Further attenuated live measles vaccines: the need for revised recommendations

Reduced Antibody Response to Infant Measles Vaccination: Effects Based on Type and Timing of the First Vaccine Dose Persist After the Second Dose

Background

The effect of age at first dose on the immunogenicity of a 2-dose pediatric schedule of measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) or measles-mumps-rubella-varicella (MMRV) vaccine was assessed in children born to mostly vaccinated mothers.

Methods

Immunogenicity data among children given their first measles vaccine dose between 11 and 22 months of age were pooled from 5 randomized controlled trials conducted in Europe and the United States between 2004 and 2010. Measles antibody titers were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay before and after each dose; geometric mean concentrations (GMCs) and the proportion seronegative (GMC <150 mIU/mL) were derived by age at first dose.

Results

Among 5542 children given a first measles vaccine dose at 11, 12, 13-14, and 15-22 months of age, the proportion seronegative decreased from 8.5% to 3.2%, 2.4%, and 1.5%, respectively (P < .001), whereas GMCs increased with older age measles vaccine initiation (P < .001). MMRV induced higher GMCs than MMR (P < .001). First and second dose GMCs were highly correlated (Spearman coefficient = 0.8).

Conclusions

As previously noted among infants born to mothers with history of wild-type measles, antibody responses among children born to vaccinated mothers were reduced based on earlier administration of their first measles vaccine dose at ≤12 vs ≥15 months of age. Negative effects of earlier age at first measles vaccine dose persisted after the second dose. The measles elimination goal may require a careful balance between earlier infant protection and the risk of reduced antibody responses and secondary vaccine failure among successive birth cohorts systematically initiated to measles vaccination <15 months of age.

Experimental vaccines against measles in a world of changing epidemiology

Vaccination with the current live attenuated measles vaccine is one of the most successful and cost-effective medical interventions. However, as a result of persisting maternal antibodies and immaturity of the infant immune system, this vaccine is poorly immunogenic in children <9 months old. Immunity against the live vaccine is less robust than natural immunity and protection less durable. There may also be some concern about (vaccine) virus spread during the final stage of an eventual measles eradication program. Opinions may differ with respect to the potential threat that some of these concerns may be to the World Health Organisation goal of measles elimination, but there is a consensus that the development of new measles vaccines cannot wait. Candidate vaccines are based on viral or bacterial vectors expressing recombinant viral proteins, naked DNA, immune stimulating complexes or synthetic peptides mimicking neutralising epitopes. While some of these candidate vaccines have proven their efficacy in monkey studies, aerosol formulated live attenuated measles vaccine are evaluated in clinical trials.

Comparison of immunogenicity and reactogenicity of a measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine in German children vaccinated at 9-11, 12-14 or 15-17 months of age

Children aged 9-11, 12-14 or 15-17 months, respectively were vaccinated with a measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine and serum antibody responses and reactogenicity were compared. The data of 118 children could be analysed (group 1=9-11 months, n=46; group 2=12-14 months, n=29, group 3, 15-17 months, n=43). The only significant difference observed was for seroconversion against measles virus between group 1 and group 3 (84.8% vs 100%, p=0.012). No serious adverse events were reported. Local side reactions were mild, infrequent and independent of age. Immunisation against MMR is safe and effective even when administered before the currently recommended age of 12 months.

IL-12, IFN-γ, and T Cell Proliferation to Measles in Immunized Infants

Measles infection in infants is associated with severe complications, and secondary infections are attributed to generalized immunosuppression. Measles binding to its monocyte receptor down-regulates IL-12 which is expected to diminish Th1-like cytokine responses, including IFN-γ. Whether young infants can be immunized effectively against measles is an important public health issue. We evaluated Ag-specific IL-12, IFN-γ, and T cell responses of infants at 6 (n = 60), 9 (n = 46), or 12 mo (n = 56) of age and 29 vaccinated adults. IL-12 and IFN-γ release by PBMC stimulated with measles Ag increased significantly after measles immunization in infants. IL-12 and IFN-γ concentrations were equivalent in younger and older infants, but IL-12 concentrations were significantly lower in infants than in adults (p = 0.04). IL-12 production by monocytes was down-regulated by measles; the addition of recombinant human IL-12 enhanced IFN-γ production by PBMC stimulated with measles Ag, but infant T cells released significantly less IFN-γ than adult T cells under this condition. Of particular interest, the presence of passive Abs to measles had no effect on the specific T cell proliferation or IFN-γ production after measles stimulation. Cellular immunity to measles infection and vaccination may be limited in infants compared with adults as a result of less effective IFN-γ and IL-12 production in response to measles Ags. These effects were not exaggerated in younger infants compared with effects in infants who were immunized at 12 mo. In summary, infant T cells were primed with measles Ag despite the presence of passive Abs, but their adaptive immune responses were limited compared with those of adults.

