In vivo depletion of host CD4+ and CD8+ cells permits engraftment of bone marrow stem cells and tolerance induction with minimal conditioning

NK Cell and CD4+FoxP3+ Regulatory T Cell Based Therapies for Hematopoietic Stem Cell Engraftment

Allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) is a powerful therapy to treat multiple hematological diseases. The intensive conditioning regimens used to allow for donor hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) engraftment are often associated with severe toxicity, delayed immune reconstitution, life-threatening infections, and thus higher relapse rates. Additionally, due to the high incidence of graft versus host disease (GvHD), HCT protocols have evolved to prevent such disease that has a detrimental impact on antitumor and antiviral responses. Here, we analyzed the role of host T and natural killer (NK) cells in the rejection of donor HSC engraftment as well as the impact of donor regulatory T cells (Treg) and NK cells on HSC engraftment. We review some of the current strategies that utilize NK or Treg to improve allogeneic HCT therapy in order to accomplish better HSC engraftment and immune reconstitution and achieve a lower incidence of cancer relapse, opportunistic infections, and GvHD.

New strategies in immune tolerance induction

Induction of tolerance in clinical organ transplantation that will obviate the use of chronic immunosuppression and preserve host immune response to other antigens remains the goal of transplant research. The thymus plays a critical role in the ability of the immune system to discriminate between self- and nonself-antigens or harmful and harmless alloantigens. We now know that multiple factors determine how the immune system responds to a self-antigen or foreign antigen. These determinants include developmental stage of the host, stage of T-cell maturity, site of antigen encounter, type and maturity of antigen-presenting cells, and presence and type of costimulatory molecules. Our understanding of the mechanisms of T-cell interactions with peptide/ major histocompatibility complex in peripheral lymphoid organs has led to experiments that translate into peripheral T-cell tolerance. The induction of high-avidity peripheral alloreactive T cells in the early phase of organ transplantation makes it difficult to achieve long-term alloantigen-specific tolerance without the use of transient perioperative immunosuppression. Therefore, protocols that induce robust tolerance in rodent and nonhuman primate models involve the use of donor antigen combined with a short course of perioperative immunosuppression. These studies suggest that the underlying mechanisms of peripheral tolerance include deletion, anergy, immune deviation, and regulatory T cells. This review focuses on recent advances in tolerance induction in experimental animal models and discusses their relevance to the development of protocols for the induction and maintenance of clinical transplant tolerance.

Strategic nonmyeloablative conditioning: CD154:CD40 costimulatory blockade at primary bone marrow transplantation promotes engraftment for secondary bone marrow transplantation after engraftment failure

There is an increased risk of failure of engraftment following nonmyeloablative conditioning. Sensitization resulting from failed bone marrow transplantation (BMT) remains a major challenge for secondary BMT. Approaches to allow successful retransplantation would have significant benefits for BMT candidates living with chronic diseases. We used a mouse model to investigate the effect of preparative regimens at primary BMT on outcome for secondary BMT. We found that conditioning with TBI or recipient T cell lymphodepletion at primary BMT did not promote successful secondary BMT. In striking contrast, successful secondary BMT could be achieved in mice conditioned with anti-CD154 costimulatory molecule blockade at first BMT. Blockade of CD154 alone or combined with T cell depletion inhibits generation of the humoral immune response after primary BMT, as evidenced by abrogation of production of anti-donor Abs. The humoral barrier is dominant in sensitization resulting from failed BMT, because almost all CFSE-labeled donor cells were killed at 0.5 and 3 h in sensitized recipients in in vivo cytotoxicity assay, reflecting Ab-mediated cytotoxicity. CD154:CD40 costimulatory blockade used at primary BMT promotes allogeneic engraftment in secondary BMT after engraftment failure at first BMT. The prevention of generation of anti-donor Abs at primary BMT is critical for successful secondary BMT.

