Decay of individual Escherichia coli trp messenger RNA molecules is sequentially ordered

Post-transcriptional control of gene expression: bacterial mRNA degradation

Many biological processes cannot be fully understood without detailed knowledge of RNA metabolism. The continuous breakdown and resynthesis of prokaryotic mRNA permit rapid production of new kinds of proteins. In this way, mRNA levels can regulate protein synthesis and cellular growth. Analysing mRNA degradation in prokaryotes has been particularly difficult because most mRNA undergo rapid exponential decay. Prokaryotic mRNAs differ in their susceptibility to degradation by endonucleases and exonucleases, possibly because of variation in their sequencing and structure. In spite of numerous studies, details of mRNA degradation are still largely unknown. This review highlights those aspects of mRNA metabolism which seem most influential in the regulation of gene expression.

Global regulation of virulence and the stress response by CsrA in the highly adapted human gastric pathogen Helicobacter pylori

Although successful and persistent colonization of the gastric mucosa depends on the ability to respond to changing environmental conditions and co-ordinate the expression of virulence factors during the course of infection, Helicobacter pylori possesses relatively few transcriptional regulators. We therefore investigated the contribution of the regulatory protein CsrA to global gene regulation in this important human pathogen. CsrA was necessary for full motility and survival of H. pylori under conditions of oxidative stress. Loss of csrA expression deregulated the oxidant-induced transcriptional responses of napA and ahpC, the acid induction of napA, cagA, vacA, the urease operon, and fur, as well as the heat shock responses of napA, groESL and hspR. Although the level of napA transcript was higher in the csrA mutant, its stability was similar in the wild-type and mutant strains, and less NapA protein was produced in the mutant strain. Finally, H. pylori strains deficient in the production of CsrA were significantly attenuated for virulence in a mouse model of infection. This work provides evidence that CsrA has a broad role in regulating the physiology of H. pylori in response to environmental stimuli, and may be important in facilitating adaptation to the different environments encountered during colonization of the gastric mucosa. Furthermore, CsrA appears to mediate its effects in H. pylori at the post-transcriptional level by influencing the processing and translation of target transcripts, with minimal effect on the stability of the target mRNAs.

The product of the pleiotropic Escherichia coli gene csrA modulates glycogen biosynthesis via effects on mRNA stability

The carbon storage regulator gene, csrA, modulates the expression of genes in the glycogen biosynthesis and gluconeogenesis pathways in Escherichia coli and has been cloned, mapped and sequenced (T. Romeo, M. Gong, M.Y. Liu, and A.M. Brun-Zinkernagel, J. Bacteriol. 175:4744-4755, 1993; T. Romeo and M. Gong, J. Bacteriol. 175:5740-5741, 1993). We have now conducted experiments that begin to elucidate a unique mechanism for csrA-mediated regulation. Steady-state levels of glgC transcripts, encoding ADP-glucose pyrophosphorylase, were elevated by up to sixfold in a csrA::kanR mutant and were less than 6.5% of wild-type levels in a strain containing pCSR10 (csrA+), as shown by S1 nuclease protection analysis. The rate of chemical decay of these transcripts after adding rifampin to cultures was dramatically reduced by the csrA::kanR mutation. Deletion studies of a glgC'-'lacZ translational fusion demonstrated that the region surrounding the initiation codon was important for csrA-mediated regulation and indicated that neither csrA-mediated regulation nor stationary phase induction of glgC expression originates at the level of transcript initiation. Cell-free (S-200) extracts containing the CsrA gene product potently and specifically inhibited the in vitro transcription-translation of glg genes. The deduced amino acid sequence of CsrA was found to contain the KH motif, which characterizes a subset of diverse RNA-binding proteins. The results indicate that CsrA accelerates net 5'-to-3' degradation of glg transcripts, potentially through selective RNA binding.

Control of mRNA processing and decay in prokaryotes

Post-transcriptional mechanisms operate in regulation of gene expression in bacteria, the amount of a given gene product being also dependent on the inactivation rate of its own message. Moreover, segmental differences in mRNA stability of polycistronic transcripts may be responsible for differential expression of genes clustered in operons. Given the absence of 5' to 3' exoribonucleolytic activities in prokaryotes, both endoribonucleases and 3' to 5' exoribonucleases are involved in chemical decay of mRNA. As the 3' to 5' exoribonucleolytic activities are readily blocked by stem-loop structures which are usual at the 3' ends of bacterial messages, the rate of decay is primarily determined by the rate of the first endonucleolytic cleavage within the transcripts, after which the resulting mRNA intermediates are degraded by the 3' to 5' exoribonucleases. Consequently, the stability of a given transcript is determined by the accessibility of suitable target sites to endonucleolytic activities. A considerable number of bacterial messages decay with a net 5' to 3' directionality. Two different alternative models have been proposed to explain such a finding, the first invoking the presence of functional coupling between degradation and the movement of the ribosomes along the transcripts, the second one implying the existence of a 5' to 3' processive '5' binding nuclease'. The different systems by which these two current models of mRNA decay have been tested will be presented with particular emphasis on polycistronic transcripts.

