Structure-Function Studies on Bacteriorhodopsin

Expression systems for bovine rhodopsin: a review of the progress made in the Khorana laboratory

Here I will review the development of gene expression systems for production of bovine rhodopsin in the Khorana laboratory with particular focus on stable mammalian cell lines made using human embryonic kidney cells (HEK293S). The synthesis of a gene encoding bovine rhodopsin was completed in 1986. This gene was expertly designed with the built-in capacity for DNA duplex cassette replacement mutagenesis which made site-directed mutagenesis relatively straightforward. Intense effort was expended over several years in order to identify a gene expression system capable of producing rhodopsin in milligram amounts as required for biophysical studies. Mammalian expression systems, both transient and stable, were found to be the most favourable based on several criteria including receptor expression levels, correct folding and post translational processing, and capacity for purification of fully functional receptor. Transient expression using COS-1 cells was preferred for routine small-scale production of rhodopsin mutants, while HEK293S stable cell lines were used when milligram amounts of rhodopsin mutants were needed; for example, when conducting NMR studies.

The Evolutionary Kaleidoscope of Rhodopsins

Rhodopsins are widely distributed across all domains of life where they perform a plethora of functions through the conversion of electromagnetic radiation into physicochemical signals. As a result of an extensive survey of available genomic and metagenomic sequencing data, we reported the existence of novel clades and exotic sequence motifs scattered throughout the evolutionary radiations of both Type-1 and Type-3 rhodopsins that will likely enlarge the optogenetics toolbox. We expanded the typical rhodopsin blueprint by showing that a highly conserved and functionally important arginine residue (i.e., Arg82) was substituted multiple times during evolution by an extensive amino acid spectrum. We proposed the umbrella term Alt-rhodopsins (AltRs) for all such proteins that departed Arg82 orthodoxy. Some AltRs formed novel clades in the rhodopsin phylogeny and were found in giant viruses. Some newly uncovered AltRs were phylogenetically close to heliorhodopsins, which allowed a closer examination of the phylogenetic border between Type-1 rhodopsins and heliorhodopsins. Comprehensive phylogenetic trees and ancestral sequence reconstructions allowed us to advance the hypothesis that proto-heliorhodopsins were a eukaryotic innovation before their subsequent diversification into the extant Type-3 rhodopsins. IMPORTANCE The rhodopsin scaffold is remarkably versatile and widespread, coupling light availability to energy production and other light-dependent cellular responses with minor alterations to critical residues. We described an unprecedented spectrum of substitutions at one of the most conserved amino acids in the rhodopsin fold, Arg82. We denoted such phylogenetically diverse rhodopsins with the umbrella name Alt-rhodopsins (AltR) and described a distinct branch of AltRs in giant viruses. Intriguingly, some AltRs were the closest phylogenetic neighbors to Heliorhodopsins (HeRs) whose origins have remained enigmatic. Our analyses of HeR origins in the light of AltRs led us to posit a most unusual evolutionary trajectory that suggested a eukaryotic origin for HeRs before their diversification in prokaryotes.

Synthetic Cell as a Platform for Understanding Membrane-Membrane Interactions

In the pursuit of understanding life, model membranes made of phospholipids were envisaged decades ago as a platform for the bottom-up study of biological processes. Micron-sized lipid vesicles have gained great acceptance as their bilayer membrane resembles the natural cell membrane. Important biological events involving membranes, such as membrane protein insertion, membrane fusion, and intercellular communication, will be highlighted in this review with recent research updates. We will first review different lipid bilayer platforms used for incorporation of integral membrane proteins and challenges associated with their functional reconstitution. We next discuss different methods for reconstitution of membrane fusion and compare their fusion efficiency. Lastly, we will highlight the importance and challenges of intercellular communication between synthetic cells and synthetic cells-to-natural cells. We will summarize the review by highlighting the challenges and opportunities associated with studying membrane-membrane interactions and possible future research directions.

An Experimental and Molecular Dynamics Study of Red Fluorescent Protein mCherry in Novel Aqueous Amino Acid Ionic Liquids

The search for biocompatible ionic liquids (ILs) with novel biochemical and biomedical applications has recently gained greater attention. In this report, we characterize the effects of two novel amino acid-based aqueous ILs composed of tetramethylguanidinium (TMG) and amino acids on the structure and stability of a widely used red fluorescent protein (mCherry). Our experimental data shows that while the aspartic acid-based IL (TMGAsp) has effects similar to previously studied conventional ILs (BMIBF4, EMIAc, and TMGAc), the alanine-based IL (TMGAla) has a much stronger destabilization effect on the protein structure. Addition of 0.30 M TMGAla to mCherry decreases the unfolding temperature from 83 to 60 °C. Even at 25 °C, TMGAla results in a blue shift of the mCherry absorbance and fluorescence peaks and an increased Stokes shift. Molecular dynamics simulations show that the chromophore conformation and its interaction with mCherry with TMGAla are changed relative to those with TMGAsp or in the absence of ILs. Protein-ILs contact analysis indicates that the mCherry-Asp interactions are hydrophilic but the (fewer) mCherry-Ala interactions are more hydrophobic and may modulate the TMG interaction with the protein. Hence, the anion hydrophobicity may explain the special TMGAla destabilization of mCherry.

