The effect of propranolol on the cerebral electrical response to deep hypothermia and total circulatory arrest in lambs

The impact of the National Institute for Health Research Health Technology Assessment programme, 2003-13: a multimethod evaluation

BACKGROUND

The National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment (HTA) programme supports research tailored to the needs of NHS decision-makers, patients and clinicians. This study reviewed the impact of the programme, from 2003 to 2013, on health, clinical practice, health policy, the economy and academia. It also considered how HTA could maintain and increase its impact.

METHODS

Interviews (n = 20): senior stakeholders from academia, policy-making organisations and the HTA programme. Bibliometric analysis: citation analysis of publications arising from HTA programme-funded research. Researchfish survey: electronic survey of all HTA grant holders. Payback case studies (n = 12): in-depth case studies of HTA programme-funded research.

RESULTS

We make the following observations about the impact, and routes to impact, of the HTA programme: it has had an impact on patients, primarily through changes in guidelines, but also directly (e.g. changing clinical practice); it has had an impact on UK health policy, through providing high-quality scientific evidence - its close relationships with the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) and the National Screening Committee (NSC) contributed to the observed impact on health policy, although in some instances other organisations may better facilitate impact; HTA research is used outside the UK by other HTA organisations and systematic reviewers - the programme has an impact on HTA practice internationally as a leader in HTA research methods and the funding of HTA research; the work of the programme is of high academic quality - the Health Technology Assessment journal ensures that the vast majority of HTA programme-funded research is published in full, while the HTA programme still encourages publication in other peer-reviewed journals; academics agree that the programme has played an important role in building and retaining HTA research capacity in the UK; the HTA programme has played a role in increasing the focus on effectiveness and cost-effectiveness in medicine - it has also contributed to increasingly positive attitudes towards HTA research both within the research community and the NHS; and the HTA focuses resources on research that is of value to patients and the UK NHS, which would not otherwise be funded (e.g. where there is no commercial incentive to undertake research). The programme should consider the following to maintain and increase its impact: providing targeted support for dissemination, focusing resources when important results are unlikely to be implemented by other stakeholders, particularly when findings challenge vested interests; maintaining close relationships with NICE and the NSC, but also considering other potential users of HTA research; maintaining flexibility and good relationships with researchers, giving particular consideration to the Technology Assessment Report (TAR) programme and the potential for learning between TAR centres; maintaining the academic quality of the work and the focus on NHS need; considering funding research on the short-term costs of the implementation of new health technologies; improving the monitoring and evaluation of whether or not patient and public involvement influences research; improve the transparency of the priority-setting process; and continuing to monitor the impact and value of the programme to inform its future scientific and administrative development.

Cerebral protection during moderate hypothermic circulatory arrest: histopathology and magnetic resonance spectroscopy of brain energetics and intracellular pH in pigs

OBJECTIVE

We evaluated the effect of antegrade and retrograde brain perfusion during moderate hypothermic circulatory arrest at 28 degrees C.

METHODS

Phosphorus 31-magnetic resonance spectroscopy was used to follow brain energy metabolites and intracellular pH in pigs during 2 hours of ischemia and 1 hour of reperfusion. Histopathologic analysis of brain tissue fixed at the end of the experimental protocol was performed. Fourteen pigs were divided into two experimental groups subjected to antegrade (n = 6) or retrograde (n = 8) brain perfusion. Anesthesia (n = 8) and hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass groups (15 degrees C, n = 8) served as control subjects. In the antegrade and retrograde brain perfusion groups, the initial bypass flow rate was 60 to 100 ml x kg(-1) x min(-1). In the antegrade group, the brain was perfused through the carotid arteries at a flow rate of 180 to 210 ml x min(-1) during circulatory arrest at 28 degrees C. In the retrograde group, the brain was perfused through the superior vena cava at a flow rate of 300 to 500 ml x min(-1) during circulatory arrest at 28 degrees C.

RESULTS

The intracellular pH was 7.1 +/- 0.1 and 7.2 +/- 0.1 in the anesthesia and hypothermic bypass groups, respectively. Brain intracellular pH and high-energy metabolites (adenosine triphosphate, phosphocreatine) did not change during the course of the 3.5-hour study. In the antegrade group, adenosine triphosphate and intracellular pH were unchanged throughout the protocol. In the retrograde perfusion group, the intracellular pH level decreased to 6.4 +/- 0.1, and adenosine triphosphate and phosphocreatine levels decreased within the first 30 minutes of circulatory arrest and remained at low levels until the end of reperfusion. High-energy phosphates did not return to their initial levels during reperfusion. Histopathologic analysis of nine regions of the brain showed good preservation of cell structure in the anesthesia, hypothermic bypass, and antegrade perfusion groups. The retrograde perfusion group showed changes in all the regions examined.

CONCLUSIONS

The study shows that moderate hypothermic circulatory arrest at 28 degrees C with antegrade brain perfusion during circulatory arrest protects the brain but that retrograde cerebral perfusion at 28 degrees C does not protect the brain.

