Coupling of protein assembly and DNA binding: biotin repressor dimerization precedes biotin operator binding

Tuning Allostery through Integration of Disorder to Order with a Residue Network

In allostery, a signal from one site in a protein is transmitted to a second site to alter its function. Due to its ubiquity in biology and the potential for its exploitation in drug and protein design, the molecular basis of allosteric communication continues to be the subject of intense research. Although allosterically coupled sites are frequently characterized by disorder, how communication between disordered segments occurs remains obscure. Allosteric activation of Escherichia coli BirA dimerization occurs via coupled distant disorder-to-order transitions. In this work, combined structural and computational studies reveal an extensive residue network in BirA. Substitution of several network residues yields large perturbations to allostery. Force distribution analysis reveals that disruptions to the disorder-to-order transitions through amino acid substitution are manifested in shifts in the energy experienced by network residues as well as alterations in packing of an α-helix that plays a critical role in allostery. The combined results reveal a highly distributed allosteric mechanism that is robust to sequence change.

Native mass spectrometry identifies an alternative DNA-binding pathway for BirA from Staphylococcus aureus

An adequate supply of biotin is vital for the survival and pathogenesis of Staphylococcus aureus. The key protein responsible for maintaining biotin homeostasis in bacteria is the biotin retention protein A (BirA, also known as biotin protein ligase). BirA is a bi-functional protein that serves both as a ligase to catalyse the biotinylation of important metabolic enzymes, as well as a transcriptional repressor that regulates biotin biosynthesis, biotin transport and fatty acid elongation. The mechanism of BirA regulated transcription has been extensively characterized in Escherichia coli, but less so in other bacteria. Biotin-induced homodimerization of E. coli BirA (EcBirA) is a necessary prerequisite for stable DNA binding and transcriptional repression. Here, we employ a combination of native mass spectrometry, in vivo gene expression assays, site-directed mutagenesis and electrophoretic mobility shift assays to elucidate the DNA binding pathway for S. aureus BirA (SaBirA). We identify a mechanism that differs from that of EcBirA, wherein SaBirA is competent to bind DNA as a monomer both in the presence and absence of biotin and/or MgATP, allowing homodimerization on the DNA. Bioinformatic analysis demonstrated the SaBirA sequence used here is highly conserved amongst other S. aureus strains, implying this DNA-binding mechanism is widely employed.

Long Distance Modulation of Disorder-to-Order Transitions in Protein Allostery

Elucidation of the molecular details of allosteric communication between distant sites in a protein is key to understanding and manipulating many biological regulatory processes. Although protein disorder is acknowledged to play an important thermodynamic role in allostery, the molecular mechanisms by which this disorder is harnessed for long distance communication are known for a limited number of systems. Transcription repression by the Escherichia coli biotin repressor, BirA, is allosterically activated by binding of the small molecule effector biotinoyl-5'-AMP. The effector acts by promoting BirA dimerization, which is a prerequisite for sequence-specific binding to the biotin biosynthetic operon operator sequence. A 30 Å distance separates the effector binding and dimerization surfaces in BirA, and previous studies indicate that allostery is mediated, in part, by disorder-to-order transitions on the two coupled sites. In this work, combined experimental and computational methods have been applied to investigate the molecular basis of allosteric communication in BirA. Double-mutant cycle analysis coupled with thermodynamic measurements indicates functional coupling between residues in disordered loops on the two distant surfaces. All atom molecular dynamics simulations reveal that this coupling occurs through long distance reciprocal modulation of the structure and dynamics of disorder-to-order transitions on the two surfaces.

A conserved regulatory mechanism in bifunctional biotin protein ligases

Class II bifunctional biotin protein ligases (BirA), which catalyze post-translational biotinylation and repress transcription initiation, are broadly distributed in eubacteria and archaea. However, it is unclear if these proteins all share the same molecular mechanism of transcription regulation. In Escherichia coli the corepressor biotinoyl-5'-AMP (bio-5'-AMP), which is also the intermediate in biotin transfer, promotes operator binding and resulting transcription repression by enhancing BirA dimerization. Like E. coli BirA (EcBirA), Staphylococcus aureus, and Bacillus subtilis BirA (Sa and BsBirA) repress transcription in vivo in a biotin-dependent manner. In this work, sedimentation equilibrium measurements were performed to investigate the molecular basis of this biotin-responsive transcription regulation. The results reveal that, as observed for EcBirA, Sa, and BsBirA dimerization reactions are significantly enhanced by bio-5'-AMP binding. Thus, the molecular mechanism of the Biotin Regulatory System is conserved in the biotin repressors from these three organisms.

Heat Capacity Changes and Disorder-to-Order Transitions in Allosteric Activation

Allosteric coupling in proteins is ubiquitous but incompletely understood, particularly in systems characterized by coupling over large distances. Binding of the allosteric effector, bio-5'-AMP, to the Escherichia coli biotin protein ligase, BirA, enhances the protein's dimerization free energy by -4 kcal/mol. Previous studies revealed that disorder-to-order transitions at the effector binding and dimerization sites, which are separated by 33 Å, are integral to functional coupling. Perturbations to the transition at the ligand binding site alter both ligand binding and coupled dimerization. Alanine substitutions in four loops on the dimerization surface yield a range of energetic effects on dimerization. A glycine to alanine substitution at position 142 in one of these loops results in a complete loss of allosteric coupling, disruption of the disorder-to-order transitions at both functional sites, and a decreased affinity for the effector. In this work, allosteric communication between the effector binding and dimerization surfaces in BirA was further investigated by performing isothermal titration calorimetry measurements on nine proteins with alanine substitutions in three dimerization surface loops. In contrast to BirAG142A, at 20 °C all variants bind to bio-5'-AMP with free energies indistinguishable from that measured for wild-type BirA. However, the majority of the variants exhibit altered heat capacity changes for effector binding. Moreover, the ΔCp values correlate with the dimerization free energies of the effector-bound proteins. These thermodynamic results, combined with structural information, indicate that allosteric activation of the BirA monomer involves formation of a network of intramolecular interactions on the dimerization surface in response to bio-5'-AMP binding at the distant effector binding site.

