Histone H1-mediated inhibition of transcription initiation of methylated templates in vitro

Nuclear Phosphoinositides-Versatile Regulators of Genome Functions

The many functions of phosphoinositides in cytosolic signaling were extensively studied; however, their activities in the cell nucleus are much less clear. In this review, we summarize data about their nuclear localization and metabolism, and review the available literature on their involvements in chromatin remodeling, gene transcription, and RNA processing. We discuss the molecular mechanisms via which nuclear phosphoinositides, in particular phosphatidylinositol (4,5)-bisphosphate (PI(4,5)P2), modulate nuclear processes. We focus on PI(4,5)P2’s role in the modulation of RNA polymerase I activity, and functions of the nuclear lipid islets—recently described nucleoplasmic PI(4,5)P2-rich compartment involved in RNA polymerase II transcription. In conclusion, the high impact of the phosphoinositide–protein complexes on nuclear organization and genome functions is only now emerging and deserves further thorough studies.

Spatial heterogeneity of dynamics of H1 linker histone

Linker histone H1 participates in maintaining higher order chromatin structures. It is a dynamic protein that binds to DNA and exchanges rapidly with a mobile pool. Therefore, the dynamics of H1 were probed in the nuclei of intact, live cells, using an array of microscopy techniques: fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP), raster image correlation spectroscopy (RICS), fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS), pair correlation functions (pCF) and fluorescence anisotropy. Combination of these techniques yielded information on H1 dynamics at small (1–100 μs: FCS, RICS, anisotropy), moderate (1–100 ms: FCS, RICS, pCF) and large (1–100 s: pCF and FRAP) time scales. These results indicate that the global movement of H1 in nuclei (at distances >1 µm) occurs at the time scale of seconds and is determined by processes other than diffusion. Moreover, a fraction of H1, which remains immobile at the time scale of tenths of seconds, is detectable. However, local (at distances <0.7 µm) H1 dynamics comprises a process occurring at a short (~3 ms) time scale and multiple processes occurring at longer (10–2,500 ms) scales. The former (fast) process (corresponding probably to H1 diffusion) is more pronounced in the nuclear regions characterized by low H1 concentration, but the latter (slow, attributable to H1 binding) in the regions of high H1 concentration. Furthermore, some regions in nuclei (possibly containing dense chromatin) may constitute barriers that impair or block movement of H1 histones within short (<1 µm) distances.

CpG island chromatin: a platform for gene regulation

The majority of mammalian gene promoters are encompassed within regions of the genome called CpG islands that have an elevated level of non-methylated CpG dinucleotides. Despite over 20 years of study, the precise mechanisms by which CpG islands contribute to regulatory element function remain poorly understood. Recently it has been demonstrated that specific histone modifying enzymes are recruited directly to CpG islands through recognition of non-methylated CpG dinucleotide sequence. These enzymes then impose unique chromatin architecture on CpG islands that distinguish them from the surrounding genome. In the context of this work we discuss how CpG island elements may contribute to the function of gene regulatory elements through the utilization of chromatin and epigenetic processes.

CpG islands recruit a histone H3 lysine 36 demethylase

In higher eukaryotes, up to 70% of genes have high levels of nonmethylated cytosine/guanine base pairs (CpGs) surrounding promoters and gene regulatory units. These features, called CpG islands, were identified over 20 years ago, but there remains little mechanistic evidence to suggest how these enigmatic elements contribute to promoter function, except that they are refractory to epigenetic silencing by DNA methylation. Here we show that CpG islands directly recruit the H3K36-specific lysine demethylase enzyme KDM2A. Nucleation of KDM2A at these elements results in removal of H3K36 methylation, creating CpG island chromatin that is uniquely depleted of this modification. KDM2A utilizes a zinc finger CxxC (ZF-CxxC) domain that preferentially recognizes nonmethylated CpG DNA, and binding is blocked when the CpG DNA is methylated, thus constraining KDM2A to nonmethylated CpG islands. These data expose a straightforward mechanism through which KDM2A delineates a unique architecture that differentiates CpG island chromatin from bulk chromatin.

