Functionally Distinct Agonist and Receptor-binding Regions in Human Chorionic Gonadotropin

Structural biology of glycoprotein hormones and their receptors: insights to signaling

This article reviews the progress made in the field of glycoprotein hormones (GPH) and their receptors (GPHR) by several groups of structural biologists including ourselves aiming to gain insight into GPH signaling mechanisms. The GPH family consists of four members, with follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) being the prototypic member. GPH members belong to the cystine-knot growth factor superfamily, and their receptors (GPHR), possessing unusually large N-terminal ectodomains, belong to the G-protein coupled receptor Family A. GPHR ectodomains can be divided into two subdomains: a high-affinity hormone binding subdomain primarily centered on the N-terminus, and a second subdomain that is located on the C-terminal region of the ectodomain that is involved in signal specificity. The two subdomains unexpectedly form an integral structure comprised of leucine-rich repeats (LRRs). Following the structure determination of hCG in 1994, the field of FSH structural biology has progressively advanced. Initially, the FSH structure was determined in partially glycosylated free form in 2001, followed by a structure of FSH bound to a truncated FSHR ectodomain in 2005, and the structure of FSH bound to the entire ectodomain in 2012. Comparisons of the structures in three forms led a proposal of a two-step monomeric receptor activation mechanism. First, binding of FSH to the FSHR high-affinity hormone-binding subdomain induces a conformational change in the hormone to form a binding pocket that is specific for a sulfated-tyrosine found as sTyr 335 in FSHR. Subsequently, the sTyr is drawn into the newly formed binding pocket, producing a lever effect on a helical pivot whereby the docking sTyr provides as the 'pull & lift' force. The pivot helix is flanked by rigid LRRs and locked by two disulfide bonds on both sides: the hormone-binding subdomain on one side and the last short loop before the first transmembrane helix on the other side. The lift of the sTyr loop frees the tethered extracellular loops of the 7TM domain, thereby releasing a putative inhibitory influence of the ectodomain, ultimately leading to the activating conformation of the 7TM domain. Moreover, the data lead us to propose that FSHR exists as a trimer and to present an FSHR activation mechanism consistent with the observed trimeric crystal form. A trimeric receptor provides resolution of the enigmatic, but important, biological roles played by GPH residues that are removed from the primary FSH-binding site, as well as several important GPCR phenomena, including negative cooperativity and asymmetric activation. Further reflection pursuant to this review process revealed additional novel structural characteristics such as the identification of a 'seat' sequence in GPH. Together with the 'seatbelt', the 'seat' enables a common heteodimeric mode of association of the common α subunit non-covalently and non-specifically with each of the three different β subunits. Moreover, it was possible to establish a dimensional order that can be used to estimate LRR curvatures. A potential binding pocket for small molecular allosteric modulators in the FSHR 7TM domain has also been identified.

Molecular architecture and biorecognition processes of the cystine knot protein superfamily: part I. The glycoprotein hormones

In this review article, the reader is introduced to recent advances in our knowledge on a subset of the cystine knot superfamily of homo- and hetero-dimeric proteins, from the perspective of the endocrine glycoprotein hormone family of proteins: follitropin (FSH), Iutropin (LH), thyrotropin. (TSH) and chorionic gonadotropin (CG). Subsequent papers will address the structure-function behaviour of other members of this increasingly significant family of proteins, including various members of the transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) family of proteins, the activins, inhibins, bone morphogenic growth factor, platelet derived growth factor-beta, nerve growth factor and more than 35 other proteins with similar topological features. In the present review article, specific emphasis has been placed on advances with the glycoprotein hormones (GPHs) that have facilitated greater insight into their physiological functions, molecular structures and most importantly the basis of the molecular recognition events that lead to the formation of hetero-dimeric structures as well as their specific and selective recognition by their corresponding receptors and antibodies. Thus, this review article focuses on the structural motifs involved in receptor recognition and the current techniques available to identify these regions, including the role of immunological methodology, peptide fragment design and synthesis and mutagenesis to delineate their structure-function relationships and molecular recognition behaviour.

