Iodination of tyrosine 59 of ubiquitin selectively blocks ubiquitin's acceptor activity in diubiquitin synthesis catalyzed by E2(25K)

Bacterial ligases reveal fundamental principles of polyubiquitin specificity

Homologous to E6AP C terminus (HECT) E3 ubiquitin (Ub) ligases direct substrates toward distinct cellular fates dictated by the specific form of monomeric or polymeric Ub (polyUb) signal attached. How polyUb specificity is achieved has been a long-standing mystery, despite extensive study in various hosts, ranging from yeast to human. The bacterial pathogens enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli and Salmonella Typhimurium encode outlying examples of "HECT-like" (bHECT) E3 ligases, but commonalities to eukaryotic HECT (eHECT) mechanism and specificity had not been explored. We expanded the bHECT family with examples in human and plant pathogens. Three bHECT structures in primed, Ub-loaded states resolved key details of the entire Ub ligation process. One structure provided a rare glimpse into the act of ligating polyUb, yielding a means to rewire polyUb specificity of both bHECT and eHECT ligases. Studying this evolutionarily distinct bHECT family has revealed insight into the function of key bacterial virulence factors as well as fundamental principles underlying HECT-type Ub ligation.

Bacterial mimicry of eukaryotic HECT ubiquitin ligation

HECT E3 ubiquitin (Ub) ligases direct their modified substrates toward a range of cellular fates dictated by the specific form of monomeric or polymeric Ub (polyUb) signal that is attached. How polyUb specificity is achieved has been a longstanding mystery, despite extensive study ranging from yeast to human. Two outlying examples of bacterial "HECT-like" (bHECT) E3 ligases have been reported in the human pathogens Enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli and Salmonella Typhimurium, but what parallels can be drawn to eukaryotic HECT (eHECT) mechanism and specificity had not been explored. Here, we expanded the bHECT family and identified catalytically active, bona fide examples in both human and plant pathogens. By determining structures for three bHECT complexes in their primed, Ub-loaded states, we resolved key details of the full bHECT Ub ligation mechanism. One structure provided the first glimpse of a HECT E3 ligase in the act of ligating polyUb, yielding a means to rewire the polyUb specificity of both bHECT and eHECT ligases. Through studying this evolutionarily distinct bHECT family, we have not only gained insight into the function of key bacterial virulence factors but also revealed fundamental principles underlying HECT-type Ub ligation.

Pivotal role for the ubiquitin Y59-E51 loop in lysine 48 polyubiquitination

Lysine 48 (K48)-polyubiquitination is the predominant mechanism for mediating selective protein degradation, but the underlying molecular basis of selecting ubiquitin (Ub) K48 for linkage-specific chain synthesis remains elusive. Here, we present biochemical, structural, and cell-based evidence demonstrating a pivotal role for the Ub Y59-E51 loop in supporting K48-polyubiquitination. This loop is established by a hydrogen bond between Ub Y59's hydroxyl group and the backbone amide of Ub E51, as substantiated by NMR spectroscopic analysis. Loop residues Y59 and R54 are specifically required for the receptor activity enabling K48 to attack the donor Ub-E2 thiol ester in reconstituted ubiquitination catalyzed by Skp1-Cullin1-F-box (SCF)(βTrCP) E3 ligase and Cdc34 E2-conjugating enzyme. When introduced into mammalian cells, loop-disruptive mutant Ub(R54A/Y59A) diminished the production of K48-polyubiquitin chains. Importantly, conditional replacement of human endogenous Ub by Ub(R54A/Y59A) or Ub(K48R) yielded profound apoptosis at a similar extent, underscoring the global impact of the Ub Y59-E51 loop in cellular K48-polyubiquitination. Finally, disulfide cross-linking revealed interactions between the donor Ub-bound Cdc34 acidic loop and the Ub K48 site, as well as residues within the Y59-E51 loop, suggesting a mechanism in which the Ub Y59-E51 loop helps recruit the E2 acidic loop that aligns the receptor Ub K48 to the donor Ub for catalysis.

Catalytic proficiency of ubiquitin conjugation enzymes: balancing pK(a) suppression, entropy, and electrostatics

Biological organisms orchestrate coordinated responses to external stimuli through temporal fluctuations in protein-protein interaction networks using molecular mechanisms such as the synthesis and recognition of polyubiquitin (polyUb) chains on signaling adaptor proteins. One of the pivotal chemical steps in ubiquitination involves reaction of a lysine amino group with a thioester group on an activated E2, or ubiquitin conjugation enzyme, to form an amide bond between Ub and a target protein. In this study, we demonstrate a nominal 14-fold range for the rate of the chemical step, k(cat), catalyzed by different E2 enzymes using non-steady-state, single-turnover assays. However, the observed range for k(cat) is as large as ∼100-fold for steady-state, single-turnover assays. Biochemical assays were used in combination with measurement of the underlying protein-protein interaction kinetics using NMR line-shape and ZZ-exchange analyses to determine the rate of polyUb chain synthesis catalyzed by the heterodimeric E2 enzyme Ubc13-Mms2. Modest variations in substrate affinity and k(cat) can achieve functional diversity in E2 mechanism, thereby influencing the biological outcomes of polyubiquitination. E2 enzymes achieve reaction rate enhancements through electrostatic effects such as suppression of substrate lysine pK(a) and stabilization of transition states by the preorganized, polar enzyme active site as well as the entropic effects of binding. Importantly, modestly proficient enzymes such as E2s maintain the ability to tune reaction rates; this may confer a biological advantage for achieving specificity in the diverse cellular roles for which these enzymes are involved.

