Intracellular protein degradation: basis of a self-regulating mechanism for the proteolysis of endogenous proteins

Out with the old, in with the new? Comparing methods for measuring protein degradation

Protein degradation is a critical factor in controlling cellular protein abundance. Here, we compare classical methods for determining protein degradation rates to a novel GFP (green fluorescent protein) fusion protein based method that assesses the intrinsic stability of cloned cDNA library products by flow cytometry [Yen et al. (2008) Science 322, 918]. While no method is perfect, we conclude that chimeric gene reporter approaches, though powerful, should be applied cautiously, due principally to GFP (or other reporter tag) interference with protein organelle targeting or incorporation into macromolecular assemblies, both of which cause spuriously high degradation rates.

Protein balance: a fundamental question of cell biology needing reappraisal

Although protein synthesis and protein degradation are two independent processes that are firmly regulated, how they maintain a balance of protein in the non-growing cell remains to be established. In work in the 1980s, the author suggested a self-regulating mechanism. However, experimental work on this interesting and fundamental problem is needed for a better understanding of 'protein balance' in cells.

Hydrophobicity as a driver of MHC class I antigen processing

The forces that drive conversion of nascent protein to major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I-restricted peptides remain unknown. We explored the fundamental property of overt hydrophobicity as such a driver. Relocation of a membrane glycoprotein to the cytosol via signal sequence ablation resulted in rapid processing of nascent protein not because of the misfolded luminal domain but because of the unembedded transmembrane (TM) domain, which serves as a dose-dependent degradation motif. Dislocation of the TM domain during the natural process of endoplasmic reticulum-associated degradation (ERAD) similarly accelerated peptide production, but in the context of markedly prolonged processing that included nonnascent species. These insights into intracellular proteolytic pathways and their selective contributions to MHC class I-restricted peptide supply, may point to new approaches in rational vaccine design.

How is the balance between protein synthesis and degradation achieved?

Unlike most substances that cells manufacture, proteins are not produced and broken down by a common series of chemical reactions, but by completely different (independent and disconnected) mechanisms that possess no intrinsic means of making the rates of the two processes equal and attaining steady state concentrations. Balance between them is achieved extrinsically and is often imagined today to be the result of the actions of chemical feedback agents. But however instantiated, chemical feedback or any similar mechanism can only rectify induced imbalances in a system previously balanced by other means. Those "other means" necessarily involve reversible mass action or equilibrium-based interactions between native and altered forms of protein molecules somewhere in time and space between their synthesis and degradation.

Rethinking peptide supply to MHC class I molecules

The notion that peptides bound to MHC class I molecules are derived mainly from newly synthesized proteins that are defective, and are therefore targeted for immediate degradation, has gained wide acceptance. This model, still entirely hypothetical, has strong intuitive appeal and is consistent with some experimental results, but it is strained by other findings, as well as by established and emerging concepts in protein quality control. While not discounting defectiveness as a driving force for the processing of some proteins, we propose that MHC-class-I-restricted epitopes are derived mainly from nascent proteins that are accessed by the degradation machinery prior to any assessment of fitness, and we outline one way in which this could be accomplished.

