Structural changes that accompany the reduced catalytic efficiency of two semisynthetic ribonuclease analogs

Characterization of an RNase with two catalytic centers. Human RNase6 catalytic and phosphate-binding site arrangement favors the endonuclease cleavage of polymeric substrates

BACKGROUND

Human RNase6 is a small cationic antimicrobial protein that belongs to the vertebrate RNaseA superfamily. All members share a common catalytic mechanism, which involves a conserved catalytic triad, constituted by two histidines and a lysine (His15/His122/Lys38 in RNase6 corresponding to His12/His119/Lys41 in RNaseA). Recently, our first crystal structure of human RNase6 identified an additional His pair (His36/His39) and suggested the presence of a secondary active site.

METHODS

In this work we have explored RNase6 and RNaseA subsite architecture by X-ray crystallography, site-directed mutagenesis and kinetic characterization.

RESULTS

The analysis of two novel crystal structures of RNase6 in complex with phosphate anions at atomic resolution locates a total of nine binding sites and reveals the contribution of Lys87 to phosphate-binding at the secondary active center. Contribution of the second catalytic triad residues to the enzyme activity is confirmed by mutagenesis. RNase6 catalytic site architecture has been compared with an RNaseA engineered variant where a phosphate-binding subsite is converted into a secondary catalytic center (RNaseA-K7H/R10H).

CONCLUSIONS

We have identified the residues that participate in RNase6 second catalytic triad (His36/His39/Lys87) and secondary phosphate-binding sites. To note, residues His39 and Lys87 are unique within higher primates. The RNaseA/RNase6 side-by-side comparison correlates the presence of a dual active site in RNase6 with a favored endonuclease-type cleavage pattern.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

An RNase dual catalytic and extended binding site arrangement facilitates the cleavage of polymeric substrates. This is the first report of the presence of two catalytic centers in a single monomer within the RNaseA superfamily.

The first crystal structure of human RNase 6 reveals a novel substrate-binding and cleavage site arrangement

We describe the first human RNase 6 crystal structure in complex with sulfate anions. Kinetic analysis, site-directed mutagenesis and molecular dynamics simulations identified novel substrate recognition and cleavage sites.

Human RNase 6 is a cationic secreted protein that belongs to the RNase A superfamily. Its expression is induced in neutrophils and monocytes upon bacterial infection, suggesting a role in host defence. We present here the crystal structure of RNase 6 obtained at 1.72 Å (1 Å=0.1 nm) resolution, which is the first report for the protein 3D structure and thereby setting the basis for functional studies. The structure shows an overall kidney-shaped globular fold shared with the other known family members. Three sulfate anions bound to RNase 6 were found, interacting with residues at the main active site (His¹⁵, His¹²² and Gln¹⁴) and cationic surface-exposed residues (His³⁶, His³⁹, Arg⁶⁶ and His⁶⁷). Kinetic characterization, together with prediction of protein–nucleotide complexes by molecular dynamics, was applied to analyse the RNase 6 substrate nitrogenous base and phosphate selectivity. Our results reveal that, although RNase 6 is a moderate catalyst in comparison with the pancreatic RNase type, its structure includes lineage-specific features that facilitate its activity towards polymeric nucleotide substrates. In particular, enzyme interactions at the substrate 5′ end can provide an endonuclease-type cleavage pattern. Interestingly, the RNase 6 crystal structure revealed a novel secondary active site conformed by the His³⁶–His³⁹ dyad that facilitates the polynucleotide substrate catalysis.

