Liver transplantation at the Mayo Clinic

Quadruple tacrolimus-based induction therapy including azathioprine and ALG does not significantly improve outcome after liver transplantation when compared with standard induction with tacrolimus and steroids: results of a prospective, randomized trial

BACKGROUND

Tacrolimus in combination with prednisolone has been proven to be a safe and effective immunosuppressive induction therapy in solid organ transplantation. However, it remains unclear whether a tacrolimus-based quadruple induction regimen with azathioprine and an antilymphocytic preparation could further improve the results after orthotopic liver transplantation. Therefore, we designed a prospective, randomized study to compare the immunosuppressive efficacy of dual (tacrolimus and prednisolone) and quadruple (tacrolimus, azathioprine, ALG Merieux and prednisolone) induction after liver transplantation.

METHODS

After randomization, 120 consecutive patients of primary liver transplants were divided into the dual group (n=59) and the quadruple group (n=61) and followed for a minimum of 3 years.

RESULTS

Patient survival at 3 years was 88.2% in the dual versus 94.9% in the quadruple group. Overall 25 patients in each group (41 and 42%, respectively) developed acute rejection. There was no difference in the number and severity of rejections. In each group only four patients required OKT3-therapy, however, although three of four patients in the quadruple group responded to OKT3 and cleared rejection, none of the four patients in the dual group were treated successfully with OKT3 (P<0.02). Rejection in these patients resolved only after additional treatment with mycophenolate mofetil. Adverse events and infections were equally distributed in both groups. Asymptomatic Cytomegalovirus infections were more common in the quadruple group (P<0.02). As of today, only one patient developed posttransplant lymphoproliferative disease (dual group).

CONCLUSIONS

The data from our single-center study indicate that both tacrolimus-based dual and quadruple immunosuppressive induction regimens yield similar safety and effectiveness after liver transplantation.

Hepatobiliary manifestations of inflammatory bowel disease

Several hepatobiliary disorders may be associated with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). These various disease states can be diagnosed before, concomitant with, or after the diagnosis of IBD is made. This article describes these disorders, clinical features, evaluation, and possible treatment.

Sclerosing cholangitis in children

We report on 56 children with sclerosing cholangitis (SC) seen between 1972 and 1992. The first symptoms occurred at a mean age of 3.7 years; 15 infants had neonatal cholestatic jaundice. At diagnosis, cholestatic jaundice was present in 25 children, hepatomegaly in 54, splenomegaly in 41, and ascites in 12. Serum alkaline phosphatase activity was increased in 49 patients and gamma-glutamyltransferase activity in all patients tested. Most often the histopathologic findings were extensive portal fibrosis and neoductular proliferation. Cholangiography showed abnormal intrahepatic bile ducts in all children and abnormal extrahepatic bile ducts in 35 (63%). The children were separated into three groups: (1) those with SC of neonatal onset (27%); (2) those with SC of postneonatal onset associated with another disease (55%)--histiocytosis X in 14 children, immunodeficiency syndromes in 8, chronic inflammatory bowel disease or autoimmune hepatitis in 8, and congenital psoriasis in 1; and (3) those with SC of postneonatal onset without an associated disease (18%). Biliary cirrhosis was present in all but three children after 6 months to 19.3 years of follow-up. Eleven children died of portal hypertension or liver failure, and six died of a complication related to the associated disease. Fifteen children had liver transplantation; 11 of these are alive 6 months to 6 1/2 years later without recurrence of SC. The overall estimated median survival time of children with SC was 10 years from clinical onset. These results indicate that SC should be suspected in all children with a chronic cholestatic disease and increased serum gamma-glutamyl transferase activity, especially when diseases known to be associated with SC are present. The prognosis is poor, but liver transplantation should be considered except in those with severe immunodeficiency syndromes.

Biliary tract reconstruction in liver transplantation

Biliary tract complications are often referred to as the "Achilles' heel" of liver transplantation and various techniques have been developed to overcome them. The two major methods of bile duct reconstruction currently in use consist of either (1) choledochocholedochostomy over a T-tube or, when duct-to-duct approximation is not feasible, choledochojejunostomy over an internal stent, or (2) interposition of the donor gallbladder as a conduit between the donor bile duct and either the recipient bile duct or a jejunal loop. Although these standardizations of biliary tract reconstruction have resulted in a reduction of biliary complications after liver transplantation, further advancement in the elucidation of ampullary obstruction and viability of the donor bile duct is needed.

