Arterial line filtration during cardiopulmonary bypass

Cerebral dysfunction after cardiopulmonary bypass: aetiology, manifestations and interventions

Central nervous system dysfunction following cardiac surgery remains a significant cause of morbidity and mortality, with the reported incidence of dysfunction varying widely between studies. Microemboli and global cerebral hypoperfusion are implicated as the major aetiologies of CNS impairment. Preoperative and intraoperative variables influencing the patient's risk of complications remain controversial. Based on a review of previous studies, this paper outlines the major causes and manifestations of CNS impairment as well as the intraoperative interventions currently advocated to improve the cerebral outcome of cardiac patients.

Haematological effects of a depth absorption arterial line filter during extracorporeal circulation

An arterial line filter (Swank High Flow 6000) was used during extracorporeal circulation (ECC) in 21 of 45 patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting, to study haematological effects. The mean age was 60 (41-69) years. All patients had obstructions of at least three coronary artery branches. Average ECC and aortic crossclamp times, drainage via chest tubes until the first day after surgery, total transfusions of blood products and haemolysis did not differ in the two groups. After 90 minutes of ECC, leukocyte counts were significantly lower in the filter group whereas haematocrit, counts of erythrocytes, lymphocytes and platelets, platelet volume, fibrinogen concentration and fibrinopeptide A were similar. Release of β-thromboglobulin and platelet factor 4 were significantly higher in the filter group. No clinically significant adverse haematological effects were observed with use of the arterial line filter, although there were indications of more pronounced platelet damage in the filter group.

The scientific evidence of arterial line filtration in cardiopulmonary bypass

BACKGROUND

The indication for arterial line filtration (ALF) is to inhibit embolisation during cardiopulmonary bypass. Filtration methods have developed from depth filters to screen filters and from a stand-alone component to an integral part of the oxygenator. For many years, ALF has been a standard adopted by a majority of cardiac centres worldwide. The following review aims to summarize the available evidence in support for ALF and report on its current practice in Europe.

METHOD

The principles and application of ALF in Europe was investigated using a survey conducted in 2014. The scientific evidence for ALF was examined by performing a systematic literature search in six different databases, using the following search terms: "Cardiopulmonary bypass AND filters AND arterial". The primary endpoint was protection against cerebral injury verified by the degree of cerebral embolisation or cognitive tests. The secondary endpoint was improvement of the clinical outcome verified elsewise. Only randomised clinical trials were considered.

RESULTS

The response rate was 31% (n=112). The great majority (88.5%) of respondents were using ALF, following more than 10 years of experience. Integrated arterial filtration was used by 55%. Of respondents not using ALF, fifty-four percent considered starting using integrated arterial filtration. The systematic literature database search returned 180 unique publications where 82 were specifically addressing ALF in cardiopulmonary bypass. Only four out of the 82 identified publications fulfilled our inclusion criteria. Of these, three were more than 20 years old and based on the use of bubble oxygenation.

CONCLUSION

ALF is a standard implemented in a majority of cardiopulmonary bypass procedures in Europe. The level of scientific evidence available in support of current arterial line filtration methods in cardiopulmonary bypass is, however, poor. Large, well-designed, randomised trials are warranted.

Reducing emboli in cardiac surgery: does it make a difference?

Particulate embolization remains a serious complication of cardiac surgery. Adverse events associated with particulate embolization affect patient morbidity and long-term survival, and increase the length of hospital stay and the cost of health care. Today, atherosclerosis plays a role in at least two-thirds of all adverse events after coronary artery revascularization, and postoperative stroke is the second most common cause of operative mortality. Because many lower-risk patients now undergo interventional revascularization, higher-risk patients are now typically referred for surgical revascularization. These patients are older and sicker, and have multiple comorbidities, making them more susceptible to adverse events. For these high-risk patients, surgeons should be proactive in attempting to reduce the possibility of emboli. Patients must be carefully assessed before surgery to determine their risk, and if the risk is high, surgeons should consider using newer, innovative devices, and techniques in their operative strategy that have proven to be effective in mitigating some of the potential embolic adverse events. A multifaceted, preventive strategy can make a difference, not only in reducing particulate emboli, but also in reducing morbidity and in lowering the economic burden on the health-care system. This brief review will address three areas of focus that are important for the prevention of particulate embolization: (i) prevalence and morbidity of atherosclerotic disease; (ii) risk factors for adverse neurologic events; and (iii) prevention/mitigation of adverse events for patients undergoing cardiac surgery.