Catalysis of lysine 48-specific ubiquitin chain assembly by residues in E2 and ubiquitin

Protein ubiquitination is catalyzed by ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes (E2s) in collaboration with ubiquitin-protein ligases (E3s). This process depends on nucleophilic attack by a substrate lysine on a thioester bond linking the C terminus of ubiquitin to a cysteine in the E2 active site. Different E2 family members display specificity for lysines in distinct contexts. We addressed the mechanistic basis for this lysine selectivity in Ubc1, an E2 that catalyzes the ubiquitination of lysine 48 (K48) in ubiquitin, leading to the formation of K48-linked polyubiquitin chains. We identified a cluster of polar residues near the Ubc1 active site, as well as a residue in ubiquitin itself, that are required for catalysis of K48-specific ubiquitin ligation, but not for general activity toward other lysines. Our results suggest that the active site of Ubc1, as well as the surface of ubiquitin, contains specificity determinants that channel specific lysines to the central residues involved directly in catalysis.

The human Cdc34 carboxyl terminus contains a non-covalent ubiquitin binding activity that contributes to SCF-dependent ubiquitination

Cdc34 is an E2 ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme that functions in conjunction with SCF (Skp1.Cullin 1.F-box) E3 ubiquitin ligase to catalyze covalent attachment of polyubiquitin chains to a target protein. Here we identified direct interactions between the human Cdc34 C terminus and ubiquitin using NMR chemical shift perturbation assays. The ubiquitin binding activity was mapped to two separate Cdc34 C-terminal motifs (UBS1 and UBS2) that comprise residues 206-215 and 216-225, respectively. UBS1 and UBS2 bind to ubiquitin in the proximity of ubiquitin Lys(48) and C-terminal tail, both of which are key sites for conjugation. When bound to ubiquitin in one orientation, the Cdc34 UBS1 aromatic residues (Phe(206), Tyr(207), Tyr(210), and Tyr(211)) are probably positioned in the vicinity of ubiquitin C-terminal residue Val(70). Replacement of UBS1 aromatic residues by glycine or of ubiquitin Val(70) by alanine decreased UBS1-ubiquitin affinity interactions. UBS1 appeared to support the function of Cdc34 in vivo because human Cdc34(1-215) but not Cdc34(1-200) was able to complement the growth defect by yeast Cdc34 mutant strain. Finally, reconstituted IkappaBalpha ubiquitination analysis revealed a role for each adjacent pair of UBS1 aromatic residues (Phe(206)/Tyr(207), Tyr(210)/Tyr(211)) in conjugation, with Tyr(210) exhibiting the most pronounced catalytic function. Intriguingly, Cdc34 Tyr(210) was required for the transfer of the donor ubiquitin to a receptor lysine on either IkappaBalpha or a ubiquitin in a manner that depended on the neddylated RING sub-complex of the SCF. Taken together, our results identified a new ubiquitin binding activity within the human Cdc34 C terminus that contributes to SCF-dependent ubiquitination.

Structure and interaction of ubiquitin-associated domain of human Fas-associated factor 1

Fas-associated factor (FAF)-1 is a multidomain protein that was first identified as a member of the Fas death-inducing signaling complex, but later found to be involved in various biological processes. Although the exact mechanisms are not clear, FAF1 seems to play an important role in cancer, asbestos-induced mesotheliomas, and Parkinson's disease. It interacts with polyubiquitinated proteins, Hsp70, and p97/VCP (valosin-containing protein), in addition to the proteins of the Fas-signaling pathway. We have determined the crystal structure of the ubiquitin-associated domain of human FAF1 (hFAF1-UBA) and examined its interaction with ubiquitin and ubiquitin-like proteins using nuclear magnetic resonance. hFAF1-UBA revealed a canonical three-helical bundle that selectively binds to mono- and di-ubiquitin (Lys48-linked), but not to SUMO-1 (small ubiquitin-related modifier 1) or NEDD8 (neural precursor cell expressed, developmentally down-regulated 8). The interaction between hFAF1-UBA and di-ubiquitin involves hydrophobic interaction accompanied by a transition in the di-ubiquitin conformation. These results provide structural insight into the mechanism of polyubiquitin recognition by hFAF1-UBA.

Residue-specific radical-directed dissociation of whole proteins in the gas phase

The rapid identification of proteins from biological samples is critical for extracting useful information in proteomics studies. Mass spectrometry is one among the various methods of choice for achieving this task; however, current approaches are limited by a lack of chemical control over proteins in the gas phase. Herein, it is shown that modification of tyrosine to iodo-tyrosine followed by UV photodissociation of the carbon-iodine bond can be used to generate a radial site specifically at the modified residue. The subsequent dissociation of the protein is largely dominated by radical-directed reactions, including dominant backbone fragmentation at the modified tyrosine. If iodination of the protein is carried out under natively folded conditions, the modification and ultimate fragmentation can typically be isolated to a single tyrosine residue. Some secondary backbone cleavage in the immediate vicinity of the modified tyrosine also occurs, especially if proline is present. In the absence of a reactive tyrosine residue, similar chemistry occurs via iodination at histidine. Possible mechanisms which would lead to the observed a-type fragments at tyrosine and the secondary fragments at proline are discussed. A method for using this type of site-specific information to reduce database searching times in proteomics experiments by several orders of magnitude is outlined.

