Purification and biochemical characterization of Escherichia coli RecA proteins mutated in the putative DNA binding site

Biochemical characterization of RecA variants that contribute to extreme resistance to ionizing radiation

Among strains of Escherichia coli that have evolved to survive extreme exposure to ionizing radiation, mutations in the recA gene are prominent and contribute substantially to the acquired phenotype. Changes at amino acid residue 276, D276A and D276N, occur repeatedly and in separate evolved populations. RecA D276A and RecA D276N exhibit unique adaptations to an environment that can require the repair of hundreds of double strand breaks. These two RecA protein variants (a) exhibit a faster rate of filament nucleation on DNA, as well as a slower extension under at least some conditions, leading potentially to a distribution of the protein among a higher number of shorter filaments, (b) promote DNA strand exchange more efficiently in the context of a shorter filament, and (c) are markedly less inhibited by ADP. These adaptations potentially allow RecA protein to address larger numbers of double strand DNA breaks in an environment where ADP concentrations are higher due to a compromised cellular metabolism.

Accumulation of inorganic polyphosphate enables stress endurance and catalytic vigour in Pseudomonas putida KT2440

Background

Accumulation of inorganic polyphosphate (polyP), a persistent trait throughout the whole Tree of Life, is claimed to play a fundamental role in enduring environmental insults in a large variety of microorganisms. The share of polyP in the tolerance of the soil bacterium Pseudomonas putida KT2440 to a suite of physicochemical stresses has been studied on the background of its capacity as a host of oxidative biotransformations.

Results

Cells lacking polyphosphate kinase (Ppk), which expectedly presented a low intracellular polyP level, were more sensitive to a number of harsh external conditions such as ultraviolet irradiation, addition of β-lactam antibiotics and heavy metals (Cd²⁺ and Cu²⁺). Other phenotypes related to a high-energy phosphate load (e.g., swimming) were substantially weakened as well. Furthermore, the ppk mutant was consistently less tolerant to solvents and its survival in stationary phase was significantly affected. In contrast, the major metabolic routes were not significantly influenced by the loss of Ppk as diagnosed from respiration patterns of the mutant in phenotypic microarrays. However, the catalytic vigour of the mutant decreased to about 50% of that in the wild-type strain as estimated from the specific growth rate of cells carrying the catabolic TOL plasmid pWW0 for m-xylene biodegradation. The catalytic phenotype of the mutant was restored by over-expressing ppk in trans. Some of these deficits could be explained by the effect of the ppk mutation on the expression profile of the rpoS gene, the stationary phase sigma factor, which was revealed by the analysis of a P_rpoS → rpoS‘-’lacZ translational fusion. Still, every stress-related effect of lacking Ppk in P. putida was relatively moderate as compared to some of the conspicuous phenotypes reported for other bacteria.

Conclusions

While polyP can be involved in a myriad of cellular functions, the polymer seems to play a relatively secondary role in the genetic and biochemical networks that ultimately enable P. putida to endure environmental stresses. Instead, the main value of polyP could be ensuring a reservoire of energy during prolonged starvation. This is perhaps one of the reasons for polyP persistence in live systems despite its apparent lack of essentiality.