DNA methylation affects nuclear organization, histone modifications, and linker histone binding but not chromatin compaction

DNA methylation has been implicated in chromatin condensation and nuclear organization, especially at sites of constitutive heterochromatin. How this is mediated has not been clear. In this study, using mutant mouse embryonic stem cells completely lacking in DNA methylation, we show that DNA methylation affects nuclear organization and nucleosome structure but not chromatin compaction. In the absence of DNA methylation, there is increased nuclear clustering of pericentric heterochromatin and extensive changes in primary chromatin structure. Global levels of histone H3 methylation and acetylation are altered, and there is a decrease in the mobility of linker histones. However, the compaction of both bulk chromatin and heterochromatin, as assayed by nuclease digestion and sucrose gradient sedimentation, is unaltered by the loss of DNA methylation. This study shows how the complete loss of a major epigenetic mark can have an impact on unexpected levels of chromatin structure and nuclear organization and provides evidence for a novel link between DNA methylation and linker histones in the regulation of chromatin structure.

Sensing DNA methylation in the protozoan parasite Entamoeba histolytica

In the protozoan parasite Entamoeba histolytica, 5-methylcytosine (m5C) was found predominantly in repetitive elements. Its formation is catalysed by Ehmeth, a DNA methyltransferase that belongs to the Dnmt2 subfamily. Here we describe a 32 kDa nuclear protein that binds in vitro with higher affinity to the methylated form of a DNA encoding a reverse transcriptase of an autonomous non-long-terminal repeat retrotransposon (RT LINE) compared with the non-methylated RT LINE. This protein, named E. histolytica-methylated LINE binding protein (EhMLBP), was purified from E. histolytica nuclear lysate, identified by mass spectrometry, and its corresponding gene was cloned. EhMLBP corresponds to a gene of unknown function that shares strong homology with putative proteins present in Entamoeba dispar and Entamoeba invadens. In contrast, the homology dropped dramatically when non-Entamoebidae sequences were considered and only a weak sequence identity was found with Trypanosoma and several prokaryotic histone H1. Recombinant EhMLBP showed the same binding preference for methylated RT LINE as the endogenous EhMLBP. Deletion mapping analysis localized the DNA binding region at the C-terminal part of the protein. This region is sufficient to assure the binding to methylated RT LINE with high affinity. Western blot and immunofluorescence microscopy, using an antibody raised against EhMLBP, showed that it has a nuclear localization. Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) confirmed that EhMLBP interacts with RT LINE in vivo. Finally, we showed that EhMLBP can also bind rDNA episome, a DNA that is methylated in the parasite. This suggests that EhMLBP may serve as a sensor of methylated repetitive DNA. This is the first report of a DNA-methylated binding activity in protozoa.

Histone H1 represses estrogen receptor alpha transcriptional activity by selectively inhibiting receptor-mediated transcription initiation

Chromatin is the physiological template for many nuclear processes in eukaryotes, including transcription by RNA polymerase II. In vivo, chromatin is assembled from genomic DNA, core histones, linker histones such as histone H1, and nonhistone chromatin-associated proteins. Histone H1 is thought to act as a general repressor of transcription by promoting the compaction of chromatin into higher-order structures. We have used a biochemical approach, including an in vitro chromatin assembly and transcription system, to examine the effects of histone H1 on estrogen receptor alpha (ER alpha)-mediated transcription with chromatin templates. We show that histone H1 acts as a potent repressor of ligand- and coactivator-regulated transcription by ER alpha. Histone H1 exerts its repressive effect without inhibiting the sequence-specific binding of ER alpha to chromatin or the overall extent of targeted acetylation of nucleosomal histones by the coactivator p300. Instead, histone H1 acts by blocking a specific step in the ER alpha-dependent transcription process, namely, transcription initiation, without affecting transcription reinitiation. Together, our data indicate that histone H1 acts selectively to reduce the overall level of productive transcription initiation by restricting promoter accessibility and preventing the ER alpha-dependent formation of a stable transcription pre-initiation complex.