CD45 congenic bone marrow transplantation: evidence for T cell-mediated immunity

CD45 congenic mice have been used to study stem cell engraftment in the absence of alloreactivity. Recently, impaired engraftment was reported in this model and attributed to weak immune reactivity. We have confirmed that there is indeed low-level reactivity mediated by CD8(+) cells and alpha beta-TCR(+) T cells. B6 (CD45.2) recipients were conditioned with total body irradiation (TBI) and transplanted with increasing doses of B6 (CD45.1) bone marrow cells (BMCs). Although chimerism was present at 1 month in all recipients, durable engraftment did not occur with <150 cGy of TBI, emphasizing the importance of long-term follow-up in evaluating nonmyeloablative conditioning approaches. A single dose of cyclophosphamide on day 2 also significantly enhanced engraftment. When B6 TCR beta(-/-), TCR delta(-/-), or TCR beta(-/-)/delta(-/-) (CD45.2) mice were transplanted with CD45.1 bone marrow, significantly enhanced engraftment occurred in recipients lacking alpha beta-TCR(+) T cells (p < .00005). Similarly, removal of alpha beta-TCR(+) host T cells in wild-type recipients resulted in enhanced engraftment. Engraftment was also significantly increased in CD8(-/-) and CD4(-/-)/8(-/-) recipients (p < .0005). Taken together, these results demonstrate that alpha beta-TCR(+) and CD8(+) T cells play a critical role in regulating engraftment of CD45 congenic marrow and suggest that these cells are the main effector cells in low-level alloreactivity to the CD45 disparity.

Perspective: fundamental and clinical concepts on stem cell homing and engraftment: a journey to niches and beyond

In many ways, the homing of hematopoietic stem cells to bone marrow and other tissues defines these cells and their immediate and long-term fates Once homed, an inevitable series of proliferative and differentiative events presumptively follows. These comments, of course, hold for both homing to marrow, or alternatively, to other nonmarrow tissues. In this review, we will specifically focus on homing and engraftment to bone marrow because this is the best-studied and clinically applicable system.

Preconditioning of NOD mice with anti-CD8 mAb and costimulatory blockade enhances chimerism and tolerance and prevents diabetes, while depletion of alpha beta-TCR+ and CD4+ cells negates the effect

Bone marrow transplantation blocks diabetes pathogenesis and reverses autoimmunity in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice. However, there is a greater barrier to engraftment in the context of autoimmunity. In the present study, we characterized which recipient cells influence engraftment in prediabetic NOD mice, with the goal to replace myelotoxic conditioning with antigen-specific deletion of reactive host cells. Preconditioning of NOD mice with anti-CD8 and anti-CD154 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) synergistically enhanced engraftment and significantly reduced the minimum total body irradiation (TBI) dose for engraftment. Strikingly, preconditioning with anti-CD4 mAb significantly impaired engraftment, negating the beneficial effect of anti-CD8, and resulted in a requirement for more TBI-based conditioning compared with controls conditioned with TBI alone. Similarly, more TBI was required when anti-T-cell receptor beta (TCRbeta) mAb was administered as preconditioning. The addition of anti-CD152 to CD154 preconditioning abrogated the engraftment-enhancing effect of anti-CD154. Taken together, these data indicate a role for CD4+ regulatory T cells in vivo which require signaling via CD152 in the induction of chimerism and tolerance in NOD recipients. Notably, disease prevention and reversal of autoimmunity was absolutely correlated with the establishment of chimerism. These studies have important implications for the design of novel clinical approaches to treat type 1 diabetes.

Transplantation of hematopoietic stem cells for induction of unresponsiveness to organ allografts

Although it has been recognized since the early days of Owen and Medawar that engraftment of donor stem cells, induced in utero spontaneously or intentionally neonatally, results in life-long unresponsiveness to donor alloantigens. However, successful induction of transplantation tolerance in adult life still represents an unsolved problem. Engraftment of donor stem cells using conventional modalities involves intensive myeloablative or lymphoablative immunosuppression, which is associated with toxicity and mortality and such methods are not suitable for organ allograft recipients. In this chapter, we present an innovative approach for induction of donor-specific unresponsiveness to bone marrow and organ allografts without myeloablative conditioning. Our methods is based on cyclophosphamide-induced, alloantigen-primed lymphocyte depletion. Cyclophosphamide is administered 1 day following infusion of donor hematopoietic cells, thus eliminating predominantly host T lymphocytes reacting against donor cell challenge, and resulting in relative unresponsiveness to donor alloantigens. Subsequently, life-long tolerance to fully mismatched donor skin allografts can be accomplished by a second infusion of stem cells from the same donor, with donor T cells displacing residual alloreactive host cells that may have escaped deletion. Taken together, we believe that induction of true permanent and specific tolerance to organ allografts using donor hematopoietic cells could become a clinical reality in the foreseeable future.