Presynaptic filament dynamics in homologous recombination and DNA repair

Homologous recombination (HR) is an essential genome stability mechanism used for high-fidelity repair of DNA double-strand breaks and for the recovery of stalled or collapsed DNA replication forks. The crucial homology search and DNA strand exchange steps of HR are catalyzed by presynaptic filaments-helical filaments of a recombinase enzyme bound to single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). Presynaptic filaments are fundamentally dynamic structures, the assembly, catalytic turnover, and disassembly of which must be closely coordinated with other elements of the DNA recombination, repair, and replication machinery in order for genome maintenance functions to be effective. Here, we reviewed the major dynamic elements controlling the assembly, activity, and disassembly of presynaptic filaments; some intrinsic such as recombinase ATP-binding and hydrolytic activities, others extrinsic such as ssDNA-binding proteins, mediator proteins, and DNA motor proteins. We examined dynamic behavior on multiple levels, including atomic- and filament-level structural changes associated with ATP binding and hydrolysis as evidenced in crystal structures, as well as subunit binding and dissociation events driven by intrinsic and extrinsic factors. We examined the biochemical properties of recombination proteins from four model systems (T4 phage, Escherichia coli, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and Homo sapiens), demonstrating how their properties are tailored for the context-specific requirements in these diverse species. We proposed that the presynaptic filament has evolved to rely on multiple external factors for increased multilevel regulation of HR processes in genomes with greater structural and sequence complexity.

A tale of two polymers: new insights into helical filaments

Many proteins function as helical polymers within the cell. Two intensively studied examples are eukaryotic actin and bacterial RecA, which belong to two different protein superfamilies. However, most other members of these superfamilies do not polymerize into helical filaments. General features of polymorphism, cooperativity and allostery that emerge from studies of eukaryotic actin and bacterial RecA raise more general issues about how conserved these filamentous structures have been during evolution.

Equilibrium binding of single-stranded DNA to the secondary DNA binding site of the bacterial recombinase RecA

The bacterial recombinase RecA forms a nucleoprotein filament in vitro with single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) at its primary DNA binding site, site I. This filament has a second site, site II, which binds ssDNA and double-stranded DNA. We have investigated the binding of ssDNA to the RecA protein in the presence of adenosine 5'-O-(thiotriphosphate) cofactor using fluorescence anisotropy. The RecA protein carried out DNA strand exchange with a 5'-fluorescein-labeled 32-mer oligonucleotide. The anisotropy signal was shown to measure oligonucleotide binding to RecA, and the relationship between signal and binding density was determined. Binding of ssDNA to site I of RecA was stable at high NaCl concentrations. Binding to site II could be described by a simple two-state equilibrium, K = 4.5 +/- 1.5 x 10(5) m(-1) (37 degrees C, 150 mm NaCl, pH 7.4). The reaction was enthalpy-driven and entropy-opposed. It depended on salt concentration and was sensitive to the type of monovalent anion, suggesting that anion-dependent protein conformations contribute to ssDNA binding at site II.

Molecular analysis of the Deinococcus radiodurans recA locus and identification of a mutation site in a DNA repair-deficient mutant, rec30

Deinococcus radiodurans strain rec30, which is a DNA damage repair-deficient mutant, has been estimated to be defective in the deinococcal recA gene. To identify the mutation site of strain rec30 and obtain information about the region flanking the gene, a 4.4-kb fragment carrying the wild-type recA gene was sequenced. It was revealed that the recA locus forms a polycistronic operon with the preceding cistrons (orf105a and orf105b). Predicted amino acid sequences of orf105a and orf105b showed substantial similarity to the competence-damage inducible protein (cinA gene product) from Streptococcus pneumoniae and the 2'-5' RNA ligase from Escherichia coli, respectively. By analyzing polymerase chain reaction (PCR) fragments derived from the genomic DNA of strain rec30, the mutation site in the strain was identified as a single G:C to A:T transition which causes an amino acid substitution at position 224 (Gly to Ser) of the deinococcal RecA protein. Furthermore, we succeeded in expressing both the wild-type and mutant recA genes of D. radiodurans in E. coli without any obvious toxicity or death. The gamma-ray resistance of an E. coli recA1 strain was fully restored by the expression of the wild-type recA gene of D. radiodurans that was cloned in an E. coli vector plasmid. This result is consistent with evidence that RecA proteins from many bacterial species can functionally complement E. coli recA mutants. In contrast with the wild-type gene, the mutant recA gene derived from strain rec30 did not complement E. coli recA1, suggesting that the mutant RecA protein lacks functional activity for recombinational repair.