The observation of evolutionary interaction pattern pairs in membrane proteins

Background

Over the last two decades, many approaches have been developed in bioinformatics that aim at one of the most promising, yet unsolved problems in modern life sciences - prediction of structural features of a protein. Such tasks addressed to transmembrane protein structures provide valuable knowledge about their three-dimensional structure. For this reason, the analysis of membrane proteins is essential in genomic and proteomic-wide investigations. Thus, many in-silico approaches have been utilized extensively to gain crucial advances in understanding membrane protein structures and functions.

Results

It turned out that amino acid covariation within interacting sequence parts, extracted from a evolutionary sequence record of α-helical membrane proteins, can be used for structure prediction. In a recent study we discussed the significance of short membrane sequence motifs widely present in nature that act as stabilizing ’building blocks’ during protein folding and in retaining the three-dimensional fold. In this work, we used motif data to define evolutionary interaction pattern pairs. These were obtained from different pattern alignments and were used to evaluate which coupling mechanisms the evolution provides. It can be shown that short interaction patterns of homologous sequence records are membrane protein family-specific signatures. These signatures can provide valuable information for structure prediction and protein classification. The results indicate a good agreement with recent studies.

Conclusions

Generally, it can be shown how the evolution contributes to realize covariation within discriminative interaction patterns to maintain structure and function. This points to their general importance for α-helical membrane protein structure formation and interaction mediation. In the process, no fundamentally energetic approaches of previous published works are considered. The low-cost rapid computational methods postulated in this work provides valuable information to classify unknown α-helical transmembrane proteins and to determine their structural similarity.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12900-015-0033-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Role of a helix B lysine residue in the photoactive site in channelrhodopsins

In most studied microbial rhodopsins two conserved carboxylic acid residues (the homologs of Asp-85 and Asp-212 in bacteriorhodopsin) and an arginine residue (the homolog of Arg-82) form a complex counterion to the protonated retinylidene Schiff base, and neutralization of the negatively charged carboxylates causes red shifts of the absorption maximum. In contrast, the corresponding neutralizing mutations in some relatively low-efficiency channelrhodopsins (ChRs) result in blue shifts. These ChRs do not contain a lysine residue in the second helix, conserved in higher efficiency ChRs (Lys-132 in the crystallized ChR chimera). By action spectroscopy of photoinduced channel currents in HEK293 cells and absorption spectroscopy of detergent-purified pigments, we found that in tested ChRs the Lys-132 homolog controls the direction of spectral shifts in the mutants of the photoactive site carboxylic acid residues. Analysis of double mutants shows that red spectral shifts occur when this Lys is present, whether naturally or by mutagenesis, and blue shifts occur when it is replaced with a neutral residue. A neutralizing mutation of the Lys-132 homolog alone caused a red spectral shift in high-efficiency ChRs, whereas its introduction into low-efficiency ChR1 from Chlamydomonas augustae (CaChR1) caused a blue shift. Taking into account that the effective charge of the carboxylic acid residues is a key factor in microbial rhodopsin spectral tuning, these findings suggest that the Lys-132 homolog modulates their pKa values. On the other hand, mutation of the Arg-82 homolog that fulfills this role in bacteriorhodopsin caused minimal spectral changes in the tested ChRs. Titration revealed that the pKa of the Asp-85 homolog in CaChR1 lies in the alkaline region unlike in most studied microbial rhodopsins, but is substantially decreased by introduction of a Lys-132 homolog or neutralizing mutation of the Asp-212 homolog. In the three ChRs tested the Lys-132 homolog also alters channel current kinetics.

Synthetic physiology strategies for adapting tools from nature for genetically targeted control of fast biological processes

The life and operation of cells involve many physiological processes that take place over fast timescales of milliseconds to minutes. Genetically encoded technologies for driving or suppressing specific fast physiological processes in intact cells, perhaps embedded within intact tissues in living organisms, are critical for the ability to understand how these physiological processes contribute to emergent cellular and organismal functions and behaviors. Such "synthetic physiology" tools are often incredibly complex molecular machines, in part because they must operate at high speeds, without causing side effects. We here explore how synthetic physiology molecules can be identified and deployed in cells, and how the physiology of these molecules in cellular contexts can be assessed and optimized. For concreteness, we discuss these methods in the context of the "optogenetic" light-gated ion channels and pumps that we have developed over the past few years as synthetic physiology tools and widely disseminated for use in neuroscience for probing the role of specific brain cell types in neural computations, behaviors, and pathologies. We anticipate that some of the insights revealed here may be of general value for the field of synthetic physiology, as they raise issues that will be of importance for the development and use of high-performance, high-speed, side-effect free physiological control tools in heterologous expression systems.