Protein metabolism in marine animals: the underlying mechanism of growth

Growth is a fundamental process within all marine organisms. In soft tissues, growth is primarily achieved by the synthesis and retention of proteins as protein growth. The protein pool (all the protein within the organism) is highly dynamic, with proteins constantly entering the pool via protein synthesis or being removed from the pool via protein degradation. Any net change in the size of the protein pool, positive or negative, is termed protein growth. The three inter-related processes of protein synthesis, degradation and growth are together termed protein metabolism. Measurement of protein metabolism is vital in helping us understand how biotic and abiotic factors affect growth and growth efficiency in marine animals. Recently, the developing fields of transcriptomics and proteomics have started to offer us a means of greatly increasing our knowledge of the underlying molecular control of protein metabolism. Transcriptomics may also allow us to detect subtle changes in gene expression associated with protein synthesis and degradation, which cannot be detected using classical methods. A large literature exists on protein metabolism in animals; however, this chapter concentrates on what we know of marine ectotherms; data from non-marine ectotherms and endotherms are only discussed when the data are of particular relevance. We first consider the techniques available to measure protein metabolism, their problems and what validation is required. Protein metabolism in marine organisms is highly sensitive to a wide variety of factors, including temperature, pollution, seasonality, nutrition, developmental stage, genetics, sexual maturation and moulting. We examine how these abiotic and biotic factors affect protein metabolism at the level of whole-animal (adult and larval), tissue and cellular protein metabolism. Available gene expression data, which help us understand the underlying control of protein metabolism, are also discussed. As protein metabolism appears to comprise a significant proportion of overall metabolic costs in marine organisms, accurate estimates of the energetic cost per unit of synthesised protein are important. Measured costs of protein metabolism are reviewed, and the very high variability in reported costs highlighted. Two major determinants of protein synthesis rates are the tissue concentration of RNA, often expressed as the RNA to protein ratio, and the RNA activity (k(RNA)). The effects of temperature, nutrition and developmental stage on RNA concentration and activity are considered. This chapter highlights our complete lack of knowledge of protein metabolism in many groups of marine organisms, and the fact we currently have only limited data for animals held under a narrow range of experimental conditions. The potential assistance that genomic methods may provide in increasing our understanding of protein metabolism is described.

Interferon-gamma, the functional plasticity of the ubiquitin-proteasome system, and MHC class I antigen processing

The proteasome system is a central component of a cascade of proteolytic processing steps required to generate antigenic peptides presented at the cell surface to cytotoxic T lymphocytes by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules. The nascent protein pool or DRiPs (defective ribosomal products) appear to represent an important source for MHC class I epitopes. Owing to the destructive activities of aminopeptidases in the cytosol, at most 1% of the peptides generated by the ubiquitin-proteasome system seems to be made available to the immune system. Interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) helps to override these limitations by the formation of immunoproteasomes, the activator complex PA28, and the induction of several aminopeptidases. Both immunoproteasomes and PA28 use cleavage sites already used by constitutive proteasomes but with altered and in some cases dramatically enhanced frequency. Therefore, two proteolytic cascades appear to have evolved to provide MHC class I epitopes. The 'constitutive proteolytic cascade' is designed to efficiently degrade proteins to single amino acid residues, allowing only a small percentage of peptides to be presented at the cell surface. In contrast, the IFN-gamma-controlled proteolytic cascade generates larger amounts of appropriate antigenic peptides, assuring more peptides to overcome the proteolytic restrictions of the constitutive system, thereby enhancing MHC class I antigen presentation.

Non-equilibrium proteins

There exist no methodical studies concerning non-equilibrium systems in cellular biology. This paper is an attempt to partially fill this shortcoming. We have undertaken an extensive data-mining operation in the existing scientific literature to find scattered information about non-equilibrium subcellular systems, in particular concerning fast proteins, i.e. those with short turnover half-time. We have advanced the hypothesis that functionality in fast proteins emerges as a consequence of their intrinsic physical instability that arises due to conformational strains resulting from co-translational folding (the interdependence between chain elongation and chain folding during biosynthesis on ribosomes). Such intrinsic physical instability, a kind of conformon (Klonowski-Klonowska conformon, according to Ji, (Molecular Theories of Cell Life and Death, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, 1991)) is probably the most important feature determining functionality and timing in these proteins. If our hypothesis is true, the turnover half-time of fast proteins should be positively correlated with their molecular weight, and some experimental results (Ames et al., J. Neurochem. 35 (1980) 131) indeed demonstrated such a correlation. Once the native structure (and function) of a fast protein macromolecule is lost, it may not be recovered--denaturation of such proteins will always be irreversible; therefore, we searched for information on irreversible denaturation. Only simulation and modeling of protein co-translational folding may answer the questions concerning fast proteins (Ruggiero and Sacile, Med. Biol. Eng. Comp. 37 (Suppl. 1) (1999) 363). Non-equilibrium structures may also be built up of protein subunits, even if each one taken by itself is in thermodynamic equilibrium (oligomeric proteins; sub-cellular sol-gel dissipative network structures).