E2-25K mediates US11-triggered retro-translocation of MHC class I heavy chains in a permeabilized cell system

In cells expressing human cytomegalovirus US11 protein, newly synthesized MHC class I heavy chains (HCs) are rapidly dislocated from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and degraded in the cytosol, a process that is similar to ER-associated degradation (ERAD), the pathway used for degradation of misfolded ER proteins. US11-triggered movement of HCs into the cytosol requires polyubiquitination, but it is unknown which ubiquitin-conjugating and ubiquitin-ligase enzymes are involved. To identify the ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme (E2) required for dislocation, we used a permeabilized cell system, in which endogenous cytosol can be replaced by cow liver cytosol. By fractionating the cytosol, we show that E2-25K can serve as the sole E2 required for dislocation of HCs in vitro. Purified recombinant E2-25K, together with components that convert this E2 to the active E2-ubiquitin thiolester form, can substitute for crude cytosol. E2-25K cannot be replaced by the conjugating enzymes HsUbc7/Ube2G2 or Ube2G1, even though HsUbc7/Ube2G2 and its yeast homolog Ubc7p are known to participate in ERAD. The activity of E2-25K, as measured by ubiquitin dimer formation, is strikingly enhanced when added to permeabilized cells, likely by membrane-bound ubiquitin protein ligases. To identify these ligases, we tested RING domains of various ligases for their activation of E2-25K in vitro. We found that RING domains of gp78/AMFR, a ligase previously implicated in ERAD, and MARCHVII/axotrophin, a ligase of unknown function, greatly enhanced the activity of E2-25K. We conclude that in permeabilized, US11-expressing cells polyubiquitination of the HC substrate can be catalyzed by E2-25K, perhaps in cooperation with the ligase MARCHVII/axotrophin.

Molecular determinants of polyubiquitin linkage selection by an HECT ubiquitin ligase

Ubiquitin (Ub)-protein ligases (E3s) frequently modify their substrates with multiple Ub molecules in the form of a polyubiquitin (poly-Ub) chain. Although structurally distinct poly-Ub chains (linked through different Ub lysine (Lys) residues) can confer different fates on target proteins, little is known about how E3s select the Lys residue to be used in chain synthesis. Here, we used a combination of mutagenesis, biochemistry, and mass spectrometry to map determinants of linkage choice in chain assembly catalyzed by KIAA10, an HECT (Homologous to E6AP C-Terminus) domain E3 that synthesizes K29- and K48-linked chains. Focusing on the Ub molecule that contributes the Lys residue for chain formation, we found that specific surface residues adjacent to K48 and K29 are critical for the usage of the respective Lys residues in chain synthesis. This direct mechanism of linkage choice bears similarities to the mechanism of substrate site selection in sumoylation catalyzed by Ubc9, but is distinct from the mechanism of chain linkage selection used by the Mms2/Ubc13 (Ub E2 variant (UEV)/E2) complex.

MdmX is a RING finger ubiquitin ligase capable of synergistically enhancing Mdm2 ubiquitination

It has been well documented that Mdm2 and its homologue MdmX not only are critical negative regulators of the tumor suppressor p53 but that both Mdm2 and MdmX interact to affect the function of the other. The mechanisms through which these effects are manifested, however, remain unclear. Although Mdm2 has been established as a RING finger ubiquitin ligase, MdmX has not been shown to possess this activity despite the extensive sequence homology between their respective RING finger domains. Here we demonstrate that MdmX acts as a ubiquitin ligase in vitro, being capable of autoubiquitination, as well as mediating the ubiquitination of p53. The addition of Mdm2 to in vitro ubiquitination assays containing MdmX results in a synergistic increase of ubiquitin conjugation. Analysis of the resulting ubiquitin conjugates reveals that this observed synergy reflects an increase in Mdm2 ubiquitination. This study also suggests that ubiquitination of Mdm2 and MdmX may not serve as a signal for degradation, as we show that each are capable of synthesizing non-lysine 48 polyubiquitin chains and, in fact, utilize multiple lysine linkages. Taken together, these findings suggest a more active role for MdmX in the Mdm2-MdmX-p53 regulatory network than has been proposed previously.

In Vitro Assembly and Recognition of Lys-63 Polyubiquitin Chains

Polyubiquitin chains assembled through lysine 48 (Lys-48) of ubiquitin act as a signal for substrate proteolysis by 26 S proteasomes, whereas chains assembled through Lys-63 play a mechanistically undefined role in post-replicative DNA repair. We showed previously that the products of the UBC13 and MMS2 genes function in error-free post-replicative DNA repair in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and form a complex that assembles Lys-63-linked polyubiquitin chains in vitro. Here we confirm that the Mms2.Ubc13 complex functions as a high affinity heterodimer in the chain assembly reaction in vitro and report the results of a kinetic characterization of the polyubiquitin chain assembly reaction. To test whether a Lys-63-linked polyubiquitin chain can signal degradation, we conjugated Lys-63-linked tetra-ubiquitin to a model substrate of 26 S proteasomes. Although the noncanonical chain effectively signaled substrate degradation, the results of new genetic epistasis studies agree with previous genetic data in suggesting that the proteolytic activity of proteasomes is not required for error-free post-replicative repair.

