The defective proton-ATPase of uncD mutants of Escherichia coli. Identification by DNA sequencing of residues in the beta-subunit which are essential for catalysis or normal assembly

ATP Synthesis by Oxidative Phosphorylation

The F1F0-ATP synthase (EC 3.6.1.34) is a remarkable enzyme that functions as a rotary motor. It is found in the inner membranes of Escherichia coli and is responsible for the synthesis of ATP in response to an electrochemical proton gradient. Under some conditions, the enzyme functions reversibly and uses the energy of ATP hydrolysis to generate the gradient. The ATP synthase is composed of eight different polypeptide subunits in a stoichiometry of α3β3γδεab2c10. Traditionally they were divided into two physically separable units: an F1 that catalyzes ATP hydrolysis (α3β3γδε) and a membrane-bound F0 sector that transports protons (ab2c10). In terms of rotary function, the subunits can be divided into rotor subunits (γεc10) and stator subunits (α3β3δab2). The stator subunits include six nucleotide binding sites, three catalytic and three noncatalytic, formed primarily by the β and α subunits, respectively. The stator also includes a peripheral stalk composed of δ and b subunits, and part of the proton channel in subunit a. Among the rotor subunits, the c subunits form a ring in the membrane, and interact with subunit a to form the proton channel. Subunits γ and ε bind to the c-ring subunits, and also communicate with the catalytic sites through interactions with α and β subunits. The eight subunits are expressed from a single operon, and posttranscriptional processing and translational regulation ensure that the polypeptides are made at the proper stoichiometry. Recent studies, including those of other species, have elucidated many structural and rotary properties of this enzyme.

Two ATPases

In this article, I reflect on research on two ATPases. The first is F(1)F(0)-ATPase, also known as ATP synthase. It is the terminal enzyme in oxidative phosphorylation and famous as a nanomotor. Early work on mitochondrial enzyme involved purification in large amount, followed by deduction of subunit composition and stoichiometry and determination of molecular sizes of holoenzyme and individual subunits. Later work on Escherichia coli enzyme utilized mutagenesis and optical probes to reveal the molecular mechanism of ATP hydrolysis and detailed facets of catalysis. The second ATPase is P-glycoprotein, which confers multidrug resistance, notably to anticancer drugs, in mammalian cells. Purification of the protein in large quantity allowed detailed characterization of catalysis, formulation of an alternating sites mechanism, and recently, advances in structural characterization.

Role of Charged Residues in the Catalytic Sites of Escherichia coli ATP Synthase

Here we describe the role of charged amino acids at the catalytic sites of Escherichia coli ATP synthase. There are four positively charged and four negatively charged residues in the vicinity of of E. coli ATP synthase catalytic sites. Positive charges are contributed by three arginine and one lysine, while negative charges are contributed by two aspartic acid and two glutamic acid residues. Replacement of arginine with a neutral amino acid has been shown to abrogate phosphate binding, while restoration of phosphate binding has been accomplished by insertion of arginine at the same or a nearby location. The number and position of positive charges plays a critical role in the proper and efficient binding of phosphate. However, a cluster of many positive charges inhibits phosphate binding. Moreover, the presence of negatively charged residues seems a requisite for the proper orientation and functioning of positively charged residues in the catalytic sites. This implies that electrostatic interactions between amino acids are an important constituent of initial phosphate binding in the catalytic sites. Significant loss of function in growth and ATPase activity assays in mutants generated through charge modulations has demonstrated that precise location and stereochemical interactions are of paramount importance.