DNA methylation in genomic imprinting, development, and disease

Changes in DNA methylation profiles are common features of development and in a number of human diseases, such as cancer and imprinting disorders like Beckwith-Wiedemann and Prader-Willi/Angelman syndromes. This suggests that DNA methylation is required for proper gene regulation during development and in differentiated tissues and has clinical relevance. DNA methylation is also involved in X-chromosome inactivation and the allele-specific silencing of imprinted genes. This review describes possible mechanisms by which DNA methylation can regulate gene expression, using imprinted genes as examples. The molecular basis of methylation-mediated gene regulation is related to changes in chromatin structure and appears to be similar for both imprinted and biallelically expressed genes.

Linker histone binding and displacement: versatile mechanism for transcriptional regulation

In recent years, the connection between chromatin structure and its transcriptional activity has attracted considerable experimental effort. The post-translational modifications to both the core histones and the linker histones are finely tuned through interactions with transcriptional regulators and change chromatin structure in a way to allow transcription to occur. Here we review evidence for the involvement of linker histones in transcriptional regulation and suggest a scenario in which the reversible and controllable binding/displacement of proteins of this class to the nucleosome entry/exit point determine the accessibility of the nucleosomal DNA to the transcriptional machinery.

Dynamic analysis of proviral induction and De Novo methylation: implications for a histone deacetylase-independent, methylation density-dependent mechanism of transcriptional repression

Methylation of cytosines in the CpG dinucleotide is generally associated with transcriptional repression in mammalian cells, and recent findings implicate histone deacetylation in methylation-mediated repression. Analyses of histone acetylation in in vitro-methylated transfected plasmids support this model; however, little is known about the relationships among de novo DNA methylation, transcriptional repression, and histone acetylation state. To examine these relationships in vivo, we have developed a novel approach that permits the isolation and expansion of cells harboring expressing or silent retroviruses. MEL cells were infected with a Moloney murine leukemia virus encoding the green fluorescent protein (GFP), and single-copy, silent proviral clones were treated weekly with the histone deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin A or the DNA methylation inhibitor 5-azacytidine. Expression was monitored concurrently by flow cytometry, allowing for repeated phenotypic analysis over time, and proviral methylation was determined by Southern blotting and bisulfite methylation mapping. Shortly after infection, proviral expression was inducible and the reporter gene and proviral enhancer showed a low density of methylation. Over time, the efficacy of drug induction diminished, coincident with the accumulation of methyl-CpGs across the provirus. Bisulfite analysis of cells in which 5-azacytidine treatment induced GFP expression revealed measurable but incomplete demethylation of the provirus. Repression could be overcome in late-passage clones only by pretreatment with 5-azacytidine followed by trichostatin A, suggesting that partial demethylation reestablishes the trichostatin-inducible state. These experiments reveal the presence of a silencing mechanism which acts on densely methylated DNA and appears to function independently of histone deacetylase activity.

Relationships between chromatin organization and DNA methylation in determining gene expression

Chromatin is the natural substrate for the control of gene expression. Chromatin contains DNA, the transcriptional machinery and structural proteins such as histones. Recent advances demonstrate that transcriptional activity of a gene is largely controlled by the packaging of the template within chromatin. The covalent modification of chromatin provides an attractive mechanism for establishing and maintaining stable states of gene activity. DNA methylation and histone acetylation alter the nucleosomal infrastructure to repress or activate transcription. These covalent modifications have causal roles in both promoter-specific events and the global control of chromosomal activity. DNA methylation and histone acetylation have a major impact in both oncogenic transformation and normal development.

