The epsilon subunit and inhibitory monoclonal antibodies interact with the carboxyl-terminal region of the beta subunit of Escherichia coli F1-ATPase

Catalytic control and coupling efficiency of the Escherichia coli FoF1 ATP synthase: influence of the Fo sector and epsilon subunit on the catalytic transition state

The rate-limiting transition state of steady-state ATP hydrolysis and synthesis reactions in the F(o)F(1) ATP synthase involves the rotation of the gamma, epsilon, and c subunits. To probe the role of the transport and coupling mechanisms in controlling catalysis, kinetic and thermodynamic parameters of ATP hydrolysis were determined for enzymes in the presence of the detergent lauryldimethylamine oxide (LDAO), which uncouples active transport and disables the inhibitory effect of the epsilon subunit. At 5 mM LDAO or greater, the inhibitory effects of epsilon subunit are abrogated in both purified F(1) and membranous F(o)F(1). In these conditions, LDAO solubilized F(o)F(1) has a higher k(cat) for ATP hydrolysis than F(1). These results indicate an influence of F(o) on F(1) even though catalysis is uncoupled from transport. The alpha(3)beta(3)gamma complex free of the epsilon subunit is activated at a lower concentration of 0.5 mM LDAO. Significantly, the gammaY205C mutant enzyme is similarly activated at 0.5 mM LDAO, suggesting that the mutant enzyme lacks epsilon inhibition. The gammaY205C F(o)F(1), which has a k(cat) for ATP hydrolysis 2-fold higher than wild type, has an ATP synthesis rate 3-fold lower than wild type, showing that coupling is inefficient. Arrhenius and isokinetic analyses indicate that enzymes that are free of epsilon subunit inhibition have a different transition-state structure from those under the influence of the epsilon subunit. We propose that the epsilon subunit is one of the factors that determines the proper transition-state structure, which is essential for efficient coupling.

Delta subunit of rat liver mitochondrial ATP synthase: molecular description and novel insights into the nature of its association with the F1-moiety

The F1 moiety of ATP synthase complexes consists of five subunit types in the stoichiometric ratio alpha 3, beta 3, gamma, delta epsilon. Of these, the delta subunit has received very little attention in the study of F1 preparations from eukaryotic cells. Although recently shown to associate tightly with the beta subunit [Pedersen, P. L., Hullihen, J., Bianchet, M., Amzel, L. M., and Lebowitz, M. S. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 1775-1784], the delta subunit is not resolved in the X-ray structure of either the rat liver or bovine heart enzyme. For these reasons, the novel studies reported here were designed both to provide a molecular description of the rat liver delta subunit and to gain insight into the nature of its interaction with F1. The rat liver delta subunit was cloned from a lambda gt11 library, sequenced, overexpressed in Escherichia coli (E. coli) in fusion with the maltose binding protein, and, after cleavage of the latter protein, purified to homogeneity. The purified delta subunit (MW = 14.7 kDa) was shown by circular dichroism spectroscopy to be highly structured and to exhibit about 25% sequence identity to the chloroplast and E. coli epsilon subunits, frequently regarded as homologues of higher eukaryotic delta subunits. Significantly, and in contrast to the chloroplast and E. coli epsilon subunits, which are readily removed from their parent F1 moieties after treatment respectively with ethanol and lauryldimethylamine oxide, the rat liver delta subunit remained tightly bound to F1 under these relatively mild conditions. For the above reasons, four types of experiments were carried out on rat liver F1 in order to (1) determine the accessibility of the delta subunit to both specific antibodies and to proteases, (2) establish the effect of nucleotides on this subunit's accessibility, (3) identify in cross-linking studies with disuccinimidyl glutarate this subunit's most reactive neighbor, and (4) determine whether this subunit can be dissociated from F1 by using ionic detergents while leaving the remaining complex intact. The data derived from this detailed set of studies (a) supports the view that the rat liver F1-delta subunit is in very close proximity to the gamma subunit near the bottom of the F1 molecule but does not penetrate deeply into the central core, (b) shows that within F1 the delta subunit's N-terminus is exposed while its C-terminus is masked, (c) indicates that access to the delta subunit is shielded in part by the alpha, beta, and gamma subunits and changes during the catalytic cycle of F1, and (d) implicates the delta subunit as important for the structural stability of the F1 unit. These novel findings on a higher eukaryotic F1-delta subunit are discussed in relationship to earlier studies on the related epsilon subunits from both chloroplasts and E. coli.