Terminal sequences do not contain the rate-limiting decay determinants of E. coli cat mRNA

The mechanism of E. coli chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (cat) mRNA decay was investigated. Alteration of the 5' untranslated terminus does not appear to have an effect on the turnover rate of the mRNA. Similarly, changes at the 3' terminus of the message, including the addition of a stable stem and loop structure, do not affect the half-life of the message. The data suggest that 5' and 3' terminal untranslated sequences do not contain the rate-limiting determinants for cat message decay. Decay rates for various segments of the cat mRNA were measured and indicate that all regions of the message have similar stabilities. The current model of cat mRNA degradation involves a rate-limiting endonucleolytic decay event that occurs internal to the message followed by degradation of the cleavage products.

Mechanisms of mRNA decay in bacteria: a perspective

Messenger RNA decay plays an important role in prokaryotic gene expression. The disparate stabilities of bacterial messages in vivo are a consequence of their differential susceptibility to degradation by cellular endoribonucleases and 3' -exoribonucleases, which in turn results from differences in mRNA sequence and structure. RNase II and polynucleotide phosphorylase, the major bacterial exonucleases involved in mRNA turnover, rapidly degrade single-stranded RNA from the 3' end, but are impeded by 3' stem-loop structures. At present, the identify and substrate specificity of the endonucleases that control mRNA decay rates are relatively poorly defined. Ribosomes and antisense RNA also can influence the stability of transcripts with which they associate. Differences in mRNA stability can contribute to differential expression of genes within polycistronic operons and to modulation of gene expression in response to changes in bacterial growth conditions.

The mRNA for an inducible chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene is cleaved into discrete fragments in Bacillus subtilis

cat-86 is a promoter-deficient plasmid gene that encodes chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT). Insertion of a promoter at a site 144 base pairs 5' to the cat-86 coding sequence activates transcription of the gene and allows cat-86 to specify chloramphenicol-inducible CAT activity in Bacillus subtilis. Induction of cat-86 by chloramphenicol has been shown to result from a regulatory event that activates translation of cat-86 mRNA that is present in cells before the addition of inducer (E. J. Duvall and P. S. Lovett, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 83:3939-3943, 1986). In the present study we show an unusual property of cat-86 mRNA. Full-length cat-86 transcripts, consisting of 920 nucleotides (nt), are cleaved in B. subtilis to yield two predominant fragmentation products: an 810-nt species that lacks sequences present at the 5' end of the 920-nt species and a 720-nt species that lacks sequences present at the 3' end of the 920-nt species. A third fragmentation product consisting of 620 nt may result from the cleavage of a single 920-nt transcript at both the 5' and 3' ends. The sequences which are missing from the 720- and 620-nt species suggest that these transcripts cannot be translated into functional CAT. The 810-nt species lacks sequences from the 5' regulatory region, and it is not yet certain whether or not translation of this species can be induced by chloramphenicol. The ratio of 920-nt molecules/720-nt molecules in rifampin-treated cells is increased when the cells are grown in chloramphenicol. Therefore, induction may partially stabilize full-length cat-86 transcripts against inactivation by a novel processing-like system.

Stabilization of translationally active mRNA by prokaryotic REP sequences

The REP sequence is a highly conserved inverted repeat that is present in about 25% of all E. coli transcription units. We show that the REP sequence can stabilize upstream RNA, independently of any other sequences, by protection from 3'-5' exonuclease attack. The REP sequence is frequently responsible for the differential stability of different segments of mRNA within an operon. We demonstrate that REP-stabilized mRNA can be translated in vivo and that cloning the REP sequence downstream of a gene can increase protein synthesis. This provides direct evidence that alterations in mRNA stability can play a role in determining bacterial gene expression. The implications of these findings for the mechanisms of mRNA degradation and for the role of RNA stability in the regulation of gene expression are discussed.

Gene algD coding for GDPmannose dehydrogenase is transcriptionally activated in mucoid Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Transcriptional regulation of alginate biosynthesis by Pseudomonas aeruginosa was studied. A DNA region complementing the alg-5 mutation within the alginate gene cluster was found by RNA-DNA dot blot and Northern hybridization to be transcriptionally activated in mucoid P. aeruginosa. This region was subcloned as a 3.2-kilobase BglII-ClaI DNA fragment on the broad-host-range controlled transcription vector pMMB24, and gene products were analyzed by expression from the tac promoter. A 48-kilodalton polypeptide was detected in extracts of P. aeruginosa and 35S-labeled Escherichia coli maxicells. By using the same expression system, GDPmannose dehydrogenase activity was detected in both P. aeruginosa and E. coli. Thus, gene algD coding for this enzyme was found to be present in the transcriptionally active DNA area. Insertion of the xylE gene within the BglII-ClaI fragment disrupted the induction of the 48-kilodalton polypeptide, GDPmannose dehydrogenase activity, and alg-5 complementing ability. With the algD-xylE transcription fusion, activation of algD gene expression was shown to occur in mucoid P. aeruginosa of different origins. In addition, regulation of the algD promoter activity was demonstrated to be mediated by a diffusible factor.