Biotin and Lipoic Acid: Synthesis, Attachment, and Regulation

Two vitamins, biotin and lipoic acid, are essential in all three domains of life. Both coenzymes function only when covalently attached to key metabolic enzymes. There they act as "swinging arms" that shuttle intermediates between two active sites (= covalent substrate channeling) of key metabolic enzymes. Although biotin was discovered over 100 years ago and lipoic acid 60 years ago, it was not known how either coenzyme is made until recently. In Escherichia coli the synthetic pathways for both coenzymes have now been worked out for the first time. The late steps of biotin synthesis, those involved in assembling the fused rings, were well described biochemically years ago, although recent progress has been made on the BioB reaction, the last step of the pathway in which the biotin sulfur moiety is inserted. In contrast, the early steps of biotin synthesis, assembly of the fatty acid-like "arm" of biotin were unknown. It has now been demonstrated that the arm is made by using disguised substrates to gain entry into the fatty acid synthesis pathway followed by removal of the disguise when the proper chain length is attained. The BioC methyltransferase is responsible for introducing the disguise, and the BioH esterase is responsible for its removal. In contrast to biotin, which is attached to its cognate proteins as a finished molecule, lipoic acid is assembled on its cognate proteins. An octanoyl moiety is transferred from the octanoyl acyl carrier protein of fatty acid synthesis to a specific lysine residue of a cognate protein by the LipB octanoyltransferase followed by sulfur insertion at carbons C-6 and C-8 by the LipA lipoyl synthetase. Assembly on the cognate proteins regulates the amount of lipoic acid synthesized, and, thus, there is no transcriptional control of the synthetic genes. In contrast, transcriptional control of the biotin synthetic genes is wielded by a remarkably sophisticated, yet simple, system, exerted through BirA, a dual-function protein that both represses biotin operon transcription and ligates biotin to its cognate proteins.

Biotin and Lipoic Acid: Synthesis, Attachment, and Regulation

Two vitamins, biotin and lipoic acid, are essential in all three domains of life. Both coenzymes function only when covalently attached to key metabolic enzymes. There they act as "swinging arms" that shuttle intermediates between two active sites (= covalent substrate channeling) of key metabolic enzymes. Although biotin was discovered over 100 years ago and lipoic acid was discovered 60 years ago, it was not known how either coenzyme is made until recently. In Escherichia coli the synthetic pathways for both coenzymes have now been worked out for the first time. The late steps of biotin synthesis, those involved in assembling the fused rings, were well described biochemically years ago, although recent progress has been made on the BioB reaction, the last step of the pathway, in which the biotin sulfur moiety is inserted. In contrast, the early steps of biotin synthesis, assembly of the fatty acid-like "arm" of biotin, were unknown. It has now been demonstrated that the arm is made by using disguised substrates to gain entry into the fatty acid synthesis pathway followed by removal of the disguise when the proper chain length is attained. The BioC methyltransferase is responsible for introducing the disguise and the BioH esterase for its removal. In contrast to biotin, which is attached to its cognate proteins as a finished molecule, lipoic acid is assembled on its cognate proteins. An octanoyl moiety is transferred from the octanoyl-ACP of fatty acid synthesis to a specific lysine residue of a cognate protein by the LipB octanoyl transferase, followed by sulfur insertion at carbons C6 and C8 by the LipA lipoyl synthetase. Assembly on the cognate proteins regulates the amount of lipoic acid synthesized, and thus there is no transcriptional control of the synthetic genes. In contrast, transcriptional control of the biotin synthetic genes is wielded by a remarkably sophisticated, yet simple, system exerted through BirA, a dual-function protein that both represses biotin operon transcription and ligates biotin to its cognate protein.

Glucocorticoid Receptor-DNA Dissociation Kinetics Measured in Vitro Reveal Exchange on the Second Time Scale

The glucocorticoid receptor (GR) is a member of the steroid receptor family of ligand-activated transcription factors. Recent live cell imaging studies have revealed that interactions of GR with chromatin are highly dynamic, with average receptor residence times of only seconds. These findings were surprising because early kinetic studies found that GR-DNA interactions in vitro were much slower, having calculated residence times of minutes to hours. However, these latter analyses were conducted at a time when it was possible to work with only either partially purified holoreceptor or its purified but isolated DNA binding domain. Noting these limitations, we reexamined GR-DNA dissociation kinetics using a highly purified holoreceptor shown to be amenable to rigorous study. We first observe that GR-DNA interactions in vitro are not slow as previously thought but converge with in vivo behavior, having residence times of only seconds to tens of seconds. This rapid exchange is seen at six individual response elements and the multisite MMTV promoter used in live cell imaging. Second, GR dissociation rates are identical for all response elements. Thus, previously observed differences in receptor affinity toward these sequences are not due to differences in off rate but in on rate. Finally, dissociation kinetics are biphasic in character. A minimal kinetic model consistent with the data is that in which DNA-bound GR interconverts between states on a second time scale, with dissociation occurring via a multistep process. We speculate that receptor interconversion in this time frame can be recognized by the coregulatory proteins that interact with GR, leading to unique transcriptional responses.

