New family of glutathionyl-biomimetic ligands for affinity chromatography of glutathione-recognising enzymes

Biomimetic Affinity Ligands for Protein Purification

The development of sophisticated molecular modeling software and new bioinformatic tools, as well as the emergence of data banks containing detailed information about a huge number of proteins, enabled the de novo intelligent design of synthetic affinity ligands. Such synthetic compounds can be tailored to mimic natural biological recognition motifs or to interact with key surface-exposed residues on target proteins, and are designated as "biomimetic ligands". A well-established methodology for generating biomimetic or synthetic affinity ligands integrates rational design with combinatorial solid-phase synthesis and screening, using the triazine scaffold and analogs of amino acid side chains to create molecular diversity.Triazine-based synthetic ligands are nontoxic, low-cost, and highly stable compounds that can replace advantageously natural biological ligands in the purification of proteins by affinity-based methodologies.

Biomimetic affinity ligands for protein purification

The development of sophisticated molecular modeling software and new bioinformatic tools, as well as the emergence of data banks containing detailed information about a huge number of proteins, enabled the de novo intelligent design of synthetic affinity ligands. Such synthetic compounds can be tailored to mimic natural biological recognition motifs or to interact with key surface-exposed residues on target proteins and are designated as "biomimetic ligands." A well-established methodology for generating biomimetic or synthetic affinity ligands integrates rational design with combinatorial solid-phase synthesis and screening, using the triazine scaffold and analogues of amino acids side chains to create molecular diversity.Triazine-based synthetic ligands are nontoxic, low-cost, highly stable compounds that can replace advantageously natural biological ligands in the purification of proteins by affinity-based methodologies.

Combinatorial de novo design and application of a biomimetic affinity ligand for the purification of human anti-HIV mAb 4E10 from transgenic tobacco

Monoclonal anti-HIV antibody 4E10 (mAb 4E10) is one of the most broadly neutralizing antibodies against HIV, directed against a specific epitope on envelope protein gp41. In the present study, a combinatorial de novo design approach was used for the development of a biomimetic ligand for the affinity purification of mAb 4E10 from tobacco transgenic extract in a single chromatographic step. The biomimetic ligand (4E10lig) was based on a L-Phe/beta-Ala bi-substituted 1,3,5-triazine (Trz) scaffold (beta-Ala-Trz-L-Phe, 4E10lig) which potentially mimics the more pronounced electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions of mAb 4E10-binding sequence determined by screening of a random peptide library. This library was comprised of Escherichia coli cells harboring a plasmid (pFlitrx) engineered to express a fusion protein containing random dodecapeptides that were inserted into the active loop of thioredoxin, which itself was inserted into the dispensable region of the flagellin gene. Adsorption equilibrium studies with this biomimetic ligand and mAb 4E10 determined a dissociation constant (K(D)) of 0.41 +/- 0.05 microM. Molecular modeling studies of the biomimetic ligand revealed that it can potentially occupy the same binding site as the natural binding core peptide epitope. The biomimetic affinity adsorbent was exploited in the development of a facile mAb 4E10 purification protocol, affording mAb 4E10 of high purity (approximately 95%) with good overall yield (60-80%). Analysis of the antibody preparation by SDS-PAGE, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA), and western blot showed that the mAb 4E10 was fully active and free of degraded variants, polyphenols, and alkaloids.

Crystallographic and functional characterization of the fluorodifen-inducible glutathione transferase from Glycine max reveals an active site topography suited for diphenylether herbicides and a novel L-site

