Temporal and spatial expression of EmH-3, a homeobox-containing gene isolated from the freshwater sponge Ephydatia muelleri

Adhesion of freshwater sponge cells mediated by carbohydrate-carbohydrate interactions requires low environmental calcium

Marine ancestors of freshwater sponges had to undergo a series of physiological adaptations to colonize harsh and heterogeneous limnic environments. Besides reduced salinity, river-lake systems also have calcium concentrations far lower than seawater. Cell adhesion in sponges is mediated by calcium-dependent multivalent self-interactions of sulfated polysaccharide components of membrane-bound proteoglycans named aggregation factors. Cells of marine sponges require seawater average calcium concentration (10 mM) to sustain adhesion promoted by aggregation factors. We demonstrate here that the freshwater sponge Spongilla alba can thrive in a calcium-poor aquatic environment and that their cells are able to aggregate and form primmorphs with calcium concentrations 40-fold lower than that required by marine sponges cells. We also find that their gemmules need calcium and other micronutrients to hatch and generate new sponges. The sulfated polysaccharide purified from S. alba has sulfate content and molecular size notably lower than those from marine sponges. Nuclear magnetic resonance analyses indicated that it is composed of a central backbone of non- and 2-sulfated α- and β-glucose units decorated with branches of α-glucose. Assessments with atomic force microscopy/single-molecule force spectroscopy show that S. alba glucan requires 10-fold less calcium than sulfated polysaccharides from marine sponges to self-interact efficiently. Such an ability to retain multicellular morphology with low environmental calcium must have been a crucial evolutionary step for freshwater sponges to successfully colonize inland waters.

Elements of a 'nervous system' in sponges

Genomic and transcriptomic analyses show that sponges possess a large repertoire of genes associated with neuronal processes in other animals, but what is the evidence these are used in a coordination or sensory context in sponges? The very different phylogenetic hypotheses under discussion today suggest very different scenarios for the evolution of tissues and coordination systems in early animals. The sponge genomic 'toolkit' either reflects a simple, pre-neural system used to protect the sponge filter or represents the remnants of a more complex signalling system and sponges have lost cell types, tissues and regionalization to suit their current suspension-feeding habit. Comparative transcriptome data can be informative but need to be assessed in the context of knowledge of sponge tissue structure and physiology. Here, I examine the elements of the sponge neural toolkit including sensory cells, conduction pathways, signalling molecules and the ionic basis of signalling. The elements described do not fit the scheme of a loss of sophistication, but seem rather to reflect an early specialization for suspension feeding, which fits with the presumed ecological framework in which the first animals evolved.

NK homeobox genes with choanocyte-specific expression in homoscleromorph sponges

Data on nonbilaterian animals (sponges, cnidarians, and ctenophores) have suggested that Antennapedia (ANTP) class homeobox genes played a crucial role in the early diversification of animal body plans. Estimates of ancestral gene diversity within this important class of developmental regulators have been mostly based on recent analyses of the complete genome of a demosponge species, leading to the proposal that all ANTP families found in nonsponges animals (eumetazoans) derived from an ancestral "proto-NK" six-gene cluster. However, a single sponge species cannot reveal ancestral metazoan traits, in particular because lineage-specific gene duplications or losses are likely to have occurred during the long history of the Porifera. We thus looked for ANTP genes by degenerate polymerase chain reaction search in five species belonging to the Homoscleromorpha, a sponge lineage recently phylogenetically classified outside demosponges and characterized by unique histological features. We identified new genes of the ANTP class called HomoNK. Our phylogenetic analyses placed HomoNK (without significant support) close to the NK6 and NK7 families of cnidarian and bilaterian ANTP genes and did not recover the monophyly of the proposed "proto-NK" cluster. Our expression analyses of the HomoNK gene OlobNK in adult Oscarella lobularis showed that this gene is a strict marker of choanocytes, the most typical sponge cell type characterized by an apical flagellum surrounded by a collar of microvilli. These results are discussed in the light of the predominant neurosensory expression of NK6 and NK7 genes in bilaterians and of the recent proposal that choanocytes could be the sponge homologs of sensory cells.