Sequence-function relationships in folding upon binding

Folding coupled to binding is ubiquitous in biology. Nevertheless, the relationship of sequence to function for protein segments that undergo coupled binding and folding remains to be determined. Specifically, it is not known if the well-established rules that govern protein folding and stability are relevant to ligand-linked folding transitions. Upon small ligand biotinoyl-5'-AMP (bio-5'-AMP) binding the Escherichia coli protein BirA undergoes a disorder-to-order transition that results in formation of a network of packed hydrophobic side chains. Ligand binding is also allosterically coupled to protein association, with bio-5'-AMP binding enhancing the dimerization free energy by -4.0 kcal/mol. Previous studies indicated that single alanine replacements in a three residue hydrophobic cluster that contributes to the larger network disrupt cluster formation, ligand binding, and allosteric activation of protein association. In this work, combined equilibrium and kinetic measurements of BirA variants with alanine substitutions in the entire hydrophobic network reveal large functional perturbations resulting from any single substitution and highly non-additive effects of multiple substitutions. These substitutions also disrupt ligand-linked folding. The combined results suggest that, analogous to protein folding, functional disorder-to-order linked to binding requires optimal packing of the relevant hydrophobic side chains that contribute to the transition. The potential for many combinations of residues to satisfy this requirement implies that, although functionally important, segments of homologous proteins that undergo folding linked to binding can exhibit sequence divergence.

A large solvent isotope effect on protein association thermodynamics

Solvent reorganization can contribute significantly to the energetics of protein-protein interactions. However, our knowledge of the magnitude of the energetic contribution is limited, in part, by a dearth of quantitative experimental measurements. The biotin repressor forms a homodimer as a prerequisite to DNA binding to repress transcription initiation. At 20 °C, the dimerization reaction, which is thermodynamically coupled to binding of a small ligand, bio-5'-AMP, is characterized by a Gibbs free energy of -7 kcal/mol. This modest net dimerization free energy reflects underlying, very large opposing enthalpic and entropic driving forces of 41 ± 3 and -48 ± 3 kcal/mol, respectively. The thermodynamics have been interpreted as indicating coupling of solvent release to dimerization. In this work, this interpretation has been investigated by measuring the effect of replacing H2O with D2O on the dimerization thermodynamics. Sedimentation equilibrium measurements performed at 20 °C reveal a solvent isotope effect of -1.5 kcal/mol on the Gibbs free energy of dimerization. Analysis of the temperature dependence of the reaction in D2O indicates enthalpic and entropic contributions of 28 and -37 kcal/mol, respectively, considerably smaller than the values measured in H2O. These large solvent isotope perturbations to the thermodynamics are consistent with a significant contribution of solvent release to the dimerization reaction.

Protein:protein interactions in control of a transcriptional switch

Protein partner exchange plays a key role in regulating many biological switches. Although widespread, the mechanisms dictating protein partner identity and, therefore, the outcome of a switch have been determined for a limited number of systems. The Escherichia coli protein BirA undergoes a switch between posttranslational biotin attachment and transcription repression in response to cellular biotin demand. Moreover, the functional switch reflects formation of alternative mutually exclusive protein:protein interactions by BirA. Previous studies provided a set of alanine-substituted BirA variants with altered kinetic and equilibrium parameters of forming these interactions. In this work, DNase I footprinting measurements were employed to investigate the consequences of these altered properties for the outcome of the BirA functional switch. The results support a mechanism in which BirA availability for DNA binding and, therefore, transcription repression is controlled by the rate of the competing protein:protein interaction. However, occupancy of the transcriptional regulatory site on DNA by BirA is exquisitely tuned by the equilibrium constant governing its homodimerization.

Functional versatility of a single protein surface in two protein:protein interactions

The ability of the Escherichia coli protein BirA to function as both a metabolic enzyme and a transcription repressor relies on the use of a single surface for two distinct protein:protein interactions. BirA forms a heterodimer with the biotin acceptor protein of acetyl-coenzyme A carboxylase and catalyzes posttranslational biotinylation. Alternatively, it forms a homodimer that binds sequence-specifically to DNA to repress transcription initiation at the biotin biosynthetic operon. Several surface loops on BirA, two of which exhibit sequence conservation in all biotin protein ligases and the remainder of which are highly variable, are located at the two interfaces. The function of these loops in both homodimerization and biotin transfer was investigated by characterizing alanine-substituted variants at 18 positions of one constant and three variable loops. Sedimentation equilibrium measurements reveal that 11 of the substitutions, which are distributed throughout conserved and variable loops, significantly alter homodimerization energetics. By contrast, steady-state and single-turnover kinetic measurements indicate that biotin transfer to biotin carboxyl carrier protein is impacted by seven substitutions, the majority of which are in the constant loop. Furthermore, constant loop residues that function in biotin transfer also support homodimerization. The results reveal clues about the evolution of a single protein surface for use in two distinct functions.