The fates of proteins in cells

Nascent polypeptide chains are in a dangerous situation as soon as they leave their place of birth, the channel of the large ribosomal subunit: more than 20 different pathways for the degradation of proteins exist in cells. Chaperones protect and guide the young protein molecules and support their correct foldings. Targeting signals direct the proteins to the organelles of their destination. The lysosome is the site of random degradation, while the proteasome is highly selective. Although these two organelles provide the most important pathways for the degradation of long- and short-lived proteins, other pathways with roles in deciding the fate of cellular proteins must also be considered.

The occurrence and functions of ultradian rhythms

Ultradian oscillations with periods between 5 min and 4 h have been described in cell-free extracts, single-celled eukaryotes, cultured cells and embryos. Whereas some of these potentially oscillatory systems (e.g. glycolysis) may only exhibit this type of behaviour rarely if at all in vivo, other ultradian oscillators in lower eukaryotes are rhythms and probably have timekeeping functions. Rhythms with ultradian periods of 10 min to 20 h in oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide production have also been studied in endotherm animals: these rhythms may be modified by variations of environmental parameters and by circadian and infradian synchronizers. Interspecies and interstrain differences strongly suggest that these rhythms are endogenous and have a genetic origin. We suggest that the temporal organization of biochemical and physiological processes facilitates optimization of thermodynamic maintenance of the organism within the random fluctuations of its physicochemical environment and contributes to genetic selection.

Induced frameshifting mechanism of replication for an information-carrying scrapie prion

A specific mistranslation mechanism for the replication of an infectious protein is described. The feedback mechanism requires the infectious agent to induce concerted frameshifts during the translation of a cellular gene. Each module of the tandem repeat region of the gene encoding the prion protein (PrP) associated with scrapie infectivity contains multiple sites of potential ribosomal frameshifting. It is proposed that some aberrant variants of PrP containing frameshifted peptides within the octapeptide repeat region of the protein backbone are able to replicate and cause scrapie by interfering with the translation and simultaneous translocation of nascent PrP molecules into the lumen of the endoplasmic reticulum. The model provides a plausible explanation for the behaviour of host-adapted scrapie strains as well as the aetiology of scrapie-like diseases. The hypothesis that a mistranslated PrP is the scrapie agent can also explain discrepancies between the published amino acid sequence of PrP and the sequence deduced from the gene.

Mechanism and regulation of protein degradation in liver

The degradation of intracellular protein and other cytoplasmic macromolecules in liver is an ongoing process that regulates cytoplasmic mass and provides amino acids for energy and other metabolic uses early in starvation. Cellular proteins are conveniently divided into two general classes according to readily discernable differences in average rates of turnover. A short-lived class, having a half-life of approximately 10 min, comprises about 0.6% of total protein. Its degradation is not physiologically controlled, and the mechanism is probably nonlysosomal in nature. The second or long-lived group, with an average half-life 250 times greater, constitutes more than 99% of the cell's protein. By contrast, its breakdown is strongly regulated, and the site of catabolism is believed to be the vacuolar-lysosomal system. Cytoplasmic sequestration by lysosomes can be divided into two categories; macro- and microautophagy. The first is induced by amino acid and/or insulin deprivation. Amino acids are considered to be primary regulators, since they can control this process over the full range of induced proteolysis in the absence of hormones. Glucagon, cyclic AMP, and beta-agonists also stimulate macroautophagy in hepatocytes but have opposite effects in myocytes. Micrautophagy differs from the former in that the cytoplasmic "bite" is smaller and the uptake process is not acutely regulated. However, the latter does decrease during starvation in parallel with basal proteolysis, effects that might be linked to the loss of endoplasmic reticulum. The primary control of macroautophagy is accomplished through a small group of direct regulators (Leu, Tyr/Phe, Gln, Pro, Met, His, and Trp) and a specific coregulatory action of alanine. As a group, regulatory amino acids produce direct inhibitory responses in the perfused rat liver that are identical to those of the complete amino acid mixture at 0.5x and 4x (times) normal plasma concentrations. However, they lose effectiveness almost completely within a narrow zone centered at normal levels, a loss that can be abolished by the addition of alanine at its normal plasma concentration (0.5 mM). At this level, alanine does not inhibit directly. Interestingly, this zonal loss is also eliminated by insulin. Glucagon, though, specifically blocks the initial inhibition evoked by 0.5x amino acid mixtures and thus induces maximal rates of protein degradation at normal amino acid concentrations.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Proteinases and their inhibitors in cells and tissues