A HECT domain E3 enzyme assembles novel polyubiquitin chains

Although polyubiquitin chains linked through Lys(29) of ubiquitin have been implicated in the targeting of certain substrates to proteasomes, the signaling properties of these chains are poorly understood. We previously described a ubiquitin-protein isopeptide ligase (E3) from erythroid cells that assembles polyubiquitin chains through either Lys(29) or Lys(48) of ubiquitin (Mastrandrea, L. D., You, J., Niles, E. G., and Pickart, C. M. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 27299-27306). Here we describe the purification of this E3 based on its affinity for a linear fusion of ubiquitin to the ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme UbcH5A. Among five major polypeptides in the affinity column eluate, the activity of interest was assigned to the product of a previously cloned human cDNA known as KIAA10 (Nomura, N., Miyajima, N., Sazuka, T., Tanaka, A., Kawarabayasi, Y., Sato, S., Nagase, T., Seki, N., Ishikawa, K., and Tabata, S. (1994) DNA Res. 1, 27-35). The KIAA10 protein is a member of the HECT (homologous to E6-AP carboxyl terminus) domain family of E3s. These E3s share a conserved C-terminal (HECT) domain that functions in the catalysis of ubiquitination, while their divergent N-terminal domains function in cognate substrate binding (Huibregtse, J. M., Scheffner, M., Beaudenon, S., and Howley, P. M. (1995) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 92, 2563-2567). Recombinant KIAA10 catalyzed the assembly of both Lys(29)- and Lys(48)-linked polyubiquitin chains. Surprisingly, the C-terminal 428 residues of KIAA10 were both necessary and sufficient for this activity, suggesting that the ability to assemble polyubiquitin chains may be a general property of HECT domains. The N-terminal domain of KIAA10 interacted in vitro with purified 26 S proteasomes and with the isolated S2/Rpn1 subunit of the proteasome's 19 S regulatory complex, suggesting that the N-terminal domains of HECT E3s may function in proteasome binding as well as substrate binding.

Cyclization of polyubiquitin by the E2-25K ubiquitin conjugating enzyme

For most substrates of ubiquitin (Ub)-dependent degradation, recognition by the proteasome is mediated by a covalently attached signal assembled from multiple ubiquitins linked to each other via the C terminus of one Ub and the epsilon-amine of Lys(48) of another Ub. Among Ub-conjugating enzymes, E2-25K is unique in its ability to synthesize in vitro unanchored Lys(48)-linked poly-Ub chains from mono- or poly-Ub, E1, and ATP; thus, E2-25K has distinct binding sites for donor and acceptor (poly)Ub. During studies of chain assembly by E2-25K, we observed that Lys(48)-linked tri-Ub was efficiently converted to a new species that upon SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis migrated between linear di-Ub and tri-Ub. Analysis of this product by mass spectrometry and tryptic digestion showed that it was a cyclic form of tri-Ub. Cyclization of tri-Ub requires E1, E2-25K, ATP, and that the linear substrate has a free Gly(76) C terminus on the proximal end Ub and a Lys(48) side chain available on the distal end Ub. E2-25K similarly can catalyze the cyclization of longer poly-Ub chains, including tetra- and penta-Ub. Although cyclic tri-Ub resists hydrolysis by the PA700 or isopeptidase T deubiquitinating enzymes, it can be disassembled to Ub monomers by isopeptidase(s) in a red blood cell extract. Thus, if cyclic poly-Ub forms in vivo, it will not accumulate as a dead-end product.

An NMR analysis of the reaction of ubiquitin with [acetyl-1-13C]aspirin

The acetylation of ubiquitin by [acetyl-1-13C]aspirin has been studied using 2D NMR methods. Studies performed in a 50:50 H2O:D2O medium show doubling of the acetyl carbonyl resonances, indicating that all of the stable adducts formed involved amide linkages. Assignment of the heteronuclear multiple quantum coherence (HMQC) resonances was accomplished based on comparison of resonance intensities with the results of an Edman degradation analysis, pH titration studies of acetylated ubiquitin, and analysis of two ubiquitin mutants, K33R and K63R. The presence of a single tyrosine residue in close proximity to lysine-48 suggested another assignment strategy. Nitration of tyrosine-59 resulted in a small, pH-dependent shift of the resonance assigned to lysine-48, with a pK of 7.0, close to that expected for the nitrotyrosyl hydroxyl group. An additional adduct resonance with very low intensity also was observed and tentatively assigned to the acetylated N-terminal methionine residue. The relative rates of acetylation of the various lysine residues were obtained from time-dependent HMQC studies. Since no sample preparation artifacts were introduced, the levels of modification of the various residues could be determined with relatively high accuracy. Based on the time-dependent intensity data, the relative rate constants for modification of K6, K48, K63, K11, K33, and M1 were 1.0, 0.59, 0.43, 0.26, 0.23, and 0.03, respectively. These results were in much better agreement with amino accessibility predictions based on the crystal structure of the ubiquitin monomer than with predictions based on the ubiquitin structure in the crystallized dimeric and tetrameric forms. This approach provides a useful basis for understanding how local environmental factors can influence protein adduct formation, as well as for comparing the extent and specificity of various acetylation reagents.