A model for the catalytic site of F1-ATPase based on analogies to nucleotide-binding domains of known structure

An updated topological model is constructed for the catalytic nucleotide-binding site of the F1-ATPase. The model is based on analogies to the known structures of the MgATP site on adenylate kinase and the guanine nucleotide sites on elongation factor Tu (Ef-Tu) and the ras p21 protein. Recent studies of these known nucleotide-binding domains have revealed several common functional features and similar alignment of nucleotide in their binding folds, and these are used as a framework for evaluating results of affinity labeling and mutagenesis studies of the beta subunit of F1. Several potentially important residues on beta are noted that have not yet been studied by mutagenesis or affinity labeling.

Epitope mapping of monoclonal antibodies to the Escherichia coli F1 ATPase alpha subunit in relation to activity effects and location in the enzyme complex based on cryoelectron microscopy

The interaction of Escherichia coli F1 ATPase (ECF1) with several different monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) specific for the alpha subunit has been examined. The epitopes for each of the mAbs have been localized by using molecular biological approaches to generate fragments of the alpha subunit. The binding of several of the mAbs has also been examined by cryoelectron microscopy of ECF1 Fab complexes. One of the mAbs, alpha II, bound in the region Asn 109-Val 153 without affecting ATPase activity. Most of the mAbs bound in the C-terminal third of the alpha subunit. MAb alpha 1 bound between residues Gln 443 and Trp 513. This mAb activated ATPase activity and was visualized in cryoelectron microscopy, superimposed on the alpha subunit, indicating that the epitope was on the top or bottom of ECF1 in the hexagonal projection. Other mAbs to the C-terminus, including alpha D which also activated the enzyme, reacted between Gly 371 and Trp 513 but failed to bind to small overlapping fragments within this sequence. The epitopes for these mAbs are probably formed by the folded polypeptide which occurs only in Western analysis when long stretches of the alpha subunit are present, suggesting that the C-terminus of alpha is a self-folding domain. In cryoelectron microscopy, Fab fragments for alpha D were seen extending from the sides of the ECF1 complex in hexagonal projection.

Catalytic site nucleotide and inorganic phosphate dependence of the conformation of the epsilon subunit in Escherichia coli adenosinetriphosphatase

The rate of trypsin cleavage of the epsilon subunit of Escherichia coli F1 (ECF1) has been found to be ligand-dependent, as measured indirectly by the activation of the enzyme that occurs on protease digestion, or when followed directly by monitoring the cleavage of this subunit using monoclonal antibodies. The cleavage of the epsilon subunit was fast in the presence of ADP alone, ADP + MG2+, ATP + EDTA, or AMP-PNP, but slow when Pi was added along with ADP + Mg2+ or when ATP + Mg2+ was added to generate ADP + Pi (+Mg2+) in the catalytic site(s). The half-maximal concentration of Pi required in the presence of ADP + Mg2+ to protect the epsilon subunit from cleavage by trypsin was 50 microM, which is in the range measured for the high-affinity binding of Pi to F1. The ligand-dependent conformational changes in the epsilon subunit were also examined in cross-linking experiments using the water-soluble carbodiimide 1-ethyl-3-[3-(dimethylamino)propyl]carbodiimide (EDC). In the presence of ATP + Mg2+ or ADP + Mg2+ + Pi, the epsilon subunit cross-linked to beta in high yield. With ATP + EDTA or ADP + Mg2+ (no Pi), the yield of the beta-epsilon cross-linked product was much reduced. We conclude that the epsilon subunit undergoes a conformational change dependent on the presence of Pi. It has been found previously that binding of the epsilon subunit to ECF1 inhibits ATPase activity by decreasing the off rate of Pi [Dunn, S. D., Zadorozny, V. D., Tozer, R. G., & Orr, L. E. (1987) Biochemistry 26, 4488-4493]. This reciprocal relationship between Pi binding and epsilon-subunit conformation has important implications for energy transduction by the E. coli ATP synthase.