Glutathione transferases (GSTs) from the tau class (GSTU) are unique to plants and have important roles in stress tolerance and the detoxification of herbicides in crops and weeds. A fluorodifen-induced GST isoezyme (GmGSTU4-4) belonging to the tau class was purified from Glycine max by affinity chromatography. This isoenzyme was cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli, and its structural and catalytic properties were investigated. The structure of GmGSTU4-4 was determined at 1.75 A resolution in complex with S-(p-nitrobenzyl)-glutathione (Nb-GSH). The enzyme adopts the canonical GST fold but with a number of functionally important differences. Compared with other plant GSTs, the three-dimensional structure of GmGSTU4-4 primarily shows structural differences in the hydrophobic substrate binding site, the linker segment and the C-terminal region. The X-ray structure identifies key amino acid residues in the hydrophobic binding site (H-site) and provides insights into the substrate specificity and catalytic mechanism of the enzyme. The isoenzyme was highly active in conjugating the diphenylether herbicide fluorodifen. A possible reaction pathway involving the conjugation of glutathione with fluorodifen is described based on site-directed mutagenesis and molecular modeling studies. A serine residue (Ser13) is present in the active site, at a position that would allow it to stabilise the thiolate anion of glutathione and enhance its nucleophilicity. Tyr107 and Arg111 present in the active site are important structural moieties that modulate the catalytic efficiency and specificity of the enzyme, and participate in k(cat) regulation by affecting the rate-limiting step of the catalytic reaction. A hitherto undescribed ligand-binding site (L-site) located in a surface pocket of the enzyme was also found. This site is formed by conserved residues, suggesting it may have an important functional role in the transfer and delivery of bound ligands, presumably to specific protein receptors.

Affinity Ligand Selection from a Library of Small Molecules: Assay Development, Screening, and Application

A facile and cost-effective process for screening synthetic libraries for an affinity ligand is described. A high throughput 96-well plate filtration method was designed to screen both discrete compounds and mixtures of compounds attached to a solid support. Human serum albumin (HSA) was used as a target protein to demonstrate the proof of concept. Detection and quantitation by fluorescence was accomplished with the use of fluorescamine to conjugate the protein in the filtrate. It is found that mixtures demonstrating low average binding reflect an overall lower hit rate of the components, whereas deconvolution of mixtures with high protein binding consistently provides a high hit rate. This differs from many of the previous experiences screening solid-phase mixtures in which high false positive rates are noted to occur. A total of 100K compounds were tested: 25K as discrete samples and 75K as mixtures. An overall hit rate of 8% was observed. Secondary screening of compounds measured specificity, recovery, and dynamic binding capacity. The effectiveness of the method is illustrated using an affinity column made with a representative lead compound. A similar purity was achieved in a single-step purification of HSA from serum as compared to that obtained by two steps of ion-exchange chromatography. The process for primary screening of a large number of compounds is simple, inexpensive, and applicable to any soluble target protein of known or unknown function from crude mixtures and may have additional utility as a generic chemical affinity tool for the functional characterization of novel proteins emerging from proteomics work.

Lock-and-key motif as a concept for designing affinity adsorbents for protein purification

The lock-and-key (LAK) motif, a common structural moiety found in subunit interfaces of glutathione S-transferases (GSTs), plays an important role in biomolecular recognition and quaternary structure integrity. Inspection of the key structural features of the LAK motif prompted the de novo design and combinatorial synthesis of a 13-membered solid-phase ligand library, employing as a lead ligand the Phe-Trz-X structure, mimicking the LAK motif. 1,3,5-Triazine (Trz) was used as the scaffold for assembly, substituted with different LAK-mimetic amino acids. De novo ligand design was effected using bioinformatics and molecular modeling and based on mimicking the interactions of the LAK motif. The library of affinity adsorbents was assessed for binding corn and human serum proteomes and purified proteins of different structure and ligand binding specificity. The results showed remarkable differences in the binding specificity of LAK-mimetic adsorbents for a wide range of proteins, as a consequence of minor changes in ligand structure. One LAK-mimetic adsorbent was integrated in a single-step purification protocol for human monoclonal anti-human immunodeficiency virus 2F5 antibody (mAb 2F5) from spiked corn extract, affording high recovery and purity. The results demonstrate that the principle of natural recognition found in the lock-and-key motif, in combination with de novo combinatorial design, may lead to synthetic affinity ligands, useful in downstream processing and proteomic research.