A comparison of alternate immunization regimes for measles in vaccinated populations

Infants today lose maternal measles antibody sooner than in the past. This is related to demographic changes in maternal immunization. Data for rates of decay of maternal antibody and seroconversion after measles vaccination for infants born to naturally immune (Group 1) or vaccinated (Group 2) mothers have been used to evaluate two vaccination schedules: Regime 1, measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) at 1 year of age and Regime 2, monovalent measles at 6 months followed by MMR at 15 months of age. Regime 2 costs less because MMR can be administered at 15 months with the last pentavalent booster. Months of protection/1000 children aged 0-15 months (child-months of protection) were estimated for infant populations ranging from 0 to 100% Group 1 for Regimes 1 and 2. Regime 1 provides more child-months of protection only for 100% Group 1 populations. For the study population Regime 2 provided at least 17% more child-months of protection than Regime 1. Regime 2 provides increased medical and financial benefits in proportion to the number of Group 2 infants in the population and thus is ever more advantageous for today's increasingly vaccinated populations.

Immune response to measles vaccine in 6-month-old infants of measles seronegative mothers

Determinants of measles vaccine-induced immune response in infancy include maternal immune status and the infant's age at immunization. In a previously published study, 74% of 19 6-month-old infants developed neutralizing antibody. Two of the infants were born to measles seronegative mothers. In order to (1) assess the prevalence of measles seronegativity in a population of US mothers born after 1960 and (2) assess the immunogenicity of standard titer measles vaccine in 6-month-old infants of measles seronegative mothers, mothers with healthy term (> or = 37 weeks gestation) infants attending well child care clinics at MetroHealth Medical Center were prospectively screened for measles antibody by EIA. If negative, maternal samples were retested for neutralization (NT) antibody. Fifteen of 169 women were seronegative by both assays. Six-month-old infants of 9 of these 15 seronegative mothers were enrolled in the pediatric vaccine study. Serological response of these 9 infants to monovalent measles vaccine (Attenuvax) was compared to the responses of 17 6-month-old infants of seropositive mothers and 15 15-month-old toddlers from our previous study. All 9 infants of seronegative mothers became EIA seropositive after the vaccine compared to 9 of 17 6-month-old infants born to seropositive mothers (p = 0.02). Differences in NT seroconversion rates (100% vs 70.6%) were not statistically significant. The comparison group of 15-month-old vaccinees showed 100% seroconversion by both assays. The NT geometric mean titer (GMT) was higher in the 15-month-old toddlers than in the 6-month-old infants born to seronegative mothers (87.2 vs 33.9, p < 0.01), suggesting age-related differences in humoral immune response unrelated to passively transferred maternal antibody.

Immune response to simultaneous administration of a combined measles, mumps and rubella vaccine with booster doses of diphtheria-tetanus and poliovirus vaccine

A combined vaccine against measles (Edmonston-Zagreb 19 strain), mumps (Rubini strain) and rubella (Wistar RA 27/3 strain) was administered to a group of 46 children aged 10-12 months simultaneously with booster doses of compulsory diphtheria-tetanus toxoid and oral poliovirus vaccine. A second group of 53 children aged 15-24 months who had received booster doses of the compulsory vaccines 5 to 12 months before was also vaccinated. The same seroconversion rates (100%) and similar antibody titers for rubella were observed in both groups. The same seroconversion rates for mumps (93%) and similar rates for measles (98 and 94%) were observed in the two groups. Significantly lower antibody titers for measles and mumps were found in the first group, but they were compensated by an earlier protection, a reduction of number of visits for immunization, costs for the community, and improvement in parental compliance. These results confirm that Edmonston-Zagreb 19 and Rubini strains are still immunogenic even when they are combined with Wistar RA 27/3 strain. Moreover, a long term follow-up in order to verify the persistence of protective antibody levels in both groups of children, could suggest that combined measles, mumps and rubella vaccine could be given earlier (at 10-12 months of age), simultaneously with booster doses of diphtheria and tetanus toxoid and of trivalent oral poliovirus vaccine.