Dynamic bubble trap can replace an arterial filter during cardiopulmonary bypass surgery

Objective: The arterial filter (AF) and the dynamic bubble trap (DBT) reduce the number of air microbubbles passing through these devices. The aim of the study was to confirm that the DBT diminishes microbubbles in the arterial line similar to, or better than, the AF, and can replace it.

Methods: In a clinical study, we evaluated 60 patients undergoing cardiopulmonary bypass surgery, divided into two groups (30 patients each). In the first group, we used an open extracorporeal system, and in the second group, a closed system. For 15 patients in each group, the AF was incorporated, the other 15 patients received the DBT. The microbubbles were counted before and after the AF or DBT, using two-channel-ultrasonic Doppler devices.

Results: The exposure of patients to small bubbles (<45μm) is significantly higher in the AF than in the DBT group. The DBT reduces large bubbles (<45μm) better than the AF, with a rate exceeding 16%.

Conclusion: The use of the DBT instead of the AF yields higher air micro-bubble removal efficacy, allowing replacement of the AF, assuming the AF is used for air removal purpose only.

Neuroprotection during cardiac surgery: strategies to reduce cognitive decline

Although the population receiving cardiac surgery is older and therefore more prone to cognitive deterioration, these difficulties have declined over the last ten years. It is likely that the multiple changes introduced to cardiac surgery over time have had a cumulative benefit in protecting the brain. The most likely causes of cognitive difficulties are microemboli delivered to the brain during surgery, altered cerebral perfusion and an inflammatory response. The interventions that have been implemented can be divided into those which have attempted to reduce the potential causes of damage and those aimed at reducing the impact by attempting to protect the brain. The evidence for three main types of intervention (equipment, techniques and drugs) is reviewed in this paper. Although many interventions are available only a few have shown a clear benefit. Progress in the future will require larger studies to address this multifactorial problem.

Alterations to haemostasis following cardiopulmonary bypass and the relationship of these changes to neurocognitive morbidity

Cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) is routinely utilized to provide circulatory support during cardiac surgical procedures. The morbidity of CPB has been significantly reduced since its introduction 50 years ago; however, cerebral injury remains a potentially serious consequence of otherwise successful surgery. The risk of stroke postoperatively is approximately 1-5%. Incidence rates for neurocognitive deficit, however, vary markedly depending on the detection method, although typically it is reported in at least 50% of patients. The aetiology of this cerebral injury remains open to debate, although evidence shows that ischaemia secondary to microembolism may be the principal factor. Emboli originate from bubbles of air, atheroemboli released on aortic manipulation and thromboemboli generated as a result of haemostatic activation. Significant generation of thrombin occurs during CPB resulting in fibrin formation, although the trigger of this activation is not fully understood. Rather than originating from contact activation as previously thought, the primary trigger may be via the activated factor VII/tissue factor pathway of coagulation, with an additional role of contact activation in amplification of coagulation as well as the fibrinolytic response to CPB. Haemostatic activation is inhibited with systemic heparin therapy. The relationship between haemostatic activation and emboli formation during CPB is not known. Interventions to reduce cerebral injury in the context of cardiac surgery depend, in large part, on the minimization of emboli. This review investigates cerebral injury after cardiac surgery and evidence showing that microembolism is the principal causative agent. Fibrin emboli are postulated to be an important source of cerebral embolism. The mechanism of haemostatic activation during CPB is therefore also discussed.

The use of leucocyte-depleting and conventional arterial line filters in cardiac surgery: a systematic review of clinical studies

Although various forms of arterial line filter have been available for use during cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) for 30 years, their use is not universal. The aim of this review was to seek evidence of the clinical benefit of using conventional or leucocyte-depleting arterial line filters during bypass. A literature search revealed 28 relevant clinical studies. Despite the wide variety of patient populations, types of filter and outcome measures utilized in studies, a few conclusions are possible. Whereas conventional filtration has the definite effect of reducing neuropsychological deficit post-CPB, the results of studies using the leucocyte-depleting filter are less clear cut. Leucocyte-depleting filters have potential for reducing inflammatory mediated heart and lung injury, however it is recommended that any additional benefit of leucocyte-depleting filters over conventional filters should be further tested by randomized controlled trials of sufficient size.

