Elective irradiation of the N0 neck in squamous cell carcinoma of the upper aerodigestive tract

Diagnostic value of sentinel lymph node biopsy in head and neck cancer: a meta-analysis

This study aimed to evaluate the diagnostic reliability of sentinel lymph node biopsy in patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity, oropharynx, hypopharynx, and larynx by reviewing the published literature. A systematic literature review was performed using MEDLINE from 1970 to 2011. With Boolean search strings, search terms included sentinel node, supraglottic, supraglottis, tongue, head and neck, oral, pharynx, laryngeal, and larynx. Additional studies were identified through article references. Duplicate data and articles were excluded based on treating institution and study inclusion time period. Additional studies were excluded if the head and neck subsite or tumor stage was not specifically identified or if the sentinel lymph node biopsy occurred in previously treated necks. All patients had sentinel lymph node biopsy performed followed by a concurrent neck dissection. Twenty-six studies met our inclusion criteria (n = 766 patients). The pooled sensitivity and negative predictive value of SLNB for all head and neck tumors was 95 % (95 % CI 91-99 %) and 96 % (95 %CI 94-99 %), respectively. The overall sensitivity and negative predictive value of SLNB in the subset of oral cavity tumors (n = 631) was 94 % (95 % CI 89-98 %) and 96 % (95 % CI 93-99 %), respectively. One-hundred percent of oropharyngeal (n = 72), hypopharyngeal (n = 5), and laryngeal (n = 58) tumor sentinel lymph biopsy results correlated with subsequent neck dissections giving a negative predictive value of 100 %, showing that, sentinel lymph node biopsy is a valid diagnostic technique to correctly stage regional metastases in patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinoma.

Long-term experience in sentinel node biopsy for early oral and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma

OBJECTIVE

Long-term results of sentinel node biopsy (SNB) in early (T1/T2) oral and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) in a single-institution experience.

METHODS

Prospective consecutive cohort analysis of 79 patients (67% male, median age 60 years, age range 34-87 years) included between 2000 and 2006. Lymphatic mapping consisted of preoperative lymphoscintigraphy, single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT/CT), and intraoperative use of a handheld gamma probe. Endpoints of the study were neck control rate, overall (OS), disease-specific (DSS), and disease-free survival (DFS).

RESULTS

Twenty-nine of 79 patients (37%) had positive sentinel nodes (SN). Six of 29 (21%) patients showed isolated tumor cells, 14/29 (48%) micrometastases, and 9/29 (31%) macrometastases. OS, DFS, and DSS at 5 years for the entire cohort were 80, 85, and 87%, for SN-negative patients were 88, 96, and 96%, and for SN-positive patients were 74, 73, and 77%, respectively. Only the difference in DSS achieved statistical significance. The neck control rate after 5 years was 96% in SN-negative and 74% in SN-positive patients. This difference was statistically significant.

CONCLUSIONS

SNB is a safe and accurate staging modality to select patients with clinically stage I/II OSCC with occult lymph node disease for elective neck dissection (END). The promising reported short-term results have been sustained by long-term follow-up. Patients with negative SN and no END achieve an excellent neck control rate which compares favorably with reports on primary END. The neck control rate in SN-negative patients is superior to that in SN-positive patients, which is reflected in superior DSS.

Neck recurrence after level I-IV or I-III selective neck dissection in the management of the clinically N0 neck in patients with oral squamous cell carcinoma

BACKGROUND

Controversy remains regarding extending the level I-III selective neck dissection (SND) to include level IV in the management of the clinically N0 (cN0) neck in patients with oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC).

METHODS

Histologic and follow-up data of 87 patients with previously untreated OSCC undergoing I-IV SND and 41 undergoing I-III SND between 2002 and 2006 were reviewed.

RESULTS

Of the 98 I-IV SNDs performed, 4 had involvement of level IV. No relationship between tumor variables and level IV involvement was identified. Survival analysis failed to demonstrate a significant difference between I-III and I-IV SND in terms of developing neck recurrence in the 2 years following surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Level I-III SND is effective management of the cN0 neck (when coupled with postoperative radiotherapy in selected cases) in patients with OSCC, although it is recommended that a larger prospective study be performed in this field.

