The role of elastase in the differentiation of Bacteroides nodosus infections in sheep and cattle

The virulence of Dichelobacter nodosus, measured by the elastase test, is an important predictor for virulent footrot diagnosis in New South Wales sheep flocks

Ovine footrot is a contagious bacterial disease that causes foot lesions, and depending on the virulence of the causative strains, may lead to severe underrunning of the hoof and lameness. Virulent footrot can be identified, treated and controlled more effectively than less virulent benign forms. The in vitro elastase test for virulence of the causative bacteria, Dichelobacter nodosus, has been used to support clinical diagnosis. However, not all laboratory-designated virulent D. nodosus strains cause clinical signs of virulent footrot. This study evaluated retrospectively how well the elastase test supported clinical footrot diagnosis in 150 sheep flocks examined for suspect footrot in New South Wales between August 2020 and December 2021. Flocks were included if measures of clinical disease, environmental conditions and the virulence of D. nodosus isolates were available. Variation in the elastase activity result between D. nodosus isolated from the same flock made bacterial virulence hard to interpret, but calculating the mean elastase rate for all isolates from the same flock made correlations between bacterial virulence and flock footrot diagnosis possible. Simplifying bacterial virulence into whether there were any elastase-positive D. nodosus isolates before 12 days increased the predictive value of elastase results for virulent diagnosis, compared with using the first day that any isolate was elastase positive or the percentage of elastase-positive isolates by 12 days, but not all clinically virulent flocks had isolates with elastase activity before 12 days. Logistic regression models were fitted to identify the minimum number of predictors for virulent footrot diagnosis, with models suggesting that virulent footrot diagnosis was best predicted by adding the elastase test result and environmental conditions to the prevalence of severe foot lesions (score 4 and 5). However, performing the same analysis with different breeds, ages of sheep and seasons might highlight other factors important in the diagnosis of virulent footrot.

Efficacy of bivalent fimbrial vaccines to control and eliminate intermediate forms of footrot in sheep

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to determine the efficacy of serogroup-specific bivalent fimbrial vaccines in the control and elimination of relatively mild (intermediate) forms of footrot in sheep flocks in NSW, there being some evidence that such forms are difficult to control.

METHODS

Four flocks of sheep with history of footrot of intermediate virulence were selected based on clinical and bacteriological diagnoses. Dichelobacter nodosus serogroups included in bivalent vaccines at each farm were based on on-farm serogroup-prevalence data. Two doses of bivalent vaccine were administered with a 4-week interval between doses. Repeated post-vaccination inspections of all feet of between 100 and 119 animals per mob were conducted and foot swabs were collected for bacteriological testing. Blood samples were collected from 10 to 24 individually identified animals per flock at each inspection to check for agglutinating antibody responses.

RESULTS

In the majority of animals, antibody levels for serogroups included in each vaccine were above the level believed to be required for protective immunity. Footrot disappeared on farm 1 prior to vaccination, but did not reappear postvaccination. Footrot was controlled but not eliminated on farms 2, 3, and 4, where the prevalence and severity of the disease and number of serogroups present were reduced.

CONCLUSION

Serogroup-specific bivalent vaccines can be effective at controlling footrot caused by intermediate strains of D. nodosus.

The severity of footrot lesions induced by aprV2-positive strains of Dichelobacter nodosus varies between strains

OBJECTIVES

The primary objective of this study was to evaluate the clinical virulence of aprV2-positive lesser virulent field isolates of footrot bacteria Dichelobacter nodosus in comparison with an aprV2-positive clinically virulent reference strain. Correlations between the clinical expression of the disease and the presence of aprV2 (detected using PCR tests) have been inconsistent. A second objective was to evaluate the elimination of D. nodosus following treatment of sheep as some strains of D. nodosus have been reported to be difficult to eliminate.

METHODS

The virulence of three aprV2-positive field isolates of D. nodosus which had lesser virulent phenotypes, and an aprV2-positive virulent reference strain was evaluated in a sheep trial using a pasture-based experimental infection model. In the second phase of the study, treatments including footbathing and a long-acting antibiotic were administered and their efficacy in elimination of these strains was evaluated.

RESULTS

Severe underrun (score 4) lesions developed in sheep infected with the aprV2-positive virulent reference strain but not in sheep infected with the field isolates; they had mild lesions (score 2 or 3). The three field isolates and the virulent reference strain of D. nodosus were eliminated by intensive foot bathing and antibiotic therapy in combination with housing the animals in dry conditions post-treatment.

CONCLUSION

The results suggest that the presence of aprV2 gene in isolates of D. nodosus may not be a reliable indicator of virulence and that further investigation of the factors that determine clinical virulence is required. While the treatment regime was successful, based on a range of considerations, the use of such an intensive treatment involving antibiotics should be limited to small groups of high-value animals, such as rams.

A comparison of multivalent and bivalent vaccination strategies for the control of virulent ovine footrot

Virulent footrot is a significant economic and animal welfare concern. The disease can be treated, controlled, and eliminated with vaccine, but selecting the appropriate vaccination strategy can be challenging. There are two main strategies: outbreak (serogroup)-specific univalent or bivalent vaccination, or use of a multivalent vaccine containing up to nine of the most common serogroups. The objective of this study was to compare these approaches in sheep flocks infected with multiple Dichelobacter nodosus serogroups. In the first phase, we undertook an immunogenicity trial in which we compared four pre-commercial multivalent recombinant fimbrial vaccines containing six (A, B, C, G, H, I) or nine (A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I) serogroups, and compared them to commercial bivalent vaccines. Two multivalent vaccines stimulated significantly higher antibody responses than two other multivalent vaccines but the number of serogroups included in the multivalent vaccine formulations did not have a significant effect. In the first phase, we also compared inter-vaccination intervals of two- and three-months between sequential bivalent vaccines, and found that a two-month interval was sufficient to avoid antigenic competition. In the second phase, the most immunogenic multivalent vaccine (nine serogroups) was compared to sequential bivalent vaccines and monthly foot-bathing in a field trial in four commercial Merino flocks. The duration of protection afforded by the multivalent vaccine was likely to be less than that of the bivalent vaccines, as the antibody titres stimulated were lower and less persistent.