Association of 5' CpG demethylation and altered chromatin structure in the promoter region with transcriptional activation of the multidrug resistance 1 gene in human cancer cells

Selection of human cells for resistance to vincristine or doxorubicin often induces overexpression of the multidrug resistance 1 gene (MDR1), which encodes the cell surface P-glycoprotein, as a result of gene amplification or transcriptional activation. However, the precise mechanism underlying such transcriptional activation of MDR1 remains unclear. The relation between methylation status of CpG sites in the MDR1 promoter region and transcriptional activation of MDR1 has now been investigated. The P-glycoprotein-overexpressing, multidrug-resistant KB/VJ300 and KB-C1 cells, which were established from human cancer KB3-1 cells, were examined; MDR1 is transcriptionally activated but not amplified in KB/VJ300 cells, whereas it is amplified in KB-C1 cells. Determination of the methylation status revealed that the MDR1 promoter region was hypomethylated in KB/VJ300 and KB-C1 cells, but hypermethylated in KB3-1 cells. Prior treatment of KB3-1 cells with the DNA methyltransferase inhibitor 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine resulted in a 90-fold increase in the frequency of vincristine-resistance. Of three lines, KB/CdR-1, KB/CdR-2, and KB/CdR-3, established from KB3-1 cells after exposure to 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine, MspI/HpaII sites in the MDR1 promoter region were hypomethylated in KB/CdR-1 and KB/CdR-2 cells, but not in KB/CdR-3 cells. MDR1 mRNA expression was detected in KB/CdR-1 and KB/CdR-2 cells, but not in KB/CdR-3 cells. The binding of YB-1 and Sp1, transcription factors implicated in MDR1 expression, in the MDR1 promoter was not affected by the methylation status of a neighboring CpG sites. The MDR1 promoter region in KB/VJ300 cells showed an increased sensitivity to DNase I compared with that in KB3-1 cells, suggesting an altered chromatin structure. The methylation status of the promoter region may plays an important role in MDR1 overexpression and in acquisition of the P-glycoprotein-mediated multidrug resistance phenotype.

Methylation in the initiation region of the first exon suppresses collagen pro-alpha2(I) gene transcription

Our previous studies demonstrated that the collagen alpha2(I) gene is hypermethylated in the promoter/first exon region after chemical transformation and the alpha2(I) promoter/first exon is sensitive to methylation in transfection studies. In this paper, we demonstrate that a minimum collagen promoter containing the preinitiation region (-41 to +54) driving luciferase reporter gene was inactivated by DNA methylation as judged by transfection assays. All the methylation sites within the preinitiation region were located in the first exon, not in the promoter. Methylation of the promoter construct inhibited transcription as determined by an in vitro assay, only if proteins were extracted from nuclei using 500 mM NaCl. Gel mobility shift analysis suggested that methylation within the first exon decreased the formation of the largest preinitiation complex while increasing the formation of faster migrating protein-DNA complexes. Competition gel mobility shift analysis indicated that the faster migrating protein-DNA complex could be competed by a smaller initiator probe which did not contain TATA binding region. A protein-DNA complex with increased affinity to methylated sequences was detected using the initiator probe, which contained two methylation sites and no TATA sequence (-25 to 30) suggesting that a separate repressor complex binds to the methylated sequences. Mutations at the methylation sites (+7, +23) in the first exon also increased the protein-DNA complex formation in gel shift analysis and inhibited collagen alpha2(I) transcription as judged by transient transfection and in vitro transcription assays. Therefore, these methylation sites in the preinitiation region are important for transcription of alpha2(I) gene and the protein responsible for the repression of transcription is extractable using high salt nuclear extracts.