Three-dimensional structures of gonadotropins

Most secreted proteins are modified post-translationally with the addition of carbohydrate. It has been difficult to use crystallography to solve the structures of these proteins due to the inherent heterogeneity of the carbohydrate. The structure of the chemically deglycosylated form (hydrogen fluoride treated) of human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) has been solved through crystallographic techniques. Unfortunately this form of hCG is not biologically active, and exhibits immunochemical differences from native hormone. In addition, subunit interactions appear altered after chemical deglycosylation as indicated by the increased thermal stability of the HF-treated hormone. The Asn 52 glycan on the alpha-subunit of hCG has been identified as being required for biological activity, it is, therefore, of physiological importance to determine the structure of the hormone with its carbohydrate intact. Also, it has not been possible to obtain crystals of the individual glycosylated subunits of hCG. Therefore an alternative method to solve the structure of the biologically active form of the hormone in solution as well as its separated subunits is necessary. Structural information utilizing NMR techniques can be obtained from native hCG subunits in solution if they can be uniformly labeled with 13C and 15N isotopes. We have developed a universal nonradioactive isotope, labeling medium enriched in 13C and 15N which can be used to express uniformly labeled hCG from Chinese hamster ovary cells suitable for solving the structure of the individual subunits and ultimately that of the native, biologically active hormone. The isotopically labeled recombinant hCG and its purified subunits are essentially identical to urinary hCG on comparison by biochemical, immunochemical, biological activity and the ability of the isolated subunits to recombine to form a biologically active dimer. Mass spectrometric analysis and preliminary structural NMR data indicate that the labeling is uniform and there is greater than 90% incorporation, sufficient for complete structural determination studies. This labeled growth medium represents a technological advance which will enable the rapid solution of the structures of the other glycoprotein hormones, as well as other glycoproteins which have proven unsuitable for crystallographic study.

Probing the functional conformation of the tridecapeptide mating pheromone of Saccharomyces cerevisiae through study of disulfide-constrained analogs

Analogs of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae alpha-mating factor, Trp-His-Trp-Leu-Gln-Leu-Lys-Pro-Gly-Gln-Pro-Met-Tyr, where Lys7 and Gln10 were replaced with Cys, Cys(CH3), or Ser, were synthesized using solid-phase procedures on a phenylacetamidomethyl resin. Cyclo7,10[Cys7,X9,Cys10,Nle12]alpha-factor , where X=D-Val, D-Ala, L-Ala and Gly, were prepared by on-resin cyclization using thallic trifluoroacetate in yields of 20-30%. Linear sulfhydryl-containing peptides were generated from their corresponding cyclic peptide by treatment with dithioerythritol in basic solution. In the linear analogs, replacement of both Lys7 and Gln10 with a cysteine residue resulted in an over 100-fold loss of the biological activity when compared with the native pheromone. The corresponding cyclic disulfides were 5-10-fold more active than their sulfhydryl-containing homologs, and cyclo7,10[Cys7,L-Ala9,Cys10,Nle12] alpha-factor was 50-fold more potent than linear analogs containing Ser or Cys(CH3) in positions 7 and 10. Binding competition studies indicated that all analogs had low affinity for the alpha-factor receptor and there was a poor correlation between binding and activity in a growth arrest assay. A cyclic analog in which residues 8 and 9 were replaced by 5-aminopentanoic acid was not biologically active. Based on NMR studies, all cyclic peptides have a higher tendency to form beta-turns spanning residues 7-10 than their less active linear counterparts. The results provide strong evidence that this beta-turn is important for optimal signal transduction by alpha-factor.

The antibodies causing thyroid stimulating hormone-binding inhibition (TSH-BI) are not responsible for the specific inhibition of gonadal steroidogenesis by Graves' sera

Graves' disease is attributed to the presence of autoantibodies with agonist activity which interact with the TSH receptor causing thyroid hyperstimulation and hyperthyroidism. The degree of TSH-binding inhibition (TSH-BI) caused by a Graves' serum in a TSH radioligand receptor assay is considered to be an index of the prevalence of anti-TSH receptor autoantibodies in that serum. We have previously shown that the specific inhibition by Graves' serum of hCG-stimulated steroidogenesis by Leydig cells was at a site distal to receptor binding and second messenger activation. In this report, we have investigated whether the effect of Graves' serum upon Leydig cells is a property of the constitutive antibodies. Immunoglobulin-enriched fractions were obtained from Graves' and normal sera using three increasingly rigorous procedures; ammonium sulphate precipitation, caprylic acid treatment and Protein A or G-affinity purification. The TSH-BI was determined for untreated and extracted sera in two radioreceptor assays developed for use with serum, one using human thyroid membranes and the other using HeLa cells transfected with the human TSH receptor, and the results were compared with effects in the Leydig cell steroidogenesis bioassay. The specific inhibition of hCG-stimulated Leydig cell steroidogenesis by Graves' sera was not retained in the antibody fraction causing TSH-BI. Thus, the inhibitory factor appears not to be an antibody and we are now attempting to purify and identify the responsible factor from Graves' serum.