Primary sclerosing cholangitis

Primary sclerosing cholangitis is a rare disease of unknown etiology. Sclerosis of the bile ducts may actually be the final result of multiple factors such as autoimmune, bacterial, congenital, drug, or viral injury. The most commonly associated diseases are ulcerative colitis and chronic pancreatitis. Except in the earliest stages of the disease, liver histologic findings are not specific. Most patients present with jaundice, pain, and pruritus, although an increasing number of asymptomatic patients with inflammatory bowel disease and abnormal liver function are being identified. Cholangiography is key to the diagnosis and is usually pathognomonic except in the unusual case where primary sclerosing cholangitis is confused with cholangiocarcinoma. Many forms of medical therapy have been tried, including antibiotics, azathioprine, cholestyramine, colchicine, cyclosporine, D-penicillamine, steroids, and ursodeoxycholic acid. To date, none of these medications has been proved to alter the course of this disease. Recent reports of ursodeoxycholic acid trials have been encouraging, but long-term results of ongoing randomized trials have yet to be published. In recent years, balloon dilatation of biliary strictures has been accomplished via endoscopic and percutaneous transhepatic approaches. However, in patients with primary sclerosing cholangitis, these nonoperative manipulations must be done repeatedly, may entail multiple general anesthetics, and are difficult to perform. We believe that a direct surgical approach to the biliary tree with long-term transhepatic stenting is indicated in selected patients with severe hilar or extrahepatic stricturing, persistent jaundice or recurrent cholangitis, and no evidence of cirrhosis. Hepatic transplantation should be reserved for patients with primary sclerosing cholangitis who have well-established cirrhosis and have not responded to other therapeutic measures.

Early diagnosis of cytomegalovirus hepatitis in liver transplant recipients: role of immunostaining, DNA hybridization and culture of hepatic tissue

Immunostaining techniques that use a monoclonal antibody against an early cytomegalovirus antigen or a polyclonal antibody, in situ DNA hybridization and inoculation of cell cultures for the detection of cytomegalovirus from liver biopsy specimens were studied in 20 liver transplant patients with cytomegalovirus hepatitis, as defined by histological criteria. A total of 108 liver biopsy specimens from 20 patients with a diagnosis of cytomegalovirus hepatitis (obtained per protocol at 7, 21, 90, and 180 days or whenever liver dysfunction occurred), which had previously been examined histologically and in cell culture, were again studied by recutting the liver tissue for histological examination, DNA hybridization and immunostaining with monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies to cytomegalovirus. In 5 of 20 patients, the diagnosis of cytomegalovirus hepatitis could have been made earlier (mean = 9.6 days) by immunostaining with a monoclonal antibody. Of 47 biopsy specimens with cytomegalovirus inclusion bodies, the sensitivity and specificity of the diagnostic procedures were immunostaining with monoclonal antibody (84% and 90%) and polyclonal antibody (72% and 97%), in situ DNA hybridization (72% and 100%) and cell culture detection (52% and 95%), respectively. Immunostaining with a monoclonal antibody against an early CMV antigen frequently detected cytomegalovirus infection in the liver allograft earlier than identification of typical histological inclusion bodies. DNA in situ hybridization was less sensitive than other techniques but highly specific; cytomegalovirus cell culture lacked sensitivity compared with the other procedures.

Infections after auxiliary partial liver transplantation. Experiences in the first ten patients

In ten auxiliary partial liver transplant recipients selective bowel decontamination (SBD) was used to reduce infections due to gram-negative microorganisms and fungi. During SBD no gram-negative infections occurred. Candida peritonitis was observed in one patient. After discontinuation of SBD serious infections of gram-negative origin did occur and three fungal infections were seen. SBD seems to have a favourable effect in reducing infections by gram-negative microorganisms and fungi. Most striking was the number of enterococcal infections that occurred. Five out of ten patients developed enterococcal infections which in two cases contributed to a fatal outcome. These infections occurred after increase of the number of enterococci in faeces and concomitant positive cultures of bile, ascites or wound drains. This increase could be due to the use of SBD. Also, the kind of biliary anastomosis may play an important role in the relatively high incidence of enterococcal infections. In the postoperative period, recurrence of hepatitis B infection in the liver graft was observed in all patients with cirrhosis due to this virus. Problems caused by other viral infections or protozoal infections remained limited in these ten patients.