The microbiome of the footrot lesion in Merino sheep is characterized by a persistent bacterial dysbiosis

Footrot is prevalent in most sheep-producing countries; the disease compromises sheep health and welfare and has a considerable economic impact. The disease is the result of interactions between the essential causative agent, Dichelobacter nodosus, and the bacterial community of the foot, with the pasture environment and host resistance influencing disease expression. The Merino, which is the main wool sheep breed in Australia, is particularly susceptible to footrot. We characterised the bacterial communities on the feet of healthy and footrot-affected Merino sheep across a 10-month period via sequencing and analysis of the V3-V4 regions of the bacterial 16S ribosomal RNA gene. Distinct bacterial communities were associated with the feet of healthy and footrot-affected sheep. Infection with D. nodosus appeared to trigger a shift in the composition of the bacterial community from predominantly Gram-positive, aerobic taxa to predominantly Gram-negative, anaerobic taxa. A total of 15 bacterial genera were preferentially abundant on the feet of footrot-affected sheep, several of which have previously been implicated in footrot and other mixed bacterial diseases of the epidermis of ruminants. Some, including Porphyromonas, can trigger a shift in the composition of bacterial communities and may therefore be of significance to the expression of footrot. A comparison of the communities in footrot lesions of different scores and at different times revealed that this state of dysbiosis is persistent at the active margins of lesions, irrespective of their severity.

Detection and Serogrouping of Dichelobacter nodosus Infection by Use of Direct PCR from Lesion Swabs To Support Outbreak-Specific Vaccination for Virulent Footrot in Sheep

Virulent footrot is an economically significant disease in most sheep-rearing countries. The disease can be controlled with vaccine targeting the fimbriae of virulent strains of the essential causative agent, Dichelobacter nodosus However, the bacterium is immunologically heterogeneous, and 10 distinct fimbrial serogroups have been identified. Ideally, in each outbreak the infecting strains would be cultured and serogrouped so that the appropriate serogroup-specific mono- or bivalent vaccine could be administered, because multivalent vaccines lack efficacy due to antigenic competition. If clinical disease expression is suspected to be incomplete, culture-based virulence tests are required to confirm the diagnosis, because control of benign footrot is economically unjustifiable. Both diagnosis and vaccination are conducted at the flock level. The aims of this study were to develop a PCR-based procedure for detecting and serogrouping D. nodosus directly from foot swabs and to determine whether this could be done accurately from the same cultured swab. A total of 269 swabs from the active margins of foot lesions of 261 sheep in 12 Merino sheep flocks in southeastern Australia were evaluated. DNA extracts taken from putative pure cultures of D. nodosus and directly from the swabs were evaluated in PCR assays for the 16S rRNA and fimA genes of D. nodosus Pure cultures were tested also by the slide agglutination test. Direct PCR using extracts from swabs was more sensitive than culture for detecting and serogrouping D. nodosus strains. Using the most sensitive sample collection method of the use of swabs in lysis buffer, D. nodosus was more likely to be detected by PCR in active than in inactive lesions, and in lesions with low levels of fecal contamination, but lesion score was not a significant factor. PCR conducted on extracts from swabs in modified Stuart's transport medium that had already been used to inoculate culture plates had lower sensitivity. Therefore, if culture is required to enable virulence tests to be conducted, it is recommended that duplicate swabs be collected from each foot lesion, one in transport medium for culture and the other in lysis buffer for PCR.

Evaluation of Genotypic and Phenotypic Protease Virulence Tests for Dichelobacter nodosus Infection in Sheep

Dichelobacter nodosus is a fastidious, strictly anaerobic bacterium, an obligate parasite of the ruminant hoof, and the essential causative agent of virulent ovine footrot. The clinical disease results from a complex interplay between the pathogen, the environment, and the host. Sheep flocks diagnosed with virulent but not benign footrot in Australia may be quarantined and required to undergo a compulsory eradication program, with costs met by the farmer. Virulence of D. nodosus at least partially depends on the elaboration of a protease encoded by aprV2 and manifests as elastase activity. Laboratory virulence tests are used to assist diagnosis because clinical differentiation of virulent and benign footrot can be challenging during the early stages of disease or when the disease is not fully expressed due to unfavorable pasture conditions. Using samples collected from foot lesions from 960 sheep from 40 flocks in four different geographic regions, we evaluated the analytical characteristics of qPCR tests for the protease gene alleles aprV2 and aprB2, and compared these with results from phenotypic protease (elastase and gelatin gel) tests. There was a low level of agreement between clinical diagnosis and quantitative PCR (qPCR) test outcomes at both the flock and sample levels and poor agreement between qPCR test outcomes and the results of phenotypic virulence tests. The diagnostic specificity of the qPCR test was low at both the flock and individual swab levels (31.3% and 18.8%, respectively). By contrast, agreement between the elastase test and clinical diagnosis was high at both the flock level (diagnostic sensitivity [DSe], 100%; diagnostic specificity [DSp], 78.6%) and the isolate level (DSe, 69.5%; DSp, 80.5%).

Molecular genetic analysis of Dichelobacter nodosus proteases AprV2/B2, AprV5/B5 and BprV/B in clinical material from European sheep flocks

Dichelobacter nodosus, the etiological agent of ovine footrot, exists both as virulent and as benign strains, which differ in virulence mainly due to subtle differences in the three subtilisin-like proteases AprV2, AprV5 and BprV found in virulent, and AprB2, AprB5 and BprB in benign strains of D. nodosus. Our objective was a molecular genetic epidemiological analysis of the genes of these proteases by direct sequence analysis from clinical material of sheep from herds with and without history of footrot from 4 different European countries. The data reveal the two proteases known as virulent AprV2 and benign AprB2 to correlate fully to the clinical status of the individuals or the footrot history of the herd. In samples taken from affected herds, the aprV2 gene was found as a single allele whereas in samples from unaffected herds several alleles with minor modifications of the aprB2 gene were detected. The different alleles of aprB2 were related to the herds. The aprV5 and aprB5 genes were found in the form of several alleles scattered without distinction between affected and non-affected herds. However, all different alleles of aprV5 and aprB5 encode the same amino acid sequences, indicating the existence of a single protease isoenzyme 5 in both benign and virulent strains. The genes of the basic proteases BprV and BprB also exist as various alleles. However, differences found in samples from affected versus non-affected herds do not reflect the currently known epitopes that are attributed to differences in biochemical activity. The data of the study confirm the prominent role of AprV2 in the virulence of D. nodosus and shed a new light on the presence of the other protease genes and their allelic variants in clinical samples.