Efficiency of an air filter at the drainage site in a closed circuit with a centrifugal blood pump: an in vitro study

In a closed circuit with a centrifugal blood pump, one of the serious obstacles to clinical application is sucking of air bubbles into the drainage circuit. The goal of this study was to investigate the efficiency of an air filter at the drainage site. We used whole bovine blood and the experimental circuit consisted of a drainage circuit, two air filters, a centrifugal blood pump, a membrane oxygenator, a return circuit, and a reservoir. Air was injected into the drainage circuit with a roller pump, and the number and size of air bubbles were measured. The air filter at the drainage site could remove the air bubbles (>40 microm) by itself, but adding a vacuum removed more bubbles (>40 microm) than without vacuum. Our results suggest that an air filter at the drainage site could effectively remove air bubbles, and that adding the filter in a closed circuit with a centrifugal blood pump would be safer.

Scanning electron microscopic analysis of arterial line filters used in cardiopulmonary bypass

The clinical value of arterial line filters is still a controversial issue. Proponents of arterial line filtration argue that filters remove particulate matter and undissolved gas from circulation while opponents argue the absence of conclusive clinical data. We conducted scanning electron microscope (SEM) studies of arterial line filters used clinically in the cardiopulmonary bypass circuits during adult cardiac surgery and analyzed the types and characteristics of materials entrapped in the arterial line filters. Twelve arterial line filters were obtained during routine hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass in 12 adult cardiac patients. The arterial line filter was a screen type with a pore size of 40 microm (Baxter Health Care Corporation, Bentley Division, Irvine, CA, U.S.A. ). After opening the housing, the woven polyester strands were examined with SEM. All segments examined (120 segments, each 2.5 x 2. 5 cm) contained no embolic particles larger in their cross-sectional area than the pore size of the filter (40 microm). The origins of embolic particulates were mostly from environmental foreign bodies. This may suggest a possible need for more aggressive filtration of smaller particulates than is generally carried out at the present time.

Issues associated with the identification of cognitive change following coronary artery bypass grafting

OBJECTIVE

Coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) is a surgical procedure used to treat individuals with ischaemic heart disease and to relieve angina. Disruption to the central nervous system (CNS) has frequently been reported by patients who have undergone CABG.

METHOD

The following paper is a review of the literature that has examined the effects of CABG on the CNS.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

It becomes apparent that issues about the incidence and severity of post-CABG cognitive decline are still unresolved. First, the cause of post-CABG CNS change has not yet been established, although the presence of changes to brain microvasculature as a result of the presence of microemboli appears to be a likely factor. Second, while some studies have reported high rates of poor performance on neuropsychological tests postoperatively, these reports are often subject to confounds such as variability in postoperative testing intervals, the definition of decline and the neuropsychological test batteries used. Finally, improvements in surgical techniques and changes in patient characteristics may have changed the real nature and prevalence of post-CABG cognitive decline. The review finishes with a series of recommendations for the neuropsychological study of CABG.

Central nervous system dysfunction after anesthesia in the geriatric patient

Cerebral infarction, bleeding, long-lasting hypofusion, and profound hypoxia are well-known factors behind central nervous system dysfunction after anesthesia. Other explanations may be the metabolic-endocrine stress response and psychologic factors related to changes in the environment. The clinical presentations can be obvious as in cerebral death or stroke but delirium also may be readily recognized. A more subtle and long-lasting deterioration in cognitive function is called postoperative cognitive dysfunction. This condition can only be detected with the use of neuropsychologic testing and recently, postoperative cognitive dysfunction has been detected as the most common cerebral complication after noncardiac surgery in elderly patients.

Bilateral cerebral emboli monitoring during extracorporeal circulation

Microembolism generated during extracorporeal circulation is thought to be responsible for stroke and neuropsychological deficits. Before one can investigate the pathogenetic role in more detail, reproducible and reliable quantitative methods need to be developed. In several previous studies, microemboli detection was performed unilaterally. We questioned if this reflects the bihemispheric embolic load. In 42 patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting, bilateral embolus detection was performed during extracorporeal circulation. The side-to-side correlation of microembolus counts was strong (0.91), but there was a significant difference in number (p < 0.01) comparing left and right emboli. The side of higher embolus counts cannot be predicted in the individual because either side may show higher counts. Doubling the unilateral count may deviate from the bilateral count by as much as 51% in the individual patient. The total embolic load to the brain during extracorporeal circulation cannot be precisely predicted from unilateral transcranial insonation alone.