Electron microscopic visualization of trp operon expression in Salmonella typhimurium

Transcriptional activity of plasmids carrying wild-type and mutant trp operons was visualized in cell lysates of Salmonella typhimurium. Plasmid and transcription-unit sizes varied with the size of the cloned operon. Following 3-(3-indolyl)acrylic acid derepression, all operons of a particular type exhibited the same high level of transcriptional activity. An estimated 11-14 transcripts must be initiated each minute to maintain the 190-base-pair spacing of RNA polymerases observed on the promoter-proximal half of the wild-type trp operon. A decline in RNA polymerase density was observed on promoter-distal portions of cloned trp operons, which may be attributable to premature transcription termination accompanying translation inhibition due to indolylacrylic acid's interference with normal tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetase activity.

Posttranscriptional modulation of bacteriophage P22 scaffolding protein gene expression

The bacteriophage P22 late operon contains 2 genes whose products are required for cell lysis and 13 genes whose products are involved in the morphogenesis of the phage particle. This operon is under the positive control of the phage gene 23 product and is thought to have a single promoter. The expression of one of these late genes, the scaffolding protein gene, is autogenously modulated independently from the remainder of the late genes. When unassembled, scaffolding protein turns down the rate of synthesis of additional scaffolding protein, and when it is assembled into phage precursor structures, it does not. Experiments presented here show (i) that the mRNA from the scaffolding protein gene is functionally threefold more stable when most of the scaffolding protein is assembled than when it is unassembled and (ii) that no new promoter near the scaffolding protein gene is activated at the high level of synthesis. These data support the model that this autogenous modulation occurs at a posttranscriptional level. We also observed that another message, that of coat protein, appears to become increasingly stable with time after phage infection.

Repetitive extragenic palindromic sequences: a major component of the bacterial genome

We describe a remarkably conserved nucleotide sequence, the many copies of which may occupy up to 1% of the genomes of E. coli and S. typhimurium. This sequence, the REP (repetitive extragenic palindromic) sequence, is about 35 nucleotides long, includes an inverted repeat, and can occur singly or in multiple adjacent copies. A possible role for the REP sequences in regulation of gene expression has been thoroughly investigated. While the REP sequences do not appear to modulate differential gene expression within an operon, they can affect the expression of both upstream and downstream genes to a small extent, probably by affecting the rate of mRNA degradation. Possible roles for the REP sequence in mRNA degradation, chromosome structure, and recombination are discussed.

Ribitol dehydrogenase messenger RNA from an enzyme superproducer strain of Klebsiella aerogenes. Purification, cell-free translation and studies in vitro and in vivo

1. Ribitol dehydrogenase messenger RNA, from a strain of Klebsiella aerogenes that had been evolved to superproduce this enzyme, has been purified in a single step by labelling extracted polysomes with rabbit anti(ribitol dehydrogenase) and immunoprecipitating with sheep anti-(rabbit IgG). 2. The extracted mRNA is stable in a protein synthesis system in vitro and directs synthesis 35-40-times more efficiently than RNA from coliphages MS2 or Q beta, to give ribitol dehydrogenase as sole major product. 3. Its size distribution shows a major band of 1500 nucleotides plus fragments 400-1400 nucleotides, with only traces of size 2400-3000 nucleotides. Only the latter could encode both proteins of the operon: ribitol dehydrogenase and D-ribulokinase. 4. Ribitol dehydrogenase mRNA represents 24% of total mRNA in cells harvested just after a 'switch' point' in mid-exponential phase. About half of the polysomes containing this mRNA are unattached to DNA, whereas only 3% of other mRNAs are unattached to DNA. 5. This mRNA is not outstandingly stable in vivo, though there are indications that it may be more stable than average. Hence the high level of synthesis of ribitol dehydrogenase (up to 30% of total protein in an extract) seems to be due to very efficient transcription and translation from multiple copies of a constitutive rbtD gene.