Production of donor T cells is critical for induction of donor-specific tolerance and maintenance of chimerism

Nonmyeloablative conditioning has significantly reduced the morbidity associated with bone marrow transplantation. The donor hemopoietic cell lineage(s) responsible for the induction and maintenance of tolerance in nonmyeloablatively conditioned recipients is not defined. In the present studies we evaluated which hemopoietic stem cell-derived components are critical to the induction of tolerance in a total body irradiation-based model. Recipient B10 mice were pretreated with mAbs and transplanted with allogeneic B10.BR bone marrow after conditioning with 100-300 cGy total body irradiation. The proportion of recipients engrafting increased in a dose-dependent fashion. All chimeric recipients exhibited multilineage donor cell production. However, induction of tolerance correlated strictly with early production of donor T cells. The chimeras without donor T cells rejected donor skin grafts and demonstrated strong antidonor reactivity in vitro, while possessing high levels of donor chimerism. These animals lost chimerism within 8 mo. Differentiation into T cells was aborted at a prethymic stage in recipients that did not produce donor T cells. Moreover, donor Ag-driven clonal deletion of recipient T cells occurred only in chimeras with donor T cells. These results demonstrate that donor T cell production is critical in the induction of transplantation tolerance and the maintenance of durable chimerism. In addition, donor T cell production directly correlates with the deletion of potentially alloreactive cells.

A delay in bone marrow transplantation after partial conditioning improves engraftment1

BACKGROUND

In the present study we examined the effect of the timing of marrow infusion on engraftment in nonmyeloablatively conditioned mice.

METHODS

B10 mice were conditioned with decreasing doses of total body irradiation (TBI) and reconstituted with bone marrow cells (BMCs) from major histocompatibility complex-disparate donor B10.BR mice at 0 or 6 hr, or on days 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 8, and 12 with respect to TBI.

RESULTS

After undergoing conditioning with 700 cGy TBI and transplantation with 15 x 10(6) BMCs, 100% of recipients engrafted if the marrow was infused between 0 and 4 days after TBI. For lower doses of TBI, a delay in infusion of the marrow after TBI conditioning was associated with a significant increase in engraftment. Significantly less engraftment was achieved in animals conditioned with 600 cGy TBI if the marrow was infused at 0 or 6 hr compared with a 1- to 4-day delay. When the TBI was decreased to 500 cGy, engraftment occurred only when the transplant was performed between days 2 and 8. The highest proportion of recipients engrafted when the marrow was infused on day 4. This enhanced engraftment after a delay in marrow infusion is associated with a significant reduction in host mixed lymphocyte reaction reactivity and is correlated inversely with serum levels of interleukin-6 in the recipient.

CONCLUSIONS

These data demonstrate for the first time that a delay between conditioning and marrow infusion significantly improves allogeneic engraftment in nonmyeloablatively conditioned recipients and reduces the total conditioning required.

Nonhuman Primate Models for Islet Transplantation in Type 1 Diabetes Research

Insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus is an autoimmune disease that causes a progressive destruction of the pancreatic beta cells. As a result, the patient requires exogenous insulin to maintain normal blood glucose levels. Both the pancreas and the islets of Langerhans have been transplanted successfully in humans and in animal models, resulting in full normalization of glucose homeostasis. However, insulin independence, transient or persistent, was documented in only a small fraction of cases until recently. The chronic immunosuppression required to avoid immunological rejection appears to be toxic to the islets and adds the risk of lymphoproliferative disease reported earlier. For islet transplantation to become the method of choice, it is essential first to identify islet-friendly immunosuppressive regimens and/or to develop methods that induce donor-specific tolerance and improve islet isolation and transplantation protocols. Indeed, researchers have already successfully allografted islets in the presence of nonsteroidal immunosuppression in a process known as the Edmonton protocol. An alternative method, gene therapy, could replace these other methods and better meet the insulin requirement of an individual without requiring pancreatic or islet transplantation. This alternative, however, requires animal models to develop and test clinical protocols and to demonstrate the feasibility of preclinical trials. Nonhuman primates are ideally suited to achieve these goals. The efforts toward developing a nonhuman primate diabetic model with demonstrable insulin dependence are discussed and include pancreatic and islet transplant trials to reverse the diabetic state and achieve insulin independence. Also described are the various protocols that have been tested in primates to circumvent immunosuppression by using tolerance induction strategies in lieu of immunosuppression, thus exploring the field of donor-specific tolerance that extends beyond islet transplantation.