DNA demethylation: turning genes on

The regulation of eukaryotic gene expression is a complicated process involving the interaction of a large number of transacting factors with specific cis-regulatory elements. DNA methylation plays a role in this scheme by acting in cis to modulate protein-DNA interactions. Several lines of evidence indicate that methylation serves to silence transcription, mainly through indirect mechanisms involving the assembly of repressive nucleoprotein complexes. DNA demethylation is mostly an active enzymatic process, controlled by cis regulatory elements which provide binding sites for trans demethylation factors. In the immune system DNA methylation plays multiple roles, such as regulating both gene expression and gene rearrangement

Involvement of DNA methylation in human carcinogenesis

It is now generally accepted that the presence of 5-methylcytosine (5mC) in human DNA has both a genetic and an epigenetic effect on cellular development, differentiation and transformation. First, 5mC is more unstable than its unmethylated counterpart cytosine. Hydrolytic deamination of 5mC leads to a G/T mismatch and subsequently, if unrepaired, to a C-->T transition mutation. Sites of DNA methylation are mutational hotspots in many human tumors. Second, DNA methylation of promoter regions is often correlated with the down regulation of the corresponding gene. Both of these effects have fundamental consequences for basic functions of the cell like cellular differentiation, the development of cancer and possibly other diseases, and on the evolutionary process. Recent hypotheses also propose a role for methylation in the process of aging. In this review we will describe recent findings and hypotheses about the function of 5mC in DNA with the focus on its involvement in human carcinogenesis.

A genomic element within the third intron of the human oxytocin receptor gene may be involved in transcriptional suppression

The human oxytocin receptor (OTR) gene comprises a large (> 10 kb) third intron between the regions encoding the transmembrane domains six and seven. It has been shown for other genes that transcriptional control elements may reside within such introns, and that these may correlate with changes in the methylation status of the DNA. Methylation mapping indeed indicated that within this third intron there was a region which appeared to be hypermethylated in non-expressing tissues, but relatively hypomethylated in the myometrium of the cycle and at term, when the OTR gene is upregulated. We then employed in vitro nuclear protein-DNA binding assays to evaluate the importance of this region in the control of the human OTR gene. As source of nuclear proteins we have compared a non-expressing tissue, human peripheral blood leucocytes, with human myometrium from the cycle (low expression) and from term pregnancy (high expression). It could be shown that a specific motif of ca. 10-15 nucleotides close to the middle of the third intron specifically binds nuclear proteins correlating with the down-regulated state of the gene. The accumulated data suggest that this intronic element is specifically binding nuclear protein(s) associated with a suppression of OTR gene activity.

Methylation of the minimal promoter of an embryonic globin gene silences transcription in primary erythroid cells

Methylation of cytosines in the dinucleotide CpG has been shown to suppress transcription of a number of tissue-specific genes, yet the precise mechanism is not fully understood. The vertebrate globin genes were among the first examples in which an inverse correlation was shown between CpG methylation and transcription. We studied the methylation pattern of the 235-bp rho-globin gene promoter in genomic DNA from primary chicken erythroid cells using the sodium bisulfite conversion technique and found all CpGs in the promoter to be methylated in erythroid cells from adult chickens in which the rho-globin gene is silent but unmethylated in 5-day (primitive) embryonic red cells in which the gene is transcribed. To elucidate further the mechanism of methylation-induced silencing, an expression construct consisting of 235 bp of 5' promoter sequence of the rho-globin gene along with a strong 5' erythroid enhancer driving a chloramphenicol acetyltransferase reporter gene, rho-CAT, was transfected into primary avian erythroid cells derived from 5-day embryos. Methylation of just the 235-bp rho-globin gene promoter fragment at every CpG resulted in a 20- to 30-fold inhibition of transcription, and this effect was not overridden by the presence of potent erythroid-specific enhancers. The ability of the 235-bp rho-globin gene promoter to bind to a DNA Methyl Cytosine binding Protein Complex (MeCPC) was tested in electrophoretic mobility shift assays utilizing primary avian erythroid cell nuclear extract. The results were that fully methylated but not unmethylated 235-bp rho-globin gene promoter fragment could compete efficiently for MeCPC binding. These results are a direct demonstration that site-specific methylation of a globin gene promoter at the exact CpGs that are methylated in vivo can silence transcription in homologous primary erythroid cells. Further, these data implicate binding of MeCPC to the promoter in the mechanism of silencing.