Secondary structure prediction of beta-subunits of the gonadotropin-thyrotropin family from its aligned sequences using environment-dependent amino-acid substitution tables and conformational propensities

The secondary structures of beta-subunits of the glycoprotein hormone family, LH (luteinizing hormone), CG (chorionic gonadotropin), FSH (follicle stimulating hormone), TSH (thyroid stimulating hormone), and GTH I/GTH II (two types of fish gonadotropins), are predicted by comparing an amino-acid substitution pattern at equivalent sites in their aligned sequences with environment-dependent amino-acid substitution tables and conformational propensities calculated from other protein families whose three-dimensional structures are known. According to the prediction results, together with other structural information obtained from experiments, the following points come up as important structural features of the beta-subunits of this family; The regions assigned to regular secondary structures (one alpha-helix and three beta-strands) are considered to constitute a core of the beta-subunits. They involve interaction sites with carbohydrate and alpha-subunit. Out of the six disulfide bonds formed in the beta-subunit, four are located together on one side of the core, and the other two on the opposite side. The two regions assumed to be a receptor binding region from experiments (therefore, species-specific regions) are predicted as loops located on the same side of the beta-subunit in this study. Some of the predicted loops are rich in proline residues. While the positions of proline residues are conserved in the family generally, there are hormone- or species-specific ones in the loop that is assumed to take part in receptor binding. The possible importance of proline residues in hormone or species specificity is discussed. (After submitting the manuscript the X-ray crystal structure of human CG was published. In order to evaluate the prediction, the original manuscript is kept intact and a comparison has been made between the prediction results and the crystal structure in an appendix).

Structure of human chorionic gonadotropin at 2.6 A resolution from MAD analysis of the selenomethionyl protein

BACKGROUND

Human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) is a placental hormone that stimulates secretion of the pregnancy-sustaining steroid progesterone. It is a member of a family of glycoprotein hormones that are disulfide-rich heterodimers, with a common alpha-chain and distinctive beta-chains specific to their particular G-protein linked receptors.

RESULTS

We have produced recombinant hCG in mammalian cells as the selenomethionyl protein, and have determined its structure (after partial deglycosylation) at 2.6 A resolution from multiwavelength anomalous diffraction (MAD) measurements. Despite only limited sequence similarity (10% identity), the alpha- and beta-subunits of hCG have similar tertiary folds. Each subunit has a cystine-knot motif at its core of extended hairpin loops. There is a very extensive subunit interface featuring two inter-chain beta-sheets and a unique, disulfide-tethered 'arm' from the beta-subunit which 'embraces' the alpha-subunit. The carboxy-terminal peptide of the beta-subunit, which is rich in O-linked sugars, is disordered.

CONCLUSIONS

Structural and sequence comparisons indicate an evolutionary homology, albeit remote, between the glycoprotein hormone chains and other cystine-knot proteins, notably platelet-derived growth factor. Segments of the alpha- and beta-chains that have been convincingly implicated in receptor binding by hCG are juxtaposed on one side of the molecule. A glycosylation site implicated in signal transduction but not in binding is also close to the presumed binding site suggesting a possible coupling between ligand binding and signaling. This study with selenomethionyl protein produced in mammalian cells extends the realm of MAD phasing.

Cloning and expression of bovine and porcine interleukin-2 in baculovirus and analysis of species cross-reactivity

The cDNAs encoding bovine and porcine interleukin-2 (IL-2) have been expressed using the baculovirus Autographa californica nuclear polyhedrosis virus as a vector in insect cells. Insect cells infected with recombinant viruses secreted bovine and porcine IL-2 into the culture medium, with biological activities for maintaining the proliferation of homologous cells. When the activities of these two IL-2 proteins and commercially available human IL-2 were tested on heterologous cells differences were found. Recombinant bovine (rb)IL-2 only supported the growth of bovine lymphocytes and was not active on human, mouse or porcine lymphocytes. Recombinant porcine (rp)IL-2 and recombinant human (rh)IL-2 supported the proliferation of human, bovine, porcine and murine cells. However, the proliferative response of human lymphocytes to rpIL-2 was only 50% of that seen with rhIL-2. Sequence differences at the predicted p55 and p75 contact binding sites may explain this.

