Interaction of rho factor with bacteriophage lambda cro gene transcripts

Understanding transcription across scales: From base pairs to chromosomes

The influence of genome organization on transcription is central to our understanding of cell type specification. Higher-order genome organization is established through short- and long-range DNA interactions. Coordination of these interactions, from single atoms to entire chromosomes, plays a fundamental role in transcriptional control of gene expression. Loss of this coupling can result in disease. Analysis of transcriptional regulation typically involves disparate experimental approaches, from structural studies that define angstrom-level interactions to cell-biological and genomic approaches that assess mesoscale relationships. Thus, to fully understand the mechanisms that regulate gene expression, it is critical to integrate the findings gained across these distinct size scales. In this review, I illustrate fundamental ways in which cells regulate transcription in the context of genome organization.

Mechanisms of Bacterial Transcription Termination: All Good Things Must End

Transcript termination is essential for accurate gene expression and the removal of RNA polymerase (RNAP) at the ends of transcription units. In bacteria, two mechanisms are responsible for proper transcript termination: intrinsic termination and Rho-dependent termination. Intrinsic termination is mediated by signals directly encoded within the DNA template and nascent RNA, whereas Rho-dependent termination relies upon the adenosine triphosphate-dependent RNA translocase Rho, which binds nascent RNA and dissociates the elongation complex. Although significant progress has been made in understanding these pathways, fundamental details remain undetermined. Among those that remain unresolved are the existence of an inactivated intermediate in the intrinsic termination pathway, the role of Rho-RNAP interactions in Rho-dependent termination, and the mechanisms by which accessory factors and nucleoid-associated proteins affect termination. We describe current knowledge, discuss key outstanding questions, and highlight the importance of defining the structural rearrangements of RNAP that are involved in the two mechanisms of transcript termination.

In vivo dynamics of intracistronic transcriptional polarity

Transcriptional polarity occurs in Escherichia coli when cryptic Rho-dependent transcription terminators become activated as a consequence of reduced translation. Increased spacing between RNA polymerase and the leading ribosome allows the transcription termination factor Rho to bind to mRNA, migrate to the RNA polymerase, and induce termination. Transcriptional polarity results in decreased synthesis of inefficiently translated mRNAs and, therefore, in decreased expression not only of downstream genes in the same operon (intercistronic polarity) but also of the cistron in which termination occurs (intracistronic polarity). To quantitatively measure the effect of different levels of translation on intracistronic transcription termination, the polarity-prone lacZ reporter gene was fused to a range of mutated ribosome binding sites, repressed to different degrees by local RNA structure. The results show that polarity gradually increases with decreasing frequency of translational initiation, as expected. Closer analysis, with the help of a newly developed kinetic model, reveals that efficient intracistronic termination requires very low translational initiation frequencies. This finding is unexpected because Rho is a relatively small protein that binds rapidly to its RNA target, but it appears to be true also for other examples of transcriptional polarity reported in the literature. The conclusion must be that polarity is more complex than just an increased exposure of the Rho binding site as the spacing between the polymerase and the leading ribosome becomes larger. Biological consequences and possible mechanisms are discussed.

Transcription termination factor rho can displace streptavidin from biotinylated RNA

In Escherichia coli, binding of the hexameric Rho protein to naked C-rich Rut (Rho utilization) regions of nascent RNA transcripts initiates Rho-dependent termination of transcription. Although the ring-shaped Rho factor exhibits in vitro RNA-dependent ATPase and directional RNA-DNA helicase activities, the actual molecular mechanisms used by Rho to disrupt the intricate network of interactions that cement the ternary transcription complex remain elusive. Here, we show that Rho is a molecular motor that can apply significant disruptive forces on heterologous nucleoprotein assemblies such as streptavidin bound to biotinylated RNA molecules. ATP-dependent disruption of the biotin-streptavidin interaction demonstrates that Rho is not mechanistically limited to the melting of nucleic acid base pairs within molecular complexes and confirms that specific interactions with the roadblock target are not required for Rho to operate properly. We also show that Rho-induced streptavidin displacement depends significantly on the identity of the biotinylated transcript as well as on the position, nature, and length of the biotin link to the RNA chain. Altogether, our data are consistent with a "snow plough" type of mechanism of action whereby an early rearrangement of the Rho-substrate complex (activation) is rate-limiting, physical force (pulling) is exerted on the RNA chain by residues of the central Rho channel, and removal of structural obstacles from the RNA track stems from their nonspecific steric exclusion from the hexamer central hole. In this context, a simple model for the regulation of Rho-dependent termination based on the modulation of disruptive dynamic loading by secondary factors is proposed.