Interdigital dermatitis, heel horn erosion, and digital dermatitis in 14 Norwegian dairy herds

The aim of this study was to assess infectious foot diseases, including identification and characterization of Dichelobacter nodosus and Treponema spp., in herds having problems with interdigital dermatitis (ID) and heel horn erosion (E) and in control herds expected to have few problems. We also wanted to compare diseased and healthy cows in all herds. The study included 14 dairy herds with a total of 633 cows. Eight herds had a history of ID and E, and 6 were control herds. All cows were scored for lameness, and infectious foot diseases on the hind feet were recorded after trimming. Swabs and biopsies were taken from the skin of 10 cows in each herd for bacterial analyses. In total, samples were taken from 34 cows with ID, 11 with E, 40 with both ID and E, and 8 with digital dermatitis (DD), and from 47 cows with healthy feet. Swabs were analyzed for identification and characterization of D. nodosus by PCR, culture, virulence testing, and serotyping. Biopsies were analyzed by fluorescent in situ hybridization regarding histopathology, identification, and characterization of Treponema spp., and identification of D. nodosus. Interdigital dermatitis was the most frequent foot disease, with a prevalence of 50.4% in problem herds compared with 26.8% in control herds. Heel horn erosion was recorded in 34.8% of the cows in problem herds compared with 22.1% in control herds. Dichelobacter nodosus was detected in 97.1% of the cows with ID, in 36.4% with E, in all cows with both ID and E, in all cows with DD, and in 66.0% of cows with healthy feet. All serogroups of D. nodosus except F and M were detected, and all isolates were defined as benign by the gelatin gel test. Treponema spp. were detected in 50.0% of the cows with ID, in 9.1% with E, in 67.5% with ID and E, in all cows with DD, and in 6.4% of those with healthy feet. In total, 6 previously described phylotypes (PT) of Treponema were detected: PT1, PT3, PT6, PT13, and PT15 in cows with ID, PT1 in a cow with E, and PT1, PT2, PT3, PT6, and PT13 in cows with both ID and E. One new phylotype (PT19) was identified. The epidermal damage score was higher but the difference in inflammatory response of the dermis was minor in cows with ID versus those with healthy feet. Fisher's exact test revealed an association between ID and D. nodosus, and between ID and Treponema spp. Logistic regression revealed an association between both ID and E and dirty claws (odds ratios=1.9 and 2.0, respectively). Our study indicates that D. nodosus, Treponema spp., and hygiene are involved in the pathogenesis of ID.

Outbreak-specific monovalent/bivalent vaccination to control and eradicate virulent ovine footrot

Footrot is a contagious disease of small ruminants which is caused by the bacterium Dichelobacter nodosus. In its virulent form there are severe economic losses and a very significant animal welfare issue. Sheep and goats can be vaccinated for treatment and prevention of the disease. There are 10 different serogroups of D. nodosus (A-I and M) and immunity is serogroup-specific. When all 10 serogroups are presented together in a vaccine, protection persists for only a few months due to "antigenic competition". Consequently we evaluated the use of sequential monovalent or bivalent vaccines to control/eliminate/eradicate virulent footrot in a longitudinal intervention study on 12 commercial farms in southeast Australia with flock sizes of approximately 1200-4200 sheep. Overall, virulent footrot was eradicated from 4 of the flocks, 2 of which had 2 serogroups, and the others 4 or 5 serogroups. Where there were only 1 or 2 serogroups (3 farms) the clinical response was rapid and dramatic; prevalence was reduced from 45 to 50% before vaccination to 0% (2 farms) or 0.4% (1 farm) after one round of vaccination. In the remaining 9 flocks there were more than 2 serogroups and successive bivalent vaccines were administered leading to eradication of virulent footrot on 2 farms over 4 years and control of the disease on all but 3 of the others. Of the latter farms, 1 discontinued, and 2 initially had poor response to vaccine due to misdiagnosis of serogroup 'M', which was previously unknown in Australia. Control was achieved after administration of a serogroup M vaccine. These results provide clear evidence for control, elimination and eradication of virulent footrot by outbreak-specific vaccination in Australia.

Producer-initiated field research leads to a new diagnostic test for footrot

The Cicerone Project was formed in 1998 to address problems faced by wool producers. In the New England area, the issue of suspected false positive diagnoses of virulent footrot, which can be a significant cause of economic loss to individual producers, was investigated. In New South Wales, footrot diagnosis is primarily a field diagnosis supported by the gelatin gel laboratory test. The principal causative agent of footrot is Dichelobacter nodosus. If the gelatin gel test finds strains of D. nodosus to be thermostable (gel stable), a finding of virulent footrot is likely and quarantine of the affected property follows. However, livestock producers and inspectors reported that there were a considerable number of cases where laboratory tests found strains to be stable but these strains did not cause virulent footrot in the field. Preliminary results using DNA markers associated with virulent footrot showed that one of these markers, intA, was absent in gel stable, field benign strains but present in all strains tested which caused field virulent footrot. A trial conducted at Uralla, New South Wales, demonstrated conclusively that there were strains of D. nodosus which were stable in the gelatin gel test but did not cause virulent footrot in the field. All of these strains were negative in the intA DNA test. These results were confirmed in a second field trial at Molong, New South Wales. These trials were instrumental in establishing that the gelatin gel test at times gave results inconsistent with the clinical expression of footrot, potentially leading to a false positive diagnosis of virulent footrot. Subsequent research led to confirmation of the intA test, which is now available as an additional tool for footrot diagnosis.

Characterisation of Dichelobacter nodosus isolates from Norway

An outbreak of ovine footrot in Norway in 2008, the first reported since 1948, prompted action to investigate Norwegian isolates of Dichelobacter nodosus. A total of 579 isolates from 124 different farms were characterised. These included 519 isolates from sheep, 52 isolates from cattle and 8 isolates from goats. The potential virulence of the isolates was assessed by the gelatin gel test (GG-test) and the elastin agar test, that test the heat stability and elastase activity of bacterial proteases, respectively. The isolates were also tested for the presence of intA by PCR, and allocated to serogroups by differentiation of fimA variants using multiplex PCR or sequencing. Thirty of the isolates were also serogrouped by slide agglutination. Three hundred and five isolates were defined as virulent by the GG-test. All these were from sheep from 52 farms located in the county of Rogaland in the south west of Norway. All isolates from cattle and goats were defined as benign by the GG-test. IntA was only detected in 6 (2.0%) of the virulent isolates. All serogroups except D and F were detected. Three hundred and seventy-two (64.3%) of the isolates belonged to serogroup A, and 96% of the virulent isolates belonged to this serogroup. On the grounds that virulent isolates were only found in one county, and that the majority belonged to the same serogroup (A), it is believed that a virulent D. nodosus strain was introduced to Norway relatively recently and that so far it has only spread locally.