Selective inhibition of biotin protein ligase from Staphylococcus aureus

There is a well documented need to replenish the antibiotic pipeline with new agents to combat the rise of drug resistant bacteria. One strategy to combat resistance is to discover new chemical classes immune to current resistance mechanisms that inhibit essential metabolic enzymes. Many of the obvious drug targets that have no homologous isozyme in the human host have now been investigated. Bacterial drug targets that have a closely related human homologue represent a new frontier in antibiotic discovery. However, to avoid potential toxicity to the host, these inhibitors must have very high selectivity for the bacterial enzyme over the human homolog. We have demonstrated that the essential enzyme biotin protein ligase (BPL) from the clinically important pathogen Staphylococcus aureus could be selectively inhibited. Linking biotin to adenosine via a 1,2,3 triazole yielded the first BPL inhibitor selective for S. aureus BPL over the human equivalent. The synthesis of new biotin 1,2,3-triazole analogues using click chemistry yielded our most potent structure (K(i) 90 nM) with a >1100-fold selectivity for the S. aureus BPL over the human homologue. X-ray crystallography confirmed the mechanism of inhibitor binding. Importantly, the inhibitor showed cytotoxicity against S. aureus but not cultured mammalian cells. The biotin 1,2,3-triazole provides a novel pharmacophore for future medicinal chemistry programs to develop this new antibiotic class.

Altered regulation of Escherichia coli biotin biosynthesis in BirA superrepressor mutant strains

Transcription of the Escherichia coli biotin (bio) operon is directly regulated by the biotin protein ligase BirA, the enzyme that covalently attaches biotin to its cognate acceptor proteins. Binding of BirA to the bio operator requires dimerization of the protein, which is triggered by BirA-catalyzed synthesis of biotinoyl-adenylate (biotinoyl-5'-AMP), the obligatory intermediate of the ligation reaction. Although several aspects of this regulatory system are well understood, no BirA superrepressor mutant strains had been isolated. Such superrepressor BirA proteins would repress the biotin operon transcription in vivo at biotin concentrations well below those needed for repression by wild-type BirA. We isolated mutant strains having this phenotype by a combined selection-screening approach and resolved multiple mutations to give several birA superrepressor alleles, each having a single mutation, all of which showed repression dominant over that of the wild-type allele. All of these mutant strains repressed bio operon transcription in vivo at biotin concentrations that gave derepression of the wild-type strain and retained sufficient ligation activity for growth when overexpressed. All of the strains except that encoding G154D BirA showed derepression of bio operon transcription upon overproduction of a biotin-accepting protein. In BirA, G154D was a lethal mutation in single copy, and the purified protein was unable to transfer biotin from enzyme-bound biotinoyl-adenylate either to the natural acceptor protein or to a biotin-accepting peptide sequence. Consistent with the transcriptional repression data, each of the purified mutant proteins showed increased affinity for the biotin operator DNA in electrophoretic mobility shift assays. Surprisingly, although most of the mutations were located in the catalytic domain, all of those tested, except G154D BirA, had normal ligase activity. Most of the mutations that gave superrepressor phenotypes altered residues located close to the dimerization interface of BirA. However, two mutations were located at sites well removed from the interface. The properties of the superrepressor mutants strengthen and extend other data indicating that BirA function entails extensive interactions among the three domains of the protein and show that normal ligase activity does not ensure normal DNA binding.

In vivo tests of thermodynamic models of transcription repressor function

One emphasis of the Gibbs Conference on Biothermodynamics is the value of thermodynamic measurements for understanding behaviors of biological systems. In this study, the correlation between thermodynamic measurements of in vitro DNA binding affinity with in vivo transcription repression was investigated for two transcription repressors. In the first system, which comprised an engineered LacI/GalR homolog, mutational changes altered the equilibrium constant for binding DNA. Changes correlated with altered repression, but estimates of in vivo repressor concentration suggest a ≥25-fold discrepancy with in vitro conditions. In the second system, changes in ligand binding to BirA altered dimerization and subsequent DNA occupancy. Again, these changes correlate with altered in vivo repression, but comparison with in vitro measurements reveals a ~10-fold discrepancy. Further analysis of each system suggests that the observed discrepancies between in vitro and in vivo results reflect the contributions of additional equilibria to the transcription repression process.

Overexpression of biotin synthase and biotin ligase is required for efficient generation of sulfur-35 labeled biotin in E. coli

Background

Biotin is an essential enzyme cofactor that acts as a CO₂ carrier in carboxylation and decarboxylation reactions. The E. coli genome encodes a biosynthetic pathway that produces biotin from pimeloyl-CoA in four enzymatic steps. The final step, insertion of sulfur into desthiobiotin to form biotin, is catalyzed by the biotin synthase, BioB. A dedicated biotin ligase (BirA) catalyzes the covalent attachment of biotin to biotin-dependent enzymes. Isotopic labeling has been a valuable tool for probing the details of the biosynthetic process and assaying the activity of biotin-dependent enzymes, however there is currently no established method for ³⁵S labeling of biotin.

Results

In this study, we produced [³⁵S]-biotin from Na³⁵SO₄ and desthiobiotin with a specific activity of 30.7 Ci/mmol, two orders of magnitude higher than previously published methods. The biotinylation domain (PfBCCP-79) from the Plasmodium falciparum acetyl-CoA carboxylase (ACC) was expressed in E. coli as a biotinylation substrate. We found that overexpression of the E. coli biotin synthase, BioB, and biotin ligase, BirA, increased PfBCCP-79 biotinylation 160-fold over basal levels. Biotinylated PfBCCP-79 was purified by affinity chromatography, and free biotin was liberated using acid hydrolysis. We verified that we had produced radiolabeled biologically active [D]-biotin that specifically labels biotinylated proteins through reuptake in E. coli.