Optimal age for measles and mumps vaccination in Australia

Trivalent measles-mumps-rubella vaccine has recently replaced measles-mumps vaccine in Australia and is recommended as a single dose at the age of 12 to 15 months, with the exception of Aboriginal children in central Australia who are vaccinated at 9 months. The timing of measles vaccination has been controversial not only in Australia but also in the United States, where measles outbreaks continue to occur. This study aimed to determine seroconversion rates for measles-mumps vaccine in children aged 12 to 18 months and to make a recommendation for the timing of vaccination based on seroconversion rates and attack rates. The parents of 425 children aged 12 to 18 months gave consent for their children to have serum collected at the time of measles-mumps vaccination and three months later. The mean age at vaccination of the children who had two serum samples for measles and mumps antibody estimations was 13.9 months (mode, 13.1). The seroconversion rate for measles was 95% (314/329) (95% confidence interval (CI), 92.5% to 97.3%) and for mumps 97% (309/320) (95% CI, 93.8% to 98.1%). There were no statistically significant differences in the rates of seroconversion for measles or mumps related to age in months at the time of vaccination or in post-vaccination measles antibody titres related to age at vaccination. Post-vaccination mumps antibody titres tended to be lower in older vaccinees. None of the children who presented for vaccination had serological evidence of prior measles infection but five had evidence suggestive of prior mumps. As the seroconversion rates for measles and mumps vaccines were very high in these children it was concluded that no advantage resulted from delaying vaccination until 15 months and that the current National Health and Medical Research Council recommendations for vaccination at age 12 to 15 months should remain.

Measles vaccination: influence of age on its efficacy

The authors compare the serologic efficacy and the clinical protection afforded by three different measles vaccination schemes in adequately nourished children in São Paulo city, Brazil. Two hundred forty two children were divided into three groups. Group A, comprising 117 children who had received the vaccine before 12 months of age and a second dose at 12 months of age or more. Group B, comprising 46 children who had received only one dose, before 12 months of age. Group C, comprising 79 children who had received only one dose, at 12 months of age or more. The geometric mean titer of antibodies in Group A was 790.1; in Group B, 251.1; and in Group C, 550.3. There was no statistically significant difference between Groups A and C. The exposure to the measles virus was probably similar in all groups, and the children in Group A and C had similar chances of acquiring the disease after vaccination whereas in Group B the chances were higher when compared to the other two groups. The results obtained in this study favor the use, in developing countries, of a vaccination program against measles that includes an early first dose at eight months of age and revaccination after 12 months of age.

Measles immunisation in Thai children aged nine to 14 months

Measles immunisation of nine-month-old Thai children has been part of the national health programme since 1984. In this study we compared the seroconversion rate following measles immunisation in nine-month-old Thai children with the older age groups, i.e. 10 to 14 months of age, to see whether revaccination at over 12 months of age is necessary. In 223 children, 204 had no measles haemagglutination inhibition antibody before measles vaccination. The seroconversion rates in children aged nine to ten, 11 to 12, and 13 to 14 months were 96.1%, 94.5% and 100% respectively with no difference statistically.

Maternally derived measles immunity in era of vaccine-protected mothers

Measles hemagglutinin-inhibiting and neutralizing antibody titers are lower in women young enough to have been immunized by vaccination than in older women. In the children of both young and older mothers the antibody is concentrated 1.7-fold across the placenta, and the child's initial titer remains proportional to that of its mother. The transferred antibody is diluted by the baby's growth and degraded with a mean half-life of 48 days. By 8 1/2 months of age, 95% of the children of the mothers born since 1963 would have become susceptible to measles and responsive to immunization; the same level of susceptibility is not reached by children of mothers born before 1958 until 11 1/2 months of age. Among the offspring of younger mothers, a small group remains, about 2% of the total, with titers high enough to provide protection for 12 months, and these children would be poorly served if the age for vaccination were reduced for all. However, selective early vaccination of children of young mothers who have low antibody titers would eliminate an important focus of measles susceptibility.

Response to measles vaccine in Haitian infants 6 to 12 months old. Influence of maternal antibodies, malnutrition, and concurrent illnesses

To study the factors affecting the serologic response to measles vaccination, we evaluated 595 Haitian infants from 6 through 12 months of age, and their mothers, at the beginning of an immunization program. Thirty-four per cent of the infants had preexisting serologic evidence of measles infections by 11 months of age. Among infants more than nine months of age, those who had had measles had a significantly lower nutritional status than those who had not (P less than 0.01). After vaccination, seroconversion rates increased from 45 per cent at 6 months to 100 per cent at 12 months. The lowest rate of vaccine failure compatible with acceptably low rates of natural infections could be achieved by vaccination after eight months of age. Infants born to mothers with low levels of antibody to measles (hemagglutination-inhibition antibody titers less than 1:40) were significantly more likely to have had natural measles (P less than 0.01) or to have seroconversion after vaccination (P less than 0.001) at 6 to 10 months of age than were infants born to mothers with higher of age than were infants born to mothers with higher titers. Malnutrition and acute infections did not affect seroconversion rates. These data support the World Health Organization recommendation to administer measles vaccine in under-developed countries as soon after nine months of age as possible, regardless of nutritional status or the presence of minor illnesses.