Metástase cervical nos tumores malignos da parótida

OBJETIVO: Analisar fatores que influenciam a ocorrência de metástase linfática cervical e a sobrevida nos tumores malignos epiteliais da glândula parótida. MÉTODO: Analisamos retrospectivamente os prontuários de 150 pacientes tratados em nossa instituição de 1974 a 1998. Vinte e quatro pacientes foram excluídos do estudo por não terem sido tratados primariamente por cirurgia. O 126 pacientes restantes foram submetidos a parotidectomia e incluídos neste estudo. Setenta e quatro pacientes tiveram sua cirurgia complementada por radioterapia pós-operatória. Trinta e quatro pacientes foram submetidos ao esvaziamento cervical associado a parotidectomia. A idade média foi de 49 anos. Todos os pacientes foram estadiados pela Classificação TNM da UICC de 1997, sendo 49 pacientes estágio I, 27 estágio II, 22 estágio III, and 28 estágio IV. A influência dos fatores analisados na ocorrência de metástase cervical foi estabelecida pelo teste do chi quadrado e por análise multivariada. A influência de fatores prognósticos na sobrevida específica de doença (SED) em 5 e 10 anos foi estabelecida pelo método de Kaplan-Meier e pelo teste log-rank. RESULTADOS: O tipo histopatológico de 40 pacientes foi o carcinoma mucoepidermóide, de 18 pacientes o adenocarcinoma (SOE), de 18 pacientes o carcinoma de células acinares, de 15 pacientes o carcinoma adenóide cístico, de 11 pacientes o carcinoma exadenoma pleomórfico, de 11 pacientes o carcinoma de ducto salivares, e de 13 pacientes outras histopatologias. Vinte e cinco pacientes apresentaram recidivas, 17 recidivas locais, quatro recidivas regionais, e quatro recidivas loco-regionais. A incidência geral de metástase linfática cervical foi de 17,5%. Metástases linfáticas cervicais ocultas ocorreram em cinco pacientes daqueles submetidos a esvaziamento cervical profilático. A presença de paralisia facial no diagnóstico, a idade, o estágio T, e o grau de malignidade foram relacionados a ocorrência de metástase linfática cervical na análise multivariada. Cinco fatores influenciaram negativamente o prognóstico, estágio T3-T4, alto grau de malignidade, presença de metástase cervical, paralisia facial no diagnóstico, e idade acima de 50 anos. A SED em 10 anos foi de 97% para o estágio I, 81% para o estágio II, 56% para o estágio III, e 20% para estágio IV. CONCLUSÕES: O grau de malignidade e o estágio foram os fatores prognósticos mais importantes. Apesar de ser um estudo retrospectivo e não randomizado, nossos dados sugerem que o esvaziamento cervical profilático deve ser considerado em casos de tumores de alto grau de malignidade, estágio T3-T4, e na presença de paralisia facial no diagnóstico.

Esvaziamento cervical seletivo no tratamento do carcinoma epidermóide do andar inferior da boca

OBJETIVO: O esvaziamento cervical seletivo, removendo apenas os linfonodos com maior probabilidade de metástases, pode ser adequado para o tratamento do pescoço nos carcinomas epidermóides do andar inferior da boca. O objetivo deste estudo é avaliar os níveis linfonodais acometidos por metástases em uma série de pacientes tratados em uma única instituição. MÉTODO: Foram avaliados os registros de 416 pacientes com câncer de lábio, língua oral, soalho de boca, gengiva inferior, região jugal e trígono retromolar, submetidos à 519 esvaziamentos cervicais entre 1977 e 2001, quanto ao níveis linfonodais acometidos por metástases. RESULTADOS: O nível I estava acometido em 107/519 (20%) esvaziamentos, o nível II em 147/519 (28%), o nível III em 75/519 (14%), o nível IV em 32/419 (7%) e o nível V em 22/419 (5%). A taxa de falso-negativos e de falso-positivos foi de 36% e 30%, respectivamente. Os pacientes com metástases nos níveis I e/ou II, III, IV ou V tiveram uma média 2,2; 4,8; 6,5 e 7,5 linfonodos comprometidos, respectivamente (p < 0.0001). As metástases no nível IIb foram diagnosticadas em 21 (5%) pacientes, sendo que 11 (52%) deles tinham metástases no nível V (p < 0,0001). CONCLUSÃO: O esvaziamento cervical dos níveis I a IV remove quase todos os linfonodos com risco de metástases no carcinoma epidermóide do andar inferior da boca. O esvaziamento seletivo com esta extensão é adequado para o tratamento eletivo do pescoço (N0), onde ocorrem aproximadamente 30% de casos falso-negativos, e também pode ser suficiente no esvaziamento terapêutico (N+). Quando ocorrem metástases no nível IIb, aumenta significativamente o risco de metástases no nível V.