Color-changing mutation in the E-F loop of proteorhodopsin

It is usually assumed that only amino acids located near the retinal chromophore are responsible for color tuning of rhodopsins. However, we recently found that replacement of Ala178 with Arg in the E-F loop of proteorhodopsin (PR), an archaeal-type rhodopsin in marine bacteria, shifts the lambda(max) from 525 to 545 nm at neutral pH [Yoshitsugu, M., Shibata, M., Ikeda, D., Furutani, Y., and Kandori, H. (2008) Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 47, 3923-3926]. Since the location of Ala178 is distant from the retinal chromophore (approximately 25 A), the molecular mechanism of the unusual mutation effect on color tuning is intriguing. Here we studied this mechanism by using additional mutations and some analytical methods. Introduction of Arg into the corresponding amino acid in bacteriorhodopsin (BR, M163R mutant) does not change the absorption spectra, indicating that the effect is specific to PR. Introduction of Arg into the A-B or C-D loop yields little (3 nm) or no color change, respectively. T177R and P180R mutants exhibited absorption spectra identical to that of the wild type, while N176R and S179R mutants exhibit lambda(max) values of 528 and 535 nm, respectively. Therefore, the observed color change is position-specific, being fully effective at position 178 and half-effective at position 179. Salt affects the absorption spectra of wild-type and A178R PR similarly. FTIR spectroscopy at 77 K indicated similar chromophore structures for wild-type and A178R PR, and A178R PR pumps protons normally. We infer that the E-F loop has a unique structure in PR and the mutation of Ala178 disrupts the structure that includes the transmembrane region, leading to the observed changes in color and pK(a).

The bacteriorhodopsin carboxyl-terminus contributes to proton recruitment and protein stability

We examined functional and structural roles for the bacteriorhodopsin (bR) carboxyl-terminus. The extramembranous and intracellular carboxyl-terminus was deleted by insertion of premature translation stop codons. Deletion of the carboxyl-terminus had no effect on purple membrane (PM) lattice dimensions, sheet size, or the electrogenic environment of the ground-state chromophore. Removal of the distal half of the carboxyl-terminus had no effect on light-activated proton pumping, however, truncation of the entire carboxyl-terminus accelerated the rates of M-state decay and proton uptake approximately 3.7-fold and severely distorted the kinetics of proton uptake. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and SDS denaturation demonstrated that removal of the carboxyl-terminus decreased protein stability. The DSC melting temperature was lowered by 6 degrees C and the calorimetric enthalpy reduced by 50% following removal of the carboxyl-terminus. Over the time range of milliseconds to hours at least 3 phases were required to describe the SDS denaturation kinetics for each bR construction. The fastest phases were indistinguishable for all bR's, and reflected PM solubilization. At pH 7.4, 20 degrees C, and in 0.3% SDS (w/v) the half-times of bR denaturation were 19.2 min for the wild-type, 12.0 min for the half-truncation and 3.6 min for the full-truncation. Taken together the results of this study suggest that the bR ground state exhibits two "domains" of stability: (1) a core chromophore binding pocket domain that is insensitive to carboxyl-terminal interactions and (2) the surrounding helical bundle whose contributions to protein stability and proton pumping are influenced by long-range interactions with the extramembranous carboxyl-terminus.

Backbone and side chain assignment strategies for multiply labeled membrane peptides and proteins in the solid state

We demonstrate that the SPECIFIC CP technique can be used to obtain heteronuclear correlation (HETCOR) spectra of peptide backbones with greater efficiency than conventional HETCOR methods. We show that similar design principles can be employed to achieve selective homonuclear polarization transfer mediated through dipolar or scalar couplings. Both approaches are demonstrated in a tripeptide with uniform 15N and 13C labeling, and with uniform 15N labeling and natural abundance 13C. In other applications, the high efficiency of the heteronuclear SPECIFIC CP transfer allows discrimination of single amide signals in the 248-residue membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin (bR). In particular, variations are detected in the ordering of the Ala81-Arg82 peptide bond among the photocycle intermediates of bR and SPECIFIC CP is used to correlate 15N and 13C signals from the three Val-Pro peptide bonds.

Magnetic resonance studies of the bacteriorhodopsin pump cycle

Active transport requires the alternation of substrate uptake and release with a switch in the access of the substrate binding site to the two sides of the membrane. Both the transfer and switch aspects of the photocycle have been subjects of magnetic resonance studies in bacteriorhodopsin. The results for ion transfer indicate that the Schiff base of the chromophore is hydrogen bonded before, during, and after its deprotonation. This suggests that the initial complex counterion of the Schiff base decomposes in such a way that the Schiff base carries its immediate hydrogen-bonding partner with it as it rotates during the first half of the photocycle. If so, bacteriorhodopsin acts as an inward-directed hydroxide pump rather than as an outward-directed proton pump. The studies of the access switch explore both protein-based and chromophore-based mechanisms. Combined with evidence from functional studies of mutants and other forms of spectroscopy, the results suggest that maintaining access to the extracellular side of the protein after photoisomerization involves twisting of the chromophore and that the decisive switch in access to the cytoplasmic side results from relaxation of the chromophore when the constraints on the Schiff base are released by decomposition of the complex counterion.