Influence of substrate composition on the helicase activity of transcription termination factor Rho: reduced processivity of Rho hexamers during unwinding of RNA-DNA hybrid regions

Transcription termination factor Rho forms ring-shaped hexameric structures that load onto segments of the nascent RNA transcript that are C-rich and mostly single-stranded. This interaction converts Rho hexamers into active molecular motors that use the energy resulting from their ATP hydrolase activity to move towards the transcript 3'-end. Upon translocation along the RNA chain, Rho can displace physical roadblocks, such as those formed by RNA-DNA helices, a feature that is likely central to the transcription termination mechanism. To study this "translocase" (helicase) activity, we have designed a collection of Rho substrate chimeras containing an RNA-DNA helix located at various positions with respect to a short (47 nucleotides) artificial loading site. We show that these synthetic constructs represent interesting model substrates able to engage in a productive interaction with Rho and to direct NTP-dependent [5'-->3']-translocation of the hexamers. Using both single and multiple-cycle experimental set-ups, we have also found that Rho helicase activity is strongly dependent on the substrate composition and reaction conditions. For this reason, the rate-limiting step of the helicase reaction could not be identified unambiguously. Yet, the linear dependence of the reaction rate on the hybrid length suggests that helicase action on the RNA-DNA region could be controlled by a unique slow step such as Rho activation, conformational rearrangement, or DNA release. Moreover, removal of the DNA strand occurred at a significant cost for the Rho enzyme, inducing, on average, dissociation from the substrate for every 60-80 base-pairs of hybrid unwound. These results are discussed in relation to the known requirements for Rho substrates, general features of hexameric helicases, and current models for Rho-dependent transcription termination.

Rho-dependent termination and ATPases in transcript termination

Transcription factor Rho is a ring-shaped, homohexameric protein that causes transcript termination through actions on nascent RNAs that are coupled to ATP hydrolysis. The Rho polypeptide has a distinct RNA-binding domain (RNA-BD) of known structure as well as an ATP-binding domain (ATP-BD) for which a structure has been proposed based on homology modeling. A model is proposed in which Rho first makes an interaction with a nascent RNA on a C-rich, primarily single-stranded rut region of the transcript as that region emerges from the exit site of RNA polymerase. A subsequent step involves a temporary release of one subunit of the hexamer to allow the 3' segment of the nascent transcript to enter the central channel of the Rho ring. Actions of the Rho structure in the channel on the 3' segment that are coupled to ATP hydrolysis pull the RNA from its contacts with the template and RNA polymerase, thus causing termination of its synthesis.

Transcription termination and anti-termination in E. coli

Transcription termination in Escherichia coli is controlled by many factors. The sequence of the DNA template, the structure of the transcript, and the actions of auxiliary proteins all play a role in determining the efficiency of the process. Termination is regulated and can be enhanced or suppressed by host and phage proteins. This complex reaction is rapidly yielding to biochemical and structural analysis of the interacting factors. Below we review and attempt to unify into basic principles the remarkable recent progress in understanding transcription termination and anti-termination.