The AprV5 subtilase is required for the optimal processing of all three extracellular serine proteases from Dichelobacter nodosus

Dichelobacter nodosus is the principal causative agent of ovine footrot and its extracellular proteases are major virulence factors. Virulent isolates of D. nodosus secrete three subtilisin-like serine proteases: AprV2, AprV5 and BprV. These enzymes are each synthesized as precursor molecules that include a signal (pre-) peptide, a pro-peptide and a C-terminal extension, which are processed to produce the mature active forms. The function of the C-terminal regions of these proteases and the mechanism of protease processing and secretion are unknown. AprV5 contributes to most of the protease activity secreted by D. nodosus. To understand the role of the C-terminal extension of AprV5, we constructed a series of C-terminal-deletion mutants in D. nodosus by allelic exchange. The proteases present in the resultant mutants and their complemented derivatives were examined by protease zymogram analysis, western blotting and mass spectrometry. The results showed that the C-terminal region of AprV5 is required for the normal expression of protease activity, deletion of this region led to a delay in the processing of these enzymes. D. nodosus is an unusual bacterium in that it produces three closely related extracellular serine proteases. We have now shown that one of these enzymes, AprV5, is responsible for its own maturation, and for the optimal cleavage of AprV2 and BprV, to their mature active forms. These studies have increased our understanding of how this important pathogen processes these virulence-associated extracellular proteases and secretes them into its external environment.

Comparative study of the commonly used virulence tests for laboratory diagnosis of ovine footrot caused by Dichelobacter nodosus in Australia

Footrot in sheep and goats is expressed as a spectrum of clinical entities ranging from benign, which is a self limiting interdigital dermatitis to highly virulent, in which severe under running of the horn of the hoof occurs. Interactions between the host, the virulence of the causative strain of Dichelobacter nodosus and environmental conditions determine the severity of the disease. Clinical diagnosis of virulent footrot, which a notifiable disease in some states of Australia, is not always straightforward. Therefore, the gelatin gel and elastase tests for protease activity, and the intA PCR test for an inserted genetic element in D. nodosus are commonly used to support or to confirm a clinical diagnosis. A comparative study of these laboratory tests with a large number of samples collected from 12 flocks of sheep with clinically virulent footrot was conducted. Based on the elastase test, 64% of the isolates tested were classified as virulent compared to 91% on the gelatin gel test and 41% according to the intA test. The agreement between the elastase and the gelatin gel test was low (kappa=0.12) as were the agreements between other tests. Only about 21% of the isolates were virulent in all 3 tests. Therefore these tests on their own may not provide standard and reliable results and are likely to remain as supplementary tests for clinical diagnosis of the disease.

S1 pocket of a bacterially derived subtilisin-like protease underpins effective tissue destruction

The ovine footrot pathogen, Dichelobacter nodosus, secretes three subtilisin-like proteases that play an important role in the pathogenesis of footrot through their ability to mediate tissue destruction. Virulent and benign strains of D. nodosus secrete the basic proteases BprV and BprB, respectively, with the catalytic domain of these enzymes having 96% sequence identity. At present, it is not known how sequence variation between these two putative virulence factors influences their respective biological activity. We have determined the high resolution crystal structures of BprV and BprB. These data reveal that that the S1 pocket of BprV is more hydrophobic but smaller than that of BprB. We show that BprV is more effective than BprB in degrading extracellular matrix components of the host tissue. Mutation of two residues around the S1 pocket of BprB to the equivalent residues in BprV dramatically enhanced its proteolytic activity against elastin substrates. Application of a novel approach for profiling substrate specificity, the Rapid Endopeptidase Profiling Library (REPLi) method, revealed that both enzymes prefer cleaving after hydrophobic residues (and in particular P1 leucine) but that BprV has more restricted primary substrate specificity than BprB. Furthermore, for P1 Leu-containing substrates we found that BprV is a significantly more efficient enzyme than BprB. Collectively, these data illuminate how subtle changes in D. nodosus proteases may significantly influence tissue destruction as part of the ovine footrot pathogenesis process.

A method to differentiate between virulent and benign isolates ofBacteroides nodosusbased on the thermal stability of their extracellular proteinases

A rapid modification of the hide powder azure proteinase degrading test was devised to distinguish between benign and virulent strains of Bucteroides nodosus grown as cultures on either liquid or solid media. The assay was based on the difference in stability, at 60 degrees C, of the enzymes released in the growth medium. The assay can be completed in four hours. Results for ovine virulent strains and their culture variants were similar and were clearly distinguishable from those of the ovine benign, bovine, deer and goat isolates which were similar to each other. The proteinase isozymes from cultures of the deer and goat isolates were separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and their molecular weights determined.

The subtilisin-like protease AprV2 is required for virulence and uses a novel disulphide-tethered exosite to bind substrates

Many bacterial pathogens produce extracellular proteases that degrade the extracellular matrix of the host and therefore are involved in disease pathogenesis. Dichelobacter nodosus is the causative agent of ovine footrot, a highly contagious disease that is characterized by the separation of the hoof from the underlying tissue. D. nodosus secretes three subtilisin-like proteases whose analysis forms the basis of diagnostic tests that differentiate between virulent and benign strains and have been postulated to play a role in virulence. We have constructed protease mutants of D. nodosus; their analysis in a sheep virulence model revealed that one of these enzymes, AprV2, was required for virulence. These studies challenge the previous hypothesis that the elastase activity of AprV2 is important for disease progression, since aprV2 mutants were virulent when complemented with aprB2, which encodes a variant that has impaired elastase activity. We have determined the crystal structures of both AprV2 and AprB2 and characterized the biological activity of these enzymes. These data reveal that an unusual extended disulphide-tethered loop functions as an exosite, mediating effective enzyme-substrate interactions. The disulphide bond and Tyr92, which was located at the exposed end of the loop, were functionally important. Bioinformatic analyses suggested that other pathogenic bacteria may have proteases that utilize a similar mechanism. In conclusion, we have used an integrated multidisciplinary combination of bacterial genetics, whole animal virulence trials in the original host, biochemical studies, and comprehensive analysis of crystal structures to provide the first definitive evidence that the extracellular secreted proteases produced by D. nodosus are required for virulence and to elucidate the molecular mechanism by which these proteases bind to their natural substrates. We postulate that this exosite mechanism may be used by proteases produced by other bacterial pathogens of both humans and animals.

