On the nature of cysteine coordination to CuA in cytochrome c oxidase

A physical chemist's expedition to explore the world of membrane proteins

Despite growing up amid humble surroundings, I ended up receiving an excellent education at the University of California at Berkeley and postdoctoral training at Harvard. My academic career at Caltech was shaped by serendipity, inspirational colleagues, and a stimulating research environment, as well as smart, motivated students and postdocs who were willing to join my search for molecular understanding of complex biological systems. From chemical physics I allowed my research to evolve, beginning with the application of NMR to investigate the base stacking of nucleic acid bases in solution, the dynamic structure of membranes, and culminating with the use of various forms of spectroscopy to elucidate the structure and function of membrane proteins and the early kinetic events in protein folding. The journey was a biased random walk driven by my own intellectual curiosity and instincts and by the pace at which I learned biochemistry from my students and postdocs, my colleagues, and the literature and through osmosis during seminars and scientific meetings.

Cytochrome c oxidase: chemistry of a molecular machine

The plethora of proposed chemical models attempting to explain the proton pumping reactions catalyzed by the CcO complex, especially the number of recent models, makes it clear that the problem is far from solved. Although we have not discussed all of the models proposed to date, we have described some of the more detailed models in order to illustrate the theoretical concepts introduced at the beginning of this section on proton pumping as well as to illustrate the rich possibilities available for effecting proton pumping. It is clear that proton pumping is effected by conformational changes induced by oxidation/reduction of the various redox centers in the CcO complex. It is for this reason that the CcO complex is called a redox-linked proton pump. The conformational changes of the proton pump cycle are usually envisioned to be some sort of ligand-exchange reaction arising from unstable geometries upon oxidation/reduction of the various redox centers. However, simple geometrical rearrangements, as in the Babcock and Mitchell models are also possible. In any model, however, hydrogen bonds must be broken and reformed due to conformational changes that result from oxidation/reduction of the linkage site during enzyme turnover. Perhaps the most important point emphasized in this discussion, however, is the fact that proton pumping is a directed process and it is electron and proton gating mechanisms that drive the proton pump cycle in the forward direction. Since many of the models discussed above lack effective electron and/or proton gating, it is clear that the major difficulty in developing a viable chemical model is not formulating a cyclic set of protein conformational changes effecting proton pumping (redox linkage) but rather constructing the model with a set of physical constraints so that the proposed cycle proceeds efficiently as postulated. In our discussion of these models, we have not been too concerned about which electron of the catalytic cycle was entering the site of linkage, but merely whether an ET to the binuclear center played a role. However, redox linkage only occurs if ET to the activated binuclear center is coupled to the proton pump. Since all of the models of proton pumping presented here, with the exception of the Rousseau expanded model and the Wikström model, have a maximum stoichiometry of 1 H+/e-, they inadequately explain the 2 H+/e- ratio for the third and fourth electrons of the dioxygen reduction cycle (see Section V.B). One way of interpreting this shortfall of protons is that the remaining protons are pumped by an as yet undefined indirectly coupled mechanism. In this scenario, the site of linkage could be coupled to the pumping of one proton in a direct fashion and one proton in an indirect fashion for a given electron. For a long time, it was assumed that at least some elements of such an indirect mechanism reside in subunit III. While recent evidence argues against the involvement of subunit III in the proton pump, subunit III may still participate in a regulatory and/or structural capacity (Section II.E). Attention has now focused on subunits I and II in the search for residues intimately involved in the proton pump mechanism and/or as part of a proton channel. In particular, the role of some of the highly conserved residues of helix VIII of subunit I are currently being studied by site directed mutagenesis. In our opinion, any model that invokes heme alpha 3 or CuB as the site of linkage must propose a very effective means by which the presumedly fast uncoupling ET to the dioxygen intermediates is prevented. It is difficult to imagine that ET over the short distance from heme alpha 3 or CuB to the dioxygen intermediate requires more than 1 ns. In addition, we expect the conformational changes of the proton pump to require much more than 1 ns (see Section V.B).