A large body of evidence has been assembled to indicate the substantial importance of proteolytic processes in various physiological functions. It has recently become clear too that endo-acting peptide bond hydrolases provisionally characterized and classified at present as serine, cysteine, aspartic and metallo together with unknown catalytic mechanism proteinases sometimes act in cascades. They are controlled by natural proteinase inhibitors present in cells and body fluids. In the first part of the present monograph the author was concerned to present an overview on the morphological and physiological approach to localization, surveying reaction principles and methods suitable for visualization of proteolytic enzymes and their natural and synthetic inhibitors. In the second part the roles played by proteinases have been summarized from the point of view of cell biology. The selection of earlier and recent data reviewed on the involvement of proteolysis in the behavior of individual cells reveals that enzymes, whether they be exogeneous or intrinsic, can be effective and sensitive modulators of cellular growth and morphology. There exists a close correlation between malignant growth and degradation of cells. It appears likely that as yet unknown or at least so far inadequately characterized factors that influence the survival or the death of cells may turn out to be proteinases. The causal role of extracellular proteolysis in cancer cell metastases, in stopping cancer cell growth and in cytolysis remains for further investigated. Ovulation, fertilization and implantation are basic biological functions in which proteolytic enzymes play a key role. The emergence of new approaches in reproductive biology and a growing factual basis will inevitably necessitate a reevaluation of present knowledge of proteolytic processes involved. The molecular aspects of intracellular protein catabolism have been discussed in terms of the inhibition of lysosomal and/or non-lysosomal protein breakdown. Peptide and protein hormone biosynthesis and inactivation are still at the centre of interest in cell biology, and a number of proteinases have been implicated in both processes. A number of conjectures partly based on the author's own work have been discussed which suggest the possibility of the involvement of proteolysis in exocytosis and endocytosis. The author's optimistic conclusion is that through the common action of biochemists, cell biologists, cytochemists, and pharmacologists the mystery of cellular proteolysis is beginning to be solved.

Synthesis, accumulation and turnover of carbamoylphosphate synthetase and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase in cultures of embryonic rat hepatocytes

Glucocorticosteroid, thyroid hormones and cyclic AMP can induce the synthesis of carbamoylphosphate synthetase and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase in cultures of hepatocytes as soon as these cells differentiate from the embryonic foregut. The low levels of both enzymes that can accumulate in such still protodifferentiated hepatocytes are due to low levels of enzyme synthesis. In cultures, the rate of synthesis of both enzymes increases continually in the presence of hormones, showing that maturation of the capacity for synthesis towards the postnatal, fully differentiated situation is occurring in these cells. The turnover rate of both enzymes in embryonic hepatocytes is lower in the presence of hormones than in the absence, but does not change during the culture period. In the presence of hormones the turnover rate is comparable to that found in adult rat liver in vivo. The development of the capacity to accumulate organ-specific enzymes in vitro (and hence the rate of enzyme synthesis) is found to be comparable to that in utero.

Degradation of short- and long-lived proteins in perfused liver and in isolated autophagic vacuoles--lysosomes