Diagnostic sampling strategies for virulent ovine footrot: simulating detection of Dichelobacter nodosus serogroups for bivalent vaccine formulation

Dichelobacter nodosus is a slow-growing anaerobic bacterium that is the causative agent of virulent ovine footrot. Vaccination targeted at up to two specific serogroups can eliminate those serogroups from infected flocks, but requires identification of serogroups present in infected flocks. Serogroups can be identified using slide agglutination or polymerase chain reaction (PCR) methods. The objectives of this project were to use stochastic simulation modeling to estimate the efficacy of sampling strategies encompassing 5-40 sheep per flock and 2-4 colonies per sheep, and to compare efficacies based on slide agglutination or multiplex PCR test results. Foot swabs collected from sheep in 12 flocks were used as the basis for a sampling strategy simulation model. None of the evaluated sampling strategies identified the two most common serogroups in the flock, or all serogroups present in the flock, in 95% of iterations. However, a simulated sample of 22 sheep/flock and 2 colonies/sheep resulted in a simulated vaccine that protected 95% of the sheep that could be protected by a single bivalent vaccine, while a sample of 24 sheep/flock and 2 colonies/sheep resulted in a series of simulated bivalent vaccines that protected 95% of diseased infected sheep. The difference in outcome was due to the distribution and frequency of serogroups within certain flocks where some serogroups were uncommon and others dominant. A sampling strategy (>40 sheep/flock, 4 colonies/sheep) that will identify the two most common serogroups in a flock 95% of the time may not be cost effective. Evaluating efficacy based on the expected effect on the flock may be more useful than one which seeks to determine the most common serogroups. These findings are broadly applicable to diseases where more than one strain or type of pathogen may be present and must be represented in a vaccine.

Crystallization of the virulent and benign subtilisin-like proteases from the ovine footrot pathogen Dichelobacter nodosus

Dichelobacter nodosus is the principal causative agent of ovine footrot, a disease of significant economic importance to the sheep industry. D. nodosus secretes a number of subtilisin-like serine proteases which mediate tissue damage and presumably contribute to the pathogenesis of footrot. Strains causing virulent footrot secrete the proteases AprV2, AprV5 and BprV and strains causing benign footrot secrete the closely related proteases AprB2, AprB5 and BprB. Here, the cloning, purification and crystallization of AprV2, AprB2, BprV and BprB are reported. Crystals of AprV2 and AprB2 diffracted to 2.0 and 1.7 A resolution, respectively. The crystals of both proteases belonged to space group P1, with unit-cell parameters a = 43.1, b = 46.0, c = 47.2 A, alpha = 97.8, beta = 115.2, gamma = 115.2 degrees for AprV2 and a = 42.7, b = 45.8, c = 45.7 A, alpha = 98.4, beta = 114.0, gamma = 114.6 degrees for AprB2. Crystals of BprV and BprB diffracted to 2.0 and 1.8 A resolution, respectively. The crystals of both proteases belonged to space group P2(1), with unit-cell parameters a = 38.5, b = 89.6, c = 47.7 A, beta = 113.6 degrees for BprV and a = 38.5, b = 90.5, c = 44.1 A, beta = 109.9 degrees for BprB. The crystals of all four proteases contained one molecule in the asymmetric unit, with a solvent content ranging from 36 to 40%.

Twitching motility is essential for virulence in Dichelobacter nodosus

Type IV fimbriae are essential virulence factors of Dichelobacter nodosus, the principal causative agent of ovine foot rot. The fimA fimbrial subunit gene is required for virulence, but fimA mutants exhibit several phenotypic changes and it is not certain if the effects on virulence result from the loss of type IV fimbria-mediated twitching motility, cell adherence, or reduced protease secretion. We showed that mutation of either the pilT or pilU gene eliminated the ability to carry out twitching motility. However, the pilT mutants displayed decreased adhesion to epithelial cells and reduced protease secretion, whereas the pilU mutants had wild-type levels of extracellular protease secretion and adherence. These data provided evidence that PilT is required for the type IV fimbria-dependent protease secretion pathway in D. nodosus. It was postulated that sufficient fimbrial retraction must occur in the pilU mutants to allow protease secretion, but not twitching motility, to take place. Although no cell movement was detected in a pilU mutant of D. nodosus, aberrant motion was detected in an equivalent mutant of Pseudomonas aeruginosa. These observations explain how in D. nodosus protease secretion can occur in a pilU mutant but not in a pilT mutant. In addition, virulence studies with sheep showed that both the pilT and pilU mutants were avirulent, providing evidence that mutation of the type IV fimbrial system affects virulence by eliminating twitching motility, not by altering cell adherence or protease secretion.

Type IV fimbrial biogenesis is required for protease secretion and natural transformation in Dichelobacter nodosus

The objective of this study was to develop an understanding of the molecular mechanisms by which type IV fimbrial biogenesis, natural transformation, and protease secretion are linked in the ovine foot rot pathogen, Dichelobacter nodosus. We have shown that like the D. nodosus fimbrial subunit FimA, the pilin-like protein PilE and the FimN, FimO, and FimP proteins, which are homologs of PilB, PilC, and PilD from Pseudomonas aeruginosa, are essential for fimbrial biogenesis and natural transformation, indicating that transformation requires an intact type IV fimbrial apparatus. The results also showed that extracellular protease secretion in the fimN, fimO, fimP, and pilE mutants was significantly reduced, which represents the first time that PilB, PilC, and PilE homologs have been shown to be required for the secretion of unrelated extracellular proteins in a type IV fimbriate bacterium. Quantitative real-time PCR analysis of the three extracellular protease genes aprV2, aprV5, and bprV showed that the effects on protease secretion were not mediated at the transcriptional level. Bioinformatic analysis did not identify a classical type II secretion system, and the putative fimbrial biogenesis gene pilQ was the only outer membrane secretin gene identified. Based on these results, it is postulated that in D. nodosus, protease secretion occurs by a type II secretion-related process that directly involves components of the type IV fimbrial biogenesis machinery, which represents the only type II secretion system encoded by the small genome of this highly evolved pathogen.

Regulation of type IV fimbrial biogenesis in Dichelobacter nodosus

Type IV fimbriae are expressed by several bacterial pathogens and are essential for virulence in Dichelobacter nodosus, which causes ovine footrot. We have identified a two-component signal transduction system (PilR/S) and an alternative sigma factor (sigma 54) that were shown by insertional inactivation to be required for the regulation of fimbrial biogenesis in D. nodosus. Western blots showed that in both pilR and rpoN mutants, fimbrial subunit production was significantly reduced by a process that was shown to occur at a PilR- and sigma 54-dependent promoter. The mutants lacked surface fimbriae, which were shown to be required for the adherence of D. nodosus cells to tissue culture monolayers. The reduction in fimbrial subunit production in these mutants also resulted in a concomitant loss of the ability to secrete extracellular proteases. A maltose binding protein-PilR fusion protein was purified and was shown to bind specifically to a region located 234 to 594 bp upstream of the fimA transcriptional start point. To determine additional targets of PilR and sigma 54, genome-wide transcriptional profiling was performed using a whole-genome oligonucleotide microarray. The results indicated that PilR and sigma 54 regulated genes other than fimA; these genes appear to encode surface-exposed proteins whose role in virulence is unknown. In conclusion, this study represents a significant advancement in our understanding of how the ability of D. nodosus to cause ovine footrot is regulated, as we have shown that the biogenesis of type IV fimbriae in D. nodosus is regulated by a sigma 54-dependent PilR/S system that also indirectly controls protease secretion.