Physiological evidence for an interaction between helices II and XI in the melibiose carrier of Escherichia coli

The melibiose carrier from Escherichia coli is a cation-substrate cotransporter that catalyzes the accumulation of galactosides at the expense of H(+), Na(+), or Li(+) electrochemical gradients. Charged residues on transmembrane domains in the amino-terminal portion of this carrier play an important role in the recognition of cations, while the carboxyl portion of the protein seems to be important for sugar recognition. In the present study, we substituted Lys-377 on helix XI with Val. This mutant carrier, K377V, had reduced melibiose transport activity. We subsequently used this mutant for the isolation of functional second-site revertants. Revertant strains showed the additional substitutions of Val or Asn for Asp-59 (helix II), or Leu for Phe-20 (helix I). Isolation of revertant strains where both Lys-377 and Asp-59 are substituted with neutral residues suggested the possibility that a salt bridge exists between helix II and helix XI. To further test this idea, we constructed three additional site-directed mutants: Asp-59-->Lys (D59K), Lys-377-->Asp (K377D), and a double mutant, Asp-59-->Lys/Lys-377-->Asp (D59K/K377D), in which the position of these charges was exchanged. K377D accumulated melibiose only marginally while D59K could not accumulate. However, the D59K/K377D double mutant accumulated melibiose to a modest level although this activity was no longer stimulated by Na(+). We suggest that Asp-59 and Lys-377 interact via a salt bridge that brings helix II and helix XI close to one another in the three-dimensional structure of the carrier.

Unravelling the folding of bacteriorhodopsin

The folding mechanism of integral membrane proteins has eluded detailed study, largely as a result of the inherent difficulties in folding these proteins in vitro. The seven-transmembrane helical protein bacteriorhodopsin has, however, allowed major advances to be made, not just on the folding of this particular protein, but also on the factors governing folding of transmembrane alpha-helical proteins in general. This review focusses on kinetic and equilibrium studies of bacteriorhodopsin folding in vitro. It covers what is currently known about secondary and tertiary structure formation as well as the events accompanying retinal binding, for protein in detergent and lipid systems, including native membrane samples.

Evidence for long range allosteric interactions between the extracellular and cytoplasmic parts of bacteriorhodopsin from the mutant R82A and its second site revertant R82A/G231C

Evidence is presented for long range interactions between the extracellular and cytoplasmic parts of the heptahelical membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin in the mutant R82A and its second site revertant R82A/G231C. (i) In the double mutants R82A/G72C and R82A/A160C, with the cysteine mutation on the extracellular or cytoplasmic surface, respectively, the photocycle is the same as in the single mutant R82A with an accelerated deprotonation of the Schiff base and a reversed order of proton release and uptake. Proton release and uptake kinetics were measured directly at either surface by using the unique cysteine residue as attachment site for the pH indicator fluorescein. Whereas in wild type proton uptake on the cytoplasmic surface occurs during the M-decay (tau approximately 8 ms), in R82A it occurs already during the first phase of the M-rise (tau < 1 microseconds). (ii) The introduction of a second mutation at the cytoplasmic surface in position 231 (helix G) restores wild type ground state absorption properties, kinetics of photocycle and of proton release, and uptake in the mutant R82A/G231C. In addition, kinetic H/D isotope effects provide evidence that the proton release mechanism in R82A/G231C and in wild type is similar. These results suggest the existence of long range interactions between the cytoplasmic and extracellular surface domains of bacteriorhodopsin mediated by salt bridges and hydrogen-bonded networks between helices C (Arg-82) and G (Asp-212 and Gly-231). Such long range interactions are expected to be of functional significance for activation and signal transduction in heptahelical G-protein-coupled receptors.

Nature of the chromophore binding site of bacteriorhodopsin: the potential role of Arg82 as a principal counterion

The nature of the chromophore binding site of light-adapted bacteriorhodopsin is analyzed by using modified neglect of differential overlap with partial single and double configuration interaction (MNDO-PSDCI) molecular orbital theory to interpret previously reported linear and nonlinear optical spectroscopic measurements. We conclude that in the absence of divalent metal cations in close interaction with Asp85 and Asp212, a positively charged amino acid must be present in the same vicinity. We find that models in which Arg82 is pointed upward into the chromophore binding site and directly stabilizes Asp85 and Asp212 are successful in rationalizing the observed one-photon and two-photon properties. We conclude further that a water molecule is strongly hydrogen bonded to the chromophore imine proton. The chromophore "1Bu*+" and "1Ag*-" states, despite extensive mixing, exhibit significantly different configurational character. The lowest-lying "1Bu*+" state is dominated by single excitations, whereas the second-excited "1Ag*-" state is dominated by double excitations. We can rule out the possibility of a negatively charged binding site, because such a site would produce a lowest-lying "1Ag*-" state, which is contrary to experimental observation. The possibility that Arg82 migrates toward the extracellular surface during the photocycle is examined.