Neurobehavioural sequelae of cardiopulmonary bypass

The development of coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) and its effect on angina is the product of a series of technical and scientific advances. Despite these advances, however, adverse neurobehavioural outcomes continue to occur. Stroke is the most serious complication of CABG, but studies that have identified demographic and medical risk factors available before surgery are an important advance. Short-term cognitive deficits are common after CABG, but may not be specific to this procedure. However, deficits in some cognitive areas such as visuoconstruction persist over time, and may reflect parieto-occipital watershed area injury secondary to hypoperfusion or embolic factors. Risk factors for cognitive decline may be time dependent, with short-term studies identifying factors that differ from those of long-term studies. Patients with depression before surgery are likely to have persistent depression afterwards. However, depression does not account for the cognitive decline after CABG. Since CABG is increasingly done in older patients with more comorbidity, the challenge is to identify patients at risk of adverse neurocognitive outcomes and to protect them by modification of the surgical procedure or by effective medical therapy.

Rehabilitation of the post-cardiac surgery stroke patient: analysis of cognitive and functional assessment

OBJECTIVE

Determine whether, as expected, patients sustaining post-cardiac surgery stroke (PCS) (n = 19) differ from other stroke (OS) patients (n = 216).

DESIGN

A total of 235 stroke patients were surveyed. Therapist ratings of Functional Independence Measure (FIM) on admission to and discharge from a rehabilitation unit were compared. Cooperation with formal neuropsychologic evaluation was assessed.

SETTING

The rehabilitation unit of a tertiary care hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Medical records for consecutive stroke patients were reviewed (January 1994 to December 1995). Groups did not differ in age, gender, or admission FIM.

INTERVENTIONS

Standardized neuropsychologic evaluation of seven cognitive domains was attempted for each patient referred to the neuropsychology service. All of the patients received FIM ratings on admission to and discharge from the rehabilitation unit.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Gain in FIM per week of rehabilitation unit stay (FIM efficiency) and discharge destination.

RESULTS

Contrary to expectations, PCS patients did not differ significantly from OS patients in FIM efficiency or discharge destination. However, PCS patients were significantly less able to cooperate with formal neuropsychologic testing, possibly secondary to their physical condition, higher-level cognitive deficits, or both.

CONCLUSION

Although PCS patients may sustain medical and cognitive deficits that interfere with exhaustive neuropsychologic evaluation, these deficits do not significantly interfere with functional progress in rehabilitation and should not make PCS patients ineligible for rehabilitation services.

Head and Heart: Neuropsychological Reaction and Arterial Line Filtration during Cardiopulmonary Bypass

As part of a prospective study of neuropsychologic reactions after cardiopulmonary bypass and their relation to arterial line filters, 44 patients who underwent elective cardiac operations were randomized into two groups. Group A had a 40-micron nylon screen filter in the arterial line. No arterial filter was used in group B. Neuropsychological examinations of all patients were conducted before and at a mean of 8 days after the operation on a double blind basis by a single trained psychologist. The tests included the Wechsler Memory Scale, the trail-making test, the Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale, and the Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression. The 2 groups were otherwise similar with respect to preoperative neurologic and intellectual status, anesthetic methods, duration of operation, operative procedures performed, and the time spent in the intensive care unit. Surprisingly, there was a highly significant improvement in all four test scores after surgery. There were no statistically significant differences in the test scores between the two groups but considerable inter-patient performance variability was noted. The arterial line filter did not appear to have an effect on test scores. Routine use of an arterial filter remains questionable.