Promotion and inhibition of catalytic cooperativity of the Ca2+-dependent ATPase activity of spinach chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF1)

ATP- and ITP-stimulation of the Ca2+-dependent hydrolysis of low concentrations of [gamma-32P]ATP was used as a direct demonstration of catalytic cooperativity in CF1. CF1 activated by epsilon-subunit removal or dithiothreitol, or by the presence of ethanol in the ATPase assay medium, shows pronounced catalytic cooperativity, with maximal stimulation of [gamma-32P]ATP hydrolysis at about 20 microM CaATP. Catalytic cooperativity is diminished by the presence of the epsilon-subunit or by pretreatment of either untreated or epsilon-depleted CF1 with azide (C1/2=30 microM). Both activated and untreated forms of CF1 also exhibit hydrolysis of CaATP by a high-affinity, low-capacity mode of turnover, which is unaffected by any of the preceding treatments and shows normal Michaelis-Menten behaviour. We propose that this high-affinity mode represents unisite catalysis, and that the endogenous inhibitor, epsilon, and the exogenous inhibitor, azide, both act exclusively on cooperative interactions between the catalytic sites.

Regulatory proteins of F1F0-ATPase: role of ATPase inhibitor

An intrinsic ATPase inhibitor inhibits the ATP-hydrolyzing activity of mitochondrial F1F0-ATPase and is released from its binding site on the enzyme upon energization of mitochondrial membranes to allow phosphorylation of ADP. The mitochondrial activity to synthesize ATP is not influenced by the absence of the inhibitor protein. The enzyme activity to hydrolyze ATP is induced by dissipation of the membrane potential in the absence of the inhibitor. Thus, the inhibitor is not responsible for oxidative phosphorylation, but acts only to inhibit ATP hydrolysis by F1F0-ATPase upon deenergization of mitochondrial membranes. The inhibitor protein forms a regulatory complex with two stabilizing factors, 9K and 15K proteins, which facilitate the binding of the inhibitor to F1F0-ATPase and stabilize the resultant inactivated enzyme. The 9K protein, having a sequence very similar to the inhibitor, binds directly to F1 in a manner similar to the inhibitor. The 15K protein binds to the F0 part and holds the inhibitor and the 9K protein on F1F0-ATPase even when one of them is detached from the F1 part.

Azide as a probe of co-operative interactions in the mitochondrial F1-ATPase

(1) The hydrolytic activity of the isolated mitochondrial ATPase (F1) is strongly inhibited by azide. However, at very low ATP concentration (1 microM or less), no inhibition by azide is observed. (2) The azide-insensitive ATPase activity represents a high-affinity, low-capacity mode of turnover of F1. This is identified with the low Km, low Vmax component seen in steady-state kinetic studies in the absence of azide. (3) The azide-insensitive ATPase activity shows simple Michaelis-Menten kinetics, with Km = 3.2 microM, and Vmax = 1.1 mumol/min per mg (6 s-1). It is unaffected by anions such as sulphite, or by increasing pH in the range 7 to 8, both of which stimulate the maximal activity of F1. (4) Both the azide-insensitive and azide-sensitive components of F1-ATPase activity are equally inhibited by labelling the enzyme with 7-chloro-4-nitrobenzofurazan, by binding the natural inhibitor protein, or by cold denaturation of the enzyme. (5) It is concluded that azide-insensitive ATP hydrolysis represents catalysis by F1 involving a single catalytic site, and that azide acts by abolishing intersubunit cooperativity between the three catalytic sites of F1. Azide-sensitivity is thus a useful probe for events which affect the active site of F1 directly.