Crystal structure of the human ubiquitin-like protein NEDD8 and interactions with ubiquitin pathway enzymes

The NEDD8/Rub1 class of ubiquitin-like proteins has been implicated in progression of the cell cycle from G1 into S phase. These molecules undergo a metabolism that parallels that of ubiquitin and involves specific interactions with many different proteins. We report here the crystal structure of recombinant human NEDD8 refined at 1.6-A resolution to an R factor of 21.9%. As expected from the high sequence similarity (57% identical), the NEDD8 structure closely resembles that reported previously for ubiquitin. We also show that recombinant human NEDD8 protein is activated, albeit inefficiently, by the ubiquitin-activating (E1) enzyme and that NEDD8 can be transferred from E1 to the ubiquitin conjugating enzyme E2-25K. E2-25K adds NEDD8 to a polyubiquitin chain with an efficiency similar to that of ubiquitin. A chimeric tetramer composed of three ubiquitins and one histidine-tagged NEDD8 binds to the 26 S proteasome with an affinity similar to that of tetraubiquitin. Seven residues that differ from the corresponding residues in ubiquitin, but are conserved between NEDD8 orthologs, are candidates for mediating interactions with NEDD8-specific partners. One such residue, Ala-72 (Arg in ubiquitin), is shown to perform a key role in selecting against reaction with the ubiquitin E1 enzyme, thereby acting to prevent the inappropriate diversion of NEDD8 into ubiquitin-specific pathways.

Core domain mutation (S86Y) selectively inactivates polyubiquitin chain synthesis catalyzed by E2-25K

The mammalian ubiquitin conjugating enzyme known as E2-25K catalyzes the synthesis of polyubiquitin chains linked exclusively through K48-G76 isopeptide bonds. The properties of truncated and chimeric forms of E2-25K suggest that the polyubiquitin chain synthesis activity of this E2 depends on specific interactions between its conserved 150-residue core domain and its unique 50-residue tail domain [Haldeman, M. T., Xia, G., Kasperek, E. M., and Pickart, C. M. (1997) Biochemistry 36, 10526-10537]. In the present study, we provide strong support for this model by showing that a point mutation in the core domain (S86Y) mimics the effect of deleting the entire tail domain: the ability to form an E2 approximately ubiquitin thiol ester is intact, while conjugation activity is severely inhibited (>/=100-fold reduction in kcat/Km). The properties of E2-25K enzymes carrying the S86Y mutation indicate that this mutation strengthens the interaction between the core and tail domains: both free and ubiquitin-bound forms of S86Y-25K are completely resistant to tryptic cleavage at K164 in the tail domain, whereas wild-type enzyme is rapidly cleaved at this site. Other properties of S86Y-26K suggest that the active site of this mutant enzyme is more occluded than the active site of the wild-type enzyme. (1) Free S86Y-25K is alkylated by iodoacetamide 2-fold more slowly than the wild-type enzyme. (2) In assays of E2 approximately ubiquitin thiol ester formation, S86Y-25K shows a 4-fold reduced affinity for E1. (3) The ubiquitin thiol ester adduct of S86Y-25K undergoes (uncatalyzed) reaction with dithiothreitol 3-fold more slowly than the wild-type thiol ester adduct. One model to accommodate these findings postulates that an enhanced interaction between the core and tail domains, induced by the S86Y mutation, causes a steric blockade at the active site which prevents access of the incoming ubiquitin acceptor to the thiol ester bond. Consistent with this model, the S86Y mutation inhibits ubiquitin transfer to macromolecular acceptors (ubiquitin and polylysine) more strongly than transfer to small-molecule acceptors (free lysine and short peptides). These results suggest that unique residues proximal to E2 active sites may influence specific function by mediating intramolecular interactions.

Specificity of the ubiquitin isopeptidase in the PA700 regulatory complex of 26 S proteasomes

The specificity of the ubiquitin (Ub) isopeptidase in the PA700 regulatory complex of the bovine 26 S proteasome was investigated. Disassembly of poly-Ub by this enzyme is restricted to the distal-end Ub of the substrate, i.e. the Ub farthest from the site of protein attachment in poly-Ub-protein conjugates. The determinants recognized by the isopeptidase were probed by the use of mutant ubiquitins incorporated into Lys48-linked poly-Ub substrates. PA700 could not disassemble poly-Ub chains that contained a distal Ub(L8A,I44A). This suggested either that the enzyme interacts directly with Leu8 or Ile44 or that it recognizes a higher order structure that caps the distal end of a poly-Ub substrate and is destabilized by Ub(L8A,I44A). The previously determined di-Ub crystal structure (Cook, W. J., Jeffrey, L. C., Carson, M., Chen, Z., and Pickart, C. M. (1992) J. Biol. Chem. 267, 16467-16471) offered a candidate for such a "cap." In solution, however, this structure was not observed by 1H NMR spectroscopy. This and the finding that di-Ub with a single proximal Ub(L8A,I44A) is cleaved efficiently suggest that Leu8 and Ile44 in the distal-end Ub contact the isopeptidase directly. In addition to Lys48-linked chains, PA700 also could disassemble Lys6- and Lys-11-linked poly-Ub, but, surprisingly, not alpha-linked di-Ub. Results with these and other substrates suggest that specificity determinants for the PA700 isopeptidase include Leu8, Ile44, and Lys48 on the distal Ub and, for poly-Ub, some features of the Ub-Ub linkage itself.