Conclusions

The strategy described in our report provides a simple and effective method for the production of [³⁵S]-biotin in E. coli based on affinity chromatography.

Biochemical properties and biological function of a monofunctional microbial biotin protein ligase

Biotin protein ligases constitute a family of enzymes that catalyze the linkage of biotin to biotin-dependent carboxylases. In bacteria, these enzymes are functionally divided into two classes: the monofunctional enzymes that catalyze only biotin addition and the bifunctional enzymes that also bind to DNA to regulate transcription initiation. Biochemical and biophysical studies of the bifunctional Escherichia coli ligase suggest that several properties of the enzyme have evolved to support its additional regulatory role. Included among these properties are the order of substrate binding and linkage between the oligomeric state and ligand binding. To test this hypothesized relationship between functionality and biochemical properties in ligases, we have conducted studies of the monofunctional ligase from Pyrococcus horikoshii. Sedimentation equilibrium measurements to determine the effect of ligand binding on oligomerization indicate that the enzyme exists as a dimer regardless of liganded state. Measurements performed using isothermal titration calorimetry and fluorescence spectroscopy indicate that, in contrast to the bifunctional E. coli enzyme, substrate binding does not occur by an obligatorily ordered mechanism. Finally, thermodynamic signatures of ligand binding to the monofunctional enzyme differ significantly from those measured for the bifunctional enzyme. These results indicate a correlation between the functional complexity of biotin protein ligases and their detailed biochemical characteristics.

Thermodynamic and structural investigation of bispecificity in protein-protein interactions

The ability of a single protein to interact with multiple protein partners is central to many biological processes. However, the physical-chemical and structural basis of the multispecificity is not understood. In Escherichia coli, the protein BirA can self-associate to a homodimer or form a heterodimer with the biotin carboxyl carrier protein of the biotin-dependent carboxylase, acetyl coenzyme A carboxylase. The first interaction results in binding of BirA to the biotin operator sequence to repress transcription initiation at the biotin biosynthetic operon and the second is a prerequisite to posttranslational biotin addition to the carrier protein for use in metabolism. A single surface on BirA is used for both interactions and previous studies indicate that, despite the structural differences between the alternative partners, the two dimerization reactions are isoenergetic. In this work, the underlying thermodynamic driving forces and the sequence determinants of the two interactions were investigated in order to elucidate the energetic and structural underpinnings of the dual specificity. Combined measurements of the temperature and salt dependencies of heterodimerization indicate a modest unfavorable enthalpy and no dependence on salt concentration. By contrast, homodimerization is characterized by a very large unfavorable enthalpy and a modest dependence on salt concentration. Measurements of the function of BirA variants with single amino acid replacements in the alternative dimerization reactions indicate that although considerable overlap in structural determinants for both interactions exists, hotspots specific for one but not the other were detected.

Ligand specificity of group I biotin protein ligase of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Background

Fatty acids are indispensable constituents of mycolic acids that impart toughness & permeability barrier to the cell envelope of M. tuberculosis. Biotin is an essential co-factor for acetyl-CoA carboxylase (ACC) the enzyme involved in the synthesis of malonyl-CoA, a committed precursor, needed for fatty acid synthesis. Biotin carboxyl carrier protein (BCCP) provides the co-factor for catalytic activity of ACC.

Methodology/Principal Findings

BPL/BirA (Biotin Protein Ligase), and its substrate, biotin carboxyl carrier protein (BCCP) of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mt) were cloned and expressed in E. coli BL21. In contrast to EcBirA and PhBPL, the ∼29.5 kDa MtBPL exists as a monomer in native, biotin and bio-5′AMP liganded forms. This was confirmed by molecular weight profiling by gel filtration on Superdex S-200 and Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS). Computational docking of biotin and bio-5′AMP to MtBPL show that adenylation alters the contact residues for biotin. MtBPL forms 11 H-bonds with biotin, relative to 35 with bio-5′AMP. Docking simulations also suggest that bio-5′AMP hydrogen bonds to the conserved ‘GRGRRG’ sequence but not biotin. The enzyme catalyzed transfer of biotin to BCCP was confirmed by incorporation of radioactive biotin and by Avidin blot. The K_m for BCCP was ∼5.2 µM and ∼420 nM for biotin. MtBPL has low affinity (K_b = 1.06×10⁻⁶ M) for biotin relative to EcBirA but their K_m are almost comparable suggesting that while the major function of MtBPL is biotinylation of BCCP, tight binding of biotin/bio-5′AMP by EcBirA is channeled for its repressor activity.

Conclusions/Significance

These studies thus open up avenues for understanding the unique features of MtBPL and the role it plays in biotin utilization in M. tuberculosis.