The lysosomal contribution to breakdown of prelabeled short- and long-lived cell proteins in the perfused rat liver was monitored in two ways. In the first, either leupeptin or chloroquine was injected into rats as well as added to the perfusate. The extent of suppression of proteolysis compared to that of controls was equated with the lysosomal share of protein breakdown. Both compounds inhibited degradation of short-lived proteins by some 30% and long-lived proteins by some 60%. In the second approach, lysosomal-autophagic vacuolar (LAV) fractions were isolated from livers pretreated and perfused as above. The LAV fractions generated different amounts of degradation products during subsequent incubations. They were, in decreasing order of magnitude, that of the LAV fraction isolated from livers perfused with chloroquine, without inhibitor, and with leupeptin. The LAV fraction from control livers was considered to yield the most reliable estimate of the lysosomal share of proteolysis as recorded during liver perfusions. It was 54% for short-lived proteins and 75% for long-lived proteins. These figures are higher than those obtained in the perfusion experiments in the first approach. It is therefore suggested that quantitative assessment concerning the lysosomal share of overall proteolysis may be underestimated when based on inhibition experiments performed on intact cells. The ultrastructure of hepatocytes and LAV fractions was also investigated. Leupeptin-treated hepatocytes displayed more frequent and larger AVs than those of control livers. Cell vacuolation was an additional characteristic of chloroquine-exposed hepatocytes. The LAV fractions isolated from control and leupeptin-treated livers mirrored the observations made in liver tissue. The constituents of the LAV fraction isolated from chloroquine-treated tissue were, however, less swollen than in situ, probably due to the extraction of water during isolation.

Pressure-adaptive differences in proteolytic inactivation of M4-lactate dehydrogenase homologues from marine fishes

The inactivation by hydrostatic pressure of muscle-type lactate dehydrogenase (M4-LDH, EC 1.1.1.27; L-lactate: NAD+ oxidoreductase) homologues from five shallow-living and six deep-living marine teleost fishes was compared. The pressures which inactivate these enzymes are much higher than the pressures experienced by any of the species. To determine whether hydrostatic pressure effects on protein aggregation state and conformation might influence proteolysis, the inactivation of LDH by the proteases, trypsin (EC 3.4.21.4) and subtilisin (EC 3.4.4.16) was determined at atmospheric pressure and 1,000 atm pressure. At 10 degrees C and atmospheric pressure, the enzymes of the shallow-living fishes are inactivated four times faster by trypsin and three times faster by subtilisin than are the homologues of the deep-living species. At 1,000 atm pressure, the homologues of shallow-occurring fishes were inactivated 28 to 64% more than predicted from the summed effects of denaturation by 1,000 atm pressure and tryptic inactivation at atmospheric pressure. In contrast, the homologues of the deep-sea species were inactivated by trypsin 0 to 21% more than expected. At 1,000 atm, inactivation by subtilisin increased to a similar degree for enzymes from both deep- and shallow-living species. However, at 1,000 atm, the M4-LDH homologues of the deep-sea species lost less activity (55.3%) than did the homologues of the shallow species (86.4%). In comparisons made at 200 atm, a pressure typical of the habitat of the deep-occurring species, tryptic inactivation of the LDH of the shallow-living Sebastes melanops was increased 14%. No pressure inactivation of the enzyme is evident at 200 atm.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Scrapie, ribosomal proteins and biological information

Consideration of the autocatalytic synthesis of ribosomal proteins leads to a criterion for the infectivity of a foreign proteinaceous species in terms of the biochemical rate constants governing the propagation of errors during the translation of genetic information in a model system. Evidence pertaining to the suggestion that scrapie and its analogues are caused by proteinaceous infectious agents (prions) which replicate by invading the translation process and altering ribosomal specificity is examined. It is found that anomalous aetiological features of scrapie infection are explained by the model. An analysis suggesting that the possibility of prion replication undermines the basis of current molecular biological theory is provided and it is concluded that the exclusive identification of biological information with nucleic acid sequences is unjustified.