Normal-mode-based modeling of allosteric couplings that underlie cyclic conformational transition in F(1) ATPase

F(1) ATPase, a rotary motor comprised of a central stalk (gamma subunit) enclosed by three alpha and beta subunits alternately arranged in a hexamer, features highly cooperative binding and hydrolysis of ATP. Despite steady progress in biophysical, biochemical, and computational studies of this fascinating motor, the structural basis for cooperative ATPase involving its three catalytic sites remains not fully understood. To illuminate this key mechanistic puzzle, we have employed a coarse-grained elastic network model to probe the allosteric couplings underlying the cyclic conformational transition in F(1) ATPase at a residue level of detail. We will elucidate how ATP binding and product (ADP and phosphate) release at two catalytic sites are coupled with the rotation of gamma subunit via various domain motions in alpha(3)beta(3) hexamer (including intrasubunit hinge-bending motions in beta subunits and intersubunit rigid-body rotations between adjacent alpha and beta subunits). To this end, we have used a normal-mode-based correlation analysis to quantify the allosteric couplings of these domain motions to local motions at catalytic sites and the rotation of gamma subunit. We have then identified key amino acid residues involved in the above couplings, some of which have been validated against past studies of mutated and gamma-truncated F(1) ATPase. Our finding strongly supports a binding change mechanism where ATP binding to the empty catalytic site triggers a series of intra- and intersubunit domain motions leading to ATP hydrolysis and product release at the other two closed catalytic sites.

ATP hydrolysis in the betaTP and betaDP catalytic sites of F1-ATPase

The enzyme F1-adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) is a molecular motor that converts the chemical energy stored in the molecule adenosine triphosphate (ATP) into mechanical rotation of its gamma-subunit. During steady-state catalysis, the three catalytic sites of F1 operate in a cooperative fashion such that at every instant each site is in a different conformation corresponding to a different stage along the catalytic cycle. Notwithstanding a large amount of biochemical and, recently, structural data, we still lack an understanding of how ATP hydrolysis in F1 is coupled to mechanical motion and how the catalytic sites achieve cooperativity during rotatory catalysis. In this publication, we report combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical simulations of ATP hydrolysis in the betaTP and betaDP catalytic sites of F1-ATPase. Our simulations reveal a dramatic change in the reaction energetics from strongly endothermic in betaTP to approximately equienergetic in betaDP. The simulations identify the responsible protein residues, the arginine finger alphaR373 being the most important one. Similar to our earlier study of betaTP, we find a multicenter proton relay mechanism to be the energetically most favorable hydrolysis pathway. The results elucidate how cooperativity between catalytic sites might be achieved by this remarkable molecular motor.

Mutagenesis of residue betaArg-246 in the phosphate-binding subdomain of catalytic sites of Escherichia coli F1-ATPase

Residues responsible for phosphate binding in F(1)F(0)-ATP synthase catalytic sites are of significant interest because phosphate binding is believed linked to proton gradient-driven subunit rotation. From x-ray structures, a phosphate-binding subdomain is evident in catalytic sites, with conserved betaArg-246 in a suitable position to bind phosphate. Mutations betaR246Q, betaR246K, and betaR246A in Escherichia coli were found to impair oxidative phosphorylation and to reduce ATPase activity of purified F(1) by 100-fold. In contrast to wild type, ATPase of mutants was not inhibited by MgADP-fluoroaluminate or MgADP-fluoroscandium, showing the Arg side chain is required for wild-type transition state formation. Whereas 7-chloro-4-nitrobenzo-2-oxa-1,3-diazole (NBD-Cl) inhibited wild-type ATPase essentially completely, ATPase in mutants was inhibited maximally by approximately 50%, although reaction still occurred at residue betaTyr-297, proximal to betaArg-246 in the phosphate-binding pocket. Inhibition characteristics supported the conclusion that NBD-Cl reacts in betaE (empty) catalytic sites, as shown previously by x-ray structure analysis. Phosphate protected against NBD-Cl inhibition in wild type but not in mutants. The results show that phosphate can bind in the betaE catalytic site of E. coli F(1) and that betaArg-246 is an important phosphate-binding residue.