Estudo retrospectivo dos carcinomas epidermóides das vias aerodigestivas superiores com metástases bilaterais

OBJETIVO: Estudo retrospectivo das características dos carcinomas epidermóides das vias aerodigestivas superiores relacionadas ao desenvolvimento de metástases cervicais bilaterais. MÉTODO: Foram revisados os prontuários de 150 pacientes com carcinoma epidermóide de boca, orofaringe, laringe e hipofaringe submetidos a esvaziamento cervical bilateral entre janeiro de 1979 e dezembro de 1996, dos quais foram selecionados 73 pacientes que apresentavam metástases bilaterais confirmadas no exame histológico. Foram considerados o estadiamento e a localização dos tumores, confrontando os achados com os estudos sobre drenagem linfática e distribuição das metástases cervicais neste tipo de tumor. RESULTADOS: Quatorze pacientes apresentaram tumor primário nos estádios T1 e T2, 57 nos estádios T3 e T4 e dois não foram estadiados (Tx). Nos cinco pacientes T1 ou T2 de laringe com metástases bilaterais, a lesão estava localizada na epiglote. CONCLUSÕES: Nos pacientes com lesões unilaterais que apresentaram disseminação bilateral, todos apresentavam lesões palpáveis unilaterais.

Does unnecessary elective neck treatment affect the prognosis of N0 laryngeal cancer patients?

OBJECTIVE

Among detractors of elective neck (N0) treatments, most suggest that lymphadenectomy removes a barrier to the spread of disease with deleterious immunologic consequences. To test this hypothesis we performed a retrospective comparison of the survival results of N0 laryngeal cancer patients who received unnecessary elective neck treatments (N0-) and those of N0 patients subjected to close and regular follow-up.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A retrospective chart review of 749 N0 laryngeal cancer patients treated at the Institute of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, University of Florence between January 1980 and January 1993 was performed. Of these, 245 (33%) received elective neck dissection (ED), while the remaining 504 (67%) N0 patients were subjected to close and regular follow-up (wait-and-see policy; WS).

RESULTS

Of the 245 ED patients, 43 (17.5%) showed an occult neck disease, while of the 504 WS subjects, 83 (17%) developed neck metastases during follow-up. Moreover, 15 ED patients subsequently experienced a contralateral occult failure despite a unilateral negative neck specimen (N0-). Thus, ultimately 187 ED (164 of whom were treated unilaterally and 23 bilaterally) and 421 WS patients were used for survival analysis. No differences in terms of postoperative complications, local or distant failure or disease-free or overall actuarial survival were found between the two groups analyzed.

CONCLUSIONS

These data indicate that unilateral or bilateral removal of cervical lymphatics in the absence of histologically proven lymph node metastases does not negatively affect the prognosis of N0 laryngeal cancer patients who were overtreated to the neck.

A new approach to pre-treatment assessment of the N0 neck in oral squamous cell carcinoma: the role of sentinel node biopsy and positron emission tomography

OBJECTIVES

Pre-operative staging of the clinically N(0) neck in patients with oral squamous cell carcinoma is hindered by the relatively high false negative/positive rates of conventional imaging techniques. The aim of this study is to evaluate the utility of (18)F-fluoro-deoxy-glucose (FDG) positron emission tomography (PET) and sentinel lymph node (SLN) imaging and biopsy to determine the true disease status of the loco-regional lymphatics.

METHODS

Nineteen patients with biopsy proven disease without palpable or radiological evidence of neck metastases underwent pre-operative (18)F-FDG PET and SLN imaging. All patients underwent whole-body FDG PET and a single view of the head and neck. SLN technique was performed using four peri-tumoural injections of (99m)Tc labeled albumin colloid each of 10 MBq. Dynamic and static imaging followed in the antero-posterior and lateral projections. At operation 1 ml of 2.5% Patent Blue Dye and a hand held gamma probe (Neoprobe 1500) were used in combination to identify and remove the SLN. Surgery then continued along conventional lines including a neck dissection. Histology of the resultant specimen was correlated with that of the SLN and pre-operative imaging.

RESULTS

In all patients SLN harvesting was feasible. In 15/19 patients the SLN(s) and the residual neck dissection were -ve for tumour. In 3/19 patients the SLN(s) were +ve for tumour as were other neck nodes. In 1/19 patients the SLN was -ve but another single tumour +ve node was identified in the neck. This patient occurred early in our series with a SLN close to the primary tumour. (18)F-FDG PET failed to identify nodal disease in all four patients with histologically proven lymph node metastases. The size of these nodes ranged from 12 mm x 10 mm x 3 mm to 25 mm x 15 mm x 10 mm.

CONCLUSION

SLN imaging and biopsy with probe and Patent Blue Dye guided harvest is feasible in patients with oral squamous cell carcinoma and can predict cervical nodal status. (18)F-FDG PET may be less useful.