Inhibition of the 26 S proteasome by polyubiquitin chains synthesized to have defined lengths

Ubiquitin is a covalent signal that targets cellular proteins to the 26 S proteasome. Multiple ubiquitins can be ligated together through the formation of isopeptide bonds between Lys48 and Gly76 of successive ubiquitins. Such a polyubiquitin chain constitutes a highly effective proteolytic targeting signal, but its mode of interaction with the proteasome is not well understood. Experiments to address this issue have been limited by difficulties in preparing useful quantities of polyubiquitin chains of uniform length. We report a simple method for large scale synthesis of Lys48-linked polyubiquitin chains of defined length. In the first round of synthesis, two ubiquitin derivatives (K48C-ubiquitin and Asp77-ubiquitin) were used as substrates for the well characterized ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme E2-25K. Diubiquitin blocked at the nascent proximal and distal chain termini was obtained in quantitative yield. Appropriately deblocked chains were then combined to synthesize higher order chains (tetramer and octamer in the present study). Deblocking was achieved either enzymatically (proximal terminus) or by chemical alkylation (distal terminus). Chains synthesized by this method were used to obtain the first quantitative information concerning the influence of polyubiquitin chain length on binding to the 26 S proteasome; this was done through comparison of different length (unanchored) polyubiquitin chains as inhibitors of ubiquitin-conjugate degradation. K0.5 was found to decrease approximately 90-fold, from 430 to 4.8 microM, as the chain was lengthened from two to eight ubiquitins. The implications of these results for the molecular basis of chain recognition are discussed.

Structure and function of ubiquitin conjugating enzyme E2-25K: the tail is a core-dependent activity element

Individual members of the conserved family of ubiquitin conjugating enzymes (E2s) mediate the ubiquitination and turnover of specific substrates of the ubiquitin-dependent degradation pathway. E2 proteins have a highly conserved core domain of approximately 150 amino acids which contains the active-site Cys. Certain E2s have unique terminal extensions, which are thought to contribute to selective E2 function by interacting either with substrates or with trans-acting factors such as ubiquitin-protein ligases (E3s). We used the mammalian ubiquitin conjugating enzyme E2-25K in a biochemical test of this hypothesis. The properties of two truncated derivatives show that the 47-residue tail of E2-25K is necessary for three of the enzyme's characteristic properties: high activity in the synthesis of unanchored K48-linked polyubiquitin chains; resistance of the active-site Cys residue to alkylation; and an unusual discrimination against noncognate (nonmammalian) ubiquitin activating (E1) enzymes. However, the tail is not sufficient to generate these properties, as shown by the characteristics of a chimeric enzyme in which the tail of E2-25K was fused to the core domain of yeast UBC4. These and other results indicate that the specific biochemical function of the tail is strongly dependent upon unique features of the E2-25K core domain. Thus, divergent regions within the conserved core domains of E2 proteins may be highly significant for function. Expression of truncated E2-25K as a glutathione S-transferase (GST) fusion protein resulted in the apparent recovery of E2-25K-specific properties, including activity in chain synthesis. However, the catalytic mechanism utilized by the truncated fusion protein proved to be distinct from the mechanism utilized by the wild-type enzyme. The unexpected properties of the fusion protein were due to GST-induced dimerization. These results indicate the potential for self-association to modulate the polyubiquitin chain synthesis activities of E2 proteins, and indicate that caution should be applied in interpreting the activities of GST fusion proteins.

Mapping the ubiquitin-binding domains in the p54 regulatory complex subunit of the Drosophila 26S protease

Short-lived intracellular proteins, after being marked by multiubiquitination, are degraded by the 26S protease. This large ATP-dependent protease is composed of two multiprotein complexes: the regulatory complex and the 20S proteosome. The selective recognition of ubiquitinated proteins is ensured by the regulatory complex. Using an overlay assay a single 54-kDa multiubiquitin-chain-binding subunit was detected in the regulatory complex of the Drosophila 26S protease. Overlay assay with the recombinant p54 subunit confirmed its ubiquitin-binding property. The recombinant protein showed pronounced preference for higher ubiquitin multimers, in agreement with the known preference of the 26S protease for multiubiquitinated proteins as substrates. To map the ubiquitin-binding domain of the p54 subunit different segments of the recombinant protein were expressed in E. coli and tested by the overlay assay. The p54 subunit carries two independent ubiquitin-binding domains. The central domain carries two highly conserved sequence blocks: the FGVDP sequence (at position 207), which is 100% conserved from yeast till human, and the DPELALALRVSMEE sequence (at position 214), which is 100% conserved in higher eukaryotes with two amino acid changes in yeast. In the C-terminal ubiquitin-binding domain the GVDP sequence motif is repeated and 100% conserved in higher eukaryotes. This domain, however, due to the shorter size of the yeast multiubiquitin-binding subunit, is present only in higher eukaryotes.