A 31p-magnetic resonance study of antegrade and retrograde cerebral perfusion during aortic arch surgery in pigs

To evaluate the effect of hypothermic circulatory arrest on brain metabolism, we used 31P-magnetic resonance spectroscopy to monitor brain metabolites in pigs during 2 hours of ischemia and 1 hour of reperfusion. Twenty-eight pigs were divided into five groups. Anesthesia (n = 5) and hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass groups (n = 5) served as controls. In the circulatory arrest (n = 6), antegrade perfusion (n = 6), and retrograde (n = 6) brain perfusion groups, the bypass flow rate was 60 to 100 ml.kg-1.min-1. In the antegrade group, the brain was perfused via the carotid arteries at a blood flow rate of 180 to 200 ml.min-1 during circulatory arrest at 15 degrees C. In the retrograde group, the brain was perfused through the superior vena cava at a flow rate of 300 to 500 ml.min-1 during circulatory arrest at 15 degrees C. The intracellular pH was 7.1 +/- 0.1 and 7.3 +/- 0.1 in the anesthesia and hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass groups, respectively. In the circulatory arrest group, the intracellular pH decreased to 6.2 +/- 0.1 and did not recover to its initial value (7.0 +/- 0.1) during reperfusion (p < 0.05 compared with the value obtained from the control groups at the corresponding time). Inorganic phosphate did not return to its initial level during reperfusion. In three animals in this group, levels of high-energy phosphates, adenosine triphosphate and phosphocreatine, recovered partially but did not reach the levels observed before arrest. In the group receiving antegrade perfusion, cerebral metabolites and intracellular pH were unchanged throughout the protocol. During circulatory arrest in the retrograde perfusion group the intracellular pH decreased to 6.4 +/- 0.1 and recovered fully during reperfusion (7.1 +/- 0.1). High-energy phosphates also returned to their initial levels during reperfusion. These studies show that deep hypothermic circulatory arrest with antegrade brain perfusion provides the best brain protection of the options investigated.

EEG and prognosis of neurologic recovery of dogs under profound hypothermic circulatory arrest

Deep hypothermia (18-20 degrees C) (DH) during prolonged circulatory arrest and cardiopulmonary bypass is used to repair complex intracardiac lesions and vascular neurosurgical lesions. DH diminishes the risk of ischemic damage and multiorgan failure after circulatory arrest. Profound hypothermia (PH) to 6-7 degrees C has recently been reported to improve the neurological outcome of dogs after 2 h of circulatory arrest. There are no reports of the possible utility of EEG activity to predict the neurological outcome. As a part of a controlled study of cardiopulmonary bypass and 2 h of circulatory arrest we compared EEG recovery to the neurological outcome in 2 groups of dogs: 4 under DH and 4 under PH. All of the dogs under PH had a good outcome: mean neurodeficit score was 6.25/500 in PH and 139.25/500 in DH dogs (P < 0.03); mean histopathological score was 19.25/100 for DH and 47.75/100 in PH dogs (P < 0.03). EEG activity 2 h after reperfusion and starting of rewarming correlated with eventual neurological outcome. EEG variables associated with good outcome were: main final frequency and degree of rhythmicity of the activity. We conclude that PH exerted a protective effect for animals undergoing 2 h of circulatory arrest. EEG was a useful tool for predicting neurological outcome under the studied conditions.

Cerebral consequences of hypothermic circulatory arrest in adults

Despite widespread use of hypothermic circulatory arrest (HCA) in aneurysm surgery and for repair of congenital heart defects, there is continued concern about possible adverse cerebral sequelae. The search for ways to improve implementation of HCA has inspired retrospective clinical studies to try to identify risk factors for cerebral injury, and clinical and laboratory investigations to explore the physiology of HCA. At present, risk factors associated with less favorable cerebral outcome after HCA include: prolonged duration of HCA (usually greater than 60 min); advanced patient age; rapid cooling (less than 20 min); hyperglycemia either before HCA or during reperfusion; preoperative cyanosis or lack of adequate hemodilution; evidence of increased oxygen extraction before HCA or during reperfusion; and delayed reappearance of electroencephalogram (EEG) or marked EEG abnormality. Strategies advocated to increase safety of HCA include: pretreatment with barbiturates and steroids; use of alpha-stat pH regulation during cooling and rewarming; intraoperative monitoring of EEG; slow and adequate cooling, including packing of the head in ice; monitoring of jugular venous oxygen content; hemodilution; and avoidance of hyperglycemia. Current investigation focuses on delineating the relationship of cerebral blood flow (CBF) to cerebral oxygen consumption and glucose metabolism during cooling, HCA, rewarming, and later recovery, and identifying changes in acute intraoperative parameters, including the presence of intracerebral enzymes in cerebral spinal fluid, with cerebral outcome as assessed by neurological evaluation, quantitative EEG, and postmortem histology. Clinically, intraoperative monitoring of EEG and measurement of CBF by tracer washout or Doppler flows are contributing to better understanding of the physiology of HCA, and in the laboratory, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has provided valuable insights into the kinetics of intracerebral energy metabolism. Promising strategies for the future include investigation of other pharmacological agents to increase cerebral protection, and use of "cerebroplegia" or intermittent perfusion between intervals of HCA to improve cerebral tolerance for longer durations of HCA.