Structural basis of substrate specificity in porcine RNase 4

RNase 4, a member of the RNase A superfamily with substrate preference for uridine, has roles in host defence, angiogenesis and neurodegenerative diseases. It also exhibits the highest interspecies amino acid sequence similarity amongst RNase A family members. However, compared to other members of the RNase A family, including eosinophil-derived neurotoxin, eosinophil cationic protein and angiogenin, little is known about the molecular basis of substrate specificity in RNase 4. Here we report high to medium resolution structures of native porcine RNase 4 (PL3), a 'substrate-specificity' determining mutant D80A and their respective complexes with deoxyuridine 5'-monophosphate (dUMP) and deoxycytidine 5'-monophosphate (dCMP). These structures provide insight into the structural basis of the uridine versus cytosine substrate specificity in RNase 4: in the D80A mutant (D80A•dCMP), the side chain of Arg101 is positioned further away from the substrate-binding pocket due to the loss of the Asp80 side chain, reducing the repulsion force on the less favoured dCMP from Arg101 and allowing the ligand to occupy the binding pocket. This can also explain the observation that the ligand in the D80A•dCMP complex is stabilized only by a small number of hydrogen bonds. Compared to the previously reported structure of the human RNase 4•2'-deoxyuridine 3'-phosphate complex, the structure of PL3•dUMP complex shows additional hydrogen bonds between the ligand and the protein. In addition, the interaction between Arg101 and the dUMP ligand is absent. These observed differences are probably the result of the flexibility and different 'positioning' of the phosphate group among the mononucleotide ligands.

DATABASE

The atomic coordinates and structure factors for PL3 (5AR6), D80A (5ARJ), PL3∙dUMP (5ARK) and D80A∙dCMP (5ARL) complexes have been deposited with the Protein Data Bank, Research Collaboratory for Structural Bioinformatics, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ, USA (http://www.rcsb.org/).

Role of aspartic acid 121 in human pancreatic ribonuclease catalysis

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) is one of the most well studied enzymes of the ribonuclease family, unlike its human counterpart, the human pancreatic ribonuclease (HPR), whose physiological role in the body is not clearly understood. Human pancreatic ribonuclease consists of 128 amino acids and the main residues located in the active site of RNase A are also conserved in HPR. In the current study, to investigate the role of Asp-121 in the catalytic activity of human pancreatic ribonuclease, several variants were generated in which Asp-121 was either mutated to an alanine or C-terminal residues beyond Asp-121, and Phe-120 were deleted. The HPR mutants were cloned, expressed in E. coli and purified to homogeneity, and functionally characterized. The mutation D121A in HPR significantly decreased the rate of the enzymatic reaction, however this decrease was not universally observed for all substrates studied. Removal of the seven C-terminal amino acid residues thereby exposing Asp-121 yielded an HPR mutant with enhanced activity, however a further deletion removing Asp-121 resulted in the complete inactivation of HPR. Our results indicate that Asp-121 is crucial for the catalytic activity of HPR and may be involved in the depolymerization activity of the enzyme.

Conformational strictness required for maximum activity and stability of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A as revealed by crystallographic study of three Phe120 mutants at 1.4 A resolution

The replacement of Phe120 with other hydrophobic residues causes a decrease in the activity and thermal stability in ribonuclease A (RNase A). To explain this, the crystal structures of wild-type RNase A and three mutants--F120A, F120G, and F120W--were analyzed up to a 1.4 A resolution. Although the overall backbone structures of all mutant samples were nearly the same as that of wild-type RNase A, except for the C-terminal region of F120G with a high B-factor, two local conformational changes were observed at His119 in the mutants. First, His119 of the wild-type and F120W RNase A adopted an A position, whereas those of F120A and F120G adopted a B position, but the static crystallographic position did not reflect either the efficiency of transphosphorylation or the hydrolysis reaction. Second, His119 imidazole rings of all mutant enzymes were deviated from that of wild-type RNase A, and those of F120W and F120G appeared to be "inside out" compared with that of wild-type RNase A. Only approximately 1 A change in the distance between N(epsilon2) of His12 and N(delta1) of His119 causes a drastic decrease in k(cat), indicating that the active site requires the strict positioning of the catalytic residues. A good correlation between the change in total accessible surface area of the pockets on the surface of the mutant enzymes and enthalpy change in their thermal denaturation also indicates that the effects caused by the replacements are not localized but extend to remote regions of the protein molecule.