Recombinational DNA repair in bacteria and the RecA protein

In bacteria, the major function of homologous genetic recombination is recombinational DNA repair. This is not a process reserved only for rare double-strand breaks caused by ionizing radiation, nor is it limited to situations in which the SOS response has been induced. Recombinational DNA repair in bacteria is closely tied to the cellular replication systems, and it functions to repair damage at stalled replication forks, Studies with a variety of rec mutants, carried out under normal aerobic growth conditions, consistently suggest that at least 10-30% of all replication forks originating at the bacterial origin of replication are halted by DNA damage and must undergo recombinational DNA repair. The actual frequency may be much higher. Recombinational DNA repair is both the most complex and the least understood of bacterial DNA repair processes. When replication forks encounter a DNA lesion or strand break, repair is mediated by an adaptable set of pathways encompassing most of the enzymes involved in DNA metabolism. There are five separate enzymatic processes involved in these repair events: (1) The replication fork assembled at OriC stalls and/or collapses when encountering DNA damage. (2) Recombination enzymes provide a complementary strand for a lesion isolated in a single-strand gap, or reconstruct a branched DNA at the site of a double-strand break. (3) The phi X174-type primosome (or repair primosome) functions in the origin-independent reassembly of the replication fork. (4) The XerCD site-specific recombination system resolves the dimeric chromosomes that are the inevitable by-product of frequent recombination associated with recombinational DNA repair. (5) DNA excision repair and other repair systems eliminate lesions left behind in double-stranded DNA. The RecA protein plays a central role in the recombination phase of the process. Among its many activities, RecA protein is a motor protein, coupling the hydrolysis of ATP to the movement of DNA branches.

The mutant RecA proteins, RecAR243Q and RecAK245N, exhibit defective DNA binding in homologous pairing

In homologous pairing, the RecA protein sequentially binds to single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) and double-stranded DNA (dsDNA), aligning the two DNA molecules within the helical nucleoprotein filament. To identify the DNA binding region, which stretches from the outside to the inside of the filament, we constructed two mutant RecA proteins, RecAR243Q and RecAK245N, with the amino acid substitutions of Arg243 to Gln and Lys245 to Asn, respectively. These amino acids are exposed to the solvent in the crystal structure of the RecA protein and are located in the central domain, which is believed to be the catalytic center of the homologous pairing activity. The mutations of Arg243 to Gln (RecAR243Q) and Lys245 to Asn (RecAK245N) impair the repair of UV-damaged DNA in vivo and cause defective homologous pairing of ssDNA and dsDNA in vitro. Although RecAR243Q is only slightly defective and RecAK245N is completely proficient in ssDNA binding to form the presynaptic filament, both mutant RecA proteins are defective in the formation of the three-component complex including ssDNA, dsDNA, and RecA protein. The ability to form dsDNA from complementary single strands is also defective in both RecAR243Q and RecAK245N. These results suggest that the region including Arg243 and Lys245 may be involved in the path of secondary DNA binding to the presynaptic filament.

Saturation mutagenesis of the E. coli RecA loop L2 homologous DNA pairing region reveals residues essential for recombination and recombinational repair

The disordered mobile loop L2 of the Escherichia coli RecA protein is known to play a central role in DNA binding and pairing. To investigate the local chemical environment in relation to function we performed saturation mutagenesis of the loop L2 region (amino acid positions 193-212) using a site-directed mutagenesis procedure, and determined the recombinational proficiency of the 380 mutants using genetic assays for homologous recombination and recombinational repair. Residues Asn193, Gln194, Arg196, Glu207, Thr209, Gly211, and Gly212 were identified as stringently required for recombinational events in bacterial cells. In addition, our findings suggest the involvement of loop L2 in the ATPase activity of RecA, and a role for residues Gln194, Arg196, Lys198 and Thr209 in the DNA-dependent hydrolysis of ATP. Finally, since 20 residue peptides that comprise this region can pair homologous DNAs by forming filamentous beta-structures, we propose how the information from the mutant analysis might facilitate the use of a simplified amino acid alphabet to design beta-structure forming L2 peptides with improved RecA-like activities.

