Features of calmodulin that are important in the activation of the catalytic subunit of phosphorylase kinase

Protein-protein docking and analysis reveal that two homologous bacterial adenylyl cyclase toxins interact with calmodulin differently

Calmodulin (CaM), a eukaryotic calcium sensor that regulates diverse biological activities, consists of N- and C-terminal globular domains (N-CaM and C-CaM, respectively). CaM serves as the activator of CyaA, a 188-kDa adenylyl cyclase toxin secreted by Bordetella pertussis, which is the etiologic agent for whooping cough. Upon insertion of the N-terminal adenylyl cyclase domain (ACD) of CyaA to its targeted eukaryotic cells, CaM binds to this domain tightly ( approximately 200 pm affinity). This interaction activates the adenylyl cyclase activity of CyaA, leading to a rise in intracellular cAMP levels to disrupt normal cellular signaling. We recently solved the structure of CyaA-ACD in complex with C-CaM to elucidate the mechanism of catalytic activation. However, the structure of the interface between N-CaM and CyaA, the formation of which contributes a 400-fold increase of binding affinity between CyaA and CaM, remains elusive. Here, we used site-directed mutations and molecular dynamic simulations to generate several working models of CaM-bound CyaA-ACD. The validity of these models was evaluated by disulfide bond cross-linking, point mutations, and fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments. Our study reveals that a beta-hairpin region (amino acids 259-273) of CyaA-ACD likely makes contacts with the second calcium binding motif of the extended CaM. This mode of interaction differs from the interaction of N-CaM with anthrax edema factor, which binds N-CaM via its helical domain. Thus, two structurally conserved, bacterial adenylyl cyclase toxins have evolved to utilize distinct binding surfaces and modes of activation in their interaction with CaM, a highly conserved eukaryotic signaling protein.

Rational design of new binding specificity by simultaneous mutagenesis of calmodulin and a target peptide

Calcium-saturated calmodulin (CaM) binds and influences the activity of a varied collection of target proteins in most cells. This promiscuity underlies the role of CaM as a shared participant in calcium-dependent signal transduction pathways but imposes a handicap on popular CaM-based calcium biosensors, which display an undesired tendency to cross-react with cellular proteins. Designed CaM/target pairs that retain high affinity for one another but lack affinity for wild-type CaM and its natural interaction partners would therefore be useful as sensor components and possibly also as elements of "synthetic" cellular-signaling networks. Here, we have adopted a rational approach to creating suitably modified CaM/target complexes by using computational design methods to guide parallel site-directed mutagenesis of both binding partners. A hierarchical design procedure was applied to suggest a small number of complementary mutations on CaM and on a peptide ligand derived from skeletal-muscle light-chain kinase (M13). Experimental analysis showed that the procedure was successful in identifying CaM and M13 mutants with novel specificity for one another. Importantly, the designed complexes retained an affinity comparable to the wild-type CaM/M13 complex. These results represent a step toward the creation of CaM and M13 derivatives with specificity fully orthogonal to the wild-type proteins and show that qualitatively accurate predictions may be obtained from computational methods applied simultaneously to two proteins involved in multiple-linked binding equilibria.

The calmodulin-binding domain of the catalytic gamma subunit of phosphorylase kinase interacts with its inhibitory alpha subunit: evidence for a Ca2+ sensitive network of quaternary interactions

Chemical cross-linking as a probe of conformation has consistently shown that activators, including Ca(2+) ions, of the (alphabetagammadelta)(4) phosphorylase kinase holoenzyme (PhK) alter the interactions between its regulatory alpha and catalytic gamma subunits. The gamma subunit is also known to interact with the delta subunit, an endogenous molecule of calmodulin that mediates the activation of PhK by Ca(2+) ions. In this study, we have used two-hybrid screening and chemical cross-linking to dissect the regulatory quaternary interactions involving these subunits. The yeast two-hybrid system indicated that regions near the C termini of the gamma (residues 343-386) and alpha (residues 1060-1237) subunits interact. The association of this region of alpha with gamma was corroborated by the isolation of a cross-linked fragment of alpha containing residues 1015-1237 from an alpha-gamma dimer that had been formed within the PhK holoenzyme by formaldehyde, a nearly zero-length cross-linker. Because the region of gamma that we found to interact with alpha has previously been shown to contain a high affinity binding site for calmodulin (Dasgupta, M., Honeycutt, T., and Blumenthal, D. K. (1989) J. Biol. Chem. 264, 17156-17163), we tested the influence of Ca(2+) on the conformation of the alpha subunit and found that the region of alpha that interacts with gamma was, in fact, perturbed by Ca(2+). The results herein support the existence of a Ca(2+)-sensitive communication network among the delta, gamma, and alpha subunits, with the regulatory domain of gamma being the primary mediator. The similarity of such a Ca(2+)-dependent network to the interactions among troponin C, troponin I, and actin is discussed in light of the known structural and functional similarities between troponin I and the gamma subunit of PhK.