The titrations of Asp-85 and of the cation binding residues in bacteriorhodopsin are not coupled

An outstanding problem relating to the structure and function of bacteriorhodopsin (bR), which is the only protein in the purple membrane of the photosynthetic microorganism Halobacterium salinarium, is the relation between the titration of Asp-85 and the binding/unbinding of metal cations. An extensively accepted working hypothesis has been that the two titrations are coupled, namely, protonation of Asp-85 (located in the vicinity of the retinal chromophore) and cation unbinding occur concurrently. We have carried out a series of experiments in which the purple blue equilibrium and the binding of Mn2+ ions (monitored by electron spin resonance) were followed as a function of pH for several (1-4) R = [Mn2+]/[bR] molar ratios. Data were obtained for native bR, bR mutants, artificial bR and chemically modified bR. We find that in the native pigment the two titrations are separated by more than a pKa unit [delta pKa = pKa(P/B)-pKa(Mn2+) = (4.2-2.8) = 1.4]. In the non-native systems, delta pKa values as high as 5 units, as well as negative delta pKas, are observed. We conclude that the pH titration of cation binding residues in bR is not directly related to the titration of Asp-85. This conclusion is relevant to the nature of the high affinity cation sites in bR and to their role in the photosynthetic function of the pigment.

Altered substrate selectivity in a mutant of an intrahelical salt bridge in UhpT, the sugar phosphate carrier of Escherichia coli

Site-directed and second site suppressor mutagenesis identify an intrahelical salt bridge in the eleventh transmembrane segment of UhpT, the sugar phosphate carrier of Escherichia coli. Glucose 6-phosphate (G6P) transport by UhpT is inactivated if cysteine replaces either Asp388 or Lys391 but not if both are replaced. This suggests that Asp388 and Lys391 are involved in an intrahelical salt bridge and that neither is required for normal UhpT function. This interpretation is strengthened by the finding that mutations at Lys391 (K391N, K391Q, and K391T) are recovered as revertants of the inactive D388C variant. Further work shows that although the D388C variant is null for G6P transport, movement of 32Pi by homologous Pi/Pi exchange is unaffected. This raises the possibility that this derivative may have latent function, a possibility confirmed by showing that D388C is a gain-of-function mutation in which phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) is the preferred substrate. Added study of the Pi/Pi exchange shows that in wild type UhpT this partial reaction is readily blocked by G6P but not PEP. By contrast, in the D388C variant, Pi/Pi exchange is unaffected by G6P but is inhibited by both PEP and 3-phosphoglycerate. These latter substrates are used by PgtP, a related Pi-linked antiporter, which lacks the Asp388-Lys391 salt bridge but has instead an uncompensated arginine at position 391. For this reason, we conclude that in both UhpT and PgtP position 391 can serve as a determinant of substrate selectivity by acting as a receptor for the anionic carboxyl brought into the translocation pathway by PEP.

Refolding of bacteriorhodopsin from expressed polypeptide fragments

Bacteriorhodopsin is a heptahelical membrane protein that can be refolded to the native state following denaturation. To analyze the in vitro folding process with independent structural domains, eight fragments comprising two (AB, FG), three (AC, EG), four (AD, DG) or five (AE, CG) of the transmembrane segments were produced by expression in Escherichia coli. The polypeptides were purified to homogeneity by solvent extraction of E. coli membranes, repeated phase separation, and anion-exchange chromatography employing the C-terminal tail of bacteriorhodopsin for adsorption. Upon reconstitution into phospholipid/detergent micelles pairs of complementary fragments (AB.CG, AC.DG, AD.EG, and AE.FG) assembled in the presence of retinal to regenerate the characteristic bacteriorhodopsin chromophore with high efficiency. Together with previous studies, these results demonstrate that the covalent connections in each of the six interhelical loops are dispensable for a correct association of the helices. The different loops, however, contribute to the stability of the folded structure, as shown by increased susceptibilities toward denaturation in SDS and at acidic pH, and decreased Schiff base pKa values for the AB.CG, AC. DG, AD.EG, and AE.FG complexes, compared with the intact protein. Notably, the heptahelical bundle structure was also generated by all possible combinations of pairs of overlapping fragments, containing one (AC.CG, AD.DG, AE.EG), two (AD.CG, AE.DG), or three (AE.CG) redundant helices. The spectral properties of the chromophores indicate that the retinal-binding pocket of the AC.CG, AD.CG, and AE. CG complexes is formed by helices A and B of the respective N-terminal fragment and the C-terminal CG fragment, whereas the AD. DG, AE.DG, and AE.EG complexes are likely to adopt a heptahelical bundle structure analogous to AD.EG. The combined data show that the specificity of the helix assembly of bacteriorhodopsin is influenced by connectivities provided by the C-D and E-F surface loops.