Applications of duplex ultrasonography in the liver transplant patient

Duplex ultrasonography plays an important role in the preoperative and postoperative assessment of liver transplant patients. Before surgical intervention, the principal use of sonography is to assess the patency of the extrahepatic portal vein because a narrowed or thrombosed portal vein may preclude transplantation. Postoperatively, several potential complications can lead to allograft dysfunction (rejection, infection, vascular thromboses, and biliary tract complications). Because these complications often manifest with variable and nonspecific symptoms, diagnosing them can be difficult. Sonography is a valuable noninvasive means of evaluating postoperative complications in liver transplant patients. When vascular complications are suspected, duplex sonography is the optimal screening procedure for assessment of the vascular anastomoses. Focal parenchymal abnormalities (hematomas, infarcts, and bilomas) and localized collections of abdominal fluid are readily detected by ultrasonography and can be safely aspirated and, when infected, percutaneously drained under sonographic guidance. Sonography is less useful in the detection of biliary tract complications early after transplantation.

Liver transplantation

Liver transplantation has become an established form of therapy for patients with almost any type of irreversible and severe liver disease. The remarkable success of liver transplantation has resulted from recent advances in immunosuppressive therapy, surgical techniques, and patient selection. Additional progress has been made in the management of the complex postoperative medical complications that may occur. Indeed, liver transplantation has contributed significantly to an improved quantity and quality of life for many patients with liver disease.

Role of the nurse in the multidisciplinary team approach to care of liver transplant patients

Nursing plays an important contributory role in the multidisciplinary team approach to patient care. The nurse who is responsible for the care of liver transplant patients requires special preparation to meet the patient's needs during the critical phases of the liver transplant process. In the hospital setting, a primary nursing-care delivery system enhances the nurse's role in supporting the goal of patient recovery. Primary nursing places the accountability and responsibility for planning, administering, and evaluating the care of the liver transplant patient with the primary nurse. The transplant nurse acts as a key link in the communication network within the multidisciplinary team, and effective communication is essential in the care of the liver transplant patient. For achievement of a life-style of independence after transplantation, the patient is assisted by the nurse, who provides instruction in such areas as diet, medications, monitoring of vital signs, and record keeping. Although the nurse is only one member contributing to the care of liver transplant patients, the nurse's role in the success of treatment is vital.

Incidence, distribution, and outcome of episodes of infection in 100 orthotopic liver transplantations

Of 83 patients who underwent 100 orthotopic liver transplantations, 53 had a single transplant procedure and at least 6 months of follow-up. In this main study group of 53 patients, major infections developed in 28 (53%) (a mean of 1.8 major episodes per infected patient). Of 51 major infections, 27 were bacterial, 19 were viral, 3 were protozoan, and 2 were fungal. Of the 27 bacterial infections, 22 (81%) occurred in the first 2 months after transplantation. Of the 40 bacterial isolates in the 27 bacterial infections, gram-positive aerobic bacteria were isolated in 26 (65%), anaerobic bacteria in 8 (20%), and aerobic gram-negative bacteria in 6 (15%). Only 1 of 16 bacteremic episodes was due to a gram-negative aerobic bacterium. Cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection occurred in 30 of the 53 patients (57%) and was symptomatic and invasive in 18. CMV infection was diagnosed a mean of 26 days after transplantation. Infections due to Pneumocystis carinii occurred later (2 to 3 months after transplantation). Death from infection occurred in 4 of the 53 patients (8%). In the group of 16 patients with two or more liver transplantations, fungal infection occurred in 2 and CMV infection in 13. In all 16 patients who underwent more than one liver transplantation, a major infection developed. The observations made in the main study group were consistent with findings in 13 patients with one liver transplantation but less than 6 months of follow-up. Infection is a major complication after liver transplantation, generally occurring in the first 2 months. Our observations suggest that the use of selective bowel decontamination may be associated with a relatively lower incidence of gram-negative aerobic bacterial infections.

Beyond 1 year after liver transplantation

We retrospectively reviewed the long-term results in 46 patients who survived at least 1 year after liver transplantation. Only one death has occurred, and one patient has required retransplantation. Biochemical liver function tests showed median values in the normal range, except for mild elevation of serum gamma-glutamyltransferase. In patients with primary biliary cirrhosis, these test results were completely normal. A liver biopsy 1 year after transplantation disclosed normal histologic findings in 31 patients (67%). The other patients had either transient (acute rejection) or stable (chronic rejection) abnormalities, except for two patients with progressive graft dysfunction attributable to chronic rejection. A clinically significant vascular anastomotic abnormality was noted in one patient who had hepatic artery thrombosis. Late bile duct complications occurred in 15% of patients, all of whom had a satisfactory outcome after surgical or radiologic intervention. Cyclosporine-related nephrotoxicity and hypertension each occurred in 67% of patients; however, conversion to a low-dose cyclosporine-azathioprine regimen yielded stabilization of renal function after the first postoperative year, and hypertension has been easily controlled medically. Diabetes necessitating insulin treatment developed in three patients. The body weight of the study patients had increased by a median of 6.5 kg at 1 year but stabilized thereafter. Subjective well-being and satisfaction with life were reported by 91% of the patients. Of the 46 patients, 26 were employed, 16 were homemakers, and only 4 did not work, 2 because of transplant-related medical problems. Thus, we conclude that liver transplantation rehabilitates patients with end-stage liver disease and enhances their quality of life.