Current understanding of the aetiology and laboratory diagnosis of footrot

Footrot is a highly contagious disease of the feet of ruminants caused by the synergistic action of certain bacterial species of which Dichelobacter nodosus (D. nodosus) is the main transmitting agent. The infection is specific to sheep and goats, although it has also been reported in cattle, horses, pigs, deer and mouflon. The antigenic diversity of D. nodosus is due to variations in the DNA sequence of its fimbrial subunit gene (fimA) and provides the basis for classification of the organism into at least 10 major serogroups (A-I and M), the distribution of which varies with different geographical locations. Host immune response to vaccination is serogroup specific. There are three different clinical forms of disease caused by virulent, intermediate and benign strains of D. nodosus, respectively. In order to facilitate rapid and reliable clinical diagnosis, virulence determination, strain differentiation and serogroup identification for effective control measures, immunological tests, DNA probes and PCR based techniques have been introduced. This review summarises the current understanding of the mechanisms of antigenic diversity of D. nodosus as well as advances made in its strain differentiation and diagnosis.

Identification of a Dichelobacter nodosus ferric uptake regulator and determination of its regulatory targets

The expression of iron regulated genes in bacteria is typically controlled by the ferric uptake regulator (Fur) protein, a global transcriptional repressor that regulates functions as diverse as iron acquisition, oxidative stress, and virulence. We have identified a fur homologue in Dichelobacter nodosus, the causative agent of ovine footrot, and shown that it complements an Escherichia coli fur mutant. Homology modeling of the D. nodosus Fur protein with the recently solved crystal structure of Fur from Pseudomonas aeruginosa indicated extensive structural conservation. As Southern hybridization analysis of different clinical isolates of D. nodosus indicated that the fur gene was present in all of these strains, the fur gene was insertionally inactivated to determine its functional role. Analysis of these mutants by various techniques did not indicate any significant differences in the expression of known virulence genes or in iron-dependent growth. However, we determined several Fur regulatory targets by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis coupled with mass spectrometry. Analysis of proteins from cytoplasmic, membrane, and extracellular fractions revealed numerous differentially expressed proteins. The transcriptional basis of these differences was analyzed by using quantitative reverse transcriptase PCR. Proteins with increased expression in the fur mutant were homologues of the periplasmic iron binding protein YfeA and a cobalt chelatase, CbiK. Down-regulated proteins included a putative manganese superoxide dismutase and ornithine decarboxylase. Based on these data, it is suggested that in D. nodosus the Fur protein functions as a regulator of iron and oxidative metabolism.

Current approaches to the management of ovine footrot

Ovine footrot remains the most important cause of lameness in sheep flocks in the UK, despite the existence of proven methods for the control of the disease. Recent research suggests that sheep farmers may be unaware of these methods and may allocate greater resources to treatment of footrot rather than to its prevention. Foot paring, topical treatments, vaccination and parenteral antibiotic therapy all have a role in treating sheep with advanced footrot infections, but prevention of severe infections is best achieved by the timely implementation of control programmes. These are usually based on footbathing and vaccination. For control programmes to be effective it is essential that the pathogenesis and epidemiology of footrot is understood and that control methods are implemented at appropriate times in the season, depending on climatic and pasture conditions. This article reviews these strategies and makes recommendations for steps to reduce the spread of footrot between flocks and to reduce the incidence of footrot within UK flocks.

Aetiology of ovine footrot in the Portuguese region of Alto Alentejo

In this work, we found it appropriate to carry out a study directed towards isolating and identifying the entailed microorganisms which trigger off footrot in sheep, placing special emphasis on the serotipification of the different Dichelobacter nodosus species. With this goal in mind four flocks from the Portuguese region of 'Alto Alentejo' were selected, all of them had one common feature: their main health problem was ovine footrot. We also set out to determine the elastolitic capacity of isolated strict-anaerobic bacteria, in order to be able to clarify the direct involvement of these microorganisms in the outbreak of this infectious process.

The type IV fimbrial subunit gene (fimA) of Dichelobacter nodosus is essential for virulence, protease secretion, and natural competence

Dichelobacter nodosus is the essential causative agent of footrot in sheep. The major D. nodosus-encoded virulence factors that have been implicated in the disease are type IV fimbriae and extracellular proteases. To examine the role of the fimbriae in virulence, allelic exchange was used to insertionally inactivate the fimA gene, which encodes the fimbrial subunit protein, from the virulent type G D. nodosus strain VCS1703A. Detailed analysis of two independently derived fimA mutants revealed that they no longer produced the fimbrial subunit protein or intact fimbriae and did not exhibit twitching motility. In addition, these mutants were no longer capable of undergoing natural transformation and did not secrete wild-type levels of extracellular proteases. These effects were not due to polar effects on the downstream fimB gene because insertionally inactivated fimB mutants were not defective in any of these phenotypic tests. Virulence testing of the mutants in a sheep pen trial conducted under controlled environmental conditions showed that the fimA mutants were avirulent, providing evidence that the fimA gene is an essential D. nodosus virulence gene. These studies represent the first time that molecular genetics has been used to determine the role of virulence genes in this slow growing anaerobic bacterium.

Pilus ELISA and an anamnestic test for the diagnosis of virulent ovine footrot and its application in a disease control program in Nepal

The immunological memory (anamnestic) responses in sheep recovered from virulent footrot (VFR) can be aroused by subcutaneous injection of outer membrane protein (OMP) antigens of Dichelobacter nodosus. The magnitude of this response is directly correlated to the highest antibody response attained during infection and memory lasts at least a year after recovery from VFR. However, some older animals show non-specific responses to OMP antigens. In this study an evaluation of D. nodosus pilus antigen for the anamnestic diagnosis of footrot in sheep was undertaken. The results indicated that the primary and anamnestic responses to pilus were similar in character to OMP antigen but were highly specific. The sensitivity of the procedure for detection of sheep with a history of VFR was approximately 80%. A low proportion of sheep with mild lesions due to virulent strains of D. nodosus reacted to anamnestic challenge. Anamnestic challenge with 10 microg pilus was used in a VFR surveillance program in migratory sheep flocks in Nepal. Conventional diagnostic methods could not be applied during the disease transmission periods in these flocks because of their migration to alpine pastures far away from human habitation. The results supported clinical and bacteriological findings suggesting that virulent strains of D. nodosus have apparently been eliminated from these flocks in Nepal.

Transmission of virulent footrot between sheep and goats

OBJECTIVE

To determine the infectivity of ovine and caprine strains of Dichelobacter nodosus for both sheep and goats.

DESIGN

Pen experiments in which 20 sheep and 19 goats were challenged directly with the two strains, and transmission experiments on pasture, using donors infected by experimental challenge.

