Acetyl-CoA pathway of autotrophic growth. Identification of the methyl-binding site of the CO dehydrogenase

Pulse-chase studies of the synthesis of acetyl-CoA by carbon monoxide dehydrogenase/acetyl-CoA synthase: evidence for a random mechanism of methyl and carbonyl addition

Carbon monoxide dehydrogenase/acetyl-CoA synthase catalyzes acetyl-CoA synthesis from CO, CoA, and a methylated corrinoid iron-sulfur protein, which acts as a methyl donor. This reaction is the last step in the Wood-Ljungdahl pathway of anaerobic carbon fixation. The binding sequence for the three substrates has been debated for over a decade. Different binding orders imply different mechanisms (i.e. paramagnetic versus diamagnetic mechanisms). Ambiguity arises because CO and CoA can each undergo isotopic exchange with acetyl-CoA, suggesting that either of these two substrates could be the last to bind to the acetyl-CoA synthase active site. Furthermore, carbonylation, CoA binding, and methyl transfer can all occur in the absence of the other two substrates. Here, we report pulse-chase studies, which unambiguously establish the order in which the three substrates bind. Although a CoA pulse is substantially diluted by excess CoA in the chase, isotope recovery of a pulse of labeled CO or methyl group is unaffected by the presence of excess unlabeled CO or methyl group in the chase. These results demonstrate that CoA is the last substrate to bind and that CO and the methyl group bind randomly as the first substrate in acetyl-CoA synthesis. Up to 100% of the methyl groups and CoA and up to 60-70% of the CO employed in the pulse phase can be trapped in the product acetyl-CoA.

Kinetics of CO insertion and acetyl group transfer steps, and a model of the acetyl-CoA synthase catalytic mechanism

Acetyl-CoA synthase/carbon monoxide dehydrogenase is a Ni-Fe-S-containing enzyme that catalyzes the synthesis of acetyl-CoA from CO, CoA, and a methyl group. The methyl group is transferred onto the enzyme from a corrinoid-iron-sulfur protein (CoFeSP). The kinetics of two steps within the catalytic mechanism were studied using the stopped-flow method, including the insertion of CO into a putative Ni(2+)-CH(3) bond and the transfer of the resulting acetyl group to CoA. Neither step had been studied previously. Reactions were monitored indirectly, starting with the methylated intermediate form of the enzyme. Resulting traces were analyzed by constructing a simple kinetic model describing the catalytic mechanism under reducing conditions. Besides methyl group transfer, CO insertion, and acetyl group transfer, fitting to experimental traces required the inclusion of an inhibitory step in which CO reversibly bound to the form of the enzyme obtained immediately after product release. Global simulation of the reported datasets afforded a consistent set of kinetic parameters. The equilibrium constant for the overall synthesis of acetyl-CoA was estimated and compared to the product of the individual equilibrium constants. Simulations obtained with the model duplicated the essential behavior of the enzyme, in terms of the variation of activity with [CO], and the time-dependent decay of the NiFeC EPR signal upon reaction with CoFeSP. Under standard assay conditions, the model suggests that the vast majority of active enzyme molecules in a population should be in the methylated form, suggesting that the subsequent catalytic step, namely CO insertion, is rate limiting. This conclusion is further supported by a sensitivity analysis showing that the rate is most sensitively affected by a change in the rate coefficient associated with the CO insertion step.