Histologic Studies of Brain Microemboli in Humans and Dogs After Cardiopulmonary Bypass

Emboli become lodged in the brains of patients undergoing cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) and can cause death, stroke, or more subtle neurological and neuropsychological deficits. Using a specialized vascular stain (for alkaline phosphatase) in autopsy tissues from the brains of patients who underwent CPB shortly before death, we found large numbers of microemboli. All of these microemboli contain lipid, some contain small birefringent particles, and some may contain aluminum or silicon. Within a few weeks after CPB, most of the microemboli had disappeared from the brain tissues, but some persisted for at least 6 months. After several days, the endothelial cells of some of the vessels containing microemboli showed subtle damage in the form of loss of alkaline phosphatase reactivity, and some vessels appeared to be degenerating. Sometimes the surrounding neuropil also showed degeneration. Since skin and muscle biopsies can be readily obtained before, during, and after CPB, we investigated their suitability as surrogate tissues for brain; however, they were unsuitable because they had so few microemboli. By injecting microspheres into dogs at various times during CPB, we have investigated the timing of the production of microemboli. We are also exploring the use of rat brains to trap microemboli from the injected blood of patients undergoing CPB. (ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY, Volume 13, September 1996)

Gas Embolism: Part II. Arterial Gas Embolism and Decompression Sickness

Gas emboli syndromes are known to occur in many different settings, and they may result in life-threatening emergencies. Venous gas embolization was discussed previously in Part I of this review. Gas emboli that gain access to the arterial circulation or that result from exposures to decreased ambient pressures in the environment are discussed in Part II. The prevalence of arterial gas emboli and decompression sickness are likely not as high as for venous gas emboli. Most cases are preventable, and prompt treatment is frequently effective. Once present, gas bubbles generally distribute themselves throughout the body based on the relative blood flow at the time, thus making the nervous system, heart, lung, and skin the primary organ systems involved. Both mechanical and biophysical effects lead to intravascular and extracellular alterations that result in tissue injury. The clinical manifestations of these disorders are varied, and a high index of suspicion in the appropriate settings will aid health care providers in prompt recognition of these problems and allow timely intervention with specific therapy. Management of arterial gas emboli and decompression sickness is similar, with a focus on hyberbaric chamber therapy and intermittent hyperoxygenation. Recompression schedules in current use have withstood the test of time. Research continues to refine our understanding of these diseases and to optimize the treatment regimens available.

Neuropsychologic change after cardiac surgery: a critical review

Studies that have examined neuropsychologic change after cardiac surgery address three main issues: (1) the incidence of cognitive change; (2) the identification of factors that put patients at higher risk; and (3) the evaluation of interventions to prevent these complications. This review attempts to bring together concerns associated with various study designs and to integrate the conclusions from these studies. Thirty-five studies have been examined in this review. Some of the difficulties encountered when quantifying the degree of cognitive change are related to study design, patient sampling, and deficit definition. Additionally, changing patient populations have influenced results reported from different health care settings. Increasing age and longer cardiopulmonary bypass times have been correlated with cognitive decline in a number of studies. Filtration devices and blood gas management techniques have decreased but not eliminated the number of patients who have cognitive decline. Cognitive change exists following cardiac procedures. Identification of a subgroup of patients at high risk for cognitive change has been difficult, possibly due to issues of study design. Design of future studies, which may include intraoperative or pharmacologic interventions, is dependent on identification of this high-risk group.

Neuropsychologic dysfunction after cardiac surgery: what is the problem?

Twenty years ago Aberg published his seminal studies on the neuropsychologic consequences of cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB). Twenty years later, what is the state of current research on the problem of post-CPB neurologic injury, and what different management techniques have been employed to influence this outcome? This article reviews the definition and assessment of postoperative neuropsychologic dysfunction; epidemiologic data and associated risk factors assessing post-CPB neuropsychologic dysfunction are critically appraised.

Improvement of outcomes after coronary artery bypass. A randomized trial comparing intraoperative high versus low mean arterial pressure

BACKGROUND

The objective of this randomized clinical trial of elective coronary artery bypass grafting was to investigate whether intraoperative mean arterial pressure below autoregulatory limits of the coronary and cerebral circulations was a principal determinant of postoperative complications. The trial compared the impact of two strategies of hemodynamic management during cardiopulmonary bypass on outcome. Patients were randomized to a low mean arterial pressure of 50 to 60 mm Hg or a high mean arterial pressure of 80 to 100 mm Hg during cardiopulmonary bypass.

METHODS

A total of 248 patients undergoing primary, nonemergency coronary bypass were randomized to either low (n = 124) or high (n = 124) mean arterial pressure during cardiopulmonary bypass. The impact of the mean arterial pressure strategies on the following outcomes was assessed: mortality, cardiac morbidity, neurologic morbidity, cognitive deterioration, and changes in quality of life. All patients were observed prospectively to 6 months after the operation.