How does DNA methylation repress transcription?

DNA methylation has an essential regulatory function in mammalian development, serving to repress nontranscribed genes stably in differentiated adult somatic cells. Recent data implicate transcriptional repressors specific for methylated DNA and chromatin assembly in this global control of gene activity. The assembly of specialized nucleosomal structures on methylated DNA helps to explain the capacity of methylated DNA segments to silence transcription more effectively than conventional chromatin. Specialized nucleosomes also provide a potential molecular mechanism for the stable propagation of DNA methylation-dependent transcriptional silencing through cell division.

DNA methylation directs a time-dependent repression of transcription initiation

BACKGROUND

The regulation of DNA methylation is required for differential expression of imprinted genes during vertebrate development. Earlier studies that monitored the activity of the Herpes simplex virus (HSV) thymidine kinase (tk) gene after injection into rodent cells have suggested that assembly of chromatin influences the methylation-dependent repression of gene activity. Here, we examine the mechanism of methylation-dependent HSV tk gene regulation by direct determination of nucleoprotein organization during the establishment of a transcriptionally silenced state after microinjection of templates with defined methylation states into Xenopus oocyte nuclei.

RESULTS

The transcriptional silencing conferred by a methylated DNA segment was not immediate, as methylated templates were initially assembled into active transcription complexes. The eventual loss of DNase I hypersenitive sites and inhibition of transcription at the HSV tk promoter only occurred after several hours. Flanking methylated vector DNA silenced the adjacent unmethylated HSV tk promoter, indicative of a dominant transmissible repression originating from a center of methylation. The resulting repressive nucleoprotein structure silenced transcription in the presence of activators that are able to overcome repression of transcription by nucleosomes.

CONCLUSIONS

Silencing of transcription by DNA methylation is achieved at the level of transcription initiation and involves the removal of transcriptional machinery from active templates. This transcriptional repression can occur by indirect mechanisms involving the time-dependent assembly of repressive nucleoprotein complexes, which are able to inhibit transcription more effectively than nucleosomes alone.

MeCP2 is a transcriptional repressor with abundant binding sites in genomic chromatin

MeCP2 is an abundant mammalian protein that binds to methylated CpG. We have found that native and recombinant MeCP2 repress transcription in vitro from methylated promoters but do not repress nonmethylated promoters. Repression is nonlinearly dependent on the local density of methylation, becoming significant at the density found in bulk vertebrate genomic DNA. Transient transfection using fusions with the GAL4 DNA binding domain identified a region of MeCP2 that is capable of long-range repression in vivo. Moreover, MeCP2 is able to displace histone H1 from preassembled chromatin that contains methyl-CpG. These properties, together with the abundance of MeCP2 and the high frequency of its 2 bp binding site, suggest a role as a global transcriptional repressor in vertebrate genomes.

Histone H1 in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The existence of histone H1 in the yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, has long been debated. In this report we describe the presence of histone H1 in yeast. YPL127c, a gene encoding a protein with a high degree of similarity to histone H1 from other species was sequenced as part of the contribution of the Montreal Yeast Genome Sequencing Group to chromosome XVI. To reflect this similarity, the gene designation has been changed HHO1 (Histone H One). The HHO1 gene is highly expressed as poly A+ RNA in yeast. Although deletion of this gene had no detectable effect on cell growth, viability or mating, it significantly altered the expression of beta-galactosidase from a CYC1-lacZ reporter. Fluorescence observed in cells expressing a histone H1-GFP protein fusion indicated that histone H1 is localized to the nucleus.