Mössbauer and EPR study of recombinant acetyl-CoA synthase from Moorella thermoacetica

Mössbauer and EPR spectroscopies were used to study the electronic structure of the A-cluster from recombinant acetyl-CoA synthase (the alpha subunit of the alpha2beta2 acetyl-CoA synthase/CO dehydrogenase). Once activated with Ni, these subunits have properties mimicking those associated with the alpha2beta2 tetramer, including structural heterogeneities. The Fe4S4 portion of the A-cluster in oxidized, methylated, and acetylated states was in the 2+ core oxidation state. Upon reduction with dithionite or Ti3+ citrate, samples of Ni-activated alpha developed the ability to accept a methyl group. Corresponding Mössbauer spectra exhibited two populations of A-clusters; roughly, 70% contained [Fe4S4]1+ cubanes, while approximately 30% contained [Fe4S4]2+ cubanes, suggesting an extremely low [Fe4S4](1+/2+) reduction potential for the 30% portion (perhaps <-800 mV vs NHE). The same population ratio was observed when Ni-free unactivated alpha was used. The 70% fraction exhibited paramagnetic hyperfine structure in the absence of an applied magnetic field, excluding the possibility that it represents an [Fe4S4]1+ cluster coupled to a (proximal) Ni(p)1+. EPR spectra of dithionite-reduced, Ni-activated alpha exhibited features at g = 5.8 and g(ave) approximately 1.93, consistent with a physical mixture of {S = 3/2; S = 1/2} spin-states for A-clusters containing [Fe4S4]1+ clusters. Incubation of Ni-activated alpha with dithionite and CO converted 25% of alpha subunits into the S = 1/2 A(red)-CO state. Previous correlation of this state to functional A-clusters suggests that only the 30% fraction not reduced by dithionite or Ti3+ citrate represents functional A-clusters. Comparison of spin states in oxidized and methylated states suggests that two electrons are required for reductive activation, starting from the oxidized state containing Ni(p)2+. Refitting published activity-vs-potential data supports an n = 2 reductive activation. Enzyme starting in the methylated state exhibited catalytic activity in the absence of an external reductant, suggesting that the two electrons used in reductive activation are retained by the enzyme after each catalytic cycle and that the enzyme does not have to pass through the A(red)-CO state during catalysis. Taken together, our results suggest that a Ni(p)0 state may form upon reductive activation and reform after each catalytic cycle.

Acetyl-coenzyme A synthase: the case for a Nip0-based mechanism of catalysis

Acetyl-CoA synthase (also known as carbon monoxide dehydrogenase) is a bifunctional Ni-Fe-S-containing enzyme that catalyzes the reversible reduction of CO(2) to CO and the synthesis of acetyl-coenzyme A from CO, CoA, and a methyl group donated by a corrinoid iron-sulfur protein. The active site for the latter reaction, called the A-cluster, consists of an Fe(4)S(4) cubane bridged to the proximal Ni site (Ni(p)), which is bridged in turn to the so-called distal Ni site. In this review, evidence is presented that Ni(p) achieves a zero-valent state at low potentials and during catalysis. Ni(p) appears to be the metal to which CO and methyl groups bind and then react to form an acetyl-Ni(p) intermediate. Methyl group binding requires reductive activation, where two electrons reduce some site on the A-cluster. The coordination environment of the distal Ni suggests that it could not be stabilized in redox states lower than 2+. The rate at which the [Fe(4)S(4)](2+) cubane is reduced is far slower than that at which reductive activation occurs, suggesting that the cubane is not the site of reduction. An intriguing possibility is that Ni(p)(2+) might be reduced to the zero-valent state. Reinforcing this idea are Ni-organometallic complexes in which the Ni exhibits analogous reactivity properties when reduced to the zero-valent state. A zero-valent Ni stabilized exclusively with biological ligands would be remarkable and unprecedented in biology.