Ability of ubiquitin radioimmunoassay to discriminate between monoubiquitin and multi-ubiquitin chains

Free ubiquitin (mainly monoubiquitin) and multi-ubiquitin chains coexist in eukaryote cells and serve distinct cellular roles. However, any immunoassay systems established previously have not been proved to be applicable for measuring the former without cross-reactive responses with the latter. For this purpose, we developed a radioimmunoassay specific to monoubiquitin by employing antiserum US-1 against ubiquitin. In this assay, ubiquitin-protein conjugates, prepared by a reticulocyte lysate fraction II and fractionated on Moro Q and Superdex 200 columns, exhibited practically no cross-reactivity. The cross-reactivity of fractionated ubiquitin-lysozyme conjugates was also analyzed as a function of their multi-ubiquitin chain size. As a result, the larger the conjugates were found to be, the weaker were the cross-reactive responses they showed, and the multi-ubiquitin chains (n > approx. 20) were substantially unreactive in the radioimmunoassay. By using the radioimmunoassay, heat-shock-induced decrease in the level of cellular free (mono)ubiquitin was detected. In addition, the standard preparation of multi-ubiquitin chains was not cross-reactive in all other five radioimmunoassays employing distinct antibodies to ubiquitin (four antisera and a monoclonal antibody). These data suggest that radioimmunoassays employing ubiquitin antibodies raised by the general methods can discriminate between monoubiquitin and multi-ubiquitin chains and quantitate cellular free ubiquitin.

Huntingtin is ubiquitinated and interacts with a specific ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme

Using the yeast two-hybrid system, we have identified a human ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme (hE2-25K) as a protein that interacts with the gene product for Huntington disease (HD) (Huntingtin). This protein has complete amino acid identity with the bovine E2-25K protein and has striking similarity to the UBC-1, -4 and -5 enzymes of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This protein is highly expressed in brain and a slightly larger protein recognized by an anti-E2-25K polyclonal antibody is selectively expressed in brain regions affected in HD. The huntingtin-E2-25K interaction is not obviously modulated by CAG length. We also demonstrate that huntingtin is ubiquitinated. These findings have implications for the regulated catabolism of the gene product for HD.

Mechanism of ubiquitin conjugating enzyme E2-230K: catalysis involving a thiol relay?

Covalent conjugation of ubiquitin to intracellular proteins is a signal for degradation by the 26S protease. Conjugation is usually accomplished by the sequential action of activating (E1), conjugating (E2), and ligase (E3) enzymes. Each of these enzymes forms a covalent thiol ester with ubiquitin as part of its catalytic cycle. In most cases, the apparent role of the ubiquitin conjugating enzyme (E2) is to transfer ubiquitin from the E1 active site to the E3 active site. Ubiquitin is then delivered from E3 to the substrate lysine residue. An unusually large, reticulocyte-specific enzyme, known as E2-230K, is unique among the large family of E2 enzymes is being susceptible to inhibition by inorganic arsenite [Klemperer et al. (1989) Biochemistry 28, 6035-6041]. We show that phenylarsenoxides potently inhibit E2-230K, apparently by binding to vicinal Cys residues of the enzyme: bound aminophenylarsenoxide partially protects the enzyme against inactivation by N-ethylmalemide (NEM), and prior enzyme inactivation with NEM blocks enzyme binding to immobilized phenylarsenoxide. Studies on the mechanistic basis of inhibition showed that a concentration of (aminophenyl)arsenoxide that produced complete inhibition of steady-state turnover had no effect on the turnover of the preformed E2-ubiquitin adduct. However, when the enzyme was preincubated with this concentration of inhibitor prior to initiation of adduct formation, the level of E2-associated ubiquitin was reduced by 60%. These results are consistent with a model in which two Cys residues of the enzyme sequentially form thiol esters with ubiquitin and the second of these Cys residues is bound to arsenic in the enzyme-inhibitor complex. In this model, E2-230K functions as an E2-E3 hybrid.

Molecular cloning and expression of a 26 S protease subunit enriched in dileucine repeats

The 26 S protease is a multisubunit enzyme required for ubiquitin-dependent proteolysis. Recently, we identified a 50-kDa subunit (S5) of this enzyme that binds ubiquitin polymers (Deveraux, Q., Ustrell, V., Pickart, C., and Rechsteiner, M. (1994) J. Biol. Chem. 269, 7059-7061). We have now isolated, sequenced, and expressed a cDNA encoding a novel 50-kDa subunit of the 26 S protease. The recombinant protein does not bind ubiquitin polymers. Two-dimensional electrophoresis reveals that two subunits of the 26 S protease have apparent molecular masses of 50 kDa. Antibodies specific for the recombinant protein recognize the more basic of the two subunits (S5b), whereas the more acidic subunit (S5a) binds ubiquitin chains. Thus, the 26 S protease contains at least two distinct subunits with apparent molecular masses of 50 kDa.