RESULTS

The overall incidence of combined cardiac and neurologic complications was significantly lower in the high pressure group at 4.8% than in the low pressure group at 12.9% (p = 0.026). For each of the individual outcomes, the trend favored the high pressure group. At 6 months after coronary bypass for the high and low pressure groups, respectively, total mortality rate was 1.6% versus 4.0%, stroke rate 2.4% versus 7.2%, and cardiac complication rate 2.4% versus 4.8%. Cognitive and functional status outcomes did not differ between the groups.

CONCLUSION

Higher mean arterial pressures during cardiopulmonary bypass can be achieved in a technically safe manner and effectively improve outcomes after coronary bypass.

Con: glucose priming solutions should not be used for cardiopulmonary bypass

In conclusion, the advantage of glucose-containing CPB priming solutions are quite modest. In contrast, the weight of current evidence strongly supports the notion that hyperglycemia is far more likely to be detrimental than beneficial to a brain challenged by ischemia, especially when there is reperfusion (hypotension or circulatory arrest) or when the brain is normothermic. Because neurologic complications pose such a serious threat to cardiac surgery patients, avoidance of hyperglycemia during surgery and CPB seems prudent at this time. Hence, CPB priming solutions should not contain glucose.

Brain microemboli associated with cardiopulmonary bypass: a histologic and magnetic resonance imaging study

Emboli in brain tissue after cardiopulmonary bypass were reported in the literature 30 years ago, but there is little objective evidence confirming the presence of emboli in the brain after cardiopulmonary bypass with more modern equipment and techniques. Recently, with alkaline phosphatase vascular staining, we found an acellular fatty material in brain microvasculature from autopsy material of patients who died shortly after cardiopulmonary bypass. These fatty intravascular collections range in diameter from 10 to 70 microns, a size that lodges in the smallest vessels of the microvasculature. They have been found in numbers sufficient to cause detectable neurologic dysfunction and are believed, but not proved, to be emboli. By sequentially injecting colored microspheres, we can determine when emboli occur during experimental cardiopulmonary bypass. In ongoing related studies, magnetic resonance imaging was performed before cardiac valve replacement in 39 patients for whom preoperative and postoperative neurologic and neuropsychologic testing was available. Preliminary results suggest that magnetic resonance imaging evidence of prior stroke is not a significant risk factor for cognitive or motor decrement after cardiopulmonary bypass.

Analysis and interpretation of neuropsychologic tests in cardiac surgery

Neuropsychologic assessment in the context of cardiac surgery is constrained by the clinical time available to see patients, and as such test selection needs to be carefully planned. Besides the time limitations, it differs from clinical neuropsychologic assessment primarily because it tends to involve at least two assessments, a comparison with performance before operation, and a limited number of tests. The analysis and design issues involved in both incidence studies and intervention studies are discussed in this article. Incidence studies customarily involve a single group assessed on at least two occasions and are designed to identify the numbers of individuals who show clear evidence of neuropsychologic changes after a cardiac operation. Intervention studies involve at least two groups where one factor (eg, surgical equipment) is varied systematically. The research on neuropsychologic deficits after cardiac operations has progressed from incidence studies, which involve a conventional definition of deficit, to intervention studies, in which specific test performance can be compared.

Cognitive function after open-heart surgery: are postoperative neuropsychological deficits caused by cardiopulmonary bypass?

Despite the many technological developments in arterial perfusion and cardiac surgical procedures, open-heart surgery is still believed to pose a significant risk for cerebral injury. There are several potential causes of brain damage during open-heart surgery, including prolonged or severe arterial hypotension, as well as emboli emanating from the cardiopulmonary bypass circuit or the operative field. This article reviews the available neuropsychological studies of outcome following cardiac valve replacement and coronary artery bypass grafting. Because both procedures are life-saving operations, the research in this area has been quasi-experimental and fraught with methodological problems. Nonetheless, the findings converge to suggest that cognitive dysfunction occurs after open-heart surgery, and that the deficits are attributable, at least in part, to factors specific to the operation or to the patient being maintained on cardiopulmonary bypass. Preliminary findings suggest that embolization is the primary cause of perioperative deficits in uncomplicated operations. Studies have also consistently found preoperative deficits in this population, suggesting that neuropsychological dysfunction is caused by severe chronic cardiac disease as well as open-heart surgery.