Topographical differences in human choriogonadotropin antagonist as revealed by monoclonal antibodies

Human choriogonadotropin (hCG), a highly glycosylated hormone loses its biological activity following deglycosylation. The deglycosylated hormone (DG-hCG) binds to gonadal cell receptors without causing complete signal transduction. In order to analyze the molecular features of DG-hCG, we have prepared and studied five monoclonal antibodies (Mab). Two DG-hCG Mabs were highly specific while three others showed some but low cross-reactivity with hCG. Only those that recognized hCG albeit weakly, could inhibit binding of 125I-hCG to receptors or hCG action in MA-10 (mouse Leydig tumor cells). All five Mabs were highly reactive with the free alpha subunit. As these alpha subunit favoring antibodies easily recognized DG-hCG but not the intact hCG configuration, we suggest that loss of sugars in alpha and beta subunits of DG-hCG was responsible for these alterations. Thus, in the molecular topography of DG-hCG, the orientation of the alpha subunit would be different from that in the native hormone and this may be further perturbed following binding to the specific receptor, leading to inefficient coupling to the signal transducing machinery.

Histidine2 of the alpha-factor of Saccharomyces cerevisiae is not essential for binding to its receptor or for biological activity

Seven His2 analogs of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae [Nle12]alpha-factor, WXWLQLKPGQP(Nle)Y, where X = beta-D-thienylalanine, beta-L-thienylalanine, 1-D-methylhistidine, 1-L-methylhistidine, 3-D-methylhistidine, 3-L-methylhistidine, and beta-3-L-pyridylalanine, were synthesized and purified to homogeneity. Assays were carried out on binding to the alpha-factor receptor and of biological activity determined by either growth arrest or morphological changes in target cells. In the L-isomer, replacement of the imidazole of histidine by thiophene or 3-pyridyl groups or derivatization of either nitrogen of the imidazole ring by methylation resulted in a 2-100-fold decrease in bioactivity. D-Isomers of the beta-thienylalanyl-, 1-methylhistidinyl-, or 3-methylhistidinyl-alpha-factors did not possess measurable bioactivity with the exception of comparatively low activity of the 3-D-methylhistidinyl and 1-D-methylhistidinyl-alpha-factors in the morphogenesis assay. In contrast, both active and inactive analogs demonstrated binding affinities 10-20-fold less than that of [Nle12]alpha-factor. These results indicate that the histidine residue of alpha-factor is not required for binding to the receptor or for biological activity and that bioactivity and binding can be dissociated through the use of pheromone analogs.

A novel computer modeling approach to the structures of small bioactive peptides: the structure of gonadotropin releasing hormone

A novel computer modeling approach suitable for the structure analysis of small bioactive peptides has been developed. This approach involves identification of conformational patterns in protein structure data bank based on the sequence homology with the bioactive peptide. The models built on the basis of this homology and having common conformational patterns are analyzed under the structural constraints derived from the activity data of various synthetic analogs of the peptide. Application of this procedure to the gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) resulted in a library of possible structures for GnRH, 9 among which shared a common beta-turn. Further analysis of the structures containing the beta-turn motif, in the context of the structure-activity data, led to a model for the active conformation of GnRH. The topology of the putative receptor binding site of the hormone is defined by a contiguous surface formed through an appropriate juxtaposition of the N-terminal pGlu1, the guanidyl group of Arg8, aromatic side chain of Trp3, and the Gly10-NH2 at the C-terminal end.

An antipodean perception of the mode of action of glycoprotein hormones

Continuance of vertebrate species and maintenance of metabolism have an absolute requirement for the glycoprotein hormones of the anterior pituitary gland. It is now firmly accepted that the N-glycans of these and the related placental hormone, chorionic gonadotropin, have essential if undefined roles in their mechanism of action. However, recent investigations by Weisshaar and his colleagues on the oligosaccharides of human luteinizing hormone and chorionic gonadotropin, do not support the generally accepted view of carbohydrates in hormone-receptor interactions and a further concept is proposed that invokes negative charges and changes in structured water.

Two receptor binding regions of human FSH show sense-antisense similarity to the human FSH receptor

The sequences of two receptor binding regions of the beta-subunit of the human follicle-stimulating hormone (hFSH-beta) were compared with the DNA-derived antisense peptide sequence of the hFSH receptor. A striking sense-antisense similarity was established between these receptor binding regions and the hFSH receptor. Based on this sense-antisense similarity four putative hormone binding regions on the N-terminal extracellular region of the hFSH receptor are identified.