Physiological evidence for an interaction between Glu-325 and His-322 in the lactose carrier of Escherichia coli

Site-directed mutagenesis and second-site suppressor analysis have proven to be useful approaches to examine the role of charged amino acids in the structure and function of the lactose carrier of Escherichia coli. A lactose carrier mutant Glu-325 --> Ser failed to ferment melibiose and showed white clones on melibiose MacConkey indicator plates. Several red revertants were isolated from these plates. Two of these revertants showed a double mutation, the original mutation (Glu-325 --> Ser) plus His-322 --> Asp. Seven revertants showed a second site mutation His-322 --> Asn. Although the second site revertants failed to accumulate sugars they do show more rapid uptake of melibiose into cells containing alpha-galactosidase than the original mutant Glu-325 --> Ser. The complete loss of transport activity due to the removal of the negative charge at 325 can be partially compensated for by the introduction of a new negative charge at 322. A site-directed double mutant His-322 --> Asn/Glu-325 --> Asn showed a greater rate of lactose uptake (Vmax) than either of the single mutants His-322 --> Asn or Glu 325 --> Asn. It was concluded that there is some type of physiological interaction (possibly a salt bridge) between His-322 and Glu-325.

Forces and factors that contribute to the structural stability of membrane proteins

While a considerable amount of literature deals with the structural energetics of water-soluble proteins, relatively little is known about the forces that determine the stability of membrane proteins. Similarly, only a few membrane protein structures are known at atomic resolution, although new structures have recently been described. In this article, we review the current knowledge about the structural features of membrane proteins. We then proceed to summarize the existing literature regarding the thermal stability of bacteriorhodopsin, cytochrome-c oxidase, the band 3 protein, Photosystem II and porins. We conclude that a fundamental difference between soluble and membrane proteins is the high thermal stability of intrabilayer secondary structure elements in membrane proteins. This property manifests itself as incomplete unfolding, and is reflected in the observed low enthalpies of denaturation of most membrane proteins. By contrast, the extramembranous parts of membrane proteins may behave much like soluble proteins. A brief general account of thermodynamics factors that contribute to the stability of water soluble and membrane proteins is presented.

Forces and factors that contribute to the structural stability of membrane proteins

While a considerable amount of literature deals with the structural energetics of water-soluble proteins, relatively little is known about the forces that determine the stability of membrane proteins. Similarly, only a few membrane protein structures are known at atomic resolution, although new structures have recently been described. In this article, we review the current knowledge about the structural features of membrane proteins. We then proceed to summarize the existing literature regarding the thermal stability of bacteriorhodopsin, cytochrome-c oxidase, the band 3 protein, Photosystem II and porins. We conclude that a fundamental difference between soluble and membrane proteins is the high thermal stability of intrabilayer secondary structure elements in membrane proteins. This property manifests itself as incomplete unfolding, and is reflected in the observed low enthalpies of denaturation of most membrane proteins. By contrast, the extramembranous parts of membrane proteins may behave much like soluble proteins. A brief general account of thermodynamics factors that contribute to the stability of water soluble and membrane proteins is presented.

Surface charge of bacteriorhodopsin detected with covalently bound pH indicators at selected extracellular and cytoplasmic sites

We present a method that allows the detection of the surface charge density of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) at any selected protein surface site. The optical pH indicator fluorescein was covalently bound to the sulfhydryl groups of single cysteine residues, which were introduced at selected positions in bR by site-directed mutagenesis. On the extracellular side, the positions were in the BC loop (72) and in the DE loop (129-134). On the cytoplasmic side, one position in each loop was labeled: 35 (AB), 101 (CD), 160 (EF), and 231 (carboxy tail). The apparent pKs of fluorescein in these positions were determined for various salt concentrations. The local surface charge density was calculated from the dependence of the apparent pK of the dye on the ionic strength using the Gouy-Chapman equation. The surface charge density at pH 6.6 is more negative on the cytoplasmic side (averaged over all positions, -2.5 +/- 0.2 elementary charges per bR) than on the extracellular side (average, -1.8 +/- 0.2 elementary charges per bR) with little variation along the surface. Since the experiments were performed with electrically neutral CHAPS/DMPC micelles, these values represent the charge present on bR itself.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Proton translocation mechanism and energetics in the light-driven pump bacteriorhodopsin

In spite of many still unsolved problems, the mechanism and energetics of the light-driven proton transport are now basically understood. Energy captured during photoexcitation, and retained in the form of bond rotations and strains of the retinal, is transformed into directed changes in the pKa values of vectorially arranged proton transfer groups. The framework for the spatial and temporal organization of these changes is provided by the protein near the retinal Schiff base. The transport is completed by proton transfer among three essential groups in three domains lying roughly parallel with the membrane plane (Fig. 1): (a) the anionic D85 that is included in a complex of residues on the extracellular side containing also R82, D212, Y57 and bound water; (b) the protonated Schiff base; and (c) the protonated D96 that is included in a complex of residues on the cytoplasmic side containing also R227, T46, S226, and bound water. Other neighboring polar groups and water bound elsewhere which play a role in the transport do so either by further influencing the pKa values of the three protonable groups, or by providing passive pathways for proton transfer. The Schiff base proton, destabilized after photoexcitation, is transferred to the low pKa group D85 located on the extracellular side. The access of the deprotonated Schiff base then changes to the cytoplasmic side (the 'reprotonation switch') and its proton affinity increases. Finally, the proton of the high pKa group D96, with access to the cytoplasmic side, is destabilized by a protein conformational change through rearrangement of R227, T46, S226 and bound water, and becomes transferred to the Schiff base. As shown schematically in Fig. 3, these internal events are coupled to proton release and uptake at the two aqueous surfaces. The charge of the extracellular hydrogen-bonded complex is redistributed upon protonation of D85, and if the pH is above the pKa of the complex a proton is released to the bulk. After reprotonation of the Schiff base the pKa of the cytoplasmic hydrogen-bonded complex is raised well above the pH, and D96 regains a proton from the bulk. If the pH is lower than the pKa of the extracellular complex the proton release is delayed until the end of the photocycle. In either sequence there is net transfer of a proton from the cytoplasmic to the extracellular phase. The transfer of excess free energy from the chromophore to the protein, and finally to the transported proton, is described by a characteristic thermodynamic cycle.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Pathways of proton transfer in the light-driven pump bacteriorhodopsin