Linear-dichroic infrared spectral analysis of Cu(I)-homocysteine complex

The interaction between homocysteine (HCysSH) and Cu(II) leads to the formation of a yellow complex [Cu(I)(HCysS-SCysH)2]Cl (1) after redox processes in the Cu(II)-homocysteine system resulting in dimerization of the ligand and formation of a mononuclear Cu(I) complex with two dimers. The structure of (1) was obtained by IR-LD spectral analysis of a solid amorphous sample oriented in nematic liquid crystal medium. The original technique for orientation developed here and the polarized IR spectra thus obtained, permit the determination of the complexation sites and coordination mode of diamagnetic complexes. In the complex (1), Cu(I) is coordinated through the two O atoms of one COO- group of each of the ligands and the metal ion coordination sphere represents a distorted tetrahedron.

Cell biology and molecular basis of denitrification

Denitrification is a distinct means of energy conservation, making use of N oxides as terminal electron acceptors for cellular bioenergetics under anaerobic, microaerophilic, and occasionally aerobic conditions. The process is an essential branch of the global N cycle, reversing dinitrogen fixation, and is associated with chemolithotrophic, phototrophic, diazotrophic, or organotrophic metabolism but generally not with obligately anaerobic life. Discovered more than a century ago and believed to be exclusively a bacterial trait, denitrification has now been found in halophilic and hyperthermophilic archaea and in the mitochondria of fungi, raising evolutionarily intriguing vistas. Important advances in the biochemical characterization of denitrification and the underlying genetics have been achieved with Pseudomonas stutzeri, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Paracoccus denitrificans, Ralstonia eutropha, and Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Pseudomonads represent one of the largest assemblies of the denitrifying bacteria within a single genus, favoring their use as model organisms. Around 50 genes are required within a single bacterium to encode the core structures of the denitrification apparatus. Much of the denitrification process of gram-negative bacteria has been found confined to the periplasm, whereas the topology and enzymology of the gram-positive bacteria are less well established. The activation and enzymatic transformation of N oxides is based on the redox chemistry of Fe, Cu, and Mo. Biochemical breakthroughs have included the X-ray structures of the two types of respiratory nitrite reductases and the isolation of the novel enzymes nitric oxide reductase and nitrous oxide reductase, as well as their structural characterization by indirect spectroscopic means. This revealed unexpected relationships among denitrification enzymes and respiratory oxygen reductases. Denitrification is intimately related to fundamental cellular processes that include primary and secondary transport, protein translocation, cytochrome c biogenesis, anaerobic gene regulation, metalloprotein assembly, and the biosynthesis of the cofactors molybdopterin and heme D1. An important class of regulators for the anaerobic expression of the denitrification apparatus are transcription factors of the greater FNR family. Nitrate and nitric oxide, in addition to being respiratory substrates, have been identified as signaling molecules for the induction of distinct N oxide-metabolizing enzymes.

Identification of essential amino acids within the proposed CuA binding site in subunit II of Cytochrome c oxidase

To explore the nature of proposed ligands to the CuA center in cytochrome c oxidase, site-directed mutagenesis has been initiated in subunit II of the enzyme. Mutations were introduced into the mitochondrial gene from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae by high velocity microprojectile bombardment. A variety of single amino acid substitutions at each of the proposed cysteine and histidine ligands (His-161, Cys-196, Cys-200, and His-204 in the bovine numbering scheme), as well as at the conserved Met-207, all result in yeast which fails to grow on ethanol/glycerol medium. Similarly, all possible paired exchange Cys,His and Cys,Met mutants show the same phenotype. Furthermore, protein stability is severely reduced as evidenced by both the absence of an absorbance maximum at 600 nm in the spectra of mutant cells and the underaccumulation of subunit II, as observed by immunolabeling of mitochondrial extracts. In the same area of the protein, a variety of amino acid substitutions at one of the carboxylates previously implicated in binding cytochrome c, Glu-198, allow (reduced) growth on ethanol/glycerol medium, with normal intracellular levels of protein. These results suggest that a precise folding environment of the CuA site within subunit II is essential for assembly or stable accumulation of cytochrome c oxidase in yeast.