Allosteric signaling in the biotin repressor occurs via local folding coupled to global dampening of protein dynamics

The biotin repressor is an allosterically regulated, site-specific DNA-binding protein. Binding of the small ligand bio-5'-AMP activates repressor dimerization, which is a prerequisite to DNA binding. Multiple disorder-to-order transitions, some of which are known to be important for the functional allosteric response, occur in the vicinity of the ligand-binding site concomitant with effector binding to the repressor monomer. In this work, the extent to which these local changes are coupled to additional changes in the structure/dynamics of the repressor was investigated using hydrogen/deuterium exchange coupled to mass spectrometry. Measurements were performed on the apo-protein and on complexes of the protein bound to four different effectors that elicit a range of thermodynamic responses in the repressor. Global exchange measurements indicate that binding of any effector to the intact protein is accompanied by protection from exchange. Mass spectrometric analysis of pepsin-cleavage products generated from the exchanged complexes reveals that the protection is distributed throughout the protein. Furthermore, the magnitude of the level of protection in each peptide from hydrogen/deuterium exchange correlates with the magnitude of the functional allosteric response elicited by a ligand. These results indicate that local structural changes in the binding site that occur concomitant with effector binding nucleate global dampening of dynamics. Moreover, the magnitude of dampening of repressor dynamics tracks with the magnitude of the functional response to effector binding.

Kinetic partitioning between alternative protein-protein interactions controls a transcriptional switch

Proteins can perform completely distinct functions in response to the particular partners that they bind to. Consequently, determination of the mechanism of functional regulation in such systems requires elucidation of the mechanism switching between binding partners. The central protein of the Escherichia coli biotin regulatory system, BirA, switches between its function as a metabolic enzyme or a transcriptional repressor in response to binding either the biotin carboxyl carrier protein subunit of acetyl-CoA carboxylase or a second BirA monomer. These two protein-protein interactions are structurally mutually exclusive. The results of earlier studies suggest that the system is regulated by kinetic partitioning between the two protein-protein interactions. In this work, sedimentation velocity was employed to monitor the partitioning directly. The results indicate similar equilibrium parameters governing formation of the two protein-protein interactions. Kinetic analysis of the sedimentation velocity data indicated that holoBirA dimerization is governed by very slow forward and reverse rate constants. The slow kinetics of holoBirA dimerization combined with fluctuations in the intracellular apoBCCP pool are critical determinants in partitioning BirA between its distinct biological functions.

Biotin Sensing: Universal Influence of Biotin Status on Transcription

Although the role of biotin in metabolic reactions has long been recognized, its influence on transcription has only recently been discovered. A key protein in biotin-mediated transcription regulation is the biotin protein ligase, the enzyme responsible for catalyzing covalent linkage of the vitamin to biotin-dependent carboxylases. In the biotin regulatory system of Escherichia coli, the best characterized of the biotin-sensing systems, the biotin protein ligase functions both as the biotinylating enzyme and as a transcription repressor. Detailed mechanistic studies of this system are reviewed. In addition, recent studies have revealed other biotin-sensing systems in organisms ranging from bacteria to humans. These systems and the central role of the biotin protein ligase in each are also reviewed.

Nucleation of an allosteric response via ligand-induced loop folding

The Escherichia coli biotin repressor BirA is an allosteric transcription regulatory protein to which binding of the small ligand corepressor biotinyl-5'-AMP promotes homodimerization and subsequent DNA binding. Structural data indicate that the apo or unliganded repressor is characterized by four partially disordered loops that are ordered in the ligand-bound dimer. While three of these loops participate directly in the dimerization, the fourth, consisting of residues 212-234 is distal to the interface. This loop, which is ordered around the adenine ring of the adenylate moiety in the BirA.adenylate structure, is referred to as the adenylate-binding loop (ABL). Although residues in the loop do not interact directly with the ligand, a hydrophobic cluster consisting of a tryptophan and two valine side-chains assembles over the adenine base. Results of previous measurements suggest that folding of the ABL is integral to the allosteric response. This idea and the role of the hydrophobic cluster in the process were investigated by systematic replacement of each side-chain in the cluster with alanine and analysis of the mutant proteins for small ligand binding and dimerization. Isothermal titration calorimetry measurements indicate defects in adenylate binding for all ABL variants. Additionally, sedimentation equilibrium measurements reveal that coupling between adenylate binding and dimerization is compromised in each mutant. Partial proteolysis measurements indicate that the mutants are defective in ligand-linked folding of the ABL. These results indicate that the hydrophobic cluster is critical to the ligand-induced disorder-to-order transition in the ABL and that this transition is integral to the allosteric response in the biotin repressor.

The biotin regulatory system: kinetic control of a transcriptional switch

An organism's response to environmental and metabolic cues requires communication between transcription regulatory processes and "other" cellular events. In a number of biological control circuits, the communication is carried out by a single multifunctional protein that participates directly in transcription initiation and in at least one other cellular process. Structural studies suggest that the function of these proteins is dictated by the formation of mutually exclusive protein-protein interactions. However, the rules that govern partner, and thus functional switching, are not known. In the Escherichia coli Biotin Regulatory System, the bifunctional protein, BirA, catalyzes post-translational biotin addition to a biotin-dependent carboxylase and binds sequence-specifically to DNA to repress transcription initiation at the biotin biosynthetic operon. Previous structural and modeling studies suggest that BirA function is determined by formation of alternative homo- and heterodimeric protein-protein interactions. In this work, the BirA functional switch is investigated using DNaseI footprinting and MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry. Results of these measurements indicate that BirA can be selectively targeted toward its enzymatic function simply by increasing the kinetic probability of heterodimerization relative to that of homodimerization. Subsequent shifting to the DNA binding function occurs as the pool of heterodimer partner is depleted and homodimerization dominates. The data support a switching mechanism in which BirA's function is dictated by its probability of encountering a particular protein partner.