Nucleotide-mimetic synthetic ligands for DNA-recognizing enzymes One-step purification of Pfu DNA polymerase

The commercial availability of DNA polymerases has revolutionized molecular biotechnology and certain sectors of the bio-industry. Therefore, the development of affinity adsorbents for purification of DNA polymerases is of academic interest and practical importance. In the present study we describe the design, synthesis and evaluation of a combinatorial library of novel affinity ligands for the purification of DNA polymerases (Pols). Pyrococcus furiosus DNA polymerase (Pfu Pol) was employed as a proof-of-principle example. Affinity ligand design was based on mimicking the natural interactions between deoxynucleoside-triphosphates (dNTPs) and the B-motif, a conserved structural moiety found in Pol-I and Pol-II family of enzymes. Solid-phase 'structure-guided' combinatorial chemistry was used to construct a library of 26 variants of the B-motif-binding 'lead' ligand X-Trz-Y (X is a purine derivative and Y is an aliphatic/aromatic sulphonate or phosphonate derivative) using 1,3,5-triazine (Trz) as the scaffold for assembly. The 'lead' ligand showed complementarity against a Lys and a Tyr residue of the polymerase B-motif. The ligand library was screened for its ability to bind and purify Pfu Pol from Escherichia coli extract. One immobilized ligand (oABSAd), bearing 9-aminoethyladenine (AEAd) and sulfanilic acid (oABS) linked on the triazine scaffold, displayed the highest purifying ability and binding capacity (0,55 mg Pfu Pol/g wet gel). Adsorption equilibrium studies with this affinity ligand and Pfu Pol determined a dissociation constant (K(D)) of 83 nM for the respective complex. The oABSAd affinity adsorbent was exploited in the development of a facile Pfu Pol purification protocol, affording homogeneous enzyme (>99% purity) in a single chromatography step. Quality control tests showed that Pfu Pol purified on the B-motif-complementing ligand is free of nucleic acids and contaminating nuclease activities, therefore, suitable for experimental use.

Affinity chromatography matures as bioinformatic and combinatorial tools develop

Affinity chromatography has the reputation of a more expensive and less robust than other types of liquid chromatography. Furthermore, the technique is considered to stand a modest chance of large-scale purification of proteinaceous pharmaceuticals. This perception is changing because of the pressure for quality protein therapeutics, and the realization that higher returns can be expected when ensuring fewer purification steps and increased product recovery. These developments necessitated a rethinking of the protein purification processes and restored the interest for affinity chromatography. This liquid chromatography technique is designed to offer high specificity, being able to safely guide protein manufactures to successfully cope with the aforementioned challenges. Affinity ligands are distinguished into synthetic and biological. These can be generated by rational design or selected from ligand libraries. Synthetic ligands are generated by three methods. The rational method features the functional approach and the structural template approach. The combinatorial method relies on the selection of ligands from a library of synthetic ligands synthesized randomly. The combined method employs both methods, that is, the ligand is selected from an intentionally biased library based on a rationally designed ligand. Biological ligands are selected by employing high-throughput biological techniques, e.g. phage- and ribosome-display for peptide and microprotein ligands, in addition to SELEX for oligonucleotide ligands. Synthetic mimodyes and chimaeric dye-ligands are usually designed by rational approaches and comprise a chloro-triazinlyl scaffold. The latter substituted with various amino acids, carbocyclic, and heterocyclic groups, generates libraries from which synthetic ligands can be selected. A 'lead' compound may help to generating a 'focused' or 'biased' library. This can be designed by various approaches, e.g.: (i) using a natural ligand-protein complex as a template; (ii) applying the principle of complementarity to exposed residues of the protein structure; and (iii) mimicking directly a natural biological recognition interaction. Affinity ligands, based on the peptide structure, can be peptides, peptide-mimetic derivatives (<30 monomers) and microproteins (e.g. 25-200 monomers). Microprotein ligands are selected from biological libraries constructed of variegated protein domains, e.g. minibody, Kunitz, tendamist, cellulose-binding domain, scFv, Cytb562, zinc-finger, SpA-analogue (Z-domain).