RESULTS

Sheep and goat strains of D nodosus infected both animal species in experimental challenges. Animals so infected transmitted footrot to both sheep and goats on pasture plots. A significantly smaller proportion of goats than sheep was infected when challenged with either strain. The interval between exposure and development of footrot in goats was longer than in sheep when recipient animals were exposed to infected donors on pasture. The disease was less invasive in goats than in sheep.

CONCLUSIONS

With the strains of D nodosus used there was no evidence of host specificity. Direct transmission of footrot can occur between sheep and goats in the same environment. There is a need to include goats in ovine footrot eradication programs and vice versa.

Improved laboratory diagnosis of ovine footrot: an update

Ovine footrot is a complex clinical disease syndrome primarily resulting from infection by the anaerobic bacterium Dichelobacter nodosus. In order to aid clinical diagnosis, various laboratory tests based on the detection and measurements of phenotypic properties of D. nodosus have been developed for genus-specific detection as well as virulence determination. However, these tests are generally time-consuming, and tend to be variable with external factors that affect the growth and metabolism of the bacterium. A new generation of diagnostic reagents, such as monoclonal antibodies, gene probes and polymerase chain reaction, has been developed recently. Preliminary assessment of these reagents has shown potential to vastly improve the laboratory identification and determination of the virulence of D. nodosus. It is important that these new reagents are vigorously assessed against existing laboratory tests, such as the elastase test and gelatin gel test, prior to their adoption for the routine diagnosis of footrot.

Comparison of gene probe and conventional methods for the differentiation of ovine footrot isolates of Dichelobacter nodosus

In a collaborative study that involved four Australian veterinary diagnostic laboratories a gene probe test based on the recombinant plasmids pJIR318, pJIR314B, and pJIR313, which contain genomic vap or vrl regions, was compared with conventional tests used for the differential diagnosis of ovine footrot. A total of 771 clinical dichelobacter nodosus isolates were tested and designated as belonging to one of several gene probe categories. The results showed that 87% of the virulent isolates belonged to gene probe category 1, compared to only 6% of the benign isolates. It was concluded that there was good correlation between the gene probe test and the virulence designation of these isolates as well as the results of elastase, gelatin-gel and protease isoenzyme tests. Furthermore, the gene probe test was converted to a polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based test. It is suggested that diagnostic laboratories consider carrying out both this PCR test and tests based on the extracellular proteases of D. nodosus.

Assessment of gelatin gel and elastase tests for detection of protease activity of Dichelobacter nodosus isolates from ovine footrot

Protease tests (the gelatin gel protease thermostability test, the elastase test or both) were performed on 4296 isolates of Dichelobacter nodosus derived from 452 outbreaks of ovine footrot occurring in New South Wales. Both tests showed a high level of repeatability. In the gelatin gel test, culture broths were heated for 16 min at 66.8 degrees C. Heated broths containing thermostable protease digested gelatin (positive gelatin gel test) while those broths containing thermolabile protease failed to digest gelatin (negative gelatin gel test). Gelatin gel positive isolates were unable to be graded into subcategories on the basis of the percentage stability of their protease. In the elastase test, the ability of isolates to digest (positive elastase test) or not digest elastin particles (negative test) was measured up to 28 days incubation. Individual elastase positive isolates yielded a graded result based on the number of days to reach a positive result. There was a very high level of agreement between the gelatin gel and the elastase tests consistent with their separating isolates into two groups based on protease activity (either gelatin gel positive and elastase positive or gelatin gel negative and elastase negative). Either test is suitable for use in footrol control and eradication schemes. The gelatin gel test provides clearcut separation of isolates into positive and negative categories and has the major advantage of yielding a more rapid result than the elastase test. The elastase test should be utilised where a graded assessment of protease activity is desired.

A single amino-acid change between the antigenically different extracellular serine proteases V2 and B2 from Dichelobacter nodosus

Dichelobacter nodosus (Dn), the causative organism of ovine footrot, secrets three distinct types of extracellular serine proteases which have been implicated in virulence. Southern analyses have shown that the proteases are encoded by three separate genes, and the genes encoding an acidic protease V5 and a basic protease have already been characterised from virulent Dn strain 198. The gene encoding the third protease type, as represented by acidic protease V2, was isolated from an EcoRI-BamHI library of strain 198 genomic DNA by probing with a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) fragment generated with oligodeoxyribonucleotides based on protease V2 amino acid (aa) sequences. A further clone from an RsaI library was isolated to complete the 5' region of the gene to yield an ORF of 1803 bp encoding a protein precursor of 601 aa. The acidic protease V2 gene, aprV2, shows the same precursor structure as the bprV and aprV5 genes with 72% and 69% similarity at the nucleotide (nt) level and with 73% and 69% similarity at the aa level, respectively. As monoclonal antibodies consistently distinguish the virulent (V) and benign (B) forms of this protease, the gene encoding the acidic protease B2 from benign Dn strain 305 was isolated using the PCR and characterized to investigate the molecular basis for this difference in antigenicity. A 2-bp substitution in a single codon was identified which appeared to be responsible for a change of epitope.

Relationship between clinical manifestations of footrot and specific DNA products of Dichelobacter nodosus amplified through PCR

A total of 141 Dichelobacter nodosus isolates from 46 merino sheep farms with various clinical forms of footrot was examined by the gelatin gel test and the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using virulent (Vf2 and Vr2) and benign (Bf and Br) specific primers. Isolates from sheep with virulent and high intermediate footrot usually produced relatively thermostable proteases, but a decreasing proportion of the isolates from sheep with medium and low intermediate or benign footrot had thermostable proteases, as determined by the gelatin gel test. The amplification by PCR of a major band of 857 bp by Vf2 and Vr2 was often associated with isolates from the more virulent forms of footrot whereas the presence of a major band of 1300 bp by Vf2 and Vr2 and/or a band of 609 bp by Bf and Br was associated with isolates from less virulent forms of footrot. Nevertheless, the virulent and benign gene regions represented by Vf2 and Vr2 and Bf and Br are only two of the many factors involved in determining the virulence of D nodosus. As a result the relationship observed between the clinical manifestations of footrot and specific DNA products amplified by PCR was not complete.