Cooperative DNA binding by the B-isoform of human progesterone receptor: thermodynamic analysis reveals strongly favorable and unfavorable contributions to assembly

Progesterone receptors (PR) play critical roles in eukaryotic gene regulation, yet the mechanisms by which they assemble at multisite promoters are poorly understood. Here we present a thermodynamic analysis of the interactions of the PR B-isoform (PR-B) with promoters containing either one or two progesterone response elements (PREs). Utilizing quantitative footprinting, we have resolved the microscopic energetics of PR-B binding, including cooperativity terms. The results of this analysis challenge a number of assumptions found in traditional models of receptor function. First, PR-B interactions at a single PRE can be equally well described by mechanisms invoking either the receptor monomer or the dimer as the active DNA binding species. If, as is commonly accepted, PR-B interacts with response elements only as a preformed dimer, then its intrinsic binding affinity is not the typically observed nanomolar but is rather picomolar. This high affinity binding is opposed, however, by a large energetic penalty. The penalty presumably pays for costly structural rearrangements of the receptor dimer and/or response element that are needed to form the protein-DNA complex. If PR-B assembles at a single response element via successive monomer binding reactions, then this penalty minimizes cooperative interactions between adjacent monomers. When binding to two response elements, the receptor exhibits strong intersite cooperativity. Although this phenomenon has been observed before, the present work demonstrates that the energetics reach levels seen in highly cooperative systems such as lambda cI repressor. This first quantitative dissection of cooperative receptor-promoter interactions suggests that PR-B function is more complex than traditionally envisioned.

Co-repressor induced order and biotin repressor dimerization: a case for divergent followed by convergent evolution

BirA catalyzes the adenylation and subsequent covalent attachment of biotin to the biotin carboxyl carrier protein (BCCP). In the absence of apo-BCCP, biotin-5'-AMP acts as a co-repressor that induces BirA dimerization and binding to the bio operator to repress biotin biosynthesis. The crystal structures of apo-BirA, and BirA in complex with biotin have been reported. We here describe the 2.8A resolution crystal structure of BirA in complex with the co-repressor analog biotinol-5'-AMP. It was previously shown that the structure of apo-BirA is monomeric and that binding of biotin weakly induces a dimeric structure in which three disordered surface loops become organized to form the dimer interface. The structure of the co-repressor complex is also a dimer, clearly related to the BirA.biotin structure, but with several significant conformational changes. A hitherto disordered "adenylate binding loop" forms a well-defined structure covering the co-repressor. The co-repressor buttresses the dimer interface, resulting in improved packing and a 12 degrees change in the hinge-bending angle along the dimer interface relative to the BirA.biotin structure. This helps explain why the binding of the co-repressor is necessary to optimize the binding of BirA to the bioO operator. The structure reveals an unexpected use of the nucleotide-binding motif GXGXXG in binding adenylate and controlling the repressor function. Finally, based on structural analysis we propose that the class of adenylating enzymes represented by BirA, lipoate protein ligase and class II tRNA synthetases diverged early and were selected based on their ability to sequester co-factors or amino acid residues, and adenylation activity arose independently through functional convergence.

The Escherichia coli biotin regulatory system: a transcriptional switch

The ability of any organism to survive depends, in part, on mechanisms that enable it to modify its patterns of gene expression in response to extra- and intracellular signals. In the classical response mechanisms, a small molecule signal impinges on either an extra- or intracellular receptor, and through a series of events the signal is ultimately transmitted to transcription regulatory proteins. An alternative to this classical mechanism is provided by multi-functional transcription factors. These proteins function directly in transcription as well as in at least one additional cellular process. An example of this class of proteins includes the dimerization cofactor of hepatocyte nuclear factor (DcoH), which serves as an enzyme involved in regeneration of the tetra-hydrobiopterin cofactor and as a factor that stabilizes the dimerization of the hepatocyte nuclear transcription factor (Mendel DB, Khavari PA, Conley PB, Graves MK, Hansen LP, Admon A, et al. Characterization of a cofactor that regulates dimerization of a mammalian homeodomain protein. Science 1991;254:1762-7; Citron BA, Davis MD, Milstien S, Gutierrez J, Mendel DB, Crabtree GR. Identity of 4a-carbinolamine dehydratase, a component of the phenylalanine hydroxylation system, and DCoH, a transregulator of homeodomain proteins. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 1992;89:11891-4). Another example is the protein PutA, a redox enzyme involved in proline utilization and a regulator of transcription of the genes involved in proline utilization (Ostrovsky de Spicer P, Maloy S. Puta protein, a membrane-associated flavin dehydrogenase, acts as a redox-dependent transcriptional regulator. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 1993;90:4295-8). While several proteins of this class have been identified, their mechanisms of functional switching remain to be elucidated.

Multilevel regulation of protein–protein interactions in biological circuitry

Protein-protein interactions are central to biology and, in this 'post-genomic era', prediction of these interactions has become the goal of many computational efforts. Close inspection of even relatively simple biological regulatory circuitry reveals multiple levels of control of the contributing protein interactions. The fundamental probability that an interaction will occur under a given set of conditions is difficult to predict because the relationship between structure and energy is not known. Layered on this basic difficulty are allosteric control mechanisms involving post-translational modification or small ligand binding. In addition, many biological processes involve multiple protein-protein interactions, some of which may be cooperative or even competitive. Finally, although the emphasis in predicting protein interactions is based on equilibrium thermodynamic principles, kinetics can be a major controlling feature in these systems. This complexity reinforces the necessity of performing detailed quantitative studies of the component interactions of complex biological regulatory systems. Results of such studies will help us to bridge the gap between our knowledge of structure and our understanding of functional biology.