Interaction of l-glutamate oxidase with triazine dyes: selection of ligands for affinity chromatography

Glutamate oxidase (GOX, EC 1.4.3.11) from Streptomyces catalyses the oxidation of L-glutamate to alpha-ketoglutarate. Its kinetic constants for L-glutamate were measured equal to 2 mM for Km and 85.8 s(-1) for kcat. BLAST search and amino acid sequence alignments revealed low homology to other L-amino acid oxidases (18-38%). Threading methodology, homology modeling and CASTp analysis resulted in certain conclusions concerning the structure of catalytic alpha-subunit and led to the prediction of a binding pocket that provides favorable conditions of accommodating negatively charged aromatic ligands, such as sulphonated triazine dyes. Eleven commercial textile dyes and four biomimetic dyes or minodyes, bearing a ketocarboxylated-structure as their terminal biomimetic moiety, immobilized on cross-linked agarose gel. The resulted mini-library of affinity adsorbents was screened for binding and eluting L-glutamate oxidase activity. All but Cibacron Blue 3GA (CB3GA) affinity adsorbents were able to bind GOX at pH 5.6. One immobilized minodye-ligand, bearing as its terminal biomimetic moiety p-aminobenzyloxanylic acid (BM1), displayed the higher affinity for GOX. Kinetic inhibition studies showed that BM1 inhibits GOX in a non-competitive manner with a Ki of 10.5 microM, indicating that the dye-enzyme interaction does not involve the substrate-binding site. Adsorption equilibrium data, obtained from a batch system with BM1 adsorbent, corresponded well to the Freundlich isotherm with a rate constant k of 2.7 mg(1/2)ml(1/2)/g and Freundlich isotherm exponent n of 1. The interaction of GOX with the BM1 adsorbent was further studied with regards to adsorption and elution conditions. The results obtained were exploited in the development of a facile purification protocol for GOX, which led to 335-fold purification in a single step with high enzyme recovery (95%). The present purification procedure is the most efficient reported so far for L-glutamate oxidase.

Designed chimaeric galactosyl–mimodye ligands for the purification of Pseudomonas fluorescens β-galactose dehydrogenase

Two chimaeric galactosyl-mimodye ligands were designed and applied to the purification of Pseudomonas fluorescens galactose dehydrogenase (GaDH). The chimaeric affinity ligands comprised a triazine ring on which were anchored: (i) an anthraquinone moiety that pseudomimics the adenine part of NAD+, (ii) a galactosyl-mimetic moiety (D-galactosamine for ligand BM1 or shikimate for ligand BM2), bearing an aliphatic 'linker', that mimics the natural substrate galactose, and (iii) a long hydrophilic 'spacer'. The mimodye-ligands were immobilised to 1,1-carbonyldiimidazole-activated agarose chromatography support, via the spacer's terminal amino-group, to produce the respective mimodye adsorbents. Both immobilized mimodyes successfully bound P. fluorescens GaDH but failed to bind the enzyme from rabbit muscle. Adsorbent BM1 bound GaDH from green peas and Baker's yeast, but adsorbent BM2 failed to do so. The mimodye-ligand comprising D(+)-galactosamine (BM1), compared to BM2, exhibited higher purifying ability and enzyme recovery for P. fluorescens GaDH. The dissociation constants (KD) of BM1 and BM2 for P. fluorescens GaDH were determined by analytical affinity chromatography to be 5.9 microM and 15.4 microM, respectively. The binding capacities of adsorbents BM1 and BM2 were 18 U/mg adsorbent and 6 U/mg adsorbent, respectively. Adsorbents BM1 and BM2 were integrated in two different protocols for the purification P. fluorescens GaDH. Both protocols comprised as a common first step DEAE anion-exchange chromatography, with a second step of affinity chromatography on BM1 or BM2, respectively. The purified GaDH obtained from the protocols using BM1 and BM2 showed specific activities equal to 1077 and 854 U/mg, respectively. The former is the highest reported so far and the enzyme appeared as a single band after sodium dodecylsulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) analysis.