Spectroscopic and mutagenesis studies on the CuA centre from the cytochrome-c oxidase complex of Paracoccus denitrificans

Cytochrome-c oxidase contains an unusual copper centre (CuA) located in subunit II. This centre mediates one-electron transfer from cytochrome c to low-spin heme a. Recent spectroscopic and biochemical studies have shown that this centre is a valence delocalised dinuclear [Cu(+1.5)-Cu(+1.5)] centre. We have measured the absorption, EPR and variable-temperature magnetic circular dichroism spectra of the CuA-binding domain isolated from Paracoccus denitrificans cytochrome aa3. The EPR spectrum showed the following signals: gparallel = 2.18; gperpendicular = 2.03. gparallel exhibited a seven-line hyperfine splitting pattern, with an intensity ratio showing that the single unpaired electron interacted equally with two copper nuclei. The magnetic circular dichroism spectrum was identical to those from CuA in bovine heart cytochrome-c oxidase and centre A of nitrous-oxide reductase, showing the close structural similarity between the three centres. To identify the ligands of CuA, all the conserved putative ligands in the P. denitrificans CuA domain were substituted. Only five residues, Cys244, Cys248, His209, His252, and Met255, were required for correct assembly of the CuA centre. Replacement of Met255 caused protein misfolding. Hence, methionine may have a structural role for the folding of the protein rather than being a CuA ligand. Given that both copper ions must have identical coordination geometries, the number of possible structures is limited. Two models are proposed: one involves the thiolate side-chains of Cys244 and Cys248 bridging a pair of copper ions with one histidine coordinating each copper ion, and the other has terminal ligation of each copper ion by one cysteine and one histidine residue. In both models, the metal-metal distance can be sufficiently short to permit direct d-orbital overlap of the copper ions. The magnetic circular dichroism transitions at 475 nm and 525 nm are assigned to thiolate-to-copper charge-transfer processes polarised perpendicular to one another, although the magnetic circular dichroism intensities show that the excited states were heavily mixed with copper d-orbitals. These intensities can be interpreted in the thiolate bridged model in terms of transitions within a Cu2(SR)2 rhomb. In the model involving terminal cysteine ligation, exciton coupling of two thiolate-to-copper charge-transfer transitions of similar energy, polarised along the Cu-S bonds, would contribute two transitions perpendicular to one another. This requires that the cysteine ligands have a cis orientation relative to one another.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Structure and function of a molecular machine: cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c is responsible for over 90% of the dioxygen consumption in the living cell and contributes to the build-up of a proton electrochemical gradient derived by the vectorial transfer of electrons between cytochrome c and molecular oxygen. The metal ions found in cytochrome oxidases play a crucial role in these processes and have been extensively studied. In this review we present and discuss some of the relevant spectroscopic and kinetic properties of the prosthetic groups of cytochrome c oxidase.

Design of a ruthenium-cytochrome c derivative to measure electron transfer to the initial acceptor in cytochrome c oxidase

A ruthenium-labeled cytochrome c derivative was prepared to meet two design criteria: the ruthenium group must transfer an electron rapidly to the heme group, but not alter the interaction with cytochrome c oxidase. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to replace His39 on the backside of yeast C102T iso-1-cytochrome c with a cysteine residue, and the single sulfhydryl group was labeled with (4-bromomethyl-4' methylbipyridine) (bis-bipyridine)ruthenium(II) to form Ru-39-cytochrome c (cyt c). There is an efficient pathway for electron transfer from the ruthenium group to the heme group of Ru-39-cyt c comprising 13 covalent bonds and one hydrogen bond. Electron transfer from the excited state Ru(II*) to ferric heme c occurred with a rate constant of (6.0 +/- 2.0) x 10(5) s-1, followed by electron transfer from ferrous heme c to Ru(III) with a rate constant of (1.0 +/- 0.2) x 10(6) s-1. Laser excitation of a complex between Ru-39-cyt c and beef cytochrome c oxidase in low ionic strength buffer (5 mM phosphate, pH7) resulted in electron transfer from photoreduced heme c to CuA with a rate constant of (6 +/- 2) x 10(4) s-1, followed by electron transfer from CuA to heme a with a rate constant of (1.8 +/- 0.3) x 10(4) s-1. Increasing the ionic strength to 100 mM leads to bimolecular kinetics as the complex is dissociated. The second-order rate constant is (2.5 +/- 0.4) x 10(7) M-1s-1 at 230 mM ionic strength, nearly the same as that of wild-type iso-1-cytochrome c.