Characterization of mutations in the beta subunit of the mitochondrial F1-ATPase that produce defects in enzyme catalysis and assembly

The ATP2 gene, coding for the beta subunit of the mitochondrial F1-ATPase, was cloned from nine independent isolates of chemically mutagenized yeast. Seven different mutant alleles were identified. In one case the mutation occurs in the mitochondrial targeting sequence (M1I). The remaining six mutations map to the mature part of the beta subunit protein and alter amino acids that are conserved in the bovine heart mitochondrial and Escherichia coli beta subunit proteins. Biochemical analysis of the yeast atp2 mutants identified two different phenotypes. The G133D, P179L, and G227D mutations correlate with an assembly-defective phenotype that is characterized by the accumulation of the F1 alpha and beta subunits in large protein aggregates. Strains harboring the A192V, E222K, or R293K mutations assemble an F1 of normal size that is none-the-less catalytically inactive. The effect of the atp2 mutations was also analyzed in diploids formed by crossing the mutants to wild type yeast. Hybrid enzymes formed with beta subunits containing either the G133D, E222K, or R293K mutations are compromised for steady-state ATPase activity. The display of partial dominance confirms the importance of Gly133 for structural stability and of Glu222 and Arg293 for catalytic cooperativity.

A model for the catalytic site of F1-ATPase based on analogies to nucleotide-binding domains of known structure

An updated topological model is constructed for the catalytic nucleotide-binding site of the F1-ATPase. The model is based on analogies to the known structures of the MgATP site on adenylate kinase and the guanine nucleotide sites on elongation factor Tu (Ef-Tu) and the ras p21 protein. Recent studies of these known nucleotide-binding domains have revealed several common functional features and similar alignment of nucleotide in their binding folds, and these are used as a framework for evaluating results of affinity labeling and mutagenesis studies of the beta subunit of F1. Several potentially important residues on beta are noted that have not yet been studied by mutagenesis or affinity labeling.

Evolution of organellar proton-ATPases

Proton ATPases function in biological energy conversion in every known living cell. Their ubiquity and antiquity make them a prime source for evolutionary studies. There are two related families of H(+)-ATPases; while the family of F-ATPases function in eubacteria chloroplasts and mitochondria, the family of V-ATPases are present in archaebacteria and the vacuolar system of eukaryotic cells. Sequence analysis of several subunits of V- and F-ATPases revealed several of the important steps in their evolution. Moreover, these studies shed light on the evolution of the various organelles of eukaryotes and suggested some events in the evolution of the three kingdoms of eubacteria, archaebacteria and eukaryotes.

The chloroplast beta-subunit allows assembly of the Escherichia coli F0 portion of the energy transducing adenosine triphosphatase

The effect of the expression of the chloroplast F1-ATPase beta-subunit in two Escherichia coli beta-subunit mutant strains was investigated. The amount of chloroplast beta-subunit formed in E. coli was increased by introducing a 'Shine-Dalgarno' sequence upstream from the translation start site. The chloroplast beta-subunit was membrane bound but was unable to functionally replace the mutant beta-subunit in a strain carrying the uncD409 allele [corrected]. However, in an E. coli mutant strain unable to form the beta- and epsilon-subunits the presence of the chloroplast beta-subunit enabled the assembly of a functional proton pore [corrected]

Characterization of Escherichia coli ATP synthase beta-subunit mutations using a chromosomal deletion strain

(1) We constructed Escherichia coli strain JP17 with a deletion in the ATP synthase beta-subunit gene. JP17 is completely deficient in ATP synthase activity and expresses no beta-subunit. Expression of normal beta-subunit from a plasmid restores haploid levels of ATP synthase in membranes. JP17 was shown to be efficacious for studies of beta-subunit mutations. Site-directed mutants were studied directly in JP17. Randomly generated chromosomal mutants were identified by PCR and DNA sequencing, cloned, and expressed in JP17. (2) Eight novel mutations occurring within the putative catalytic nucleotide-binding domain were characterized with respect to their effects on catalysis and structure. The mutations beta C137S, beta G152D, beta G152R, beta E161Q, beta E161R, and beta G251D each impaired catalysis without affecting enzyme assembly or oligomeric structure and are of interest for future studies of catalytic mechanism. The mutations beta D301V and beta D302V, involving strongly conserved carboxyl residues, caused oligomeric instability of F1. However, growth characteristics of these mutants suggested that neither carboxyl side chain is critical for catalysis. (3) The mutations beta R398C and beta R398W rendered ATP synthase resistant to aurovertin, giving strong support to the view that beta R398 is a key residue in the aurovertin-binding site. Neither beta R398C or beta R398W impaired catalysis significantly.

Effect of the weakly acidic uncoupler 2,4-dinitrophenol and dimethyl sulfoxide on the coordination of Mg2+ with ATP. Possible mechanism of activation of the isolated F1-ATPase by 2,4-dinitrophenol

The exchange rate constants between Mg2(+)-free and Mg2(+)-bound ATP were determined under various conditions by line shape analysis of the 31P-NMR spectrum based on the exchange reaction, and the thermodynamic parameters of this exchange reaction were determined from the temperature dependence of its rate constants. Analysis of the activation enthalpy change delta H showed that Mg2+ is coordinated with the beta- and gamma-phosphoryl groups of ATP asymmetrically, being in closer proximity to the beta-phosphoryl group. The weakly acidic uncoupler 2,4-dinitrophenol increased this asymmetric coordination of Mg2+, and this effect was enhanced by the further addition of dimethyl sulfoxide. The hydrolysis of ATP in aqueous solution correlated well with the degree of asymmetry of Mg2+ coordination. Thus, this asymmetric coordination specifically weakens the O-P gamma bond at which specific cleavage of ATP catalyzed by most ATPases takes place in the presence of Mg2+. In this paper, the mechanism of activation of isolated ATPase (F1-ATPase) by 2,4-dinitrophenol, and that of ATP synthesis by isolated F1-ATPase in the presence of dimethyl sulfoxide are considered on the basis of these results. The essential role of the OH group of Ser-174 of the beta-subunit of F1-ATPase in ATP hydrolysis is also discussed.

Identification of a mutation in Escherichia coli F1-ATPase beta-subunit conferring resistance to aurovertin

A mutation conferring aurovertin resistance on Escherichia coli F1-ATPase was identified as R398----H in the F1 beta-subunit. Beta-subunit from the mutant does not bind aurovertin; therefore our results suggest the region of sequence around residue beta-398 is involved in aurovertin binding. Since nucleotide and aurovertin binding to isolated beta-subunit are not mutually exclusive, the data further suggest that the beta-subunit catalytic nucleotide-binding domain does not include residue 398. The mutation prevented aurovertin inhibition of ATPase at pH 6 and 8.5, implying charge on the arginine side-chain is not a major determinant of aurovertin binding or that the pK of R398 is shifted due to a peculiar environment. The equivalent residue is usually arginine in F1 beta-subunits of different species; notably in the aurovertin-insensitive thermophilic bacterium PS3 F1-ATPase, this residue is phenylalanine.

Structure-function relationships of mitochondrial ATPase-ATPsynthase using Schizosaccharomyces pombe yeast mutants with altered F1 subunits