Design and selection of ligands for affinity chromatography

Affinity chromatography is potentially the most selective method for protein purification. The technique has the purification power to eliminate steps, increase yields and thereby improve process economics. However, it suffers from problems regarding ligand stability and cost. Some of the most recent advances in this area have explored the power of rational and combinatorial approaches for designing highly selective and stable synthetic affinity ligands. Rational molecular design techniques, which are based on the ability to combine knowledge of protein structures with defined chemical synthesis and advanced computational tools, have made rational ligand design feasible and faster. Combinatorial approaches based on peptide and nucleic acid libraries have permitted the rapid synthesis of new synthetic affinity ligands of potential use in affinity chromatography. The versatility of these approaches suggests that, in the near future, they will become the dominant methods for designing and selection of novel affinity ligands with scale-up potential.

Galactosyl-mimodye ligands for Pseudomonas fluorescens beta-galactose dehydrogenase

Protein molecular modelling and ligand docking were employed for the design of anthraquinone galactosyl-biomimetic dye ligands (galactosyl-mimodyes) for the target enzyme galactose dehydrogenase (GaDH). Using appropriate modelling methodology, a GaDH model was build based on a glucose-fructose oxidoreductase (GFO) protein template. Subsequent computational analysis predicted chimaeric mimodye-ligands comprising a NAD-pseudomimetic moiety (anthraquinone diaminobenzosulfonic acid) and a galactosyl-mimetic moiety (2-amino-2-deoxygalactose or shikimic acid) bearing an aliphatic 'linker' molecule. In addition, the designed mimodye ligands had an appropriate in length and chemical nature 'spacer' molecule via which they can be attached onto a chromatographic support without steric clashes upon interaction with GaDH. Following their synthesis, purification and analysis, the ligands were immobilized to agarose. The respective affinity adsorbents, compared to other conventional adsorbents, were shown to be superior affinity chromatography materials for the target enzyme, Pseudomonas fluorescensbeta-galactose dehydrogenase. In addition, these mimodye affinity adsorbents displayed good selectivity, binding low amounts of enzymes other than GaDH. Further immobilized dye-ligands, comprising different linker and/or spacer molecules, or not having a biomimetic moiety, had inferior chromatographic behavior. Therefore, these new mimodyes suggested by computational analysis, are candidates for application in affinity labeling and structural studies as well as for purification of galactose dehydrogenase.

Galactosyl-biomimetic dye-ligands for the purification of Dactylium dendroides galactose oxidase

Two anthraquinone galactosyl-biomimetic dye-ligands comprising, as terminal biomimetic moiety, galactose analogues (1-amino-1-deoxy-beta-D-galactose and D(+)-galactosamine) were designed for the enzyme galactose oxidase (GAO), using molecular modelling, synthesized and characterized. The biomimetic ligands were immobilized on agarose beads and the affinity adsorbents, together with a non-biomimetic adsorbent bearing Cibacron Blue 3GA, were studied for their ability to purify GAO from Dactylium dendroides. Both biomimetic adsorbents showed higher purifying ability for GAO compared to the non-biomimetic adsorbent, thus demonstrating their superior effectiveness as affinity chromatography materials. In particular, the affinity adsorbent comprising, as terminal biomimetic moiety, 1-amino-1-deoxy-beta-D-galactose (BM1) exhibited the highest purifying ability for GAO. This affinity adsorbent did not bind galactose dehydrogenase, glucose dehydrogenase, alcohol dehydrogenase, or glucose oxidase. The dissociation constant (K(D)) of the immobilized BM1 ligand with GAO was found to be equal to 45.8 microM, whereas the binding capacity was equal to 709 U per ml adsorbent. Therefore, the BMI adsorbent was integrated in a facile two-step purification procedure for GAO. The purified enzyme showed a specific activity equal to 2038 U/mg, the highest reported so far, approximately 74% overall recovery and a single band after sodium dodecylsulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis.