The evolution of the scrotum: a new hypothesis

Comparative genomics reveals molecular mechanisms underlying health and reproduction in cryptorchid mammals

BACKGROUND

Mammals have wide variations in testicular position, with scrotal testes in some species and ascrotal testes in others. Although cryptorchidism is hazardous to human health, some mammalian taxa are natural cryptorchids. However, the evolution of testicular position and the molecular mechanisms underlying the maintenance of health, including reproductive health, in ascrotal mammals are not clear.

RESULTS

In the present study, comparative genomics and evolutionary analyses revealed that genes associated with the extracellular matrix and muscle, contributing to the development of the gubernaculum, were involved in the evolution of testicular position in mammals. Moreover, genes related to testicular position were significantly associated with spermatogenesis and sperm fertility. These genes showed rapid evolution and the signature of positive selection, with specific substitutions in ascrotal mammals. Genes associated with testicular position were significantly enriched in functions and pathways related to cancer, DNA repair, DNA replication, and autophagy.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results revealed that alterations in gubernaculum development contributed to the evolution of testicular position in mammals and provided the first support for two hypotheses for variation in testicular position in mammals, the "cooling hypothesis", which proposes that the scrotum provides a cool environment for acutely heat-sensitive sperm and the "training hypothesis", which proposes that the scrotum develops the sperm by exposing them to an exterior environment. Further, we identified cancer resistance and DNA repair as potential protective mechanisms in natural cryptorchids. These findings provide general insights into cryptorchidism and have implications for health and infertility both in humans and domestic mammals.

Spermatogenesis in the Roborovski hamster (Phodopus roborovskii) and the Chinese hamster (Cricetulus griseus)

BACKGROUND

Spermatogenesis is an elaborately organized and tightly regulated differentiation process. The spermatogenesis duration is stable within a certain species but highly variable between species of the same family.

OBJECTIVES

In this study, the spermatogenesis duration of the Roborovski hamster was measured for the first time, and the spermatogenesis duration of the Chinese hamster was re-assessed.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Stage classification and cycle length measurement were carried out by labeling the dividing cells with bromodeoxyuridine and an antibody-based chromogen as well as with the periodic acid-Schiff/hematoxylin stain. Analysis was conducted using reference calculation and linear regression. Morphological measurements completed our set of methods.

RESULTS

The mean duration of one seminiferous epithelium cycle was 8.58 ± 0.34 days (mean ± SEM; Phodopus roborovskii) and 16.59 ± 0.47 days (Cricetulus griseus) based on the reference calculation. Slightly higher results were obtained using linear regression analysis: 9.72 ± 0.41 days for P. roborovskii and 17.64 ± 0.61 days for C. griseus. Additionally, a newly developed exemplary flowchart was proposed for the Roborovski hamster to facilitate spermatogenesis stage classification also in other species. The Chinese hamster presented an unexpectedly high paired epididymides weight of 1.701 ± 0.046 g (mean ± SEM) although having a body weight of only 40.5 ± 0.7 g. However, no significant correlation between the relative epididymis weight and spermatogenesis duration in mammals (Spearman rank correlation: r = -0.119, p = 0.607, n = 21) or rodents could be found (r = 0.045, p = 0.903, n = 11).

CONCLUSION

Our data emphasize the stability of the spermatogenesis duration within species and its remarkable variability between species. Further research is needed to identify the principal mechanisms and selection drivers that are responsible for such stability within species and the variability between species.

Rapid evolution and molecular convergence in cryptorchidism-related genes associated with inherently undescended testes in mammals

BACKGROUND

The mammalian testis is an important male exocrine gland and spermatozoa-producing organ that usually lies in extra-abdominal scrotums to provide a cooler environment for spermatogenesis and sperm storage. Testicles sometimes fail to descend, leading to cryptorchidism. However, certain groups of mammals possess inherently ascrotal testes (i.e. testes that do not descend completely or at all) that have the same physiological functions as completely descended scrotal testes. Although several anatomical and hormonal factors involved in testicular descent have been studied, there is still a paucity of comprehensive research on the genetic mechanisms underlying the evolution of testicular descent in mammals and how mammals with ascrotal testes maintain their reproductive health.

RESULTS

We performed integrative phenotypic and comparative genomic analyses of 380 cryptorchidism-related genes and found that the mammalian ascrotal testes trait is derived from an ancestral scrotal state. Rapidly evolving genes in ascrotal mammals were enriched in the Hedgehog pathway-which regulates Leydig cell differentiation and testosterone secretion-and muscle development. Moreover, some cryptorchidism-related genes in ascrotal mammals had undergone positive selection and contained specific mutations and indels. Genes harboring convergent/parallel amino acid substitutions between ascrotal mammals were enriched in GTPase functions.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that the scrotal testis is an ancestral state in mammals, and the ascrotal phenotype was derived multiple times in independent lineages. In addition, the adaptive evolution of genes involved in testicular descent and the development of the gubernaculum contributed to the evolution of ascrotal testes. Accurate DNA replication, the proper segregation of genetic material, and appropriate autophagy are the potential mechanisms for maintaining physiological normality during spermatogenesis in ascrotal mammals. Furthermore, the molecular convergence of GTPases is probably a mechanism in the ascrotal testes of different mammals. This study provides novel insights into the evolution of the testis and scrotum in mammals and contributes to a better understanding of the pathogenesis of cryptorchidism in humans.

Testicular hyperthermia reduces testosterone concentrations and alters gene expression in testes of Nelore bulls

Increased testicular temperature reduces sperm motility, morphology and fertility. Our objectives were to characterize effects of testicular hyperthermia (scrotal insulation) on acute testosterone concentrations and gene expression in Bos indicus testes. Nelore bulls (n = 20), ∼27 mo of age, 375 kg, scrotal circumference >31 cm, with ≥30% motile sperm, were allocated into four groups (n = 5/group): non-insulated (Control) and insulation removed after 12, 24, or 48 h. Immediately after insulation, intratesticular temperatures (needle thermocouples) were coolest in Control bulls and warmest in 48-h bulls (mean ± SEM, 35.28 ± 0.31 vs 38.62 ± 0.57 °C, P < 0.05). Bulls were castrated and testes recovered. Testicular testosterone concentrations were higher in Control versus 48-h bulls (3119 ± 973.3 and 295.5 ± 122.8 ng/g of tissue, respectively, P < 0.05). Total RNA was extracted, reverse transcribed and RT-qPCR done. For STAR, mRNA abundance decreased from Control to 48 h (1.14 + 0.32 vs 0.32 + 0.5, P < 0.05). For BCL2, expression decreased from Control to 24 h (1.00 + 0.07 vs 0.70 + 0.12, P < 0.05), but then rebounded. In addition, GPX1 had a 70% increase (P < 0.05) at 48 h, whereas HSP70 had a 34-fold increase (P < 0.05) at 12 h and 2- and 14-fold increases (P < 0.05) at 24 and 48 h, respectively. HSF1, BAX, P53 and CASP 8 remained unchanged. Downregulation of STAR, critical in androgen production, was consistent with reduced testosterone concentrations, whereas increased GPX1 enhanced testicular antioxidative capability. Huge increases in HSP70 conferred protection again apoptosis and cell destruction, whereas reduced BCL2 promoted apoptosis. These findings provided novel insights into acute tissue responses (testosterone and gene activity) to testicular hyperthermia in B. indicus bulls.

Testicular hyperthermia increases blood flow that maintains aerobic metabolism in rams

There is a paradigm that testicular hyperthermia fails to increase testicular blood flow and that an ensuing hypoxia impairs spermatogenesis. However, in our previous studies, decreases in normal and motile spermatozoa after testicular warming were neither prevented by concurrent hyperoxia nor replicated by hypoxia. The objective of the present study was to determine the effects of increasing testicular temperature on testicular blood flow and O2 delivery and uptake and to detect evidence of anaerobic metabolism. Under general anaesthesia, the testicular temperature of nine crossbred rams was sequentially maintained at ~33°C, 37°C and 40°C (±0.5°C; 45min per temperature). As testicular temperature increased from 33°C to 40°C there were increases in testicular blood flow (13.2±2.7 vs 17.7±3.2mLmin-1 per 100g of testes, mean±s.e.m.; P<0.05), O2 extraction (31.2±5.0 vs 47.3±3.1%; P<0.0001) and O2 consumption (0.35±0.04 vs 0.64±0.06mLmin-1 per 100g of testes; P<0.0001). There was no evidence of anaerobic metabolism, based on a lack of change in lactate, pH, HCO3- and base excess. In conclusion, these data challenge the paradigm regarding scrotal-testicular thermoregulation, as acute testicular hyperthermia increased blood flow and tended to increase O2 delivery and uptake, with no indication of hypoxia or anaerobic metabolism.

A new paradigm regarding testicular thermoregulation in ruminants?

Increased testicular temperature reduces percentages of morphologically normal and motile sperm and fertility. Specific sperm defects appear at consistent intervals after testicular hyperthermia, with degree and duration of changes related to intensity and duration of the thermal insult. Regarding pathogenesis of testicular hyperthermia on sperm quality and fertility, there is a long-standing paradigm that: 1) testes operate near hypoxia; 2) blood flow to the testes does not increase in response to increased testicular temperature; and 3) an ensuing hypoxia is the underlying cause of heat-induced changes in sperm morphology and function. There are very limited experimental data to support this paradigm, but we have data that refute it. In 2 × 3 factorial studies, mice and rams were exposed to two testicular temperatures (normal and increased) and three concentrations of O₂ in inspired air (hyperoxia, normoxia and hypoxia). As expected, increased testicular temperature had deleterious effects on sperm motility and morphology; however, hyperoxia did not prevent these changes nor did hypoxia replicate them. In two follow-up experiments, anesthetized rams were sequentially exposed to: 1) three O₂ concentrations (100, 21 and 13% O₂); or 2) three testicular temperatures (33, 37 and 40 °C). As O₂, decreased, testis maintained O₂ delivery and uptake by increasing testicular blood flow and O₂ extraction, with no indication of anaerobic metabolism. Furthermore, as testicular temperature increased, testicular metabolic rate nearly doubled, but increased blood flow and O₂ extraction prevented testicular hypoxia and anaerobic metabolism. In conclusion, our data, in combination with other reports, challenged the paradigm that testicular hyperthermia fails to increase testicular blood flow and the ensuing hypoxia disrupts spermatogenesis.

Reappraising the exteriorization of the mammalian testes through evolutionary physiology

A number of theories have been proposed to explain the exteriorization of the testicles in most mammalian species. None of these provide a consistent account for the wide variety of testicular locations found across the animal kingdom. It is proposed that testicular location is the result of coordinate action of testicular tissue ecologies to sustain preferential states of homeostatic equipoise throughout evolutionary development in response to the advent of endothermy.

Increased testicular blood flow maintains oxygen delivery and avoids testicular hypoxia in response to reduced oxygen content in inspired air

Despite a long-standing assertion that mammalian testes operate near hypoxia and increased testicular temperature causes frank hypoxia, we have preliminary evidence that changes are due to hyperthermia per se. The objective was to determine how variations in inspired oxygen concentration affected testicular blood flow, oxygen delivery and extraction, testicular temperature and lactate production. Eight rams were maintained under general anesthesia, with successive decreases in oxygen concentration in inspired air (100, 21 and 13%, respectively). As oxygen concentration decreased from 100 to 13%, there were increases in testicular blood flow (9.6 ± 1.7 vs 12.9 ± 1.9 ml/min/100 g of testis, P < 0.05; mean ± SEM) and conductance (normalized flow; 0.46 ± 0.07 to 1.28 ± 0.19 ml/min/mm Hg/100 g testis (P < 0.05). Increased testicular blood flow maintained oxygen delivery and increased testicular temperature by ~1 °C; this increase was correlated to increased testicular blood flow (r = 0.35, P < 0.0001). Furthermore, oxygen utilization increased concomitantly and there were no significant differences among oxygen concentrations in blood pH, HCO₃− or base excess, and no effects of venous-arterial differences in lactate production. In conclusion, under acute hypoxic conditions, testes maintained oxygen delivery and uptake by increasing blood flow and oxygen extraction, with no evidence of anaerobic metabolism. However, additional studies are needed to determine longer-term responses and potential evidence of anaerobic metabolism at the molecular level.

An Update on Oxidative Damage to Spermatozoa and Oocytes

On the one hand, reactive oxygen species (ROS) are mandatory mediators for essential cellular functions including the function of germ cells (oocytes and spermatozoa) and thereby the fertilization process. However, the exposure of these cells to excessive levels of oxidative stress by too high levels of ROS or too low levels of antioxidative protection will render these cells dysfunctional thereby failing the fertilization process and causing couples to be infertile. Numerous causes are responsible for the delicate bodily redox system being out of balance and causing disease and infertility. Many of these causes are modifiable such as lifestyle factors like obesity, poor nutrition, heat stress, smoking, or alcohol abuse. Possible correctable measures include foremost lifestyle changes, but also supplementation with antioxidants to scavenge excessive ROS. However, this should only be done after careful examination of the patient and establishment of the individual bodily antioxidant needs. In addition, other corrective measures include sperm separation for assisted reproductive techniques. However, these techniques have to be carried out very carefully as they, if applied wrongly, bear risks of generating ROS damaging the germ cells and preventing fertilization.

Singular features of fertilization and their impact on the male reproductive system in eutherian mammals

Therian (marsupial and eutherian) mammals have evolved a suite of novel reproductive features – seen variously in their gametes, the steps of fertilization and the male reproductive tract – whose adaptive significance remains unclear. Present evidence for the better-understood eutherian mammals suggests that the ‘prime mover’ in their evolution has been the character of the egg coat, with other such features being adaptations to the consequences of this. Its elastic thickness allows the zona pellucida to stretch to a variable degree and yet remain around the blastocyst during much or all of its expansion before implantation, but its character represents an unusual challenge for spermatozoa. Novel aspects of the acrosome related to this challenge enable it to maintain a relatively prolonged binding after the onset of the acrosome reaction, and the structure, shape and behaviour of the sperm head point to physical thrust as a major element of zona penetration – with the unique configuration of gamete fusion as a sequela of this strategy. In the male, such adaptations are reflected in sperm head formation in the testis and in sperm maturation in the epididymis involving at least the sperm head's structure, plasmalemma and acrosome. This complexity allied to a slow epididymal sperm transport, a relatively modest sperm production and the brief life span of mature spermatozoa kept above the cauda epididymidis could account for the evolution of the sperm storage function – a development seemingly linked, in turn, to the need for sperm capacitation and scrotal evolution.

On the Origin of Descended Scrotal Testicles: The Activation Hypothesis

Male gonads contained in an unprotected skin sack located outside the body cavity are a peculiar mammalian anomaly. We advance the hypothesis that descended scrotal testicles in humans and many other mammals evolved to provide a situation specific means of activating sperm. As a result of consistent temperature differences between the male and female reproductive tracts (i.e., scrotal temperatures are typically maintained at 2-3°C below body temperature), we propose that the rise to body temperature that accompanies insemination into the vagina serves as one of several triggers for the activation of sperm. We explore some of the features of mammalian reproduction and behavior that are consistent with this hypothesis, make some testable predictions, and examine the psychological and behavioral adaptations that have evolved to protect otherwise vulnerable scrotal testicles from damage.

Testicular descent, sperm maturation and capacitation. Lessons from our most distant relatives, the monotremes

The present review examines whether monotremes may help to resolve three questions relating to sperm production in mammals: why the testes descend into a scrotum in most mammals, why spermatozoa are infertile when they leave the testes and require a period of maturation in the specific milieu provided by the epididymides, and why ejaculated spermatozoa cannot immediately fertilise an ovum until they undergo capacitation within the female reproductive tract. Comparisons of monotremes with other mammals indicate that there is a need for considerable work on monotremes. It is hypothesised that testicular descent should be related to epididymal differentiation. Spermatozoa and ova from both groups share many of the proteins that are thought to be involved in gamete interaction, and although epididymal sperm maturation is significant it is probably less complex in monotremes than in other mammals. However, the monotreme epididymis is unique in forming spermatozoa into bundles of 100 with greatly enhanced motility compared with individual spermatozoa. Bundle formation involves a highly organised interaction with epididymal proteins, and the bundles persist during incubation in vitro, except in specialised medium, in which spermatozoa separate after 2–3 h incubation. It is suggested that this represents an early form of capacitation.

Cycle Length of Spermatogenesis in Shrews (Mammalia: Soricidae) with High and Low Metabolic Rates and Different Mating Systems1

The aim of the present study was to establish and compare the durations of the seminiferous epithelium cycles of the common shrew Sorex araneus, which is characterized by a high metabolic rate and multiple paternity, and the greater white-toothed shrew Crocidura russula, which is characterized by a low metabolic rate and a monogamous mating system. Twelve S. araneus males and fifteen C. russula males were injected intraperitoneally with 5-bromodeoxyuridine, and the testes were collected. For cycle length determinations, we applied the classical method of estimation and linear regression as a new method. With regard to variance, and even with a relatively small sample size, the new method seems to be more precise. In addition, the regression method allows the inference of information for every animal tested, enabling comparisons of different factors with cycle lengths. Our results show that not only increased testis size leads to increased sperm production, but it also reduces the duration of spermatogenesis. The calculated cycle lengths were 8.35 days for S. araneus and 12.12 days for C. russula. The data obtained in the present study provide the basis for future investigations into the effects of metabolic rate and mating systems on the speed of spermatogenesis.

Lifestyle impact and the biology of the human scrotum

The possession of a scrotum to contain the male gonads is a characteristic feature of almost all mammals, and appears to have evolved to allow the testes and epididymis to be exposed to a temperature a few degrees below that of core body temperature. Analysis of cryptorchid patients, and those with varicocele suggest that mild scrotal warming can be detrimental to sperm production, partly by effects on the stem cell population, and partly by effects on later stages of spermatogenesis and sperm maturation. Recent studies on the effects of clothing and lifestyle emphasize that these can also lead to chronically elevated scrotal temperatures. In particular, the wearing of nappies by infants is a cause for concern in this regard. Together all of the evidence indirectly supports the view that lifestyle factors in addition to other genetic and environmental influences could be contributing to the secular trend in declining male reproductive parameters. The challenge will be to provide relevant and targeted experimental results to support or refute the currently circumstantial evidence.

Enigmas of mammalian gamete form and function

The gametes of man and some other Eutheria have been manipulated successfully for practical reasons, but many gaps remain in our basic understanding of the way that they function. This situation stems not least from a failure to recognize the extent to which eutherian spermatozoa and eggs, and elements related to their operation, have come to differ from those of other groups. Novel features in the male that reflect this include a radical design of the sperm head with the acrosome seeming to function primarily in egg-coat binding rather than its lysis, a multifaceted post-testicular sperm maturation and an androgen/low-temperature-regulated system of sperm storage--both tied to the epididymis, a variable male accessory sex gland complex, and descent of the testis and epididymis to a scrotum. In the female, such novelties are represented in a need for sperm capacitation, in an unusual regulation of sperm transport within the oviduct, in the cumulus oophorus and character of the zona pellucida around the small egg, and in a unique configuration of gamete fusion. The collective evidence now suggests that many of these features reflect a new fertilisation strategy or its consequences, with most being causally linked. One initial 'domino' in this regard appears to be the small yolkless state of the egg and its intolerance for polyspermy, as determinants of the unusual mode of oviductal sperm transport and possibly the existence and form of the cumulus oophorus. However, a particularly influential first 'domino' appears to be the physical character of the eutherian zona pellucida. This differs from the egg coats of other animal groups by virtue of a resilient elasticity and thickness. These qualities allow this primary and often only coat to stretch and so persist during later expansion of the blastocyst, usually until close to implantation. At the same time, the dimensions, physical character, and particularly the relative protease-insensitivity of the zona appear to have had profound effects on sperm form and function and, more indirectly, on sperm-related events in the male and the female tract. Marsupials display some similarities and also some strikingly different features, against which the enigmas of the eutherian situation can be evaluated.

Retrotransposition of glycerol kinase-related genes from the X chromosome to autosomes: functional and evolutionary aspects

Glycerol kinase catalyzes the metabolism of endogenously derived and dietary glycerol. GyK is a member of a small group of kinases termed ambiquitous enzymes, which are found either in the cytosol or as membrane-bound complexes associated with the voltage-dependent anion channel of the mitochondrial outer membrane. In Homo sapiens, the GyK gene family consists of an X-encoded locus and several X-linked and autosomal intronless retroposons, which, apparently, comprise both functional genes and processed pseudogenes. To study the role of the autosomal genes in mammalian physiology, we have isolated two murine GyK-like genes, determined their structures and chromosomal locations, and examined their functions. These sequences are intronless retroposons, which appear to be paralogues of the X-encoded, brain-specific GyK isoform and are expressed only in the testes. Though both retrotransposition events appear to have occurred prior to the primate-rodent divergence of some 65-80 million years ago, only one of the retrotransposed murine gene sequences, based upon its chromosomal location, is conserved with modern H. sapiens. To test the hypothesis that the murine GyK-like genes encode functional GyK activity, transient transfection of the gene sequences into COS7 cells was carried out. While in vitro translation confirmed that the transcripts could direct the synthesis of proteins of the appropriate size, no GyK activity was detected. Such data suggest that the autosomal GyK-like genes have evolved novel, testis-specific functions. A comparison of the human and mouse GyK-like gene sequences demonstrates the evolutionary relationships between each autosomal isoform and its corresponding X-linked ancestral locus.

To store or mature spermatozoa? The primary role of the epididymis

The function of the epididymis is considered in the context that it is necessary to transport spermatozoa for internal fertilization, but is also an adaptation involved in the competition between males to achieve paternity. Post-testicular sperm maturation and storage occur in lower vertebrates, such as the chondrichthyes, in which sperm storage is essential due to the slow rate of spermatogenesis. These roles persist in higher vertebrates, including mammals. However, they are less important in certain birds, in which the rate of sperm production by the testes is sufficient to supply enough spermatozoa to cope with the demands of a competitive mating system. There is no evidence for mammals, other than humans, that spermatozoa can achieve the capacity to fertilize an ovum without passing through some of the proximal epididymis. Storage of spermatozoa in the epididymis is probably not essential for a male to achieve conception in a protected mating system, but is very important in a competitive mating system. There is some variation between species in the magnitude of the epididymal storage region. This is related to the descent of the epididymides (and testes) into a scrotal sac in some species and/or the demands of the mating system in other species. The claims that humans are not dependent on post-testicular sperm maturation and storage need to be qualified, as they are based on studies of abnormal tracts and tests of fertility which are not rigorous. Nevertheless, the claims are of considerable clinical significance and may indicate that humans are less dependent on post-testicular sperm maturation and storage than other mammals. This may be an adaptation of the testes and epididymides to the scrotal conditions of modern man or a response to changing environmental factors.

Studies on the fetal development of the gubernaculum in cetacea

BACKGROUND

Adult cetacean males, like non-mammalian vertebrates and other testicond mammals, have intra-abdominal testes. There is no evidence of a processus vaginalis in them. Testicondia in cetaceans is considered secondary as they are judged, evolutionarily, the descendants of terrestrial mammals (ungulates) with testis descent. A possible argument in support of the latter contention would be that cetacean fetuses develop gubernacula which are the primordia of the processus vaginalis and other structures associated with testis descent in other placental mammals. The present study intended to analyse cetacean fetuses in this respect.

METHODS

Serial sections of 25 fetuses (total body length between 39.5 and 160 mm) of 4 cetacean species (Delphinus delphis, Phocoena phocoena, Eschrichtius robustus, Physeter catodon) were examined with special attention to the presence or absence of structures homologous to the gubernaculum of other placental mammals (rats and humans).

RESULTS

Gubernacular primordia were observed in fetuses from about the time of onset of sexual differentiation. Their shape and anatomical relationship with the surrounding structures were similar as those in mammals with testis descent. The gubernaculum in males developed into a large mass of dense connective tissue in the ventral-caudal abdominal region at the site of the insertion of the mesonephric inguinal ligament and associated to the tip of the internal abdominal oblique muscle. No (or only very little) development of a processus vaginalis was noticed.

CONCLUSIONS

The results demonstrate initial emergence of mammalian-like gubernacular primordia in cetacean fetuses without their further development to elaborate structures required for testis descent. The findings support the view that cetaceans are secondarily testicond. It is suggested that (1) absence of the pelvic girdle together with (2) the development of structures in and beyond the caudal abdominal region, particularly the caudal hypaxial musculature, precludes the outgrowth, into caudal direction, of hollow organs (such as the processus vaginalis) from the abdominal cavity.