Phenotypic revertants have been selected from mutants of the yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe devoid of either alpha or beta subunits of mitochondrial ATPase-ATPsynthase. In contrast to parental mutants, phenotypic revertants are able to grow on glycerol respiratory medium and show immunodetectable alpha and beta subunits. However, growth and cellular respiration are only partially restored as compared to the wild strain, indicating that the recovered subunits are mutated. ATPase activity of revertant submitochondrial particles shows markedly different parameters: more acidic optimal pH, absence of bicarbonate activation and decreased sensitivity to azide inhibition in the alpha subunit-modified R3.51. Opposite differences are observed in the beta subunit-modified R4.3: more alkaline optimal pH, much higher bicarbonate activation, and increased sensitivity to azide. The ITPase activity of R4.3 submitochondrial particles is also more sensitive to azide as compared to the wild strain. ATPase activity of purified F1 also exhibits marked differences: loss of bicarbonate-sensitive negative cooperativity, decreased sensitivity to both ADP and azide inhibitions in the R3.51 revertant. On the contrary, increased negative cooperativity and increased sensitivity to both ADP and azide inhibitions are observed for the R4.3 revertant enzyme which in addition exhibits a much lower maximal rate. The beta subunit-mutation of R4.3 also increases the sensitivity of ITPase activity to tripolyphosphate inhibition, whereas the alpha subunit-mutation of R3.51 is without any effect. Soluble F1 with beta subunit-mutation is very sensitive to high ammonium sulfate concentrations required for enzyme precipitation and concentration and known to partially deplete the enzyme from its endogenous nucleotides. On the contrary, poly(ethylene)glycol is very efficient for preparing from any strain a pure and very stable enzyme retain-ing high amounts of endogenous nucleotides. The R4.3 revertant F1 retains even more nucleotides than the wild-strain F1 and is much less sensitive to high iodide concentrations which favor enzyme dissociation and precipitation. The tryptophan intrinsic fluorescence of F1 is modified by both mutations that increase the maximal emission intensity. The most important effect is produced by beta subunit-mutation which decreases the quenchable fraction, one-third to one-half tryptophans being no longer accessible to iodide. The overall results suggest that both mutations modify enzyme-nucleotide interactions: the alpha subunit-mutation of R3.51 would favor ADP release by lowering interactions with the adenine moiety, whereas the beta subunit-mutation of R4.3 would lower ADP release by strengthening interactions with the phosphate chain moiety.

Purification from a yeast mutant of mitochondrial F1 with modified beta-subunit. High affinity for nucleotides and high negative cooperativity of ATPase activity

Mitochondrial F1 containing genetically modified beta-subunit was purified for the first time from a mutant of the yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Precipitation by poly(ethylene glycol) allowed us to obtain a very stable and pure enzyme from either mutant or wild-type strain. In the presence of EDTA, purified F1 retained high amounts of endogenous nucleotides: 4.6 mol/mol and 3.7 mol/mol for mutant and wild-type F1, respectively. The additional nucleotide in mutant F1 was ATP; it was lost in the presence of Mg2+, which led to a total of 3.4 mol of nucleotides/mol whereas wild-type F1 retained all its nucleotides. Mutant F1 bound more exogenous ADP than wild-type F1 and the same total nucleotide amount was reached with both enzymes. Kinetics of ATPase activity revealed a much higher negative cooperativity for mutant than for wild-type F1. Bicarbonate abolished this negative cooperativity, but higher concentrations were required for mutant F1. The mutant enzyme was more sensitive than the wild-type one to azide inhibition and ADP competitive inhibition; this indicated stronger interactions between nucleotide and F1 in the mutant enzyme. The latter also showed increased sensitivity to N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide irreversible inhibition.

ATP synthases--structure of the F1-moiety and its relationship to function and mechanism

A great deal of progress has been made in understanding both the structure and the mechanism of F1-ATPase. The primary structure is now fully known for at least five species. Sequence comparison between chloroplast, photobacteria, aerobic bacteria, and mitochondrial representatives allow us to infer more general functional relationships and evolutionary trends. Although the F1 moiety is the most studied segment of the H+-ATPase complex, there is not a full understanding of the mechanism and regulation of its hydrolytic activity. The beta subunit is now known to contain one and probably two nucleotide binding domains, one of which is believed to be a catalytic site. Recently, two similar models have been proposed to attempt to describe the "active" part of the beta subunits. These models are mainly an attempt to use the structure of adenylate kinase to represent a more general working model for nucleotide binding phosphotransferases. Labelling experiments seem to indicate that several critical residues outside the region described by the "adenylate kinase" part of this model are also actively involved in the ATPase activity. New models will have to be introduced to include these regions. Finally, it seems that a consensus has been reached with regard to a broad acceptance of the asymmetric structure of the F1-moiety. In addition, recent experimental evidence points toward the presence of nonequivalent subunits to describe the functional activity of the F1-ATPase. A summary diagram of the conformational and binding states of the enzyme including the nonequivalent beta subunit is presented. Additional research is essential to establish the role of the minor subunits--and of the asymmetry they introduce in F1--on the physiological function of the enzyme.