Normal donor bone marrow is superior to Flt3 ligand-mobilized bone marrow in prolonging heart allograft survival when combined with anti-CD40L (CD154)

Flt3 ligand (FL) administration markedly increases bone marrow (BM) stem cells and immature dendritic cells. We investigated the influence of CD40-CD40Ligand (CD154) pathway blockade on antidonor immunity, cytokine production, microchimerism and heart graft survival in BALB/c (H2d) recipients of fully allogeneic C57BL/10 (H2b) FL-mobilized BM (FL-BM) or normal BM. Anti-CD40L mAb strongly suppressed anti-donor T-cell proliferative responses in recipients of either normal or FL-BM, but was less efficient in inhibiting antidonor cytolytic T-cell (CTL) activity, especially in recipients of FL-BM. Interestingly, CD40L blockade was more effective in recipients of multiple compared with single donor BM infusions. Anti-donor cytokine responses revealed complete impairment of IFN-gamma, IL-4 and IL-10 production in recipients of normal BM and CD40L mAb. By contrast, and in agreement with the CTL data, mice given FL-BM retained ability to produce IFN-gamma CD40-CD40L blockade did not promote microchimerism, as evidenced by immunohistology and real time polymerase chain reaction. Nevertheless, anti-CD40L mAb enhanced heart allograft survival in recipients of FL-BM, but the effect was inferior to that achieved with normal BM. These data provide insight into the influence of growth factor-expanded donor BM and costimulation blockade on antidonor immune reactivity and transplant outcome. The comparatively poor outcome obtained using FL-BM plus anti-CD40L mAb in this model may be ascribed to the failure of effectively interdicting antidonor CTL activity.

CD8(+), alphabeta-TCR(+), and gammadelta-TCR(+) cells in the recipient hematopoietic environment mediate resistance to engraftment of allogeneic donor bone marrow

Historically, conditioning for engraftment of hematopoietic stem cells has been nonspecific. In the present study, we characterized which cells in the recipient hematopoietic microenvironment prevent allogeneic marrow engraftment. Mice defective in production of alphabeta-TCR(+), gammadelta-TCR(+), alphabeta- plus gammadelta-TCR(+), CD8(+), or CD4(+) cells were transplanted with MHC-disparate allogeneic bone marrow. Conditioning with 500 cGy total body irradiation (TBI) plus a single dose of cyclophosphamide (CyP) on day +2 establishes chimerism in normal recipients. When mice were conditioned with 300 cGy TBI plus a single dose of CyP on day +2, all engrafted, except wild-type controls and those defective in production of CD4(+) T cells. Mice lacking both alphabeta- and gammadelta-TCR(+) cells engrafted without conditioning, suggesting that both alphabeta- and gammadelta-TCR T cells in the host play critical and nonredundant roles in preventing engraftment of allogeneic bone marrow. CD8 knockout (KO) mice engrafted without TBI, but only if they received CyP on day +2 relative to the marrow infusion, showing that a CD8(-) cell was targeted by the CyP conditioning. The CD8(+) cell effector function is mechanistically different from that for conventional T cells, and independent of CD4(+) T helper cells because CD4 KO mice require substantially higher levels of conditioning than the other KO phenotypes. These results suggest that a number of cell populations with different mechanisms of action mediate resistance to engraftment of allogeneic marrow. Targeting of specific recipient cellular populations may permit conditioning approaches to allow mixed chimerism with minimal morbidity and could potentially avoid the requirement for myelotoxic agents altogether.

Mixed allogeneic chimerism and tolerance to composite tissue allografts

The development of effective immunosuppressive drugs has made solid organ allotransplantation the preferred approach for treatment of end-organ failure. The benefits of these immunosuppressants outweigh their risks in preventing rejection of lifesaving solid-organ allografts. On the contrary, composite tissue allotransplants are non-lifesaving and whether the risks of immunosuppressants justify their benefits is a subject of debate. Hence, composite tissue allografts (CTA) have not enjoyed widespread clinical application for reconstruction of large tissue defects. Therefore, a method of preventing rejection that would eliminate the need for toxic immunosuppressants is of particular importance in CTA. Bone marrow transplantation (BMT) to establish mixed chimerism induces tolerance to a variety of allografts in animal models. This article reviews mixed chimerism-based tolerance protocols. Their limitations and their relevance to CTA are discussed, highlighting some unique characteristics (high antigenicity and the presence of active bone marrow) that make CTAs different from solid organ allografts.