A high-resolution analysis of chromatin structure along p53 sequences

A detailed investigation of how nucleosomes are formed and arranged on the DNA sequence is a prerequisite to understanding the molecular mechanisms of DNA-dependent processes such as transcription, replication, DNA repair, and mutagenesis. In this report we analyzed the chromatin structure of exons 5-8 of the p53 gene in human fibroblasts. We mapped at the nucleotide level the positions of DNase I and micrococcal nuclease cleavage sites in permeabilized cells. Areas of clear DNase I protection, which would be indicative of the binding of sequence-specific proteins, were not detected. Instead, the micrococcal nuclease and DNase digestion patterns suggested that this region was covered by nucleosomes and that two areas spanning exons 5 and 6 are occupied preferentially. These nucleosomes could influence DNA damage distribution, repair of certain lesions, and other aspects of the mutagenesis process in p53 sequences.

Nucleosome assembly on methylated CGG triplet repeats in the fragile X mental retardation gene 1 promoter

Expansion and methylation of CGG repeat sequences is associated with Fragile X syndrome in humans. We have examined the consequences of CGG repeat expansion and methylation for nucleosome assembly and positioning on the Fragile X Mental Retardation gene 1 (FMR1) gene. Short unmethylated CGG repeats are not particularly favored in terms of affinity for the histone octamer or for positioning of the reconstituted nucleosome. However, upon methylation their affinity for the histone octamer increases and a highly positioned nucleosome assembles with the repeat sequences found adjacent to the nucleosomal dyad. Expansion of these CGG repeats abolishes the preferential nucleosome assembly due to methylation. Thus, the expansion and methylation of these triplet repeats can alter the functional organization of chromatin, which may contribute to alterations in the expression of the FMR1 gene and the disease phenotype.

Transcriptional repression by methylation: cooperativity between a CpG cluster in the promoter and remote CpG-rich regions

Cytosine methylation of binding sites for transcription factors is a straightforward mechanism to prevent transcription, while data on an indirect mechanism, by methylation outside of the factor binding sites, are still scarce. We have studied the latter effect using a model promoter construct. For this, a 69 bp G + C rich DNA segment with a cluster of 14 CpG sites was inserted between upstream lexA sites and the TATA box. Transcription was measured in transient transfection assays with lexA-VP16 as an activating factor. When the entire plasmid was methylated at all CpGs before transfection, transcription was blocked (to 3% residual activity), whereas transcription was only mildly inhibited (to 60%) by methylation of a control plasmid that lacked the 69 bp CpG cluster. However, the effect could not simply be attributed to methylation of the CpG cluster: neither a methylated CpG cluster in an otherwise methylation-free reporter gene plasmid, nor the methylated plasmid with an unmethylated CpG cluster, inhibited transcription considerably (69% and 44% remaining activity, respectively). The data presented here suggest that a minimal length of methylated DNA in the promoter is required for repression, and imply that concomitant methylation of CpGs in the promoter region and in remote sequences can cooperatively block transcription, without the need to methylate any binding sites for transcription factors. We also note that the cooperation for a negative effect described here bears an analogy to transcriptional activation, where a promoter often cooperates with a remote enhancer.

Differential sensitivity of zinc finger transcription factors MTF-1, Sp1 and Krox-20 to CpG methylation of their binding sites

Cytosine methylation at CpG sites is often negatively correlated with mammalian gene activity. Many transcription factors whose DNA binding site contains one or more CpG dinucleotides are no longer able to efficiently bind DNA when the site is methylated. A notable exception is the zinc finger factor Sp1 which binds DNA and activates transcription even when its binding site is methylated. Here we show that two other zinc finger factors, MTF-1 and Krox-20, can also bind to CpG methylated sites. MTF-1 regulates metallothionein gene transcription by binding to a number of metal responsive elements (MREs), and Krox-20 regulates Hox genes during hindbrain segmentation. However, a refined analysis of MTF-1/MRE binding shows that methylation is not tolerated at every binding site: the highest affinity site in the mouse metallothionein I gene, MREd, is unaffected by methylation, while two other MRE sites with CpGs at different positions are rendered partially or completely nonfunctional by methylation. Both methylation sensitive and insensitive factors/binding sites are likely to determine the developmental expression pattern of a gene.