Acute hepatic failure: the emerging role of orthotopic liver transplantation

From 1985 through 1987, we diagnosed acute hepatic failure in 13 patients. Spontaneous recovery occurred in three of these patients. Eight patients underwent liver transplantation, five of whom survived and three of whom died. In addition, two patients died before undergoing transplantation. The survival rate of 62% was better than that among our previous series of similar patients. This improvement seems to be related to the use of orthotopic liver transplantation as a therapeutic alternative among these patients. One of the three patients who died after liver transplantation had normal liver function, but respiratory failure caused by Pneumocystis carinii developed 4 months after the transplantation. The surgical procedure was less difficult in patients with acute fulminant hepatitis than in those with chronic liver disease because fewer problems arose from adhesions, venous collaterals, and ascites. The emerging role of orthotopic liver transplantation in patients with acute hepatic failure is demonstrated by the improvement of survival rates observed by various groups, including ours, when this therapeutic modality is available.

Hemodynamic and metabolic changes in hepatic transplantation

In this study, we retrospectively analyzed the intraoperative hemodynamic, laboratory, and coagulation data on the first 83 patients who underwent an initial liver transplantation procedure at our institution. The major hemodynamic changes at the time of reperfusion of the donor liver were significant decreases in arterial blood pressure, systemic vascular resistance, and pulmonary artery temperature and significant increases in cardiac output and pulmonary capillary wedge pressure. The alterations in laboratory values reflected intraoperative therapeutic manipulations. Citrate toxicity is a concern, and the amount of calcium chloride administered reflected the volume of blood transfused. On reperfusion, the fibrinogen concentration decreased and both the prothrombin time and the activated partial thromboplastin time increased. This coagulopathy was also evident in the thromboelastographic values. Aggressive monitoring and prompt intervention are necessary to maintain hemodynamic and metabolic homeostasis in these patients.

Assessment of nutritional status of patients with end-stage liver disease undergoing liver transplantation

Nutritional assessment factors (including dietary history, anthropometric and biochemical measurements, and evaluation of immunocompetence) were retrospectively reviewed in 74 patients undergoing an initial liver transplantation procedure. The patients were subdivided into four categories on the basis of type of liver disease: chronic active hepatitis (N = 24), primary sclerosing cholangitis (N = 22), primary biliary cirrhosis (N = 20), and acute or subacute hepatitis (N = 8). Our nutritional assessment data indicated that malnutrition was present preoperatively in all liver transplantation groups but that each group had distinct characteristics. The group with primary biliary cirrhosis seemed to have the best hepatic synthetic function despite extreme wasting of muscle and fat. On the basis of all criteria, the group with acute hepatitis was the most malnourished of the various disease groups. Aggressive nutritional support, which includes adequate intake of nutrients and supplementation of vitamins and trace minerals, should be encouraged for all potential liver transplant patients.

The first 100 liver transplantations at the Mayo Clinic

Between March 1985 and June 1987, the first 100 liver transplantations at the Mayo Clinic were performed in 83 patients (primarily adults). The most frequent diagnoses were chronic active hepatitis (in 24 patients), primary sclerosing cholangitis (in 22), and primary biliary cirrhosis (in 20). The median operating time was 406 minutes, and the median usage of erythrocytes was 13.2 units. A venovenous bypass was used in all patients older than 10 years of age. Hepatic artery thrombosis occurred in 10% of the 100 transplants. A choledochocholedochostomy was done in 58 patients and a choledochojejunostomy in 25 patients. Revision of the biliary anastomosis was necessary in 9 of the 83 patients (11%). Rejection, diagnosed by clinical and histologic criteria, occurred in 50 patients (60%) and was treated with a corticosteroid bolus, followed by OKT3 (monoclonal antibody) treatment if necessary. Selective bowel decontamination helped prevent infections; only 16 bacteremias occurred, 1 of which was caused by a gram-negative organism. Fungal infections were rare. Cytomegalovirus infection occurred in 47 patients (57%). Of the 83 patients, 16 required retransplantation, in 11 of whom graft rejection had occurred. One- and 2-year patient survival was 83% and 70%, respectively. Although problems still remain, liver transplantation is a reasonable option for patients with end-stage liver disease.