The impact of microemboli during cardiopulmonary bypass on neuropsychological functioning

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Microemboli have been implicated in the etiology of neuropsychological deficits after cardiopulmonary bypass. This study examined the incidence of high-intensity transcranial signals (microemboli) and their relation to changes in neuropsychological performance after surgery.

METHODS

Transcranial Doppler ultrasonography was used to measure middle cerebral artery blood flow velocity and detect microemboli. The number of high-intensity transcranial signals was determined and related to a neurological examination and absolute changes in neuropsychological performance as well as the number of patients considered to exhibit a neuropsychological deficit. Data were available on 100 consenting patients undergoing routine cardiopulmonary bypass. Fifty of the patients were randomly assigned to a procedure that included a 40-microns arterial line filter, and 50 had the procedure without any arterial line filter.

RESULTS

Significantly more patients were found to have neuropsychological deficits in the group without the arterial line filter at both 8 days (P < .05) and 8 weeks (P < .03) after surgery. In addition, more "soft" neurological signs were found in the nonfiltered group 24 hours after surgery (P < .05). More high-intensity transcranial signals were found in the nonfiltered group, and the number of high-intensity transcranial signals was found to be related to the likelihood of a patient having a neuropsychological deficit at 8 weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that neuropsychological deficits after routine cardiopulmonary bypass are related to the number of microemboli delivered during surgery. Furthermore, the numbers of microemboli may be reduced by including a 40-microns filter on the arterial line.

Neuropsychiatric complications of cardiac surgery

Historically, intracardiac operations have carried a higher risk of neurologic complications than coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) procedures, although the incidence of such complications has been increasing after CABG in recent years. In both intracardiac and extracardiac surgery, macroemboli from the surgical field cause most neurologic complications. The periods of highest risk for emboli are during aortic cannulation, onset of bypass, and weaning from bypass. Risk factors include atherosclerosis of the ascending aorta, advanced age, presence of concomitant cerebral vascular disease, previous neurologic abnormality, duration of surgery, diabetes, and history of failure of the native circulation. Although hypothermia is beneficial in elective circulatory arrest, its usefulness in reducing postoperative central nervous system deficits during routine cardiac operations may be limited. Studies suggest a role for barbiturate protection in intracardiac but not in extracardiac surgery. Studies have not shown better neurologic or neuropsychological outcome with the use of membrane oxygenation and arterial filtration. Recent studies suggest no correlation of neurologic injury with serum glucose levels during CABG, with either duration or severity of hypotension during hypothermic CABG, or with blood gas management during hypothermic CABG.

Brain embolic phenomena associated with cardiopulmonary bypass

Various biologic and non-biologic materials may be embolized to the brain after the use of cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) pumps during open heart surgery but their relative frequency and importance are uncertain. Among the nonbiologic materials, Antifoam A, which contains organosilicates and silicon, continues to be employed as an additive to prevent frothing. Recent improvements in filtration and oxygenation techniques have clearly reduced the incidence of large emboli and complications like stroke but other neurologic sequelae following open heart surgery are common and in many cases poorly explained. A recently developed histochemical technique for the demonstration of the endothelial alkaline phosphatase (AP) was employed in a post-mortem study of brains from 8 patients and 6 dogs dying within a few days after open heart surgery employing cardiopulmonary bypass perfusion. Brains from 38 patients and 6 dogs who were not subjected to heart surgery were studied as controls with the same technique. The AP-stained slides are suitable for both light microscopic examination of the thick celloidin sections as well as a subsequent processing for high-resolution microradiography. Small capillary and arteriolar dilatations (SCADs) were seen in the test subjects/animals but not controls. SCADs were seen in all parts of the brain. Approximately 50% of the SCADs showed birefringence when examined with polarized light. SCADs are putative embolic phenomena and the exact nature and source of the embolic material is under investigation. A glycolipid component is indicated by preliminary studies. SCADs are difficult to find in routine paraffin sections and most if not all of the offending material seems to be dissolved during processing.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Neuropsychological dysfunction after cardiopulmonary bypass: a comparison of two institutions