Conservation and Phylogeny of a Novel Family of Non-Hox Genes of the Antp Class in Demospongiae (Porifera)

A survey across the most basal animal phylum, the Porifera, for the presence of homeobox-containing genes led to the isolation of 24 partial or complete homeobox sequences from 21 sponge species distributed in 15 families and 6 orders of Demospongiae. All the new sequences shared a high identity/similarity with EmH-3 (Ephydatia muelleri), a non-Hox gene from the Antp class. The Demox sequences, EmH-3, and related homeodomains formed a well-supported clade with no true affinity with any known bilaterian family, including the Tlx/Hox11 family, suggesting that the EmH-3 family of genes, comprising 31 members, represents a novel family of non-Hox genes, called the Demox family, widespread among Demospongiae. The presence of the Tlx/Hox11 specific signature in the Demox family and common regulatory elements suggested that the Demox and Tlx/Hox11 families are closely related. In the phylogenetic analyses, freshwater Haplosclerida appeared as monophyletic, and Haplosclerida and Halichondrida as polyphyletic, with a clade comprising Agelas species and Axinella corrugata. As for their expression, high levels of Demox transcripts were found in adult tissues. Our data add to the number of published poriferan homeobox sequences and provide independent confirmation of the current Demospongiae phylogenies.

Mineral skeletogenesis in sponges

Sponges secrete a variety of mineral skeletons consisting of calcite, aragonite, and (or) amorphous silica that confer strength and protect them from physical perturbations. Calcification takes place in a solution of bicarbonate and calcium ions, which is supersaturated with respect to both calcite and aragonite. In contrast, siliceous spicules are formed from an environment that is undersaturated with respect to silicon. Silification is the predominant process of biomineralization in extant sponges (92% of the species). The number of axes of symmetry in the large skeletal elements (megasclere spicules) is the main skeletal difference between the classes Hexactinellida (monaxons and triaxons) and Demospongiae (monaxons and tetraxons). Hypersilification occurs in both lithistid demosponges and hexactinellids, which are mostly confined to silicon-rich environments. Both siliceous and calcareous sponge skeletons are deposited within a well-defined restricted space by the so-called matrix-mediated mineralization. Both processes require organic molecules, which are secreted by a particular cell type (sclerocytes) and guide spicule formation. In most siliceous sponges, these molecules form a discrete filament, which is mainly triangular or quadrangular in cross section in demosponges and hexactinellids, respectively. No discrete axial filament has been reported for calcareous sponges. Silica polycondensation produces nanospheres to microspheres, which are arranged in concentric layers to form the spicules. The potential number of siliceous spicule types in a sponge species appears to be fixed genetically, but the environmental conditions (specifically the availability of silicon) may determine whether a genetically determined spicule type is finally expressed. In this study I review the current knowledge on sponge skeletogenesis, from molecular, cellular, and structural points of view. The contribution of environment variables, as well as the proliferation and decay of the main skeleton types in the past, are also considered.

Embryogenesis and larval differentiation in sponges

Having descended from the first multicellular animals on earth, sponges are a key group in which to seek innovations that form the basis of the metazoan body plan, but sponges themselves have a body plan that is extremely difficult to reconcile with that of other animals. Adult sponges lack overt anterior–posterior polarity and sensory organs, and whether they possess true tissues is even debated. Nevertheless, sexual reproduction occurs as in other metazoans, with the development of embryos through a structured series of cellular divisions and organized rearrangements of cellular material, using both mesenchymal and epithelial movements to form a multicellular embryo. In most cases, the embryo undergoes morphogenesis into a spatially organized larva that has several cell layers, anterior–posterior polarity, and sensory capabilities. Here we review original data on the mode of cleavage, timing of cellular differentiation, and the mechanisms involved in the organization of differentiated cells to form the highly structured sponge larva. Our ultimate goal is to develop interpretations of the phylogenetic importance of these data within the Porifera and among basal Metazoa.