Mapping the ribonucleolytic active site of eosinophil-derived neurotoxin (EDN). High resolution crystal structures of EDN complexes with adenylic nucleotide inhibitors

Eosinophil-derived neurotoxin (EDN), a basic ribonuclease found in the large specific granules of eosinophils, belongs to the pancreatic RNase A family. Although its physiological function is still unclear, it has been shown that EDN is a neurotoxin capable of inducing the Gordon phenomenon in rabbits. EDN is also a potent helminthotoxin and can mediate antiviral activity of eosinophils against isolated virions of the respiratory syncytial virus. EDN is a catalytically efficient RNase sharing similar substrate specificity with pancreatic RNase A with its ribonucleolytic activity being absolutely essential for its neurotoxic, helminthotoxic, and antiviral activities. The crystal structure of recombinant human EDN in the unliganded form has been determined previously (Mosimann, S. C., Newton, D. L., Youle, R. J., and James, M. N. G. (1996) J. Mol. Biol. 260, 540-552). We have now determined high resolution (1.8 A) crystal structures for EDN in complex with adenosine-3',5'-diphosphate (3',5'-ADP), adenosine-2',5'-di-phosphate (2',5'-ADP), adenosine-5'-diphosphate (5'-ADP) as well as for a native structure in the presence of sulfate refined at 1.6 A. The inhibition constant of these mononucleotides for EDN has been determined. The structures present the first detailed picture of differences between EDN and RNase A in substrate recognition at the ribonucleolytic active site. They also provide a starting point for the design of tight-binding inhibitors, which may be used to restrain the RNase activity of EDN.

The ultrahigh resolution crystal structure of ribonuclease A containing an isoaspartyl residue: hydration and sterochemical analysis

Crystals of the deamidated form of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease which contains an isoaspartyl residue in position 67 diffract to 0. 87 A at 100 K. We have refined the crystallographic model using anisotropic displacement parameters for all atoms to a conventional crystallographic residual R=0.101 for all observed reflections in the resolution range 61.0-0.87 A. The ratio observations/parameters is 7.2 for the final model. This structure represents one of the highest resolution protein structures to date and interestingly, it is the only example containing more than one molecule in the asymmetric unit with a resolution better than 1.0 A. The non-crystallographic symmetry has been used as a validation check of the geometrical parameters and it has allowed an estimate for an upper limit of errors associated with this high resolution model. In the present structure it was possible to obtain a more accurate picture of the active site whose electron density was not clearly interpretable in the previous 1.9 A resolution structure. In particular, the P1 site is alternatively occupied either by a sulphate anion or by a water molecule network. Most of hydrogen atoms were visible in the electron density maps, including those involved in C(alpha)-H(alpha).O interactions. Analysis of protein-solvent interactions has revealed the occurrence of an extensive cluster of water molecules, predominantly arranged in pentagonal fused rings and surrounding hydrophobic moiety of side-chains. Finally, in spite of the limited sample of residues, we have detected a clear dependence of backbone N-C(alpha)-C angle on residue conformation. This correlation can be fruitfully used as a valuable tool in protein structure validation.

His ... Asp catalytic dyad of ribonuclease A: histidine pKa values in the wild-type, D121N, and D121A enzymes

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) has a conserved His ... Asp catalytic dyad in its active site. Structural analyses had indicated that Asp121 forms a hydrogen bond with His119, which serves as an acid during catalysis of RNA cleavage. The enzyme contains three other histidine residues including His12, which is also in the active site. Here, 1H-NMR spectra of wild-type RNase A and the D121N and D121A variants were analyzed thoroughly as a function of pH. The effect of replacing Asp121 on the microscopic pKa values of the histidine residues is modest: none change by more than 0.2 units. There is no evidence for the formation of a low-barrier hydrogen bond between His119 and either an aspartate or an asparagine residue at position 121. In the presence of the reaction product, uridine 3'-phosphate (3'-UMP), protonation of one active-site histidine residue favors protonation of the other. This finding is consistent with the phosphoryl group of 3'-UMP interacting more strongly with the two active-site histidine residues when both are protonated. Comparison of the titration curves of the unliganded enzyme with that obtained in the presence of different concentrations of 3'-UMP shows that a second molecule of 3'-UMP can bind to the enzyme. Together, the data indicate that the aspartate residue in the His ... Asp catalytic dyad of RNase A has a measurable but modest effect on the ionization of the adjacent histidine residue.