Catabolism of intracellular protein: molecular aspects

All living cells regulate the content and composition of their resident proteins, but the mechanisms by which this is accomplished are not understood. The process of protein degradation has an important role in determining steady state and fluctuations of protein concentrations in mammalian cells. This process may be regulated by innate properties of the protein substrates, by factors that interact or "brand" proteins for degradation or by the degradative machinery of the cell. For a specific protein, there appears to be a committed step, an irreversible event that leads to rapid and extensive degradation. That initial event may or may not involve 1) proteolysis, 2) a nonproteolytic covalent modification or branding event (e.g., oxidation, ubiquitin conjugation), 3) denaturation or unfolding of the protein, or 4) sequestration. The degradative machinery of cells may either recognize proteins committed to degradation or initiate degradation, but the process must be selective because there is great heterogeneity in the rates of degradation for different proteins of one cell. The degradative process certainly requires proteases, and it is probable that lysosomal and extralysosomal proteases are involved in the catabolism of cellular proteins. We review here briefly what is currently known about the factors that may determine the half-life of a protein in a mammalian cell, the role of the protein substrate and sequestration in the process, the proteolytic and nonproteolytic enzymes that may initiate the degradative process, and the regulation of extensive degradation of proteins in cells.

Pressure inactivation of tetrameric lactate dehydrogenase homologues of confamilial deep-living fishes

The susceptibility to inactivation by hydrostatic pressure of the tetrameric muscle-type (M4) lactate dehydrogenase homologues (LDH, EC 1.1.1.27; L-lactate: NAD+ oxidoreductase) from six confamilial macrourid fishes was compared at 4 degrees C. These marine teleost fishes occur over depths of 260 to 4815 m. The pressures necessary to half-inactivate the LDH homologues are related to the pressures which the enzymes are exposed to in vivo; higher hydrostatic pressures are required to inactivate the LDH homologues of the deeper-occurring macrourids. The resistance of the LDH homologues to inactivation by pressure is affected by protein concentration. After an hour of incubation at pressure, the percent remaining activity approaches an asymptomatic value. The inactivation of the macrourid LDH homologues by pressure was not fully reversible. Assuming that inactivation by pressure was due to dissociation of the native tetramer to monomers, apparent equilibrium constants (Keq) were calculated. Volume changes (delta V) were calculated over the range of pressures for which plots ln Keq versus pressure were linear. The delta V of dissociation values of the macrourid homologues range from -219 to -439 ml mol-1. Although the hydrostatic pressures required to inactivate the LDH homologues of the macrourid fishes are greater than those which the enzymes are exposed to in vivo, the pressure-stability of these enzymes may reflect the resistance of these enzymes to pressure-enhanced proteolysis in vivo.

Investigation of the mechanism of protein turnover in HeLa S-3 cells by incubation at elevated temperatures

An apparent paradox relating to the degradation of endogenous proteins in HeLa S-3 cells occurs at 45 degrees C, at which their proteolysis is considerably enhanced in vitro but completely inhibited in vivo. No significant differences in rates of degradation of short-lived (nascent) and long-lived ('existing') proteins synthesised at 37 degrees C were found when chased at temperatures up to 43 degrees C, but at 45 degrees C degradation of both categories was reduced to zero in vivo. Synthesis of protein was suppressed at temperatures above 41 degrees C, being reduced by up to 60% at 43 degrees C. Proteolysis in vitro proceeded 1.6-1.7 times faster at 45 degrees C than at 37 degrees C and neutral pH. Evidence is presented for the involvement of the basal system; the findings both in vivo and in vitro do not seem to implicate the lysosomal system, no firm indication being obtained of its 'induction' at elevated temperatures. The results are discussed in terms of the arrest of intracellular circulation at elevated temperatures, thereby reducing the delivery rate of proteins as substrates of the intracellular basal proteolytic enzyme system to negligible levels (i.e., to the frequency of encounters due solely to the diffusion of protein molecules with the cytoplasm).

Mini-review. On the possible importance of an intracellular circulation

Since ultrastructural, biophysical and other studies continue to demonstrate that the internum of the cell is highly structured, the question raised and discussed in this review is whether an intracellular circulatory system is essential for the maintenance of active metabolism. Although cytoplasmic streaming is evident in large animal and plant cells, it is argued that it probably occurs in all cells irrespective of size, and is of particular importance in bringing together interacting molecules fast enough for metabolic processes to occur which would otherwise be far too slow if diffusion were the only form of motion. A common intracellular system would suffice for most metabolic processes and would also help to dissipate waste products. Interruption of this internal circulation would result in the inhibition of metabolic functioning, including for example protein turnover, for which evidence is presented to substantiate this hypothesis.