Autocatalytic activation of acetyl-CoA synthase

Acetyl-CoA synthase (ACS identical with ACS/CODH identical with CODH/ACS) from Moorella thermoacetica catalyzes the synthesis of acetyl-CoA from CO, CoA, and a methyl group of a corrinoid-iron-sulfur protein (CoFeSP). A time lag prior to the onset of acetyl-CoA production, varying from 4 to 20 min, was observed in assay solutions lacking the low-potential electron-transfer agent methyl viologen (MV). No lag was observed when MV was included in the assay. The length of the lag depended on the concentrations of CO and ACS, with shorter lags found for higher [ACS] and sub-saturating [CO]. Lag length also depended on CoFeSP. Rate profiles of acetyl-CoA synthesis, including the lag phase, were numerically simulated assuming an autocatalytic mechanism. A similar reaction profile was monitored by UV-vis spectrophotometry, allowing the redox status of the CoFeSP to be evaluated during this process. At early stages in the lag phase, Co(2+)FeSP reduced to Co(+)FeSP, and this was rapidly methylated to afford CH(3)-Co(3+)FeSP. During steady-state synthesis of acetyl-CoA, CoFeSP was predominately in the CH(3)-Co(3+)FeSP state. As the synthesis rate declined and eventually ceased, the Co(+)FeSP state predominated. Three activation reductive reactions may be involved, including reduction of the A- and C-clusters within ACS and the reduction of the cobamide of CoFeSP. The B-, C-, and D-clusters in the beta subunit appear to be electronically isolated from the A-cluster in the connected alpha subunit, consistent with the ~70 A distance separating these clusters, suggesting the need for an in vivo reductant that activates ACS and/or CoFeSP.

Stopped-Flow Kinetics of Methyl Group Transfer between the Corrinoid-Iron-Sulfur Protein and Acetyl-Coenzyme A Synthase from Clostridium thermoaceticum

Kinetics of methyl group transfer between the Ni-Fe-S-containing acetyl-CoA synthase (ACS) and the corrinoid protein (CoFeSP) from Clostridium thermoaceticum were investigated using the stopped-flow method at 390 nm. Rates of the reaction CH(3)-Co(3+)FeSP + ACS(red) <==> Co(1+)FeSP + CH(3)-ACS(ox) in both forward and reverse directions were determined using various protein and reductant concentrations. Ti(3+)citrate, dithionite, and CO were used to reductively activate ACS (forming ACS(red)). The simplest mechanism that adequately fit the data involved formation of a [CH(3)-Co(3+)FeSP]:[ACS(red)] complex, methyl group transfer (forming [Co(1+)FeSP]:[CH(3)-ACS(ox)]), product dissociation (forming Co(1+)FeSP + CH(3)-ACS(ox)), and CO binding yielding a nonproductive enzyme state (ACS(red) + CO <==> ACS(red)-CO). Best-fit rate constants were obtained. CO inhibited methyl group transfer by binding ACS(red) in accordance with K(D) = 180 +/- 90 microM. Fits were unimproved when >1 CO was assumed to bind. Ti(3+)citrate and dithionite inhibited the reverse methyl group transfer reaction, probably by reducing the D-site of CH(3)-ACS(ox). This redox site is oxidized by 2e(-) when the methyl cation is transferred from CH(3)-Co(3+)FeSP to ACS(red), and is reduced during the reverse reaction. Best-fit K(D) values for pre- and post-methyl-transfer complexes were 0.12 +/- 0.06 and 0.3 +/- 0.2 microM, respectively. Intracomplex methyl group transfer was reversible with K(eq) = 2.3 +/- 0.9 (k(f)/k(r) = 6.9 s(-1)/3.0 s(-1)). The nucleophilicity of the [Ni(2+)D(red)] unit appears comparable to that of Co(1+) cobalamins. Reduction of the D-site may cause the Ni(2+) of the A-cluster to behave like the Ni of an organometallic Ni(0) complex.

A methylnickel intermediate in a bimetallic mechanism of acetyl-coenzyme A synthesis by anaerobic bacteria

Resonance Raman (RR) spectroscopy was used to identify a methylnickel adduct (upsilon Ni-C = 422 wave numbers) of carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (CODH) from Clostridium thermoaceticum. Formed at a nickel/iron-sulfur cluster on CODH called center A, the methylnickel species is the precursor of the methyl group of acetyl-coenzyme A in an anaerobic pathway of carbon monoxide or carbon dioxide fixation. Rapid kinetic and RR studies demonstrated that methylation of nickel occurs by heterolysis of the methyl-cobalt bond (upsilon Co-C = 429 wave numbers) of a methylated corrinoid/iron-sulfur protein. In combination with the earlier finding of an iron-carbonyl adduct at center A, detection of the methylnickel intermediate establishes a bimetallic mechanism for acetyl-coenzyme A synthesis.