Investigation of the secondary DNA-binding site of the bacterial recombinase RecA

The L2 loop is a DNA-binding site of RecA protein, a recombinase from Eschericha coli. Two DNA-binding sites have been functionally defined in this protein. To determine whether the L2 loop of RecA protein is part of the primary or secondary binding site, we have constructed proteins with site-specific mutations in the loop and investigated their biological, biochemical, and DNA binding properties. The mutation E207Q inhibits DNA repair and homologous recombination in vivo and prevents DNA strand exchange in vitro (Larminat, F., Cazaux, C., Germanier, M., and Defais, M. (1992) J. Bacteriol. 174, 6264-6269; Cazaux, C., Larminat, F., Villani, G., Johnson, N. P., Schnarr, M., and Defais, M. (1994) J. Biol. Chem. 269, 8246-8254). We have found that mutant protein RecAE207Q lacked one of the two single stranded DNA-binding sites of wild type RecA. The remaining site was functional, and biochemical activities of the mutant protein were the same as wild type RecA with ssDNA in the primary binding site. The second mutation, E207K, reduced but did not eliminate DNA repair, SOS induction, and homologous recombination in vivo. In the presence of ATP, mutant protein RecAE207K catalyzed DNA strand exchange in vitro at a slower rate than wild type protein, and ssDNA binding at site I was competitively inhibited. These results show that the L2 loop is or is part of the functional secondary DNA-binding site of RecA protein.

TrwD, a protein encoded by the IncW plasmid R388, displays an ATP hydrolase activity essential for bacterial conjugation

A 1.7-kilobase pair segment from the conjugative transfer region of plasmid R388 DNA was cloned and sequenced. It contained trwD, a gene essential for plasmid R388 conjugation, for expression of the conjugative W-pilus and for sensitivity to phage PRD1. The deduced amino acid sequence of TrwD showed homology to the PulE/VirB11 superfamily of potential ATPases involved in various types of transport processes. A fusion of trwD with the glutathione S-transferase (GST) was constructed, and the resulting fusion protein was purified from overproducing bacteria. Factor Xa hydrolysis of GST-TrwD and further purification rendered TrwD protein with more than 95% purity. Antibodies raised against TrwD localized it both in the soluble fraction and in the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. TrwD is probably a peripheral outer membrane protein because it could be solubilized by increasing salt concentration to 0.5 M NaCl in the lysis buffer. Both purified GST-TrwD and TrwD could hydrolize ATP. ATPase activity increased 2-fold in the presence of detergent-phospholipid mixed micelles. To study the importance of the nucleotide-binding site, Walker box A (GXXGXGK(T/S)), present in TrwD, the conserved lysine residue was replaced by glutamine. The mutant protein, expressed and purified under the same conditions as the wild type, did not exhibit ATPase activity. TrwD(K203Q) was not able to complement the mutation in trwD of the R388 mutant plasmid, suggesting the essentiality of the ATPase activity of the protein in the conjugative process. Furthermore, the dominant character of this mutation suggested that GST-TrwD(K432Q) was still able to interact either with itself or with other component(s) of the conjugative machinery.

Locations of functional domains in the RecA protein. Overlap of domains and regulation of activities