ATP and other nucleotides stabilize the Rho-mRNA complex

Transcription termination factor Rho from Escherichia coli is a protein that consists of a single 47 kDa protomeric unit that can form a hexameric structure. To determine whether active hexamers can form on an RNA by assembly of subunits, we measured the dependence of complex formation on the concentration of Rho protein in the presence and absence of various nucleotides and related the binding properties to association states determined from sedimentation properties. The results show that the presence of adenine nucleotides converts RNA binding from a multimeric process to a largely monomeric process and that the change correlates with the stabilization of multimers of Rho by the nucleotides. The experimental evidence also indicates that the hexameric form of Rho is stabilized slightly by binding to a transcript but that the protein on RNA is in equilibrium with nonhexameric forms. These results suggest that a Rho hexamer can form on a transcript by addition of subunits to a partial assembly, which means that the complex can consist of six subunits surrounding an RNA transcript as proposed in recent models for Rho action.

rut Sites in the nascent transcript mediate Rho-dependent transcription termination in vivo

The in vitro function of the coliphage lambda tR1 Rho-dependent terminator is governed primarily by a tripartite upstream sequence element designated rut. To determine the contribution of the different components of the rut site to terminator function in the normal context of coupled translation of the nascent cro message, tR1 variants lacking different rut site sequences were tested for terminator function in vivo. Intact rutA and rutB sequences were both necessary for efficient termination. However, deletion of the upstream rutA was far more detrimental than deletion of rutB. The intervening boxB, which encodes a short RNA stem and loop, could be deleted without reducing termination or detectably altering Rho's interaction with the corresponding cro transcript. The relative importance of these sequence elements was also the same in a minimal in vitro termination assay system. Rut sequences are therefore essential for terminator function in vivo and rutA contributes substantially more to tR1 function than does rutB. The relative contribution of these elements can be ascribed to differences in Rho's binding affinity for the encoded transcripts. If other cellular factors also bind the rut element RNA, they do not alter the relative contribution of its two regions to Rho-dependent transcription termination in vivo.

Effects of reaction conditions on RNA secondary structure and on the helicase activity of Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho

The ATPase and helicase activities of the Escherichia coli transcription termination protein rho have been studied under a variety of reaction conditions that alter its transcription termination activity. These conditions include KCl, KOAc, or KGlu concentrations from 50 to 150 mM and Mg(OAc)2 concentrations from 1 to 5 mM (in the presence of 1 mM ATP). In higher KCl or higher Mg(OAc)2 concentrations we found that the translocation of rho hexamers along RNA was slower and less processive than the same process measured at 50 mM monovalent salt concentrations and 1 mM Mg(OAc)2. The ATPase activity of rho was also decreased under reaction conditions that slowed translocation. RNA melting experiments showed that the decreased ATPase activity of rho and the slower helicase activity at increased KCl or Mg(OAc)2 concentrations are accompanied by a concomitant increase in the secondary structure of the RNA portion of the helicase substate. In contrast, the ATPase activity of rho in the presence of poly(rC), a synthetic RNA that does not form salt-concentration-dependent secondary structure, was shown to be the same in each of the three monovalent salts. Thus, the salts do not directly affect the structure or conformation of the rho protein or the binding of rho to single-stranded RNA. However, the translocation of rho along RNA was more processive in 150 mM KOAc or KGlu than in 150 mM KCl, while the RNA secondary structure was the same in all three monovalent salts. Therefore, the monovalent salt present in the reaction may directly affect rho-RNA interactions when the RNA substrate can form secondary structure. Helicase experiments with an RNA molecule that does not contain a rho loading-site showed that rho translocates less processively along this potential helicase substrate. These results suggest that the helicase activity of rho may be significantly regulated by RNA secondary structure. In addition, one of the mechanisms to concentrate the activity of rho on transcripts containing unstructured rho loading sites may be that rho translocation along such molecules is more processive than it is along more structured RNA molecules in the cell.