Low spin quantitation of NiFeC EPR signal from carbon monoxide dehydrogenase is not due to damage incurred during protein purification

Evidence is presented that the O2-sensitive, nickel- and iron-containing enzyme carbon monoxide dehydrogenase from Clostridium thermoaceticum was purified without significantly inactivating either its CO oxidation or CO/acetyl-CoA exchange activities. All CO oxidation activity from the crude extract was recovered in the purified enzyme (and side fractions). The exchange activity could not be quantified similarly, because the crude extract and early purification step fractions exhibited little or no exchange activity. Later purification fractions exhibited much more exchange activity, suggesting that an inhibitor was present in the impure fractions. The NiFeC EPR signal intensity was used as an indicator of the enzyme's capacity to catalyze exchange. This signal was extremely sensitive to oxygen; exposure to as little as 0.5 equiv/mol enzyme dimer resulted in substantial loss of intensity. The NiFeC intensities at each step in the purification were virtually invariant, indicating that the enzyme had not been exposed to oxygen and had not been inactivated towards catalyzing exchange. The ability to purify carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (CODH) without inactivating nearly any of the molecules suggests that it is quite stable under anaerobic conditions. The purified enzyme, which could not have lost functional metal ions during purification, contained 1.9 Ni and 11.3 Fe, similar to previous reports. The NiFeC EPR signal intensity from each purification fraction (0.2 spins/mol enzyme dimer) was as low as from previous preparations, indicating that its low spin quantitation is not the result of damage incurred during purification. If the low intensity arises from heterogeneity as proposed earlier, the heterogeneity must originate prior to purification.

EPR characterization of a high-spin system in carbon monoxide dehydrogenase from Methanothrix soehngenii

Carbon monoxide dehydrogenase and methyl-coenzyme M reductase were purified from 61Ni-enriched and natural-abundance nickel-grown cells of the methanogenic archae Methanothrix soehngenii. The nickel-EPR signal from cofactor F-430 in methyl-CoM reductase was of substoichiometric intensity and exhibited near-axial symmetry with g = 2.153, 2.221 and resolved porphinoid nitrogen superhyperfine splittings of approximately 1 mT. In the spectrum from 61Ni-enriched enzyme a well-resolved parallel I = 3/2 nickel hyperfine splitting was observed, A parallel = 4.4 mT. From a computer simulation of this spectrum the final enrichment in 61Ni was estimated to be 69%, while the original enrichment of the nickel metal was 87%. Carbon monoxide dehydrogenase isolated from the same batch exhibited four different EPR spectra. However, in none of these signals could any splitting or broadening from 61Ni be detected. Also, the characteristic g = 2.08 EPR signal found in some other carbon monoxide dehydrogenases and ascribed to a Ni-Fe-C complex, was never observed by us under any conditions of detection (4 to 100 K) and incubation in the presence of ferricyanide, dithionite, CO, coenzyme A, or acetyl-coenzyme A. Novel, high-spin EPR was found in the oxidized enzyme with effective g-values at g = 14.5, 9.6, 5.5, 4.6, 4.2, 3.8. The lines at g = 14.5 and 5.5 were tentatively ascribed to an S = 9/2 system (approximately 0.3 spins/alpha beta) with rhombicity E/D = 0.047 and D less than 0. The other signals were assigned to an S = 5/2 system (0.1 spins/alpha beta) with E/D = 0.27. Both sets of signals disappear upon reduction with Em,7.5 = - 280 mV. With a very similar reduction potential, Em,7.5 = - 261 mV, an S = 1/2 signal (0.1 spins/alpha beta) appears with the unusual g-tensor 2.005, 1.894, 1.733. Upon further lowering of the potential the putative double cubane signal also appears. At a potential E approximately - 320 mV the double cubane is only reduced by a few percent and this allows the detection of individual cubane EPR not subjected to dipolar interaction; a single spectral component is observed with g-tensor 2.048, 1.943, 1.894.