The mechanism of proton transport in the light-driven pump bacteriorhodopsin is beginning to be understood. Light causes the all-trans to 13-cis isomerization of the retinal chromophore. This sets off a sequential and directed series of transient decreases in the pKa's of a) the retinal Schiff base, b) an extracellular proton release complex which includes asp-85, and c) a cytoplasmic proton uptake complex which includes asp-96. The timing of these pKa changes during the photoreaction cycle causes sequential proton transfers which result in the net movement of a proton across the protein, from the cytoplasmic to the extracellular surface.

Refolding and proton pumping activity of a polyethylene glycol-bacteriorhodopsin water-soluble conjugate

Bacteriorhodopsin (BR), from the purple membrane (PM) of Halobacterium halobium, was chemically modified with methoxypolyethylene glycol (m-PEG; molecular weight = 5,000 Da) succinimidyl carbonate. The polyethylene glycol-bacteriorhodopsin (m-PEG-SC-BR33) conjugate, containing one polyethylene glycol chain, was water soluble. The secondary structure of the conjugate in water appeared partially denatured, but was shown to contain alpha-helical segments by circular dichroism spectroscopy. The isolated bacteriorhodopsin conjugate, with added retinal, was refolded in a mixed detergent-lipid micelle and had an absorption maximum at 555 nm. The refolded conjugate was transferred into vesicles that pumped protons, upon illumination, as efficiently as did native BR. Modification of the PM with m-PEG did not alter the native structure or inhibit proton pumping, and therefore it is suggested that the glycol polymer is present as a moiety covalently linked to residues unnecessary for proton pumping and proper folding. The site of attachment of m-PEG was determined to be at either Lys 129 or Lys 159, with position Lys 129 the most probable site of attachment. The m-PEG-SC-BR33 could be stepwise refolded to the native conformation by the addition of trifluoroethanol to lower the dielectric constant, simulating the insertion of the BR into the phospholipid bilayer.

Effects of mutagenetic substitution of prolines on the rate of deprotonation and reprotonation of the Schiff base during the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin

Membrane-buried proline residues are found in many transport proteins. To study their roles in the structure and function of bacteriorhodopsin (bR), effects of the individual substitutions of Pro-50, Pro-91 and Pro-186 on the deprotonation and reprotonation kinetics of the Schiff base (SB) were determined by flash photolysis. The obtained rate constants and the amplitudes of the slow and fast components were compared with those of ebR (wild-type bR, the native protein that is expressed in Escherichia coli). The deprotonation rates of PSB were found to be 10 times faster than that of ebR for P50A, P91A and P91G mutants, and 4 times faster for the P50G mutant. These mutations also increased the initial reprotonation rate of the SB, although the overall change in the reprotonation rate is not as significant as that in the deprotonation rate. Our results indicate that Pro-50 and Pro-91, as well as Pro-186, are important for the proton-pumping function of bR.

Proton transfer from Asp-96 to the bacteriorhodopsin Schiff base is caused by a decrease of the pKa of Asp-96 which follows a protein backbone conformational change

In the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle the transported proton crosses the major part of the hydrophobic barrier during the M to N reaction; in this step the Schiff base near the middle of the protein is reprotonated from D96 located near the cytoplasmic surface. In the recombinant D212N protein at pH > 6, the Schiff base remains protonated throughout the photocycle [Needleman, Chang, Ni, Váró, Fornés, White, & Lanyi (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 11478-11484]. Time-resolved difference spectra in the visible and infrared are described by the kinetic scheme BR-->K<==>L<==>N (-->N')-->BR. As evidenced by the large negative 1742-cm-1 band of the COOH group of the carboxylic acid, deprotonation of D96 in the N state takes place in spite of the absence of the unprotonated Schiff base acceptor group of the M intermediate. Instead of internal proton transfer to the Schiff base, the proton is released to the bulk, and can be detected with the indicator dye pyranine during the accumulation of N'. The D212N/D96N protein has a similar photocycle, but no proton is released. As in wild-type, deprotonation of D96 in the N state is accompanied by a protein backbone conformational change indicated by characteristic amide I and II bands. In D212N the residue D96 can thus deprotonate independent of the Schiff base, but perhaps dependent on the detected protein conformational change. This could occur through increased charge interaction between D96 and R227 and/or increased hydration near D96. We suggest that the proton transfer from D96 to the Schiff base in the wild-type photocycle is driven also by such a decrease in the pKa of D96.