Metal-metal bonding in biology: EXAFS evidence for a 2.5 A copper-copper bond in the CuA center of cytochrome oxidase

Evidence for a direct Cu-Cu bond in the CuA center of cytochrome oxidase is reported. Simulation of the X-ray absorption spectrum of a recombinant CuA-binding domain of Bacillus subtilis cytochrome oxidase, and comparison with a structurally characterized directly-bonding Cu(1.5) ... Cu(1.5) inorganic complex, suggests that a Cu-Cu interaction of 2.5 +/- 0.1 A together with a short 2.2 A Cu-S interaction may be present in the CuA site. In light of these data, previous interpretations of the EXAFS of a number of cytochrome oxidase and nitrous oxide reductase enzymes which modeled the 2.6 A interaction as a long Cu-S(methionine) bond are possibly incorrect. A structural model based on the new data is presented which suggests that the CuA sites in cytochrome oxidase and N2O reductase are likely composed of a pair of modified type 1 copper centers with one histidine, one cysteine, and one weakly bound ligand (Met and/or Gln) joined by a Cu-Cu bond.

ENDOR and ESEEM studies of cytochrome c oxidase: evidence for exchangeable protons at the CuA site

Electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) and electron spin echo envelope modulation (ESEEM) spectroscopies were used to study whether protons in the immediate protein environment around CuA in cytochrome c oxidase are susceptible to solvent exchange. The enzyme was incubated in buffered D2O under resting or turnover conditions for 90 min and then frozen to quench the hydrogen/deuterium-exchange process. ENDOR spectra of the deuterated sample were essentially identical to those of control samples. The ESEEM spectra, however, provided a clear indication of the introduction of deuterium into the CuA environment following incubation in buffered D2O. The extent of deuterium incorporation was not affected by enzyme turnover. An analysis of the ESEEM data indicated that water is in reasonably close proximity to the CuA site, but not in the immediate coordination sphere of the metal(s). We estimate a minimum distance of 5.4 A between the CuA center and the protein/water interface. This relatively short surface separation distance is consistent with the role of CuA as the immediate oxidant of cytochrome c in the cytochrome oxidase (Hill, B. C. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 2219-2226).

The nature of the CuA center in cytochrome c oxidase

The merits of the suggestion that CuA in cytochrome oxidase is a mixed-valence binuclear site is reviewed on the basis of recent analytical and spectroscopic studies. First an alternative mononuclear model is presented. Metal analyses indicate that homogeneous oxidase preparations with high activity contain 3Cu/2Fe. Multifrequency EPR measurements demonstrate a close similarity with a copper site in nitrous oxide reductase, and this is also supported by optical and MCD spectra. Strong evidence for a binuclear site is provided by a 7-line hyperfine structure in the EPR spectra of both enzymes. A binuclear model consistent with amino acid sequence data can be formulated.

X-ray absorption spectroscopy of oriented cytochrome oxidase

The polarized X-ray absorption spectra of the copper, iron and zinc sites of mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase in oriented membrane multilayers have been examined. The copper X-ray absorption edge spectra indicate the presence of a tetragonal copper, which we assign as CuB, oriented with the long axis approximately orthogonal to the membrane normal. We have also detected the presence of a relatively long (2.6 A) Cu-S or Cu-Cl interaction, which we assign to a copper-thioether (probably Met210) coordination at the CuA site, with the bond oriented along the membrane normal. The coordination of the zinc, the iron and the CuB heme a3 binuclear site are discussed.

Stoichiometry and redox behaviour of metals in cytochrome-c oxidase

The early observation of extra copper in preparations of cytochrome-c oxidase has recently lead to a renewed interest in its stoichiometry and possible redox function. In various, pure preparations (heme A contents close to the theoretical value of 9.79 nmol/mg protein for the 13-subunit bovine enzyme) protein-related metal stoichiometries of 3 Cu, 2 Fe, 1 Zn, 1 Mg/monomer with M(r) 204266 were determined. Despite the presence of five potential redox metal ions, reductive and reoxidative titrations indicate the presence of only four one-electron-accepting/donating species in the ligand-free enzyme. Participation of two copper ions in a binuclear copper site acting as one-electron acceptor may explain both the observed copper stoichiometry and the redox behaviour. The homology of the C-terminal sequence of subunit II with one of the copper-binding sites in nitrous-oxide reductases provides possible ligands for complexing two copper ions in a binuclear center.

A comparative EPR investigation of the multicopper proteins nitrous-oxide reductase and cytochrome c oxidase

The multicopper proteins, nitrous-oxide reductase (N2OR) and cytochrome c oxidase (COX), were investigated by EPR spectroscopy at microwave frequencies 2.4-35 GHz. Our results support a Cu-Cu interaction in COX and N2OR. At least 10 lines in the 2.7-GHz, 12 lines in the 4.6-GHz and 14 lines in the 9.2 GHz spectra were resolved for N2OR. Eight copper lines at 2.7 GHz, about nine lines at 4.6 GHz and about six lines at 9.2 GHz were resolved for COX. Simulations of the EPR spectra were consistent with most of the resonances of the multiline spectra, including regions in the center of the spectra where overlap of the three seven-line patterns is proposed. These simulations indicated that Cu-Cu interaction, in a mixed-valence [Cu(1.5) ... Cu(1.5)], S = 1/2 site is consistent with, if not proof of, the unusual spectral features observed for N2OR and COX.

Derived amino acid sequences of the nosZ gene (respiratory N2O reductase) from Alcaligenes eutrophus, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Pseudomonas stutzeri reveal potential copper-binding residues. Implications for the CuA site of N2O reductase and cytochrome-c oxidase

The nosZ genes encoding the multicopper enzyme nitrous oxide reductase of Alcaligenes eutrophus H16 and the type strain of Pseudomonas aeruginosa were cloned and sequenced for structural comparison of their gene products with the homologous product of the nosZ gene from Pseudomonas stutzeri [Viebrock, A. & Zumft, W. G. (1988) J. Bacteriol. 170, 4658-4668] and the subunit II of cytochrome-c oxidase (COII). Both types of enzymes possess the CuA binding site. The nosZ genes were identified in cosmid libraries by hybridization with an internal 1.22-kb PstI fragment (NS220) of nosZ from P. stutzeri. The derived amino acid sequences indicate unprocessed gene products of 70084 Da (A. eutrophus) and 70695 Da (P. aeruginosa). The N-terminal sequences of the NosZ proteins have the characteristics of signal peptides for transport. A homologous domain, extending over at least 50 residues, is shared among the three derived NosZ sequences and the CuA binding region of 32 COII sequences. Only three out of nine cysteine residues of the NosZ protein (P. stutzeri) are invariant. Cys618 and Cys622 are assigned to a binuclear center, A, which is thought to represent the CuA site of NosZ and is located close to the C terminus. Two conserved histidines, one methionine, one aspartate, one valine and two aromatic residues are also part of the CuA consensus sequence, which is the domain homologous between the two enzymes. The CuA consensus sequence, however, lacks four strictly conserved residues present in all COII sequences. Cys165 is likely to be a ligand of a second binuclear center, Z, for which we assume mainly histidine coordination. Of 23 histidine residues in NosZ (P. stutzeri), 14 are invariant, 7 of which are in regions with a degree of conservation well above the 50% positional identity between the Alcaligenes and Pseudomonas sequences. Conserved tryptophan residues are located close to several potential copper ligands. Trp615 may contribute to the observed quenching of fluorescence when the CuA site is occupied.