A consensus motif common to all Rho-dependent prokaryotic transcription terminators

We have characterized at the molecular level several polar mutations in four different cistrons of the his operon of S. typhimurium. An analysis of the his-specific transcripts produced in vivo in the mutant strains, together with in vitro transcription assays, led to the identification of several cryptic Rho-dependent transcription termination elements within the his operon that are activated by the uncoupling of transcription and translation. Common features of these elements were sought and found with a computer program. We have identified a consensus motif, consisting of a cytosine-rich and guanosine-poor region, that is located upstream of the heterogeneous 3' endpoints of the prematurely terminated in vivo transcripts and that is present in all the Rho-dependent transcription terminators described thus far.

tRNA(Trp) translation of leader peptide codon 12 and other factors that regulate expression of the tryptophanase operon

Tryptophanase (tna) operon expression in Escherichia coli is induced by tryptophan. This response is mediated by features of a 319-base-pair leader region preceding the major structural genes of the operon. Translation of the coding region (tnaC) for a 24-amino-acid leader peptide is essential for induction. We have used site-directed mutagenesis to investigate the role of the single Trp codon, at position 12 in tnaC, in regulation of the operon. Codon 12 was changed to either a UAG or UGA stop codon or to a CGG arginine codon. Induction by tryptophan was eliminated by any of these changes. Studies with suppressor tRNAs indicated that tRNA(Trp) translation of codon 12 in tnaC is essential for induction of the operon. Reduction of tna expression by a miaA mutation supports a role for translation by tRNA(Trp) in regulation of the operon. Frameshift mutations and suppression that allows translation of tnaC to proceed beyond the normal stop codon result in constitutive tna operon expression. Deletion of a potential site for Rho factor utilization just beyond tnaC also results in partial constitutive expression. These studies suggest possible models for tryptophan induction of tna operon expression involving tRNA(Trp)-mediated frame shifting or readthrough at the tnaC stop codon.

Structural and functional properties of the segments of lambda cro mRNA that interact with transcription termination factor Rho

Termination of transcription at tR1, the Rho-dependent terminator between genes cro and cII of bacteriophage lambda, is dependent upon the structure of segments near the 3' end of the nascent cro gene transcript and on contacts between Rho protein and a 3' proximal segment called rut. The characteristics of the structure of cro RNA in the region from residue 220 to residue 355 in free, isolated RNA and in the presence of Rho or NusA proteins were analyzed by measuring relative rates of reactivity of individual nucleotides with chemicals and enzymes of defined specificities. The results indicate that the rut segments are single-stranded and become blocked to the action of the various probes in the presence of Rho factor. They also show that this region contains two stem-loop structures; one involves the boxB sequence of nutR, the other precedes the tR1 subsite II end points. The results provide direct evidence for a primary binding contact between Rho protein and the rut segment of cro RNA and demonstrate that this binding contact remains stable when the cro RNA is serving as a cofactor for ATP hydrolysis, an observation that is consistent with a mechanism in which Rho maintains contact with the rut region while it makes additional interactions with RNA that are coupled to ATP hydrolysis.

Thermodynamic and enzymological characterization of the interaction between transcription termination factor rho and lambda cro mRNA

Termination of transcription at tR1, the rho-dependent terminator between genes cro and cII of bacteriophage lambda, is mediated by interactions between rho protein and an RNA sequence element called rut. We show, using a filter retention assay technique, that rho protein binds with about 10-fold lower affinity to variants of cro RNA lacking both parts of rut or to normal cro RNA having one or the other part of rut bound to a complementary DNA oligonucleotide than it binds to unmodified cro RNA. These same variant and modified forms are nearly devoid of the strong rho ATPase cofactor activity of cro RNA. Estimates of binding energies of the rho-cro RNA interaction under different conditions reveal that termination function correlates with about 12.6 kcal of binding energy, of which two-thirds is due to nonelectrostatic interactions. The rut segment is shown to contribute about 1 kcal, nearly all to nonelectrostatic interactions. KCl is found to be more effective than potassium glutamate as a competitive counterion, and a decrease in 1.4 kcal of binding energy due to counterion competition correlates with a loss of termination and ATPase activities. In sum, the results indicate that the rut sequence contributes substantially to the overall binding affinity, that ionic interactions are also important, and that mere binding of rho to RNA is not sufficient for rho ATPase activation.