Molecular genetics of biotin metabolism: old vitamin, new science

Biotin is a water-soluble vitamin that participates as a cofactor in gluconeogenesis, fatty acid synthesis and branched chain amino acid catabolism. It functions as the carboxyl carrier for biotin-dependent carboxylases. Its covalent attachment to carboxylases is catalyzed by holocarboxylase synthetase. Our interest in biotin has been through the genetic disease, "biotin-responsive multiple carboxylase deficiency," caused by deficient activity of holocarboxylase synthetase. As part of these studies, we made the unexpected findings that the enzyme also targets to the nucleus and that it catalyzes the attachment of biotin to histones. We found that patients with holocarboxylase synthetase deficiency have a much reduced level of biotinylated histones, yet the importance of this process is unknown. The dual nature of biotin, as the carboxyl-carrier cofactor of carboxylases and as a ligand of unknown function attached to histones, is an enigma that suggests a much more involved role for biotin than anticipated. It may change our outlook on the optimal nutritional intake of biotin and its importance in biological processes such as development, cellular homeostasis and regulation.

Use of binding enthalpy to drive an allosteric transition

The Escherichia coli biotin repressor is an allosteric DNA binding protein and is activated by the small molecule bio-5'-AMP. Binding of this small molecule promotes transcription repression complex assembly between the repressor and the biotin operator of the biotin biosynthetic operon. The ability of the adenylate to activate the assembly process reflects its effect on biotin repressor dimerization. Thus concomitant with small molecule binding the free energy of repressor dimerization becomes more favorable by approximately -4 kcal/mol. The structural, dynamic, and energetic changes in the repressor monomer that accompany allosteric activation are not known. In this work the thermodynamics of binding of four allosteric activators to the repressor have been characterized by isothermal titration calorimetry. While binding of two of the effectors results in relatively modest activation of the dimerization process, binding of the other two small molecules, including the physiological effector, leads to large changes in repressor dimerization energetics. Results of the calorimetric measurements indicate that strong effector binding is accompanied by an enthalpically costly transition in the protein. This transition is "paid for" by the enthalpy that would have otherwise been realized from the formation of noncovalent bonds between the ligand and repressor monomer.

Frequency domain chemical Langevin analysis of stochasticity in gene transcriptional regulation

We present a frequency domain Langevin approach for stochastic analysis that remains valid for many important gene circuit elements even as molecular populations approach zero. We begin by considering the case of low-rate transcription and show that the previously reported shot noise representation is exact at all mRNA population levels for a constant transcription rate. Next, we consider transcriptional control through protein-DNA interactions at an operator site within the gene promoter region. This analysis results in expressions for the dynamics and noise behavior of this important gene sub-circuit, including the spectral density of the intrinsic operator noise and the processing of extrinsic noise by this transcriptional regulation system. This analysis shows that mRNA synthesis noise is composed of wideband shot noise and band-limited operator binding generated noise components. We find that the bandwidth of operator noise and its ultimate effect on total mRNA and protein noise is controlled by operator binding and unbinding dynamics. The most substantial impact of the operator noise is seen at transcription rates just above basal expression. This analysis captures the full behavior of this transcriptional regulation system, and points to potentially serious flaws in simplified mathematical relationships often used to model transcriptional regulation.

Promiscuous protein biotinylation by Escherichia coli biotin protein ligase

Biotin protein ligases (BPLs) are enzymes of extraordinary specificity. BirA, the BPL of Escherichia coli biotinylates only a single cellular protein. We report a mutant BirA that attaches biotin to a large number of cellular proteins in vivo and to bovine serum albumin, chloramphenicol acetyltransferase, immunoglobin heavy and light chains, and RNAse A in vitro. The mutant BirA also self biotinylates in vivo and in vitro. The wild type BirA protein is much less active in these reactions. The biotinylation reaction is proximity-dependent in that a greater extent of biotinylation was seen when the mutant ligase was coupled to the acceptor proteins than when the acceptors were free in solution. This approach may permit facile detection and recovery of interacting proteins by existing avidin/streptavidin technology.

The biotin repressor: modulation of allostery by corepressor analogs

The Escherichia coli biotin repressor functions in biotin retention and regulation of biotin biosynthesis. Biotin retention is accomplished via the two-step biotinylation of the biotin-dependent enzyme, acetyl-CoA carboxylase. In the first step of this reaction the substrates biotin and ATP are utilized in synthesis of the activated biotin, biotinyl-5'-AMP, while in the second step this activated biotin is transferred to a unique lysine residue of the biotin carboxyl carrier protein subunit of the carboxylase. Regulation of biotin biosynthesis is accomplished through binding of the repressor to the transcription control region of the biotin biosynthetic operon. The adenylated or activated biotin functions as the corepressor in this DNA binding process. The activated biotin is a mixed anhydride and thus labile. In efforts to develop tools for structural and thermodynamic studies of the biotin regulatory interactions, two analogs of the adenylate, a sulfamoyl derivative and an ester derivative, have been synthesized and functionally characterized. Results of fluorescence measurements indicate that both analogs bind with high affinity to the repressor and that both are inactive in biotin transfer to the acceptor protein. Functional studies of their corepressor properties indicate that while the sulfamoyl is a weak allosteric activator, the ester closely mimics the physiological corepressor in activation of assembly of the transcription repression complex. Results of these studies also provide further insight into the allosteric mechanism of the biotin repressor.