A retrospective study of clinical and laboratory characteristics of ovine footrot

The infection of the feet of sheep by the anaerobic bacterium Dichelobacter nodosus results in a spectrum of diseases ranging from virulent through intermediate to benign footrot. By examining the clinical characteristics of various forms of footrot from 22 properties in Victoria, Australia in association with the results of several laboratory tests including the gene probe-based dot blot hybridisation, it was shown that virulent footrot could not be differentiated from intermediate footrot using the clinical characteristics alone. In addition, D. nodosus isolates from sheep with benign footrot as diagnosed by the clinical manifestations might in fact show characteristics associated with those causing virulent, intermediate or benign footrot as determined by the laboratory tests. Although the elastase test, gelatin gel test and dot blot were in agreement with isolates from 9 of the 22 properties under investigation, they displayed differences from one another in many other cases, especially those with clinical benign footrot. The results of the elastase test appeared to be slightly closer to those of the dot blot compared with the gelatin gel test. Like any other tests based on the measurements of phenotypic characteristics of D. nodosus bacteria, the elastase test and gelatin gel test are subject to changes with factors that affect bacterial growth and metabolism. The use of DNA based detection methods would eliminate many of the problems associated with the conventional tests for differentiating strains causing virulent, intermediate and benign footrot.

Development of gene probes of Dichelobacter nodosus for differentiating strains causing virulent, intermediate or benign ovine footrot

Seven Dichelobacter nodosus genomic DNA clones including six specific for virulent and one for benign strains were identified. A collection of 96 footrot isolates, which in turn comprised 27 virulent isolates showing elastase activity at 7 days, 25 high intermediate isolates with elastase activity at 14 days, 24 low intermediate isolates with elastase activity at 21-28 days and 20 benign isolates with no elastase activity at up to 28 days, were used to assess these clones. Of the six virulent specific clones, five (pV238-83, pV405-239, pV470-65, pV470-145 and pV470-178) reacted with 27 virulent isolates, and 12 of 25 high intermediate isolates, but none of 24 low intermediate isolates and 20 benign isolates in dot blot hybridization. The other virulent-specific clone (pV470-13) recognized all 27 virulent and 25 intermediate isolates, and 22 of 24 low intermediate isolates and three of 20 benign isolates in dot blot hybridization. By contrast, the benign-specific clone (pB645-335) detected all 20 benign isolates and 24 low intermediate isolates, and also 13 of 25 high intermediate isolates, but none of 27 virulent isolates in dot blot hybridization. Southern hybridization analysis indicated that whereas clones pV238-83, pV405-239 and pV470-178 bound a Sau3A band of 0.5 kb, clones pV470-65 and pV470-145 recognized two Sau3A bands of 0.7 and 0.5 kb in virulent strains of serogroups A to I. However, clone pV470-13 detected a Sau3A band pattern in virulent strains different from those recognized by the other five virulent specific-clones. Besides showing a distinct Sau3A band pattern in intermediate strains, pV470-13 also reacted with three benign strains that showed binding with it in dot blot hybridization. The benign-specific clone pV645-335 detected a Sau3A band of 0.5 kb in both intermediate and benign strains of serogroups A to I. Thus the combination of pV470-13 and pB645-335, or any other virulent-specific clone, would clearly differentiate among D. nodosus strains causing virulent, intermediate or benign footrot.

Cloning, sequence and expression of the gene (aprV5) encoding extracellular serine acidic protease V5 from Dichelobacter nodosus

The acidic protease V5-encoding gene (aprV5) from Gram- Dichelobacter nodosus virulent strain 198 was isolated from a cosmid bank by activity screening and sequenced. The 2371-bp nucleotide (nt) sequence contained an open reading frame coding for a protein precursor of 595 amino acid (aa) residues composed of a signal peptide, a pro-region, a mature active protease of 347 aa and a C-terminal extension region of 120 aa. The deduced aa sequence of the pre-pro-mature protease regions showed about 65% similarity to that of D. nodosus basic protease while the C-terminal extension region showed only about 26% similarity. The aprV5 gene, without its C-terminal extension region, was cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli. The acidic protease B5-encoding gene (aprB5) from non-virulent strain 305 was also cloned and sequenced. The aprB5 nt sequence showed 99% homology to that of aprV5 with two single-aa changes occurring in the precursor.

Dichelobacter nodosus: differentiation of virulent and benign strains by gene probe based dot blot hybridisation

Gene probes specific for benign and virulent strains of Dichelobacter nodosus were used in a dot blot hybridisation procedure involving 96 strains of D. nodosus isolated from cases of ovine footrot. The performance of the probes was compared with that of the elastase test. All 27 strains with elastase activity at 7 days and 12 of 25 strains with elastase activity at 14 days reacted with the virulent-specific probe. Twenty-four strains with elastase activity between 21-28 days, and 20 strains with negative elastase activity up to 28 days did not bind with this probe. On the other hand, the benign-specific probe failed to bind with the 27 strains with elastase activity at 7 days, and 13 of the 25 strains with elastase activity at 14 days but reacted with 20 of the 24 strains with elastase activity at 21-28 days, and 19 of the 20 strains with negative elastase activity up to 28 days. The 12 strains with elastase activity at 14 days which were detected by the virulent-specific probe were not those recognised by the benign-specific probe. The use of virulent and benign specific gene probes in combination provides a rapid and precise screening system for differentiation of virulent and higher intermediate footrot from benign and lower intermediate footrot.

Recombinant vaccines against ovine footrot

For the past 20 years footrot vaccines have evolved from simple bacterins to highly specific recombinant DNA (rDNA) fimbrial vaccines. The development of these vaccines has left a trail of discoveries, challenges and solutions; these processes continue as we move closer to understanding the requirements of a footrot vaccine. The initial whole cell vaccines were unsuccessful due to the short duration of immunity and incorporation of limited serotypes. A multistrain vaccine eliminated the problem of serotype inclusion, although the duration of immunity in many cases is still inadequate. The proteases of Dichelobacter nodosus appear to be cross protective; however, little is known of their ability to protect sheep against footrot. The major protective immunogen is the bacterial fimbriae, which also forms the basis for the K-agglutination serotyping system. K-agglutinin titre correlates directly with resistance to challenge. The protective fimbrial epitope is conformationally dependent, suggesting little advantage in the development of synthetic peptide vaccines. To enhance the efficiency of vaccine production D. nodosus fimbrial genes were eventually cloned and successfully expressed in Ps. aeruginosa. Monovalent vaccines based on recombinant fimbriae are omnipotent, inducing high levels of agglutinins and long lasting immunity. In multivalent vaccines, on the other hand, incorporation of each additional serogroup into the vaccine results in reduced efficacy both in terms of reduced K-agglutinin titres and reduced protection following challenge. The least effective are multivalent formulations representing all major serogroups. In addition, considerable genetic variation has been observed in the ability of sheep to respond optimally to each serogroup in a multivalent vaccine. Results show that the limitation of the sheep to mount an effective immune response, rather than the quality or quantity of the immunogen, limits the efficacy of current footrot vaccines. Studies are being undertaken to examine in detail the immune response of sheep to potentially highly effective footrot vaccines.