Hox11L1 expression by precursors of enteric smooth muscle: an alternative explanation for megacecum in HOX11L1-/- mice

Previous studies have focused on expression of Hox11L1 in enteric neurons as the explanation for intestinal and urinary bladder dysmotility observed in mice that do not have the transcription factor. However, Hox11L1 is also expressed transiently in endo-, meso-, and ectodermal cells of the most caudal embryo during gastrulation. We sought to more fully characterize the fates of these cells because they might help explain the pathogenesis of lethal pseudo-obstruction in Hox11L1-null mice. The Cre recombinase cDNA was introduced into the Hox11L1 locus, and expression of the "knock-in" allele was used to activate the Rosa26R, beta-galactosidase reporter gene in cells with ongoing Hox11L1 transcription and their descendants. During gastrulation, Rosa26R activation was observed in progenitors of caudal somatic and visceral cells, including enteric smooth muscle. Expression in enteric neural precursors appeared much later. Analysis of endogenous Hox11L1 mRNA in aneuronal segments of large intestine that were grafted under the renal capsule indicated that the early activation of Hox11L1 in visceral mesoderm was transient and ceased before colonization of the large intestine by neural progenitors. Mice homozygous for the Cre allele died shortly after weaning, with cecal and proximal colonic distention but without overt anatomic defects that might represent maldevelopment of the visceral mesoderm. Our findings expand the range of possible functions of Hox11L1 to include activation of an as yet unknown developmental program in visceral smooth muscle and allow the possibility that intestinal dysmotility in Hox11L1-null animals may not be a primary neural disorder.

Isolation and expression analysis of a poriferan Antp-class Bar-/Bsh-like homeobox gene

A novel non- Hox Antp-class gene ( BarBsh- Hb) was isolated from the marine sponge Halichondria sp. This gene shares high sequence identity with eumetazoan genes from the Bsh and Bar gene families and can be distinguished from other non- Hox Antp-class genes by diagnostic residues. We also present an alignment of all known (full-length) poriferan non- Hox Antp-class genes. Maximum likelihood methods were employed to estimate phylogenetic relationships among non- Hox genes and BarBsh- Hb. We employed RT-PCR techniques to look at expression across different developmental stages (larval to rhagon). BarBsh- Hb product was present in newly released larvae, but expression was not detected 8-16 h post-release. Expression of BarBsh- Hb was detected in later-stage (>16 h post-release), free-swimming larvae until they settled and attached to the substratum, after which expression was down-regulated. In a separate set of experiments, low levels of expression were observed in normal adult tissue and disaggregated adult tissue, but BarBsh- Hb expression increased during tissue re-aggregation. These data increase the number of non- Hox homeobox genes identified in sponges and provide evidence of regulation of this non- Hox gene during sponge development. While the Bar and Bsh genes play important roles in the development of nervous tissue--especially visual systems--in metazoans, the specific role(s) BarBsh- Hb play(s) in sponge development is unclear and deserves greater attention.

The molecular basis for the evolution of the metazoan bodyplan: extracellular matrix-mediated morphogenesis in marine demosponges