Oxygen activation and the conservation of energy in cell respiration

Many of the membrane-associated oxidases that catalyse respiratory reduction of O2 to water simultaneously couple this exergonic reaction to the translocation of protons across the inner mitochondrial membrane, or the cell membrane in prokaryotes, a process by which metabolic energy is conserved for subsequent synthesis of ATP. The molecular mechanism of O2 reduction and its linkage to H+ translocation are now emerging. The bimetallic haem iron-copper reaction centre in this family of enzymes is the critical structure for catalysis of both these processes.

Properties of the two terminal oxidases of Escherichia coli

Proton translocation coupled to oxidation of ubiquinol by O2 was studied in spheroplasts of two mutant strains of Escherichia coli, one of which expresses cytochrome d, but not cytochrome bo, and the other expressing only the latter. O2 pulse experiments revealed that cytochrome d catalyzes separation of the protons and electrons of ubiquinol oxidation but is not a proton pump. In contrast, cytochrome bo functions as a proton pump in addition to separating the charges of quinol oxidation. E. coli membranes and isolated cytochrome bo lack the CuA center typical of cytochrome c oxidase, and the isolated enzyme contains only 1Cu/2Fe. Optical spectra indicate that high-spin heme o contributes less than 10% to the reduced minus oxidized 560-nm band of the enzyme. Pyridine hemochrome spectra suggest that the hemes of cytochrome bo are not protohemes. Proteoliposomes with cytochrome bo exhibited good respiratory control, but H+/e- during quinol oxidation was only 0.3-0.7. This was attributed to an "inside out" orientation of a significant fraction of the enzyme. Possible metabolic benefits of expressing both cytochromes bo and d in E. coli are discussed.

Cytochrome c oxidase metal centers: location and function

Cytochrome c oxidase of Paracoccus denitrificans is spectroscopically and functionally very similar to the mammalian enzyme. However, it has a very much simpler quaternary structure, consisting of only three subunits instead of the 13 of the bovine enzyme. The known primary structure of the Paracoccus denitrificans subunits, the knowledge of a large number of sequences from other species, and data on the controlled proteolytic digestion of the enzyme allow structural restrictions to be placed on the models describing the binding of the active metal centers to the polypeptide structure.

RNA sequence and the nature of the CuA-binding site in cytochrome c oxidase

For cytochrome c oxidase subunit II (COXII), DNA and protein sequences suggest that Met-207 (bovine numbering) is conserved in all species except plants. Sequencing of plant mitochondrial COXII mRNAs now indicates that Met-207 is also conserved among plants as a result of a C-to-U type of RNA editing. Considering the strict evolutionary conservation of Met-207 and the homology of COXII to type I (blue) copper proteins and nitrous oxide reductase, we propose a model in which Met-207 is associated with the CuA-binding site (along with Cys-196, Cys-200 and His-204) and plays a role in determining its reduction potential and stability.

Heat treatment of cytochrome c oxidase perturbs the CuA site and affects proton pumping behavior

It has been previously reported that mild heat treatment (43 degrees C for ca. 60 min) abolishes the proton pumping activity of cytochrome c oxidase while leaving the oxidase activity and cytochromes a and a3 unperturbed [Sone, N., & Nicholls, P. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 6550-6554]. We herein describe the effects of this heat treatment on the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and optical absorption signatures of the redox-active metal centers in the enzyme. We find that heat treatment of the oxidized enzyme causes a local structural perturbation at the CuA site. After heat treatment, the enzyme sample contains three subpopulations, each of which has a different structure at CuA. These include (i) native CuA, (ii) a type 2 copper species similar to the one produced by chemical modification by p-(hydroxymercuri)benzoate (pHMB) [Gelles, J., & Chan, S. I. (1985) Biochemistry 24, 3963-3972], and (iii) a novel type 1 copper species. In addition to changes at the CuA site, we find that heat treatment results in accelerated cyanide binding and the removal of subunit III. If the cytochrome c oxidase is heat treated while fully reduced, none of these changes are observed except for subunit III depletion. Furthermore, partial (CO mixed-valence derivative) reduction of the enzyme as well as ligand binding to cytochrome a3 also protects the enzyme against the heat-induced changes, indicating that the oxygen binding site plays a role in stabilizing the CuA site against structural perturbations.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)