TESS: a geometric hashing algorithm for deriving 3D coordinate templates for searching structural databases. Application to enzyme active sites

It is well established that sequence templates such as those in the PROSITE and PRINTS databases are powerful tools for predicting the biological function and tertiary structure for newly derived protein sequences. The number of X-ray and NMR protein structures is increasing rapidly and it is apparent that a 3D equivalent of the sequence templates is needed. Here, we describe an algorithm called TESS that automatically derives 3D templates from structures deposited in the Brookhaven Protein Data Bank. While a new sequence can be searched for sequence patterns, a new structure can be scanned against these 3D templates to identify functional sites. As examples, 3D templates are derived for enzymes with an O-His-O "catalytic triad" and for the ribonucleases and lysozymes. When these 3D templates are applied to a large data set of nonidentical proteins, several interesting hits are located. This suggests that the development of a 3D template database may help to identify the function of new protein structures, if unknown, as well as to design proteins with specific functions.

Ionic interactions in crystalline bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A

Isomorphous crystals (space group P3(2)21) of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) were prepared at a pH of 5.5 in a series of high salt conditions, where both the nature of the ions and the ionic strength varied: 80% ammonium sulfate (mu = 12.5); 8 M sodium formate (mu = 8.0); 3 M NaCl, 30% ammonium sulfate (mu = 7.0); 3 M CsCl, 30% ammonium sulfate (mu = 7.0); and 2.5 M NaCl, 3.3 M sodium formate (mu = 5.8). These structures were independently refined to a resolution of 2.0 A or better with R-factors that range from 16.1% to 17.5%. A comparison of these six structures and the monoclinic crystal form of RNase A grown from alcohol shows that changes in ionic strength do not alter the secondary or tertiary structure and that there are no significant changes in intramolecular salt bridges. These findings support the notion that structures determined from crystals grown in high salt are representative of the overall structural and electrostatic features present under physiological conditions. While little effect was observed on the main chain conformation, several residues adopted different side chain conformations and altered hydrogen-bonding patterns, either as result of direct anion binding or more subtle indirect effects. Changes in the ionic composition of the mother liquor allowed for the occupancy of the active site with different anions. The direct observation of active site-bound chloride and formate anions supports the proposal that these species act as true competitive inhibitors of RNase A and not through nonspecific electrostatic effects. The identification of bound formate anions allowed for an experimental validation of computational-based functional group mapping techniques and suggests a useful modification to these approaches. Electrostatic surface potential calculations identify a nearly continuous band of positive potential, consistent with an extended binding site for polynucleotide ligands and substrates. The majority of these residues are not involved in salt bridges, which may facilitate binding to extended polynucleotide substrates. Selection of the appropriate solvent conditions results in an unoccupied active site, which will allow this crystal form to be used for the crystallographic study of productive ligand-binding modes.

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A as a model of an enzyme with multiple substrate binding sites

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A is an enzyme that catalyses the depolymerization of RNA. This process involves the interaction of the enzyme with the polymeric substrate in the active site and its correct alignment on the surface of the enzyme through multiple binding subsites that essentially recognize the negatively charged phosphate groups of the substrate. The enzyme shows a strong specificity for pyrimidine bases at the 3'-position of the phosphodiester bond that is cleaved and a preference for purine bases at the 5'-position and, probably, for guanine at the next position. On the other hand, the enzyme shows a clear preference for polynucleotide substrates over oligonucleotides. In this review the contributions to the catalytic mechanism of some amino-acid residues that are located at non catalytic binding subsites are analysed.

The structures of RNase A complexed with 3'-CMP and d(CpA): active site conformation and conserved water molecules

The interactions of RNase A with cytidine 3'-monophosphate (3'-CMP) and deoxycytidyl-3',5'-deoxyadenosine (d(CpA)) were analyzed by X-ray crystallography. The 3'-CMP complex and the native structure were determined from trigonal crystals, and the d(CpA) complex from monoclinic crystals. The differences between the overall structures are concentrated in loop regions and are relatively small. The protein-inhibitor contacts are interpreted in terms of the catalytic mechanism. The general base His 12 interacts with the 2' oxygen, as does the electrostatic catalyst Lys 41. The general acid His 119 has 2 conformations (A and B) in the native structure and is found in, respectively, the A and the B conformation in the d(CpA) and the 3'-CMP complex. From the present structures and from a comparison with RNase T1, we propose that His 119 is active in the A conformation. The structure of the d(CpA) complex permits a detailed analysis of the downstream binding site, which includes His 119 and Asn 71. The comparison of the present RNase A structures with an inhibitor complex of RNase T1 shows that there are important similarities in the active sites of these 2 enzymes, despite the absence of any sequence homology. The water molecules were analyzed in order to identify conserved water sites. Seventeen water sites were found to be conserved in RNase A structures from 5 different space groups. It is proposed that 7 of those water molecules play a role in the binding of the N-terminal helix to the rest of the protein and in the stabilization of the active site.