Molecular data on development/differentiation and on comparative genomics allow insights into the genetic basis of the evolution of a bodyplan. Sponges (phylum Porifera) are animals that are the (still extant) stem group with the hypothetical Urmetazoa as the earliest common ancestor of all metazoans; they possess the basic features of the characteristic metazoan bodyplan also valid for the animals of the crown taxa. Here we describe three homeobox genes from the demosponge Suberites domuncula whose deduced proteins (HOXa1_SUBDO, HOXb1_SUBDO, HOXc1_SUBDO) are to be grouped with the Antennapedia class of homeoproteins (subclasses TIx-Hox11 and NK-2). In addition, a cDNA encoding a LIM/homeobox protein has been isolated which comprises high sequence similarity to the related LIM homeodomain (HD) proteins in its LIM as well as in its HD domains. To elucidate the potential function of these proteins in the sponge a new in vitro system was developed. Primmorphs which are formed from dissociated cells were grown on a homologous galectin matrix. This galectin cDNA was cloned and the recombinant protein was used for the preparation of the matrix. The galectin/polylysine matrix induced in primmorphs the formation of channels, one major morphogenetic process in sponges. Under such conditions the expression of the gene encoding the LIM/homeobox protein is strongly upregulated, while the expression of the other homeobox genes remains unchanged or is even downregulated. Competition experiments with galactosylceramides isolated from S. domuncula were performed. They revealed that a beta-galactosylceramide, named Sdgal-1, prevented the expression of the LIM gene on the galectin matrix, while Sdgal-2, a diglycosylceramide having a terminal alpha-glycosidically linked galactose, caused no effect on the formation of channels in primmorphs or on LIM expression. This study demonstrates for the first time that an extracellular matrix molecule, galectin, induces a morphogenetic process in sponges which is very likely caused by a LIM/homeobox protein. Furthermore, a new model is introduced (galectin-caused channel formation in sponge primmorphs) to investigate basic pathways, thus allowing new insights into the functional molecular evolution of Metazoa.

sine oculis in basal Metazoa

We report the recovery of homologs of Six1/2/sine oculis (so), a homeodomain-containing member of the Six-gene family, from a diverse set of basal Metazoa, including representatives of the poriferan classes Demospongia, Calcarea and Hexactinellida, the cnidarian classes Hydrozoa, Scyphozoa and Anthozoa, as well as a ctenophore. so sequences were also recovered from a platyhelminth, an echiurid and two bivalve molluscs, members of the super-phyletic group Lophotrochozoa. In the case of the platyhelminth, multiple distinct so sequences were recovered, as well as a member of the related group Six4/5/D-Six4. Extended sequences of the so gene were recovered from the demosponge, Haliclona sp., and the scyphozoan Aurelia aurita via PCR, and 3' RACE. The affinities of all recovered sequences were assessed using a parsimony analysis based on both nucleic and amino acid sequence and using successive character weighting. Our results indicate that so is highly conserved across the animal kingdom. Preliminary expression data for Aurelia reveal that transcripts of the so homolog are present in the manubrium as well as in the rhopalia, which contain the statocyst and eyes, in the free-swimming ephyra and juvenile stages of these jellyfish.

Siliceous spicules and skeleton frameworks in sponges: Origin, diversity, ultrastructural patterns, and biological functions

Silica deposition is a fundamental process in sponges. Most sponges in the Classes Demospongiae and Hexactinellida secrete siliceous elements, which can subsequently fuse, interlock with each other, or form three-dimensional structures connected by spongin. The resulting skeletal frameworks allow sponges to grow upwards and facilitate water exchange with minimal metabolic cost. Several studies on sponge skeletogenesis have been published. We are beginning to understand the mechanisms of spicule secretion and the role of spicules and skeletal frameworks in the biology, ecology, and evolution of sponges. Molecular techniques and ecological experiments have demonstrated the genetic control of the process and the contribution of environmental factors to the expression of a sponge spicule, respectively. However, other classic topics such as the role of membranes in silicon transport or whether spicules are formed in situ or secreted anywhere in the sponge mesohyl and then transported to the skeletal framework require further investigation. We review the process of silica deposition in sponges at the molecular and cellular levels, as well as the biological and ecological functions of spicules and skeletons. The genetic control of spicule shapes makes them useful in the reconstruction of sponge phylogeny, although recent experiments have demonstrated the influence of environmental factors in modulating spicule size, shape, and the presence or absence of one or more spicule types. The implications of such variations in sponge taxonomy may be important. Besides supporting sponge cells, spicules can help larvae stay buoyant while in the plankton or reach the bottom at settlement, enhance reproduction success, or catch prey. Conversely, the role of spicules and skeletons in deterring predation has not been demonstrated. Knowledge of several aspects is still based on a single or a few species and extrapolations should be made only with caution. With the advent of new molecular techniques, new lines of research are presently open and active in this field.

