Extravesical ureteroneocystostomy in renal transplantation

Ureteral complications in renal transplantation: a comparison of the Lich-Gregoir versus the Taguchi technique

OBJECTIVE

Modifications of the Lich-Gregoir extravesical ureteroneocystostomy have become the standard technique for management of the ureter during renal transplantation. We performed a comparative outcome examination of the standard Lich-Gregoir technique and the Taguchi or "one-stitch" technique.

METHODS

We reviewed our experience at the University of Washington with the Taguchi (one-stitch, Minnesota) extravesical reimplant technique that involves tacking the distal ureter to the bladder mucosa with a single absorbable stitch.

RESULTS

During a 3.5-year period, 330 renal transplants were performed and in 73 cases a Taguchi ureteral anastomosis was employed rather than the Lich-Gregoir technique (238 cases). The overall complication rate for the Taguchi technique was 23% (n = 16) as opposed to 7.1% for the Lich-Gregoir technique. When comparing the Taguchi to the Lich-Gregoir technique, there was a significant increase in hematuria and ureteral complications (P = .002, .012). In a multivariate analysis, the Taguchi technique was a significant risk factor for both hematuria and ureteral complications.

CONCLUSIONS

In summary, our limited experience with Taguchi ureteroneocystostomy resulted in dramatically higher complication rates than the modified the Lich-Gregoir technique.

Risk factors for urinary complications after renal transplantation

Urinary complications are common following renal transplantation. The aim of this study is to evaluate the risk factors associated with renal transplant urinary complications. We collected data on 1698 consecutive renal transplants patients. The association of donor, transplant and recipient characteristics with urinary complications was assessed by univariable and multivariable Cox proportional hazards models, fitted to analyze time-to-event outcomes of urinary complications and graft failure. Urinary complications were observed in 105 (6.2%) recipients, with a 2.8% ureteral stricture rate, a 1.7% rate of leak and stricture, and a 1.6% rate of urine leaks. Seventy percent of these complications were definitively managed with a percutaneous intervention. Independent risk factors for a urinary complication included: male recipient, African American recipient, and the "U"-stitch technique. Ureteral stricture was an independent risk factor for graft loss, while urinary leak was not. Laparoscopic donor technique (compared to open living donor nephrectomy) was not associated with more urinary complications. Our data suggest that several patient characteristics are associated with an increased risk of a urinary complication. The U-stitch technique should not be used for the ureteral anastomosis.

Comparing two ureter reimplantation techniques in kidney transplant recipients

We compared the incidence of urological and anastomotic complications for the ureteroureterostomy and Lich-Gregoir techniques in kidney transplant recipients. Between May 2003 and February 2004, 75 kidney transplant recipients from living donors were divided into two similar groups to receive ureteroureterostomy (n = 41, 28 male, 13 female) and Lich-Gregoir techniques (n = 34, 24 male, 10 female) for ureteral reimplantation. Patients with vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) to the native kidneys were excluded from the study. The urological complications included complicated hematuria, ureteral stenosis, symptomatic VUR, recurrent urinary tract infection (UTI). There was no statistical significance between two groups in terms of gender, age, end-stage renal disease etiology, human leucocyte antigen (HLA) mismatch numbers, type and duration of dialysis, and cold ischemia time. The incidence of urologic and anastomotic complications was 12%. Complications in the Lich-Gregoir group included symptomatic VUR in 8.8% and stent migration in 2.9% of cases. Complications observed in the ureteroureterostomy group were ureteral stricture 7.3% and complicated hematuria in 4.9% of cases. However, symptomatic reflux was not observed in the ureteroureterostomy group. UTI frequency was similar in both groups. Ureteroureterostomy can be safely performed as a primary choice in kidney transplant recipients.

Urological complications of live related donor renal transplantation: 13 years' experience at a single center

BACKGROUND

This study is a retrospective analysis of urological complications and their treatment in our series of live-donor renal transplantation.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The series comprised of 500 patients. All underwent extravesical ureteroneocystostomy and all except a few initial patients were stented.

RESULTS

There were 92 complications in 82 patients (18.4%). Urinary leakage occurred in 1.2%. There were no intrinsic ureteric obstructions. Extrinsic ureteric obstruction occurred in 0.8% of cases. The incidence of UTI was 15.4% and of urethral strictures 1%.

CONCLUSION

The technique of stented extravesical ureteroneocystomy has led to an extremely low rate of urological complications in our series, over a long time and in a substantial number of patients.