We review the locations of various functional domains of the RecA protein of Escherichia coli, including how they have been assigned, and discuss the potential regulatory roles of spatial overlap between different domains. RecA is a multifunctional and ubiquitous protein involved both in general genetic recombination and in DNA repair: it regulates the synthesis and activity of DNA repair enzymes (SOS induction) and catalyses homologous recombination and mutagenesis. For these activities RecA interacts with a nucleotide cofactor, single-stranded and double-stranded DNAs, the LexA repressor, UmuD protein, the UmuD'2C complex as well as with RecA itself in forming the catalytically active nucleofilament. Attempts to locate the respective interaction sites have been advanced in order to understand the various functions of RecA. An intriguing question is how these numerous functional sites are contained within this rather small protein (38 kDa). To assess more clearly the roles of the respective sites and to what extent the sites may be interacting with each other, we review and compare the results obtained from various biological, biochemical and physico-chemical approaches. From a three-dimensional model it is concluded that all sites are concentrated to one part of the protein. As a consequence there are significant overlaps between the sites and it is speculated that corresponding interactions may play important roles in regulating RecA activities.

Strandedness discrimination in peptide-polynucleotide complexes

Preferential binding to single- or double-stranded nucleic acids is important for the activity of many proteins that process RNA and DNA. We have investigated the mechanism of strandedness discrimination with peptides derived from the putative DNA-binding domain of the RecA protein, a bacterial recombinase that modulates its affinity for single-stranded DNA by means of ATP binding and hydrolysis. Contributions of electrostatic and non-electrostatic interactions to binding of these peptides with polynucleotides were evaluated by fluorescence spectroscopy as a function of salt concentration and peptide charge. Binding of these peptides to single- and double-stranded nucleic acids was dominated by non-electrostatic interactions. Small electrostatic contributions selectively enhanced peptide complexation with single-stranded nucleic acids. Similar results were observed in control experiments carried out with tripeptides containing charged and aromatic amino acid residues. It was possible to modify the strandedness preference of peptide-polynucleotide complexes by changing electrostatic contributions to the binding free energy. These observations suggest a mechanism whereby some proteins that interact with DNA or RNA might determine and regulate their relative affinity for single- and double-stranded nucleic acids.

Homologous DNA pairing promoted by a 20-amino acid peptide derived from RecA

The molecular structure of the Escherichia coli RecA protein in the absence of DNA revealed two disordered or mobile loops that were proposed to be DNA binding sites. A short peptide spanning one of these loops was shown to carry out the key reaction mediated by the whole RecA protein: pairing (targeting) of a single-stranded DNA to its homologous site on a duplex DNA. In the course of the reaction the peptide bound to both substrate DNAs, unstacked the single-stranded DNA, and assumed a beta structure. These events probably recapitulate the underlying molecular pathway or mechanism used by homologous recombination proteins.

Differential proximity probing of two DNA binding sites in the Escherichia coli recA protein using photo-cross-linking methods

The DNA strand-exchange reaction catalyzed by the Escherichia coli RecA protein occurs between the two DNA binding sites that are functionally distinct. Site I is the site to which a DNA molecule (normally single-stranded DNA) binds first; this first binding makes site II available for additional DNA-binding (normally double- stranded DNA). Photo-cross linking was employed to identify the amino acid residues located close to the bound DNA molecule(s). A ssDNA oligo containing multiple 5-iodouracil residues (IdU) was cross-linked to RecA by irradiation with a XeC1 pulse laser (308 nm), and the cross-linked peptides were purified and sequenced. To differentiate the two DNA binding sites, we used two protocols for making RecA-ssDNA complexes: (1) IdU-containing oligo was mixed with a stoichiometric excess of RecA, a condition which favors the binding of the oligo to site I, and (2) RecA was first allowed to bind to a nonphotoreactive oligo and then chased with the IdU-containing oligo, a condition which favors the binding of the IdU-oligo to site II. We observed that when RecA was in excess (site I probing), cross-linking occurred to Met-164 which is located in the disordered loop 1 of the RecA crystal structure [Story, R.M., Weber, I.T., & Steitz, T.A. (1992) Nature 355, 318-325]. When site II was probed, the majority of cross-linking occurred to Met-202 or Phe-203, located in loop 2. These results support the idea that, as predicted by Story and co-workers (1992), the disordered loops are involved in DNA binding. The results also suggest that the two sites are not only functionally but also physically distinct.