Allogeneic chimerism with low-dose irradiation, antigen presensitization, and costimulator blockade in H-2 mismatched mice

We have previously shown that the keys to high-level nontoxic chimerism in syngeneic models are stem cell toxic, nonmyelotoxic host treatment as provided by 100-cGy whole-body irradiation and relatively high levels of marrow stem cells. This approach was unsuccessful in H-2 mismatched B6.SJL to BALB/c marrow transplants, but with tolerization, stable multilineage chimerism was obtained. Ten million B6.SJL spleen cells were infused intravenously into BALB/c hosts on day -10 and (MR-1) anti-CD40 ligand monoclonal antibody (mAb) injected intraperitoneally at varying levels on days -10, -7, -3, 0, and +3 and the BALB/c mice irradiated (100 cGy) and infused with 40 million B6.SJL/H-2 mismatched marrow cells on day 0. Stable multilineage chimerism at levels between 30% to 40% was achieved in the great majority of mice at 1.6 mg anti-CD40 ligand mAb per injection out to 64 weeks after transplantation, without graft-versus-host disease. The transplanted mice were also tolerant of donor B6.SJL, but not third-party CBA/J skin grafts at 8 to 9 and 39 to 43 weeks after marrow transplantation. These data provide a unique model for obtaining stable partial chimerism in H-2 mismatched mice, which can be applied to various clinical diseases of man such as sickle cell anemia, thalassemia, and autoimmune disorders.

A partial conditioning approach to achieve mixed chimerism in the rat: depletion of host natural killer cells significantly reduces the amount of total body irradiation required for engraftment

BACKGROUND

Mixed allogeneic bone marrow chimerism induces tolerance to solid organ grafts. Although we previously reported that partially ablative conditioning with 700 cGy of total body irradiation (TBI) is sufficient to allow for bone marrow engraftment in mice, we determined that a minimum of 1000 cGy was required in the rat. Because T cells and NK cells are critical in bone marrow graft rejection, our purpose was to examine whether targeting of radioresistant NK cells and/or T cells in the recipient hematopoietic microenvironment would reduce the TBI dose required for engraftment of allogeneic rat bone marrow.

METHODS

Wistar Furth rats received either anti-NK3.2.3 monoclonal antibodies on days -3 and -2, anti-lymphocyte serum on day -5, a combination of both or no pretreatment. TBI was performed on day 0 and rats were reconstituted with 100x10(6) T cell-depleted bone marrow cells from ACI donors.

RESULTS

Engraftment of T cell-depleted rat bone marrow was readily achieved in animals conditioned with 1000 cGy TBI alone (12/12) and the level of donor chimerism averaged 89%. At 900 cGy TBI alone only one of eight recipients engrafted. In striking contrast, 11 of 12 animals pretreated with anti-NK monoclonal antibodies and irradiated with 900 cGy showed donor chimerism at a mean level of 41%. No further enhancement of bone marrow engraftment could be achieved when recipients were pretreated with antilymphocyte serum alone or antilymphocyte serum plus anti-NK monoclonal antibodies. Mixed allogeneic chimeras exhibited stable multilineage chimerism and donor-specific tolerance to subsequent cardiac allografts.

CONCLUSION

Specific targeting of radioresistant host NK cells allows for a significant reduction of the TBI dose required for allogeneic bone marrow engraftment.

Clinical applications of mixed chimerism

Bone marrow transplantation (BMT) is currently a procedure that is associated with high morbidity and mortality. Thus, the clinical application of this technique is limited to the treatment of life-threatening hematopoietic malignancies. The morbidity and mortality of BMT is mainly related to graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), failure of engraftment, and toxicity related to fully myeloablative conditioning. GVHD can be prevented by T-cell depletion. However, T-cell depletion increases the risk of failure of engraftment. With the identification of a facilitating cell population that enables engraftment of hematopoietic stem cells across major histocompatibility barriers, the dichotomy between GVHD and failure of engraftment has been resolved. If one could overcome the toxicity of conditioning with the development of partially ablative conditioning strategies, BMT could be used for the treatment of a variety of nonmalignant diseases, as well as in the induction of donor-specific transplantation tolerance. This review outlines the development and advantages of partially ablative conditioning strategies and illustrates possible applications of the technique. Forty years ago E.D. Thomas discussed the potential of BMT for treating immunodeficiencies and for the induction of transplantation tolerance. BMT can be viewed as a natural form of gene therapy to replace a defective cell or enzyme with a functional and normally regulated one.

Leukodystrophy and bone marrow transplantation: role of mixed hematopoietic chimerism

Bone Marrow Transplantation (BMT) is currently the most physiologic treatment for some types of leukodystrophies. In enzyme deficiency states, replacement of defective genes with cells carrying "normal" copies of these genes offers a natural form of gene therapy. This review will cover the various disease states which may be treated using bone marrow transplantation as well as the obstacles and advantages offered by this treatment modality. The potential for mixed hematopoietic chimerism, with reference to the advantages and disadvantages of treating various leukodystrophies, is reviewed. Finally, certain approaches which would reduce the morbidity and mortality associated with conventional BMT are discussed. If these obstacles can be overcome, BMT may offer the hope of cure to a number, but certainly not all, leukodystrophies.