Expression of one sponge Iroquois homeobox gene in primmorphs from Suberites domuncula during canal formation

Sponges (Porifera) represent the evolutionary oldest multicellular animals. They are provided with the basic molecules involved in cell-cell and cell-matrix interactions. We report here the isolation and characterization of a complementary DNA from the sponge Suberites domuncula coding for the sponge homeobox gene, SUBDOIRX-a. The deduced polypeptide with a predicted Mr of 44,375 possesses the highly conserved Iroquois-homeodomain. We applied in situ hybridization to localize Iroquois in the sponge. The expression of this gene is highest in cells adjacent to the canals of the sponge in the medulla region. To study the expression of Iroquois during development, the in vitro primmorph system from S. domuncula was used. During the formation of these three-dimensional aggregates composed of proliferating cells, the expression of Iroquois depends on ferric iron and water current. An increased expression in response to water current is paralleled with the formation of canal-like pores in the primmorphs. It is suggested that Iroquois expression is involved in the formation of the aquiferous system, the canals in sponges and the canal-like structures in primmorphs.

Early steps in the evolution of multicellularity: deep structural and functional homologies among homeobox genes in sponges and higher metazoans

The sponge homeobox gene EmH-3 had not been attributed to any homeobox family. Comparative promoter and homeodomain sequence analyses suggest that it is related to the Hox11 gene, which belongs to the Tlx homeobox family. Hox11 is highly expressed in proliferating progenitor cells, but expression is downregulated during cell differentiation. Using reporter gene methodology, we monitored function of the sponge EmH-3 promoter transfected into human erythroleukemia K562 cells. These cells express the Tlx/Hox11 gene constitutively, and downregulate its expression upon differentiation. The same pattern of expression and downregulation was observed for the sponge reporter construct. We propose that Tlx/Hox11 genes have structural and functional homologies conserved in phylogenetically distant groups, that represent a deep homology in the regulation of cell proliferation, commitment and differentiation.

The Chemokine Networks in Sponges: Potential Roles in Morphogenesis, Immunity and Stem Cell Formation

Porifera (sponges) are now well accepted as the phylum which branched off first from the common ancestor of all metazoans, the Urmetazoa. The transition to the Metazoa became possible because during this phase, cell-cell as well as cell-matrix adhesion molecules evolved which allowed the formation of a colonial stage of animals. The next prerequisite for the evolution to the Urmetazoa was the establishment of an effective immune system which, flanked by apoptosis, allowed the formation of a first level of individuation. In sponges (with the model Suberites domuncula and Geodia cydonium), the main mediators of the immune responses are the chemokines. Since sponges lack a vascular system and consequently blood cells (in the narrow sense), we have used the term chemokines (in a broad sense) to highlight that the complex network of intercellular mediators initiates besides differentiation processes also cell movement. In the present review, the cDNAs encoding the following chemokines were described and the roles of their deduced proteins during self-self and nonself recognition outlined: the allograft inflammatory factor, the glutathione peroxidase, the endothelial-monocyte-activating polypeptide, the pre-B-cell colony-enhancing factor and the myotrophin as well as an enzyme, the (2-5)A synthetase, which is involved in cytokine response in vertebrates. A further step required to reach the evolutionary step of the integrated stage of the Urmetazoa was the acquisition of a stem cell system. In this review, first markers for stem cells (mesenchymal stem cell-like protein) as well as for chemokines involved in the maintenance of stem cells (noggin and glia maturation factor) are described at the molecular level, and a first functional analysis is approached. Taken together, it is outlined that the chemokine network was essential for the establishment of metazoans, which evolved approximately 600 to 800 million years ago.