Paramagnetic centers and acetyl-coenzyme A/CO exchange activity of carbon monoxide dehydrogenase from Methanothrix soehngenii

Carbon monoxide (CO) dehydrogenase was purified, both aerobically and anaerobically, to apparent homogeneity from Methanothrix soehngenii. The enzyme contained 18 +/- 2 (n = 6) mol Fe/mol and 2.0 +/- 0.1 (n = 6) mol Ni/mol. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra of the aerobically purified CO dehydrogenase showed one sharp EPR signal at g = 2.014 with several characteristics of a [3Fe-4S]1+ cluster. The integrated intensity of this signal was low, 0.03 S = 1/2 spin/alpha beta dimer. The 3Fe spectrum was not affected by incubation with CO or acetyl-coenzyme A, but could be reduced by dithionite. The spectrum of the reduced, aerobically purified enzyme showed complex EPR spectra, which had several properties typical of two [4Fe-4S]1+ clusters, whose S = 1/2 spins weakly interacted by dipolar coupling. The integrated intensity was 0.1-0.2 spin/alpha beta dimer. The anaerobically isolated enzyme showed EPR spectra different from the reduced aerobically purified enzyme. Two major signals were apparent. One with g values of 2.05, 1.93 and 1.865, and an Em7.5 of -410 mV, which quantified to 0.9 S = 1/2 spin/alpha beta dimer. The other signal with g values of 1.997, 1.886 and 1.725, and an Em7.5 of -230 mV gave 0.1 spin/alpha beta dimer. When the enzyme was incubated with its physiological substrate acetyl-coenzyme A, these two major signals disappeared. Incubation of the enzyme under CO atmosphere resulted in a partial disappearance of the spectral component with g = 1.997, 1.886, 1.725. Acetyl-coenzyme A/CO exchange activity, 35 nmol.min-1.mg-1 protein, which corresponded to 7 mol CO exchanged min-1 mol-1 enzyme, could be detected in anaerobic enzyme preparations, but was absent in aerobic preparations. Carbon dioxide also exchanged with C-1 of acetyl-coenzyme A, but at a much lower rate than CO and to a much lower extent.

Enzymology of the acetyl-CoA pathway of CO2 fixation

We know of three routes that organisms have evolved to synthesize complex organic molecules from CO2: the Calvin cycle, the reverse tricarboxylic acid cycle, and the reductive acetyl-CoA pathway. This review describes the enzymatic steps involved in the acetyl-CoA pathway, also called the Wood pathway, which is the major mechanism of CO2 fixation under anaerobic conditions. The acetyl-CoA pathway is also able to form acetyl-CoA from carbon monoxide. There are two parts to the acetyl-CoA pathway: (1) reduction of CO2 to methyltetrahydrofolate (methyl-H4folate) and (2) synthesis of acetyl-CoA from methyl-H4folate, a carboxyl donor such as CO or CO2, and CoA. This pathway is unique in that the major intermediates are enzyme-bound and are often organometallic complexes. Our current understanding of the pathway is based on radioactive and stable isotope tracer studies, purification of the component enzymes (some extremely oxygen sensitive), and identification of the enzyme-bound intermediates by chromatographic, spectroscopic, and electrochemical techniques. This review describes the remarkable series of enzymatic steps involved in acetyl-CoA formation by this pathway that is a key component of the global carbon cycle.