Mechanism of F1-ATPase studied by the genetic approach

E. coli F1-ATPase has been studied mainly by the genetic approach. Mutations in either the alpha or beta subunit modified the kinetics of multisite and uni-site hydrolysis of ATP. The mechanism of F1-ATPase and the essential amino acid residues of beta subunits are discussed.

Identification of alpha-subunit Lys201 and beta-subunit Lys155 at the ATP-binding sites in Escherichia coli F1-ATPase

Binding of about 1 mol of adenosine triphosphopyridoxal to Escherichia coli F1-ATPase resulted in the nearly complete inactivation of the enzyme [(1987) J. Biol. Chem. 262, 7686-7692]. About two thirds of the label was bound to the alpha-subunit, and the rest to the beta-subunit. The present study revealed that Lys201 in the alpha-subunit and Lys155 in the glycine-rich region of the beta-subunit are the major sites labeled with this reagent. Thus, these two residues might be located close to the gamma-phosphate of the bound ATP.

E. coli F1-ATPase: site-directed mutagenesis of the beta-subunit

Residues beta Glu-181 and beta Glu-192 of E. coli F1-ATPase (the DCCD-reactive residues) were mutated to Gln. Purified beta Gln-181 F1 showed 7-fold impairment of 'unisite' Pi formation from ATP and a large decrease in affinity for ATP. Thus the beta-181 carboxyl group in normal F1 significantly contributes to catalytic site properties. Also, positive catalytic site cooperativity was attenuated from 5 X 10(4)- to 548-fold in beta Gln-181 F1. In contrast, purified beta Gln-192 F1 showed only 6-fold reduction in 'multisite' ATPase activity. Residues beta Gly-149 and beta Gly-154 were mutated to Ile singly and in combination. These mutations, affecting residues which are strongly conserved in nucleotide-binding proteins, were chosen to hinder conformational motion in a putative 'flexible loop' in beta-subunit. Impairment of purified F1-ATPase ranged from 5 to 61%, with the double mutant F1 less impaired than either single mutant. F1 preparations containing beta Ile-154 showed 2-fold activation after release from membranes, suggesting association with F0 restrained turnover on F1 in these mutants.

Directed mutagenesis of the dicyclohexylcarbodiimide-reactive carboxyl residues in beta-subunit of F1-ATPase of Escherichia coli

Previous studies in which dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) was used to inactivate F1-ATPase enzymes have suggested that two glutamate residues in the beta-subunit are essential for catalysis. In the Escherichia coli F1-ATPase, these are residues beta-Glu-181 and beta-Glu-192. Oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis was used to change these residues to beta-Gln-181 and beta-Gln-192. The beta-Gln-181 mutation produced strong impairment of oxidative phosphorylation in vivo and also of ATPase and ATP-driven proton-pumping activities in membranes assayed in vitro. A low level of each activity was detected and an F1-ATPase appeared to be assembled normally on the membranes. Therefore, it is suggested that the carboxyl side chain at residue beta-181 is important, although not absolutely required, for catalysis in both directions on E. coli F1-ATPase. The beta-Gln-192 mutation produced partial inhibition of oxidative phosphorylation in vivo and membrane ATPase activity was reduced by 78%. These results contrast with the complete or near-complete inactivation seen when E. coli F1-ATPase is reacted with DCCD and imply that DCCD-inactivation is attributable more to the attachment of the bulky DCCD molecule than to the derivatization of the carboxyl side chain of residue beta-Glu-192. M. Ohtsubo and colleagues (Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. (1987) 146, 705-710) described mutagenesis of the F1-beta-subunit of thermophilic bacterium PS3. Mutations (Glu----Gln) of the residues homologous to Glu-181 and Glu-192 of E. coli F1-beta-subunit both caused total inhibition of ATPase activity. Therefore, there was a marked difference in results obtained when the same residues were modified in the PS3 and E. coli F1-beta-subunits.