The central aromatic residue in loop L2 of RecA interacts with DNA. Quenching of the fluorescence of a tryptophan reporter inserted in L2 upon binding to DNA

To determine the role of the central aromatic residue in one of the DNA binding domains in Escherichia coli RecA protein, we have constructed a protein in which a tryptophan fluorescence reporter is inserted in the place of phenylalanine residue 203 in loop L2, a putative DNA binding site, and measured its fluorescence. The modified protein is active both in vivo and in vitro. The binding of nucleotide cofactor (ATP or its analog adenosine 5'-O-3-thiotriphosphate) does not modify the fluorescence. By contrast, the binding of DNA, both in the absence and presence of cofactor, strongly decreases the fluorescence in intensity (40-65%) and shifts the emission peak from 344 to 337 nm. The change occurs both with single- and double-stranded DNA and also upon the binding of a second single-stranded DNA. The results indicate that the residue 203 is in fact close to the first and second DNA binding sites. However, the quenching is not total and depends only slightly on the nature of DNA bases, thus suggesting an indirect interaction with DNA bases.

Photocross-links between single-stranded DNA and Escherichia coli RecA protein map to loops L1 (amino acid residues 157-164) and L2 (amino acid residues 195-209)

To function as a repair and recombination protein, RecA has to be assembled as an active filament on single-stranded DNA in the presence of ATP or its analogs. We have identified amino acids in the primary DNA binding site of RecA that interact with single-stranded DNA by photocross-linking. A nucleoprotein complex consisting of RecA protein bound to a monosubstituted oligonucleotide bearing a 5-iododeoxyuracil cross-linking moiety was irradiated with long wavelength ultraviolet radiation to effect cross-linking with RecA protein. Subsequent trypsin digestion, followed by purification and peptide sequencing, revealed the cross-linking of two independent peptides, amino acid residues 153-169 and 199-216. Met164 from loop L1 and Phe203 from loop L2 were determined to be the exact points of cross-linking. Thus, our data confirm and extend predictions about the DNA binding domain of RecA protein based on the molecular structure of RecA (Story, R. M., Weber, I. T., and Steitz, T. A. (1992) Nature 355, 318-325).

The identification of the single-stranded DNA-binding domain of the Escherichia coli RecA protein

To identify the ssDNA-binding domain of Escherichia coli RecA protein, we examined the ssDNA-binding capabilities of synthetic peptides, the sequences of which were derived from the C- and N-termini and from sequences within loops L1 and L2 of the RecA molecule identified from the crystal structure. Synthetic peptides derived from amino acid residues 185-219 of several bacterial RecA proteins, which include loop L2 of RecA, bound to ssDNA in filter-binding assays, whereas three separate synthetic peptides corresponding to single point mutants of E. coli RecA in this region did not. The binding of RecA to ssDNA examined using a gel-shift assay was inhibited by a synthetic peptide derived from this ssDNA-binding region, but not by synthetic peptides derived from amino acid residues 301-329 of the C-terminus or from N-terminal residues 6-39. A peptide corresponding to amino acid positions 152-169 of the RecA molecule and spanning loop L1 and its flanking regions did not bind ssDNA at peptide concentrations up to 250 microM. We have also defined a synthetic 20-amino-acid peptide that comprises amino acid residues 193-212 and includes loop L2 of RecA as the minimum unit that can bind to ssDNA from this region of RecA. Finally, two maltose-binding protein-RecA fusion proteins were made, one containing amino acid residues 185-224 of RecA and the other the last 51 C-terminal residues of RecA (amino acid residues 303-353). In contrast to the C-terminus-derived fusion protein, the fusion protein containing the putative DNA-binding site demonstrated significant binding to single-stranded oligonucleotides in both filter-binding and gel-shift assays. These findings suggest that a portion of the region extending from amino acid residues 193-212 is either part of or the whole ssDNA-binding domain of the RecA protein.