Retinoic acid down-regulates the expression of EmH-3 homeobox-containing gene in the freshwater sponge Ephydatia muelleri

The effects of retinoic acid (RA), a common morphogen and gene expression regulator in vertebrates, were studied in the freshwater sponge Ephydatia muelleri, both on morphogenesis and on the expression of EmH-3 homeobox-containing gene. At 0.3 microM, RA had no noticeable influence on sponge development, slightly up-regulating EmH-3 expression. In contrast, in sponges reared in 10, 8 microM and to a lesser extent 2 microM RA, there was a strong down-regulation of EmH-3 expression after hatching. This induced modifications in cell composition and morphology, greatly disturbing normal development. Archaeocytes kept the features found in newly hatched sponges while choanocytes and a functional aquiferous system were completely absent. The inhibition of morphogenesis and down-regulation of EmH-3 expression were reversible when sponges were no longer subjected to RA. After RA removal, EmH-3 expression returned to the high values found in untreated sponges, archaeocytes differentiated into choanocytes and sponges achieved a normal development. These results clearly show that, in freshwater sponges, the most primitive metazoan, RA may also act as a morphogen, regulating the expression of a homeobox-containing gene. They demonstrate that the expression of EmH-3 is necessary for the differentiation of archaeocytes into choanocytes and hence for the formation of a complete functional aquiferous system.

Homeobox gene diversification in the calcareous sponge, Sycon raphanus

Knowledge of the developmental mechanisms in living basal metazoan phyla is crucial for understanding the genetic bases of morphological evolution in early animal history. We looked for homeobox genes in the calcareous sponge, Sycon raphanus, using the polymerase chain reaction. Partial sequences of eight homeoboxes were recovered, five of which are assignable to the NK-2 class of homeoboxes. The three remaining sequences are related members of a new class of homeoboxes, the Sycox class, showing limited similarity to bilaterian Lbx, Hlx, HEX, En, and Cad classes. Among the five NK-2 class homeoboxes are four closely related sequences occupying a divergent position within the class, the remaining one on the contrary showing high sequence similarity with members of the NK-2 family, a particular subgroup within the NK-2 class, previously known only from the Bilateria. This suggests that diversification of the NK-2 class occurred early in metazoan history. Altogether, the results reveal an unexpected diversification of homeobox genes in S. raphanus.

Evolution of Antp-class genes and differential expression of Hydra Hox/paraHox genes in anterior patterning

The conservation of developmental functions exerted by Antp-class homeoproteins in protostomes and deuterostomes suggested that homologs with related functions are present in diploblastic animals. Our phylogenetic analyses showed that Antp-class homeodomains belong either to non-Hox or to Hox/paraHox families. Among the 13 non-Hox families, 9 have diploblastic homologs, Msx, Emx, Barx, Evx, Tlx, NK-2, and Prh/Hex, Not, and Dlx, reported here. Among the Hox/paraHox, poriferan sequences were not found, and the cnidarian sequences formed at least five distinct cnox families. Two are significantly related to the paraHox Gsx (cnox-2) and the mox (cnox-5) sequences, whereas three display some relatedness to the Hox paralog groups 1 (cnox-1), 9/10 (cnox-3) and the paraHox cdx (cnox-4). Intermediate Hox/paraHox genes (PG 3 to 8 and lox) did not have clear cnidarian counterparts. In Hydra, cnox-1, cnox-2, and cnox-3 were not found chromosomally linked within a 150-kb range and displayed specific expression patterns in the adult head. During regeneration, cnox-1 was expressed as an early gene whatever the polarity, whereas cnox-2 was up-regulated later during head but not foot regeneration. Finally, cnox-3 expression was reestablished in the adult head once it was fully formed. These results suggest that the Hydra genes related to anterior Hox/paraHox genes are involved at different stages of apical differentiation. However, the positional information defining the oral/aboral axis in Hydra cannot be correlated strictly to that characterizing the anterior-posterior axis in vertebrates or arthropods.