Structural basis for the activation of anthrax adenylyl cyclase exotoxin by calmodulin

Oedema factor, a calmodulin-activated adenylyl cyclase, is important in the pathogenesis of anthrax. Here we report the X-ray structures of oedema factor with and without bound calmodulin. Oedema factor shares no significant structural homology with mammalian adenylyl cyclases or other proteins. In the active site, 3'-deoxy-ATP and a single metal ion are well positioned for catalysis with histidine 351 as the catalytic base. This mechanism differs from the mechanism of two-metal-ion catalysis proposed for mammalian adenylyl cyclases. Four discrete regions of oedema factor form a surface that recognizes an extended conformation of calmodulin, which is very different from the collapsed conformation observed in other structures of calmodulin bound to effector peptides. On calmodulin binding, an oedema factor helical domain of relative molecular mass 15,000 undergoes a 15 A translation and a 30 degrees rotation away from the oedema factor catalytic core, which stabilizes a disordered loop and leads to enzyme activation. These allosteric changes provide the first molecular details of how calmodulin modulates one of its targets.

Direct visualization of the calmodulin subunit of phosphorylase kinase via electron microscopy following subunit exchange

Calmodulin is a tightly bound, intrinsic subunit (delta) of the hexadecameric phosphorylase-b kinase holoenzyme, (alphabetagammadelta)4. To introduce specifically labeled calmodulin into the phosphorylase-b kinase complex for its eventual visualization by electron microscopy, we have developed a method for rapidly exchanging exogenous calmodulin for the intrinsic delta subunit. This method exploits previous findings that low concentrations of urea in the absence of Ca(2+) ions cause the specific dissociation of only the delta subunit from the holoenzyme [Paudel, H. K., and Carlson, G. M. (1990) Biochem. J. 268, 393-399]. In the current study, phosphorylase-b kinase was incubated with excess exogenous calmodulin and a threshold concentration of urea to promote exchange of its delta subunit with the exogenous calmodulin. Size exclusion HPLC was then used to remove the excess calmodulin from the holoenzyme containing exchanged delta subunits. Using metabolically labeled [35S]calmodulin to allow quantification and optimization of exchange conditions, we achieved exchange of approximately 10% of all delta subunits within 1 h, with the exchanged holoenzyme retaining full catalytic activity. Calmodulins derivatized with Nanogold for visualization by scanning transmission electron microscopy were then exchanged for delta, which for the first time allowed localization of the delta subunit within the bridged, bilobal phosphorylase b kinase holoenzyme complex. The delta subunits were determined to be near the edge of the lobes, just distal to the interlobal bridges and proximal to a previously identified region of the enzyme's catalytic gamma subunit.

Analysis of the functional coupling between calmodulin's calcium binding and peptide recognition properties

The enhancement of calmodulin's (CaM) calcium binding activity by an enzyme or a recognition site peptide and its diminution by key point mutations at the protein recognition interface (e.g., E84K-CaM), which is more than 20 A away from the nearest calcium ligation structure, can be described by an expanded version of the Adair-Klotz equation for multiligand binding. The expanded equation can accurately describe the calcium binding events and their variable linkage to protein recognition events can be extended to other CaM-regulated enzymes and can potentially be applied to a diverse array of ligand binding systems with allosteric regulation of ligand binding, whether by other ligands or protein interaction. The 1.9 A resolution X-ray crystallographic structure of the complex between E84K-CaM and RS20 peptide, the CaM recognition site peptide from vertebrate smooth muscle and nonmuscle forms of myosin light chain kinase, provides insight into the structural basis of the functional communication between CaM's calcium ligation structures and protein recognition surfaces. The structure reveals that the complex adapts to the effect of the functional mutation by discrete adjustments in the helix that contains E84. This helix is on the amino-terminal side of the helix-loop-helix structural motif that is the first to be occupied in CaM's calcium binding mechanism. The results reported here are consistent with a sequential and cooperative model of CaM's calcium binding activity in which the two globular and flexible central helix domains are functionally linked, and provide insight into how CaM's calcium binding activity and peptide recognition properties are functionally coupled.

The structural effects of endogenous and exogenous Ca2+/calmodulin on phosphorylase kinase

The activity of phosphorylase b kinase (PbK) is stimulated by Ca2+ ions, which act through its endogenous calmodulin subunit (delta), and further stimulated by the Ca2+-dependent binding of exogenous calmodulin (delta'). In contrast to their highly characterized effects on activity, little is known regarding the structural effects on the (alphabetagammadelta)4 PbK holoenzyme induced by Ca2+ and delta'/Ca2+. We have used mono- and bifunctional chemical modifiers as conformational probes to compare how the two effectors influence the structure of the catalytic gamma subunit and the interactions among all of the subunits. As determined by reductive methylation and carboxymethylation, Ca2+ increased the accessibility of the gamma subunit; it also increased the formation by phenylenedimaleimide of an alphagammagamma conjugate that is characteristic of activated conformations of PbK (Nadeau, O. W., Sacks, D. M., and Carlson, G. M. (1997) J. Biol. Chem. 272, 26196-26201); however, Ca2+ also had structural effects that were clearly distinct from other activators. Moreover, similar structural effects of Ca2+ were observed with PbK that had been activated by phosphorylation, consistent with the fact that such activation does not eliminate the catalytic dependence of the enzyme on Ca2+. Our results suggest tiers of conformational transitions in the activation of PbK, with the most fundamental being induced by Ca2+. Analysis of the various cross-linked conjugates formed in the presence of Ca2+ by o-phenylenedimaleimide or m-maleimidobenzoyl-N-hydroxysuccinimide ester showed that the binding of Ca2+ to the delta subunit triggers changes in the interactions among all subunits, including between protomers, indicating an extensive communication network throughout the PbK complex. Most of the structural effects of delta'/Ca2+ were qualitatively similar to, but quantitatively greater than, the effects of Ca2+ alone; but delta'/Ca2+ also had distinct effects, especially involving cross-linking of the delta subunit.