Measles in the 1980s

We detail aspects of measles immunization programmes in several countries. Live measles vaccine has been available in Australia for 16 years, yet, in 1981, there were outbreaks of measles in the State of New South Wales (population 5 200 000) which led to 2200 admissions to hospital and five deaths. In response to complaints of "vaccine failure", a survey determined that 22.5% of children with measles seen by general practitioners and 10.3% of those admitted to hospitals had been previously immunized. There was no evidence of waning immunity, and noparticular batch of vaccine was implicated. The vaccine failures are attributed in part to failure of seroconversion in some recipients when immunized at 12 months of age as a result of interference by transplacentally acquired antibodies. As more of the susceptible population is vaccinated, there will be fewer cases of measles, but among these cases will be an increasing proportion of cases occurring in previously vaccinated individuals. The equation to calculate this expected proportion of "vaccine failures" is given. We support the measures to increase immunization compliance.

Need for measles revaccination in adolescents: correlation with birth date prior to 1972

Measles hemagglutination inhibition (HI) antibody titers of less than 1:4 were significantly (P less than 0.05) more prevalent among subjects born from 1962 through 1971 and vaccinated with a single dose of live measles virus vaccine at 12 months of age (14.5%) than among subjects born during the same years but vaccinated at 13 months or older (2.3%). For subjects born in 1972 through 1976, however, this difference was not statistically significant; titers of less than 1:4 occurred in 6.2% of those vaccinated at 12 months, compared to 0% in those vaccinated at 13 months or older. A decline in maternally derived measles HI antibody may be related to the increased rate of HI antibody titers of 1:4 or greater following vaccination of more recently born subjects. Following revaccination of subjects whose measles HI antibody titers were less than 1:4, measles HI titers were lower than would be expected after successful primary vaccination. Nevertheless, measles HI antibody persisted at a level of 1:4 or more until the latest titer measurement of this study (one to two years after revaccination) in 87.5% of those whose initial vaccination had been at 11 or 12 months of age. No adverse reactions to revaccination occurred. Revaccination programs should be considered for adolescents and young adults born before 1972 who received live measles virus vaccine at or before 12 months. Children born from 1972 through 1976 who were vaccinated at 12 months or later are not in need of revaccination.

Effect of timing of measles vaccination on compliance with immunizations during the second year of life

In 1976 the recommended time for routine measles immunization was changed from 12 to greater than or equal to 15 months of age. Because of the known decrease in compliance with immunizations given during the second year of life and the scheduling of an additional visit close to the time of the diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis (DTP) booster immunization, the potential benefit from this change might be offset by a decrease in compliance in securing both measles vaccination and DTP booster immunization. A study of the change in immunization compliance was carried out in a county health facility and in a prepaid medical group practice. Charts of 795 infants (395 born before and 400 born after the change) were reviewed to assess the rates of compliance with measles and with DTP immunizations. Administration of measles vaccine at a scheduled time decreased by 10% (0.05 less than P less than 0.06) at the public health facility after the change in 1976 and by 13% at the prepaid group practice (P less than 0.01). This difference evened out in the public health facility patients by age 2 years, but a 9% decrease was still apparent at the prepaid medical group. A similar pattern was seen in compliance with the DTP booster immunization at each site. Any benefit derived by an increased measles seroconversion rate apparently was offset by an overall decrease in compliance for both measles and DTP booster immunizations.

School-based measles outbreaks: correlation of age at immunization with risk of disease

During the Spring of 1978, students with a history of previous measles vaccination accounted for over three-forths of 203 cases of measles in a metropolitan county. Seventy cases occurred in two schools where 99% of the students were vaccinated. We analyzed countywide data to determine past patterns of measles vaccination, including outbreak control and vaccination update clinics. We also examined records of children from the two schools to assess the relationship between disease incidence and age at vaccination. When susceptibility was determined by trained health workers rather than by parents, fewer doses of measles vaccine were estimated to be needed. The majority of cases occurred among children 5 to 9 years old. Attack rates were higher for children vaccinated at 12 months of age or younger than for those vaccinated at 13 months of age or older. There were no significant differences in attack rates among children vaccinated at 13 months of age or older. These findings support recommendations for delaying routine measles vaccination until after 12 months of age and suggest that, during outbreaks, all children vaccinated prior to 13 months of age be revaccinated.