Regulation of nitrogenase messenger RNA synthesis and stability in Klebsiella pneumoniae

Nitrogenase messenger RNA synthesis in Klebsiella pneumoniae was determined by labelling cells with (3H)uracil and isolating total RNA, which was then hybridized to filter-bound recombinant plasmid pSA30 DNA carrying the nitrogenase structural genes nifH, D, and K, Derepression of nitrogenase mRNA starts 1.5 h before the onset of nitrogenase activity (as measured by acetylene reduction). Exposure of nif-derepressed cultures to either NH4+, air, or high temperatures (39 degree C) results in a rapid decrease of the synthesis rates both of nitrogenase mRNA and nitrogenase polypeptides. Nitrogenase mRNA is remarkably stable. After blocking transcription with rifampicin, hybridizable and actively translatable nitrogenase mRNA survives with an average half-life of 18 min. Half-lives are considerably shorter when rifampicin-inhibited cultures are simultaneously shifted to conditions which are non-permissive for nitrogenase synthesis, pointing to some posttranscriptional influence on nitrogenase mRNA stability. In all experiments performed there was no evidence for uncoupling of nitrogenase mRNA synthesis from nitrogenase mRNA translation, indicating that nitrogenase synthesis is regulated solely by transcriptional control.

Synthesis and degradation of lac mRNA in E. coli depleted of 30S ribosomal subunits

Escherichia coli was depleted of active ribosomes by a thermal shock at 47 degrees C which quantitatively destroyed the 30S ribosomal subunits. During recovery, RNA is synthesized while protein synthesis resumes only after about 90 minutes. It is shown that lac mRNA is synthesized in the complete absence of ribosomal activity and hence RNA synthesis is not coupled to protein synthesis. Transcription time and average transcript length were slightly less than in untreated cells. lac mRNA was degraded much more slowly in bacteria depleted of ribosomes. In E. coli W both functional half life (T 1/2 = 28 min vs. 2.25 in untreated cells) and chemical stability. The analysis of rna and pnp mutants showed that polynucleotide phosphorylase is involved in lac mRNA degradation in heat treated cells but that RNase I is not. The functional T 1/2 was increased in pnp mutants and was 95 min during the recovery period. The rate of chemical decay is so slow that the half-life cannot be accurately determined.

Evidence for endonucleolytic cleavage at the 5'-proximal segment of the trp messenger RNA in Escherichia coli

The 5'-proximal trp leader RNA segment (about 5S) decays at 2 to 3 times slower rates than the distal trp mRNA sequence. This has been demonstrated by employing the deletion mutants which lack a large portion of the structural genes but retain the promoter-proximal region of the trp operon. Relative stability of the leader RNA is not merely due to the presence of an untranslatable region in the segment; the internal untranslatable segment of trp mRNA downstream from the nonsense alteration site of a double mutant trpAD28.trpE9758 decays as fast as the normal trp mRNA sequence. These results suggest that the trp mRNA is endonucleolytically cleaved to yield the small 5'-proximal leader RNA segment before the distal mRNA decays and that the leader RNA sequence is not subject to usual mode of mRNA decay in the 5' to 3' direction.

Individual messenger RNA half lives in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We have measured the decay half-life of functional messenger RNA (mRNA) for some thirty different proteins in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Production of newly synthesized mRNA was halted by raising the temperature of a culture of a temperature-sensitive mutant, ts 136. Aliquots of this culture were pulsed-labelled with [35S]-methionine at various times after the temperature shift and the radioactive proteins separated on the two-dimensional gel electrophoresis system of O'Farrell. We find a range in the decay half lives of individual mRNA species which varies from 3.5 min to greater than 70 min. We find three general classes of decay curves, (a) simple exponential (first order); some of these showed a shoulder before onset of exponential decay; (b) bi-component or multi-component concave upward; (c) initial stimulation of rate of mRNA synthesis, followed by virtually undetectable decay.

Gene affecting longevity of messenger RNA: a mutant of Escherichia coli with altered mRNA stability

We have screened 897 temperature sensitive growth mutants of E. coli for mutant strains showing longer mRNA half-life. The fate of pulse-labelled RNA was examined at 42 degrees C after cessation of RNA synthesis and with prior exposure to nonpermissive temperature (42 degrees C). Eight stains showed altered turnover of RNA (presumably mRNA), and further analysis on mutant strain JE15144 indicated that the stability of pulse-labeled RNA as well as of tryptophan (trp) mRNA increased four to seven fold over its parental strain at 42 degrees C. At 4 min or 10 min after addition of rifampicin, some 70 to 80% of polyribosome in the growing cells could still be conserved in JE15144 cultured at the nonpermissive temperature while little, if any, polyribosomes remained in its parental strain (PA3092) under the same condition. Two generation times were required for complete stoppage of growth of this mutant strain after shifting to 42 degrees C, and protein synthesis continued at a significant, but slightly reduced, rate at 42 degrees C. However, functional decay of mRNA in the mutant strain, with respect to the capacity for producing peptides, appeared to be similar to the parent strain, with half-lives of 3.5 min in PA3092 and 4.7 min in JE15144.