Stented versus nonstented extravesical ureteroneocystostomy in renal transplantation: a metaanalysis

Stenting of the extravesical ureteroneocystostomy in renal transplantation is controversial. This study is a metaanalysis of 49 published studies over 30 years time in which the extravesical technique was used. Stented and nonstented anastomoses were compared. One-hundred six articles published between 1973 and 2002 were reviewed and 49 met criteria for inclusion. Articles were required to list original, numeric, previously unpublished data and to report or to describe the use of an extravesical ureteroneocystostomy, with or without stent. Data were analyzed within separate groups, (1) randomized, controlled trials and (2) case series. Data were included from five randomized, controlled trials and 44 case series. In the controlled trials group, there were urologic complications in 6 of 407 stented (1.5%), and 35 of 389 nonstented subjects (9.0%) (p < 0.0001, OR 0.24, 95% CI 0.10-0.57). In the case-series group, there were urologic complications in 137 of 4245 stented (3.2%) and 433 of 9077 nonstented subjects (4.8%) (p = 0.007, OR 0.58, 95% CI 0.39-0.86). Renal transplants with stented extravesical ureteroneocystostomy have a significantly lower urologic complication rate than those with nonstented anastomoses. All five randomized, controlled trials individually found stented anastomoses to have a lower complication rate and this was confirmed by metaanalysis of these trials and of case-series data.

The urological complications of renal transplantation: a series of 1535 patients

OBJECTIVE

To determine the incidence of urological complications of renal transplantation at one institution, and relate this to donor and recipient factors.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A consecutive series of 1535 renal transplants were audited, and a database of donor and recipient characteristics created for risk-factor analysis. An unstented Leadbetter-Politano anastomosis was the preferred method of ureteric reimplantation.

RESULTS

There were 45 urinary leaks, 54 primary ureteric obstructions, nine cases of ureteric calculi, three bladder stones and 19 cases of bladder outlet obstruction at some time after transplantation. The overall incidence of urological complications was 9.2%, with that for urinary leak or primary ureteric obstruction being 6.5%. One graft was lost because of complications, and there were three deaths associated directly or indirectly with urological complications. There was no association with recipient age, cadaveric vs living-donor transplants, or cold ischaemic times before organ reimplantation, although the donor age was slightly higher in cases of urinary leak. There was no association with kidneys imported via the UK national organ-sharing scheme vs the use of local kidneys. The management of these complications is discussed.

CONCLUSION

The incidence of urological complications in this series has remained essentially unchanged for 20 years. The causes of these complications and techniques for their prevention are discussed.

[Surgical aspects of kidney transplantation in children (study of 148 cases)]

OBJECTIVE

Kidney transplantation is the best treatment for end-stage renal disease. This procedure is by now routinely used and permits children survival and rehabilitation. We describe the surgical complications of kidney graft in our paediatric experience.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

From April 1987 to August 2000, 175 kidney transplantation were proceeded in the department of urology and transplantation in Edouard Herriot Hospital (Lyon). Twenty-nine kidneys (17%) were from living related donors and 146 (83%) were from cadaveric donors. We evaluated 148 kidney transplantation (132 patients) in 79 male and 53 female children. Mean age was ten years (range: seven months to 18 years). Twelve allografts were from living related donors and 136 cadaveric donors.

RESULTS

Twelve patients died of various medical complications. One patient was lost of sight. Surgical complications were postoperative bleeding, lymphocele, urologic and digestive troubles. The rest of our patients had uneventful evolution.

CONCLUSION

A general commitment is the only way to promote organ donation and enable patients with terminal renal failure to have access to renal transplantation.

Comparing Taguchi and Lich-Gregoir ureterovesical reimplantation techniques for kidney transplants

PURPOSE

We compared the incidence of urological and anastomotic complications, and the duration of ureteral reimplantation for the Taguchi and Lich-Gregoir techniques.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We recorded all urological and anastomotic complications that developed from the date of transplantation through December 31, 2001. The cutoff date for transplantation was August 30, 2000. The urological complications evaluated included complicated hematuria, urinary fistula, ureteral stenosis, symptomatic vesicoureteral reflux and operative time. The chi-square test was done to compare the proportion of complications in the groups and the Mann Whitney test was used to compare the duration of ureteral reimplantation.

RESULTS

Of the 575 transplants evaluated 416 and 159 were performed via the Lich-Gregoir and Taguchi techniques, respectively. The incidence of anastomotic complications was 10.7%. Complications in the Lich-Gregoir group included fistula in 4.7% of cases, stenosis in 4.1%, symptomatic vesicoureteral reflux in 1.9% and complicated hematuria in 0.5%. Complications in the Taguchi group included urinary fistula in 6.3% of cases, stenosis in 2.5% and complicated hematuria in 2.5%. Symptomatic reflux was not observed in this group. There was a higher proportion of hematuria at the limit of statistical significance in the Taguchi group (p = 0.05). There were a higher number of urological complications in transplants from live donors in the Lich-Gregoir group (p = 0.01), mostly involving fistula (p = 0.05). There were no significant differences in the groups in overall complications. Average operative time for the Taguchi and Lich-Gregoir techniques was 14.2 and 29 minutes, respectively. This difference was significant (p = 0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

In the sample studied Taguchi ureterocystoneostomy proved to be a more rapid method without increasing the incidence of urological or anastomotic complications. There were no cases of symptomatic reflux in the Taguchi group and select fistula cases could be managed conservatively. The Lich-Gregoir cohort was at greater risk for the urological complications of live donor transplantation. The Taguchi method has become the ureterovesical reimplantation technique of choice in our setting.