In vivo analysis of the mechanisms responsible for strong transcriptional polarity in a "sense" mutant within an intercistronic region

We have studied a very unusual strong polar mutant in the intercistronic barrier between the second (hisD) and third (hisC) cistrons of the histidine operon of Salmonella typhimurium to obtain further insights into the molecular mechanisms leading to transcription termination within cistrons. We have performed a detailed transcriptional analysis in vivo and have found that the his mRNA in this polar mutant is reduced in size as a result of premature termination of transcription at a cryptic Rho-dependent site within the proximal region of the hisC cistron.

Interactions of Escherichia coli transcription termination factor rho with RNA. I. Binding stoichiometries and free energies

In this paper we examine the binding of Escherichia coli transcription termination factor rho to single-stranded RNA. Random polyribonucleotide copolymers containing low ratios of the fluorescent base 1,N6-ethenoadenosine have been synthesized using polynucleotide phosphorylase. Binding of rho to these polynucleotides elicits a significant increase in fluorescence, thus allowing either the direct monitoring of the titration of these polynucleotides with rho or measurement of the competitive displacement of the protein from these probes with other nucleic acids, even in the presence of biologically significant concentrations of ATP. By these techniques, it is shown that the binding site size (n) of rho protein to polynucleotides is 13(+/- 1) nucleotide residues per rho monomer (or 78(+/- 6) nucleotide residues per rho hexamer). Binding constants (K) and co-operativity parameters (omega) for the binding of rho to these polynucleotides have been measured as a function of nucleotide composition and of salt concentration. The results show that the affinity of rho for cytosine residues is quite strong and salt concentration independent, whilst binding to uridine residues is somewhat weaker and very salt concentration dependent. Poly(rC) and poly(dC) bind to rho competitively and with equal affinity and site size, although poly(rC) is the strongest cofactor for activating rho-dependent ATPase and poly(dC) has no ATPase cofactor activity at all. It is also shown that ATP (or ADP or ATP-gamma-S) binding does not change the binding site size of rho on RNA nor decrease its affinity for RNA binding. Circular dichroism measurements of rho binding to phage R17 RNA suggest that the affinity (K omega) of rho for RNA may be increased by ATP. The possible significance of these results for models of rho-dependent transcription termination is discussed in the companion paper.

nusA protein of Escherichia coli is an efficient transcription termination factor for certain terminator sites

We have studied the factors that affect transcription termination in vitro at the tR2 terminator of bacteriophage lambda and at the T1 terminator of the Escherichia coli rrnB operon. Termination efficiency at both of these sites is enhanced by the E. coli nusA protein, giving final efficiencies of termination in vitro comparable to those estimated in vivo. Transcripts terminated in the presence of nusA protein are all released from the RNA polymerase complex, indicating that a complete termination reaction is involved, rather than simply induction of a long pause at the terminator. The termination factor activity of the nusA protein does not depend on the presence of rho protein and is not detectably enhanced by that factor. Thus, the nusA protein appears to play a pleiotropic role in E. coli transcription, serving as an antitermination factor, RNA polymerase subunit and true termination factor for some terminator sites.

Rho-dependent transcription termination in the tryptophanase operon leader region of Escherichia coli K-12

Recent studies have suggested that expression of the tryptophanase (tna) operon of Escherichia coli is subject to transcription termination-antitermination control (V. Stewart and C. Yanofsky, J. Bacteriol. 164:731-740, 1985). In vivo studies have indicated that the transcribed leader region, tnaL, contains a site or sites of rho-dependent transcription termination (rho is the polypeptide product of the gene rho). We now report direct in vitro evidence that tnaL contains rho-dependent termination sites. In vivo termination appeared to occur at the rho-dependent termination sites identified in vitro. Transcription pausing analyses correlated sites of pausing in tnaL with sites of rho-dependent termination.