Conformation and thermal denaturation of apocalmodulin: role of electrostatic mutations

Scanning microcalorimetry and circular dichroism were used to study conformational state and heat denaturation of Ca2+-free synthetic calmodulin (SynCaM) and three charge reversal mutants. We produced evidence for the major role of the electrostatic potential in the stability and flexibility of SynCaM. The substitution of 118DEE120 by 118KKK120 (SynCaM12A) does not influence the flexibility of the protein; the replacement of 82EEE84 by 82KKK84 (SynCaM8) decreases its level, while the combination of these two mutations in SynCaM18A significantly increases the flexibility. The heat denaturation of apoSynCaM and its mutants is well approximated by two two-state transitions with the lower-temperature transition corresponding to C-terminal lobe melting and the higher-temperature one to N-terminal lobe melting. The difference in transition temperatures for the two lobes decreases in SynCaM8 and increases in SynCaM18A, suggesting a modification in the influence of one lobe to the other. The electrostatic mutations change the parameters of thermal denaturation of SynCaM lobes in a similar way as pH conditions affect thermal transition parameters of multidomain proteins, leading to a linear temperature dependence of transition enthalpy. One domain of the N-terminal lobe in apoSynCaM18A is unfolded in the native state. Near-UV CD spectra point out the invariability of the local structure of aromatic residues upon mutations, although the secondary structure undergoes striking transformations. Cacodylate ions strongly and specifically alter the helical content of SynCaM. Our data unambiguously demonstrate that the two lobes are not independent, and interactions between the lobes are mediated by the electrostatic potential of the molecule.

Interaction of smooth muscle caldesmon with calmodulin mutants

The interaction of avian smooth muscle caldesmon with calmodulin (CaM) was investigated by studying the ability of selected mutant calmodulins to induce fluorescence changes in caldesmon. Different types of CaM mutants were used including point charge mutants, cluster mutations, and mutations which alter the calcium binding of CaM. The caldesmon binding properties were only slightly affected by E84K-CaM or by the double mutation E84Q/E120Q-CaM. Affinity of calmodulin to caldesmon was decreased 2-4 times by point mutation G33V-CaM, double mutation E84K/E120K-CaM, deletion of residues 82-84, and by cluster mutations DEE118-120-->KKK or EEE82-84-->KKK. Mutations of the first (E31A-CaM) and the second (E67A-CaM) calcium binding sites reduced the affinity of calmodulin to caldesmon by at least 5-fold; in addition these calmodulin mutants exhibited smaller changes in the fluorescence spectra of caldesmon. Simultaneous mutation of the two negatively charged clusters of calmodulin EEE82-84-->KKK and DEE118-120-->KKK resulted in a more than 15-fold decrease in the affinity of calmodulin for caldesmon. The data indicate that charged and uncharged amino acids in both halves of CaM play an important role in the binding of calmodulin to caldesmon, and that Ca2+ binding must be maintained in the amino-terminal sites for maximal interaction with caldesmon.

Gain of function mutations for yeast calmodulin and calcium dependent regulation of protein kinase activity

Yeast calmodulin binds only three calcium ions in the presence of millimolar concentrations of magnesium due to a defective calcium-binding sequence in its carboxyl terminal domain. Yeast calmodulin's diminished calcium-binding activity can be restored to that of other calmodulins by the use of site-directed mutagenesis to substitute its fourth calcium-binding domain with that of a vertebrate calmodulin sequence. However, the repair of yeast calmodulin's calcium-binding activity is not sufficient to repair quantitatively yeast calmodulin's defective protein kinase activator activity. Yeast calmodulin's activator activity with smooth muscle and skeletal muscle myosin light chain kinases and brain calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II can be progressively repaired by additional substitutions of vertebrate calmodulin sequences, provided that the four calcium-binding sites remain intact. An unexpected result obtained during the course of these studies was the observation that myosin light chain kinases from smooth and skeletal muscle tissues can respond differently to mutations in calmodulin. These and previous results indicate that the binding of four calcium ions by calmodulin is necessary but not sufficient to bring about quantitative activation of protein kinases, and are consistent with the conformational selection/restriction model of the dynamic equilibrium among calcium, calmodulin and each calmodulin regulated enzyme.