The DNA methylation machinery as a target for anticancer therapy

DNA methylation is now recognized as an important mechanism regulating different functions of the genome; gene expression, replication, and cancer. Different factors control the formation and maintenance of DNA methylation patterns. The level of activity of DNA methyltransferase (MeTase) is one factor. Recent data suggest that some oncogenic pathways can induce DNA MeTase expression, that DNA MeTase activity is elevated in cancer, and that inhibition of DNA MeTase can reverse the transformed state. What are the pharmacological consequences of our current understanding of DNA methylation patterns formation? This review will discuss the possibility that DNA MeTase inhibitors can serve as important pharmacological and therapeutic tools in cancer and other genetic diseases.

Binding of histone H1 to DNA is indifferent to methylation at CpG sequences

The possibility that histone H1 binds preferentially to DNA containing 5-methylcytosine in the dinucleotide CpG is appealing, as it could help to explain the repressive effects of methylation on gene activity. In this study, the affinity of purified H1 for methylated and non-methylated DNA sequences has been tested using both naked DNA and chromatin. Based on a variety of assays (bandshifts, filter-binding assays, Southwestern blots, and nuclease sensitivity assays), we conclude that H1 has no significant preference for binding to naked methylated DNA. Similarly, H1 showed the same affinities for methylated and non-methylated DNA when assembled into chromatin in a Xenopus oocyte extract. Thus potential cooperative interaction of H1 with polynucleosomal complexes is not enhanced by the presence of DNA methylation.

Electrophoresis of chromatin on nondenaturing agarose gels containing Mg2+. Self-assembly of small chromatin fragments and folding of the 30-nm fiber

We show that nondenaturing agarose gels can be used for the study of the structure and dynamic properties of native (uncross-linked) chromatin. In gels containing 1.7 mM Mg2+, chicken erythrocyte chromatin fragments having from about 6 to 50 nucleosomes produce well defined bands. These bands have an electrophoretic mobility that decreases only slightly with molecular weight. This surprising behavior is not observed in low ionic strength gels. Fragments with less than 6 nucleosomes and low content of histones H1-H5 give rise to broad bands in gels with Mg2+. In contrast, fragments containing only 3-4 nucleosomes but with the normal H1-H5 content are able to form associated structures with a mobility similar to that observed for high molecular weight chromatin. Electron microscopy results indicate that the associated fragments and the fragments of higher molecular weight show similar electrophoretic properties because they become very compact in the presence of Mg2+ and form cylindrical structures with a diameter of approximately 33 nm. Our results suggest that the interactions involved in the self-assembly of small fragments are the same that direct the folding of larger fragments; in both cases, the resulting compact chromatin structure is formed from a basic element containing 5-7 nucleosomes.

Methylation at CpG sequences does not influence histone H1 binding to a nucleosome including a Xenopus borealis 5 S rRNA gene

We demonstrate that methylation of the 12 dinucleotide CpGs within a GC-rich DNA fragment containing a Xenopus borealis 5 S rRNA gene does not influence histone H1 binding to naked or nucleosomal 5 S DNA. Thus a simple mechanism in which histone H1 selectively associates with nucleosomes containing methylated CpG cannot explain the repressive effects of methylation on gene activity.

Role of DNA methylation in the regulation of transcription

DNA methylation plays an important role in the regulation of gene expression during development. Methyl moieties at CpG residues suppress transcription by affecting DNA-protein interactions, thus altering the accessibility of genes to trans-acting factors in the cell. Because it works in cis, this mechanism is important in the control of X inactivation and genomic imprinting.