The occupancy of two distinct conformations by active-site histidine-119 in crystals of ribonuclease is modulated by pH

Structures of a semisynthetic RNase have been obtained to a resolution of 2.0 A at pH values of 5.2, 6.5, 7.5, and 8.8, respectively. The principle structural transformation occurring over this pH range is the conversion of the side chain of active site residue His-119 from one conformation (chi 1 = -43 degrees to -57 degrees) at low pH to another (chi 1 = +159 degrees to +168 degrees) at higher pH values. On the basis of this observation, a model is proposed that reconciles the disparate pK values for His-119 in the enzyme-substrate complex that have been deduced from kinetic studies and from proton NMR measurements in the presence of pseudosubstrates.

Structural investigation of catalytically modified F120L and F120Y semisynthetic ribonucleases

The structures of two catalytically modified semisynthetic RNases obtained by replacing phenylalanine 120 with leucine and tyrosine have been determined and refined at a resolution of 2.0 A (R = 0.161 and 0.184, respectively). These structures have been compared with the refined 1.8-A structure (R = 0.204) of the fully active phenylalanine-containing enzyme (Martin PD, Doscher MS, Edwards BFP, 1987, J Biol Chem 262:15930-15938) and with the catalytically defective D121A (2.0 A, R = 0.172) and D121N (2.0 A, R = 0.186) analogs (deMel VSJ, Martin PD, Doscher MS, Edwards BFP, 1992, J Biol Chem 267:247-256). The movement away from the active site of the loop containing residues 65-72 is seen in all three catalytically defective analogs--F120L, D121A, and D121N--but not in the fully active (or hyperactive) F120Y. The insertion of the phenolic hydroxyl of Tyr 120 into a hydrogen-bonding network involving the hydroxyl group of Ser 123 and a water molecule in F120Y is the likely basis for the hyperactivity toward uridine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate previously found for this analog (Hodges RS, Merrifield RB, 1974, Int J Pept Protein Res 6:397-405) as well as the threefold increase in KM for cytidine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate found for this analog by ourselves.

Modulation of the activity of angiogenin by mutagenesis at Asp-116

Substitution of Asn, Ala or His for Asp-116 in angiogenin increases its ribonucleolytic activity towards tRNA and, at least in the case of His, its ability to induce blood-vessel formation (Harper, J.W. and Vallee, B.L. (1988) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 85, 7139-7143). Six additional Asp-116 mutants have been examined to further probe the basis for this phenomenon. Substitution of Val, Lys, Glu, or Ser increases activity towards tRNA 2-, 4-, 9- and 16-fold, respectively, whereas substitution of Trp and Pro leads to 2- and 10-fold decreases, respectively. Similar changes are seen in activity towards rRNA. Studies of base-cleavage specificity towards dinucleotide substrates (NpN') reveal a change in preference for G vs. A at the N' position when Ser replaces Asp-116 and a diminished preference for C vs. U at the N position. The Pro, Lys and Glu mutants have essentially unchanged angiogenic activity. The results demonstrate that the principal effect of replacing Asp-116 in angiogenin is to modulate enzymatic activity, possibly through an effect on His-114, and suggest that Asp-116 plays a role in controlling specificity.

Crystal packing in six crystal forms of pancreatic ribonuclease

We compare the molecular packing of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) in six crystal forms, two grown with alcohol, three with high salt and one with polyethylene glycol as a precipitant. The six packings differ in the number of molecules in contact and in the extent of the contacts, which bury 1570 A2 to 2790 A2 of the RNase surface. Regions of the protein surface involved in the six packings cover almost the whole RNase molecule. The abundance of polar interactions, about one per 200 A2, is the same in all types of precipitants. All molecule-to-molecule contacts are different in the six crystal forms, except for the one that forms a RNase dimer. The dimer has a large interface covering 1800 A2 and eight to ten polar interactions. Its presence in the three salt-grown crystal forms suggests that it is an intermediate in salt induced crystallization. In contrast, the two alcohol-grown forms contain only small interfaces, implying a different mechanism of nucleation.