Immunoassay for the quantification of intracellular multi-ubiquitin chains

A sandwich ELISA has been developed to measure intracellular levels of multi-ubiquitin chains. The mixture of multi-ubiquitin chains, prepared in vitro by incubation of ubiquitin (plus 125I-ubiquitin) and lysozyme with ubiquitin-ligating enzymes and ATP, was partially purified and established as a standard named the multi-ubiquitin-chain reference preparation 1 (MUCRP1). The concentration of MUCRP1 was calculated from the recovered radioactivity of 125I-ubiquitin. All measurements by the ELISA were expressed in terms of MUCRP1. The ELISA showed good sensitivity (98 pg/ml), precision (intra-assays < 6%) and reproducibility (interassay < 9%). In addition, there was no substantial cross-reaction with mono-, di- and tri-ubiquitin, or mono-ubiquitinated and di-ubiquitinated lysozyme in the ELISA, and large multi-ubiquitin chains (n > approximately 6) may be fully reactive. These results combined with excellent results in the recovery and dilution tests guarantee accurate measurement of multi-ubiquitin chains in cell extracts prepared with a lysis buffer (water soluble) or the buffer supplemented 8 M urea (urea soluble). The level of the water-soluble multi-ubiquitin chains in reticulocytes was lower than that of erythrocytes, but the urea-soluble chain level was higher in the reticulocytes. Heat-shock treatment of HeLa cells increased the urea-soluble multi-ubiquitin chains. These data indicate that this ELISA provides a useful and reliable approach to the study of intracellular multi-ubiquitin-conjugate turnover.

Ubiquitin and the enigma of intracellular protein degradation

Contrary to widespread belief, the regulation and mechanism of degradation for the mass of intracellular proteins (i.e. differential, selective protein turnover) in vertebrate tissues is still a major biological enigma. There is no evidence for the conclusion that ubiquitin plays any role in these processes. The primary function of the ubiquitin-dependent protein degradation pathway appears to lie in the removal of abnormal, misfolded, denatured or foreign proteins in some eukaryotic cells. ATP/ubiquitin-dependent proteolysis probably also plays a role in the degradation of some so-called 'short-lived' proteins. Evidence obtained from the covalent modification of such natural substrates as calmodulin, histones (H2A, H2B) and some cell membrane receptors with ubiquitin indicates that the reversible interconversion of proteins with ubiquitin followed by concomitant functional changes may be of prime importance.

Dynamics of ubiquitin conjugation during erythroid differentiation in vitro

To gain insight into the role of ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis in erythroid differentiation, levels of ubiquitin conjugating enzymes (E2s) and ubiquitin conjugates were analyzed during in vitro differentiation of murine erythroleukemic (MEL) cells. After 4 days of culture in the presence of the inducer dimethyl sulfoxide, MEL cells expressed high levels of the erythroid-specific proteins, globin, and band 3. During the same interval, cellular contents (mol/cell) of E2-14K, E2-25K, and E2-35K decreased up to approximately 5-fold; as suggested by results obtained with E2-25K, this reflected a lower level of mRNA in differentiating cells. Concentrations of these E2s changed more modestly during in vitro differentiation, since cellular volume also decreased. Comparison of levels of the three E2s in undifferentiated MEL cells and reticulocytes suggests that their concentrations remain fairly constant during in vivo differentiation of proerythroblasts into reticulocytes. Thus, these components of the ubiquitin-mediated proteolytic pathway are likely to function constitutively during this interval. Two-dimensional Western blots showed a broad spectrum of ubiquitin conjugates, including free multiubiquitin chains, in undifferentiated MEL cells. As seen for several E2s, the concentration of ubiquitin conjugates (including free chains) decreased modestly during in vitro differentiation. E2-20K and E2-230K, which are abundant in reticulocytes, were low or absent in undifferentiated and differentiated MEL cells. In erythroid cells these two E2s are reticulocyte-specific; apparently MEL cells do not differentiate far enough to allow induction of their expression.

The soluble but not mitochondrially bound hexokinase is a substrate for the ATP- and ubiquitin-dependent proteolytic system

Intracellular protein degradation is highly selective, however, the mechanism(s) underlying this selectivity are not fully understood. We have previously shown that purified rabbit hexokinase type I, an enzyme present in mammalian brain both in soluble and mitochondrial bound form, is conjugate to ubiquitin and then degraded by a rabbit reticulocyte fraction II. In the present study we report that the mitochondrial bound hexokinase is stable for several hours in the same proteolytic system both in the presence or absence of ATP. E1, E2 and E3, the enzymes of the ubiquitin conjugating system, are able to incorporate 125I- or biotin-labelled ubiquitin in an ATP-dependent manner in soluble hexokinase as well as in a number of mitochondrial proteins. Furthermore, the mitochondria by themselves have a pronounced ATP-dependent ability to conjugate 125I-ubiquitin. However, Western blotting experiments, using a specific antibody against hexokinase, or against ubiquitin, showed that the mitochondrial bound enzyme is neither ubiquitinated nor degraded. This result has been confirmed by purification of bound hexokinase from the brain mitochondrial fraction or following the incubation of intact mitochondria with ATP, 125I-ubiquitin and E1, E2 and E3. Thus, mitochondrial bound hexokinase is not recognized by the ubiquitin conjugating system while the soluble enzyme is conjugate to ubiquitin and then degraded. Furthermore, the soluble hexokinase from rabbit brain was isolated by immunoaffinity chromatography and shown to be recognized by an anti-ubiquitin antibody. These results suggest that the intracellular distribution of protein is an important feature of a protein which determines its susceptibility to ubiquitin-dependent degradation.