Cytomegalovirus infection in orthotopic liver transplantation

We retrospectively studied 175 orthotopic liver transplants in 151 patients. Of the 151 patients, 59 (39.1%) were diagnosed as having cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection. The rate of infection in patients treated for rejection was 48.8% as compared to 26.2% in patients without rejection (P less than 0.01). Antirejection therapy was associated with culture-positive cases in 33 out of 43 patients as compared to 9 out of 16 patients who had CMV antibody titer elevations. Patients were treated with gancyclovir if they had simultaneous positive cultures from multiple sites and were seriously ill. Eighteen of the 19 patients thus treated had side effects, one of which was serious (bone marrow hypoplasia). Cultures became negative in 15 out of 17 (88%) of the surviving patients. Patient survival was similar to our overall survival rate of 87%.

Liver Transplant Sonography

Sonography plays a crucial role in assessing liver transplant patients for vascular patency, fluid collections, and abdominal disease. This article discusses examination techniques, a suggested scanning routine, and the appearance of pretransplant and posttransplant disease.

Central nervous system toxicity after liver transplantation. The role of cyclosporine and cholesterol

We describe severe central nervous system (CNS) toxicity, manifested by confusion, cortical blindness, quadriplegia, seizures, and coma, associated with cyclosporine treatment in three patients undergoing liver transplantation. CT and magnetic resonance studies disclosed a severe, diffuse disorder of the white matter. All side effects and radiographic findings were reversed with discontinuation or a reduction in the dose of cyclosporine. We also observed an inverse association between CNS side effects and total serum cholesterol levels after transplantation. A retrospective analysis of 54 liver transplantations performed in 48 patients revealed that 13 patients had symptoms of CNS toxicity associated with the use of cyclosporine. These patients' total serum cholesterol levels in the first week after transplantation were reduced as compared with those in patients without symptoms (mean +/- SE, 94 +/- 4 mg per deciliter vs. 132 +/- 6, or 2.44 +/- 0.10 mmol per liter vs. 3.43 +/- 0.16). We conclude that cyclosporine therapy for immunosuppression in liver transplantation may cause a syndrome of encephalopathy, seizures, and white-matter changes and that this is most likely to occur in patients with low total serum cholesterol levels after transplantation.

Hemostatic evaluation of patients undergoing liver transplantation

A detailed coagulation and thromboelastographic study was done on the first 50 liver transplantation procedures performed at the Mayo Clinic between March 1985 and June 1986. Most of the patients suffered from primary sclerosing cholangitis, primary biliary cirrhosis, or chronic active hepatitis. Seven patients required a second liver transplantation, and six patients died, none intraoperatively. Most of the patients had distorted hemostatic mechanisms preoperatively, as would be expected because the liver generates most of the clotting factors. The outstanding exception was factor VIII, which was usually in the high-normal range or even more elevated. Substantial deterioration of coagulation factors occurred regularly during reperfusion of the donor liver. In some instances, this trend was corrected within 1 hour, but platelet counts continued to decrease, and some coagulation factors rebounded only partially. Because thromboelastographic tracings are quickly available to the liver transplant team and because they tend to forewarn of impending hemostatic problems, we believe that thromboelastography is a reasonably effective procedure for monitoring coagulation during liver transplantation.

Orthotopic liver transplantation: postoperative complications and their management

The Birmingham liver transplant programme started in 1982. Forty-six patients have been transplanted with a follow-up of 3 months or longer. Twenty-seven patients are still alive, of whom sixteen have lived for more than one year. The 30 day hospital mortality was 30.4 per cent and the actuarial predicted one year survival 55.5 per cent. Four patients have been regrafted for chronic rejection and graft failure. Thirteen patients have required surgery in the postoperative period for: bleeding (two), removal of abdominal packs (four), biliary leaks and obstruction (five), duodenal perforation (one) and small bowel obstruction (one). Acute rejection was common, occurring in 30 patients and progressing to chronic rejection in 4. Ten patients developed renal failure with an 80 per cent mortality and eleven patients developed grand mal fits. Severe bleeding (greater than 70 units) was associated with previous abdominal surgery and a high mortality (88.9 per cent). Opportunistic fungal infection carried a 100 per cent mortality. Although more than half of all transplanted patients will survive for more than one year, the postoperative period is still one of high morbidity and mortality.