Glutathionylcobalamin as an intermediate in the formation of cobalamin coenzymes

To evaluate the possible role of glutathionylcobalamin (GS-Cbl) in the intracellular metabolism of cobalamin, the following reactions were analyzed using extracts of rabbit spleen: (i) decyanation of cyanocobalamin; (ii) utilization of GS-Cbl by cobalamin reductase; (iii) participation of GS-Cbl in methionine biosynthesis; and (iv) conversion of GS-Cbl to adenosylcobalamin. Decyanation of cyanocobalamin required reduced glutathione which appeared to form a complex with the cobalamin. This complex decomposed during the extraction steps to sulfitocobalamin which was identified by high-performance liquid chromatography. Cobalamin reductase in spleen extract was more active with GS-Cbl than with aquocobalamin or cyanocobalamin as substrates (specific activities: 10.4, 2.8 and 0.93 nmol/mg/min, respectively). Methionine synthase utilized GS-Cbl as cofactor more efficiently than aquocobalamin or cyanocobalamin based on initial rates of enzyme activity. This suggests that GS-Cbl is a more direct precursor of the coenzyme required for methionine synthase. Formation of adenosylcobalaminm from GS-Cb1 was four times greater than from aquocobalamin alone. Based on these results, we propose that GS-Cbl or a closely related thiol-cobalamin adduct is a proximal precursor in cobalamin coenzyme biosynthesis.

Carbonyl sulfide inhibition of CO dehydrogenase from Rhodospirillum rubrum

Carbonyl sulfide (COS) has been investigated as a rapid-equilibrium inhibitor of CO oxidation by the CO dehydrogenase purified from Rhodospirillum rubrum. The kinetic evidence suggests that the inhibition by COS is largely competitive versus CO (Ki = 2.3 microM) and uncompetitive versus methylviologen as electron acceptor (Ki = 15.8 microM). The data are compatible with a ping-pong mechanism for CO oxidation and COS inhibition. Unlike the substrate CO, COS does not reduce the iron-sulfur centers of dye-oxidized CO dehydrogenase and thus is not an alternative substrate for the enzyme. However, like CO, COS is capable of protecting CO dehydrogenase from slow-binding inhibition by cyanide. A true binding constant (KD) of 2.2 microM for COS has been derived on the basis of the saturable nature of COS protection against cyanide inhibition. The ability of CO, CO2, COS, and related CO/CO2 analogues to reverse cyanide inhibition of CO dehydrogenase is also demonstrated. The kinetic results are interpreted in terms of two binding sites for CO on CO dehydrogenase from R. rubrum.

Kinetic characterization of the [3'-32P]coenzyme A/acetyl coenzyme A exchange catalyzed by a three-subunit form of the carbon monoxide dehydrogenase/acetyl-CoA synthase from Clostridium thermoaceticum

The ability of acetyl coenzyme A synthesizing carbon monoxide dehydrogenase isolated from Clostridium thermoaceticum to catalyze the exchange of [3'-32P]coenzyme A with acetyl coenzyme A is studied. This exchange is found to have a rate exceeding that of the acetyl coenzyme A carbonyl exchange also catalyzed by CO dehydrogenase ([1-14C]acetyl coenzyme A + CO in equilibrium acetyl coenzyme A + 14CO). These two exchanges are diagnostic of the ability of CO dehydrogenase to synthesize acetyl coenzyme A from a methyl group, coenzyme A, and carbon monoxide. The kinetic parameters for the coenzyme A exchange have been determined: Km(acetyl coenzyme A) = 1500 microM, Km(coenzyme A) = 50 microM, and Vmax = 2.5 mumol min-1 mg-1. Propionyl coenzyme A is shown to be a substrate (Km approximately 5 mM) for the coenzyme A exchange, with a rate 1/15 that of acetyl coenzyme A, but is not a substrate for the carbonyl exchange. CO dehydrogenase capable of catalyzing both these two exchanges, and the oxidation of CO to CO2, is isolated as a complex of molecular weight 410,000 consisting of three proteins in an alpha 2 beta 2 gamma 2 stoichiometry. The proposed gamma subunit, not previously reported as part of CO dehydrogenase, copurifies with the enzyme and has the same molecular weight on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis as the disulfide reductase previously separated from CO dehydrogenase in a final chromatographic step.