Laparoscopic live donor nephrectomy

Laparoscopic donor nephrectomy offers numerous advantages when compared with the traditional open approach. For the donor, it has resulted in a shorter hospital stay, fewer postoperative analgesic requirements, earlier return to activities of daily living and employment, and decreased financial loss owing to absence from the workforce. For the recipient, the procedure does not adversely impact on allograft function, graft survival, or patient survival.

Laparoscopic versus open donor nephrectomy: comparing ureteral complications in the recipients and improving the laparoscopic technique

BACKGROUND

Laparoscopic live donor nephrectomy (LDN) is a recently developed procedure, the performance of which needs to be studied. Given the reported advantages in the donors, this study looks at graft outcome and ureteral complications in recipients of kidneys procured by open donor nephrectomy (ODN) versus LDN.

METHODS

The LDN recipients consisted of 193 patients since 3/27/96. A total of 168 ODN recipients from 1991 to 1998 served as controls. Immunosuppression protocols were similar for both groups.

RESULTS

Two-year graft survival for LDN and ODN was 98% and 96%, respectively. Two-year patient survival for LDN and ODN was 98% and 97%, respectively. The incidence of delayed graft function and mean serum creatinine at 3 and 12 months was similar in both groups. However, the number of ureteral complications that required operative repair was significantly higher for LDN recipients compared to ODN recipients, 7.7% (n=15) vs. 0.6% (n=1) respectively (P=0.03). Ureteral stenting was required in an additional 3.1% (n=6) of LDN and 2.4% (n=4) of ODN (P=NS). There was, however, a learning curve with time. For the first 130 LDN patients, a total of 20 ureteral complications were recorded, whereas only one occurred in the more recent 63 patients (P=0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

The higher ureteral complication rate in LDN recipients has improved over time as technical causes have been identified. We have noted significant improvement in ureteral viability by using the endogastrointestinal anastomosis instrument on the ureter and peri-ureteral tissue. LDN is therefore an excellent alternative to ODN. Identification of hazards unique to this technique is critical before its broader application.

Endo-urological cold-knife incision for ureteral stenosis after renal transplantation

Cold-knife incision of stenoses in the transplant ureter was performed in 11 patients with upper urinary tract obstruction in renal transplants. The operations were complicated by bleeding in 2 patients and the graft had to be removed in 1 of them. The stenoses could be treated successfully in 10 of the 11 patients (91%) and the mean serum creatinine concentration decreased significantly from 3.4 to 1.8 mg./dl. After a mean of 26 months only 1 obstruction recurred, so the long-term success rate was 82%. Because of the favorable long-term results and the low incidence of complications, we recommend endo-urological cold-knife incision of ureteral stenosis as the first-line treatment for upper urinary tract obstruction in renal transplants.

Treatment of renal transplant ureteral complications by percutaneous techniques

From January 1985 to October 1990, 487 adult renal transplantations were performed at our institution. Of 16 ureteral complications noted 15 were initially managed with percutaneous nephrostomy. Of the 8 complications that occurred during the last 2 years 5 resolved on percutaneous nephrostomy and stenting, or stenting with dilation alone. We conclude that percutaneous nephrostomy is indicated as an initial step in the diagnosis and treatment of urological transplant complications, and that it allows for nonoperative resolution of many of these complications.

Pyeloureterostomy in the management of renal allograft ureteral complications: an alternative technique

Pyeloureterostomy is the standard procedure for reconstructing renal allograft ureteral complications. Most reports describe an end-to-end technique with or without native nephrectomy. An alternative is an end-to-side anastomosis, leaving the native ureter in continuity. We report our experience with the latter method. Since July 1983, 437 renal transplantations have been performed at our institution. End-to-side pyeloureterostomy has been used in 5 cases for urological reconstruction after renal transplantation following ureteral ischemic necrosis or stenosis. In 1 patient the native kidneys had been removed several years previously but in the remaining 4 the native kidneys were left in situ. There have been no significant complications following this procedure. We believe that by not significantly mobilizing, ligating or dividing the native ureter the chance of anastomotic breakdown due to ischemia may be decreased.

Treatment of renal transplant stones by extracorporeal shock-wave lithotripsy in the prone position

Two patients with renal transplant lithiasis were successfully treated with extracorporeal shock-wave lithotripsy (ESWL) in the prone position. Pathogenesis and treatment of transplant lithiasis are discussed. Performing ESWL on renal transplant patients in the prone position has advantages over standard positioning techniques.