ATP synthases--structure of the F1-moiety and its relationship to function and mechanism

A great deal of progress has been made in understanding both the structure and the mechanism of F1-ATPase. The primary structure is now fully known for at least five species. Sequence comparison between chloroplast, photobacteria, aerobic bacteria, and mitochondrial representatives allow us to infer more general functional relationships and evolutionary trends. Although the F1 moiety is the most studied segment of the H+-ATPase complex, there is not a full understanding of the mechanism and regulation of its hydrolytic activity. The beta subunit is now known to contain one and probably two nucleotide binding domains, one of which is believed to be a catalytic site. Recently, two similar models have been proposed to attempt to describe the "active" part of the beta subunits. These models are mainly an attempt to use the structure of adenylate kinase to represent a more general working model for nucleotide binding phosphotransferases. Labelling experiments seem to indicate that several critical residues outside the region described by the "adenylate kinase" part of this model are also actively involved in the ATPase activity. New models will have to be introduced to include these regions. Finally, it seems that a consensus has been reached with regard to a broad acceptance of the asymmetric structure of the F1-moiety. In addition, recent experimental evidence points toward the presence of nonequivalent subunits to describe the functional activity of the F1-ATPase. A summary diagram of the conformational and binding states of the enzyme including the nonequivalent beta subunit is presented. Additional research is essential to establish the role of the minor subunits--and of the asymmetry they introduce in F1--on the physiological function of the enzyme.

Evidence from immunological studies of structure-mechanism relationship of F1 and F1F0

Monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies directed against peptides of F1-ATPase of F1F0-ATPase synthase provide new and efficient tools to study structure-function relationships and mechanisms of such complex membrane enzymes. This review summarizes the main results obtained using this approach. Antibodies have permitted the determination of the nature of subunits involved in the complex, their stoichiometry, their organization, neighboring interactions, and vectorial distribution within or on either face of the membrane. Moreover, in a few cases, amino acid sequences exposed on a face of the membrane or buried inside the complex have been identified. Antibodies are very useful for detecting the role of each subunit, especially for those subunits which appear to have no direct involvement in the catalytic mechanism. Concerning the mechanisms, the availability of monoclonal antibodies which inhibit (or activate) ATP hydrolysis or ATP synthesis, which modify nucleotide binding or regulation of activities, which detect specific conformations, etc. brings many new ways of understanding the precise functions. The specific recognition by monoclonal antibodies on the beta subunit of epitopes in the proximity of, or in the catalytic site, gives information on this site. The use of anti-alpha monoclonal antibodies has shown asymmetry of alpha in the complex as already shown for beta. In addition, the involvement of alpha with respect to nucleotide site cooperativity has been detected. Finally, the formation of F1F0-antibody complexes of various masses, seems to exclude the functional rotation of F1 around F0 during catalysis.

The mitochondrial ATP synthase inhibitor protein binds near the C-terminus of the F1 beta-subunit

The specific, mitochondrial ATP synthase protein (IF1) was covalently cross-linked to its binding site on the catalytic sector of the enzyme (F1-ATPase). The cross-linked complex was selectively cleaved, leaving IF1 intact to facilitate the subsequent purification of the F1 fragment to which IF1 was cross-linked. This fragment was identified by sequence analysis as comprising residues 394-459 on the F1 beta-subunit, near the C-terminus. This finding is discussed in the light of secondary structure predictions for both IF1 and the F1 beta-subunit, and sequence homologies between mitochondrial and other ATP synthases.