The structures of bacteriorhodopsin with different retinal-Schiff base orientations--computer modeling and energy minimization studies

Bacteriorhodopsin has been the subject of intense study in order to understand its photochemical function. The recent atomic model proposed by Henderson and coworkers based on electron cryo-microscopic studies has helped in understanding many of the structural and functional aspects of bacteriorhodopsin. However, the accuracy of the positions of the side chains is not very high since the model is based on low-resolution data. In this study, we have minimized the energy of this structure of bacteriorhodopsin and analyzed various types of interactions such as--intrahelical and interhelical hydrogen bonds and retinal environment. In order to understand the photochemical action, it is necessary to obtain information on the structures adopted at the intermediate states. In this direction, we have generated some intermediate structures taking into account certain experimental data, by computer modeling studies. Various isomers of retinal with 13-cis and/or 15-cis conformations and all possible staggered orientations of Lys-216 side chain were generated. The resultant structures were examined for the distance between Lys-216-schiff base nitrogen and the carboxylate oxygen atoms of Asp-96--a residue which is known to reprotonate the schiff base at later stages of photocycle. Some of the structures were selected on the basis of suitable retinal orientation and the stability of these structures were tested by energy minimization studies. Further, the minimized structures are analyzed for the hydrogen bond interactions and retinal environment and the results are compared with those of the minimized rest state structure. The importance of functional groups in stabilizing the structure of bacteriorhodopsin and in participating dynamically during the photocycle have been discussed.

FTIR difference spectroscopy of bacteriorhodopsin: toward a molecular model

Bacteriorhodopsin (bR) is a light-driven proton pump whose function includes two key membrane-based processes, active transport and energy transduction. Despite extensive research on bR and other membrane proteins, these processes are not fully understood on the molecular level. In the past ten years, the introduction of Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectroscopy along with related techniques including time-resolved FTIR difference spectroscopy, polarized FTIR, and attenuated total reflection FTIR has provided a new approach for studying these processes. A key step has been the utilization of site-directed mutagenesis to assign bands in the FTIR difference spectrum to the vibrations of individual amino acid residues. On this basis, detailed information has been obtained about structural changes involving the retinylidene chromophore and protein during the bR photocycle. This includes a determination of the protonation state of the four membrane-embedded Asp residues, identification of specific structurally active amino acid residues, and the detection of protein secondary structural changes. This information is being used to develop an increasingly detailed picture of the bR proton pump mechanism.

Design of a helix-bundle cross-link: NMR and UV-visible spectroscopic analyses and molecular modeling of ring-oxidized retinals

In order to generate potential chemical cross-links for studying the chromophore binding site of bacteriorhodopsin and related helix-bundle proteins, MnO2 was used to oxidize all-trans-retinal's ring moiety. The structures and solution conformations of three ring-oxidized retinal analogues have been determined by using UV-visible absorption and 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopies, primarily with regard to (i) the introduction of a functional group at the ring end of the chromophore, (ii) the retention of the all-trans geometry of the polyenal side chain, and (iii) the torsional angle of the ring-polyenal bond. Analyses of their UV-visible absorption spectral parameters (lambda max, epsilon max, and vibrational fine structure) and NMR spectral parameters (1H-1H coupling constants, 1H and 13C NMR chemical shifts, and 1H homonuclear Overhauser effects) indicated the 4-oxo and the 2,3-dehydro-4-oxo derivatives both possess the twisted 6-s-cis conformation adopted by most six-membered ring analogues of retinal in solution or crystal. However, the alpha-dioxocyclopentenyl analogue exists in solution predominantly (70-80%) as the planar 6-s-trans conformer, similar to violerythrine chromophore analogues. In order to identify the minor solution forms, molecular modeling and geometry optimizations using the semiempirical molecular orbital method AM1 defined two additional symmetry-related minima at +/- 30-40 degrees in its C6-C7 torsional energy profile. Because the chromophores of bacterio- and halorhodopsins and sensory rhodopsins are bound as the 6-s-trans conformer [Harbison, G.S., Smith, S.O., Pardoen, J.A., Courtin, J.M.L., Lugtenburg, J., Herzfeld, J., Mathies, R.A., & Griffin, R.G. (1985) Biochemistry 24, 6955-6962; Baselt, D.R., Fodor, S.P.A., van der Steen, R., Lugtenburg, J., Bogomolni, R.A., & Mathies, R.A. (1989) Biophys. J. 55, 193-196], we suggest that the cyclopentenyl analogue's alpha-diketo function may be favorably positioned within the binding pocket and sufficiently reactive toward nucleophilic attack to cross-link an arginine located in or near the ring end of the chromophore cavity: Arg134 according to the current model of bacteriorhodopsin's tertiary structure [Henderson, R., Baldwin, J.M., Ceska, T.A., Zemlin, F., Beckmann, E., & Downing, K.H. (1990) J. Mol. Biol. 213, 899-929] or Arg82 as postulated from an alternate model constructed primarily to accommodate the external point charge contribution to bacteriorhodopsin's opsin shift.