Conformational perturbation of interleukin-2: a strategy for the design of cytokine analogs

Interleukin-2 (IL-2) is a representative of a growing family of small proteins termed lymphokines which are responsible for mediating cell differentiation, growth and function in the immune system. Many of these proteins are being evaluated for their clinical potential. From the perspective of drug development, structure-function analysis of these molecules and their receptors require the use methodologies different than those traditionally employed for small peptides and other natural products. However, similar pharmacologic principles apply and an understanding of ligand-receptor interactions and the associated responses is required in order to efficiently pursue agonist and antagonist design. Although IL-2 is a protein of only 133 amino acid residues for which a low resolution X-ray structure does exist, the complexity of its receptor system has provided an added challenge to structure-function studies. Consequently, little is known concerning the receptor contact residues for this protein. We have attempted to utilize established principles of protein and peptide structure to manipulate the conformation of IL-2 in a manner which has provided analogs helpful for receptor interaction studies. These proteins have not only providing useful information on the nature of the IL-2 receptor but have also revealed potential strategies for the design of IL-2 agonists and antagonists.

Histones inhibit human chorionic gonadotrophin-stimulated but not atrial peptide-stimulated testosterone production and cyclic nucleotide formation by isolated mouse Leydig cells

Recently it has been reported that histone type H2A can inhibit gonadotrophin-stimulated cAMP formation and steroidogenesis by ovarian cells. In the present study we have investigated if similar antigonadotrophic effects of commercially available histones can also be demonstrated on testicular steroidogenic cells. Using percoll-purified mouse Leydig cells, we have demonstrated that several types of histones could almost completely inhibit hCG-stimulated testosterone production and cAMP formation. The inhibition was dose-dependent and could be reversed by the addition of excess of hCG. The most potent histone types were H2AS and H8S, both of which could inhibit hCG-stimulated cAMP formation half-maximally at concentrations of 4-5 micrograms/ml. Forskolin-stimulated cAMP formation was not affected by histones. When the cells were stimulated with either db-cAMP or rAP-II, histone H2AS and H8S failed to inhibit the testosterone production. In fact there was a marked increase in the amount of testosterone produced, the reason for which is not yet understood. The amount of cGMP accumulated in response to rAP-II was not affected by the presence of H2AS or H8S. In unstimulated cells, neither the cyclic nucleotide level nor the amount of steroid produced was affected by the histones. Based on the [125I]hCG binding data it is possible to conclude that histone H2AS inhibits the binding of hCG to its receptors on Leydig cells and thereby causes the inhibition of hCG-stimulated cAMP formation and steroidogenesis.

Amino acid sequence elucidation of human acrosin-trypsin inhibitor (HUSI-II) reveals that Kazal-type proteinase inhibitors are structurally related to beta-subunits of glycoprotein hormones

The amino acid sequence of the acrosin-trypsin inhibitor HUSI-II from human seminal plasma is presented which unequivocally identifies HUSI-II as being of Kazal-type. In addition, the HUSI-II sequence shows a striking similarity to the middle part of glycoprotein hormone beta-subunits thus revealing a hitherto unknown structural and evolutionary relationship between Kazal-type inhibitors and glycoprotein hormones.

Conformation of the alpha-subunit of glycoprotein hormones: a study using polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies

The conformation of the common alpha-subunit of human glycoprotein hormones, luteinizing hormone (hLH), follicle-stimulating hormone (hFSH), thyroid-stimulating hormone (hTSH) and chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) was probed using a highly specific polyclonal antiserum against the alpha-subunit of hCG and several monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) produced against hCG which recognized the alpha-subunit in free and combined form. The alpha-subunit was found to be conformationally altered (compared to its conformation in the isolated state) when it was in combination with various beta-subunits as indicated by shifts in the displacement curves of binding of [125I]hCG alpha to the polyclonal antiserum. The extent of the change was dependent on the beta-subunit present with minimum change being observed with hLH beta, intermediate with hCG beta and maximum change with hFSH and TSH beta-subunits. However, the affinity constants of this antiserum for all four hormones were nearly similar. Further, it was also found that binding of any one of the glycoprotein hormones to this antibody could be completely inhibited by any other hormone suggesting that the conformation of the alpha-subunit in all the four hormones is probably very similar. This was further investigated using five hCG MAbs capable of recognizing the alpha-subunit, but with different epitope specificities. All these MAbs could recognize all the four hormones suggesting the presence of the epitopes in these proteins. These epitopes were conformation specific since the MAbs did not bind reduced and carboxymethylated alpha-subunit. Displacement analysis using [125I]hCG as the tracer showed that two epitopes have nearly the same conformation in all the four hormones, while two were partially modified depending on the beta-subunit present. Based on these results, it is concluded that the alpha-subunit of glycoprotein hormones has nearly the same conformation, though subtle differences do exist.