Ptc-bearing transcripts were induced within 0.5 h after cycloheximide treatment. The reversal by protein synthesis inhibitors was not restricted to lymphoid cells, as shown with TCR-beta and beta-globin constructs transfected in HeLa cells. Collectively, the data suggest that the ptc-mediated mRNA decay pathway requires an unstable protein, a ribosome, or a ribosome-like entity. Protein synthesis inhibitors may be useful tools toward elucidating the molecular mechanism of ptc-mediated mRNA decay, an enigmatic response that can occur in the nuclear fraction of mammalian cells.

Molecular basis of hereditary fructose intolerance: mutations and polymorphisms in the human aldolase B gene

Mutations in the human aldolase B gene that result in hereditary fructose intolerance have been characterized extensively. Although the majority of subjects have been from northern Europe, subjects from other geographical regions and ethnic groups have been identified. At present 21 mutations have been reported; 15 of these are single base substitutions, resulting in nine amino acid replacements, four nonsense codons, and two putative splicing defects. Two large deletions, two four-base deletions, a single-base deletion, and a seven-base deletion/one-base insertion have been found. This last mutation leads to a defect in splicing and it is likely that one of the small deletions does as well. Regions of the enzyme where mutations have been observed recurrently are encoded by exons 5 and 9. Indeed, the three most common mutations are found in these exons. Two of these prevalent HFI mutations arose from a common ancestor and spread throughout the population by genetic drift. This finding was based on linkage to two sequence polymorphisms, which are among very few informative polymorphic markers that have been identified within the aldolase B gene. Because of the prevalence of a few HFI alleles, and the recent advances in molecular methods for identifying and screening for mutation, the diagnosis of HFI by molecular screening methods should become routine. These molecular diagnostic methods will be extremely beneficial for this often difficult to diagnose and sometimes fatal disease.