The authors compared perioperative neuropsychologic dysfunction in patients participating in two studies conducted in institutions using different strategies to manage cardiopulmonary bypass. These differences included hypothermia versus normothermia, presence versus absence of arterial microfilters, and the presence versus absence of glucose-containing solution in the pump prime. Other differences between the two institutions included the type of surgery (intracardiac v extracardiac), the mean duration of cardiopulmonary bypass, and degree of low perfusion pressure during bypass. Despite these major differences, perioperative neuropsychologic dysfunction measured by the two-part Trail-Making psychometric test was similar in the two institutions. Several factors were analyzed for their possible contribution to development of dysfunction, including institution, anesthetic management, age, sex, degree of low perfusion pressure during bypass, and duration of bypass; only age was significant. These results suggest that differences in surgical procedure and management of cardiopulmonary bypass previously thought to contribute to the development of subtle cognitive deficits after cardiac surgery may have been overemphasized.

Brain microemboli during cardiac surgery or aortography

We have observed many focal dilatations or very small aneurysms in terminal arterioles and capillaries of 4 of 5 patients and 6 dogs who had recently undergone cardiopulmonary bypass. A smaller number of sausagelike dilatations distended medium-sized arterioles. Two other patients had a small number of the same microvascular changes following proximal aortography. Thirty-four patients and 6 dogs not undergoing cardiopulmonary bypass had none. (A 35th patient who had not undergone cardiopulmonary bypass or aortography showed a small number of dilatations; mediastinal air was a suggested source.) Some of the dilatations exhibited various forms of birefringence. Because most of the dilatations appear empty, we speculate that they are the sites of gas bubbles or fat emboli that have been removed by the solvents used in processing. These microvascular events, occurring only in conjunction with major arterial interventions, may be the anatomical correlate of the neurological deficits or moderate to severe intellectual dysfunction seen in at least 24% of patients after cardiac surgical procedures assisted by cardiopulmonary bypass.

Brain protection: physiological and pharmacological considerations. Part II: The pharmacology of brain protection

Neuroprotective agents may exert their effect by reducing cerebral oxygen demand (CMRO2), increasing cerebral oxygen delivery, or by altering ongoing pathological processes. Barbiturates provide neuroprotection by reducing the CMRO2 necessary for synaptic transmission while leaving the component necessary for cellular metabolism intact. Isoflurane may exert a neuroprotective effect by a similar mechanism but its efficacy is likely less than that of barbiturates due to adverse effects on cerebral blood flow. Lidocaine reduces CMRO2 by affecting both cellular metabolic processes and synaptic transmission and thus resembles hypothermia in its mechanism of action. Benzodiazepines reduce CMRO2 by reducing synaptic transmission and their use as neuroprotectants produces less haemodynamic compromise than barbiturates. The mechanism of protection by calcium entry blocking agents appears to be due to improved blood flow as opposed to altering abnormal Ca++ fluxes. In contrast, agents such as ketamine and MK-801 may prevent abnormal Ca++ fluxes through their competitive interaction with N-methyl-D-aspartate receptors. Phenytoin prevents K(+)-mediated ischaemic events from progressing. Agents worthy of further investigation include corticosteroids, free radical scavengers, prostaglandin inhibitors and iron chelators.

The effect of arterial filtration on reduction of gaseous microemboli in the middle cerebral artery during cardiopulmonary bypass

Noninvasive in vivo detection of gaseous microemboli in the middle cerebral artery, by transcranial Doppler ultrasound, was used to determine the effect of filtration in the arterial catheter using 25- and 40-microns filters and bubble oxygenators in patients undergoing cardiopulmonary bypass surgery. Eighteen patients undergoing coronary artery bypass surgery were studied using a closed cardiac (unvented heart) model. Group 1 patients (no filters) had the highest incidence of gaseous microemboli, as indicated by the ultrasound microemboli index, at both high and low oxygen flow rates. Group 2 patients (40-microns filters) had a significantly lower microemboli index, particularly at low oxygen flow rates (t = 4.9, p less than 0.001). The 25-microns group patients had the lowest values of all. No microemboli were detected at low oxygen flow rates, and microemboli were detected in only 0.1% of the samples at high oxygen flow rates. Additionally, observations on vented hearts in 3 patients undergoing cardiac valve surgery indicate that the origin of gaseous microemboli may be air trapped inside the heart.